The Ringer NFL show evaluates the 2026 NFL draft, identifying both winners and losers across franchises. The Cleveland Browns stand out as a clear winner, having made shrewd, long-term draft moves focused on starter-level talent across offense and defense. Their strategy—centered on addressing core needs, securing quality players at premium positions, and rebuilding from a history of failure—demonstrates a significant shift toward sustainability. The New York Giants are also praised for strong draft value, with top-10 picks in offensive tackle and linebacker, and a balanced roster of high-ceiling and reliable players. In contrast, several teams face criticism: the New England Patriots are a “loser” due to head coach Mike Vrabel’s public withdrawal from day three of the draft without addressing a reported personal scandal, creating instability and distrust. Jacksonville’s draft is seen as reactive and poorly strategic, with a high-risk pick of Nate Borkature far above his consensus ranking, lacking clear alignment with team needs. The Rams’ selection of Ty Simpson at 13 and Max Cale at 35 raises concerns about quarterback depth and offensive fit, undermining their established strengths. While the Rams remain a favorite to win the Super Bowl, the draft choices are viewed as ill-timed and misaligned with their current roster. Overall, the analysis underscores the importance of long-term planning, transparency, and alignment between leadership decisions and team-building goals.
This episode is brought to you by Ethos.
Buying a house is one of those moments where you realize,
oh yeah, I have responsibilities now.
And if you have a family,
you want to know they could stay in that house
if something happened to you.
Ethos makes life insurance painless.
Get a quote in seconds,
apply in minutes, all online with no medical exam.
Take 10 minutes to get covered today
with life insurance through Ethos.
Get your free quote at ethos.com slash ringer NFL.
That is E-T-H-O-S.com slash ringer NFL.
Application times may vary, rates may vary.
This episode is brought to you by Chevrolet.
Chevy drivers need a truck
that shows up the same way they do.
That's why Chevy Silverado is number one
in manufacturer loyalty,
so they can go where others won't.
Make their own way there and always get it done.
And as long as Chevy people keep showing up,
we'll keep building trucks
that do the same.
Chevrolet, together, let's drive.
Visit chevy.com slash trucks to explore the lineup.
Welcome to the Ringer NFL show.
I'm your host, Sheil Kapadia.
The 2026 NFL draft is in the books.
We're doing winners and losers today.
We're looking at the entirety of the three days.
Which teams do we feel like,
hey, they did a good job with the
resources they had.
Which other teams do we say,
you know what?
I don't know.
I don't know about what they did
with some of these decisions
over draft weekend.
So we're going to have on my friend,
Deontay Lee from the Ringer.
Do winners and losers with Deontay
when we come back.
All right.
We are back here on the Ringer NFL show
doing drafts.
Draft winners and losers.
We did the first round Deontay after Thursday night.
A lot of picks have been made since then.
What like 226 picks or something like that.
There have been trades.
There have been stories.
And so we're basically just ping ponging back and forth.
You could do a winner.
You could do a loser.
What topics are front of mind?
You get to get us started.
Where are you going?
You going positive?
You go a negative?
How are we starting this?
You know me, man.
I'm the eternal optimist.
I feel like that is just my mode of being for everything.
Maybe not Eagles related.
I am an eternal optimist.
So let's start off with the winner.
And I think I'm going to go off the beaten path.
Somebody or I guess a team, a franchise
and an executive brain trust
that I probably don't give very much credit to often.
And I'm going to say it's the Cleveland Browns.
I thought my first winner as well.
Deontay, what a moment for the Browns
on the Ringer NFL show.
It's already the most positive buzz they've gotten.
I think since I started working here.
So there you go.
Absolutely.
I mean, and I feel like so.
Often we're talking about like, you know,
how analytically driven their decision-making is.
And, you know, they always seem to want,
they always want to be pushing maybe a stride
and a half ahead of wherever they think
the trend lines are supposed to be, right?
They're going to take whatever data you get
from the draft or free agency or whatever.
And they're going to try to maximize it to me.
And it's not necessarily that they abandoned
that approach in this draft.
I just think that to me, they went with what was obvious,
right, which is that they needed starters.
They especially needed starters on offense.
And I think that they really went out with their top 50 picks
and approached this like, we need to walk out of this
with three potential starters.
And I think that they did that.
Getting Spencer Fano, I think was probably the best
top 10 tackle they could have grabbed, right?
That's somebody that I've been very warm on
throughout this process.
Even when there were questions about whether or not
he was going to be able to play out at tackle.
Does he need to kick to guard?
They ended up getting a versatile guy.
And I think that they need a guy like that to where,
even if he's not the perfect guy,
he's a perfect prospect at tackle.
They can still get starting quality from him on the interior.
I think the wide receiver duo of Casey Concepcion and Denzel Boston,
not only does that fit two major needs that they had,
they didn't have a field stretcher and explosive play threat
the way that Casey Concepcion can be.
And they don't have a big body guy that can go out and win
out on the perimeter the way that Denzel Boston can.
So if those two guys end up being the best versions of themselves,
I think you're going to be really happy.
And I think it compliments guys like Harold Fanon and Kunshan Jenkins
and all the guys that they have on offense really well.
And it gives whoever ends up under center,
taking quarterback snaps for them,
an opportunity I think to be successful.
And then I loved,
maybe a major value for me for how much I liked his tape,
getting Emmanuel McNeil-Warren right at the tail end in the second round.
I felt really,
really happy with them being able to go out and make that pick.
And most of their day three picks as well,
I would say,
are guys that project to be able to compete,
to start maybe outside of tail and green,
who might need a little bit of time to hone.
Some of the mechanical issues and some of the decision-making issues that come
up with him as a quarterback.
It's so hard at this night,
especially talking draft.
What happens is I feel like the worst teams,
sometimes the worst franchises in the NFL get the most shine.
And sometimes it's just because,
well,
they had,
they had high picks of court,
like,
of course,
you know,
they're going to draft prospects we know,
and we've heard up.
And so I do want to,
you know,
that context is always important.
You know,
one of the reasons why we've created this mess,
you know,
this is all about digging out of that hole from one of the worst decisions of our lifetime.
A team has made,
which is the trade for Deshaun Watson and the ensuing contract for Deshaun Watson.
That is what they're trying to dig out of.
And that is this regime.
That is Andrew Barry.
That is this ownership who made those decisions.
So that is all important context here.
Having said all that,
man,
that might've been the biggest caveat in the history of the show right there.
But having said all that I'm with you.
If the goal here was to dig out.
Of that hole and try to find a path towards getting on the right track and building a winning franchise.
I think they did a really nice job here.
I mean,
you mentioned it with all the players.
I don't need to repeat what you said.
I think they did a good job.
Premium positions,
starters also trading down from six to nine.
So you read the draft,
you know,
kind of the rest of the league.
You read that properly.
You let the chiefs move up,
you get additional draft capital and you still get the offensive tackle you want there.
And then this really goes back.
To last year,
Deontay,
because this has been at least a two year process of trying to dig out of that Deshaun Watson ditch.
And,
you know,
last year,
the Jaguars want to move up for Travis Hunter.
They say,
all right,
come get him.
And they get the additional first round pick this year,
which worked out well for them because then later in the draft,
you mentioned it,
they get Carson Schlesinger,
they get Harold fan and junior,
they get quench on Judkins.
There's a chance that if the Cleveland Browns make the playoffs,
then I don't think it's going to be this year.
Let's say,
two years from now,
even three years from now,
we look back and we say the 2025 draft and the 2026 draft.
We say,
man,
look,
look at what they did at those two drafts.
That set the stage.
All these core players are from those two drafts.
And that is part of NFL GM.
Now,
not all GMs get the opportunity when you screw something up really badly to get a second opportunity,
but even someone like,
I would say,
Howie Roseman of the Eagles,
like maybe his biggest strength is when they have a disaster of a season,
figuring out a way to get,
to get out of that,
to move on from certain assets and to rebuild the roster.
And so I think Andrew Barry,
we've criticized him a lot in the past and totally rightfully.
So I don't,
you know,
take back anything.
I don't feel bad at all.
Yeah,
I don't feel bad at all.
Right.
But to look at it objectively and fairly,
I think he's done a good job here these last two years.
Now,
having said all that,
the big,
you know,
the elephant in the room is we don't know what they're doing at quarterback.
We don't know if their head coach is going to be any good and they still profile.
