2026 New Orleans Saints Preview: Roster, Odds & Win Total
54m 34s
The New Orleans Saints are positioned as a team with high potential but significant risks in 2024. Their offseason strategy focused heavily on building around rookie quarterback Tyler Schuck, who showed flashes of brilliance in preseason but still has a limited sample size and early-season inconsistencies. The offense relies on Schuck’s growth, chemistry with Kellen Moore, and depth at wide receiver—particularly with Chris Olave, whose injury vulnerability adds risk. On defense, the team has a solid run defense and a capable front line, but lacks depth and experienced playmakers, with key players like Kim Jordan and Mario Davis sidelined. The Saints’ schedule is relatively easy, especially against a division with multiple injury-prone teams and weak defenses, giving them a favorable edge. Despite this, the roster remains flawed, and the market undervalues them at a minus-3 point, suggesting a potential bet opportunity. While Schuck’s development remains a major question, the combination of a favorable schedule, strong coaching (Kellan Moore and Brandon Staley), and strategic free-agent additions supports cautious optimism. However, the team’s success hinges on Schuck’s consistency, injury recovery, and the ability to convert a strong preseason performance into a full-season impact. The analysis concludes with tempered optimism—believing the Saints have upside to win the division but not as a guaranteed outcome. The season’s early matchups and injuries will be critical, especially if Schuck or key receivers like Jordan Tyson recover. A potential swing trade or bet on late-season momentum could offer value, particularly in December against division rivals like Tampa or Carolina. Ultimately, the Saints represent a balanced blend of bold optimism and structural weaknesses, making them a compelling but not risk-free bet in the NFC South.
[Music]
Welcome to the acclaimed podcast The Deep Died featuring your esteemed hosts
Andy Monitor and Drew Dinsick, powered by BetSperse. Welcome to The Deep Died and do NFC South
matriculates down to the big easy where we are going to cover the Saints today.
Four flawed teams in the NFC South. I don't think anyone's surprised to hear that.
The team with the reason to bet on their upside in the offseason was the Saints in my opinion.
And it was entirely fueled by the idea that as an organization, they evaluated what happened
in the back half of last season. And they pushed their chips into the table with their
with their offseason free agency moves and draft decision making to suggest we're going to bet on
we can get a top 10 offense out of this Tyler Schuck guy while he's a rookie. And if that comes
to fruition, we're going to win our damn division. And who the hell knows what happens after that.
It was very pretty clear telegraphing by the New Orleans front office. And I found that bold and
exciting. Of cool. As an idea. And there's two reasons. The first is they went all in on a draft
choice who is potentially going to have a red shirt ear in Jordan tights. And they're wide
receiver. Depth chart now relies on Chris Olave not getting concussed. I think the fragility is
very present when you look at the existing state of things. And now I kind of look at their moves
in the offseason and wonder if this was a little bit of fooling themselves because they tried down
the home stretch against teams that were trying to lose and maybe got a little false signal about
how good Mr. Schuck can be. This is in the face of reports that he's looked great in preseason.
What do you think? No, it was it was bumpy. Like even in the winds, it's like
because I watched a lot of that. We took some shock at like what 250 or some scene. I think
at 225 to one to win rookie year. I had some dark. And then eventually I had to just buy all the
Macmillan once it got cheap to buy my way out of that mass because it was like the dark number
was good. The Schuck number was amazing. And so I did grass. I was watching a lot of saints at
the time because it was fun. But he would make some clear bone headed rookie mistakes where it's
like, hey, buddy. No, we're not there yet. Yeah, it was a lot of dumb and dumber where it's like
totally redeemed himself. In the next drive, you'd make a great play. I like the brain trust there
a little as far as more and what they've put together with a very flawed roster, especially
last year and some of the injuries and somebody's ankle being dust and the running back room being
a little elder and him having to take over a franchise that was in a weird spot cap wise for like
10 years after the hate of things as they tried to work out rebuilds without actually rebuilding.
It was a goofy spot. Even that time where they bounced back a little, they're just like, oh,
you just locked out on the best draft class anyone's ever had. It's kind of like when the Eagles did
it a couple years back, which hey, sometimes, sometimes you roll 10-11s in a row and everybody at
the table wins. Yo, Levin, let's go. But you know, the Saints were always weird for me to kind of
square as far as what the what the goal was in a shitty division because I think that's a tough
part about it was, hey, we should maybe tank, but because we're a team that maybe should tank,
but we're also within spending distance winning this division because it's the south and go look
at what everyone else has right now, especially pre maybe even pre-baker even during some of the
Baker seasons where you know, Tampa was good but not unbeatable and they had a lot of injuries
and a fight through as well. So it's been weird for me and you know, I like Shuck. I like what he's
done, but as I mentioned, we have such a small sample on the guy and we saw plenty of bad with the
good and when he was beating teams for the most part, it wasn't very good teams or teams that were
you know, kind of a different spot that that part of the season where they weren't trying to win
games. No, I agree with that. 373 drop-axe from Mr. Shuck last year, so it's not that small of
synthesis. He took over in week 9, they threw him for the wolves against the LA Rams on the road
to make his first start because we had just seen flat out enough from Spencer Eller at that point,
I suppose. He actually came in and did a healthy amount of relief and I lost to the Tampa Bay
Buccaneers in Leakeat, but I'm going to start the clock on him in the offense in week 9.
