Go back

2026 Starting Pitcher Recap Part 2! Plus, More Moves! (11/19 Fantasy Baseball Podcast)

1h 28m 12s

2026 Starting Pitcher Recap Part 2! Plus, More Moves! (11/19 Fantasy Baseball Podcast)

This episode of CBS Sports' Fantasy Baseball Today features hosts Frank Sample, Scott White, and Chris Towers recapping the top starting pitchers from the past season while covering offseason news. They begin with a blockbuster trade between the Mariners and Royals, analyzing how Michael Garcia and Bryce Miller are affected by swapping parks, particularly Seattle's extreme strikeout-boosting environment. The hosts then cover Sunny Gray's return to Minnesota, Dustin May signing with the White Sox, and qualifying offers accepted by David Bednar and Ryan Jeffers, noting these moves are largely positive for fantasy value. The bulk of the show is a tiered review of starting pitchers ranked roughly 11 through 40. Discussions highlight breakout seasons from Chase Burns, Cade Cavalli, and Peyton Tolley, while questioning whether limited track records justify their rising draft prices. Reid Detmers earns praise for his improved control after a bullpen stint, while Nick Martinez's outperformance is dismissed as unsustainable. Paul Skeen's velocity decline sparks extended debate about whether his mechanical issues are fixable. Later segments cover Brian Wu's likely bounce-back, Garrett Cole's solid return from surgery, Jacob deGrom's age concerns, and Walbert Arreña's tantalizing but flawed profile. Throughout, the hosts stress that pitcher volatility is unavoidable, favoring volume and late-round upside over certainty.