As you know,
one of the worst teams in the NFL in 2026,
but it's a step in the right direction.
You know,
it's almost like we talk about the jets.
Like,
can you,
are you putting an infrastructure in place where,
when your quarterback lands,
hopefully for both franchises next year,
that the guy has a chance to succeed.
And I think you can make the case that they're on the way to at least doing that.
Absolutely right.
Like we don't,
we don't often get the gift of really taking a long view with franchises because this isn't the MLB.
This isn't baseball where you're happy about a draft.
Pick with an understanding that I might not see this guy playing at the biggest level for half a decade.
Right.
But I do think that for Cleveland,
from Cleveland's perspective,
the only way they're going to dig themselves out of the Deshaun Watson ditch,
as you coined is to think like that,
right?
Who are guys that for five years from now,
when we finally have cleared all this dead cap that we are eventually going to have at the end of the Deshaun Watson deal,
because you have to continue to rework his contract to be able to create some kind of functional cap space in the present.
Day,
these might be the players that now we are ushering in the new era with.
Right.
And I think that that's the right way to look at it.
Honestly,
you think about teams like Denver after the Russell Wilson trade and being able to dig out of that ditch.
Now,
obviously they were able to pivot quickly because it got out of that deal quickly.
Right.
And there just weren't as there wasn't as much guaranteed money.
So the ramifications aren't as severe,
but I think they're trying to take that approach of let's maximize what draft capital we do have.
They were able to,
as you said,
gin up enough interest in the,
the number six pick to be able to add even more draft capital.
They didn't cost themselves access to the players that they wanted at the top of the draft.
And everybody they've brought in really since day one,
again,
just project as starters are guys that can be there as plus contributors for a long time.
And I think that that is a huge win.
Really,
the last two drafts have really projected,
I think really well for Cleveland.
Maybe they're not a playoff team in the next two or three years,
but honestly,
I think that this is one of the few teams and there are probably some other rebuilders that we're
we're gonna talk about later today,
where that's not gonna be the metric at all, honestly.
They just need to look like, is there positive momentum happening?
Do you have playable guys at all three levels of your defense?
Are you readdressing your trenches?
Are you being smart with your money?
And I would say over the last two off seasons, the answer has been a resounding yes for the
Browns.
And for that reason, at least, I feel really kind of encouraged where they're at and ultimately
how we're going to feel about them is going to come down to whether or not Todd Munkin
and his staff can maximize these young guys and speed up their developmental curves.
And what they do a quarterback next year as well.
We'll see there.
So there you go, Browns fans.
Don't say we never say anything nice about your team.
I mean, that was what a strong eight minutes or so where we're just heaping praise.
It may never happen this way.
It may, it might not happen for a long, long time, but who knows?
They've got some interesting players.
They've got some good players from last year.
Let's see what it looks like once we get to August and September.
I'm continuing with the theme here, Deontay, a team that I have pretty consistently ripped
an organization.
I've pretty consistently ripped on this podcast over the years pointing out, hey, don't just
make fun of the Jets in New York.
There's a team that's actually been just as bad as them for the last 10 years that still
gets talked about as a classy organization that knows what it's doing.
And that's the New York Giants.
And I think the New York Giants had a nice three days here.
You know, we all know it's John Harbaugh calling the shots, but I think that that first round
couldn't have gone any better for them.
We spoke about it a little bit on.
In our previous pod, Arvel Reese dropping to five where he could have gone as high as
two Francis.
Now we know dropping to 10 where he could have gone as high as three.
And so three, yeah, you get, you get good value for two players.
You're building the trenches with Arvel Reese.
We'll see.
I, you know, John Harbaugh did drop a position where a positionless defense quote there where
I don't know why it is that that makes me nervous.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Let's see.
Do you have the coaching staff to be able to do that?
But I,
I think we can all agree Reese is a very talented player with huge upside that can help you
win in different ways.
And we just kind of don't know what those ways are going to be.
It could go poorly if you really are struggling to, to define his role, but there's also a
chance that he's awesome.
And then Matt, we know, uh, uh, I think he's going to start at guard for them.
They said, but then it gives you a tackle option for the future.
It gives you a tackle option if someone goes down with injury.
So I think Thursday night worked out really well for them.
And then in the second round, they,
we're going to get Colton hood, the cornerback who I think he's a pretty exciting player,
you know, 21 years old, high end traits, hasn't played a lot of football, just 13 starts.
So there's certainly some uncertainty there, but it's a guy with upside at a premium position
who I think you've got at a good spot in the draft here.
So potentially you got the best offensive tackle in the draft.
This is all three theoretical, potentially you got the best defensive player from the
draft.
I don't think that would shock us five years from now.
And then it.
We have a chance to get a really good quarterback there in the second round.
So they spent their draft capital in the smart way they spent on premium positions.
They've had six top 10 picks in the last five drafts, which is wild.
So I do that again.
There's a lot of caveats on post-draft analysis.
That's a caveat because after they drafted cave on Thibodeau and Evan Neal in 2022, I
said, good job.
You addressed good positions with, you know, good players.
And that really hasn't worked out, but I think this draft, as we sit here right now this
is about.
As good as you could have hoped.
If you're a New York giants fan.
My winner for New York was really Joe Shane being able to draft off of maybe the successes
of John Harbaugh as you know, the guy that might be making the final decisions in that
building and being able to shield himself in case things go poorly, right?
For the first time, maybe in Joe Shane's career as an executive or as a decision maker, if
something goes wrong with these picks, he's not the guy who's got a bear, you know, the
brunt of whatever criticism comes with it.
But I think to your point, they did exactly what they needed.
To do.
I think that round one, especially having two top 10 picks, the best outcome for them
is that they get two high ceiling players.
And I don't know if you could have found a more high ceiling guy in the offensive trenches
in Francis Maui, Noah, whether he does play guard or tackle.
And then Arbel Reese obviously is this edge linebacker hybrid.
And then in the second and third round, they found high floor guys, guys that can go play
a role.
Even if they don't necessarily have star potential, they can step into the league right now and
give you something.
And Colton hood is like, can be at least based off the tape that I've seen, he can be an
immediate upgrade over Deontay banks, who was just kind of proven himself to be really
tough to play.
Right.
It's been really hard.
I think watching him being out there on the perimeter, you just haven't gotten the kind
of coverage upside.
They thought they would from a guy who came into the league, kind of being that speed
length, you know, vertical jumper type, right.
They just haven't gotten that level of play from them.
Hood can come in and supplant him as maybe number two or number three in the cornerback
rotation.
That should be interesting.
And then Malachi fields has been a guy.
I feel like the last season or two, I've had an eye on right.
Big bodied wide receiver, somebody who in theory should be able to go win on the outside
or be able to body guys up, move the chains on third downs.
You can be a red zone threat and he doesn't necessarily have to be a star here because
you have Malik neighbors already, right?
You kind of have guys for roles in this offense already.
And it does give Malachi fields a job, an opportunity to just go out and do a job.
And if he's able to contribute to this offense in that way, I think that that's a win.
So yeah, I think that, I think that for them all three days of the draft, they went out
and address needs that they had.
Obviously you'd like to be saying that you're dropping these players in around someone like
Dexter Lawrence, but you can't have it both ways.
You don't get the number 10 pick without making that deal, right?
So you kind of just have to take the good and bad with that.
And ultimately, if you were telling me going into the draft that they were going to be
dealing Lawrence to be able to come out with this as your bounty, right?
From the draft, I think that you're probably feeling pretty good about where this franchise
can be.
What these guys hit.
The Shane thing is so interesting because we like, is he going to still be, is his key
card going to work a week from now?
You know, there's been kind of a lot of buzz about, is this just, Hey, he built the draft
board and you brought on Harbaugh in January, so you keep him on board, um, with the scouts
and Harbaugh's making the final decisions, but at least you have all the background stuff
there from Shane.
I'll give him credit.
You know, like obviously we've, I I'll speak for myself.
I have ripped him and criticized him.
Again.
I don't take any of it back.
What I have said, you know, he, he's done a good job of trying to swallow his pride
where Harbaugh at every turn is just letting it be known that this guy has like no role
really in the organization anymore.
He's done a good job being like, all right, the situation is what it is.
It's not how, you know, I would love for it to be ideally, but I get it.
That's how things work in the NFL.
And now we see if he sticks around past this year or if he's doing something else when
we get to draft time.
