2026 Midseason Awards: Joe Burrow, Josh Allen, or Jordan Love?
1h 25m 32s
The mid-season awards discussion on the Athletic football show centers on standout players across offensive and defensive positions. Offensive Player of the Year goes to Jackson Smith, celebrated for his elite efficiency, high target share, and dominance in a system with minimal alternatives, while Kenneth Walker and Jermir Gibbs are named as strong contenders due to their exceptional rushing production. T Higgins is recognized for a transformative rise, particularly in middle-of-the-field play, with a high rate of first downs and explosive targets. For defense, Fred Warner is championed as the top candidate, with his return from injury significantly improving the 49ers’ defensive metrics, including a league-leading reduction in explosive plays in key areas. Will Anderson Jr. is acknowledged as a dominant edge rusher, though Warner’s broader impact on team performance is emphasized. Blake Cashman is lauded as a pivotal figure in the Vikings’ defense, showcasing versatility and consistency. Other notable mentions include Chase Young and Dexter Lawrence, whose defensive schemes have reshaped opponents. The show concludes by advocating for a more comprehensive award system, recommending position-specific honors—such as best interior lineman—to better reflect the modern game’s strategic depth and player roles.
Welcome to the Athletic football show brought to you by the US Bank. Smartly visas signature card. I'm Robert Mays. Mid season awards time is here. Derek in studio. We had some great conversations about these awards. We blew through the first like six awards. And then we spent like half an hour on the final two. But I think that's probably how it should be. Let's get to our mid season award picks on the athletic football show right now. Mid season awards time on the athletic football show. I like our little graphic that's behind us for those of you watching on YouTube. It actually does have like an Oscar's vibe to it. The gold like plus the black. And that's always how I thought about this. And that's why as we go through these awards. I've always started with like offensive player of the year. Because it feels like best supporting actor actress, which is how the Oscars start every year. Did you know that? I did not know that every year, but it's traditional. They often start that way. They start with like a meaty one first. Yeah. They start with like a meaty one first to suck you in. But not the biggest one. Not the biggest one. You have to find like the eight out of 10. You can't go straight to 10 out of 10. They often they used to do that. The previous winner would present it. But then they stopped doing that and I hated it. I'm a traditionalist. And so I like to go back to how we often done things. And so there's a reason why we go by the book here. We're just going to do how we often do it. You've seen more of the Oscars. Like you watch more of the Oscars every year than Derek. And I have probably watched combined if I had to guess. It's really one of my favorite nights of the entire year. I really do love it. Did they stop doing that in the event that you have to like present yourself? Or, no, no. They just, they just, they just, they, they always mess up the format because it's some executive is like we need to make this show shorter. And for a young audience and all of those amazing bits of feedback from people in charge that never actually makes sense. Okay. Let's kick things off with offensive player of the year. David, I'm going to let you start us off, everybody. Your OPOI for the 2026 first half of the season is who? I will admit this about myself. I'm self-aware. I'm always going to try to enhance them and humble. Thank you. Thank you so much. And in short, I'm always going to try to zig when some, when people's ag. Like I'm bored by the consensus. And just across all chapters of my life. And so when I knew we were doing this show, I started looking for an outside the box candidate to stump for. And this is an interesting strategy. I'm just picking the best answer. Well, let me get there and I do have some outside the box candidates in this show because I just get bored by the obvious. I do too. I do too. I'm very guilty of that. All of that said, I started researching this show. And I was like, okay, I got nothing against. I can't, I can't beat Jackson Smith and Jigba's candidacy for offensive player of the year. It would be disingenuous to try. And so after looking at it for a couple hours, I was like, even I, the hipster can't deny this. He's been absolutely incredible. And I think halfway through the year, there's a couple other names I want to bring up. Yeah, but halfway through the year, I don't even really think it's a debate. I mean, I have the same answer. I mean, he is on pace to almost win the triple crown. Like if you stop the season right now, I think the only one he's short on is receptions by like two. Like he's, he's doing it again. My, he's also not answer. I just think that the combination of efficiency and volume and tandem is unbelievably impressive. He is still sixth among all receivers in EPA per target, despite how often he's being targeted. And he's the only worthwhile receiving option within the offense right now. And so the fact that teams know he's going to be the entire diet of the passing game. And they still can't really slow him down specifically in any given game is incredible. If he was getting 20 targets a game and he was finishing with like 80 yards a game, that's not that impressive. Like it's, we're throwing the ball 20 times the game. This point, you, the combination of high efficiency, plus how much of a focus he is, is incredible to me. I did a video, one of the replay brews that we did maybe a month ago about JSN. And a lot of the stats I laid out there are still applicable here. The one that, I mean, there's plenty of them. He right now is at 49.9% of the Seahawks total areas. If he breaks 50%, he would be the first player, the first player since 2014 Calvin Johnson with a 100 targets that would break 50% of his team's total areas. Like the idea that he is the only show in town. And like the fact that he's still this efficient with having that sort of prominence is amazing to me. His target share right now is 36% of the Seahawks targets, which is at least three or four percent higher than name your favorite wide receiver. Like I mean, CD lamb is sitting at 33%, I'm in Rossane Brown sitting at 32%. Like there are guys north of 30. Nobody is flirting with 40% the way JSN is. And I would argue too, you, you touched on it. But say your favorite receiver. And I'll tell you the other option in the offense that is doing lifting or the quarterback that is doing heavy lifting, not only does JSN not have somebody else. He's not getting good quarterback play this year. Like at least halfway through last year, Sam Donald was on a heater. Sam Donald hasn't been healthy or good this year and he's still producing. That's what I was going to say. The volume is one thing. Like we knew that they were going to throw the ball to JSN a billion times. Like they just don't have many other guys in the offense. But the fact that he's done it with like Sam Donald being banged up for a lot of the season, either not playing so Drew Locke has to play or like with Sam Donald has played this year. He's just not been as good as he was last year because I think he's not been healthy. So you have that element of it. The run game has also just been non-existent from most of the season, where I think especially when JSN was great early on last year. So because teams were dedicating resources to be like it's the kubiak system. They want to run the ball. They want to do all this stuff. Obviously team shifted a little bit over the second half and he was still incredible. The fact that defense is now really don't have to respect the run game. They're counting for him. And they're counting for him. And he's still doing this with backup quarterbacks. Being as efficient as he is. Like he just has such a rare blend of the spatial awareness, how quick he is and just how he attacks the footballfer. I know that he's not like small, but again, he's not like T-higgins. But he can attack the ball in the way that a lot of those guys can. It's unbelievable. We've talked so much about the aesthetics of JSN, the style of JSN. He's a singular player in the way that he moves, in the way that he plays. And you combine that with the production. And he's just a one-of-one type guy that I absolutely love watching. And it's hard to really pick anybody else at this point. The guys I throw out, I have two others that I think are on the short list for me. Kenneth Walker has been everything the chiefs could have asked him to be. Kenneth Walker this year, Pernexion, 17 total rushing EPA, which is number one in the league. And the guy that I would also list right on the short list of players is Jermir Gibbs. Just for context, Jermir Gibbs has negative total rushing EPA on the season. Kenneth Walker has two and a half touchdowns worth. That's partially a product of when you run the ball a lot. You're going to have inefficient plays. Like that's just the nature of that stat for rushing specifically. But that's why the Kenneth Walker number is so ridiculous. Like the explosives that he's ripping off, the pure value created from them is unbelievable. And he's still third in rushing success rate, despite all of the volume. So Walker and Gibbs to me would be the next two names I would probably throw out there. Was there anybody else for you guys? I also still had Vajon Robinson. Like I just think because I think with all three of those backs and then obviously including JSN, the volume that they get and still being as efficient as they are, like I think all four of those guys, those to me would be the ones that I'm guessing by the end of the year that's still who we're talking about in this in this room. He you wouldn't vote for him to win this. But I just want to say T Higgins's name. He was the last name on my list. He's been incredible. He's the last name on my list. So I went into it. I went into the exercise. Like is there a way I can finagle choosing T Higgins? And after 15 minutes, I was like, no, there is not. But it does not diminish what he has done this year. I was curious because just anecdotally, I remember we talked about it. How many plays he's making over the middle of the field? And in my mind, I know he's been playing on the league for seven years. Of course, he's made plays over the middle of the field. But all of my favorite long lasting team memories before this year were outside the numbers. Outside the numbers, dunks. Yeah. Yes. So I was just curious what he's doing over the middle of the field. Did you look this up? I've looked it up earlier in the season. It's a staggering comparison compared to their careers. Joe and him. T Higgins is averaging 1.13 EPA per target when the bingles target him between the numbers. This year, his previous high was 0.66 and the volume of it too. Oh, the volume's crazy. He's he's been targeted 34 times. I think his high for his careers, like 45 in a set in a 13 game season. Think about that. Yeah, it's crazy. Also half of his middle of the field catches 15 of 30 have been an explosive or a touchdown. That's insane. It's crazy. Half of it is crazy. 83% of his catches this year have gone for first downs to Higgins. 83%. It's the highest rate in the league among players. The least 50 targets. The quality of his targets and the value of the throws to T Higgins this year. It has been insane. And he's doing it in different ways than he's ever done before. It's kind of wild that a guy that I think we all probably would have considered. Like a top 15 receiver in the league is probably a worthwhile consideration for the most improved player in the NFL this year. But like that really is what it feels like. And it's maybe not improved skills. But the blossoming of all the ways he's affecting this of the game in ways that he didn't necessarily in previous years has been so notable to me. Like you feel it within the offense. What those two are doing right now is the fact that you have a team with Jamar Chase and the other guy might be the offensive player. Exactly. And I will say Jamar Chase can still the way that he played. Yeah, we got a lot of games left. There's nine games left. We might be the end of the season.