Transcription

15798 Words, 81727 Characters

English
Speaker 1College football season is Modelo season. There's nothing quite like a college football Saturday. The fight songs, the rivalries, the traditions passed down from one generation of fans to the next, and of course they're settling in for a full day of football with Chris Modelo. Because Saturdays are for the gridiron and cervezas. College football is built on tradition and no one knows tradition like Modelo. From the fanquakes that shake the stadium to the rivalry trophies that mean everything year after year, these traditions are what makes Saturday special. So if you're listening to this, consider it your sign. Grab a Chris Modelo, settle in, and enjoy a full day of college football. Because it's just not game day, it's tradition. And those who keep college football traditions alive deserve a Modelo. Modelo is the official beer sponsor of the college football playoff. Drink responsibly. Modelo Especial beer imported by Crown Imports, Chicago, Illinois.
Speaker 2I'm pretty confident talking into a mic. Hey, I'm doing it right now. But home projects, I second guess everything. Is that noise normal? Is that water damage? Who do I even call? That's where Thumbtack comes in. Just upload a photo or voice note and it uses AI powered search to match you with a right top rated local pro. So instead of guessing, you get clarity and can hire with confidence. For your next home project, try Thumbtack. Hire the right pro today.
Speaker 3Welcome to the Fantasy Baseball Today podcast from CBS Sports. And first pitch, rushing deep left field. This is where the walkable. Got a fantasy question? Email fantasybaseball at cbsi.com. Get ready to win your league. Where fantasy becomes reality. Now here's Frank, Scott, and Chris.
Speaker 4What's up and welcome in to Fantasy Baseball Today on Thursday, November 19th. I am Frank Sample joined by Scott White and Chris Towers. Today on the show, it is starting pitcher recap part two. We're breaking down the top 40 or so pitchers from this past season and we have a lot more news to talk about. I was going to start this podcast by asking you guys about GTA 6. Are you going to play it? Are you downloading it? Are you ready to go? But there's no time. We literally have so much news to talk about.
Speaker 5I did start downloading it as we were speaking before the show though.
Speaker 4Yep, I downloaded it. It's all ready to go. As soon as we get started, we're going to start downloading it. We're going to start downloading it. As soon as we get started, we're going to finish. We're going to go ahead and play GTA 6.
Speaker 6I never played a Grand Theft Auto game.
Speaker 4I think I think
Speaker 6I did dabble with the very first one. You know, both of those make sense. Yeah, I'm old. Yeah. All right.
Speaker 4Well, if you ever have a chance in life, Scott, to go back and play Vice City, that's the one I would recommend. All right, let's get into the news and notes. We had a big old trade. The Mariners received Michael Garcia reliever James MacArthur and a minor league reliever. While the Royals received a minor league reliever, the Royals received Bryce Miller, Jose Ferrer and right-handed starter Logan Evans. We will start with the Garcia side of this. He's coming off a dreadful season where he dealt with many injuries to both hamstrings as well as a muscle strain in his left hand. But he was great in 2025. He finished 61st overall in Roto that season. He still is in the prime of his career at 27 years old. The park shift obviously is very scary going into Seattle. But StatCast actually kind of likes it for his power. So, Chris, we'll start with you. What do you think about this move here? What are your expectations for Michael Garcia in Seattle?
Speaker 5Yeah, T-Mobile Park is one of the parks where I just don't think the expected home runs metric for StatCast tells us very much because it assumes that they're going to have the same number of balls in play in their new ballpark. And that's the biggest thing about, I always want to call it Safeco, even though it hasn't been that for a while. T-Mobile is that it just, it's actually not like a super big park, especially it was early on, but they, they moved the fences in at one point. And now the biggest impact is it just boosts strikeouts like crazy. The strikeout park factor there is 116. That is by far the highest of any park. Only American Family Field, Milwaukee's Park, boosts by more, has a higher park factor for strikeouts of more than 107. And so we don't, we genuinely don't know. Like some guys can go there and not really be affected. Randy Rosarena, I think generally speaking was just Randy Rosarena in Seattle. He did, did not really have a problem there. And then you've got like Eugenio Suarez, who has gone to Seattle twice, and it's been an outright disaster both times. There's something about the way the, the light sets and hits the batter's eye, I think is the best explanation that I've seen for why it's like the orientation of the batter's eye, something about it. Just guys don't see the ball well, and it doesn't affect everyone equally. And that's the thing about Seattle is we just don't know if Michael, Michael Garcia could go there and hit more or less like he normally does. I don't think you can count on it though. And then there's just kind of, a lot of uncertainty about how good he actually is. All right. You know, he had the, the huge, when you said like he normally does, what does he normally do? He has the big 2025 season where he, I think the average exit velocity was up to 91.3 miles per hour, which is a career high. You got the average launch angle up to, I think, 10 degrees always makes a lot of contact as a great eye at the plate. And then in 2026, he comes back and he's basically a league average hitter. He loses about two miles per hour on the average exit velocity. He doesn't hit the ball in the air quite as much. And his WRC plus was like 99, right? Dead on average. But he also, you know, I think right at the end of May, he had that hand injury and he lost two months. So how much of this season was he healthy for? Cause after that he had the multiple hamstring injuries. And so there's a lot of uncertainty around Michael Garcia. And so I think generally speaking, arrow down for him after this trade, but because his price was actually a lot lower than I expected in the early drafts, his ADP is 169.2 before this trade. I don't really see much reason to move him that much further down from there just because I do think he's likely to be pretty good. You know, looking at the ADP, I'd take Curtis Meade over him, but I might've done that before the trade. I'd probably take Nusak Bredas over him, but the uncertainty with where he's going to play, you know, whether Houston trades him, I think that's enough. I don't think I could move Michael Garcia more than like 14th at the position. So I'm not going to drop him too much, but I think he's definitely, you know, worse, but well, I'd probably rank him ahead of Bryson Stott. So I guess maybe 13th for me. Yeah. I was not
Speaker 6inclined to move Michael Garcia down either with this trade, but I had him 17th initially at third base. So I, I, I'm a downer from way back. Uh, yeah, it's. Arenado ahead of him? Arenado's directly behind him. Arenado's 18th. Uh, I have, let's see if you must know. Oh, Muncy's buried in the, in the ADP. He'd be ahead. Gelof, I'm sure you have ahead. Yep. I, I have Gelof way ahead. I have Muncy way ahead. I have Casey Schmidt ahead. I have Bryson Stott ahead. I have Austin Riley one spot ahead in my third base rankings.
Speaker 4Okay. The early projections on him for, from Steamer, 273, 11 homers, 65 runs, 62 RBI, 15 steals. I would probably boost the steals a little bit. I, I'd probably expect 20 ish, but everything else looks pretty spot on it. I don't know that there's a huge ceiling, but I think from like a Roto perspective, he could be a high floor player. I think, I don't know that to be, to be true. I can't say that with much.
Speaker 6It's hard this year to draft Michael Garcia for the floor. I get saying that going into it. I don't know. I don't know that to be, to be true. I think the
Speaker 5skill set is fairly stable, but what does that mean in Seattle? That's a much tougher question to answer because we just saw Josh Naylor who had a very good stint with Seattle in 2025 after the trade just completely fell apart last year. How much of that was more exposure to T-Mobile? I don't know, but it probably didn't help. It never helps. You know, that's the thing about T-Mobile.
Speaker 4Yep. Over to, over to Bryce Miller. Who is now with the Kansas City Royals who on the surface, just doing the opposite for Michael Garcia, a career 349 ERA at home for Bryce Miller, 463 on the road. So right there, you don't love that. And another player who I, I just don't even know who Bryce Miller is anymore because when he was healthy two years ago in 2024, he was amazing. Uh, but since the elbow popped up last year, he hasn't really been the same. Uh, the start of the season was fantastic. And then he completely plummeted as the season went on. So he's another tough player where I just don't even know who he is. Like, what does he bounce back to? And can he even bounce back pitching in Kansas City? I have no idea. The early ADP for Bryce Miller is 266. He's going right around Ryan Weathers, Foster Griffin, Cody Ponce, Bubba Chandler. Uh, Scott, what do you think about Bryce Miller in Kansas City and that early price tag 266 ADP?
Speaker 6Uh, let's see, since I've put my overall rankings together, curious, how it compares to mine. Okay, I'm 245, so a little higher. That was before the trade. um but it's it's you get this far down in the rankings i feel like you're you're kind of just trying to shoot the moon anyway you know that's certainly the case with bryce miller and this is this is kind of my read on both sides of this trade yes it it's a park downgrade for both michael garcia and bryce miller but there's so much they have to overcome before you even get to thinking about venue that it that part of it's kind of a shoulder shrug to me because it's like okay no matter where he is the first thing bryce miller has to do is fix himself you know in theory
Speaker 5i think they could both be good enough to matter for fantasy
Speaker 6anywhere yeah especially miller i think because he he at his best he's such a good batman or bad ministers can succeed anywhere and he misses bats with his fastball when he's at his best that's been the overpowering pitch for him and it was early early in 2026 so we've seen very recently the good version of bryce miller first eight starts he had a 171 era and 10.6k per nine but you know he lives and dies with that fastball and and the health has been very shaky and when it's not in its top form there's not much else there for him to to succeed with and so we haven't sustained it except for that one year could he get back to that yes is it worth gambling on it with a late pick in a 12 team draft well i rank them 245 so i guess so but not any more than it is nicola dolo or spencer strider or kyle bradish maybe i'd probably i think i think i probably have all three of those guys ahead of miller actually but they're all they're in the same basic range uh yeah i have strider once but i have bryce miller and bryce miller and bryce miller and then the other two five or six among starting pitchers so yeah that's that's it's just a late round dart throw and whether he's in kansas city or seattle i don't think the outlook changes for bryce miller as far as
Speaker 5that goes this feels like a real lose lose for fantasy but also a real it makes more sense in real life than it does for fantasy trade yeah like i i you can absolutely make sense of why the mariners want michael garcia because they were the second worst team in baseball with third baseman last year um they were
Speaker 4also just really bad defensively they were the worst defensive team in baseball and garcia is a gold glove third baseman so i
Speaker 5mean he's a shortstop caliber defender who can handle who can play third base like that's that's huge um because they're gonna have three short stops in the infield next year probably cole young came up as a short stop to emerson called emerson i assume is going to be the starting short stop so that should be a very good defensive infield they just you know might all be below average hitters um and then miller i mean god that the royals desperately need like i think logan evans might be in the uh in the royals rotation after missing the entire season just because
Speaker 4their their rotation
Speaker 5stinks outside of michael waka
Speaker 4yeah yeah so yeah with bryce miller i if he's completely right completely healthy i think he has the upside to be in sp2 or sp3 type i just have no confidence that he is healthy that he's right that his mechanics are good um so again paul talks about this a lot too if you play in you know a standard 10 or 12 team home league one of your last round picks take a shot i think you'll know early on or not if bryce miller is himself and if he's not you can just drop him if you're doing a draft and hold i'm not sure bryce miller is someone i would just want to have on my team all season long because i could it could turn out very very bad for him uh other fallout from this trade jerry depoto said he will not trade another mariners pitcher so that sounds like logan gilbert and george kirby will be thinking darn it this makes the path a little bit easier for ryan sloan but even with the trade of bryce miller they still have a rotation of five pitchers with uh gilbert kirby kate anderson emerson hancock and brian woo so oh look pitchers get hurt all the time so if we get one pitcher injury i mean that could lead to ryan sloan so uh we're one step closer healthy he'll be up at some
Speaker 6point this year guaranteed it's just just a question of how
Speaker 5early it's just is it in april is it in september like it was for kate anderson uh
