Speaker 1Delivered by Little Caesars, the official pizza sponsor of the NFL. Garlic lovers, unite, because right now you can take game day to the next level with cheesy garlic pepperoni for just $6.99. It's a new take on a classic with cheesy garlic white sauce, pepperoni, and surrounded by a toasted garlic parmesan and asiago crust. And we can all agree that pepperoni pizza is delicious, but cheesy garlic pepperoni is next level delicious. Get a cheesy garlic pepperoni pizza for a limited time for just $6.99 only at Little Caesars. Make your game day delicious all season long with Little Caesars. Officially delicious. Available at participating locations for a limited time. Prices may vary and are higher in Alaska, Hawaii, California, many areas in New York, Oregon, Washington, and third-party online sites. Taxes and fees may apply.
Speaker 2Mavs fans. November basketball is heating up in Dallas, and there's nothing like experiencing the excitement live at American Airlines Center. Get ready for high-flying dunks, incredible plays, and the electric atmosphere that only Mavericks basketball can deliver. Bring your family, grab your friends, and be part of the action as the Mavs take on the NBA's best. Don't just watch the highlights, be there when they happen. Get your November game tickets now at mavs.com slash tickets. Let's go, Mavs.
Speaker 3Welcome to the Fantasy Baseball. Today, podcast from CBS Sports. Got a fantasy question? Email fantasybaseball at cbsi.com. Get ready to win your league. Now, here's Frank, Scott, and Chris.
Speaker 4Hey there. Welcome in to Fantasy Baseball today on Tuesday, November 17th. I am Frank Stample, joined by Scott White and Chris Towers. Today on the show, we're going to be talking about the Mavs. Today on the show, starting pitcher recap part one. We'll look at preseason ADP, the biggest bust, breakout, and sleepers, top 12 finishers from this past season. And we've got some news. Perhaps the biggest of all, Scott's goatee is gone.
Speaker 5Evil Scott is gone. End of an era. And Angelic Scott is back. I don't know. Heroic Scott? What would be the opposite of Evil Scott? Just Scott. Normal. Just Scott. There you go.
Speaker 6Yeah. So, big news. He's gone from Walter White to, what was his dad, Hal? Hal. Hal. Hal Wilkerson?
Speaker 5Was that their last name? Malcolm? Malcolm Wilkerson? How in the middle? You're not the boss of me now? Yeah. Never watch that one.
Speaker 4We did get actually.
Speaker 6It's the other show.
Speaker 4Yeah, I know. That guy. We did actually get some big news over the weekend. So, we're going to start with the big news. We're going to start there, then we'll get into all the. Wilkerson, I was right. Okay, sorry. We'll get into all the pitching stuff a little bit later on. But, the big news. The Red Sox signed Jake Bowers to a four-year, $58 million contract. And it was a big breakout season for Bowers, who hit.266 with a.389 on base, 26 homers, 11 steals, and.873 OPS. He hit both lefties and righties well. Big bat speed, big exit velocities. StatCast, however, does not like his swing for Fenway. He hit 27 total home runs last year. That's the postseason included. If he played every game in Milwaukee, that number would still be 27. If he played every game in Fenway, that number would be 18. So, what do you guys think about this move for Jake Bowers heading to Boston?
Speaker 6Don't like it. Yeah, Fenway is a very good hitter's park. And it's a good hitter's park for lefties. It's a very bad hitter's park for power for lefties. And so. It's not great. It's not an ideal hitter's park for him. It's also just a weird fit, I think, in a lot of ways. The Boston Red Sox roster, as presently constructed, does not seem like the roster that they are going to go into the 2027 season with. I think we're going to see multiple high-profile players traded away. Obviously, Jaron Duran feels all but certain. But even so, I mean, you look at this and it's like. They kind of have a full roster of first basemen. And then also. Like, a couple of really good defensive outfielders. And it's just kind of hard to figure out where the pieces are all going to fit. Like. Is Curtis going to be a full-time second baseman now?
Speaker 5Well, yeah, I think that's the plan. As long as he hits well enough to justify it. Because he's not good defensively. But that's what they acquired him to do, Meade. And it never got a chance to come to fruition, of course. Because he got hurt right away. Yeah, I think the plan is. As far as their primary DH, some first base, letting Wilson Contreras flip there. But they will have to get rid of somebody. Or else somebody who we value in fantasy, to some extent, is going to be on the bench. Jaron Duran is most likely. I think it's expected they'll trade him. You always wonder, though, in a case where it's expected they'll trade him. Yeah. Does it completely bottom the value out such that it no longer makes sense to trade them? Which I could see happening. I'm not saying it's the likely scenario. But I could see it. And then you got five players for four spots. You wouldn't think Bowers with this deal would be one of the ones to suffer. He's good against lefties, all of that. But weird things happen when you're trying to jam five players into four spots. And if he has a cold stretch or if he doesn't start out well, you know, things could happen to him.
Speaker 6The nice thing about the fit is he's stood out in a corner outfield spot a few times in his career. This wouldn't be a bad spot. To have to do that if you did have to play Jake Bowers in the outfield. Obviously, if Roman Anthony's healthy, I don't think there's a lot of playing time in the outfield available. But, you know, as a potential hedge on Roman Anthony's, you know, wrist slash hand, maybe there's something there. But you figure it's a very small left field. They have a very good center. I mean, the second best or I don't know, one B center fielder in baseball. Really good defensive right fielder as well. So I could see Jake Bowers. I think some outfield here, too.
Speaker 5The bottom line is, though, this was already the sort of player who was going to invite a lot of skepticism and fantasy. The age 31 breakout.
Speaker 6He doesn't even have 100 career home runs at age 31.
Speaker 5As impressive as all the data is, as theoretically as valuable as Bowers is, just the fact that he never did it until age 31, you should be skeptical. You should approach him. You should approach him with skepticism and drafts. And then for him to go sign with the team that has the venue that's tied for the worst expected home run number for him last year in Pittsburgh, Boston and Pittsburgh tied for the lowest expected home run number for Bowers last year. Not ideal. That increases the skepticism. So I still have him as a top 30 outfielder where you're more likely to play him in fantasy. I have him outside the top 15 at first base. At least in auto leagues, because that's such a deep position. It's going to get drafted in the early to middle-ish stages of the draft. Let's say middle-ish. But to the degree we're already skeptical of Jake Bowers following up on that, you should be even more so now. That's probably the best way to sum it up for fantasy.
Speaker 4The early NFBC ADP for Jake Bowers is 1.5. That is just behind his new teammates, Wilson Contreras and Willier Abreu. And it's just ahead of Josh Naylor and Vinny P. Baby! Does that sound like an okay range for Jake Bowers? Sandwiched between Contreras, Abreu, Naylor, and Vinny Pasquantino.
Speaker 5Uh, I mean, to me, Abreu and Naylor sound too high. But having Bowers a little behind Wilson Contreras sounds. That sounds about right.
Speaker 4I agree. Next up for the Red Sox, as Chris mentioned, they're not done making moves. I mean, we've heard for years now that Jaron Duran was going to be traded. It feels like a foregone conclusion that will happen. And we did kind of get an update here about Roman Anthony. Craig Breslow said he wouldn't commit to Anthony being fully ready for the start of spring training. Anthony has not suffered a setback, but we know when he was in the playoffs, kind of re-injured his wrist and hand. So I guess that was kind of a setback, but he hasn't suffered. He hasn't suffered like a new setback or anything. They just, they can't commit to a timeline. And so they're just kind of leaving it vague, heading into an off season when we will get no news. So that's not great for Roman Anthony. This next one surprised me. It surprised me so much. I texted Scott. I said, what the heck is going on with the Braves? Because they signed reliever Evan Phillips to a three-year, $35 million deal. He is 32 years old. He had Tommy John surgery back in 2025. He returned to the Dodgers in July of this year. He pitched pretty well. 348 ERA, 108 whip. Up over 11K per nine. His fastball velocity was actually up from where it was in 2025. He also gave up a lot of hard contact and a lot of barrels. He has some experience closing. Scott, what's your read here on the signing for Phillips? Is it just insurance because Robert Suarez dealt with like a elbow flexor thing last year? Can you actually just see him being in the mix for saves right away? What do you think?