It's like, oh, wait, yeah, Jamar Chase has won the triple crown before he might be the offensive player of the year. And so either of those guys being in the running by the end would not surprise me. Let's get the defensive player of the year. Derek, why don't you kick us off here? Your defensive player of the year for the first half of the season is who? This one I did come down to like two, maybe two and a half candidates. I still think it is Will Anderson Jr. I think he is playing at an unbelievable level. Still he leaves the NFL in sacks with nine and a half. He has 44 pressures according to next chance after to second most in the league. 19 quick pressures tied for second most in the league is still a phenomenal run defender in basically every way. And he is to me just when you turn on Texas Texans film, it's so obvious on every snappy, the best player on the football field is no matter what they're doing, no matter what the concept is, quick pass, deep pass, under center play action, like he just finds a way to affect the game. And there's definitely a couple of other like deserving candidates, but this really does feel like Will Anderson Jr. has kind of crescendoed into this just unstoppable force of a player. I fully support this because I sent him a million times last year. If Miles Garrett didn't break the sack record, Will Anderson Jr. would win defense player of the year and any other season. And so the fact that in a year where there's a little bit more opportunity. Miles Garrett's out playing and Will Anderson Jr. is playing at the exact same level he played at last year. I like the fact that we might have like a second wave appreciation for the player that he has become over the last two seasons. I don't want to sound like I'm shooting on Will Anderson. He's an incredible football player. He's been the best edge this year considering Miles Garrett hasn't been available up until recently. This goes back to, I remember we talked about this when we did end of season awards last year. I'm stuck in the balance between who's the best player and what effect are you having on this season? And I can't shake the fact that the Houston Texans have been a disappointing team through the first half of the year. What would you say if he wasn't on the team? Let me do you want better. Let me talk to you about a guy who has had a very tangible impact on why his team is the best team in the NFL. And I'm surprised I'm doing this instead of you. This was my other pick. I know where you're going. I give it to Fred Warner. Fred Warner is also my pick. I would give it to Fred Warner. And it's not a knock on Will Anderson. He is incredible. And he's been the best edge in football over the first half of the year. But I'm looking at performances that are not only outstanding, but have a tangible effect on the season we're watching play out. And it is there's still a lot of football left. The Texans aren't out of it. The 49ers have been the best team in the league through the first half of the year. And we have a very real data point that says, and I know there's so many variables that go into it. You can't give all the credit to Fred Warner. But this was a bottom of the barrel defense last year when he went out. They were 27th in EPA per snap. 27th in yards per play and 30th and success rate down the second 75% of the season last year after his injury. Right now their top half of the league in EPA per snap. 10th in yards per play. Fred Warner has five forced fumbles, which I believe is the most through eight games in modern NFL history. Wow. Really? Yes. I mean, that is a lot. If you play that, I mean, if he's an awful linebacker, he's an awful linebacker. And I believe the single season record for a non defensive lineman is like 10. He's one of 10 linebackers with three pass breakups. He's got four non sack tackles for loss. He has half a sack this year. He's just been fantastic. And obviously, he's the best linebacker in football. He's playing like it. He's, he's, you know, back after the injury, obviously, we don't usually do come back player of the year. He'd be a slam dunk for a comeback player of the year. But I think he's been even better than that. And after the career that he's had, you know, I could say not like a, you're not doing this for sympathy. But as a like crowning achievement on the career of such a great player, I think it makes a lot of sense. He's also my pick. I think that there are a lot of kind of intangible. Exant like reasons for this just because of how different like Dave said, the Niners defense fuels with him out there compared to him not being out there. There is one stat I would throw out there that I do think is just a perfect representation of when he's on the field, what it means there to this season on throws between five and 15 air yards between the numbers. The San Francisco 49ers have allowed 31 yards per game, which is dead last in the NFL. They have allowed an explosive play rate on those plays of five percent, which is dead last in the entire NFL. Just for context, the league average is 14.1%. There's is at five percent. He erases an entire area of the field and that area of the field going back to the T Higgins conversation is the most valuable area of the field. The completions to there are the best completions you can have as an offense. And teams just don't even try to do it against the Niners and can't do it because he's out there. And that taking the ball away, the way that the run defense feels like the run defense for the Niners has been so much better than we ever could have hoped. And there are reasons for that. Like I think the front diversification we've seen from them has led to some of that Grayson Holton is a way better. I mean, we never we didn't know who he was before the season started. Obviously losing him hurts, but also did he do as a good player, but he's a very specific like gap shooting type of player. The defense for the most part isn't that much different, that much different, personal wise. Then it was last year when they were at absolute shit show, they all come Fred Warner's plan. They haven't had Bosa for a few chunk of this either. Yeah. The idea of like, well, Nick Bosa was hurt last year. He's been hurt this year. Michael Williams has heard for a good chunk of the start of this season. Like I just think that they're eighth and defensive DV. It's crazy. And I think really was a ton of credit for that. Like they are they are doing things that has led to that. And I think that the young DBS have taken a step forward. There are certainly reasons for what Dave is saying outside of just Fred Warner is back. But I do think Fred Warner is back to me is probably the number one reason he has a gravity to him that no other like middle of the field player has like safety or I mean, like maybe like peak Kyle Hamilton, but really other than that, that's probably it. And even I think Fred Warner is a little bit of a different beast. I also again, nothing against Will Anderson. I would if there is a worthy candidate, I would like to think other positions can win defensive player of the year. I know Patrick Sir Tan did it recently, but that was in a weird year for edge rushers. Like I would like to see an off ball linebacker get some shine given what we've seen from that position and how big it's been to some of the defensive trends in the NFL right now. But we had one of what it seems to look really want to. I don't think so. It's been on the past russia award. Well, the last 15 or so years, we got a past russia award or if like a corner has a special. Has like this to fund you more Patrick Sir Tan. Like that's really the only that and I think that this is the year. And I also, this wouldn't be the reason there's no way this creeps into the AP voting pool. But I think that the way the sport has shifted over the last like few years where we've gotten back to a place where box players running backs linebackers. I think we're starting to really appreciate their value again, just because of certain meta shifts in the league. I think that this is the moment. I think in a lot of ways for a player like Fred Warner to be popped properly appreciated. And I think this right now based on what he's doing, what the Niners are doing, I think it would be an appropriate time for that to happen. For all those reasons, there's another name I would throw out at the same position for me. And it's Blake Cashman. He's I, I wanted to at least mention Blake Cashman. I don't think he like quite, he quite gets, he quite gets there for me. But I completely understand why you're saying that he's an unbelievable. Fred Warner is my choice. But Blake Cashman is right there. And like I, I think narrative is important. You don't want it to be the only reason why you hand out an award, but the Vikings defense has been the best in the league through the first half of the year. It's been a dominant storyline. It's the reason why they're even relevant. And who personifies that more than the linebacker who does everything for that defense. I mean, the guy had the guy is tied for the league lead in off-ball linebacker sacks second among all linebackers and pressures. He's top 10 in tackles. He has four pass breakups, which is tied among all off-ball linebackers for best almost picked off Josh Allen like immediately in the last game. He's he has been absolutely incredible. And on that defense, like Dallas Turner has been amazing. The safeties are so fun. Like there are a lot of pieces of it that make it go. But if if I had to circle a guy that sort of personifies what the Vikings have done, I think it would be Cashman. And so he's at least worth mentioning. I think that Harrison Smith also does that to an extent just because of how important he is like their pre snap process. But in terms of like how the defense feel like play to play execute like making your actual plays. Yeah, Cashman is kind of a different a different guy there. The couple other guys I wanted to throw out just because I think that they've been so impactful in terms of how some of these teams play this season. The Cincinnati Bengals lead the league in light box rates against the run. And they are a dead average rushing success rate defense and a top five rushing success defense on up the middle runs like not outside the tackles. Dexter Lawrence has legitimately changed the way that the Bengals are allowed to play defense because he is out there. They're doing what actually watching them reminds me a little bit of is the year the bucks won the Super Bowl with Tom Brady and the defense was really good and Vita Vaya was playing at a supremely high level. The way that they just played some of the spacing in their fronts was like Vita Vaya will literally cover both sides of the center all the way to the tackle. Like just the way that they're spacing the front. The Bengals do that with Dexter Lawrence where they're like we can kick the end out a little bit further. Like we'll he'll buy time for a linebackers behind him or if he's got to be the double team he'll just do it and get back across the face of the guard. Like he just buys so much space for a defensive. Yeah, like I said, you look at the numbers like okay, they're average run defense, but they're not committing any resources. There it is.