And what I see as I kind of look through the numbers is a player that he outperformed Sam
Donald who of course went on to win the Super Bowl, he outperformed J. He outperformed
Hertz who won last year's Super Bowl. He outperformed Bonix, Walmart Jackson, Baker Mayfield,
Aaron Rodgers, yeah, he's Pat Moms, a better EPA per play in this sample. So it's a funny
like in totality, he looked like he can be an NFL quarterback, like he looked like he should get
the opportunity to have a full season with Kellan Moore and some more weapons and a little
better protection just to see if he could take another step forward. And actually even more detailed
than that, like he did get better, it felt like every week, like it did feel like the more
reps he got, the game was slowing down. And as you noted, he was very close to stealing a playoff
spot last year, which would have been wild. And yeah, it ultimately proved to be
enough positive signal that the people in the building felt like this is assigned to bet on.
The thing you noted about the quality of opponents was, I think it's real, but you know,
is good news for the St. St. Andy? They're in the NFC South and they got an easy schedule,
that's correct. That's correct. The Saints have the softest schedule of opposing past defenses
in the NFL. I think actually, I take it back, it's not the, I think that the Vikings actually have
the softest past defense. I'll tell you that. Did we talk about this? Anyway, Saints are down there
though. They play the thirtiesiest schedule of passing defenses. They play the thirties second
schedule in terms of just neutral rating for opponents. And a ton of that is fueled by the
fact that no one in your division is really positive. I think in general, the Saints could
still, if again, you get 17 games out of Chris Alave, they could still in this division,
and we shouldn't be surprised. But the more you chew on, you know, what is here right now,
the more clear and obvious the holes look. And so, I think tempered optimism is the correct
spirit to evaluate these guys. Yeah, that's fair. Three and three in the division.
Ricky quarterback, who had a certain nine games, they moved on from Ratler, which felt right.
He had the highest yards per attempt in the NFC South. I thought if the quarterback should play
he added about 200 yards rushing, another few scores on the ground. He was good.
And Lave, 151 targets. He can be your volume guy. Signed his extension. He's, you know, his chemistry
with Chuck was on. He was another one that was like it two yards per out on a big, a big sample of
targets. You lost Mario Davis. We're getting some more of that. The defense has some question marks.
Did, uh, do you have the oldest defense fan ever who's still kind of doing it?
Played like half the Cameron Jordan played like 55% of the snaps.
17 games. I don't think he, I don't think he plays. Now, it's, he is, uh, he's hurt right now.
He has a hamstring issue with no time table right now. So we'll see what happens.
Yeah, some of your, but I'm just saying some of your positives from last year because he wasn't
terrible. He had like 10 seconds.
are either jets or old or God, we hope crystal love is healthy. So I do worry about the downside
on this team and I don't have a lot more to say about the the officer last year.
I don't really either. I thought yeah, I thought in general crystal love being healthy,
being available and having as much chemistry as he had with shutdown stretch was kind of a major
positive and also killing more look like maybe you hired the right guy. I mean he doesn't seem to
fit the kind of God-like offensive genius mold that a lot of the other young hires like Ben Johnson
who were especially excited about he's probably in the next year down. I think that's fair to qualify
but he definitely understands what he wants the offense to look like and his vision seems to be
succeeding in today's NFL. It's kind of funny because they were successful despite having a
really, really bad rushing offense last year in terms of efficiency. So it did put a lot of pressure
on the quarterback but the play concepts he was calling at his sequencing did help him and I
think that's something you can't teach an offensive guy. So yeah, good signal that you're
Kellan Moore higher was good. Kellan Moore brought Doug Newsmeyer and Brandon Staley with him
and Brandon Staley surely punched above his weight with the defensive numbers last year.
The Saints were pretty comparable in run defense to the likes of the Broncos and the Texans.
Like I think only the Seahawks really stood clear above them. We'll put them in the category.
I put them in the Josh McDaniel's category. This guy can't be that good. Staley's role. McDaniel's
yeah, but he is a solid solid coordinator because yeah, he didn't it's the old maybe chicken salad
out of chicken shit because he didn't have a ton to work with get to the level he did with this
defense and then yes, Doug Newsmeyer is offensive coordinator in name. He's obviously a big part of
how they put the offense together but Kellan is who play collar and he is
Doug Newsmeyer's son. Okay. Fun fact. I didn't know that. It was a quarterback, remember him?
I forgot about that. Okay. I do think some of the like the one caveat with the defense
because we were just mentioning they did not play very many good quarterbacks last year. In fact,
they didn't play any. So there's a little bit of a it's a little bit of a bias sample in terms of
the particularly over the second half of the season where the defense looked really good. There
was a lot of a lot of Kirk cousins and Bryce Young in there. I just think Garrett did I say he
was Doug Newsmeyer's son. He is Doug Newsmeyer home. I'm looking at now. I'm looking at Garrett
Newsmeyer. You I assumed you meant Doug Newsmeyer was Garrett Newsmeyer's dad, right? Yeah. I said
it the wrong way. The quarterbacks. Yeah. Yeah, that's it's it's been a long week and we
didn't get the Vegas yet. We are pre-recording. Tuesday Andy.