Speaker 5I think things would have to go wrong for him to be in the mix for saves right. way, though it's possible things could go wrong and he could enter the mix for saves the kind of money they're paying him you have to think he'll be high in the bullpen pecking order you need a whole bullpen of course you don't just need a closer so uh i get i get them bringing in evan phillips who um i think i think the first couple weeks he was back he struggled but then if you take his numbers from that point forward they look a lot more dominant still i i was surprised by the three years like i if you paid if they were paying him 12 million for one year okay i wouldn't make much of that but for them to pay him basically that amount over three years i mean that's that's what a really high-end reliever gets and evan phillips is not somebody i've thought about in a few years it's not uh somebody we're adding for holds and i know he's been injured for part of that time but that's all the more reason why you wouldn't hand him a huge contract by reliever standards so it was it was a bit of a head scratcher uh but yeah he'll be he'll be you know presuming the braves don't bring back ricella glacius which they definitely could but presuming they don't robert suarez first in line for saves dylan lee is up there in a setup role i guess evan phillips becomes the primary right-handed setup man though yeah i would think
Speaker 6phillips is second in line and you know frank you mentioned the scary part of the profile is the quality of contact he gave up i think it was eight homers and 26 or six homers and 26 innings something like that um so you know that's not great but everything else looks pretty awesome like the velocity was back to actually i think it was the hardest he's ever thrown on average um he got 11k per nine the control was good he gave up a lot of fly balls and a lot of homers but it's a very small sample size if you were going to have one of the skills go wrong in that small sample size you'd rather it be the quality of contact just because that's so noisy that it could just be you know three or four extra batted balls that got hit hard but might not in the future so i i think for the most part he looked pretty good and if something happens to robert suarez and again he missed half of last season with a an elbow injury i think evan phillips could absolutely matter for fantasy not someone that i think right now you have to draft in a 30 round draft but in all these drafting holds that are going on right now and and you know especially once we get to spring training and you know anything can happen from that point uh i think there's a decent chance evan phillips matters quite a bit for fantasy in in 2027 yeah
Speaker 4and again there still is a chance that ricel iglesias could resign with the brave so we'll see where he winds up but the way things stand right now it looks like we're going to have to think robert suarez up at the top evan phillips right behind him and i do think the signing of phillips makes it even more likely that didier fuentes will just start in the rotation for the atlanta brave so uh let's hope that is the case uh as a sleeper breakout
Speaker 6type good piece on cbs sports.com about that subscribe to the fbt newsletter yes
Speaker 4yes do all that as expected randy rosarena declined his qualified uh qualifying offer that's one year 23 million dollars believe the deadline is uh here on tuesday so we'll hear about the rest of the as well brian cashman said last week that aaron judge is currently in a good place after a follow up exam on his right rib fracture uh interesting that they went back to the rib but they didn't really update us on the calf i mean i guess it's fine but um yeah the rib was the thing that kept him out for most of the season the mets apparently viewed devin williams as their closer heading into 2027 that is according to pat regazo of the of fan sided the market for catel marte is apparently heating up the blue jays and orioles are both in uh marty does have the 10 and 5 rights that's basically a no trade clause so at this point he can dictate where he gets traded to um and i think it's pretty likely that catel marty will be traded this offseason connelly early has begun his offseason program without any restrictions he dealt with left elbow inflammation this year uh he did get back for one start with the nationals the final weekend of the season so that was good to see and this is good to hear that apparently uh he's good throwing progression should be fine there for connelly early this one out of nowhere jordan lawler apparently uh underwent tommy john surgery to repair the ucl in his right elbow the d bags do expect him to be ready for opening day that seems optimistic yeah because
Speaker 6my understanding is tommy john surgeries for position players are more like a six month uh recovery than the 12 to 14 that we usually see for pitchers but six months is still doesn't the math doesn't really work there unless they're unless it was they're foreshadowing the well when the season will start if it was just right after the season like if it was like the day after the season that would be right around six months right october november december january february march yeah that'd be about right around six months so it's not impossible but if he had the surgery recently it feels pretty unlikely so that's just kind of a different difference of timetable there i guess brandon
Speaker 4marsh underwent surgery on his left hand and uh it was just above his wrist area apparently he played with the injury for several months which could explain his terrible second half the brewers acquired reliever ryan walker from the giants in exchange for two minor league pitchers blake holub and gavin perry i wonder if that's kind of uh foreshadowing a trade of trevor mcgill to come for the brewers which again we have heard that they're shopping him uh if that happens i think abner ribe or aaron ashby or maybe a combination of both could wind up getting saves for next season and we had more awards announced no surprises here we got the ms jacob mizziarowski winning the cy young nl cy young cam schlittler winning it in the al and then your mvps again as expected p crow armstrong and jordan alvarez awesome awesome seasons all right all four
Speaker 5of those awards were unanimous first time that's ever happened
Speaker 4right i i didn't see anything about that but yeah i mean that doesn't feel like it would happen very often i mean
Speaker 6it's just like the the late season oh are we sure junior common arrow isn't the mvp was like yes we're sure he was he had a great season it was awesome but like jordan absent like the three bad weeks that he had between the end of august and the beginning of september and he was the clear mvp i thought i
Speaker 5like that not that it necessarily has to be writers voting for the awards it's it's not so much that all the writers are the ones who know the most but it's just that i like that it's a a voting process i like that we see difference of opinions and how weighted a winner is through that voting process uh having said that it would be hard i i from my perspective it'd be hard to come up with an argument for anyone other than pca for nl mvp or mizurowski for nl cy young or cam schlitter for al cy young agree the one that kind of surprised me was jordan alvarez for al mvp not that i don't think he should have won it i do he was a weak-ish candidate relative to the others i mean the others all had like historic seasons and jordan alvarez had a very good mvp worthy season but other players in the al had mvp worthy seasons too cam schlitter himself i mean bobby witt was the best player in the america
Speaker 6league you know in terms of wins above replacement i think he was like a clear a win clear of everyone they were never going to give it to a guy on i don't know if they were a last place team but not even close to the playoffs and he only hit 18 homers like that's if he had had the exact same season but he had 25 homers instead of 18 i think bobby witt's the mvp even on a last place team or wherever they finished uh and it was just it is hard to look at 18 homers and 54 rbi or whatever it was as good as he is defensively and say ah that's the that's the mvp on a team that won you know 63 games or whatever it was right it's it's it's i i honestly have no idea how many games the royals won that could have
Speaker 4been way off yeah 69 sub 70 sounds about right there for the royals uh big thanks to everyone watching live or on demand make sure to hit that like button on youtube i imagine most people watching this time of the year are already subscribed but for some reason if you aren't subscribe for a while and i'll see you in the next one bye a bunch of off-season content let's take a break and we'll be back right after this
Speaker 7college football season is modello season there's nothing quite like a college football saturday the fight songs the rivalries the traditions passed down from one generation of fans to the next and of course they're settling in for a full day of football with chris modello because saturdays are for the gridiron and cervasus college football is built on tradition and no one knows tradition like modello from the fan quakes that shake the stadium to the rivalry trophies that mean everything year after year these traditions are what make saturday special so if you're listening to this consider it your sign grab a chris modello settle in and enjoy a full day of college football because it's just not game day it's tradition and those who keep college football traditions alive deserve a modello modello is the official beer sponsor of the college football playoff drink responsibly modello especial beer imported by crown imports chicago illinois
Speaker 8dallas men's pro soccer is coming back to the historic cotton bowl This upcoming March, Athletico Dallas takes the field for their inaugural season in the USL Championship. 2027 season tickets are on sale now for as little as $18 per game. Be a part of Dallas history from the very beginning. Men's pro soccer now lives in the heart of our city. Bring your friends, your family, and passion for the game. Make sure you lock in your seats today. Visit athleticodallas.com. That's athleticodallas.com.