And I think that's what we're going to see.
I think that's what we're going to see.
of the division right now
would be that Tampa Bay
is first.
Correct.
And Carolina's second.
No.
And then I'm. Wow, so I'm guessing
Atlanta must be second.
Atlanta's second, yeah.
Okay, and then Carolina
and New Orleans
after that will be. will probably be the order
I would lay out.
Yeah.
I'm trying to. That's interesting.
I'm trying to decide
how surprised I am by this.
Yeah, I don't. I don't know that I view
the Falcons that way.
I don't know that I view
the Falcons as the second
best team in the division
That's the one that I think
surprises me the most.
The Falcons at two.
Yeah, I don't know.
Now, I guess
if you want to make the case,
they have the most proven
commodities outside of the Bucs
because you do have
Drake London,
you have Kyle Pitts.
You know, I do think, though,
I mean, that is a lot of trust
that Tua Tunga-Vailoa
or whatever you're going to get
from Michael Pitts Jr.
when he's healthy again
is going to make you. I'm guessing. I mean, in the NFC South,
eight games sometimes
gets it done.
So I guess I'm guessing
when the win totals come out,
you're going to say that
Atlanta's probably like
seven and a half.
On the line for their
over-under on total wins.
That's exactly what it is.
Yeah, just pulled it up.
Seven and a half.
So I guess I can see that.
I guess I can see that.
And that also is
quite the indictment
on Carolina's season.
That is them saying
that all those four downs
that they converted,
all those close games
they were able to win,
it was 100% a fluke
and not to expect
that that defense to be
as good as it was last year
and certainly not to expect
very much from Bryce Young
in 2026.
Yeah, Panthers are six and a half.
They're over-under.
Saints are six and a half.
They're over-under as well.
And then the Bucs
who are just sort of
a forgotten team,
they're at eight and a half
if they're over-under.
So, I mean, like I said,
very bunched
between six and a half
and eight and a half.
All four teams there.
We'll see where we land
in August and September
with those teams
in the NFC South.
All right, let's take a break.
We come back.
Hate to do it,
but I'm going to have to,
you know,
turn to some losers here.
It's time.
We got through the first segment
being positive.
Deontay's positivity
rubbed off on me.
We were positive,
but now it's time
to maybe rip.
This episode is brought to you
by Nationwide.
A football team is so much more
than a set of players.
It's a complete roster
filled with depth and grit.
It's offense and defense
coming together
to make something unstoppable.
It's like how Nationwide
is so much more
than a great insurance company.
They're one of America's
largest financial services
companies too.
Insurance and financial services,
that's a whole team
in and of itself.
Team Nationwide.
For your insurance
and financial needs,
Nationwide is on your side.
Nationwide Investment Services Corporation,
member FINRA, Columbus, Ohio.
This episode is brought to you
by Core Power Protein Shakes.
In football,
staying ready isn't just about
what you do on game day.
Good recovery is just as important
to be prepared
for your next matchup.
Core Power Protein Shakes
help you keep up with your game day.
Help you keep going
after your workout
with high-quality protein
to build muscle
and electrolytes
to help hydrate.
This shake has all your recovery needs
in one bottle.
Available in 26-gram
and 42-gram protein options.
Visit corepower.com
to learn more.
Some teams here
when we come back.
All right, we are back here
on the Ringer NFL show.
I think we got to get into this story,
Deontay.
New England Patriots
are a loser
from this weekend.
It has very little to do
with their draft.
Nothing to do with their draft.
It has to do with this
Mike Rabel,
Diana Rossini story,
which has been the biggest story
in the NFL offseason.
Let's just be honest.
But it has been,
I had thought for a while there
that, well,
this is kind of more of a media story
than a football story.
You know, if you kind of,
you know,
if we were making a big deal
about every NFL head coach
who was potentially,
I'm trying to choose
my words carefully here,
unfaithful
to their team,
to their partners,
you know,
I think it would be,
probably be a large percentage
of the league there.
So I was like,
well, I don't know.
Nothing's really coming of this.
But now,
as more photos come out,
more reports come out
that this is not just about
one weekend in Arizona,
that this is six years ago
in New York,
that this is after Mike Rabel
was fired from the Titans
in Biloxi, Mississippi.
All these things
that are coming out
from the New York Post
and TMZ
and wherever else,
it becomes a different story.
Because Rabel has had
to address it
multiple times
to the press
and then it kind of
reached ahead
draft weekend
where he says,
I'm not going to be
in the building
for day three
of the draft
because I'm seeking counseling.
So he gives this statement
to ESPN,
then he holds
multiple press conferences
there.
He says,
you know,
the report said
he's going to plan
to be with his family
outside of Massachusetts
and it just leads
to so many questions here.
You know,
and if you're interested
in the media aspect of this,
the press box
from Brian Curtis
has done a great job.
Joel Anderson,
they all had
really good discussions
from the media perspective,
but from a head coach
football perspective,
like what is he seeking
counseling for?
That has not been
communicated to me.
Like what wrong doing
is he specifically
admitting to here?
It said he would still
be able to communicate
with the team
on Saturday.
So I'm like,
is this a performative thing?
Like, why are you starting
this the Saturday
of the draft?
Is that supposed
to make me think like,
oh, you're really taking
this seriously
and you're so remorseful
that you're giving up
day three
of the draft year?
Is it,
there's more stuff
that's going to come out
and I don't want to wait
for that to happen
until I say
I've taken steps
to remedy this.
I want when those things
actually do come out
and do happen
that I can say,
hey, I'm already working
on it and I told you
I missed day three
of the draft
for counseling.
So you have all those things
happening right here,
but it is unusual
for a head coach
to not be in the building
day three of the draft.
I don't know how much
it actually matters
or not to be,
you know,
quite honest.
You have the draft board.
I know Vrabel has the final say
on everything there,
but it's like,
this is the team
that made it
to the Super Bowl
last year.
This would be a big story
if they were seven and 10.
This team was in the Super Bowl
last year.
They were on the rise
with the young quarterback
and,
and now we know
that it's,
it's very difficult
to get back to the Super Bowl
or even have
a very successful season
the year after losing it.
I think the last time,
if I'm not mistaken,
was the Patriots
in 27,
2018.
They lose to the Eagles
and then they come back
and they win it the next year.
But I think
other than that,
it has been very rare
to get back
the following year.
And so now,
if you're looking
at the Patriots
and you're looking
at 2026
and this uncertainty
around the head coach
and the story
surrounding them
draft weekend
like this is a time
where most fan bases
are just so excited
about their teams.
I mean,
every,
every fan base thinks
we crushed the draft,
you know,
oh,
screw those guys.
They may,
you know,
they're calling us a loser,
but this guy's going
to be awesome.
This guy's going
to be awesome.
Don't sleep on us.
You know,
we're going to be
a playoff team.
And then you have
the Patriots
and their fan base
where I just feel
like they've got
to be thinking
we got the year
from hell coming up
here in 2026.
And there's more
important,
obviously there are
children involved.
There's more important
stuff involved here,
but we're talking
about it from a
football perspective.
This has to be
for a team coming
off the Super Bowl
as downtrodden
as a fan base
could be in late
April,
Deontay.
So that's why I've
got them in the
loser category.
I mean,
there's just no,
there's short of
the most dire
circumstances happening.
There's no bigger
gut punch.
I think that can
happen ahead of the
draft than your
head coach being
royal in this
kind of controversy.
And to your point,
I think that if
you're a fan,
I think even if
you're,
the biggest Homer
that you can be,
you have to be very
frustrated in just
how shrouded in
words that mean
nothing.
This whole situation
has been especially
from Mike Vrabel,
right?
Like,
and then the fact
that the things
that are kind of
hinted at from
Vrabel also seem
to undermine the
stories that we
were receiving,
or at least the
statements that we
were receiving from
Diana Rossini's side
and Steven Ginsberg
of The Athletic,
right?
And I think that
all of that has
played out now to
this point where
we can say pretty
definitively,
that whatever,
whatever internal
investigation was
happening at The
Athletic clearly
resulted in something
that they were
displeased with.
And under that
kind of duress,
and maybe that is
why Diana Rossini
ultimately resigned.
But strictly
speaking to the
Patriots,
and what I do
believe is probably
a little bit of
them being
performative,
is the fact that
you decided to do
this on day three
of the draft
without ever
really directly
acknowledging what
the situation is,
right?