Wednesday 11. We're recording this the week before because we're off next week. So apologies if
anything is out of date for the same. Well, the freaking Falcons which we pre-recorded might be out
of date. I know. See, Penix might actually be the starting QV week one. But we said that. We
said we don't know. He might just I kind of just assumed it wasn't going to be two of but I didn't
expect this going to be ready. I didn't think he'd be ready week one. I still don't know that he
will be. I obviously will know more about it soon. But yeah, the fact that there's a chance with
Penix is just playing week one is obviously good. It's two as bad. He's the penix is the favorite like 56%
on Calgary. It's like a very low illiquid market. I don't know if I'd be betting that.
You want some no? You can get it. I don't want to either side. All right, off-season.
You mentioned it. They bet on their offense. Travis, ETN, Jr. signed to be your A1 from day one in
the backfield because Camara is not the Camara of old and the MCL sprain kind of made him look
a little worse. He didn't grade out all that well. You brought in also Caden Ellis out of free
agency. As we get to you. He had a great year last year for the Falcons. Another reason that
the Falcons defense might suck to Super Donk you all. Yeah, and this was we'll mention it. I'll
mention it now. You lost, you know, you lost tomorrow Davis to the Jets. So this is kind of an answer
to your weekside linebacker there. Yeah, great run defense mark.
He also played for the Saints prior to that, I think. What was I looking at here? David Edwards
guard, free agent guard. Big splash. Big splash. This is a nice one. You got him. He was a buffalo bill.
He's your starting. He holds the distinction. Andy has being the best biggest free agent
signing with the most generic name. Okay, David. He's the most generic playing the most generic position.
But yeah, signed him for four years out of free agency. And you know, Chuck was sacked 31 times
in his 11 starts. Need some help up there. That'll help. No offense out of free agency. Tight end.
He's added to the room with John Johnson. He, uh, nice TN two. You just told me to sort of puncher
Ryan Wright, um, which helps because you needed that. I think you had a couple of young guys
or something that was it like Kai Kroger was traded. Um, you needed a puncher.
Ty Chandler, another one from Minnesota. Jesus, the pipelines are up there. Backup running back.
Zach Wilson's on this. He is probably better than Ratler. We'll see where they list him.
Uh, not based on the last preseason performance. Both of these guys can go ahead and pack their bags.
QB two. It's, you don't have a QB two. You have two QB three is defensive and Tyree Wilson trade
from Las Vegas on, uh, on draft weekend. What do you think of that? This is going to bear.
He was a really high draft pick in what? 2023 and they didn't really do anything else to address
outside pass rush. You have Granderson and Chase Young and Chase Young can still flash.
I don't know. Like we'll see. I think it's more of a, hey, it was, it was kind of a cheap,
cheap pickup and he was drafted really highly and we'll see. And, you know, they, they declined
to the 50 or options. So this is just a one year trial type thing. It's crazy that trade for a guy
and then decline his option because he can. This is such a cheap pickup. So be interesting between
him and I guess they didn't say and for any Jennings. Another, but that's, you know, more of a depth
piece at edge there and he is again more of a run-stopping edge piece. So we'll see if he has to play
because of, as I mentioned, Kim Jordan, his hamstring is old as shit. They brought in Martin
Emerson, Cornerback Depth. They brought in a couple more linebackers Jackson Sermon and D.M.
Jones out of free agency. He was a buck and he was already gone. He was traded in San Francisco
about two days ago. Well, five days ago, when he listened to this, I suppose. Cleal Saunders,
another interior dude because of the, you know, the, what they need, I guess, at no stack on defensive
tackle. They traded, they got some earwights in that trade for T.M. Jones. After they picked him up,
another running back. They need a bunch with Kamara out for at least a month, I suppose. He just
did a bunch of guys. And then they had a kicker competition that was bad and none of them were good.
So they went and picked up Daniel Carlson on August 24th. He's an actual real decent kicker at times.
He was not good when he was in Minnesota, but he ended up going to the Raiders and kicking pretty well.
And as I mentioned, some of the losses were to Mario Davis, linebacker to the Jets. Alante Taylor,
not one they backfield, really, either. He's a, your corner. He is now a Tennessee Titan. He got,
yeah, pretty paid. We talked about that with Tennessee. He got paid up there,
which is crazy. Quincy Riley is stepping in on outside the corner for him.
They traded that puncher Houston, Kai Kroger. I guess we'll talk about him when we get to Houston.
Tian Jones, I mentioned Foster Merle. They lost a Titan to Houston. That's why we added another one,
a Luke Fortner interior line depth going to the Panthers. Another, it's been a lot of this
inter division stuff, I'll leave.
and then some other depth that was lost, Jonathan Bullard went to Dallas, defensive lineman,
Jonah Williams, Stair, so in a different Jonah Williams defensive lineman, land in young,
swing tackle depth to the Jets, and Dante Pettis, not Dante Pettis. He was actually a, you know,
he did a lot of the returning at times, so you need to fill in there. The most important one that
I haven't got to, yes, of course, unrestricted free agent in March. He walked, said I'm not a
saint anymore. The most dangerous man with the ball in his hands, tight end quarterback,
wet receiver, land back, or Tyson Hill, Tyson Hill, we'll see if he ends up on a roster.
Jalen Polk also, he went on the reserve. I don't hate bringing him back in. I don't
hate bringing him back to New Orleans. I wouldn't do it. I don't know the, I don't know the
Kellen wants the Gadgety package. It just, I don't know if that's what his offense like. So
as you mentioned, Jordan Tyson was the very hydraphic. He was taking, they said, I want him
starting outside. I want to lobby on one side, Tyson at the X, hamstring hurt in the joint
practices, practice with Jacksonville, talking about what a two-month timeline may be longer.