Speaker 4other fallout for this trade uh jose ferrer can he be part of the royals saves mix i personally don't think so i mean you look at his splits he got destroyed by right-handed hitters this season he's awesome against lefties i kind of just think he's a lefty specialist so you use him in the right lanes i i just don't think he's going to be part of the saves mix uh i would lean steven cruz for now but i also wouldn't be surprised if maybe they and the bottom of this royals lineup is absolutely pitiful michael massey john rave nick lofton and somebody named carson roccaforte uh yeah i can't tell you a single thing about him so they need at least one more hitter maybe two i
Speaker 5mean the at least the top of the lineup's really good right the
Speaker 4top five i
Speaker 5think is pretty good it's extremely okay yeah so uh that is the royals
Speaker 6it's the start of the off season so you know it's i don't think you should take any any uh anybody's projected roster right now too seriously continuing
Speaker 4on we do have some other moves here sunny gray is headed back to the twins on a two-year 55 million dollar deal that includes an opt-out after the first year and he had the two best years of his career in minnesota back in 2022 and 2023 he finished second in the al cy young voting back in 2023 uh over that stretch 290 era 114 whip of course he is a different pitcher now because he's just a different pitcher every single year and the twins are very different because they don't have the same coaching staff the same pitching coach and all that uh so scott what do you think about uh sunny gray here back to the twins he just finished as a top 12 starting pitcher and his early adp is 150 i am not a fan admit that that's probably too low for sunny
Speaker 6gray yeah that's i i think that's fair uh and i'm pleasantly surprised he's going that low because i i felt like i was burying him in my rankings and he's 148 for me so i'm pretty much right in line with adp on sunny gray uh and i'd be happy to take him there he'll probably be good but he has been notoriously the most player for me to analyze like he's been the bane of my existence as far as that goes when i'm when i'm high on him he's bad when i'm low on him he's great and he can't maintain any kind of consistency with the strikeout rate or era or pitch selection or anything he's just kind of making it up as he goes and it it generally ends in a favorable place so yeah i could sit here and say oh at age 36 it's a bad sign that he had a career low 7.9 k per nine it's not accurate but it's a bad sign that he had a career low 7.9 k per nine it's not accurate it's not accurate actually a career low he was lower than that at the start of his career but you know the lowest has been in a long time it was a it was 10 per nine last year and 7.9 in 2026 that's a big scary drop and of course late 30s of
Speaker 5course he was much better at the year his strikeout rate was way
Speaker 6lower yeah he ended he had a much lower era with the low lower strikeout rate in boston but but my point is i i can't confidently say yes this is the start of a decline because he'll just start doing something different that gets him back to 10k per nine next year if he wants to he made me doesn't need to he wasn't that big of a strikeout pitcher in minnesota he was more like right at a strikeout per inning you know at some point just given his age it's not going to be true that sunny gray will be fine but the safe bet is he'll probably be fine uh yeah and i
Speaker 4think the twins might have a sneaky good rotation they have sunny gray joe ryan taj bradley that is a really great top three pablo lopez will be back at some point from i believe that was tommy john it might be both it might be tommy john with the internal brace um and they have some depth you know they have connor prelip they have bailey obers that'd be matthews dean kramer so uh pretty interesting
Speaker 5it was not a full tommy john so he should be okay more than ready for the start of the season assuming everything goes well which we won't know until whenever the lockout ends he did throw a uh recently yeah recently to yesterday yeah that was reported today that he had thrown a bullpen session so that's good good timing good timing
Speaker 4there for pablo lopez the white socks signed dustin may to a three-year 52 and a half million dollar deal and he made 31 starts this past season 470 era 132 whip he actually was much better with the cardinals than he was with the brewers chris it was a weird season for dustin may i kind of just feel like it's been a weird career for dustin may where we keep waiting for him to be much better than he actually is uh but he had a 12-star stretch with the cardinals this year we had a 254 era 0.98 whip there was a weird collection of injuries that kind of like derailed things and then he got traded so i don't really know what to do with this uh your thoughts on dustin may to the white socks his early adp is 448
Speaker 5um i i guess that's too low but i don't think dustin may is very good very good like dustin may might be like the preeminent if you just watch him from the time the ball leaves his hand until the time the ball inevitably makes contact with a hitter's bat you would think he is like one of the best pitchers in the world like there is a reason this guy is always on like the pitching ninja gifs right like his his stuff moves like crazy but he's not actually that good and he kind of never has been and for some reason over a 13 month stretch he was traded as an expiring contract twice and received three top 100 prospects in return plus uh the the other guy that the red socks gave up for him is actually looking pretty good as well but alexander freus and uh josiah ragsdale were who the brewers gave up for him and then james tibbs was the other guy that the red socks gave up and yep i don't know teams and major league baseball teams keep convincing themselves dustin may is going to be really good and but it might work yeah it's very much the uh the uh tobias tobias yeah uh meme from arrested development and i don't know it might work out it probably won't white socks aren't a team i give a ton of deference to in this regard anyway i feel the red socks brewers and dodgers couldn't figure it out i don't really have much reason to think the white socks will but maybe he'll run out of 360 yards or something like that i don't know and strike out 155 batters over 170 innings i could see that that's a useful pitcher i think that's probably the ceiling i have
Speaker 4a feeling he's going to be on scott sleeper pitchers quite a bit in 2027 you know dustin may is just a name that you know pops up on the waiver wire you write him for a couple good matchups yeah okay yeah i thought like i didn't think
Speaker 6so no what my sleeper weekly streamers no you know i do call it right week week whatever week blank sleeper pitching but it's it's more like streamers i meant
Speaker 4the in-season article not the you know scott's going to be really excited about dustin may this season
Speaker 6article yeah in fact you said he's 448 is where he's going on average he's 444 in my rankings which wow
Speaker 4scott did you just uh did you copy the homework and just change it a little
Speaker 6bit it's funny to me when you know that far down the rankings you can be that close to to the adp but that's yeah i guess i'm right in line with this dustin may thinking as well
Speaker 4and lastly we had two players except the qualifying offer david bednar with the yankees and ryan jeffers with the twins and i think it's good for both of their fantasy values david bednar just slots back in as the yankees closer i think he should be drafted as a top 10 closer in fantasy for next season and then ryan jeffers goes back to the twins where he doesn't play as much as you would like he doesn't get you know he's not this huge playing time standout that other catchers are but he'll be a majority starter he'll probably start you know the next season two-thirds of the time and he had an interesting offensive profile this past season so i think it's good for both of those guys to go back to the teams
Speaker 6they were on i was i was excited about jeffers free agency because the twins have always suppressed his playing time and uh not so much the data set but the production has always been pretty strong for jeffers i would have liked to see him get uh extended run elsewhere but probably status quo now he's going back to the twins but of course i'm happy bednar's still going to be the yankees closer and anytime a closer enters free agency you can't be sure he's going to sign elsewhere to be a closer well we know bednar's going to be a closer still so that's
Speaker 4a good thing all right let's hit our first break when we return into all the starting pitchers we'll do that right after
Speaker 7this this year set up your holiday gifting with a little extra magic the perfect shoes from designer shoe warehouse dsw's got holiday gifts and stocking stuffers for everyone on your list and tis the season for a little self-gifting too whether you bake all day dance all night carol all over town or tiptoe under the mistletoe dsw is your designer shoe wonderland for comfy slippers joyful party shoes statement boots and more shop in-store or visit dsw.com dsw let us surprise you a beautifully
Speaker 8designed squarespace website is the difference between thinking about photography school and selling your portraits online it's the difference between giving away those cookies you just made for free and running your cookie empire a beautifully designed squarespace website is the difference between having a movie reviewing hobby and a movie reviewing career squarespace because no matter what you're into a website makes it real use offer code difference for 50 off select plans terms and conditions apply
Speaker 9ready set go get in gear with an auto loan from worth credit union with a rate as low as 4.25% on new and used vehicles plus 90 days no payment on your worth credit union auto loan from your daily commute to your next weekend getaway let worth help you get where you want to go worth credit union apply online today get in gear with an auto loan from worth credit union subject to credit approval membership eligibility required see worthcu.org for details welcome back fantasy
Speaker 4baseball today starting pitcher recap part two we're going to do this a lot like the outfield recap part two we left off with the top 10 so i'm going to go in groups of three i'll throw trios out at you guys and we'll try and get through the top 40 or so starting pitchers from this past season 11 through 13 we had zach wheeler sunny gray who we just talked about and chase burns wheeler incredible comeback season from the thoracic surgery july and august were ugly for wheeler but he blamed it on his mechanics uh he did bounce back and he finished very strong i think i'm still in even though i i noticed that i'm i'm optimistic about a bunch of old pitchers i don't know how i should feel about that but like it's good sale wheeler and degrom i'm like still kind of in on all three old is good at starting pitcher uh sunny gray we just spoke about he's back with the twins he leaned on the sinker and the cutter more which explained the drop in strikeouts i do expect some regression maybe it's like a mid-three zra for sunny gray uh and then chase burns a great first full season he did fade the final two months of the season uh maybe kind of tired out we know limited later on as well they were trying to preserve those innings he only throws really two pitches and it's really only one dominant pitch which would scare you but the reds just developed this same pitcher with hunter green and he's been awesome so i i don't really worry about it too much uh chris you get the first shot here zach wheeler sunny gray and chase burns
Speaker 5yeah in theory it'd be great if chase burns had a reliable third or fourth pitch uh but guys who have reliable third and fourth pitches generally don't have first and second pitches as good as chase burns and so it becomes a much smaller concern when your primary pitches are as good as burns is like you can see maybe some years where the home run to fly ball ratio is 15 to 16 and the era gets closer to like 370 but i think the overall skill set here is incredibly strong he shouldn't have any innings limitations as long as chase burns stays healthy which is a big if any young pitcher but especially one who averages 98 miles per hour with his fastball assuming he stays healthy i i think he's one of the best pitchers in baseball i have him and zach wheeler ranked seventh and eighth uh at starting pitcher right now sunny gray's a little lower than both of them yeah chase
Speaker 4burns i will point out if you look at his splits you might get concerned because he struggled a little bit against lefties this past season really all the struggles were just that he tried to throw his change up eight percent of the time against lefties and it got absolutely bad so i think it's a good thing that he's a good pitcher and he's a good pitcher and he's a good pitcher and he's a good pitcher and he's a good pitcher and he's a good absolutely demolished 476 batting average against a 952 slug so really the only difference in his left right splits were that he tried to use the change up and um it was not good so just stick with what works man for semen and slider i think he started using a sinker later on in the season or is thinking about it for next season so uh we'll see if perhaps chase burns could get anything out of that sinker next season 14 15 and 16 we had logan henderson gavin williams and kade cavalli uh henderson has allowed three earned runs or fewer in all 23 regular season starts of his career he does it with deception and control he is a fly ball heavy pitcher so that will lead to some home runs i think it will also come with a great whip uh gavin williams big jump in strikeout rate while improving the walks the trade-off was that he gave up a lot of hard contact and a lot of home runs i think if he ever puts it together and that is a big if i i'm not betting on it i i think we're looking at a cy young type season if gavin williams could ever put it all together uh and then kate cavalli another breakout season another as in like joining logan henderson as a breakout uh but he really took off as the season went on seems tied to this new sweeper that he was throwing it was really really good and he used it more as the season went on uh he is a little bit older than you think at 28 years old has an extensive uh history of arm injuries but he was money down the stretch so um three really really interesting pitchers uh i think kind of all over the place here but yeah feel free to start with whoever you want i think we can spend a little bit more time on this group because they're all pretty interesting