Speaker 9I'm Chicharito Hernandez, and Atletico plays for Dallas. Hi, this is PJ Vogt from the Search Engine Podcast. So, you're a great small business owner, but math was never your thing. Totally get it? Enter Xero, that's X-E-R-O, as in X marks the spot for the perfect platform that puts accounting, payments, payroll, and analytics in one connected platform. With visual dashboards, Xero makes it easy to understand your cash flow. You know exactly what's coming in and what's going out. Join 5 million customers worldwide who use Xero to manage their finances. Learn more at Xero.com.
Speaker 4That's X-E-R-O. Welcome back, Fantasy Baseball Today. All right, this is what you came for. Starting Pitcher Recap. This is part one of two, although we could probably make this like a six-part series if we really wanted to, but we're not going to do that. We're only going to make this two episodes long. We're going to start up at top, take a little bit of a macro view at Starting Pitcher right now. The, I don't know, Starting Pitcher seems pretty good. Obviously, it's like extremely volatile and unpredictable from year to year, but according to the Fangraphs Player Rater, we had one pitcher with $40 or more of value, three with $30. 12 with $20. A year ago, zero with $40 of value, three with $30, 14 with $20. So it was a little bit deeper, not as good as up top. If you look at CBS Points Leagues, we had two pitchers with 600-plus fantasy points this year, six with $500, 29 with $400. A year ago, it was two with $600, 11 with $500, so better in that middle part, and then 26 with $400. So it was a little bit deeper from a Points League perspective. This year? But a little bit better up top last season. So, again, remains volatile, unpredictable, both for injury reasons and performance with Starting Pitcher. With that said, I think this position is loaded with talent right now. You just have to navigate the landmines, which is obviously easier said than done. Chris, I know you did some interesting research. I was, again, reading this earlier today about the return on investment among Starting Pitchers, and you found that. Starting Pitcher 25-36 in ADP has provided more value than SP 13-24 in each year since 2021.
Speaker 6That just strikes me as very interesting. I mean, because, like, we talk a lot about how much better, how much more efficient the marketplace is in fantasy sports these days than it was 15 years ago, 20 years ago, 10 years ago. And that is the one place where it's not. Really is, you know, that second. I mean, look, these are all arbitrary endpoints, and it might look different if I did 1-10, 11-20. Like, you know, it's possible that there's just, like, every year, one guy, if you move him from one bucket to another, might change the whole outlook. But when you're going on six straight years of the SP 3s in a 12-team league, outperforming the SP 2s, often by a lot. especially. So in 2026, SP 25-36 as a whole were worth $155, or $156. Let's round up. SPs 13-24 were worth $68. Ugh. The year before, it was only a $35 difference collectively, so about $3 per player. 2024, it was a $61 difference. In 2023, it was a $41 difference. $45 in 2022. Like, those are not even spread across 12 players. Those are pretty significant bumps, and I think this is in line with different versions of this analysis I've done where I've looked at the rounds pitchers are drafted in, and you see something similar where the first tier, however you define it, tends to be a pretty good return on investment. It's that next tier where things get really ugly for starting pitchers, and it's always interesting to think about why. And I think it's just. This year, we had an unusually good group of SP3s because we had Mizyrowski and Schlittler, and I think Jesus Lozardo. No, Jesus Lozardo was in the top 24. Chase Burns. Chase Burns, yeah. We just had an unusually. And we don't have that this year. Like, that specific crop of high-end second-year talents, we don't have that.
Speaker 5But. No, there was, like, a rash of, like, young guns who were on everybody's plate. And those guys are all. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. They're all on everybody's list.
Speaker 6SP1s. Or they may have been on somebody's bust list. I had several of them on everybody's bust list. But I do think what you see there is. It's, like, older guys that were kind of overlooking some flaws. Or young guys who aren't quite there, but we're excited about them, so we push them up. And I think that's generally. Those are opposing stances. Well, no, but I'm saying, like, SP2. The SP2 range is kind of just, like, well, someone has to be drafted here, and we're going to push up. I don't have a good explanation.
Speaker 5How do we consistently pick the wrong somebodies is the thing. That's what's surprising to me. Because, yes, I've heard your analysis before. You might as well draft an ace because the second tier is much less likely to pay off. But then finding out, oh, but the third tier is more likely to pay off than the second tier kind of flips the whole argument on its head in a way. Well, like, that's not to say. How do you distinguish the. The third tier from the second tier? Like, we're consistently getting it wrong, but what are we doing wrong to consistently get it wrong?
Speaker 6My biggest takeaway is less that these third tier SP3s are better than the SP2s. It's worked out that way, and maybe it just will continue to, but my sense has been more that it's just not quite worth paying up for the almost aces. I think that's been my takeaway, that the. However you define it, SP2. SP2s or in the round-by-round analysis that I've done in the past, it's been like, once you get to pitchers picked in, like, round five, the return on investment for round five is basically no better than round 10 for starting pitchers specifically. It's the only group that that's true for, historically. And so my takeaway is less, ah, just skip SP2 and take two SP3s. I don't. Like, that's. Your ability to actually tell which ones are going to be the ones, like, I think that's. But it kind of plays out that way, doesn't it? It does, but. Yeah. You know, like, last year. Okay, yeah, if you bet on Jacob Mizurowski, that worked out great. But it's not necessarily. Like, that was, you know, him and KM Schlittler were like the two guys. They accounted for more than half of the SP3 value. You know, they were, I think, about $75 combined. So it's. I don't know. Like, I don't have a good answer for how to, like, I don't think the answer is just, we should take all the SP3s and rank them as SP2s and rank the SP2s as SP3s. Like, I don't think that makes sense. I don't think that's the actual. No, I'm sure there were
Speaker 5winners from the SP2 group. For sure. Jesus Lozardo.
Speaker 4Yeah, Lozardo and Cease were big winners in that SP2 group. But it is
Speaker 6to say that paying up for non-aces is generally a pretty bad strategy. I think that's the takeaway that we should have from this. It's not. It's not draft the SP3s as the SP2. Like, why don't they make the whole plane out of the black? That's not how it works. Like, you. I think the takeaway should just be be careful with how you spend around pitchers. Just, like, unless they're, like, proven multi-year aces, it's probably not worth paying whatever premium it is.
Speaker 4My early lean is that you should prop. Look, you could win in a bunch of different ways, but my early lean with this data is to use a hero SP strategy. Yeah. To get one top 12 starter and then jump back in in the middle rounds and just attack it there. Or, Scott, the way you've kind of been playing it out the past couple years is just attacking those middle rounds with reckless abandon.
Speaker 5Whatever way you were already approaching it, you could use this data to justify that thinking. Because my approach has been, well, I don't think I'm that good at evaluating whether this pitcher is going to win. I don't think I'm going to be better than this pitcher. Within a certain range. Like, they all have a ton of upside. So rather than saying, I'm going to target this guy making my guy, I'm going to target whichever ones seem to come to me at the best value when there's not, like, an obvious hitter alternative to take there. Just take whatever the best pitcher, in theory, should be on paper and not necessarily make it like your pet pitcher. Like, I'm going to be the one who picks out the ace in waiting here.