Candidate to probably open on IR with more of a week, six weeks, seven return looking like it.
So I, that sounds optimistic to me. They said, it was, it happened on the 13th and they said two
months. So that's week six. We'll call it week six to eight somewhere in there. And his
durability was a knock pre-draft. Yeah, this is a recurrence. Yeah, it was, it was something
they were worried about coming into the draft when people did their mock. If he contributes
this year, it's a gift. Hopefully he can step in. Defense of tackle from Georgia in the second
round. Christian Miller crafted for interior rotation. Did we mention Brian Bracy? Yet? No.
He plues ACL. Yeah. And he plays in the interior defensive line. So all of those people I mentioned
are now more important. He is your second listed nose tackle. And he didn't look bad. Some people
had some nice things to say about him in the preseason game where they played what the Rams.
Titan Oscar dealt from Georgia. He's your third Titan in the third round. Share my right guard
from Auburn in the fourth round interior lined up. Bryce Lane. A wide receiver from North to
go to state. North to go to state. Excuse me. Excuse me. Bryce Lance Lance. Lance. Sorry, I said
Lane. I'm sorry. Lance Lance. Lance from North to go to state. He's a son of brother. No, he's
the son of former professional defensive back Carlton Lance. Who is also Tray Lance. Yes.
He was fast as shit at the combine. He was like a 435 guy. He had 50 catches for a thousand yards,
20 yards per catch man. Like he's a fun deep threat. He's listed second behind a lava but
with Tyson banged up. You could see the field might be thrust into more of a starting role. A few more
picks. They took defensive back Lorenzo styles from Ohio State. He's a backup nickel right now.
They took Baryon Brown, LSU wide receiver. Probably somebody who's going to mix into the return
game currently listed as your content trick return. Yeah. Over taking over for the Dante
Pettis role and yet six return touchdowns in 65 kick returns and SSC an SEC record. So he sees
something to watch for on the end of the return game and then eventually they did take TJ Hall
another corner back from Iowa. Iowa corner. That's Rick Dodd before. Corner depth. He's listed third
on the depth chart because he is a seventh rounder. It's about to lie out. Okay. That's the,
it was a good op season. The big splashes were obviously Etienne and Edwards and you never
gonna find true game changers in the free agency pool because they're there for a reason. They're
there for a reason, right? But yeah, I mean David Edwards was the top. He was a top 10 contract
overall value among the free agent signings and he was the number two offensive lineman after
Tyler Linda bomb, Linda bomb. So he was a press. Yeah. I mean, I don't know. Kind of would have,
I would have liked to have seen them more active in the wide receiver trade market with like the
Patriots after the after the ice injury. Booty was cheap. I know they, Patriots frigging,
finally, finally gave them up. There's like five teams that should have jumped on that and maybe,
we should have given the Patriots the third next year's third for him. I think they would have
taken it over Jalen Reed who I have no idea is going to make an impact on the field this year.
So I wish they had tried wide receiver depth address it multiple ways instead of just drafting
three guys. But we'll see. All right, man. Ready to go to circa? I am. We've already been.
We're recording. I was your time. Do you have a great time in the desert? Can you believe the heat?
Was it what was the 2018 on Friday? Oh my god. It's a dry heat. No, it's not, but that's just it.
Like you obviously didn't go outside like the monsoon moisture has really challenged. I mean,
I feel bad for like there's that door out of that door over the bridge. There's the walking bridge
toward the ubers and the cars pick you up. And then there's this from the door to the entrance
of the circa. And until I go out to stadium swim, those should be the only two times I go outside.
It's so hot. In the in the afternoon, it's crazy hot. It is this time. You can't do it.
You got to go to stadium swim or some other pool. You can't go outside. It's too much.
So we're going to be inside for the most part signing up for the contest. The only thing hotter.
Sportsbook guaranteed 30 million. Oh god. I was going to say, yeah, the sportsbook desk was hot,
man, it was a it was a fight to get the entries in. I mean, we're we're pacing for
we're headed for rare here with these contest pools. And our entries are they have accrued some
value. Yeah. As we're assuming. Right. Just based on actuary numbers. At least four people who've
signed up for the contest are currently incarcerated and will not be able to get their picks in.
That's just no, I called up plus EV. I said on average, how many people in this subset of,
you know, you know, US citizens are going to be arrested and incarcerated for some time.
So they won't get hospitalized or passed. I didn't want to go too dark with it. I was going to say
dead, but like that's more fun because there are people. I'm guessing I'm sure that the no picks. I guess once
once in a while, it's probably somebody you it's no more, you know, they shuffled off this mortal coil.