Speaker 6so i rank them gavin williams kate cavalli logan henderson and they're each probably five or six spots apart i'm probably most off the consensus with cavalli and then i'm higher on cavalli than the consensus he's my sp 16. actually might be right on consensus. That might be right on? Yeah, he's quite high. So part of it is, okay, you have the full breakout season, but the breakout didn't really start. Well, I guess it started at the beginning, but it kept getting better. You mentioned the sweeper, Frank. Also, there was a big leap in control mid-season. For the year, Cade Cavalli averaged 14.38 points per game, which is about a typical second-tier starter, 14.38. A big improvement from past Cavalli, but typical second-tier starter. From June 25th on, so 14.38 for the year. From June 25th on, 20.19 points per game, which is basically what Jacob Mizorowski averaged on the season. During that time, Cavalli had a 2.14 ERA, a.90 whip, 11.5 K per nine. Did you go into the change?
Speaker 5What specifically changed on June 25th?
Speaker 6Oh, was it the sweeper? It was the cutter.
Speaker 5The cutter. That was basically when he started throwing the cutter, which was never, he threw it around 10% to 15% of the time down the stretch, but June 25th is basically the day the cutter was introduced in his arsenal for good.
Speaker 6He was a monster from that point forward, and I don't think he can sustain that over a full season, but you're obviously not drafting him to be a 25th. You're not drafting him to be a 20-point-per-game pitcher. You're drafting him to be a fringe number one as the 16th taken. We had our first MAAC draft last night. I got him as my SP3 in that one in round six, I believe it was. Yeah, I took pitchers in rounds four, five, and six, which is unusual for me, but I like the way my team turned out. Yeah, I like Cavalli. Go ahead, Chris.
Speaker 5He terrifies me. And I'm not that much lower on the consensus. I am on the consensus on him. The ADP is 19 right now. I am at 21, so you're a little bit higher. I'm a little lower. It's more I'm just probably not going to be the one to do it, and that's just because I feel a little uncomfortable taking a borderline ace who's only done it for four months. But I could be wrong. I'm totally open to it. It's just given his injury history, given the very, very short track record, I'm just— A little less willing to pay the price, but I don't think the price is terrible. I don't think the price is wrong. It'll just— You know, we had that long conversation in the previous episode about why SP2s go wrong. And I feel like Cade Cavalli is probably a good archetype for why SP2s go wrong. Guys who show real, real skills, but with a very, very, very limited track record, this is kind of where those guys get pushed, and sometimes it works out. Yeah. But it's a dangerous game to play in that range.
Speaker 6I guess then the question is, who in this range feels good? Like, who do you say, oh, yeah, the track record is so extensive here, it could possibly go wrong?
Speaker 5That's part of why the SP2
Speaker 6range tends to be a pretty bad place to invest. But— The one that worries me most from this group,
Speaker 5it's Henderson. Henderson is the most— Let me see if this makes sense. He is the most left-handed, coded, right-handed pitcher in baseball. Like, everything about Logan Henderson feels like he should be a crafty lefty, and then he's just a righty throwing 93-mile-an-hour fastballs and somehow dominating. You know, like, that almost never works for right-handed pitchers. And it works really, really— It works really well for him across 23 starts.
Speaker 6Hmm. 23 starts spread across two seasons, right? It was 18 in 2026. It was five in 2025. The numbers in those 23 starts, a.233 ERA, a.87 whip, and 10.4K per nine. It's just like you said, obviously, that's not much of a track record either. And it's a limited arsenal like Chase Burns in that it's— Yeah. Two-and-a-half pitches, but with low-end velocity rather than high-end velocity. And I just worry the league will catch up to it. I think it's fine. Like, I rank him 19th at starting pitcher. I'd take him 19th at starting pitcher, but that's why he's only 19th at starting pitcher. Well, I think just from the pure numbers, some people may be inclined to move him beyond that.
Speaker 5Yep. I agree with pretty much everything you said. Weirdly, for being the Gavin Williams hater on this pod and maybe in the world, I do have him a decent amount clear of the other two. It's about seven spots in the rankings. He's 13 for me. Henderson and Cavalli are 20 and 21. So for all of my concerns about Gavin Williams, and this is very much in the Blake Snell mold where I just— I cannot watch this guy pitch. It drives me crazy, but the production is what the production is. The stuff is what it is. It's very, very good. The command got better. I think there are real flaws in his game that have not gone away. They have been different over the course of several seasons now. He's had kind of different flaws, but last year was clearly the best version of him we've seen. And I think the ERA might remain a little inflated because I think home runs are always going to be an issue for him. But— Yeah. Everything else is so good that I'm kind of willing to overlook it. When you're as good of a
Speaker 6strikeout pitcher as he became last year, eight of his final 14 starts yielded double-digit strikeouts. Yeah, I was just going to bring that up. Okay, I'll take a 350 ERA from that.
Speaker 5Right. I think you just have to go into this with the understanding that there's a reason I comped him to Blake Snell, and it's not just the aesthetic. I think there are just going to be stretches where he drops. It drives you crazy. And you have to understand, if you can't deal with that, and if Gavin Williams has a 480 ERA at the end of April, which is—he probably had two months like that last year, you've got to understand that the last thing you can do is sell low on him.
Speaker 6Yeah. Because there's going to be much better stretches. So he's the highest ranked for me of these three, Gavin Williams. He's 11th at starting pitcher. But oddly, I feel like— I know, Frank, you're saying, maybe there's a chance he has a Cy Young caliber season one of these years. He just prevents his home runs to the extent to make that possible. But if we're talking like realistic ceiling next year, Williams might be the lowest of the three, because I feel like you can go ahead and pencil him in for a mid-three ZRA. It's just he's also the least likely of the three to be an outright bust. I agree with that.
Speaker 417, 18, and 19 at starting pitch. We had Nick Martinez. He can't keep getting away with it! He won't, he won't. But he did. And then Reid Detmers and Braxton Ashcraft. So Nick Martinez, awesome season where he outperformed by a lot. But he does do that routinely. I will remind you that he has thrown over 700 innings since returning to Major League Baseball in 2022. During that stretch, he has a.353. ERA and a.116 whip. So I don't know. Nick Martinez just kind of does this a lot. Reid Detmers, trust the process. He cut the walks down, and all three of his secondary pitches were awesome. It was really the first time that he had all three secondaries working in the same season. And this is the result that we got from Reid Detmers. And then Braxton Ashcraft, a great first full season. There were some ups and downs for sure. He had a rough middle part, but he finished strong. The problem is he. He finished the season on the IL on September 10th with right arm discomfort. So it wasn't reported as like an elbow or a flexor or anything. I just think he threw a lot of innings early on in the season and kind of tired out. But it's still an arm injury, and we didn't see him return. So that's at least a little worrisome. Chris, Nick Martinez is not like the others here. I think there's a lot more excitement about Detmers and Ashcraft going into next season.
Speaker 5Yeah, I don't really think we have to talk about Nick Martinez. There's always one or two of these guys. Every year. And it almost never lasts. Guys who just way outperform their peripherals. There's something about Nick Martinez that seems to help him do that. Like you said, 353 ERA over the last 700 innings. But it's just. There's no real reason to buy into it. It feels very much like that good Seth Lugo season where this can happen. I don't want to take anything away from him. He pitched really well. But it's not. He's not a 3 ERA pitcher. He's probably a 4 ERA pitcher. And with his strikeout rate, that just doesn't matter for fantasy. So we don't need to spend much time on him. Detmers is one. Boy, I don't know. It feels like he could have finally figured it out, right? Like he is one of these guys who. You know, I wrote last week about the SP to RP conversions. And he was one of the more successful ones. Remember, he was a full-time relief pitcher in 2025. And he came back and basically Basically didn't lose anything in his stuff and was the best version of himself. I think he's super talented. Do I have any faith that Reed Detmers is going to repeat this? Of course I don't. How could I? I've seen Reed Detmers' career. The skills indicators mostly back it up. I don't know. I have him ranked almost, I think, dead high. He's 29th in my rankings. I think he's 29th in ADP. It's always funny when that happens. But it just feels like this is a Charizard. Really? And as talented as he is. He was awesome last year.
Speaker 4But that's really the only time we've ever seen him. The only time he's ever done that.
Speaker 6You're redefining Charizard on us. Charizard is you don't know what's going to happen from start to start.
Speaker 4Charizard from the year-to-year basis. I think it's a forward-looking Charizard.
Speaker 5Because Nick Martinez was really consistent last year. But none of us think he's going to do that.
Speaker 6Yeah, but he wasn't. Detmers, actually, in the ways we normally assess pitching talent, he looked like one of the most talented pitchers in baseball.
Speaker 5I just think the talent here is going to fluctuate. I don't know.
Speaker 6I guess I just, yeah, I'd like a long track record. Rarely is any pitcher going to give you a long track record. They have short shelf lives.
Speaker 5Well, but he does have a pretty long track record. He does have a pretty long track record.
Speaker 6Yeah, but. Like, this is not a low-end person. The kind of leap he made was one we've seen before, where a pitcher gets banished to the bullpen. And he kind of just learns to lock in and throw a lot more strikes. And Detmers was one of the best strike throwers in baseball last year. He also improved the depth on his slider during that time, where he just had to maximize efficiency pitching out of the bullpen. And a lot of times we see, when pitchers do that, they come out and they've learned efficiency at that point. And that's what we saw from Detmers last year. Final 22 starts. He had a.263 ERA. He had a.93 whip. He had 10.4K per nine. If he continues to go where he is, I'm going to have a lot of read Detmers, because I rank him 18th. I think he is a borderline ace. Of course, you can't say whether or not he's going to give some of that back. That's true for 75% of the starting pitcher pool. And I know the upside is there for him to dominate. And I'd rather have upside than not have upside. I think in terms of upside, the biggest issue is he pitches for the Angels, who, despite all his dominance, yielded him only seven wins. But wins is kind of. I think three of those wins came in his final four starts. So that just kind of shows you the nature of wins, where you can't really predict how much or when.
Speaker 5And hopefully he's not
Speaker 4pitching for the Angels
Speaker 5next year. Yeah, I mean, that would also be nice. If I may, I would love that long, simmering Cubs rumor to come through. If I may show my age, something I often do on this podcast with some player comps, it just gives me a little Danny Duffy. Remember, he had that breakout, I think 2015, because similar, had been banished to the bullpen, came back, figured it out, and was just dominant. And then after that, he was okay. But he was never quite that good. That's my expectation here. He's not going to be incredible. And he's not going to be bad. I think he'll give some of this back.
Speaker 6I guess part of why I don't relate Detmers to some of these other examples that are coming up, we saw it for Detmers for a long time. We thought he could be great. And he just kept falling short for one reason or another. He finally put it together. Honestly, it's the same thing. I guess it's the same way we disagree on Jordan Walker. You could definitely see how this guy becomes a monster. And he just kept having issues mechanically or in terms of physical stuff or whatever. And then he finally puts it together. And it's like, yeah, that's not the most surprising thing ever. It's not surprising that he would become this because it seems well within his skill set that he'd become this.