run defense with below average linebacker play. And I think that's being a corner you don't tackle. Yeah. It's what he has done to just the overall compaction of the defense to me is incredible. And so Dexter Lawrence at their out there, Jeffrey Simmons has been amazing. Not a share. No, if Simmons has been unbelievable. If Simmons had gotten to Chicago three weeks earlier, it would be not and not that he wasn't great in Tennessee. Don't get me wrong. But like if if he had been doing this for a few weeks longer on that sort of stage, I think you'd be hearing that a lot more. Two other names I would throw out. Chase Young has been amazing this year. Yeah, man. Can we sit in how cool that is for him? Yeah. The fact that his career looked kind of over. He looked like he was a little bit lost in places like San Francisco. He was like a decent player. But you didn't remember that he was the second or third overall picker, whatever he was in the draft. And now he is fully back to like, oh, yeah, that is the guy. When he came out of Ohio State, we all thought he was just as good as the Boses. And so the fact that he's been able to have this resurgence, I know it's on like a Saints team that nobody really cares about this year, but speak for yourself. We're Jordan Tyson's back, man. Yeah, and I have the Saints in the winds pool. We're kind of deeply invested in the world and saying, so I've really been enjoying the Chase Young experience. The other guy I throw out, talk about leveling up, just feeling like a completely different player, impact, play to play. Greg Russo has had an unbelievable season for the bills. And so those are like the five or six guys out there. It's going to be a fun second half of the season race for this award specifically, because I think there are a lot of guys within striking distance of it. Like Jeffrey Simmons could absolutely be the defensive player of the year. I think that Will Anderson Jr. is the betting favorite to do it right now and all the guys that we've said. And so it's going to be a fun second after the season to kind of figure out who's actually going to pitch this thing and run with it. Last year, we already knew it was Miles Garrett, even with exactly what Anderson was doing. We knew it was Miles Garrett, so that's fun. All right, let's take our first quick break and then come back and shout a little offensive rookie of the year. We've got a great Sunday night football match up this week between the Steelers and Bengals. When you flip on the game, be sure to turn on the athletic live on YouTube as well. Watch the game along with host Charles McDonald, Max Brown and Daniel Popper and become part of the show in the interactive chat. The athletic live is presented by Google Gemini. Check it out now and subscribe on YouTube. Dave Europe, buddy, your offensive rookie of the year, halfway through the season is who? If I was actually betting on who I thought was going to win offensive rookie of the year, I would either go with one of the Cleveland receivers or Jonah Coleman, especially like if you're talking about the end of the year, Jonah Coleman. He was on IR, so his stats don't look outstanding right now, but based on the usage we've seen out of Jonah Coleman since he got back, he has a shot at a thousand scrimmage yards and like seven or eight touchdowns for a playoff team. I think that in a year where there's not like a slam dunk candidate to win this award, I think Jonah Coleman is worth mentioning. Concepcion and Denzel Boston have been so, so much fun. Boston's got a shot at a thousand yard season. I think those guys are worth mentioning if you're talking about who actually wins it. I'll talk about them. Right now, halfway through the year, it's been kind of a down year for rookies. The big, big guys haven't been otherworldly. They haven't gotten out to these hot starts. So my awards, who I'm handing this out, I'm giving mine to all of Ivanka. You want a of the Baltimore Ravens. It's dumb. That offensive lineman can't win awards like this. And he's been fantastic on a year where like really nothing's gone right for the Ravens and so many things have gone wrong for wrong for their offensive line in general. He's like the steady Eddie on the Ravens offensive line as a rookie starter. He's allowed. Fewest pressures allowed among rookies who have played 50% or more of their team snaps. He hasn't allowed a sack since week one. And oh, by the way, the Ravens asked him to play center in week three and made him do it until Camjurgen's got up the speed. And he looked fine doing it did not play center in college. They were just like, Hey, you're big. Can you snap? And he was like, yeah, sure. Then he sprained his MCL and missed one game and came back and he looked like a guy dealing with an injury in the Thursday night game, but he looked fine to me like he's still like he's he's an awesome player. The Ravens have to be thrilled at what they got with him. And in a year where nobody else is taking it and running running with it, I think he should like right now he I would give it to him. I'm sure somebody else just by volume stats has the chance to pass him, but I think he's the best right now. He absolutely to me is on the short list. If I had like four or five guys like by three or four guys, he would be on my short list. Well, I do want to like I that's not my people like he I really did think about it for a lot of reasons. Like if Lamar doesn't get hurt, I almost think that like it would be a lot easier to make the case. Yeah, absolutely because it would be like the impact would be clearer. Yeah, it would be my god. The Ravens are top five offense. Like they're doing all the stuff that they want. And then we'd be like, Oh, yeah, maybe they're best offensive lineman right now. It's a rookie who played center for a little bit. And so I think that he's been fantastic. Everything you want. My pick was still Denzel Boston. I think it's like this to me, I think feels like the word that I have the least amount of faith whoever I pick today is by the end. Totally agree. But this was the one that I was like, I gotta pick something. Yeah, I will say I don't think he's been quite as good as McMillan was last year, but there is a case to me of like the fact that Denzel Boston has like yes, like 500 yards of season, he's had a number of great games with like still bottom of the barrel quarterback play. Yes, there's a part of me that wonders if he had average quarterback play, would he just have like 700 yards and like be one of those guys who is that's a great point. That is my argument. Yeah, like that is exactly my argument because really other than getting the lengths by the Ravens and he did not play well in that game other than that. He's been like a pretty impactful guy week to week. And obviously, what he was able to do last week, like picking the ball off of a guy's helmet. Like I just think that his best plays are really impressive. And he really is like a true dominant outside receiver or like tracking to be that sort of guy and a lead that like that kind of is becoming the thing again is like you need some of those guys who can win outside the numbers and in big boy situations. I legitimately think he's just like really good player right now. And with very with bottom eight quarterback play, if you're being even generous and it's probably been worse than that and he's still producing. And to me, the thing that really jumps out is he does a little bit of everything already. Like the idea that coming into the league, I think that if you were down on a player of Denzel Boston's archetype and you wanted to kind of ping with a broad brush about what he was in college, you could have done the those guys who aren't really separators, like how many of them do actually have success in the league, yada, yada. He's not been that at all. Like he is a worthwhile intermediate target over the middle of the field. He's a vertical threat in a way that I think people might have had questions about like what the long speed would look like. I there's like to me, there's like a shades of Drake London, like sort of player to him with some like gas down the field. But I legitimately think he has a chance to be a really, really good player and is already productive in an objectively bad situation. And so I really do think that if they get even average quarterback play in there, we could see a tough 12-ish type receiver if things keep going in this direction. Like I legitimately believe that's a ceiling for him. The efficiency of the offense is worth bringing up like the the raw numbers don't blow you away. But given the circumstances in Cleveland, the consistency he's been producing with that it's worth mentioning that and it is impressive. Get your defensive rookie of the year, Derek. It's all you buddy. You're defensive rookie of the year for the first half of the season is who. This is where I will take an off-ball line maker, or Vell Reese is so damn good already man. Yeah, he's also my choice. He is everything you could have wanted him to be like. I just think that what he is as an athlete is truly special. And this is why like coming out of college when he was like this hybrid like is he a pass referee, is he an off-ball? It was part of me that was like he is such a phenomenal athlete. He can figure out anything. And I think it's funny. I think what's been so impressive to me when you watch him in the preseason, obviously, it's just preseason. He was a little cat chasing a laser because I think like it was like, yeah, of course this is going to be up to speed when you're first playing off-ball. It's a position that has notoriously tough development curve. But we're nine weeks into his season. And I don't really feel that way. Every now and then because you're a rookie. But like, I don't feel like he's a guy who's lost. I'm like, man, he is so buttoned up in terms of like his zone flow. He'll fall back into where he needs to be the way that he's taking on guards, the way that he's taking on pullers. I mean, there was a play in the Saints game. This was on a screen. There was about seven and a half minutes in the second quarter. They tried to throw like a little running back screen to the left. He explodes the left guard. And he doesn't even make the tackle. He just pushes the offensive lineman into the back and he trips over him. Like he just has a level of physicality, violence, speed, he's so instinctive. Like I really do think that he is a special football player in the making. It's really fun how similar his pro tape looks to his college tape where like nine out of 10 times would be like, okay, but you're not going to be able to just bow up guards like that and have it work out for you in the NFL. Well, our values might be the exception. He's my he's my choice too. I just love the fact that he's and similar to the federal conversation a little bit different. But when you think about the where the league is right now defensively. And the giants are one of these teams. The giants are a blitz heavy team. They are a blitz happy team on third down like they have one of the highest covers your rates in the entire NFL. They are weaponizing him as a past rusher in the way that you would want him to be weaponized. But not even just what's happening with him and the giant specifically, if you look at the broader league landscape, he's a perfect football player for this moment. Yes. Perfect. Like the idea that if we're going to be in this blitz heavy world, you have a guy who can play off ball who is a skilled and dangerous past rusher. And I think that's only going to get better over time. The giants didn't even figure out how often they wanted to be sending them until like week four. Like his numbers have doubled over the second month of the season in terms of going after the quarterback. And if you let you let's break down like the three sacks he had against the jets. The first one he gets untouched. He explodes Joe Milton. It's like all right. Well, that's play a lot of guys can make the third one.