And that's just life because older people play this contest and younger people die too. But
we won't get that dark. We're assumed that some people were arrested. And then I think they're
picks in. So our our entries have accrued some value 30 million plus in money. 30 million guaranteed
anything above and beyond the guaranteed money is not taken by the sports. But Derek doesn't put
that it's pocket. They don't give that to Jeff. They don't give that to anyone. They take that and
they put it right back into the contest. So it goes to the players. It goes to the players. There's no
rake. Some contests will have rake. This does not 100% of the entry fees are paid back to the
players, whether it's quarterly prizes, end of the year prizes, booby prizes, or the ultimate gem,
the winner of the 20 plus million dollar survivor contest. So get yourself out there. Sign up. You
haven't till the 12th. If you have any questions about sign up proxies. How it works. How you turn
your picks in every week. Hit us up in the DMs. I am not afraid to have a 20 minute conversation
with a stranger to help modify our little gun shy. Remember when I first signed up the first time
I was so confused. I'm less reliable just because I'm not on Twitter as often as Andy. Yeah,
but it bothered me. True. It's a real job. I'm off. When I'm done with this, I'm working at
a golf game, man. Yeah. But like, and, you know, some of my favorite weekends in Vegas were going
out for NFL week one, signing up at the, you know, right at the death. Yeah, and then stay for those,
and then stay for the games. Yeah, it's so fun. You get college football, real college football,
and NFL week one that weekend. So if you missed contest sign up weekend, it is far, far from too late,
to remedy, to remedy this. You can remedy this. It's the 12th. You can sign up after the Australian
game after the first Thursday night game. You can still sign up after those games of you haven't
You know, that the main slate kicks on that weekend. So thank you to them. And let's get into our
Power ratings. I have the QB OC number
This was really hard
for
Shuck guy, I'm a nice fire guy, and you know what? A lot of this is Kalinmore. I was impressed with what he did
I was impressed with this the decision-making saying hey, honestly, I was just impressed with this. I'm pulling the plug
On on this this rattler. I'm moving. We're gonna try another thing
The skill position group was not helping him out. They still had a
Pretty nice results for a first year guy. Okay, I'm at 3.1 here as bullish as I am. I still can't
realistically go
with a you know, a number that is you know kind of threatening some of the good
Quarterbacks who have done it over time
The fact that this second year player we only have a half a season from
Doesn't really doesn't really give me warm fuzzies. He's still he's still carrying the
The prior that he came in with where he was drafted. So 3-1 for me. Yeah, okay
skill 4-2 4-8
Some of this is a little more because the Jordan Tyson missing 2-3 months
Camara to 4-2 is probably closer to correct. Yeah. What's the Camara entry a sprained MCL?
He's out for a month. Sounds right. Maybe that's a good thing
Nice contributory in the passing game. He he is still a decent, you know receiving back
But still a larvae Devon Vélez
Travis Ctn he's gonna get your first down early down work and he's fine John Johnson and
Yeah, it's still below average a 4.2 for me and then O line. I
Think we're close here
What's your 4.7 for four five for me?
This is the
Like bottom half but not by much an offensive line
Kelvin Banks, Jr. He graded well for me with room to grow. I like David Edwards as we mentioned
Eric McCoy sees a release and
Tolis say Fuwaga are all right around average but
And Fuwaga is still young years from the girl
How long is so to get early for a few years?
Fuwaga and Banks have to kind of hit their potential this year for this to be a top 10 O line
But I'll be watching
There's it's possible
Caesar who he is cashed a bit for me. He was the he pushed the offensive lineman over
In the year he was drafted. I think there was more there was more after him possibly even but he was the one
Center bridge down for that year
Yeah, as we took it. Yeah, it was a pretty hefty price. So
Yeah, it's below average. This is a you know
42nd percent held offense for me. Maybe 43rd. I'll pull it up
Four for four really is not impressed by this offensive line. They rated them 27
Shockly in fact a lot 14th, but I put that more on shock
It was more and if you watch if you dig into it a lot of it was on shock
Just say I'm gonna hold on to this and make something happen
Because I think they kind of gave him the green light to just do that
Thorn has them about 14th. So kind of varying opinion on these things
I think if you are just a hair below average, you're probably in the right right ballpark
So and that we both that's where we both are
my totality
Or my total offensive rating is a 37.4 percentile that is 27th best in the NFL
but
Hey within the enough AFC with the NFC South that's not too bad. No
Spit in distance
What is your run step grade for this team?
5.4
I am lower
Um, I'm at a 4.5 the to mario Davis. Let's talk through it here
The mario Davis exiting isn't helping this brand breecies ACL makes the interior a lot thinner and then
I have shepherd and godshaw is pretty damn good interior detackle for run stop
Um, I have
I don't know. I just have a lot of you know, you know, you know, okay guys
Yeah, it's fine, but you know who actually still grades out pretty well who
Kim Jordan. I know. Yeah, he's seen and he's heard like
You wouldn't think somebody who's 37 years old and you know
Also getting me 10 sacks this season somehow. Yeah, it's gonna be a big but he graded out well
He's run and he's likely to miss week one. I haven't penciled out right now and in the front
I have probably godshaw in the middle shepherd. No, I'm low. What was your number again?
Uh 4.5 4.5 and I was a 5.4 so I really like tap. I really like the
D-line here for run shop, I have him. I like shepherd. I like godshaw
um
Broughton's no no real red flags
um, but uh, I
Don't like Pete Werner
It do like Kaden Ellis and the safeties are not contributing anything
Um, so it's it's like it's good. Not great. But this is the thing is like you have to square it with the fact that they were what number three
Number two in defense of you. It's allowed last year for running like how the hell
Stay. No one could run on them. Really push
Really built this up some island to be fair. They had Davis they had cam Jordan playing a lot of those games and
Uh right now. Yeah, I'm I'm slight pluses to neutral across the front
Werner is a negative Kaden Ellis is not as much of a positive to overcome that
So I'm just slightly blow average because not only are they thin, but uh
Uh the depth is very young
so
I think I'm gonna be just lower on the defense than you. I have a 5.1 for pass rush. I'm a 5.1 for pass rush
And it's a lot of it is just chase young is
Good at times, but it's another one where hey cam Jordan give me 10 sacks
15 tackles for losses. He was uh
He was an important part of that as well
Tyree Wilson is what's obviously going to move this up and down if if he is able to
contribute
Carl Granderson had seven sacks in 39 pressures last year. Yeah, he great. Yeah, maybe I have a little low on this
Kaden Ellis is a good pass rusher too
Yeah, I see what they're gonna ask him to do because of how they
I though. Yeah, the real can I mean help with these safeties at times?