Speaker 6I 100% agree. But, like, because, like, okay, if you did that with Jacob Mizurowski this year, okay, that worked out. But you know who everyone was higher on coming into the season? Uri Perez. Who had an okay season? Definitely some stretches. I still think ace potential is there. But if you made Uri Perez your guy, probably didn't have a great season. Everybody made Kyle Bradish our guy, and it didn't work out. And so, you know, that is, like, I mean, in just looking at that SP2 range, We have a lot of people who are We papered over a lot of flaws in this group coming into 2026. Cole Reagans, we love the skills, but the injuries obviously were an issue. Logan Webb, iffy skills. Freddie Peralta, coming off a career year, had never been that good before. George Kirby, just not that dude anymore. Just straight up not the ace he was supposed to be. Kyle Braddish, we gave him a lot of credit for. Here's the thing, not to interrupt
Speaker 5your whole list there, but Cole Reagans was like 7th SP7 coming into the year, I think. 13 in AP. Who was 12?
Speaker 4Oh no, sorry, he was 12. Yeah, Logan Webb was 11.
Speaker 5Not that he was that good either.
Speaker 4Yeah, Max Fried was 10. This is based on our SPC ADP.
Speaker 5I guess what I'm trying to say, so who was 7th?
Speaker 6Logan Gilbert. And who was 8th?
Speaker 5Brian. Brian Wu. Okay, this is really interesting listening. What I'm trying to say is, even if you want to take the hero ace approach. It didn't always work. Well, how do you know where the cutoff for an ace is? Like it's not just automatically number 12. You could have drafted Garrett Crochet. It might be number 5 or number 6. And then you're really having to pay a premium for that. And like, it's just, I don't know. You can't feel too confident in any starting pitcher you draft is generally the way I approach it. But the good news is there's a lot with a ton of upside. So you just, if you become too confident in any one starting pitcher you take, it might incline you to take fewer pitchers than you actually need because, oh, I got this guy. I'm safe for these pitching categories. I got my ace, whatever. You are never. You can never,
Speaker 6you can never, we talk about it for real life baseball team, but it's also true. Your fantasy team, you never have enough pitching. It just, maybe you'll get there at some point in the season. But if you think you have 10 good pitchers at the start of the season, surprise, you've got five at best. Yeah, that's just, that's how high the attrition rate is among pitchers.
Speaker 4Let's take a look at preseason SP ADP. This is according to fantasy pros, the number one pitcher drafted was Tarek Skubal, uh, number two was Paul Skeens. Garrett Crochet was number three. All three of those were being drafted inside the first round. Then you dropped down to Yoshinobu Yamamoto, Christopher Sanchez, Brian, Woo, Hunter Brown, Logan Gilbert, Chris Sale, Max Freed, Logan Webb, Cole Reagans, according to the Fangraphs Player Rater, four, four of those finish inside of the top 12, which was the same amount as last year. So again, just highlighting that kind of. That unpredictability, the biggest bust at the position. I think all things considered, you include injury. It has to be Garrett Crochet being a first round pick and just getting virtually nothing out of him this year. Paul Skeens was also a big bust, but he's still finished as the SP 30, you know, being drafted as a top three starting pitcher, it was obviously not great. It's not what you wanted, but it didn't completely sink you the way that crochet.
Speaker 6There is something to be said for just being able to drop Garrett Crochet. Yeah. Whereas like Paul Skeens, the final, look, the final numbers in a roto league, especially they are what they are, right? Like you'll take 200 strikeouts and a three 80 era and a pretty good whip. Like that's, it's a useful season. You'd rather have that than not, but it was a tale of two seasons.
Speaker 4If you just dropped him midway, you, you would've been better off.
Speaker 6He was awesome for two months and then mid-May
Speaker 5on or 56 era, one 31 whip. And those final 23 starts, he was actively harming you.
Speaker 6That's more than half of the season. Yeah. Yeah. Um, so it's crochet because he was also awful for a month and then got hurt. But I would guess teams with crochet on, I don't know, I could see a world where teams with that drafted crochet, all else being equal did better than teams that drafted Paul skins. I could see that.
Speaker 5I could see, I don't know that I could see it in like a 15 team context, but like a 12 team or 10 team context where you have. You can, you can get lucky off the waiver wire. You're more likely to do that. Uh, I could see it.
Speaker 4Sure. Especially when there were so many names that emerged in season that just went on crazy runs, right? The Logan Henderson's, the Cade Cavalli's, uh, I wrote down basically a handful of names here that I think were pretty big bus this season. Brian Wu was the SP six and ADP finished SP 32. Logan Webb was SP 11 in ADP. He finished pitcher 115, uh, despite a strong finish, Freddie Peralta was SP 14 and ADP. He finished pitcher 155, George Kirby, uh, SP 15 and ADP. He finished pitcher 229. Frambois Valdez SP 19 in ADP finished pitcher 161.
Speaker 6Look, if you have a mid four ZRA for the season and it's, it's really hard to pitch that much and be that much of a negative.
Speaker 5Yeah. And I, I think it probably that particular group of pitchers, the high ERA volume guys, uh, you know, if we did this in points leagues, did the same announce of points leagues, they, they would still be reputable in that format just because they're providing so much volume and the ERA doesn't hurt as much because ratios don't count for anything.
Speaker 6Kirby gave you 175 innings of a 140 whip. Yeah, that's bad. That's a nightmare. That's gonna, that's gonna drag. I did not realize it was a 140 whip. That is. Yeah.
Speaker 4It got really bad as the season went on. The biggest breakouts at the position. I think we know the obvious ones, the Miz. Ben Camp, Schlitler, they both won the Cy Young awards. The ADP for Mizzerowski was 107 for Schlitler is 121. Uh, but I think also Chase Burns, his ADP was 114. Gavin Williams, his ADP was 144. Uh, all four of those finished as top 20 starting pitchers this past season. So, uh, we'll talk about, uh, some of those today, obviously the Miz and Schlitler, those names will come up and then, you know, later in the week, we'll get to those others as well. Some sleepers at the position. This is usually the name like nobody saw coming. Drew Rasmussen, I just felt like we kind of just swept his name under the rug. It was like, ah, you know, he's good, but you know, the Rays limit him and they, there's no ceiling. Yeah. His ADP was myself here.
Speaker 5Now we're going to draft him as an ace.
Speaker 4And of course I, I, that was one thing doing the research today. I already have names that like just cross them off the list. Like I'm just, if he's going there, I'm just not going to draft him. Drew Rasmussen, his ADP was 161. He finishes the SP five Parker Messick, ADP 303. He finished SP nine, Logan Henderson, ADP 295, finished SP 14, Kate Cavalli, ADP 340. He finished SP 16 and shout out to Nick Martinez. ADP 386 finished SP 19, a top 20 starting pitcher. So those five, I, I don't know that any of us saw that coming.
Speaker 5Well, no, not, I mean, look, some of them had that kind of upside. I think, um, Mizzy Rowski obviously had that kind of upside Schlittler. Yeah. Uh, I know Chris was very high on Parker Messick. I ended up drafting Parker Messick on my championship tout wars team in round 26 of a 15 team league.
Speaker 6That was one that just, it never made sense at the time. I thought like, I know that we weren't sure he had a job, but yeah, that felt like you don't get a lot of true sleepers where people are just not seemingly aware of how good a player is.