Speaker 4My default as of now, and this is kind of unfair analysis, and I'm going to continue to dig in as the offseason goes on. My default is to just kind of fade all of these second year starting pitchers. Cade Cavalli, Logan Henderson, Reed Detmers. It's just a really big price tag. They're all going inside the top 75. The big breakouts, you mean?
Speaker 6Yeah. Well, who are you going to draft instead? There is one name. Zach Wheeler! Old guys!
Speaker 5Yeah, but he's gone in round three or four. Okay, can I give you the name that I keep coming back to that I just think is. Like, the best value, and we haven't talked about him yet, and he's like 36th, I think. I think Garrett Cole is just an awesome value. And that is the one, comparing him to everyone, that I'm just like, I'm going to take Garrett Cole. Like, I have him ranked 19th, so I'm taking him ahead of Logan Henderson and Cade Cavalli and Reed Detmers. I just. And he's way cheaper than all of them.
Speaker 6I mean, 36 is too low. I have him 25. Yeah. But I can't sit here and say I feel better about Garrett Cole than. Oh, I do. Cade Cavalli. I mean. Yeah, I think it was all the way back, basically.
Speaker 5But it wasn't. We're going to get to Cole. By what measure? It was like some. There was some weird stuff early on where he wasn't missing bats, but after, like, the first month, I think he just looked like himself as a bat-misser. That's not what the data shows. We'll see. Okay.
Speaker 6Yeah. I'll pull it up, but, like, I'm just going off memory. I'd have to pull it up.
Speaker 5It was. July and August, the strikeouts were. The strikes. Strikeouts were. The swinging strikes were better. September, he gave a little bit of a back.
Speaker 6Yes. He. There was a stretch mid-season where it looked like he got the swing and miss back, but it didn't last. Like, his. His last. Boy. Basically, from August on, I got to be careful not to include the postseason starts in there. Not that they were good for swinging strikes. 9% swinging strike rate from. Between August and September. That's bad. That doesn't matter.
Speaker 4Uh, he. He did rank among pitchers with 120 innings. He was first in called strike percentage. So, do with that what you will. I'm still kind of figuring out how to use that in my analysis, but Nolan McClain is another pitcher who ranks very highly in that stat. He doesn't get swinging strikes, but he gets a lot of called strikes. And as a result, it still allows him to get enough strikeouts. Um, let's talk about Nolan McClain. 20, 21, and 22. We had Nolan McClain, Logan Gilbert, and Eduardo Rodriguez. You can't keep getting away with this! But he did. And, uh, so Nolan McClain, great first season. 9.6% swinging strike rate. That is very bad. It scares you. But again, he was first among all qualified starters in called strike percentage. So, obviously that helps. For Logan Gilbert, the ERA ran hot, but it's a sub-110 whip four years in a row. Can you just focus? Fastball slider. Stop trying to add more pitches, Logan Gilbert. I think. We're going to be all right if we do that. Uh, and then Eduardo Rodriguez. Uh, look, he, he did the thing. Throw him away. 289 ERA, despite a 389 FIP, a 427 XERA. Uh, maybe it's lazy analysis, but I am just expecting a low to bid for his ERA for next season.
Speaker 5Don't draft him. Just like there's his ADP is like 147th among pitchers. There's no reason to draft him.
Speaker 6And I'll, I'll, I will note, he did not keep getting away with it. He had a 520 ERA in September.
Speaker 4Which was weird because his swinging strikes actually got better as the season went on. We had a stretch where he was actually getting more whiffs and more strikeouts and then kind of gave it back in September. So that is ERAD, uh, anything to add here on Noah McClain. Again, he's kind of a confusing one, like bad control. I wouldn't say bad control. He just gets so much movement on his pitches that I think it leads to a lot of walks for him. Um, and then Logan Gilbert, like he's one of the guys in this range that actually has done it for a while. But what is it? It's like kind of a midtime. A high three ZRA, uh, but does give you a lot of innings and, and a very good whip. So that is Logan Gilbert.
Speaker 6Yeah. I mean, maybe Nolan McClain is setting himself up for a sunny gray type of career where he just keeps confounding me. I'm, I'm kind of down on him right now. I don't think you're, I'm not alone. Uh, I mean, it was a very good rookie season, but he's just trending toward being more of a pitch to contact round ball guy. Second half. Yeah. Average. Less. Less than a strikeout per inning and his swinging strike rate for the season was below 10%. Average, you know, is like 10 and a half, 11 and a half percent is, was 9.6 for the season. Um, so he, he got away from missing bats, got away from getting strikeouts, good ground ball rate, but that can elevate whip. And then when you're walking three and a half batters per nine, obviously that elevates whip too. So I think McClain's going to be. I think McClain's going to be a negative for whip. He might only be average for strikeouts. He'll probably be good for ERA, but the trade-offs there make him a borderline two at best in fantasy. That's how I rank him. I rank him 22nd. Uh, he's still young enough that he could change this whole profile again and I'll have to reassess. But right now that's where thing, that's where McClain stands for me.
Speaker 5The weird thing with Nolan McClain is you go pitch by pitch and he's got a. a whole bushel full of like whiff pitches not everything is elite although the four seamer has a borderline elite whiff rate for a four seamer the curveball is very good but everything's at least pretty good and often very good and then he just he throws so many sinkers and he gets so much contact on it and it's often weak contacts you live with it but i i don't know i i think people's expectations were a little too high for nolan mclean as a rookie to the point where a 316 era over 180 innings was kind of viewed as a disappointment um in a lot of ways and i think that's unfair and i also just think like there he is not a perfect pitcher to be sure but he has so many ways to beat you and he only needs to get a little bit better in one or two ways like his control needs to get a little better or his strike his swing strike rate needs to get a little better or he gets a few more ground balls and you can really see him taking off like there there are some you um there are some like zach wheeler comps that i think you can make with nolan mclean with the skill set that he has and it took wheeler a while to figure out and that doesn't mean zack nolan mclean will but i think he's a little underrated i've actually got him 15th um what's
Speaker 6his adp i know i can just check but they mix in the well yeah the
Speaker 5relievers it's around 20 probably i think kate cavalli was 18 or 19 so nolan mclean's one because you're you're
Speaker 6a couple spots higher than the consensus and i'm a couple spots lower than the consensus which means he's you know there's a chance either one of us could draft him it's not way off but um i do think the whip is a like kind of
Speaker 5hidden concern for him yeah
Speaker 6because it ended up being 117 which is yeah doesn't hurt you but doesn't okay but if you walk
Speaker 4that many and you have you get a lot of ground balls it's it's just going to lead to hits what was it i wonder what it was in
Speaker 6the second half when he pitched to contact more it was load page load it was 1.24 in the second
Speaker 5half yeah he was a he was a mild negative for for whip um but his era was actually better this kate cavalli and chase burns were also mild negatives for whip for what it's worth um so he's you know not alone there yeah that
Speaker 6was a different picture as you know and on as i pointed out control got a lot better
Speaker 5but he also go ahead he might just be like michael king who's been a very good but sub ace pitcher for a while yeah i mean michael king's strikeout rate got a lot lower last year but you know the good verse the very good versions of michael king i do think if you
Speaker 4take chase burns as your ace uh you have to be cognizant of whip so you're probably looking at like a brian woo or imanaga or joe ryan or multiple of those guys so um and then maybe a steer clear of like a mclean or same with christopher sanchez logan webb or someone like that so yeah just just keep those things in mind uh let's take our final break here we are 50 minutes uh we're gonna go a little bit longer but we want to get to some of these pictures so we'll take that break we'll be
Speaker 10back right after this delivered by little caesars the official pizza sponsor of the nfl garlic lovers unite because right now you can take game day to the next level with the best pizza sponsors you can take game day to the next level with cheesy pizza sponsors you can take game day to the next level with cheesy garlic pepperoni for just 6.99 it's a new take on a classic with cheesy garlic white sauce pepperoni and surrounded by a toasted garlic parmesan and asiago crust and we can all agree that pepperoni pizza is delicious but cheesy garlic pepperoni is next level delicious get a cheesy garlic pepperoni pizza for a limited time for just 6.99 only at little caesars make your game day delicious all season long with little caesars officially delicious available at participating locations for a limited time prices may vary and are higher in alaska hawaii california many areas in new york oregon washington and third-party online sites taxes and fees may apply the
Speaker 2core short from viore is one pair i keep reaching for morning run afternoon training watching the game it doesn't matter soft four-way stretch built-in liner comfortable all day plus they look good enough to wear well beyond the gym ready to try a pair head to viore.com slash pod 20 to get 20 off your first purchase exclusions apply visit the website for full terms and conditions
Speaker 4welcome back fantasy baseball today we are uh doing our recap part two let's continue on sp 23 24 and 25 we had shohei otani the pitcher peyton toley who's going to be pitching this year and michael king uh otani remained dominant but he has not thrown more than 14 starts since 2023 he also stopped pitching in july due to uh knee and biceps injuries no clue what the plan is for 2027 uh peyton toley first full season he was awesome he added a new sinker he is going with that three fastball approach very similar to cam schlittler uh i am very excited about toley i guess he is the one exception for the second year pitchers the only thing that worries me slightly is that his innings jump is going to be a little bit more he went from 108 to 168 so that's that's quite a bit of a jump um and then michael king awesome ratios here but the strikeout rate the swinging strike rate has plummeted the past two seasons and i don't know he he kind of has like a he got away with it type vibe for michael king so interested to see what the contract where he lands michael king uh what all that looks like but yeah i'm not i'm not overly enthusiastic about michael king myself yeah i'm
Speaker 643rd for next year so i'm not either um bad control bad whiffs though we've seen better in the past it does allow weak contact but he outperformed his era estimators by more than a run pretty much all of them so uh i i think there's a better version of michael king than we saw last year obviously we've seen a better version in previous years but i don't think he could count on it next year so um yeah i'm i'm pretty low on him totally i guess is i don't know how much we need to talk about otani because we don't know what the plan is and in most leagues you can't even use the pitcher version because he's tied to the hitter version so let's just talk about uh about totally here and i'll give one of my favorite stats again when he threw his curveball at least 10 of the time he had a 194 era a 0.831 whip and 12.6k per nine and his fastball is amazing too but when he when he brings in that breaking ball just 10 at the time he looks like cyan caliber pitcher his numbers without that are still decent but you know not
Speaker 4as dominant yeah that curveball 137 xwoba 43 percent whiff rate that curveball was outstanding
Speaker 5i don't think there's a huge difference between him and cam schlittler from like a skill standpoint oh i think their approach is very similar yeah and um judging by a lot of the discussions at first pitch arizona his adp is around probably 12 right now i would guess uh he's not going to be drafted that late in most leagues i think uh peyton tolly is your favorite fantasy analyst favorite pitcher right now and i think
Speaker 4nick pollock ranks him six or seven
Speaker 5six yeah i i think eric samulski had him like ninth um i've got him 14th and that basically means there's no way i'm going to draft peyton tolly i think uh unfortunately and so i'll have to figure out how much i want to bet on him being the one guy who breaks out that often doesn't work out yeah especially when you start pushing them that high but i think he's awesome i don't really think there's much to ding in his profile i think he's absolutely on the short list for most talented players in the league that's that's what that's
Speaker 6what we talk about when we say the the fantasy baseball analyst community is just so sharp because i i hadn't i had no idea everybody else felt as strongly about peyton tolly as i do um i i have no idea what kind of analysis they've been doing or i don't think it's obvious just from looking at the top line numbers but everybody arrives in the same place at him such that it prices me out of him because i i rank him 15th and i thought i was being pretty aggressive ranking him 15th at starting pitcher because he only finished 24th uh but apparently not and like