I mean, I think they you mentioned it that Wilson is a wild card, but chase young is good
He's just a good player and he found a very good home and a good system for him
So I think he's going to be kind of a good anchor for a good pass rush. He knew it overall
I'm yeah, I'm at average. I'll quickly move him up if Tyree contribute turf granderson looks good again
Coverage for me 5.8. Uh, I would completely admit. I will completely admit my so much of my
Number my you know, I I started so much of my stuff is skewed from how they performed overall last year
You have to use last year. That's what you have
You have last year plus who's on the roster right now and you're all the way up at a 5.8 somehow
He's yeah, I am at a 5.7 here. Oh, so we're the same number
You're acting like you're going to be
Coolade McKinstree good good good
Yeah, Justin Reed good really good coverage player
Sanker was good. He's actually in a better role for him now, I think
P-Warner first shit is he is at run defense. You can cover
um
I don't know if you read on Quincy rash. Yeah, so a lot of retailers. We said he's overpaid, but he was still good
It's you know, he's not this top five top 10 guy, but he was good and he was your he played
Basically, I think I don't know if he missed time at all. He was your volume corner
And now you have Quincy Riley inheriting the job Martin Emerson
um
Who I believe missed all of last year with a
Torne Achilles says some depth there
Uh, I think he is your next guy up on as far as outside corners useless to be on McKinstree if you need to run six guys out there
um
So it's good not great, but definitely above average because yeah, McKinstree's been good
Reading black men good enough. They actually do create out decent against the run. Especially when Reed's asked me
You know more of a box safety
But yeah the the big question mark around Quincy Riley
Hmm
Okay
Will uh
This is a 57th percentile defense switch
is good enough for 10th for me. I think there's upside. So that's going to probably be
not not a popular opinion. Not consensus. No, it's not going to be a popular opinion.
The power rating overall, you're at 44th percentile and at a 41st, that makes you a minus 1.8 and I
will minus 2. Right now, the market has these saints at minus 3. So we like the saints. We're betting
on this team. There's a point available relative to market and I'm intrigued at when and where
we're going to fire saints bets this year. Yeah, a little lower on coaching than you and willing
to come up with that. I just don't have a big sample of meaningful decision making in a lot of
these games for Kellyn Moore at this point. Special team is numbers quite a bit lower. I got to
check what are my special teams though. Jesus Christ. Dead last. This is my dead last special teams.
Is it apparently? Well, it's because the kickers were all screwed up. Did you adjust for Carlson?
No, this needs to come up. So this is based on Charlie Smith and Tanner or Smife. Tanner
Brown splitting kicks. I'll update this a little with Daniel Carson. Not that that moves the
number much at all anyway. So let's look at this easy schedule that they have. It does not start
that way. This is incredibly tough. This is the best. This is so great. I love when you want to buy
some saints. I love it. The time is not quite yet. Go get yourself a bayonet. A bayonet. I say bayonet. I know it's a bayonet. It's like who's the tight end that we
say that with Dallas Goddard. Go there. Dallas go there. Anyway, get yourself a bayonet. Get
yourself a bowl of gumbo. Gumbo. Oh, come by. Because you've got time. You've got until
or you get a go get go to the palestation oyster bar. What was the plan? What was the call?
What was the call? It's going to be so hot. I don't think we can swing it. It's indoors. What was the pan? What was the pan roast? It was the pan roasts were
Yeah, whatever it was. Yeah, go get yourself a go get yourself a go an etufe a gumbo pan roast
and yeah, it's funny. I'm watching I'm rewatching true detective right now. Oh,
Fox makes sense. These are one. These are one. It's so good. I needed a good download. And it's
based in Louisiana. They had some etufe regardless. The at Detroit apple tomorrow, you are a
big over a touchdown dog start to season and then things get quite a bit easier. There is
five games, which are still cool or less. You're favorite in two of them. Then you get the buy,
you get two more games you're favorite in at home. There's a tough stretch again with Chicago
Sensei Green Bay two of those being on the road. Chicago coming off their buy Green Bay having
a rest advantage and also some of those being cold weather games with at Chicago in late November,
it could be shitty out, maybe not at that point, but it's kind of a toss up.
And then the end of the season easy issue game. You got a nice one home again,
Sarah. So now you get two divisional foes to close the year. In fact, four of your last five games
are against the NFC South with Carolina Tampa on the road, Atlanta on the road and Tampa at home.
So you need, you need to win some road games there if you want to take this division, but it's not.
Is that a schedule where you can't win double digit games if things break right?
Yeah. Did you mention that the New Orleans pit game will be the first NFL game contested in France?
I'd forgotten. Perry, gay, Perry, probably at the PSG set that works out because they have the
floor to Lee, the floor to Lee. And we're about at the point here where we need to start eating the
rich. So maybe we bring some guillotine back, get gas prices backed out under four bucks. I can't
imagine what you're paying California, but I bet they do it in leaders out there because you guys are
it's that it's that obscene. You're just that to European. This is the kind of schedule, they aren't
taking the buy after the French game though. Yeah. This is the kind of schedule I absolutely love.