Speaker 5But even then I, it's not like I drafted him in round 26 thinking, Oh, this guy could be an ace for me. It was, it was like, Oh, maybe he'll win a job and be worth keeping around all year.
Speaker 6That was more copped him to, I think I compared him to Matthew Boyd.
Speaker 5But I will say that list of pitchers, my best teams this year had at least one of those guys on it. It feels like like that, that, you know, peak Armstrong was my most drafted player and surely that helped a lot too. But I think that list of pitching success stories. With very low picks or even mid round picks really says it all the more.
Speaker 4All right, let's take our final break. When we return, we'll actually get into the top 12 finishes from this past season. We'll do that right after this.
Speaker 10Avoiding your unfinished home projects because you're not sure where to start. Thumbtack knows homes, so you don't have to. Don't know the difference between matte paint finish and satin or what that clunking sound from your dryer is. With Thumbtack, you don't have to. You don't have to be a home pro. You just have to hire one. You can hire top rated pros, see price estimates and read reviews all on the app.
Speaker 11Download today. Finding everyday essentials that are actually clean, effective and easy to incorporate into your routine can feel overwhelming. They make simple, non-toxic swaps that actually work. Their clean start bundle is the perfect place to begin with three everyday essentials. Their best selling aluminum free deodorant, mini body butter and lip balm for fresh pits, nourished skin and hydrated lips. Whether you're new to Primally Pure, refreshing your routine, the clean start bundle makes switching to cleaner care simple and gives you an even better value when you start with the bundle.
Speaker 4Welcome back to Fantasy Baseball Today's Starting Pitcher Recap Part 1. We are focusing on the top 12 starting pitchers. This is where they finished according to the Fangraph's Player Rater. I'll also mention how they did in CBS Points Leagues. And your number one pitcher, The Miz. Because I'm The Miz. - And I'm awesome! He was provided $44 of Roto value, 607 total fantasy points and 20.2 fantasy points per game. Those were all three of those were first among starting pitchers. He's your NL Cy Young winner. He was the best pitcher in baseball this year. He was virtually unhittable. He cut the walk rate nearly in half. He tweaked the pitch mix. He threw even harder. He averaged over 100 miles per hour on his fastball. He really is awesome. The only worry we have now is, hey, he throws 100 miles per hour as often as he does. And the innings jump is, it's not egregious. 141 and a third total innings last year, up to 193 and two thirds total this year when you include the postseason as well. So it's not a crazy jump, but it is a jump. What do you guys think?
Speaker 5I'm concerned because I think anytime you're talking about the hardest, the hardest throwing starting pitcher ever, we've seen a few iterations of that in recent years, but this is the latest one, the hardest throwing starting pitcher ever. There's a shelf life to that. Even if, even if he doesn't get hurt, he probably will get hurt at some point, but even if he doesn't, he's just not going to throw that hard forever. And so at what point are you caught holding the bag? It could be 2027 in theory. I don't, I see an outsized reason to say, well, it's going to be 2027. So I have to avoid Jacob is around like this year. He's going to be a bus. Sure. He could be a bust, but like they all could be bust. So could I need literally any picture? I think at some point, some year down the line, Jacob Mizorowski will be a bust, but that's, yeah, that's kind of true for every starting pitcher. So I don't know that you need to fixate on him singularly. If you don't want to pay a first, the first round pick it'll take to get him. I get it. I might not either, but, um, there's not, as I say that I'm, I'm, I'm looking up his final tally here. Uh, final stretch of starts, six starts, including the post season. He had a one 32 ERA. He also just had 8.2 K per nine.
Speaker 6Yeah. He was weirdly not that great in the post season.
Speaker 5He wasn't, he didn't allow runs, but he wasn't the bat missing monster he was during the regular season. So did he start to run out of steam then? You can make the argument. I think though there, maybe the only other guy you could argue for being number one at starting pitcher is, is Scooble just because he's had three years in a row where he's been a total world beater with some injuries along the way. So, you know, it's not an open and shut case, but I don't know. Mizorowski was so dominant that, um, I just can't justify putting anyone else ahead of him in the rankings for next
Speaker 6year. I can squint and see the case for Tarek Scooble. I think it's the coward's case personally. Um, I think the best case is like Scott said, you just, is it a great idea to pick a starting pitcher in the first round, especially only one, one who's only done it once. That's a fair question. And I think you can make the case that he's not worth a first round pick or that you shouldn't be the one to do it. Um, I, yeah, I don't really have any inclination to rank anyone ahead of him though.
Speaker 4Yeah. I, Hmm.
Speaker 6The skillset is just so, so strong. Like as good as Scooble's been as good as crochet was as good as schemes has been. None of those guys have done what Jacob Mizorowski did. Like this is the, I think it's the second lowest whip for a qualifier outside of the 2020 season ever, or in the last years, that was supposed to be a problem for 0.8. Oh, whip. It was like him. And I think there was a Jacob to Grom season and maybe a Pedro Martinez season. Um, but it was about as good as we've ever seen. And it was 265 strikeouts, something like that. Um, just absolutely ridiculous.
Speaker 4Yeah. The number two pitcher this past season was Cam Schlittler. Also your AL Cy Young award winner provided $38 of Roto value. He was second in total fantasy points, third in fantasy points per game like the Miz. He improved his control big time. He threw more cutters and sinkers just leaning into this three fastball approach that souped up Lance Lynn. It seems like it's kind of, uh, taking over baseball right now. You've got cam doing it. Drew Rasmussen, Peyton, totally other pitchers as well, but it kind of feels like this is the fatter right now is, is that three fastball approach. Uh, the only worry for me with cam is that the velocity has just been jumping year after year after year. And, you know, again, it's like it's going to take its toll eventually, but he's awesome.
Speaker 5So, yeah, part of me actually does kind of want to rank him ahead of, of Mizurowski. Even though I said there's no justification for anybody, but Scooble, I'll explain. Um, part of me wants to rank Schlittler ahead because he took on an even bigger workload and he showed less signs of feigning down the stretch. And because while it's an amazing velocity, it's not that unprecedented velocity that raises even more red flags like with Mizurowski. But ultimately the reason I don't think you could justify it is what Chris was pointing out with the whip there. So 0.92 whip for Schlittler. Amazing. Great whip guy, but the, the difference between 0.8 and 0.92 is the difference between 110 and 122, which we would view that as of like the difference between, okay, this guy's pretty good for whip. This guy's bad for whip, you know, like that 0.12 difference is more enormous than it seems if you're just looking at the whips individually. And that's not to say they're both going to repeat exactly the same whip they had, but knowing Mizurowski has that kind of unprecedented whip upside,
Speaker 6like that's, I just think Mizurowski, Mizurowski skill set stronger. Like as good as Schlittler is the best argument for him is he's probably a better bet for ratings. Like that's the Yankees really trust their pitchers. They, they, they let their guys go deep. Like that is a thing with the Yankees. I, I can't justify Schlittler over Mizurowski for that. When the, the gap in talent as good as Schlittler is, I just think Mizurowski is kind of on a different level than anyone we've seen since, uh, see Jacob DeGrom.
Speaker 4Yeah. And you see it like among qualifiers, the Miz was first in, in virtually everything. When you look at, uh, his stuff plus his K per nine, his K minus walk rate, his swinging strike rate. And then even if you just line up the ERA estimators for the Miz, 217 FIP, 229 XFIP, 235 Sierra, 212 XERA. For Cam, it was 256 FIP, 286 XFIP, 293 Sierra, 285 XERA. So more in the high, like twos range, whereas the Miz, like everything is in the low twos. It's goes to show truly how dominant he was. The number three starting pitcher was Yoshinobu Yamamoto. His preseason ADP was 24, uh, as the SP four. And he finished as SP three here, uh, perhaps the highest floor of any pitcher. If you can even have a floor as a pitcher, uh, but he provided 31 and a half dollars of Roto value fourth in total fantasy points. Second in fantasy points per game, he has provided a sub one whip, two years in a row, only got to 28 starts, but still managed to rack up 185 innings just because he was so efficient. Believe he led all baseball in innings pitch per start. Uh, you look at the strikeouts,
Speaker 66.6 innings per start.