Speaker 5looking ahead i've got gavin williams paul skeens drew asperson dylan cease jesus lazarda right ahead of him uh paul skeens also i think i forgot him um i i think there's very little separating all of them those guys so if you really wanted to twist my arm and say hey you should rank him eighth sure i could yeah i think i think that's the right range for peyton
Speaker 6tolly the highest i think i could personally justify it is 10th that's what
Speaker 4i was gonna say scott we did the express episode the other day and you're like i don't really know who i should put sp10 i was gonna say just put peyton tolly there i
Speaker 6i may wind up there just so i have a chance of getting him once or twice you know but like
Speaker 5i i could justify taking him ahead of jesus lazardo i don't think it's something you should do every single time but i can absolutely justify it i can absolutely justify dylan cease with the whip risk Drew Rasmussen just with all of the risk, I think, for Drew Rasmussen.
Speaker 6Paul Skeen was terrible. Yes, he says it in that top nine, that untouchable top nine for me. I'm just saying for me, he can't break into that nine. That nine is so firm for me. That goes Chase Burns' number nine there.
Speaker 4Yeah. I think Burns versus Tolley is like an interesting conversation. I think you can make the case for Tolley ahead of Burns.
Speaker 6I'm just saying I can't do it.
Speaker 4Yeah. Moving on, 26 through 28, we had Sean Burke, Shota Imanaga, and Max Meyer. Burke, up and down season. He was great in the middle. It seems tied to his fastball velocity being up one mile per hour during that stretch. And then he crashed hard in his final eight games, personally. I'm pretty pessimistic on Sean Burke. Imanaga's velocity was back up on the fastball. The skills bounced back as well. You just have to go along for the ride with Imanaga. His ERA by month, 288, 580, 413. 153, 596, 225. And that came out to like a high three ERA for Imanaga. And then Max Meyer, the breakout season was helped by throwing a lot more sweepers. Kind of reminds me of like a right-handed Jesus Lizardo. And then he was derailed by a neck strain. He also received a cortisone injection in his side slash rib area in August. It kind of gives me like some thoracic outlet-y feel. I haven't heard that anywhere, but like neck, rib stuff, normally that's kind of connected. Uh, that's just pure speculation on my part, but yeah, that, that scares me a little bit. Uh, any thoughts here, Scott, on Sean Burke, Imanaga, Max Meyer?
Speaker 6Yeah. Uh, it's a hard group to rank for sure. It's an interesting group for sure. Uh, Burke did crack my top 40, barely.
Speaker 5Um. Barely cracked my top 50.
Speaker 6Yeah. I, I, I don't, I'm not firm on him being in my top 40. Uh, overall, the, the numbers ended up impressive. Three 34-year. A 120 whip, 9.7 K per nine, but it was mostly a mid-season surge that was bookended by some pretty serious control issues. Uh, the stuff I think is there, but the issue is how well he repeats his mechanics and, and that creates a lot of volatility and is the upside worth the volatility. I think in the top 40 range, it is that's, that's also where I rank Taj Bradley was also, uh, uh. Is the upside worth the volatility kind of pitcher. Uh, but I get if I, if you, if you take a negative view of Sean Burke, I get it because those control issues just bite, eat them up all season. Uh, Imanaga has innings issues and home run issues. The ERA is always going to skew high. Uh, and then is the volume enough to make it worth it? Fair. Max Meyer. Um, I, I, I thought Max Meyer would be kind of a forgotten man because he didn't pitch after, uh, did he even pitch in August at all? I don't think so. I think he got out in July. Yeah. So he kind of disappeared after he disappeared after 20 starts, but he was one of the biggest breakout pitchers of the year before then. Um, two 68 ERA, one 14 whip, nearly 10 K per nine made the all-star team, all of that. He looked like, you know, he was having the breakout season. So where do I put him? I put him, I guess it's, he technically finished 28, right? By the Roto measurements. I have him 46th ADP. I think, I think, I think ADP is pretty close to where I have him, but I, I'm kind of surprised he's that high. Uh, just cause he was out of commission for so long and then it didn't have her chance to really complete the breakout season.
Speaker 5Yeah. Um, and I think things were going to get uglier for him at some point. Um, yeah. All his XERA was 389. Yeah. His control is average ish. His strikeout rate is good, but not very good. Um, and he's really kind of a two pitch pitcher and it's really the sweeper and slider
Speaker 6variations of it. Yeah. Okay. Fair enough though. Obviously he has fastball and he has. Yeah, no, no.
Speaker 5He has four or five pitchers. If you count the sinker,
Speaker 6but sweeper and slider is really all that works. The key to the breakout was adding that second. So now he has the two variations of the slider and they're both very good and they can kind of play off each other. And that's what fueled the breakout for Meyer this year. Um, yeah, he's probably more of a mid three ZRA than mid two ZRA, but with good strikeout numbers, I, you know, I, I think, I think health permitting, you'll be happy with him as a number four, number five.
Speaker 5Um, yeah, I'm ranking him with Ryan Weathers, Andrew Painter and Kyle Bradish in like that, just outside of the top 50 in that I think there's talent for all of them. Um, but I, I don't feel a large degree of certainty in any of them. And so, you know, if they go cheaper than that, I'll be happy to draft them. But if I, if I have to push any higher, I'm, I'm not all that interested in it. And I think ADP for Meyer at least is in that range.
Speaker 4Yeah. Um, his ADP is one 63, this range, one 55 to one 75 in NFBC, ADP, the starting pitchers, Sean Burke, Griffin, Jax, Christian Scott, Sandy Alcantara, Max Meyer, George Kirby, Emmett Sheehan, Trey is savage that, I mean, that range is all over the
Speaker 5place and talent all over the guy. Christian Scott kind of feels like, you know, the, the, the, the, what the heck's a polar bear. They're doing an Arlington, Texas meme. You guys seen that one. It's kind of how I feel about Christian Scott in there. I just don't think I agree. You really belong. Like, I don't really see it. I know. I think Christian Scott's going ahead of, of Trevor Rogers.
Speaker 6Yes, he is.
Speaker 4What? What in the world? By 20 picks.
Speaker 5Yeah. His strikeout rate was really good. Um, that was kind of all that he really stood out for.
Speaker 4I think he's like a K minus walk guy. And he like the width rates on his individual pitch. His pitches are good.
Speaker 5Yeah. 18.4% K minus walk, but it's a 10% walk rate. So yeah, he's really gotta be either improved control or, you know, really be like a 28, 29% strikeout rate guy. And I'm just not sure the stuff is good enough for that. So I, he's the one that really stands out, but we're not talking about him. Yeah. Rank that's high.
Speaker 4Let's see how many more of, uh, you have anyone else, Chris, you want to mention? No. Let's see how many more of these pictures we can get to 29 through 31. We had Michael Waka, Paul Skeens. And Foster Griffin. One of these things is not like the other. Say what you will about Waka, but since 2022, 139 starts. That is a 342 ERA and a 116 whip for Michael Waka. Skeens, finally human. His first two years, a sub two ERA that jumped up to 382. And that coincided with a drop in velocity, spin rate, and his stuff. Plus Foster Griffin, Jack of all trades, master of none. Uh, great with the nationals, bad with the guardians meets. Somewhere in the middle. Very interested to see what he gets in free agency and where he lands. Uh, yeah, I think Paul Skeens is a pretty clear standout here from this group. Chris, we talked a lot about him, uh, on our podcast and at first pitch Arizona. And, uh, yeah, as one of like the toughest pitchers to rank because, you know, he was the most dominant pitcher his first two years in the league. And then the velocity drops and boom, he's, he's kind of human all of a sudden. And I, I just,
Speaker 5I really wish I had a better explanation for why things went wrong. I, I have seen, you mean
Speaker 4better than the WBC and, um, his pillows not working.
Speaker 5That's, that's his explanation. And I find that extremely, uh, unsatisfying. Um, but even like I, I, there was a really good piece in baseball prospectus late in the season that looked at like his mechanics and, you know, he's one of these cross body throwers. He kind of, I think he lands with his left. Left foot when he's at his best, he lands with his left foot a little closer to the third base side than to the first base side. So he steps over and he was not getting quite as far over. And, you know, whether that's waning athleticism or like, that's something you see with pitchers who rely on, you know, kind of funky mechanics that, you know, when their athleticism drops, it can have a, a much better. Much bigger impact than you would think. And so, you know, even just a couple of inches difference in where he lands with a strike foot might have a huge impact on how good he is. And it's one of those things where I don't know how you can have confidence that he's gotten that back until you see it. So he's going to get drafted as a top 10 starting pitcher. When I first did my rankings, I ranked him like 20th and I, I moved him up. Because I'm a coward to 12.
Speaker 4The ADP and the steamer projections are much higher.
Speaker 5And of course, like the projections are going to be based on, you know, the three year sample size where he was a God. Yeah. You know, the best young pitcher we've seen since Dwight Gooden. 40 years ago. Like that, that's, that is historic stuff. But he wasn't that guy for the final four months of the season. And we didn't really see any sign of it. And look, I know because I spent about a month. A month and a half, two months of his slide, trying to argue against it as it was happening. And at some point I just reached a point where it's just, no, he's lost. and maybe he'll get it back he's so talented that it it feels bad to bet against it but I don't think this is one where just looking at the three-year track record tells you the whole story there was a real skills decline that he may be able to arrest this offseason but I don't think Paul Skeen's coming into spring training next year and saying I figured it out guys it's gonna be fine I don't think that's gonna be enough for me to buy in and I might miss out on the best pitcher in baseball I'm I'm
Speaker 6cognizant of that fact if all these media people can point out what is wrong with his delivery then surely he someone in the staff have to figure it out like I'm sure they
Speaker 5see it then surely they can I think it's very unlikely that there's anything in the public discourse that teams except maybe the Rockies and Angels are not aware of like I just that's hard to
Speaker 6fix in season yeah
Speaker 5for sure and he said that like that's that was his his thing was like I just we're gonna have to fix in the offseason it's like well
Speaker 6will you yeah I hope so I mean he still was a great strikeout pitcher just by the data he deserved to have my like that the ERA estimator still liked him yeah um so I I think even if he doesn't fix it there's probably room for the good kind of regression here but I think he'll probably fix it I I rank him 12th too I I wound up in the same place again I sort of like you I went into the process thinking I'd wind up lower on him I don't think I ended up moving Skeens up as out of cowardice like you did I think I just I know you are but I I do think when I dug in more on Paul Skeens I came out more optimistic and you just kind of backed into ranking him 12th it sounds like
Speaker 4yeah the underlying stuff is still there for Paul Skeens the whiff rate on the fastball was still there it's just it's a vibes thing man something feels wrong and the velocity being down at least your mind has to go to was he pitching through injury is there something else you know is the other shoe gonna drop in 2027 it's always a possibility uh SPs 32 through 34 this past season that's right they finished as top 35 starting pitchers Brian Wu, Kader Montero, and Cal Quantrill that's right that's the trio that I'm bringing up right now Brian Wu his ERA Montero his ERA and whip both jumped up this past season the biggest thing that I could see is that his left on base percentage was just much worse which feels fluky for Brian Wu also his home road splits those were like we know Mariners have big home road splits but Brian Wu didn't deal with that at all in 2024 or 2025 so uh I I think he's a pretty good bet to bounce back Brian Wu uh Kader and Cal Quantrill they got much better results I didn't see too much in the underlying profile to explain it just kind of feels like you know one of those things um if you guys have anything on Montero or Quantrill go for it but yeah Brian Wu feels like a pretty pretty believable bounce back for next season
Speaker 6so with Montero and and really you could say this for Foster Griffin too so Foster Griffin finished 31st Montero finished 33rd I don't think anybody thought of them as being the 33rd or the 31st and 33rd best pitcher last year and that's just one of those quirks of the roto formula where if you stand out in one of the five categories and you stay healthy then you're going to get elevated like Griffin won 15 games last year that's a lot of wins nobody's penciling him in for 15 wins again and then Montero had a 104 whip last year that's an incredible whip and I think he's probably decent for whip but he's not going to get a 104 whip again um it's not gonna be a 234 bad whip again for sure yeah for sure so yeah I think we can safely ignore them we can safely ignore Quantrill it's just Wu like you say who matters uh and and in all leagues and uh I think so this is this is what I found with Wu this is what I decided with Wu so yeah we could look at the home away splits much better home that that normalized a little over the course of the season but I think it's going to be a little better over the course of the year but you could fixate on that if you want what it ultimately came down to I think though is just a much worse Babbitt his Babbitt was much worse in 2026 than it was the previous two years everything else was exactly the same and so it was that fluky was it defense related sounds like the Mariners gonna have a very different infield defense next year and outfield and outfield defense it's a very different defense behind Wu in general so I don't I don't think we should hold that against them I I think just Babbitt normalization fixes this and if that's the case getting them outside the top 20 starting pitchers it's going to feel really good yeah I