He beats land in Dickerson one-on-one in like a true pass rush situation and so you have that part of it. And then you have a guy like Derek is saying that is a downhill bumper has incredible like athleticism, explosiveness, he's a great tackler. He is to me like a perfect expression of a modern second level defender and he's already really good. And I think too with his block take on here, he has to like just violence it people that I love. And he already has a really good job understanding to of which tool do I need right now. Do I need to back to this block? Do I need to get over the top? Do I need to go through this guy? Do I need to take back space? Do I need to slip this like I just think he has such a good understanding of what the moment needs. And then like you're saying to like he does a little bit of everything when they get in like short yardage, they just put him on the edge because he can set the edge and do that stuff for them. Obviously, they blitz him a ton. I think he's already like for a rookie, especially a pretty decent coverage player. There was actually a two minute play against Houston where he's in the A gap in one of those blitz. Look, he pops out and flies to the opposite hash and like gets a hand in the window. I'm like, he could kind of just do a little bit of everything. And the last thing I love, he runs his ass off. He will chase plays 20 yards down the field that he has no business being near. And that's one of those things is like, true, the offense gains 20 yards. They might have got 30 if he doesn't run down there and make those plays and it's just some of those little things like he is, you just feel the energy and like what he brings to your team every single way. It kind of reminds me of the T1000 when he runs, you remember, Terminator 2. I got a couple stats for you. So our Val is sitting on 68 tackles and four and a half sacks after eight games. The last players to finish with a hundred plus tackles and five plus sacks as rookies. Oddly enough, both happened in 2018, it was rookie Shaq Leonard and Rohquan Smith. Shaq Leonard was all pro and defensive rookie of the year in 2018. And the last rookie to finish with a hundred plus tackles and eight plus sacks Brian Erlocker. And also, pretty insane company, Reese is statistically on pace to match Lawrence Taylor's rookie season, not, not, you know, that's not a comparison. That's just a statistical fact there. The Brian Erlocker thing is, it feels right. Yeah. Like when you just think of the frame, the athleticism, the movement skills, like, it's funny because Erlocker was a tweener in that he was a college safety and Reese is a tweener in a different way. But they just like all time mutants, like, that's the type of players that we're talking about here. I think Reese's versatility and production, I wasn't even that torn about it when I made a choice, but I do want to say the other guy that plays at MetLife is having a really nice rookie year. Agreed. David Bailey has been awesome. His production lately, I think there was a lot of like cleanup effort plays early on. I think that now you're starting to see him really put it all together. There's like a true past Russia bent and coming around the edge. Some of the hand usage stuff has gotten really good recently. Like, if you watch what he was doing against the chiefs, like, there's a refinement already. And what coming into the league, like, he was a fastball, fireball pitcher. Like, that's what he was a Texas tech. And so seeing some of the actual nuance already started to come about in on top of the athleticism, the around the corner stuff and just the effort he brings to the position. I think it's really nice to see the other two other guys out there out. Jake Rodriguez is having a really nice season for the for the dolphins. I don't think he's been quite on the level of these other guys have been at. And then the other guy I would throw out there. I think that even if he's not playing as much by the end of this season, I he's going to be on a very short list of the defensive players from this draft that I would want moving forward is gay back is gay back is just a ball. Hell yeah. He's amazing. He is. So good. The guys we loved in the pre-draft process are all in through the first couple months. Cause like statistically, he doesn't really have the case like two and a half sacks or whatever that you don't like. He's giving us the problem. Yes. He just you, you note if you look for him on the field every play, you're like, Oh, he's just kind of like around the quarterback a lot. He's much more flexible than I thought he would be after watching him at Illinois. When you see the ground, that's what that's, that's all about. I have really, really enjoyed watching him and then the chances I've gotten to. I want to say really quickly, every single fan base with a rookie linebacker is going to think they're God deserves it by the way. So many styles, I think. Yeah. Pretty good. Like just, I have trotter has been awesome. Anthony Hill Jr., I think even for the Titans has been good. And then obviously the other guys we mentioned like Rodriguez and again, I don't think most of those guys are on the level of like Bayley or Reese, but like, this is like kind of one of the coolest land back classes in a while. The fact that there are this many rookies that are playing at average or above already is pretty phenomenal. It's really sick that they're living up to the hype because we were excited about them coming in. Let's get to the next one here. Protector of the year. Obviously, this is a new one we've had one year of this before, but if you are unfamiliar with the award, if you listen to this show, I doubt that you are the best offensive one. And we last year was Joe Tony, year two of this, Dave, what do you got for me? Your protector of the year half of the season is who I can't stand this category. Yeah, just there's like, there's at least three or four guys that I think have a really compelling case. To me, it's a two man race right now. I mean, the guy that I ultimately went with is who I think would win and it's Trent Williams. That's awesome. I think he's, I mean, he's the, he's the best guy doing it. He continues to be the best guy doing it. These eight pressures allowed one sack, which I think was to Zadaria Smith on a day where like nothing will it really went right for the 49ers? Their offense is incredible. So much of it runs behind him. So much of, I mean, Brock party is phenomenal and he'll come up in conversation soon. I'm sure. But so much of what Trent Williams is able to do for them just lifts Brock's floor at lifts the offensive floor. He's been doing it for 15 years and I can't believe he's like 38 years old. He is on an island in one-on-one situations at a, the rate that very few guys often tackles in the NFL. It's like a top three rate. And it's actually a, Derek and I were talking about this when we were talking about the Niners on the hangover. The way the Niners are approached their passing game is just drastically different than how we used to think about Shanahan offense. Like Shanahan offense is used to be play action, a lot of help for the tackles. Like it's not a situation where you're in a lot of true dropback one-on-one scenarios. Now they've gone away from, they've used more of it this year than they had over the last couple of years. But for the most part, they are not like a play action heavy team anymore. And so they are more of a dropback team. So you're putting your tackles in more one-on-one situations. He's been phenomenal in those one-on-one situations. And he's still the best run-blocking tackle in the league, potentially. It's like him and Darnell Wright. And so when you combine those two things together, it's crazy. Like, Amarius Mims, who might be your pick, I don't know. He is my pick. I will get to that in a minute. It's Amarius Mims has been unbelievable as a one-on-one pass protector this year. But I think Trent Williams has been in that same class as a one-on-one pass protector and is still an unbelievably dominant run-blocker. And so those two things and combinations to me, that's the reason why I think that he ultimately deserves it. I think if I were like, if I were trying to like forecast who is going to win it, it will probably be Trent, because I think that's just the way that he's playing right now. I mean, I think we talked about it on the hangover. Someone had like the goal on stuff that he was doing in that game, like he just, he can clear people out of the way in the way. The frequency with which he basically throws guys is jarring. Moves other 300 pound men completely out of the way. And so I think if you were doing like, in totality, I think Trent Williams is absolutely as deserving as anyone. I think I'm probably getting over my skis with Amarius Mims and like picking him because it's fun. But like, I do think that-- Oh, no. It's a flag crash. It's a man race. Those are the two men. It's also-- It's a mid-season award. Yeah. What has happened in the games that have been played so far? And I think what I would say, like obviously, Trent Williams is unbelievably like central to the way that the Niners can play offense. I do think, and we'll talk about this probably when we talk about MVP a little bit, the way that the bangles are allowed to play offense, where they are so much dropback, we're going to chuck it. We're going to do all this. You can kind of only do that if you have one of these tackles who you can just leave on an island and be like, we can forget about it. That guy's going to keep Joe protected. It's the exact same car we said we had about Wayne Johnson and the Eagles for like seven years. It's the same thing. And like, men's is probably not quite there in terms of the run-bocking as guys like, right or even like, Tristan Wurfs or Trent Williams, but like, one, I think he's still very good. And two, like-- He plays for the bangles. Who gets a shit about that? He's also just don't do as much of that. And so there's part of me that's like, well, if he played for the bills, wouldn't he probably just be like murdering people every play like if they wanted him to do that? And so that's a little bit of like theory. But I just think that what he's become is just one of the half dozen just set it and forget the tackles in the NFL. He's awesome. And when you look at the matchups he's had to like the gauntlet of players that he's had to play against this year, you had the week two games against the Texans where he was really, really good against William Anderson and Daniel Hunter. And I talked about this in the moment. The bangles when they were prepping for the Steelers, their first matchup this year, when they were going through like the plan for what they would have to do with T.J. But typically that is a, oh man, what are we going to do? Like how much extra help do we have to give? What do we have to get? How are we going to account for this person? And this year it was, eh, we're just going to leave one on one with the right tackle and be fine. Like that to reach that place with the guy that's this early in his career and feel comfortable doing it. He's done it against some of the most dangerous, like fear inducing ed rushers in the league for multiple different times this year. And I think he deserves so much credit for that tree beard. He's my number two. Emery's men's is my number two. I guess when I say I hate the category, I just feel bad that Tristan Worf's Penaisule and I'll continue to stump for Garrett Bulls as well. Like the idea that they're not even, they're fighting for bronze. It's just tough to swear. And I would get it if it frustrates you as a fan of one of those teams. It's just, it's a stacked category and only one guy gets to win. The other guy I would throw out, I don't think he's going to win it. just to go.