Speaker 4Yeah. The, the, the K rate came down this year, but it seems kind of fluky to me because the swinging strike rate was basically in line with 2024 and 2025. So, uh, I, I would bet on Yamamoto strikeouts bouncing back, maybe probably closer to like 10 K per nine again next year, which, that's where he's normally at.
Speaker 6Yeah. I mean, maybe it makes him a little less efficient and you know, but like his strikeout rate went down from 29.4 to 25.7%. That's a pretty big drop, but his walk rate dropped by almost the same amount. Yeah. And he was more efficient. So yeah, he got 19, he got 19.7 whip. Yeah. He got 19 fewer strikeouts than the year before. Yeah. I don't think that's, I think you take that trade off.
Speaker 5Yeah. Would you rather have 19 more strikeouts or would you rather have a 0.12 difference in whip? That's how much Yamamoto's whip drop from a 2025 to 2026 putting like, if you're getting below 0.9, I mean, that's insane and it's more valuable probably for Roto, even in the extra strikeouts. He was better. Yeah. I do wonder if there's still a best of all worlds scenario where he has the great walk rate and he has the good strikeout rate and maybe Yamamoto's the best pitcher in fantasy, but you know, you don't draft, you don't draft along those lines. You don't draft for the best of all worlds scenario. He's an ace. I think regardless of how that trade off between walks and strikeouts looks.
Speaker 6Yeah. Maybe the ceiling is lower for him than some of the other guys were talked about, but he's so good that it doesn't really matter.
Speaker 4And again, it's like, I don't know how reliable any pitcher's floor is, but if you, you want to find a way to quantify it, I think Yamamoto is among the best floors at starting pitcher in all
Speaker 6fantasy. I know he's only been in the majors for three years. This guy's been one of the 10 best pitchers in the world for five or six years. Like this is not a small sample size we're dealing with. He's just been this good for a long time now.
Speaker 4The number four starting pitcher was Chris sale who had a preseason ADP of 39 as the SP nine. And again, finishes as the SP four here, stay away father time. We are not done with Chris sale. Just yet provided $29 and a half dollars of Roto value. He was ninth in total fantasy. points tied for fourth in fantasy points per game because he just doesn't give you as much volume as other aces. But on a per inning per start basis, he's still among the best in baseball in three seasons with the Braves. Now put all those numbers together. It's a two 36 era, one Oh two whip 11.4 K per nine. I know that he's 37 years old and that just makes him more likely to get injured as, as much as a pitcher can get injured. I just think he's more likely because he's 37, but when you dig into the profile guys, I just don't see anything wrong with it when it comes to Chris sale.
Speaker 6He, he has, he maybe has fragile bones. I think that's the only knock you can make against him at this point really. Cause since he came back from Tommy John surgery, what five years ago, the only injury risk, the only injury issues that he's had, I believe have been, I guess there was the, the back at the end of 2024. But other than that, it's been, it's, it's just a lot of fluky broken bones, right? Like there was the, he got hurt riding a bicycle. He got hurt in 2025, like fielding a ball.
Speaker 5Yeah. I mean, just look at it more recently. The last three years is three years with the Braves. The only time he's missed with injury was when he broke his rib, diving for a ball in 2025, 2024 and 2026. We're all completely healthy. I know he missed some time in the post season in 2024, but for, you know, that was the year he made his most starts with the Braves, 29 of them, which does underscore another point for being healthy. Last year, Chris sale made only 27 starts. He threw only 162 and two thirds innings. The Braves, he never throws on four days.
Speaker 6I don't think he's thrown on four
Speaker 5days rest since he got to the Braves. They build in a lot of extra rest for him in order to keep him healthy. And that's part of the reason why he was only the seventh best pitcher overall in points leagues while he was fourth best in Roto. Obviously those ratios are sparkling, but, but you need the volume a little more in points leagues. So maybe a slight amount of separation for sale in those two formats. And I do worry, you know, if he's only, only good for a two 90 ERA next year, rather than two 16, how much with that innings deficit, how much does that cost him in fantasy? Still, he's my sixth ranked pitcher for next year.
Speaker 6I think the floor is as high as it can be for a guy with the inherent injury risk. But I, he's my number five SP.
Speaker 4Yeah. All right. Moving on to number five this past season. That was drew Rasmussen preseason. ADP was one 61 drafted as the SP 50. It was a career year for Rasmussen as the raise took off the kid's gloves provided $29 of Roto value. He was fifth in total fantasy points, seventh in points per game. He's always been awesome. It's just a matter of volume since joining the raise back in 2021. Two 71 ERA 0.99 whip 8.3 K per nine. He doesn't give you the strikeouts of other aces in fantasy, but his ratios since joining the raise as good as they get. So he got all the way up to 202 thirds total innings. When you include the post season worries me a little bit for Rasmussen. It's like just that big jump and the most innings he's ever thrown in a season. He's entering a contract year. But yeah, look, if he's healthy and good to go, the ratios will be as, as good as anybody.
Speaker 5Yeah. Since becoming a full-time starter in 2022 and there have been injuries along the way, but since becoming a full-time starter in 2022, he's never for a season had higher than a two 84 ERA and he's never had higher than a one Oh eight whip. The total during that five year stretch is two 74 ERA and an even one whip. So he's as safe as they come for ERA and whip, but he is a little lacking. And the strikeout department and that kind of puts them in the same category as a max freed. He's a little better for whip than max freed has been at his best to be fair. It is a little, the ceiling's a little higher, but he's more of that state. He's more of that category stabilizer at the top of your rotation rather than that overpowering dominant force. And do you want to invest a, well, how high of a pick do you want to invest in that? What, what's his 80 piece right now? I think it's SP 12. Yeah. It's for where, where is it overall? Uh, 54. That doesn't sound bad to me. That's round five in a 12 team league. Um, it's fine. Yeah. That, that seems fine. Yeah. Um, yeah, he's not like great value or anything, but it seems fine.
Speaker 6It is like comparing max for, he does an interesting one because it's like max freed is definitely more, uh, dealing with injury. Red flags. Rasmussen is a 32 year old, I believe who just threw more than 150 innings for the first time in his career.
Speaker 5He'll be 32 in July. So he's, he's next year. I'll be his age. 31. Yeah. Um,
Speaker 6he is a double Tommy John and internal brace guy. I believe I, I think there are risks for sure with giraffe. Yeah. Like this is the first time he's ever really given us anything close to an ACE workload. And it was still only 172 innings. Um, but I think SP 12 is probably fine. I think that's basically right where I have him ranked. Let me see. I have him 11. So yeah, that's,
Speaker 4that's fine. The SP six was Dylan cease. His preseason ADP was 71 as the SP 16. Uh, his first year with the blue Jays was outstanding. He provided, $24 of Roto value eighth in total fantasy points, 12th in points per game. He just became more of a complete pitcher credit to the blue Jays. He mixed in more change-ups curves and sinkers. That change-up was an awesome pitch for him, but his season ended with a shoulder injury. The fastball velocity dropped big time in the second half. So it was scary. Like, I don't know. It was worrisome at the time, but he was still getting good results that we didn't really know what to do with it. And then getting better results for a while. It was weird.