That's the weirdest
part, yes.
Why are you
leaving that to us
as the public,
as the
media,
to have to
converse about
when you called
an entire press
conference?
It could not
speak directly
about whatever
this situation is.
To your point
about maybe
trying to get
ahead of these
things,
it was very
prescient by
the New York
Post to wait
until after that
press conference
and then have
more things
published in
terms of
photographs.
I think that
the first one
was after the
firing in
2024 from
Tennessee when
they were seen
kind of at this
bar together and
then you get the
ones from back
in 2020 where
they're out
together and a
couple takes a
photo of them as
well.
So I think that
maybe with
knowledge of
what's to come,
you kind of start
to get ahead of
it.
It's also very
fascinating though
that that would
be the strategy
because Roger
Goodell I think
has already kind
of put out
information to
the media that
this is not a
league disciplinary
issue, right?
This would be a
team matter.
So the only
reason I would
think that you
would want to
step away is
if you believe
that this can
only get more
embarrassing for
you and the
team.
from here and I would hate to speculate
Because everything about this situation has been taking what facts we do have and then people who speculate for a living blowing this up as big as they can.
And there are some parts of this that are very serious to your point about whether or not people were unfaithful.
We don't know the intimate details of what was going on with their relationship.
I think that from a media perspective, there is a conversation to have about just what these relationships are between insiders and the people that they are getting information from.
And that maybe this is just the most salacious version of it if you're talking about a potential affair or extramarital relationship between the two parties involved.
But yeah, I just think there are just so many layers to this that kind of blow my mind.
And maybe the most frustrating aspect of it is the fact that Mike Vrabel can't speak directly to it.
And that I guess we're supposed to receive him stepping away from day three of the draft, which is all about your area scouts and what information they and the GMs have been talking about.
And your assistant coaches and what they've. Kind of evaluated on film.
These are the guys who are really making those picks anyways.
I am not moved by you stepping away from the team in this.
And this is also not going to make this story go away.
Because there are a lot of people who have very strong feelings about the media, about, unfortunately, women in media.
Because we do still have to deal with the misogyny that comes from the public and from NFL fans and sports fans in general.
Mike Vrabel cannot just counsel this one away.
You cannot, my family needs me, this one away.
This is still. This is still going to be a talking point.
And I think that ultimately, like you said, when you get back to training camp, they are still going to be staring down the barrel of this thing.
And I can't imagine that you can have a normal season under these conditions.
Yeah, it's like the consequences for this are like, Rossini has already resigned.
Like, so that is, you know, so that has already happened.
Anything else that she's going to deal with is going to be about her home life.
It's really not going to have anything to do with her professionally.
Yeah, that part of it is over.
Or at least for the time being here.
But with Vrabel, he is trying to coach the defending Super Bowl champions here, you know, in 2026.
And yeah, I'm with you.
I just, is it family counseling?
Is it marriage counseling?
Was there a way?
It felt like what they were trying to do was get ahead of the story and be like, let's, you know, we kind of screwed it up when it first surfaced and we released the statements.
And you can understand, at that time, you just did not, you know, we see this throughout different walks of life all the time with people.
In the news, that the first move is denial, denial, denial.
This is nonsense.
And then, you know, you hope, like, hey, if that sticks, then cool.
A lot of times that doesn't stick because more information comes out and you can't just deny.
And then, you know, then it looks like you lied or at least you went forth right there.
And then you get to the next phase, which is the phase Vrabel's at.
To your point, Rossini hasn't said anything publicly to indicate that she's at this phase.
But Vrabel's at this point where it feels like he wants to convince.
They, a sense of wrongdoing, remorse of being apologetic, yet it seems very clumsy.
And, you know, part of that is probably just the NFL where, like, he's speaking in NFL coach speak.
You know, he's like, this is, I want to attack this, this challenge head on.
Like, wait, what are we talking about here?
What are we talking about?
So it's, it's very, it's very difficult to figure out what his next move is.
What their next move is.
But yet this does feel performative to me to be like, all right, day three of the draft.
He's not going to be in the building yet.
He hasn't said what he's done wrong.
He hasn't really just indicated, you know, I know he might not want to come out and say it explicitly, but even indicating it.
I haven't been, you know, a good husband.
I haven't, you know, whatever it is.
Again, we're speculating.
We're all going by what eight photos or whatever it is we've seen.
And then some statements.
And then you're trying to connect dots left and right.
But it's.
It is just, uh, it is a bad situation for a fan base that was all in on this guy.
I mean, they were just, they thought, you know, we, we lost Belichick.
We had one bad year with Mayo in between there.
Now we got Frabel.
Now we got our quarterback.
It's back to the promised land.
And that's what it looked like last year.
And now you kind of just wonder, like, what does this year look like?
What do the next three years look like, uh, for this organization?
So, yeah, they, they absolutely have to be on the list of losers from the draft.
All right.
No easy transition.
No easy transition from that one.
Deontay, we're going to go, we're going to go in a different direction, but what's the
next one you got winner or loser here?
I've got a loser and I'm still like kind of perplexed just at how everything has played
out.
And it's going to be hard to talk about their draft without bringing up 20 or drop bringing
up 2025 and just last season and how they handled it in general.
But my loser here is Jacksonville.
I did not love their draft.
I thought that the neighbor, um, I'm sorry, I'm going to absolutely butcher.
I think it's Borkature.
Yes.
Yeah.
Name Borkature pick was way ahead of where you would see him on most consensus boards.
When I watch and evaluate, I don't see a tight end that you'd want to take near the top 50.
Um, somebody who that will be, it would need to be somebody who could step in immediately
and contribute and maybe have star potential.
I don't know if I see that in his game.
You go out and you get, you know, another tight end on day three and not that that's
a problem, but this feels very much like a reactive draft, right?
Then maybe.
Looking at how they lost games last year and saying, okay, if we just plug these holes
or we have extra tight in depth.
So that way of course, strange, much as time, we don't only have to be one style of team
and they did not get players in my opinion that fit that offensively.
And then on the defensive end, I don't know exactly what you expect to get out of Albert
Regis, right?
I think that he's a fine player again, no star potential there.
And maybe I guess for me and the reason why I have them as a loser is when we were all
laughing and joking.
And really enjoying James Gladstone and Liam Cohen last off season, you know, like, and
they were just speaking in all this flowery language about how they wanted to attack this
process to add talent.
And ultimately where we landed now wasn't an objectively excellent 20, 25 season and
objectively excellent 20, 25 season out of nowhere.
They absolutely caught fire after like mid October and we're one of the toughest teams
to beat in the NFL.
And, um, this off season, all we have heard is that Travis Hunter is probably not going
to be the same kind of two way players that they thought they were trading for, right?
You have not really made any market improvements on this roster outside of that.
Some of that is just because some of their money is tied up and they've had to make,
they're going to have to start making difficult decisions in the future because some of their
young guys, they're going to have to make decisions on how they're going to pay them
and how much they're going to pay them.
And you've got the Trevor Lawrence money kicking in.
This would be a, this is the kind of draft where even though you don't have a first round,
pick, you have to nail it because you do have a ton of top 100 draft capital.
And those all need to be players that you see either having a high level trajectory
where they could be stars in a couple of years time, or can step in and be average to better
starters right this moment.
I don't necessarily see that in this draft.
I don't want to be a total prisoner to the consensus board because if these are good
players, like I do believe Emmanuel pregnant can be a good player as a guard that could
work out for them.
They're a wide receiver.
Do all his day three pace and Josh Cameron and CJ Williams, those can end up being decent
depth for them.
But if you just look at it on the whole, or you kind of aggregate these picks, it's really
hard to find a lot to be excited about.
I think.
And for that reason, for a team that is willing to have championship aspirations in a very
competitive division, I don't know if they took the extra step forward to make sure that
they stay at the top of the AFC South.
Yeah.
We talked about the consensus board stuff a little bit on our last pod.
And I think it's fun to look at.
Day two and day three.
And the idea is not, oh, just go with what everyone's saying that that's not it.
But the idea is if a guy is at one spot in the consensus board and you take him way higher
than that, then it's fair to question.
Could you have traded back?
Is there a way you could have gotten him while doing something else rather than just taking
him at the spot?
You took him in Nate Borkature, this tight end from Texas A&M.
They took him 56 and the consensus boards had him, I believe at 162.