terms of acknowledging what certain units have felt like the players who either have gotten more shine or have, I don't think he's improved that much because he was already a good player. Zach Frazier is like somebody should recognize if we're doing the mid season all pro teams, he's the first team all pro at center. And so I wanted to say his name on this show. And if you're trying to like find who would be the interior guy who's going to at least be in the conversation by the end, it probably is Zach Frazier. They've been incredible. I think we should just have a Joe Moore award for the NFL. Yeah, like we just absolutely should have a Joe Moore award for the NFL. I've said it before, I think every position should have an award just like college football does. Like, but that's what we should have a unit one. No, no, I would love that. Yes, for the, for offensive lines, like, I would love if the Steelers offensive line, could I get a trophy at the end of this season? The Joe Moore trophy kicks ass. Yes, incredible. 300 pounds. Like the 2024 bucks offensive line should have like, yes, something we should have now. I hope that that's what they were. Is anybody going to complain if we like, why the into best interior offensive lineman, best interior defensive lineman, best edge, best offball linebacker, they do a whole, I guess we do have those in college. Like, there's a, there's a rooming 10 award that exists. And we do this big dumb award show every year. And then there's like six categories. Like, let's blow this thing out. Sickos like us would watch it. Why not? Hell not. I wouldn't watch the award show, but I'd be curious who would I would argue about the award in this. I'd be more excited if I thought I could see Zach Frazier get up and have to accept the trophy. That would be fun. All right, let's take a quick break and then we're going to come back with some heavy hitters. All right, assistant coach of the year. Derek, I'm going to let you kick this one off your assistant coach of the years. Who? I think this was the quickest answer to me. It's perfect. I 100% are what they are doing with. And I know that there are good players on the Vikings, defensively cashmints and incredible injury bank ankle Dallas Turner. A lot of the other like elite defenses right now have guys who are like consistent all pros, potential Hall of Famers and stuff like that. What the Brian Flores thing has become with like three, four years of developing a lot of these guys in the system, getting the communication to a spot that is rare and then being able to operate in a way that like over my lifetime in like, I don't know about NFL history. I don't know if we have blitz numbers for the 1980s or whatever. We don't. But like for what I've been able to ever see a football, they are doing something that I've never seen before and doing it at an exceptional level. I kind of think it has to be Brian Flores. Yeah, I people when we talked about the Vikings, when we said that, people were talking about buddy Ryan and like the way that the Bears would play, she's like it's a different sport. Like it's things are so different now in so many different ways. And I just think that the elements of how they're approaching this and just the flexibility of the players like it's not just the blitz rates like the blitz rates are not what sticks out about this. I'm sure there are teams that have blitzed at that level in different errors of football. But like what the system overall is and how fit it is for the way the modern game is being played and how much trouble it's giving people. My favorite part is when you watch these teams, the Lions and the Bills and Back to Back Weeks, okay? Bulletproof top seven offenses, even if you're not being discerning. Bulletproof top seven offenses in the NFL, the creativity and ingenuity necessary to get first downs against this team. Like the fact that even the best offenses in the league have essentially conceded. We can't just line up and play. We can't do it. That to me is all you need to know about how hard it is, how hard he is making it on the teams he is playing against weekend and week out. Like you said, without this like high level of elite talent, if you look at this team, if you look at it, it's crazy. Here, I'm going to list off the starting 11 for the Minnesota Vikings, the draft position that was used to find these players. Tyrion Dock, Ingraham Dockins, fifth round pick in 2025, Levi Drager Rodriguez, seventh round pick in 2024, Jalen Redmond Street free agent, Dallas Turner, first round pick, Eric Wilson, under Eric Wilson, unrestricted free agent, Blake Cashman free agent, Andrew Bankingel free agent, Isaiah Rogers free agent. Harris's fifth was the first round pick in 2012 and was not on the team before the season started. Theo Jackson was a, I think a waiver claim by Ramurfi was a free agent, Josh Mattelis was a sixth round pick in 2020. And so it's made up of mostly free agents and guys who were like late round picks. And so you think, Oh, well, maybe they're spending a lot on the defense. Seventh, they are 25th in the NFL in defensive spending this year. I was going to say, what's the biggest to like, what's the biggest contract on the Vikings defense? That is not an extension that the Vikings signed the guy to for excelling. You know, like Eric Wilson's on a pretty big deal right now, but that's not how it started. But even Eric, Eric Wilson's deal is, Eric Wilson's deal is not like a huge contract boss. No, but it's, it's not nothing either. Eric Wilson's on a three year 22 and a half million dollar deal. He's making seven million hours a year. They get out of them, but they, they brought him on for pennies. That's, that's yeah, they're like Kyle Van Noy is a member of this team, like signed off the street. Like what he has been able to do with this group of players is insane. It we, Derek and I were talking about this the other night, defense at a certain point. You can do all the funky shit that you want to at some point along the process. You were going to feel the lack of high end talent. You were going to feel the lack of superstars on that side of the ball over a 17 game season. The Vikings and in their defense, they have superstar level players, right? Like Blake Cashman has been unbelievably impactful. If you took all 11 players in the Vikings, all 15 contributors and you put them in a different situation. How many superstar players would there be? Not a whole lot. I think maybe probably zero. Like Jalen Redmond to me is a really, really good player. I think that he could play in any defense. Other than that, like Dallas Turner might be getting there, but it's just the uniqueness of the situation. It's hard to say. It gets more free runs than like any other password for the NFL. I just think that what he is doing, considering the pieces that have been given to him is unbelievable. And the league has like bent to his image. Like everybody's blitzing more because they realize that this is kind of what you have to do right now. And even more specifically, teams weren't really running that many of these like two high zone pressures until Flores really turned it up in 2024. And obviously that's, you know, three years ago. That's not what the words about, but like him and to a different degree like Steve Svagnolo kind of ushered in like this newer era of how teams are blitzing right now. And so yeah, this is kind of been amazing what he's been able to do at every part of this stop. But the fact that it's reached even this level now is just insane. The only other note I would add is of the top 10 defenses by DVOA right now. Six have offenses that are in the top half of the league. The Vikings are getting zero benefit of complimentary football right now. And of the four teams in the bottom half in offensive DVOA that have top 10 defenses. Seattle 19th and offensive DVOA Atlanta 21st Tampa 23rd. Seattle's five and four on the other two or three games below 500. The Vikings are six and two. Six and two with like Will Reichard's the only guy giving them any help on a consistent basis. I think the brand for us to use a clear winner. I will say this is the category for wish I had the most names because I think there have been so many awesome assistant coaches in the offensive guys. I did want to ask that. So in the offense, it was mostly defensive guys. The two offensive guys I would throw out there. And I don't think they're in the same level as the defensive guys that are worth mentioning. We've talked about bread. It's a lot. They've fallen off a little bit. I think what bread is a day, especially over the first like six weeks of the season. I was really impressed with the job he was doing in Carolina. I think Drew Petzing has been really really good for the offensive name I have where I was like, he belongs somewhere in this category of five or six guys. So those are the two offensive guys I had. I would have them probably a step down because I think if I think Florida is in a tier of his own for this award specifically. I personally the next tier down from that. I think the two guys I would probably put in there Jonathan Ganon. Jonathan Ganon has done an insane job with the Packers defense this year. Like this being a unit where we're all kind of like, I don't know. And then they're just a bulletproof top five defense. Like it was it is not smoking mirrors, man. Like they are really, really good. And they're about to get micro Parsons back. And if we're doing like relative to expectation, it's like some of the other names on here. Like we could have thought that Brian four is just going to be great. I was like a little iffy on the talent. But we know that he can do this. Drew Petzing in the lines offense. We were like, yeah, if they're just a little bit better, the offense is going to be crazy. Patrick Graham with the sealers. I think we were excited about. I think he's on my list too. Yep. To me, like second and third is Dennis Allen. And it's like, yeah, Dennis Allen has called crazy stuff before and made defenses better than they deserve to be. Jonathan Ganon was truly like a, I have no idea what I'm supposed to believe that this defense is even going to look like let alone like how well they will play behind him. I JG deserves so much credit for what they've done for like keeping that team afloat a little bit as the offense was trying to figure itself out. Like it, I blown away by the job that he has done. So he's probably the next, the first name on the second tier guys out throughout you mentioned Patrick Graham. He was on my list. Dennis Allen is on my list. That's probably like tier two and Kampineelay out there when they're saying Kampinelli just, he's just doing what he did last year. Exactly. He was my assistant coach to your last year. And so I picked him last year because I was just so impressed by what they were doing. The way they play defense down there is just unbelievably cool. It's like such a great blend of so many different influences. I love watching them play. And we mentioned Dennis Allen. The two other guys I would throw out. Vance Joseph continues to be incredibly good in Denver. Incredibly good. And I really