Speaker 5don't think he's a top five starting pitcher like he was the year before but somewhere in the middle yeah you know 20th or so
Speaker 4feels somewhere in the middle right 294 and 401 era 0.93 and 110 whip I think it's all somewhere in the middle it's like a mid-three ZRA and uh you know maybe closer to a 110 but like a 105 108 whip something like that for Brian Wu feels attainable and again Scott I would say like look at the left on base percentage too like that is something that's kind of fluky you can't really predict it year over year but like league average is 75 percent Brian Wu his career is 73 percent and this past season his left on base percentage was 66 percent the year before it was 80 percent so again in the middle it feels like that's it was just it was really lucky one year and then it was unlucky the next year for Brian Wu uh 35 36 and 37 Taj Bradley Garrett Cole and Jacob degrom Taj Bradley each of his era FIP ex-fip Sierra and xera were all between 373 and 397. so that is a very close range but I think as long as his control is this bad and he throws his fastball as much as he does I just think he's going to remain a very volatile pitcher Garrett Cole returned from the first year returned from the elbow surgery he was mostly Garrett Cole outside of that swinging strike rate that was just 9.6 percent but again he did get a lot of called strikes this past season and Jacob degrom his ratios jumped up a lot but a 311 FIP 347 xera his secondaries were still awesome the fastball got hit really hard it's not like the velocity changed on it or anything I kind of want to buy but also he's turning 39 years old and like is my whole pitching staff just going to be Chris Bale and Zach Wheeler and Jacob degrom that that feels kind of scary too so I don't know there's
Speaker 6there's there's no way to draft the pitching staff you feel confident about load up on Metamucil with those guys you know that's uh I mean you could you could dismiss and and every starting pitcher you know beyond the the guys who you draft in the early rounds the Zach wheelers and the Yamamoto's and all of them and every other pitcher you could say oh well uh I I here's why I think it could go wrong and for half of them it probably will go wrong that's why you need to draft a lot of them and and that's why I don't get that picky about who it is because I I don't think you're going to be that accurate uh in in pinpointing where exactly the misses will be they all have flaws that could bring them down and we saw it with the Grom last year I don't even think we're going to be that accurate uh in in pinpointing where exactly the misses will be they all have flaws that could bring them down and we saw it with the Grom last year I don't even think we're going to be able to even think we saw him as somebody with an obvious red flag other than health but that wasn't the issue the issue it turns out was that his slider wasn't as effective and so he got hit harder and I think he could definitely get that back I worry when somebody loses something at that age how likely are they to get it back you generally shouldn't bet on it yeah uh but it wasn't so much velocity that he lost and he still had the best swinging strike or second best swinging strike rate among qualifiers so I I think DeGrom will bounce back but I have him 28th so it's not like a heavy bet I'm making I have him around
Speaker 520. um it's interesting yeah I um I do want to focus on Cole because we talked about him earlier and it is so the swinging strike break by month is 11 7 13 11 and 8.8. so kind of all over the place really really low early really really low late um what's interesting is if you look at the first half versus second half the CSW which is called plus swinging strike rate was 28.7 percent in both the first half and the second half the called strike rate was 20.6 percent in the first half 17.9 percent in the second half so the swinging strike rate did go up but the overall number of strikes he generated was the same across the board I don't know it's it's hard and and maybe I over understated the the downsides for him but I just kind of look at the whole picture and it's his first season back from Tommy John's surgery he put up a 20 K minus walk rate I just think he's mostly still an elite pitcher maybe the shape of it is slightly different than in years past maybe he's not quite the elite strikeout rate guy he had been at his best but he hadn't really been that guy since like 2022 and remember he won a Cy Young with a lower strikeout and swinging strike rate in 2023 so you know there are some issues he's a fly pitcher and a tough park for that, but I think Gary Cole is going to be a rock solid low threes ERA guy, and he's going to throw a lot of innings. He's going to pitch deep into games. He's going to win a lot of games. I think in as much as anybody can be safe, Gary Cole feels pretty safe
Speaker 4to me. I kind of expect a higher threes ERA at this point and a lower whip, kind of in a Joe Ryan kind of way, because he threw more in the zone. You see the walks were down for Gary Cole, and he still gave up a lot of hard contact, a lot of fly balls, a lot of barrels, and you do that in Yankee Stadium. You're just going to give up home runs, so I think he could still be good, but kind of in like a Joe Ryan, Imanaga type of way. Sure, that's fair. 38-40, Max Freed, Walbert Arreña, and Michael Soroka. Freed was mostly just Max Freed. He obviously missed time. He landed on the aisle with a left bone bruise, and he had off-season surgery to remove a bone spur. He is expected to be ready for spring training. Walbert Arreña, very interesting collection of skills. He throws hard. He gets a lot of ground balls. He's a wicked change-up, but he also had over four walks per nine, and that has been the case at every single level of his minor league career as well. And then Michael Soroka, a strong season with the D-backs. I still think that he just has one great pitch with that slurve. He struggled against lefties. The XERA was closer to four. Interested to see what kind of contract he gets and where he lands, but I don't really see it with Soroka. I'm intrigued by Walbert Arreña though, and I think the ADP, the early ADP is way too low on him.
Speaker 5I agree. 190.5, probably around SP55 or so. I think that's too low for Arreña. He is a fringe top 36, top 40-ish starting pitcher for me. There are clear limitations in his skill set as it presently exists. 123 whip, 11% walk rate, not a great strikeout pitcher, but this is another one where there are two places he needs to get better. Control or strikeout rate, because his swinging strikeout rate was actually 12%, which is pretty good. So it's either getting ahead of hitters a little more consistently or putting hitters away a little more consistently. If he does one of them, I think he's awesome. I think he's like a top 25 starting pitcher. And if he does both, I mean he could be really, really good. There could be some like Christopher Sanchez here. And Christopher Sanchez was a guy who did improve his control as he went on. And obviously, you know, both have really, really sick changeup sinker combinations. I think Sanchez probably benefits a little bit from being a lefty. Yeah. Herania hurt by being an angel in all the ways that that matters. But I'm genuinely kind of shocked at how little enthusiasm there appears to be for this guy, who as a 22 year old, basically skipped AAA. He made three starts at AAA, put up a two 97 ERA with a 329 X ERA. I know the limitations are what they are, but I don't really see things getting worse for Wobbit or Rain yet. This feels like a worthwhile, very cheap bet on someone who's just got a really good chance to build on a very solid rookie season. Aren't those like
Speaker 6enormous ifs though? Sure. They, if he becomes better putting away hitters or if he becomes better getting ahead of hitters, I mean.
Speaker 5Well, but that's what I'm, what I'm saying is if he does that, he's a top 25. Yeah. Okay. Well, even if he doesn't
Speaker 6throw out the Christopher Sanchez, so we're like a guy who's had plus walks per nine at every so far in Wobbit or Rain. Yeah. And Christopher Sanchez, one of the best control pitchers in baseball. So like, yeah, everybody gets, yes,
Speaker 5a really bad control. And look, not everybody develops the same way. And that's why that's what I, what I said was if both of those things happen, I think they're both unlikely. Okay. Like it's probably a 5% chance that they both happen together. And it's probably a 20% chance that they happen independently of each other. But this is one where I think because he does such a good job limiting damage on contact and he does such a good job generating ground balls that I think the floor like he's not a three ERA pitch, but he's probably like a 350 or 360 ERA pitcher. As is as presently constituted. And so that's where I just think there's there's real room for this guy to just take off in a way that you don't typically get from guys at the I wish they would separate RPs and SPs in the ADP. He's 77th among pitchers. I'm guessing he's 50 to 55 among all starting pitchers. And you look around, it's like runner Suarez is pretty good, but he is what he is. And Jackson Jobes right ahead of him. I feel like the Wobbler, the present skills for Wobbler and Rainier are just a lot stronger than Jackson Jobes. Didier Fuentes is right ahead of him. Some pretty big question marks there. Trevor Rogers. I mean, I love Trevor
Speaker 6Rogers, man. I don't that that's that seems like the most underdrafted pitcher in the entire player pool to me.
Speaker 5Trey Savage has huge flaws and he's going like 30 picks ahead. And I know we were more excited about him coming into last seasons. And I think Trey Savage is a pretty good bet this year, but like 30, 30. I'm not sure he 30 picks overall. Okay. Yeah. I don't I just don't think he's 20 or 22 picks of ADP more likely to figure out what's wrong with him than Wobbler and Rainier.
Speaker 6Yeah, I agree with that. I have I have a Rainier 49th. Okay. But 50th is Trey Savage and 51st is Jackson Jobes. So
Speaker 5yeah, I'm with you on some of those. Like Kyle Harrison's behind him, Andrew Painter, Kevin Gosman, Connelly. Like I just I think he stands out in this group for just having really, really defined skills and a very obvious path for improvement if he can do it. It's a big if I grant that, but I just I this is usually a a combination of skill and age that gets overhyped. And I think he's just underhyped.
Speaker 4Yeah, I will point out too. I don't know how much stock to put in this if anything at all, but his location plus was 102 for Wobbler to Rainier. Just to put that in perspective, that's the same amount as like Cam Schlittler this past season, Foster Griffin who, you know, were in like the low to mid twos in terms of walks per nine comparing to someone like Todd Bradley, for example, who was nearly four walks per nine as well. His location plus was 91. And so Wobbler to Rainier was 102. So I don't know if there's anything there. It could just be noise, but the location plus metric actually liked Wobbler to Rainier's command a lot more than it did for Todd Bradley. Someone like Todd Bradley. So we'll see if that could lead to less walks in 2027. We are going to wrap there for Scott. Chris, I am Frank. Thanks as always for tuning into Fantasy Baseball today. Please make sure to follow and leave a five star rating on Apple or Spotify and we will be back again next week. Bye bye!
Speaker 11Bye bye!. games and more. From tip-off to the final buzzer, stay connected to your team all season long. Subscribe to a season-long plan today at Mavs.com slash stream.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The transcript opens with promotional segments for Modelo beer's college football sponsorship, Thumbtack's AI home-project matching service, and CBS Sports' Fantasy Baseball Today podcast.
  2. The Fantasy Baseball Today hosts break down a trade sending Michael Garcia to the Mariners and Bryce Miller, Jose Ferrer, and Logan Evans to the Royals, debating the fantasy impact of the Seattle park shift for both players.
  3. They discuss Sunny Gray's two-year return to the Twins, Dustin May's three-year deal with the White Sox, and qualifying-offer acceptances by David Bednar and Ryan Jeffers.
  4. In the starting-pitcher recap, the hosts analyze tiers of pitchers including Zach Wheeler, Chase Burns, Logan Henderson, Gavin Williams, and Cade Cavalli, weighing breakout seasons against limited track records.
  5. Reid Detmers, Nick Martinez, and Braxton Ashcraft are evaluated, with Detmers' bullpen-driven improvement earning optimism while Martinez's peripheral outperformance is dismissed as unsustainable.
  6. Paul Skeen's velocity and stuff decline is debated at length, with the hosts split on whether his mechanical issues can be fixed in the offseason.
  7. Later tiers cover Brian Wu's expected bounce-back, Garrett Cole's encouraging return from elbow surgery, Jacob deGrom's age-related risk, and Walbert Arreña's intriguing but flawed skill set.
  8. The hosts repeatedly emphasize that most pitchers carry significant risk, encouraging late-round dart throws rather than overpaying for uncertain breakouts.