I mean, it was just nowhere close to being ranked that high in this high class by just
about anybody you would ask.
Right.
So it's, it's just, you know, if you just look at the difference and where a guy got
taken and that where he was ranked on the consensus board, I mean, that qualifies as
one of the biggest reaches in the second round.
And this is coming off a, like you mentioned, this is a draft where he didn't have a first
round pick.
So, you know, you certainly could be thinking about, Hey, what are some ways we can get
additional resources?
They did make a bunch of picks.
They did still have a bunch of top 100 pigs.
So it's not like they only drafted four players, but I think you open yourself up to criticism
by taking a guy 56, who was 162 on the consensus board.
And then you're right about this does go back to last year because as you were just discussing
that with Gladstone, which I'd kind of forgotten, like has a GM ever set up a prospect worse
for success than the way he managed that last year?
It's hard to think of one.
He's going to change the game of football and the guy has not played a snap in the NFL.
And here we are a year later, you gave out, you use the first, you use two first round
picks on him.
And I think you like Travis Hunter.
I like Travis Hunter.
I hope he's an all pro corner this year.
And I think that's in the cards.
He could be, you just have him focused on corner.
He could, we could be saying he's one of the five best corners in the NFL by the end of
the year.
But that, you know, remains to be seen, has to be proven.
And I'm with you.
I think it was a great coaching.
job last year from Liam Cohen.
Like I think he proved, hey, I can go from one place to another.
plays one quarterback to another quarterback. And I can get the most out of this guy and Trevor
Lawrence, and we can have an offense that really cooks here. And they did that. And they got a nice
defensive season. I thought they overachieved on that side of the ball, but I do think it's fair
with the team building aspect of this is now they try to make the step from, Hey, plucky playoff
team, fun team to know this team can actually contend for a super bowl. Now's when you have to
like the stuff around the margins has to be really sharp and you got to build the roster in a certain
way. And I do think that remains to be seen for the Jaguars. Yeah. Yeah. It's just, um, I'm stuck.
And then you look at like where other teams are at in their division. Like I think specifically
you look at where Houston is at and the way that they were able to plug needs that I do think will
help move the needle for them in the AFC hierarchy. I look at Jacksonville and I think that we're just
right back in a position where you're going to be asking your head coach to have to absolutely
maximize every last player that you got in,
in order to be able to hold your spot. That is part of coaching, right? And if we get to October
and November and the Jags are definitely underperforming, I am going to come back and say,
Hey, Liam Cohen, at the end of the day, we got a what 12, 13, one season out of you last year.
I want to see that level of coach on a year by year basis. There is some accountability to be
held there if we do get there, but just as a GM, this is one of the few opportunities for a team
that wants to contend when you do have as many picks, cause they weren't able to, um, you know,
approach this draft with high volume to be able to come out with guys that you can at least feel
like are either contributing to push you into that Superbowl conversation right now, or in two or so
years are going to be able to supplant some of your vets and be able to fill in roles to be able
to hold you at whatever spot you're at. And I just don't know yet if they've accomplished either.
And based off my evaluation of some of the players they picked, I just feel a little bit more kind of
bearish on where they are right now. All right, let's take one more break. We come back with some
losers and losers. This episode is brought to you by Sharpie. For Jeremiah Love, Sharpie's 2026
Rookie of the Year and third overall draft pick, career milestones deserve a signature that stands
out. That's why he signed his pro contract using the Sharpie S gel pen, making sure his mark looked
clean, confident, and unmistakably his. Sharpie S gel features no smear, no smudge, no
bleed technology, and always vivid writing. High performance for a high performer. For life's
biggest signing moments, make it Sharpie. Shop now at Amazon from the 2026 NFL Draft.
I've got another loser,
Deontay. Matthew Stafford. I mean, the Ty Simpson pick is the story of the draft,
if you had to say. What's the one thing that we're going to remember from this
three years from now, five years from now? And so we discussed it when we were discussing
the moves in the first round. Since then, you know, I was reading kind of the coverage just from
Les Snead and Sean McVay's media availability. And if you read about that, I was reading about
this in The Athletic. It's like they couldn't really, they weren't like in a state to be
excited about it. You know, like they were trying to manage the situation,
knowing how the pick of Ty Simpson at 13 was going to be perceived by the public, by the media,
trying to keep their current MVP quarterback, Matthew Stafford, happy. I was reading this
from Nate Atkins from The Athletic. He wrote, across beats covering the Chicago Bears,
Detroit Lions, Indianapolis Colts, and now the Rams. This was the first time I've covered a
first round draft pick news conference where the regime showed so little excitement about the
player selected, which I thought was very interesting.
Context. It was an 11 minute news conference where they almost seemed like sullen rather than
excited. And, you know, McVay, the first thing he was asked about Simpson, I guess,
was about if he's going to be the backup. And he said, we'll see. He's going to compete with
Stetson Bennett. Who was somebody who has never once threatened to like be their top backup.
They wouldn't have had Jimmy Garoppolo there if they thought that Stetson Bennett actually should
have been their backup quarterback. Yeah. He had something going on off the field. I don't think
it's been reported. Right.
But he was away from the team for a little bit. So this is what they're saying about the guy they
drafted 13th overall in a season where, again, they are contending for a Super Bowl. They are
among the Super Bowl favorites. And if I'm Stafford, I'm just looking at all the guys
taken after him. And it just feels like now they can still win the Super Bowl. They still have a
very good team. There's a chance this works out for them if they win the Super Bowl in the next
year or two.
With Stafford. And then if Simpson takes over, they look great with all this. But I even more
and more impassioned that they've outsmarted themselves here and that they felt like,
hey, you know, this is going to get criticized, but this is the right thing to do.
I really feel like there's going to be a moment during the 2026 season where we all look around
and we go, man, they could have really used player X right now. Whoever that is, Makai,
Lemon, Kenyon, Sadiq, whoever it is, a tackle, whatever, whoever was high on their board that
we're going to say, they really could have used this player right now as they try to compete for
a Super Bowl. And I just think they've created such an awkward situation with a player who
they've had some, you know, for as well as that marriage has worked out with Stafford and McVay,
it's gotten prickly. They've had these rocky off seasons where it's usually, you know,
financial, uh, based on financials and how much Matthew Stafford wants to get paid and whether he
guaranteed money or an extension. But again, a year ago, we were talking about this guy shopping
himself to other teams. Is he going to be out there? There were teams that are on the record
with, man, we thought we had a shot at him. We wanted to bring him in. And then he goes back
and has an MVP season. So now this kind of just hangs over their entire 2026 season. And I just
think it was unnecessary. And I continue to want to know the intimate details of whether everyone
was on board with this. Cause they obviously feel like we got to manage this and make it look a
certain way. Cause we don't want to upset our MVP quarterback right now. Absolutely. And you know
what? It's so funny. I think I was willing to, I might've been willing to accept that. Hey, you
just take Ty Simpson. Cause it's good process. You know, that you're eventually going to have
to find a replacement at quarterback down the line. Um, they weren't, they must not have been
interested in getting someone like Kenyon Sadiq in the building. They must not have been interested
at all and getting some of these other options in.
And then with their second round pick, they take Max Claire. And I was like, wait,
if you guys were in the market for tight ends in the top two rounds of the draft,
why would you not go get Kenyon Sadiq? Who is a much more dynamic version. And I would say,
if you're comparing, if you're comparing Claire to Sadiq, Claire does not project nearly as well
as a blocker, in my opinion right now, as what you could get out of someone like Sadiq. So you
can't even, to me, make the sales pitch of like, Hey, we wanted to go get one of these six, six,
255 pound guys who are just going to be on the backside of whatever our little run scheme.
And we're using him to be, you know, kind of like an honorary sixth offensive lineman. That's not
what they went on to draft it. Claire is going to go be another receiving type guy, which is why
you'd go take them that high. So that one really kind of flummoxed me. And then to come back to
the pick itself, which obviously we covered on day one of the draft when, in writing about it,
one of the biggest things you always want to go and see, what's the precedent here? What are the trend
lines? Historically, what can we expect? And when I went back over the last decade and was looking
for first round quarterbacks who only had a year's worth of starting experience, and you start seeing
names like Mack Jones and Anthony Richardson and Trey Lance and Dwayne Haskins and Mitchell
Trubisky, right? Like, and the only real hit in that crop is Kyler Murray, who physically is
worlds apart from anyone else in this cluster. You have to be concerned if you're a
Rams fan. You've got to be concerned if you're Sean McVay. And you can try to pitch me until you're
blue in the face about, it's not going to be the same with those guys because Simpson gets to sit
and learn behind Matthew Stafford. But Simpson's game is not Matthew Stafford's game. They're not
the same. And if they were similar, he wouldn't have been available at 13 because the Cardinals
might've taken them, number three overall. The Jets might've taken them, number two overall.