really like the job that Reem Morris has done in San Francisco. I just think that the layers he has added to that defensive system, we talk about right for the modern brown version of the NFL, like the correct modernization and iteration of that, like, four down attack front system that we know really well, they started doing in Atlanta, right? And so, like, he was, and I think Kyle deserves credit for this, which we'll get to in a second. Kyle deserves credit for this because I think that, all right, how do I take a system that if we continue doing it the same way over and over and over again, is ultimately going to get stale, is ultimately going to be something that people can pick on. The Falcons already did that last year, like, Obrich had really started modernizing those ideas and twisting them a little bit. And so trying to tap Reem, who was there with Jeff Obrich last year to do that for your defense, I just think is a, we should have maybe thought about that in the moment, but it was, it, it's worked out so, so well. So those are, again, that's like eight names and I don't think that's any like pity names. We're not like throwing a bone to anybody there, like all of those guys probably deserve mention. It's really cool that it's so defense heavy. Yeah. Everybody falls in love with the play callers every year, but the defensive assistants have been the story of the first half of the year. They really happen. That is a hundred percent true. I absolutely agree with that. All right. Let's get to the bigger one here. Coach of the year, Dave, what do you got for me? Here comes my curve ball. This is a mid season award. I'm not forecasting what's going to happen. I would guess the trend line is suggesting that this team, like this coach won't be in the conversation by the end of the year. But if I'm handing it out for the first eight or nine weeks, my choice is Clint Kubiak. I'm just blown away by this. All right. Okay. I love it because like the, we can talk about the run game. Maybe some of that is his fault. Some of it is not that offensive line is. It's not good. The fact that they've made the passing game what it's been despite that is pretty phenomenal. This is basically and the defense has been back. This is the same team. I know Tyler Linderbaum is there, but this isn't that good. He hasn't been that good. This is the same team as the one that barely looked like an NFL universe. Yeah. And that's a great point. Kirk Cousins was an afterthought. He's 24th in EPA per play during his time in Atlanta. Nobody thought that this was a meaningful thing that was happening for the loss of Vegas Raiders. And I think some people would say, well, Gina was really bad last year, but we see that Gina. You don't play. Yeah. Gina can still play. Last year, the Raiders were 31st and team DVOA 31st and offensive DVOA 31st and EPA per play dead last and scoring through nine games right now. They're 22nd and team DVOA 15th top half of the league in offensive DVOA 16th and EPA per play. And it's only that low because they can't run the ball at all. Yeah. So the offensive line is no better. And ashton genty, unfortunately, is not really given you anything more than what he did as a rookie. They're top 10 in past EPA. They're 11th and past DVOA. They're better in overall DVOA than the New York Giants who are leading their division. They have a 15% explosive play rate, which is top 10 in the NFL. They're one of only two teams in the top 10 that is not above 500. Kirk Cousins was 10th in EPA per dropback as a Raider. It was his best EPA per play since 19, uh, since 2019 when he was with Minnesota. Cousins was not good in Atlanta, Clint Kubiak, and like, and like, this is a overall. This is not a good team. They're not going to go to the playoffs for Nando Mendoza's taking over. Hopefully, it's very exciting, but it might not be who the hell knows. But this was a team with zero expectations. Their preseason overrunner was five and a half wins. And they're sitting at four at the midway point of the season. They have been an enjoyable watch. The defense was fun and surprising for at least a few weeks before it kind of started to fall off. And Kirk in the offense has been good. Brock Bowers has been exactly what you want him to be. And so Clint Kubiak showed up after doing what he did in Seattle. And by the way, how much to the Seahawks probably miss Clint Kubiak right now. And he's doing exactly what you wanted him to. And the Raiders have been a very pleasant surprise. There are many other coaches who are deserving who will win this award. Clint Kubiak will not win it. But at the midpoint of the season, I think he's very deserving and I think it's worth shouting out. Less for Nando Mendoza looks incredible. I mean, a Fernando, if Fernando looks incredible out of the box, then all bets are off. But I'm guessing that the Raiders are going to continue to come down to earth. Who's the coach to your last year? My rival. Mike Faible. Yeah. Which makes sense. I was just curious. I was like, I remember the conversations. It's a really, really good answer. Yeah. I don't really, it's, it depends on what you, and this is always the case with Coach of the year. It depends on what you want from the award. And if you're, if your view of the award is who is doing the best coaching job with the pieces that he is given as a head coach, I think you can make an argument that Clint Kubiak is on the shortlist of those guys for exactly the reason that you're saying. The team isn't really that much different. It's, Spencer Burford is not the reason that the, the Viking or the Raiders have gone from a, like, awful, awful worst in the league offense to a top 11 passing, passing offense. Brock Fowars is great. The receivers have been exactly as bad as we were worried about. Oh, I don't know, man. Trade soccer can play. I'm not going to hear that. Fine. The receiving core is not amazing. No, no. No. And the running game is DOA. And this, like I've had fun watching like every Raiders game this year. Who would have thought? I think a great, great job on the higher, even if, even if Clint Kubiak doesn't win the award. I get this. And I completely understand where you're coming from. I don't have a ton of pushback. He's done a really, really good job. I think that if I'm like actually trying to pull coals in it, which isn't really worth doing, he is responsible for some of their own game issues. He is responsible for some of the staff issues, like, but it's year one, like that's, those are things they're going to tweak heading into year two. If I were a Raider fan in terms of the results that we've seen on the field, the way they handle the quarterback situation, how good I would feel about putting Fernando into the situation they're about to put him in. That so much of that is Clint Kubiak. He deserves so much credit for us feeling that way about this version of the Raiders compared to what they felt like a year ago. And so it's a really good answer. Derek, your coach of the year for 2026 so far as who? Maybe this is just because of how I felt about them going into the season, but to me, it's caution and to me, to me, it's caution and the offense. Why does everybody want to vote for Kyle now? And the job he did last year was even more masterful. I don't agree. But here's, I think in terms of, in terms of like, they won more games last year, well, in terms of like making shit work for like, obviously, they had a ton of issues, but like, and that night, our team was good. That night, our team did not feel like they were going to like win the super exactly. And they were beat to shit, but they were falling apart, but they're falling apart again. They have no receivers, like all of their receivers have not played this year for the most part. Every single notable receiver on this team has missed at least a couple of games. Obviously, Pure Sal hasn't played, dribbling hasn't played, debos missed a lot of games. Mike Evans hasn't played recently. They're having to trade for Keenan Allen, who is like, not that useful of an NFL player anymore, but they just need bodies. Brandon Cokes is catching like opening drive passes for them, and they're still incredible. The offensive line also, I do think this is where he deserves credit. This is basically the offensive line they played with last year. The offensive line in run game looks way better than that is the reason to me. Like Trent is still playing obviously at an incredibly high level, but the rest of the offensive line is a seventh round pick left guard, Jake Brindell, the center. I think he's playing his best ball that he's ever played. Who needs a third round pick has taken a step and then Colton McHivitz with a fifth round pick a while ago. Like, these are not premium, premium players, and they have elevated to a completely different level. Part of that's having Kettleback in terms of the run game stuff, but like, I do think that the way it's constructed in the way that those guys are playing right now is unbelievable. In terms of what he's doing specifically, the offense is as forward thinking as you end unique as any in the end of the week, we talked about it on Monday. I like it all the five out that they play like the spacing in the offense, the way that the quarterback is seeing it, like how Kyle Shanahan is doing this again with the receivers that's like in and out of the lineup every single week, I think is