Summary:

This episode of CBS Sports' Fantasy Baseball Today features hosts Frank Sample, Scott White, and Chris Towers recapping the top starting pitchers from the past season while covering offseason news. They begin with a blockbuster trade between the Mariners and Royals, analyzing how Michael Garcia and Bryce Miller are affected by swapping parks, particularly Seattle's extreme strikeout-boosting environment. The hosts then cover Sunny Gray's return to Minnesota, Dustin May signing with the White Sox, and qualifying offers accepted by David Bednar and Ryan Jeffers, noting these moves are largely positive for fantasy value.

The bulk of the show is a tiered review of starting pitchers ranked roughly 11 through 40. Discussions highlight breakout seasons from Chase Burns, Cade Cavalli, and Peyton Tolley, while questioning whether limited track records justify their rising draft prices. Reid Detmers earns praise for his improved control after a bullpen stint, while Nick Martinez's outperformance is dismissed as unsustainable.

Paul Skeen's velocity decline sparks extended debate about whether his mechanical issues are fixable. Later segments cover Brian Wu's likely bounce-back, Garrett Cole's solid return from surgery, Jacob deGrom's age concerns, and Walbert Arreña's tantalizing but flawed profile. Throughout, the hosts stress that pitcher volatility is unavoidable, favoring volume and late-round upside over certainty.

FAQs

Modelo is the official beer sponsor of the College Football Playoff.

Thumbtack lets you upload a photo or voice note, then uses AI-powered search to match you with a top-rated local pro.

The Mariners received Michael Garcia, James MacArthur, and a minor league reliever, while the Royals received Bryce Miller, Jose Ferrer, and Logan Evans.

Sunny Gray is returning to the Twins on a two-year, $55 million deal that includes an opt-out after the first year.

The White Sox signed Dustin May to a three-year, $52.5 million deal.

David Bednar accepted with the Yankees and Ryan Jeffers accepted with the Twins.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.