If you genuinely believe that a guy like that had that level of ceiling. And like you said, I think to
wrap up my point on this, this does not mean that I'm not going to pick the Rams to win a Super Bowl
when it's season preview time. They're my pick right now. I have no reason to waver on that.
They went out and they addressed their defensive backroom with Trent McDuffie and Jalen Watson,
basically within the same week. They already had one of the most high octane offenses,
both on the ground and through the air in the NFL. And hell, for the last two postseasons,
they have taken the eventual champions down to the brink and can very much feel like if we had one more chance with
the ball, if we had one more opportunity, if we can make one more play call, that might be us holding
up the Lombardi trophy in each of the last two seasons. I get it if you're the Rams and you're
arrogant enough to believe that you've done enough work and now it's time to be a little forward
looking. I just feel like that pick specifically, if you were going to go take a project, you could
have taken a project elsewhere. You could have gone and taken like a Max Ahanich or a Monroe
Freeling and say, hey, we're going to take our time with this guy. He's going to be our right tackle of the future. He's going to compete with Warren McCullough.
Clinton to go play right tackle right now.
We'll just see where that lands.
Ty Simpson.
at the absolute best case scenario
doesn't have to play until maybe 2028, 2029
because that's the level of development
I think he'll need.
And there's still no guarantee
that his ceiling is high enough
to justify this pick right now.
And you know what else I was thinking
was about like McVay and Stafford
and why they have this sort of superpower together.
They're both obviously great on their own,
but put them together.
And I really thought their superpower
has been the ability to figure things out
during the course of a game.
Like this is why, you know,
Vic Fangio defense isn't going to shut them down
because they say, all right,
we're coming in with this game plan,
but this guy's really hard to go against.
We need to, if we see this,
hey, what do you see?
I see this.
Hey, what do you see?
I see this.
Okay, let's pivot to this.
They are awesome at doing that
against the most complex defenses
in the entire NFL.
Who's the only team that could do anything
against that Seahawks defense?
Like we forget now,
they were going up and down the field
against the Mike McDonald Seahawks defense.
That was incredible against everyone else
because they had the ability to figure it out.
You know why?
Because McVay's a great offensive coach,
but also Stafford has seen everything.
He has seen everything.
He has this library of reps.
Doesn't mean every game is going to be perfect,
but when some of the physical tools start to diminish,
he can make up for it because he is so smart.
He's able to make high degree of difficulty throws.
I mean, the no look throws are not like performative.
It's like he is literally holding.
That is kind of built into the design of this now.
He's opening a window because he's looking here
and the defender's not closing his own window
and now he can throw it there.
I mean, it's incredible.
And so if I'm like thinking about the Rams
and in the future and life after Stafford,
I'm going like, we're going to be able to,
veteran quarterbacks are first of all,
going to want to play for Sean McVay
and we have a talented roster and it's Los Angeles.
I don't think you're going to have trouble,
you know, attracting veteran,
the next version of Matthew Stafford.
It might not be as good, obviously,
but you can,
you can get veteran quarterbacks to come play there.
And now if McVay's superpowers,
the ability to figure things out on the fly
and he's going to be doing it with a quarterback
who started 13 games post high school at some point,
that doesn't align with me.
Those things don't mix.
They don't mix.
It's not going to look as good.
I don't care how good McVay is
and how good the supporting cast is.
So yeah, the more I thought about it,
the more I'm just leaning into,
I don't think they should have done that.
And man, I would,
I would love to be a fly on the wall
of Matthew Stafford's private conversations
with family, with friends,
with his agent, with whoever.
I'm sure he will try to be the good soldier
at his next press availability
and say, I'll take him under my wing.
I was young once.
I'm trying to give back to the game and all that.
And he probably, I'm sure he will be.
He seems like a great teammate.
Everybody likes him.
I can almost guarantee he will be.
And you know why?
Because Matthew Stafford is going to say,
you can do whatever you want with that draft pick.
But since you made that decision,
you are going to pay me what I'm asking for.
You're going to give me the years and the money.
Absolutely.
If not, I will go hit the open market
and I'll see what Matthew Stafford is worth
to the rest of the league.
Because I've already proven I can step into a place.
I can be at this advanced age
and still bank me, right?
To make the NFC championship game,
to be a playoff contender if I'm healthy.
Yeah, if I'm him, you're going to pay me.
And then after you pay me
and give me the years that I'm after,
now I can come in and be quarterback developer.
But outside of that,
yeah, I can't imagine that he's feeling the warmest
about this pick, this decision,
and what it means within this timeline
of this team trying to get back over the hump.
All right.
So, all right.
Let's wind down here.
Deontay, do you have any more here
that you wanted to get off your chest?
I can hit you with a couple of quick hitters here.
Otherwise, in a minute.
Let's do some quick hitters.
I got a winners and losers.
One winner, one loser.
And then I think just one conversation.
That kind of interests me before we get out of here.
Winners here, it's kind of like the obvious.
It's the good process teams.
It's the teams that take multiple bites at the apple.
It's the teams that are willing to trade up
to go get guys who are high on consistent draft wars
because they believe they won't be available later.
And it's the usual suspects in that respect, right?
I think about Dallas.
I think about Baltimore.
I think about Philadelphia.
I would say that all three of those teams,
while maybe their worlds have not changed as franchises,
and Dallas maybe takes the biggest leap
because they did take multiple bites.
At the apple, as far as defense,
and if all those guys hit,
they will be able to kind of catapult themselves maybe
into being more closely into the playoff contender
pool of teams in the NFC.
But those three teams
and teams that just approach the draft that way
always seem to come out of the draft
with everybody feeling like
they got a little bit better, at least.
They got marginally better.
And I would say that all three of those teams
got at least marginally better by addressing needs.
And then the loser for me
would be the rebuilding teams in a light draft.
So I'm thinking about Miami.
I'm thinking about Arizona.
And it's probably. I'm trying not to slam them
because the truth be told,
there just wasn't a lot to choose from
deep in this draft.
I would say that day three of this draft
is one of the lighter ones that I can remember
since I've been working in the media,
trying to find players that you think have high upside.
And maybe they weren't drafted as high
because they didn't produce a bunch
or they might've bounced around a bit
or maybe been miscast.
There's really not a lot of that in this draft.
So you look at Miami,
who has a boatload of picks.
It's like,
yeah, I think they did the right thing
with each of these picks individually.
But I look at these names
and I try to judge the upside
after you get out of the second round
and you're just kind of crossing your fingers
that something happens with these guys.
None of these guys, I think,
strike me as players who will be stars
or plus starters by the end of their rookie deals.
And obviously with Arizona,
I think that we hit that pretty hard
on Thursday with the Jeremiah Love pick.
And I would say that most of their picks
after do still leave me kind of scratching my head.
Although Deontay, did you see after we spoke,
that they spoke to the media and said
they had the wrong phone number down for Jeremiah Love.
I don't know if you caught that or not,
but they were having a hard time
getting in touch with Jeremiah Love.
And the question was,
why are you like the clock was kind of winding down there?
You know, what was going on?
And Monte Austin Ford said
we had the wrong phone number down for Jeremiah Love.
And then-
Why can't you just say we were trying to trade out
and we couldn't trade out?
It's okay.
I think it was Bidwell who was next to him
was trying to be like,
yeah, like,
don't, please don't say that.
Don't make us look dumber
than we already look here.
But it's just, I mean,
poorly run franchise, bad ownership, no direction.
I honestly don't even know if it's Austin Ford
who makes that pick.
If it came out, you know, in 48 hours,
that ownership just kind of put their,
you know, put their foot down and was like,
hey, we got nothing going for us.
Let's go take the exciting running back,
sell some jerseys, get people excited.
That would not shock me as well.
And you're going up against, I mean, Rams,
you know, Seahawks, Rams and 49ers.
In your division, it feels just about as hopeless
as it gets for a franchise and a fan base post-draft.