unbelievable. The 2023 team was statistically one of the best offenses of all time, right? If you just look at the pure efficiency numbers, in my, in my opinion, what we are watching right now, considering all the injuries that they've had to endure, okay? The San Francisco 49ers, the 2026 diners through eight games have a 51% offensive success rate. That is the highest rate of the next gen era. It's 11 seasons. They have the highest offensive success rate. They are number one in passing success rate, they are number one in rushing success rate. Who is the wide receiver on the San Francisco 49ers is sure that it's played the most steps? Can you tell me right now? Played the most. Played the most. Oh my God. No, my God. It's Watkins. Jordan Watkins. Yeah. Didn't you mention them? Yeah. The other, the other wide receivers on this team that have played 150 snaps. Mike Evans, Debo Samuel and Jacob Cowling. They have the best offense of the last 11 years. And specifically with the passing offense, pretty success rate right now, it is like up there again. I said this on the Sunday show. It's up there with like 07 Brady, 2011 breeze, 2020 Alan, 2004 Peyton, like they're, it's all time passing offense right now. I want to be really clear, Kyle Shanahan is overdue to win this award. And if we're going to vote for him this year, if he finally gets it this year, it'll be well deserved. And it's criminal that he doesn't have one yet. They were in the position to win 12 games last year, despite Brock Purdy missing eight games. And Fred Warner was out for the year and Nick Bosa was out for the year. Don't give me all that stuff is good and true. I thought what he did.
did getting to 12 wins last year was fucking incredible. And he finished third in his division. And it got overlooked. And now the Niners are first in their division. And that is, that's great. The guy about wins and losses to me. That's like it. I feel like the thought about wins and losses. I trust that that's true for you. But in general, I like, you should be able to win this award, finishing third in your division. If they were six and three right now, he would still be my answer if the offense was looking like this. And because actually it's what you said a little bit at the top where like coach of the year, I think is one of those where it's like, what are you picking for? I think I've come closer to the fact of like the coach that is like coaching the best team. Like I voted for Mike McDonald at the end last year because the way that the job that they were doing as an overall. And I think that's totally reasonable. That's kind of where I landed with the award in general. I think it's, it's on a bunch of different levels to me. Again, I think that the fact that this offense statistically is the best one that he has ever coached in San Francisco through the first a weeks of the season, considering the injuries. The 2003 team was the monsters. This is not that like they still have like George Kiddles, an amazing player. The fact that he came back. This trick is amazing. CFC is still a really good player, but he's not the player he was three years ago. And Trent Williams is obviously hyper elite. But the idea, that team, when D 23 debos, different than this, they had brand and I yuk playing it like an all pro level. They don't have that stuff right now. And they're still doing this. I said this on Monday. And if you didn't listen to hangover, if you've already listened to hangover, I'm sorry, but I'm going to do the whole spiel again. What Derek is saying about the construction of the offense and what it looks like and what the, how it is built. He is bending the sport to his will. Like what they have been able to do by having this run game with this passing game, Brock party. And that passing game is the most efficient passing game in the NFL. They face the highest rate of base defense in football and the highest rate of light boxes or the lowest rate of light boxes in the NFL because of what the run game is him going into the lab this spring and being like this. I'm gonna have the best run game in the league again because I want to. And then doing it is crazy. I think right now Kyle Shanahan is the best offensive coach of his generation. He's one of the best offensive coaches of all time full stop. This is the greatest painting he has ever ever painted. Like this is him at the ultimate apex, what we have seen from him with what they did with the run game in the off season and what this thing has looked like. We made the joke before. It's the Iron Man thing. It's like he built this thing in a cave with Jordan Watkins. Like it's crazy. What they are doing right now. Like I cannot get over it. It's unbelievable. And the last wrinkle on this we said it before where he morris was such a great choice to be like to come in and be the defensive coordinator for like this moment and like the way that they've diversified certain things about who they are, the five down front stuff, the pressures, like every tweak that they've made on that side of the ball is met for this moment along with getting their guys back. And so listen, I I was an early adopter. I was the driver of the Kyle Shanahan train a decade ago. Like I've been here for a long time. I right now what we are watching to me is the most impressive job he's ever done. You're not going to get any pushback for me on the job that he's done. I just thought he should have won last year. And I thought being above average with what was left to him last year was incredible. But I think the argument is like he might have less to work with now. Obviously, pretty healthy. But I think he has as little to work with now and the offense is way better. I don't think it's the same. It's it's it's you're proud. The defense was part of him more last year. But it's true. It's true. I just I don't know. I I do think that like I would love to ask Kyle that. I would love to ask true. Do you feel right now as opposed to a year ago at this time? And because again, I do think I've more shifted my thinking to this award of just like who is doing the like who is coaching the best team in the NFL? Because when we look at almost all of the other words, that's what it is. Yeah. Who is the best defensive player? But I think that was the best offensive player. But the complication with this is talent drives so much of it. I think that you can't do it without talent. And like and what Dave's answer is is like who is doing the best with the least? To me, it's not who's overachieving the most compared to previous and expectations. That's how it's about. Like I picked Brian Dable in 2021 because I thought he was doing the most with the least that year with that offense. It didn't wasn't sustainable, obviously. But like that's a way of doing it. But I just think the answer to me is you have a level of talent. Okay. How much is that talent being maximized? What sort of multiplier are you for the talent that you are being given? Mike McDonald had a shitload of defensive talent last year. He is still the biggest he was the biggest maximizer of talent. Like I think that's it. And that's there's no way to measure that because there's no objection. There's no there's no objective measure of the talent. But I still think that's the way I look at it. I think in general voting for this stuff for this award in particular is always so flawed. And like, I mean, it's insane that Andy Reid never won coach of the year during the peak of the chance. I don't care how good Patrick Mahomes is. It's insane that Kyle Shanahan would be winning his first coach of the year. So if this is the performance that gets the trophy on his shelf, no, fine by me, no argument here. You're just saying he should have two in a row basically. Yeah. Yeah. Or or. And I'm not saying this is why y'all are doing that. But if he had one last year, then you wouldn't feel pressure to vote for him to do to to win at this year. I legitimately just what he's doing the shares more impressive. I just think what he's doing this year is more impressive than we did last year. Like, I think that for Derek's like, I think Mike McDonald's, I don't know. I can't remember. I think I picked mine with all two last year. But even if I didn't like, I understand why that would be the case. It's a very similar thought process for Shanahan right now. I'm not pushing back on the on the opinion at all. Mainly just the methodology of how we vote for coach. The other one we should mention before. Oh, there's five. There's a bunch of guys. If we're doing like overall like coaching the best team in football, maybe Liam Cohen in the Jaguars like he's the next name on my list. They what they're doing. If they get if for the reasons that you're stating, like we just don't award to these types of coaches very often, they gave it to Liam Cohen this year. I wouldn't like be breaking down the doors of the NFL offices in Park Avenue. Like I like I'd be fine if Liam Cohen won this award. Liam Cohen is on this to me. Ben Johnson, I think should be mentioned here. I think John Harball has done a remarkable job with the giants. And to me, it's like in a different way than we typically award coach of the year, like the way they assembled the staff. How well that is going. Like I just am so impressed by what John Harball has done is a head football coach this year. Dan Campbell continues to be a very good coach. In the fact that he is he's one, he won one of these. Did you not or wasn't a KOC one. I know Dan Campbell should have. Yeah, Dan Campbell's never won. It's crazy. The other and the other guy I'll throw out. Because I genuinely do believe what he is doing is super, super impressive because he is inseptive to quarterback into playing actual football and the offense is watchable. Mike McCarthy has done a really good job with the Pittsburgh Steelers this year. I like I I want that on record. That's the most boring pick, but it's like they are legitimately like better and more interesting that team has any right to be like they nailed like the DC hires exactly like an exact gram. Like that's a huge part of the offensive line that like I know they just max in ultra this year, but like a lot of the same pieces are there. And they have gone from like talented offensive line that we believe in but