Speaker 6It was, it was like it never, it never limited him.
Speaker 4Yeah. And I think, I think they kind of just let him go cause he was chasing the Cy Young award. And I, I get that. But the fact that his season ended with a shoulder injury and we didn't see him return, you know, it's, it's scary heading into next year.
Speaker 5And there were reports as it was happening that he was kind of going easy at the beginning of starts. And that's the way it played out with his velocity is velocity be way down at the beginning of the start. And then it pick up over the course of the start. And it was like, it was by design. the shoulder injury kind of puts that in a different light and maybe it wasn't as much by design as it was reported at the time, though, I guess we can't really prove that, uh, there is that element to it, but it, it obviously left a bad taste in our mouth. Uh, the, the way he finished, he had two really rough starts in September that took them out of the running for Cy Young. And then he ended with the shoulder injury and shoulder injuries are bad. It may not be a bad shoulder injury. It's inflammation. That's what they called it, but we didn't get to see him return and full strength. And, and then there's the track record where it's been very up and down over the years. I hope that the blue J sorted out that aspect with the addition of the new pitches,
Speaker 6but his walk rate was still crazy high. He had the highest walk rate he's had since 2020 actually, which I think is hilarious that he also arguably had his best season while doing that. Um, so I, I rank him 10th.
Speaker 5I feel great about my top nine. I feel like these are the right top nine. They may not agree with ADP, but I feel like my top nine are the right top nine. Dylan Cease is the first one where I'm like, this doesn't feel right 10th, but putting him 12th or 13th doesn't feel right either. And so I don't know if that's itself is going to make him an avoid for me unless it's just great value.
Speaker 6Yeah, this is one that I think we had two big, big wins for the trust, the process approach to ranking pitchers because him and Jesus Lizardo were the two guys that you could tell yourself, well, I know what the peripherals say, but my eye test, and this is what I did this with Jesus Lizardo. I thought that he was just going to keep out underperforming his expected stats because that's what he's done for most of his career. Dylan Cease has done that for a lot of his career as well, but this is a big win for both him and Lizardo. For the just, whether you want to go with the smart advanced metrics like XERA or just FIP either way, you got a big win for those guys and it's, it's a win for target skills in both cases. And I do, I will be going with cease over Lizardo. I don't know if that's the right choice.
Speaker 5Lizardo is one of the nine that I feel good about.
Speaker 6Okay. I was like, I didn't think Chase Burns was going to be in that.
Speaker 5So yeah, Chase Burns is number nine. He's in there.
Speaker 4Okay. I think I would lean Lizardo overseas too solely because he returned in the playoffs and he looked good in his velocity.
Speaker 6Yeah. Yeah. I think so. However, many starts cease missed at the end of the season, two or three, maybe one or two. I don't know what, what the exact number was. That was the first, first starts. He's missed with injury. I think ever in the major. Yeah. I literally don't think he had missed. There was maybe like a COVID. IELTS stint at one point, but I don't think he's missed it. start due to injury ever but i remember there was a point where we're saying about that that about corbin burns the year it's the year corbin burns got tommy john surgery i believe that was a thing that we said about him so it's you can't predict the
Speaker 5shoulder is an additional worry on top of existing worries for me since the walk rate was still bad i think that leaves him for with a very low margin for error leaves dylan sees very low margin for error performance wise i think both
Speaker 6luzardo and cease have that in common it takes a different form and we'll talk about who's his luzardo now but i think luzardo is just he gets hit really hard when he gets hit hard you know like and i think that's a skill um cease it's the walks like they both have one big red flag in their profile i think all
Speaker 5right well let's didn't get hard hit hard this past not at all no for sure
Speaker 4let's talk about it jesus luzardo was the number seven starting pitcher his preseason adp was 74 the sp18 drafted so him and cease drafted basically back to back and finished top seven pitchers basically back to back here uh get yeah trust the process with luzardo he provided 24 dollars of roto value sixth in total fantasy points tied for ninth in points per game 286 era 107 whip 11.1k per nine he got off to a slow start but from may on he was just outstanding he leaned on that sweeper more uh unfortunately he also dealt with that shoulder injury but he did return for a start in the playoffs he pitched well in that one and the velocity was fine so i look you still worry because it's a shoulder but i think you feel a little bit better about luzardo than you do for cease because at
Speaker 6least we saw him return um you would rather see them return than not but i i don't see how you can look at the totality of dylan cease and jesus luzardo's careers and say that just because jesus jesus luzardo came back for a playoff start and that cease has more injury risk like dylan cease again had never missed a start in the majors before this jesus luzardo has missed a few over the course of his career um he has had several seasons completely wrecked by injuries he's had shoulder surgery he has had tommy john surgery he's had a lot of different surgeries he's a he's a frequent customer so if you want to say luzardo's skill set is safer because of the you know the the better control and similar strikeout i i think that's fair but i i can't get on board with jesus luzardo is a better bet from a health perspective than dylan cease if they are both equally healthy right now and i have to assume that they all yeah
Speaker 5yeah i mean that's fine if if dylan sees comes into spring training with a clean bill of health and throwing as hard as normal whatever that looks like anymore um then i'm that's probably going to remove the injury risk at least put him on equal footing with any other pitcher as far as that goes i'm not saying luzardo is a model of health by any means it's my my affection for him is more i mean look at the year he just had oh yeah he was perfect basically there's nothing i can point to that said i wish he did this better uh swinging strike rate was incredible strikeout rate and ground ball rates were both tied for sixth among qualifiers weak contact only 87.3 miles per hour that was a really two years in a row where it was weak in 2025 he had the pitch tipping problem where i'm sure it wasn't weak in those starts walk rate is fine like it was all good it was all good for luzardo like a perfect pitcher in 2026 which doesn't mean he necessarily is going to be that in 2027 but also none of it was really out of character except for maybe the hard contact and again i'm saying that's kind of a two-year trend though of him yeah no i'm not allowing hard contact i
Speaker 6think that's i i still i think it's hard to get past the injury risk with luzardo just given how much of his career has been defined by that but otherwise i think you're right there's there's very few holes to pick in his game the number
Speaker 4eight starting pitcher was tarik scooble preseason adp was eighth overall the number one that starting pitcher being drafted did have loose bodies removed from his elbow but that didn't that couldn't stop him he still finished here as a top 10 starting pitcher provided 24 of roto value 17.7 fantasy points per game that was sixth among starting pitchers he had the surgery mid-season once he returned it took him a little bit of time to get going but eventually he did get there and he was basically tarik scooble down the stretch of course he got traded to the dodgers he's just so proven uh 626 innings since 2023 of a 247 era 0.92 whip nearly 11 k per nine he's a free agent this offseason it sounds like he wants to sign before the lockout december 1st or 2nd whatever it is um will be interesting to see where he lands kind of sounds like the new york mets are the uh the leader in the clubhouse for tarik scooble what could go wrong
Speaker 5before i was gonna say i i will won't care where he signs unless it's colorado but you know the mets uh big big dollar free agents going to the mets doesn't they don't have a good track record um no i won't care where he signs unless it's colorado but you know the mets uh big big dollar i want to i want to put too much stock in that really it doesn't matter to me where scooble signs because he's not signing with colorado or if you want to throw the athletics in there as another no-go i don't think it's as bad as colorado for for pitch shape but yeah he's not going to either of those places so i really don't care where scooble signs he's going to be a first round