It is very clear and obvious that there is a buy point after the first couple of weeks and yeah,
it's only going to take seven eight wins. So giving the year division a two week head start doesn't
really matter. You're still going to be competitive for the South. So I really hope we get
kind of going into that Las Vegas game. We get a little bit of positive news about Jordan.
Tyson's recovery and that he's on the mend. He's ramping up if he's not done.
You know, it would be a fun exercise. I'm going to do this, you know, I'm a little tight on time
today. Okay. Just looking at this, it makes me wonder about the first two to three games for
the other teams in the division. And it makes me want to do a little evaluation of the first two,
three, four, you know, do a bunch of different simulations on teams and how tough their schedules
are because I think there are spots to do this in how the prediction markets are so prevalent.
If you wanted to, hey, I like the Saints. We're above the market in here. You know what I might
start the season with? Saints to not win the South. And you know, you're not going to get rich on
some of these. And we talk about this so much with futures. I hate betting a future that's minus
110 and I'm going to sit on for eight months. I don't think it's a great use of money, but I don't
mind betting a future that maybe I only make 20% on 10% on, but I feel really good about the chances
of me making that 10 to 15% return in two weeks. You know, it's something like that. If there are
some spots, it doesn't have to be in the South. If there are some teams that we, hey, they're going
to get the shit kicked out of them for two weeks. And at least one of these other teams is probably
going to be two and oh, we take it, we bet it, we cash it out in two weeks and then flip it onto
the other side, maybe the sweet spot for that type of play is week 14, December 13. You want to come
off of that Chicago Cincinnati Green Bay, where presumably they have been, well, I'm playing
a little bit around trips on this team. Right. Like you want to come off at that stretch where they've
gotten beat up by the good teams a little bit. And then they're going into two high leverage games
against Carolina at Carolina at Tampa and their small dogs on the road in those games. Like they can
win those games. Then they get Arizona, Atlanta, which should be win-win. I don't know. I feel like
that's the swing trade spots. And in general, I'm still not entirely quit on the idea that these
guys are actually much better than the market things, and that we're going to laugh at see who can
believe we have these guys in minus two. Like Tyler Schuck and Kelly Moore clearly have chemistry.
I mean, honestly, just reading and hearing about from Saints Beat guys on how good
Schuck has looked and camp has me kind of wanting to drink some of the
Marty Gragius.
Yeah.
Pour some hurricanes. Have a grenade. You've been to, you've been to, uh,
never, never, uh, French quarter. No, okay. I don't like the French.
I would never go to Montreal either. I'm kidding. I've been to France.
Never been to New Orleans. Probably going, I have been looking at train schedules. I'm planning
European vacation ahead of time. It's crazy how fast you can get places over there. Just take
the train. Maybe I'll get real French food instead of the Cajun version. It's on my list. I'd
like to visit the city. I like to go places and eat good food and New Orleans is probably pretty
damn high on that list for people. I love it. Well, considering how F to their,
says, F to the secondary for the Detroit lines is it's a damn shame that the Saints don't have
a completely viable set of passing weapons in a game to make this fun threat. I would really love
some early season chaos with some of the big dogs losing week one for survivor purposes and
they just don't know if we're going to get it. Um, you can have the balls to pull the sugar on
Saints after Christmas against the Arizona Cardinals for survivor. No, I'm probably on the some
Devon Valey overs against Detroit. Okay. Just give me, give me slots. I got to look at what
Shucks splits were for where he was throwing it on the field, but I think we could get a bunch of
Devon Valey week one against the secondary that's probably can have their hands full
despite having like you said, not a great wide receiver room. It's just to beat up defensive
backfield right now. Yeah, I'm looking at it like we said. I'm looking at some
entry point here. I like what you said, getting in that late in the season, especially if they're
trailing by a game or two, because I think that's something the market doesn't price in as
well as it could. It's just the absolute leverage of winning those games against your division
foes, the two the two game swings that you can start to throw if you get hot at the end of the season
compared to, you know, a spot where, hey, this team won five games. Yeah, but the team that was two
games ahead of them went four and one. Yeah, right. And they didn't play each other and, you know,
we really didn't make up much ground here. So that's fun. But also at the same time,
I still kind of do want to bet against them to start the year. I do got to look at the schedules
for Tampa and Carolina and see if that drives a little theory. For the last five games for the
Saints are in this dog shit division and the fifth is Arizona.
Tour Tampa, though, Tampa's favorite Tampa is the best quarterback in the division. Tampa has a lot
of question marks. So what kind of level of confidence you're going to say that in December
that Tampa is the best quarterback in the division? I probably still will say that he's
pretty good. Well, what level what's your what's your confidence interval? 90% confidence interval
that you'll still see Baker Mayfield is the best quarterback in this division in December.
Yeah, I'm going to I'm probably not going to say about a falcon's quarterback.
Bryce as a small chance. It feels like I mean, Shuck is most likely to take over that. Actually,
the most likely way to take over that is Baker gets hurt. Second most likely is Shuck third most
likely is Bryce. Okay. Bryce is a better quarterback than Shuck right now. But I think his upside
is capped a little more where Shuck has, hey, we don't know, he could be a lot better than this.