Like we were kind of saying with the Patriots
for a very different reason.
But yes, I think the Arizona Cardinals
definitely deserve a mention there as well.
Let me see.
What else did I have written down?
I did have that Cardinals.
I was like, we got to hit him for being a loser
once again here.
So I'm glad you brought that up.
We did that there.
What did you think, Deontay?
This was one, this was like,
just missed the cut for me where I'm like,
I don't think I want to go totally go in on them,
but I have some questions about what they did.
And that's the Los Angeles Chargers,
who I think are going to be, you're with me.
Okay.
Cause I think they're going to be a pretty trendy,
maybe Superbowl pick next year.
And I get it.
Mike McDaniel being there.
That's exciting.
O-line gets healthy.
That's exciting.
We talked about Mesidor, 25 years old in the first round.
Maybe he'll be good.
I would not be spending my biggest draft resource
on a guy who's 25 years old.
And then in the second round,
they take interior offensive lineman,
Jake Slaughter from Florida.
Now, usually you would say interior offensive lineman.
Great.
Makes sense for the Chargers.
However, he played center exclusively in college
and they signed Tyler Biotish,
which I think was a good signing in the off season.
And I think they announced Jake Slaughter as a guard.
So with their second most valuable draft resources,
again, they didn't have a lot.
They had one top 50 pick.
They had two top 100 picks.
Their second most valuable draft resources.
They're taking a guy who played 33 games at center
over five seasons.
And now it sounds like they're going to move him to left guard.
So maybe it'll work out great.
I, you know, I do kind of trust Mike McDaniel to figure it out
and nobody's looking for,
but that's like a lot of uncertainty
with my two biggest draft assets.
When I feel like I have a team
that could really contend next year.
I mean, Keelan Rutledge went later in the first round.
If you were looking for a guard,
you could have went out and gotten Rutledge, right?
Yeah, they really could have.
That would make me feel better about them, honestly,
if that was the move.
Chase Besantis could have been an option, right?
For them, that would have made a lot of sense
to put him in that guard.
And his play style matches perfectly in my mind
with everything that I think about Jim Harwaugh, right?
Playing tough, being able to win between the tackles,
being able to play bully ball when you want to
and control the line of scrimmage.
So to pass on that
and then ultimately land on Jake Slaughter,
who I think,
his skill set might be able to slide over to guard.
But like you said,
you're taking a guy
who kind of was playing a specialty role.
He only really knows center
and you're telling me you're going to slide him over
in the league
with an interior offensive line
that already has had a reputation
that these guys are just kind of on a revolving door
from one spot to the next
and you have no idea who's going to be lined up
in what spot on a weekly basis
and none of them seem to be able to move people
on the interior in the run game
or keep Justin Herbert from being pressured
shirt up the interior.
I'm really kind of concerned, I think, on the whole of their offseason.
And we talked about this again on Thursday, where he didn't spend much money in free agency, which, OK, I mean, the Chargers have never been notorious for being big splash guys in free agency, even though I think there were a lot of players that have gone elsewhere in the league that they should have been in on.
And you're thinking, OK, maybe in the draft is because they're planning to go take high upside players.
And then you look at the list and Akeem Mesidor at 25 years old does not strike me as a high upside player.
Could be good, but that is really more of a eventual Khalil Mack replacement to me than somebody who's going to have some high upside or star potential.
Jake Slaughter, again, a projection because you're moving his position.
I think even Brennan Thompson, right?
Like, I don't see guys that I can square.
And convince myself that they are going to be changing the way we look at the AFC West or changing the way they will look at the hierarchy in the NFL because the Chargers now have shot to the top of, you know, what we think contenders are.
These are still maximizers at the end of the day.
Jim Harbaugh knows how to get the most out of these guys.
Mike McDaniel has a long track record of getting the most out of his offensive pieces.
We will see about Chris O'Leary as a defensive play caller.
But I am definitely waiting with bated breath to find out how exactly.
This picture is supposed to come together and why they believe this year is going to be any different than the up and down nature that 2025 was.
Yeah, I think that's well said.
All right.
What else did I have here?
All right.
Here's another loser, Deontay.
Headlines about the Pittsburgh Steelers.
You ready?
I'm going to read it.
I'm going to read one for you.
This is a sad headline.
I'm sorry, Steelers fans.
Pittsburgh looked beautiful on TV.
Have you been to Pittsburgh, Deontay, before?
I have not.
I have not.
I've heard it's a great.
Underrated.
Great city.
Yeah, great city.
I like a Pittsburgh.
I thought it looked great on TV.
Record number of fans showed out.
So this is not a shot at Pittsburgh, the city.
Love Pittsburgh, the city.
But headline.
This is in The Athletic.
Mike McCarthy bet on himself.
Let the Drew Aller versus Will Howard competition begin.
I feel like every word of that made me feel worse than the one before.
I mean, and this is, by the way, I didn't even mention Aaron Rodgers, who they're just, you know, waiting on still.
Where we thought, all right, I think their owner, what, said, hey, we're going to get an answer from him before the draft.
That didn't happen.
Okay.
Definitely didn't happen.
No.
Now you'll get an answer, I guess, after the draft.
So that's the QB competition.
Meanwhile, while you wait for Aaron Rodgers, this is just not a good time for anyone.
They had the thing about wanting Makai Lemon in the first round, which I still don't understand how you call the prospect before it's your turn to be on the clock.
Like, isn't there always a chance that someone's going to trade up and take the guy?
So.
Those who missed it, that was an NFL Network report that they're on the phone with Makai Lemon and now the footage is out there thinking that the Cowboys are going to.
At the very least.
Yeah.
At the very least, that's a horrible job of gathering intel because they absolutely could have been making calls to 2019, 18, 17 to just see if those picks were up for sale.
So that way you can gauge whether or not somebody might be making a leap to go get a player that you're interested in.
Exactly.
Yeah.
So they were, they thought the Cowboys were taking a defensive player.
We're on the phone with Makai Lemon.
You're going to be, you know.
Pittsburgh Steeler.
And then he gets the call from Philadelphia during that call with Pittsburgh and his agent comes running in saying the Eagles just traded for you.
So, I don't know.
Not a, not a great, it just feels like the Steelers are, you know, it's kind of like they're in the place they always are, except they don't have Mike Tomlin, which I don't think, you know, that does not make me feel great about them either.
All right.
I'm scrolling around here.
Let me see.
All right.
Here's one more for you.
We can finish on this one unless you have anything else.
I had the Minnesota Vikings maybe as a loser here.
I was on the frame.
I was saying about the Chargers.
I was kind of on the fringes with them.
I'm not like all in with my chest that, oh my gosh, they blew it.
But here's the case for the Vikings.
I am just concerned about how they are navigating the league wide waters without a real GM.
You know, they fire Kwestia Dofamensa late in the process.
It's a bit of a surprise there.
Kevin O'Connell obviously has the keys.
His guys.
Bob Brzezinski is sort of acting as their GM here.
And you're like, all right, let's see how this goes.
And they take Florida defensive tackle Caleb Banks in the first round at 18.
He was 44 on the consensus board.
So that is one of the biggest reaches of the entire first down.
So even if you like the player and I absolutely see the upside with him.
Like I think there's a case where three, you know, three years from now, like, man, he is absolutely one of the best defensive players from this draft.
But.
He's had, he's had injuries, there's uncertainty, there's question marks.
It seems like if you had a stable situ infrastructure, stable GM in place, could you have navigated that a little bit better?
Maybe traded back, got some additional draft capital and then still taking him.
Maybe you're taking him, you know, in the late twenties or whatever it is in the first round.
So that's one.
And then the Jonathan Grenard trade.
I mean, it really sounds like this just came down to money where if you read some of Kevin O'Connell's quotes, he's like, he's like, I love it.
I love it.
I love it.
I love it.
I love Jonathan Grenard.
Like he was great leader.
He was a captain.
He was good for our culture.
He was very productive when he was healthy.
He was playing through injury last year.
Now he wanted more money and they didn't want to give him more money.
But that's like on the short list of things that GMs have to deal with.
Player isn't, isn't happy with contract.
Okay.
Like this is another day in the NFL.
In the office.
Yes.
In the office.
And a lot of times if you believe in the player and you're trying, you're kind of in win now mode, which I think they are.
You're trying to come to some sort of agreement.
Hey, can we guarantee?
Can we guarantee you this much?