Speaker 6pitcher for me regardless it is really really rare to have a pitcher who has been as good as in baseball since he came back from the flexor tendon surgery in 2023 i believe um basically since he stepped on a mound in the 2023 season he's been the best pitcher in baseball not every moment of that time because obviously jacob mizurowski exists now but yeah to to get a pitcher with this track record as the number two sp is super super rare i i think he's closer to i think it's a clear a more clear two than a than three um so as long as you have schlittler too just no i i understand um i just think the as good as schlittler was last year i don't think it was better than any of scoobles full seasons like in in terms of skills um sure and scoobles healthy right now so i i yeah there's a little bit of added risk coming off of a surgery like but we already saw him pitch oh yeah we saw him
Speaker 5pitch for a long time
Speaker 6yeah so i don't really like if we're tying in 35 to the baseline injury rate for pitchers maybe he's closer to 40 but i don't think it's significant i don't think his injury risk is higher than schlittler or mizurowski it's not a firm opinion i hold
Speaker 5that i think they're probably back to back not just a starting pitcher but overall for me schlittler and scooble but i do have scooble higher i mean schlittler
Speaker 4higher i haven't ranked yet but i am one of the cowards chris that will rank terry scooble as the sp1 heading into next season i won't draft him i won't draft any picture in the first round you're
Speaker 6not gonna be you're not gonna be alone like we we had that multiple panels at uh fpaz people asked are you taking scooble over mizurowski and it wasn't the majority opinion but it wasn't like a small minority it was probably closer to 35 to 40 of the people so i think you won't be alone in scooble over mizurowski and i think it's like i just said given the track record the the length and quality of the track record for terry scooble is almost always the sp1 and the fact that you can maybe get him in the second round this year that's cool that's that's that's very nice let's
Speaker 4wrap up with two more names here and number nine starting pitcher that was parker messick who had a preseason adp of 303 as the 97th starting pitcher drafted chris i think we could define him as like a medium beefy baseball boy he's pretty oh yeah oh
Speaker 6he's no he's a big beefy baseball
Speaker 4all right we'll go he's
Speaker 6like big beefy he's got a very interesting body shape uh he's got like real small legs like long beefy torso he's he's he's fun he's also just fun to watch like that was that was one that like i like the numbers and the metrics but also like part of it was like that boy good like that that's just like i think he's a really good pitcher
Speaker 4it's cliche too you hear it about so many pitchers the bulldog mentality but he he really is a bulldog provided 23 of roto value 11th in total fantasy points he was 17th in points per game uh awesome season with that fastball change of combination 256 era 106 whip but it's more like a load of mid threes on all the era estimators you know the the control was out of whack in the postseason and and that was a problem for him in the minors i think the expectation should be a step back here for messick as great as he was i i think a low to mid threes era makes sense to expect moving forward
Speaker 6i don't disagree i think his price is still at least in these early drafts still a little soft i think he's around 20 maybe later it's hard to say because he's 32 at pitcher but there are some amount of closers and i can't count
Speaker 4that high yeah he is 78 he's actually behind cavalli and ahead of henderson so that's just an - Yeah. - Trio, Cavalli, Messick, Henderson all in order there I
Speaker 6think I'm going to be just a little bit more skeptical of Cavalli but I think Messick's a really really nice SP2 and and if you're going to draft anyone in that range I think he's got a good combination of skills and however much floor can exist for a young pitcher I think it's there like he's thrown the innings he's made the starts he's really solid I don't think he's an ace but I think he's really good
Speaker 5where do you have Messick in your starting pitcher rankings
Speaker 6uh first draft was 17 I have
Speaker 5him 14 but kind of like cease Messick and Cade Cavalli those three it felt like wherever I put them wasn't quite right yeah I got that
Speaker 6like I've got him ahead of Jacob DeGrom I I don't really know I've got him right behind Nolan McLean those two feel pretty similar to me um yeah I have McLean
Speaker 5I have McLean 22nd so I might just it's the high whip right uh the high whip and the low swinging strike rate he just it feels like he's trending toward being a pitch to contact type that's fair I I think
Speaker 6he's I think he's better than that but I I get it um but yeah I I think Messick is kind of a pitch to contact guy too
Speaker 4yeah it's only an 11% swinging strike rate for Messick like he's not but we're talking he's not Nick Martinez I don't want to say
Speaker 6he's a pitch to contact guy like he misses bats but it's it's not like a huge bat missing profile um I think Messick and McLean are both very good I'll take either of them in that range plus McLean's walk
Speaker 5rate a lot higher than Messick's
Speaker 4yeah yeah let's wrap up here with Christopher Sanchez the number 10 starting pitcher his preseason ADP was 28 he was the fifth starting pitcher drafted uh so I yeah I don't think he's I know Scooble dropped down a little bit so Sanchez I think is the only other name here that was um drafted higher than where he finished but like Yamamoto I mean it's just an incredibly high floor for Sanchez he gets so many ground balls gets a good amount of whiffs uh obviously the whip was a problem this year 1.2 whip or higher in two of the last three years uh for Sanchez but he gives you a ton of volume he's up over 200 innings two years in a row he's an ace but the whip is a problem is something you have to account for especially in a category and
Speaker 6it's probably not a total fluke because that is well dreadful defense behind him it it's going to look a lot different next year
Speaker 5though because Boehm is going to be gone a rise is going to be gone I think they should move Trey Turner to second base I don't know that they will but I don't know if they did but I I think I I think rather than approaching Christopher Sanchez as if he's a bad source of whip you just have to approach him as if he's a volatile source of whip because the Phillies defense wasn't any different really in 2025 and he had a 106 whip it wasn't Trey Turner just
Speaker 6magically played incredible defense for one
Speaker 5year well yeah I guess that helped but 2020 so really two of the last four years Sanchez has had a whip around 105 and then the other two years it's been like 120 and that's partly because he's such a big ground ball pitchers ground balls introduce a lot more volatility to the batted ball profile uh so I'm not saying it's not a concern but I'm not ranking him as if he's going to have a 120 whip
Speaker 6again no I'm just I don't think he's someone you should look at who will definitely help your whip and I think that's probably the first guy we've talked about that I would say that about maybe cease but even then he limits hits really well generally um but Sanchez
Speaker 5is a great control pitcher he's a great control pitcher he's a great ground ball pitcher like one of the best both of them is a great control pitcher he's a great ground ball pitcher he's a great control pitcher and he's become a great strikeout pitcher yes uh increasingly the last two years he was 10k per nine this past year so he I was saying Luzardo is perfect Sanchez is pretty close to perfect too it might just in his case it's like he allows too many ground balls for his own good um normally that's a good thing but it's it's it kind of comes back to bite him a little bit but I I still see him as a true ace he's my number
Speaker 12four for next
Speaker 5year
Speaker 6he's six for me small small samples or small differences there but I agree almost entirely I just think he's among the top you know whatever you called it nine whatever it ends up being he's probably the weakest whip source of that group I would
Speaker 4probably expect like a 110 to 115 whip but just realizing the kind of ranges of outcomes where like the floor could be 120 once again and over that level of volume 200 innings it just it's it's a lot it's it it it affects you even more so you just you have to make sure you you draft um a couple other whip specialists along with with Christopher Sanchez if you want to hear way too early starting pitcher rankings for 2027 make sure to tune into FBT Express because we're doing exactly that and we are going to wrap there for Scott and Chris I am Frank thanks as always for tuning in to Fantasy Baseball today please make sure to follow and leave a five-star rating on Apple or Spotify and we'll be back again later this week bye
Speaker 12Paramount Podcasts The Stratotech Tee from Viore is one of those shirts you put on once and immediately get why people love it it's incredibly soft stretches with you dries fast and still looks sharp enough to wear from a workout to the ballpark without missing a beat it's become my go-to tea for pretty much everything head to viore.com slash pod 20 for 20% off your first purchase exclusions apply visit the website for full terms and conditions