Absolutely. Which is fun. So any preseason bets, I think Kellin Morris pretty high up on the list
for if you want to bet on a coach in the year, just because they had six wins and you know,
they have a good shot to what if they win 11? That's a five game improvement. They win the division.
Shuck looks good. I think Kellin Moore definitely we talked about in that despite not really having
a shot at getting a one or two seed, about two 75 to win the NFC South. Win total sitting 7.5
juiced to the over at about minus 120. They could win 11. That's not crazy. Yeah, but that's
just not getting you a one or two seed. You you the case for Kellin Moore is like he's getting
the credit for Shuck took this big step forward and win their division. They look good. He is
getting the it has to be driven in the media too. We're like Kellin Morris. The reason this team
has turned around. This was a six win fourth place team last year and really it's like hey,
but they also have like 11 very winable games on the schedule and a couple more coin flips. So
huh. Yeah, I don't hate it. I know that's he's short for a reason in that market.
I don't think it's something I'm playing preseason. No, I don't either. We agree.
Especially because they're probably going to lose to this right in Baltimore week one and
week two. Yeah, if you want if you want coach of the year, you bet that as well. Take him to 18
to one after he's gotten his shit kicked out of my couple times. Kim Jordan, I think he said
this will be his last season, 16th season. So I'll be excited to watch him a little more once he's
healthy. I love him. Yeah. I'm looking at beyond his terms. We'll see.
Hopefully he can come back for the second half of the season and maybe they're in a spot where
they found a rotation and they can use him a little more sparingly and we get him all the way through
the year. So I'm always been a fan. So with that, that's the Saints. We'll be on to the
next one. Tomorrow, your favorite twin, the NFC. It doesn't work with like the East. I can say
they'll announce like the South. Sad South.
Someday someone's got a win.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The New Orleans Saints are viewing their 2024 season as a high-risk, high-reward bet on young quarterback Tyler Schuck, who showed promise in preseason but has a small sample size and early-season flaws.
Despite a flawed roster and injuries—especially to key players like Mario Davis and Cameron Jordan—the Saints have made significant offseason moves, including signing David Edwards and trading for depth, to strengthen the offensive line and defensive backfield.
The team’s soft NFC South schedule, combined with strong defensive run defense and a promising quarterback development story, gives them a realistic chance to win the division, though their weaknesses in depth and durability raise concerns.
Summary:
The New Orleans Saints are positioned as a team with high potential but significant risks in 2024. Their offseason strategy focused heavily on building around rookie quarterback Tyler Schuck, who showed flashes of brilliance in preseason but still has a limited sample size and early-season inconsistencies. The offense relies on Schuck’s growth, chemistry with Kellen Moore, and depth at wide receiver—particularly with Chris Olave, whose injury vulnerability adds risk.
On defense, the team has a solid run defense and a capable front line, but lacks depth and experienced playmakers, with key players like Kim Jordan and Mario Davis sidelined. The Saints’ schedule is relatively easy, especially against a division with multiple injury-prone teams and weak defenses, giving them a favorable edge. Despite this, the roster remains flawed, and the market undervalues them at a minus-3 point, suggesting a potential bet opportunity.
While Schuck’s development remains a major question, the combination of a favorable schedule, strong coaching (Kellan Moore and Brandon Staley), and strategic free-agent additions supports cautious optimism. However, the team’s success hinges on Schuck’s consistency, injury recovery, and the ability to convert a strong preseason performance into a full-season impact. The analysis concludes with tempered optimism—believing the Saints have upside to win the division but not as a guaranteed outcome.
The season’s early matchups and injuries will be critical, especially if Schuck or key receivers like Jordan Tyson recover. A potential swing trade or bet on late-season momentum could offer value, particularly in December against division rivals like Tampa or Carolina. Ultimately, the Saints represent a balanced blend of bold optimism and structural weaknesses, making them a compelling but not risk-free bet in the NFC South.
FAQs
The Saints are betting on a top-10 offense led by rookie quarterback Tyler Schuck. The organization pushed hard on Schuck, believing he can develop into a legitimate NFL starter, especially with improved protection and weapons like Chris Olave. Despite early struggles and a high-risk rookie status, Schuck outperformed several established quarterbacks in metrics and showed consistent improvement week-over-week.
The Saints made significant free agent signings, including offensive lineman David Edwards, running back Caden Ellis, and linebacker Kaden Ellis. These moves strengthen the offensive line, backfield, and defensive depth, addressing key weaknesses from last season, particularly in pass rush and run defense.
The defense has question marks due to aging players like Cameron Jordan (hamstring injury) and depth issues at linebacker and corner. While the team showed strong performance against high-quality quarterbacks last year, the sample is biased due to limited exposure to top-tier opponents, making the defense's long-term stability a concern.
The Saints have one of the softest schedules in the NFL, playing against teams with weak defenses and few wins. This gives them a significant advantage, especially in the early part of the season, where they face only a few tough road games and have a strong chance to build momentum and secure a division title.
While Schuck has made rookie mistakes, he has consistently outperformed top quarterbacks in metrics and showed improvement each week. His performance against tough opponents and in high-leverage situations suggests potential, though full development will depend on protection, game experience, and further development under Kellan Moore's coaching.
Jordan Tyson is recovering from a two-month injury and is expected to return around week six to eight, while Camara is out for a month due to an MCL sprain. Both absences create short-term instability but are expected to be mitigated by depth and the development of younger players.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.