Hey, can we throw in some incentives?
Hey, what if we do this in this year?
Like those are the things that GMs have to deal with.
And instead they end up just trading him, you know, and they're, uh, you know, Brzezinski, this is from the athletic said very difficult decision for our organization.
It's something we understand is not making us a better team today where you just like, huh, man, I don't know.
It just does.
It feels like that doesn't inspire confidence.
Doesn't inspire me.
Yeah.
So that's why I kind of had them in.
The loser category here, even though I'm kind of bullish on the Vikings.
I think I'm going to see where I land in August or September, but I feel like they have a chance to be a pretty good team in 2026, but I don't necessarily love how these things, um, you know, along the margins are going for them.
I feel like I, the reason why I really don't love the Caleb Banks pick is because it immediately felt like the Dominique orange pick is a way to kind of backstop against the fact that if he does break his foot or if he continues to have foot issues that you have another interior.
Defender that can come in and play.
I don't love that.
Right.
If the big swing is Caleb Banks, then the big swing is Caleb Banks, because you believe that his health is not going to preclude him from being a contributor for your team.
I look at Jay Golday, who's like by size, a really inch by size and athletic profile, a very interesting linebacker, but they have this, this exact style of linebacker, a straight line run ahead, try to get across the line of scrimmage and make a tackle in the backfield.
Good blitzer type.
Their roster is not hurting.
For players who can do that.
That's been the entire build of this defense.
I would think again, that if you're going to be picking at or near the top 50, you'd want to bring in a guy who's either going to break the mold or who shows in either instant production or a high ceiling.
If you're not breaking the mold, especially at a non-premium position, it's entirely possible that Jay Golday is going to be the 51st pick and just kind of hanging around.
They're a linebacker rotation, right?
Caleb Banks, if he gets hurt now, it's just going to be another guy hanging around.
You're D-line rotation.
And if there's one thing that has dogged the Vikings since drafting Justin Jefferson, which should have been transformative when he was there with Kirk Cousins, it's the fact that their drafts have just led them nowhere.
And they have continually been forced to spend extra money on veterans to try to, you know, build up depth by overspending in free agency.
And it has not netted the type of team that I think they ultimately want it to be.
And this draft doesn't feel like much of a break from those.
So, yeah, if I'm Coise Adolfo Mensah, I'm looking around like, hey, this might not have just been a me problem.
Clearly, it seems like just this entire decision-making process is maybe a little bit more flawed than what we were giving it credit for in Minnesota over the last few years.
Yeah, it's like, are they up for this is sort of the question you ask when you look at some of these decisions.
All right.
Those were some winners and losers from the 2026 NFL draft.
We, of course, have much more time to talk.
We're going to talk about the teams, the decision, the picks, and everything else that we didn't get to in this episode or the previous episode.
We will do that in the future for sure.
All right.
Thank you to Deontay Lee, my friend from The Ringer, for joining me throughout draft weekend here.
Thank you to Christopher Sutton for producing.
Stefano Sanchez on video and additional production supervision by Connor Nevins and Arjuna Ramgopal.
I'm Shil Kapadia.
We will talk to you next time on The Ringer NFL Show.
We'll be right back.
Or call 800-327-5050 for 24-7 support in Massachusetts.
Or call 1-877-8HOPE-NY or text HOPE-NY in New York.
For Louisiana, call 1-
Return to theaters for Avengers: Endgame Encore.
I know I said no more surprises,
but I was really hoping to pull off one last one.
Reassemble the team.
Six stones, three teams, one shot.
Relive the experience.
You mess with time, time tends to mess back.
The story continues.
Tony, this is a second chance.
Don't miss Marvel Studios' Endgame Encore.
Early in theaters Friday.
Get tickets now.
Rated PG-13.
Maybe inappropriate for children under 13.
Before this.
There's this.
As you celebrate the game,
take a deeper look at its roots.
The people growing the grass,
paving the lots,
welding the goalposts,
inspecting every football.
The hardworking people that make every Sunday possible.
Carhartt is proud to outfit the crews behind the game.
Visit Carhartt.com/jointhetrades to learn more.
- 877-9000.
877-770-7867.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The Cleveland Browns made strategic, high-impact draft picks focusing on starters, especially Spencer Brown at offensive tackle and a wide receiver duo of Casey Concepcion and Denzel Boston.
The Browns’ draft showcased long-term planning, with players projected to contribute for years, helping them rebuild after years of poor performance and the Deshaun Watson era.
The New York Giants delivered strong value with top-10 picks in offensive tackle (Francis Mauti) and edge linebacker Arvel Reese, while adding high-potential depth in the second and third rounds.
The New England Patriots are a draft loser due to head coach Mike Vrabel stepping away from the draft on day three without addressing the personal or professional fallout from a reported relationship scandal.
The Jacksonville Jaguars’ draft is criticized for taking a low-ranked tight end (Nate Borkature) at 56, far exceeding his consensus board ranking, indicating a reactive and poorly strategic approach.
The Los Angeles Rams’ selection of Ty Simpson at 13 overall is viewed as a risky move, undermining their quarterback depth and conflicting with their defensive and offensive strength.
The Rams’ decision to draft a receiving-type tight end (Max Cale) over a more dynamic option like Kenyon Sadiq shows a misalignment with their offensive needs.
The Rams’ draft risks disrupting their established on-field chemistry between Matthew Stafford and Sean McVay, which has been a key strength in past seasons.
Summary:
The Ringer NFL show evaluates the 2026 NFL draft, identifying both winners and losers across franchises. The Cleveland Browns stand out as a clear winner, having made shrewd, long-term draft moves focused on starter-level talent across offense and defense. Their strategy—centered on addressing core needs, securing quality players at premium positions, and rebuilding from a history of failure—demonstrates a significant shift toward sustainability.
The New York Giants are also praised for strong draft value, with top-10 picks in offensive tackle and linebacker, and a balanced roster of high-ceiling and reliable players. In contrast, several teams face criticism: the New England Patriots are a “loser” due to head coach Mike Vrabel’s public withdrawal from day three of the draft without addressing a reported personal scandal, creating instability and distrust. Jacksonville’s draft is seen as reactive and poorly strategic, with a high-risk pick of Nate Borkature far above his consensus ranking, lacking clear alignment with team needs.
The Rams’ selection of Ty Simpson at 13 and Max Cale at 35 raises concerns about quarterback depth and offensive fit, undermining their established strengths. While the Rams remain a favorite to win the Super Bowl, the draft choices are viewed as ill-timed and misaligned with their current roster. Overall, the analysis underscores the importance of long-term planning, transparency, and alignment between leadership decisions and team-building goals.
FAQs
The Cleveland Browns and the New York Giants were highlighted as winners. The Browns are praised for addressing immediate needs with starters at key positions and showing long-term rebuilding momentum. The Giants are commended for making smart, high-ceiling picks in the first and second rounds, especially with players like Arvel Reese and Colton Hood.
The Browns were praised for focusing on acquiring starters in critical positions, such as offensive tackle (Spencer Fano) and wide receivers (Casey Concepcion and Denzel Boston). Their draft strategy showed a clear, data-driven approach to rebuilding, and their ability to trade down and still secure top talent was seen as a strong indicator of long-term progress.
While the Giants were considered a winner, concerns included the uncertainty around Arvel Reese’s role as a hybrid edge linebacker and the limited experience of Colton Hood, a young cornerback. There was also skepticism about whether the team could fully integrate these players into an effective system without significant coaching adjustments.
The Patriots were labeled a loser due to the ongoing controversy involving head coach Mike Vrabel and former assistant Diana Rossini, which included allegations of a personal relationship. The situation was seen as damaging to team stability, especially given the Patriots' recent Super Bowl win, and the lack of direct accountability from Vrabel raised concerns about leadership and team cohesion.
The Jaguars were criticized for taking tight end Nate Borkature at No. 56, who was significantly lower-ranked on consensus boards, indicating a reactive and risky draft. The move was seen as a failure to build a competitive roster with high-impact players, especially in a division where other teams were making stronger strategic investments.
The Rams’ selection of Ty Simpson at No. 13 was criticized because it appeared to be a defensive move to avoid upsetting MVP quarterback Matthew Stafford. Analysts questioned the decision, noting that Simpson lacked the ceiling of a true franchise quarterback and that a more dynamic option like Kenyon Sadiq could have been selected instead.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.