haven't quite taken the step to like, oh they're just an ooking like every team that they play now. I don't feel like stepping up on my soap box right now, but like Mike McCarthy is good at his job. There's probably a ceiling there. But I mean, look at look at the last two years in Dallas as opposed to the consistency that they operated with when Dak Prescott was healthy in Dallas. So he's he's not the best coach in the league and and his Dallas teams had a very firm ceiling. That is all fair, but there's a consistency and an approach there that you can't deny. Yeah, he's I think he's done a really good job. So those are like the five guys that I would probably throw out. All right, Derek your MVP for the first half of the 2026 season is who think that there are five or six guys we're going to talk about. It's means Josh Allen still. I have I think he is players. I think Josh Allen. These are really just name some guys shows. Yeah. And that's fine. I I still think that Josh Allen and like MVP, I think is always one that's a little bit hard to untangle. Like what exactly are you voting for is it the most productive guys that the guy who's carrying the highest burden, blah, blah, blah, blah. To me, there is still just an element of that team gets away with so much because of what he can do. Yeah, like even recency bias, the like me see him. Obviously, he's got a couple of bad plays in it because it's brown for us and that team is insane. They can only get away with what they get away. Like him making the four words throw to Latu in the back of the end zone where he's just like finding time and just chucking it to the back line to special football play. He leads the league and break your clipboard players. Yes. And he's there are other quarterbacks who do some cool stuff, but he just has the highest volume of those the Rams game. He he had no right to win that game, being what he did doing what he did with his legs, but he is a special player in terms of just the different ways that I think that he can find and allow this team to win football games with. I know that he is supported by the run game in the offensive line or obviously exceptional. I think part of the offensive line ecosystem in terms of like pass protection. Like is he definitely talked about. Yes. And but this is still like a pass catching unit that is like incomplete. They trade for DJ more, but he has been in and out of the line, but not been particularly productive when he's there. The bills pass catchers this year with 20 catches in 300 yards are Dalton King Cage who did like most of that the first two weeks. Khalil Shakir and Keon Coleman. And they are still operating like one of the best offenses. Are you we still the best offense in the NFL? And I even think like in some ways, the offensive line like they were shuffling guys around. Like I think Keon Dawkins has not been quite what he used. Spencer Brown's been hurt. Yeah. That's Brown's been hurt. Yeah. The left guard, they were putting in a new guy in the lineup. Like the fact that they have withstood all of this and he is still just a player that almost every game is a complete force. It's hard for me to go any other way. Like I still think that he is just an unbelievable football.
popular. There's a clear methodology divide when we do these shows, which I think is really interesting. Oh, it's because it's exactly. It's how you see the award. I don't disagree with anything that Derrick's. I don't disagree with it at all. I just want to have five players. Somebody could pick and I'd be like, Oh, why not? The idea that Josh Allen is the best football player in the world. And that he is asked to do so much lifting for his team, even if they are able to lean on the run game. But here's the other thing I would throw out. I was looking to stop as you were talking just because I was I was curious about it. So yes. So the bills, obviously, you know, they're they lean on the run game. They are a run heavy team. It is like the engine of how the offense works. But if you simply look at running back runs this season, the bills this year are just one, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight. They're ninth in running in rushing success rate on running back runs purely. If you take out, if you make it for all positions, they go to fifth, yeah, because of what he does. And they right now have negative rushing EPA total. If you include all positions, it's 20. Because his scrambles are, yeah, I would just have for that. It's the ramp team, by the way. But not even his scrambles, like, they just make it make him a one man off it. How many rushing touchdowns does he have this year? It's something stupid. They have 17 is a team. I think he I want to say he's got. Well, because that's the thing. He doesn't have that many passing touchdowns right now, but he has a touchdowns because he has like 10 rush. He's quietly having a Jalen hertsy in season, where he's, yeah, Mike has got like nine rushing touchdowns. I the idea that Josh Allen is still is yet again the best football player in the world. And that's why he's the MVP. You'll hear no argument from me. I push back from me. I just I have a different answer in part because like, I want to make a different argument. You know, like that's kind of where I am with it. What's your answer? I picked Jordan love. I love that. I also picked Jordan love. I pick Jordan love. That is shocking to me. You get you went against Warner and against Jordan love. Who the hell even are you? I don't know. I we've talked so much about the ecosystem that the packers are playing in right now. And just what is on the quarterback? Yeah. And this is a team with like a 30% rushing success rate. They cannot run the football like they they just cannot do it. And the offensive line is in tatters. You want some numbers? So I had a I had a short list of guys I wanted to talk about. I was curious about offensive line combinations in particular Cincinnati Bengals preferred O line group has played 97% of their offensive snaps. The Niners 92% the bills been banged up 55% the Jags again Anton Harrison banged up 50% the Green Bay Packers offense offensive line of choice has played 34% of their. And even that like they threw some bullshit at it in week three. I'm still not even sure they know what their lineup of choices. They're 32 in EPA per rush 28 and rushing success rate. All the other teams I just mentioned are top five top 10 in those categories except the Bengals who are still like middle of the pack in in the rushing numbers. The packers are firmly one of the worst running teams in the NFL. They've got they've had a nothing offensive line and a nothing running game. And Jordan love is doing what he's doing. That that was my entire premise for this. The past catchers are really good. They're not good enough to ding me for like what Green Bay leads the NFL and drops by a lot. But that's my only thing that that is I group that but like this is anecdotal. But I do think there's probably some true to it every time Matthew Golden drops a ball. He catches an explosive on the next play. That is so anecdotally true. Doesn't change the fact that they've dropped 25 passes through the first half of the season. The numbers would look a little cleaner if they just weren't doing that. What he is doing and some listen. I know that we I am guilty of this and I will speak for the rest of the football internet cognizant in saying that they are also guilty of this. There are times where we make aesthetic choices and arguments as it relates to quarterback play specifically and Jordan love is the next guy up and that entire **** did a bullshit. But it is not just that. It's not just like big arm quarterback throwball far. The way he is playing is the way they need to play. They they don't have another option like they have to play that way because they can't sustain drives. And so him doing what he is doing and pushing the ball down the field. It is not only a cool way to play. There is utility in playing that way when you're constructed the way that their constructs he has to do it. And the stat I threw out on the preview show last week. The idea that they lead the league and quick pressures allowed. And he has fifth in the NFL and pressure to saturate should be untenable. Should be impossible to do that. The comparison I made when I was talking about with Nate yesterday is I've used the term shot making a lot which are in love. Like that's what I watch him when I watch it happen. It's in me. It's like when you watched like Kevin Durant go to work at the top of the key where it's like all these like leaners and fadeaways and like the way that the shot to get off despite what is happening around him is like a singular talent. And to me Jordan love has a football version of that as a quarterback. And we have seen like the purest expression of that ability specifically this year. And I just don't know what other quarterback in those circumstances would be able to do what he has been doing. It's it really is like peak mames Josh Allen could probably figure something up. But even like the way that they're doing it. It's the way he does it. It's different. Yes. It's the way like his ability to like these little tiny like resets or hops in the pocket where he's buying like just a little sliver of space and pushing the ball 50 yards down field accurately consistently. And that is the foundation of the offense should not be possible. Like Josh Allen is a very resilient thrower. He can handle guys like who are near him. He can throw through contact all this other stuff. Jordan love is a very just like flexible in terms of how he's getting to this spot. Yes. He really is like a really impressive basketball player. And like the deep ball stuff. It's not like they're just chucking go balls or he's just like throwing it into triple coverage and getting lucky. Like these are 20 out 20 yard corner outs 15 yard comebacks. He's throwing a 22 yard dig to like John Michael Stewart to vaude like he's just the way that they are operating right now is pretty unique to the sport. Like they are truly one of one. And the fact that they're not this would be impressive if he was like producing like the 12th best quarterback in the league. It would be like wow they're really getting away with it. He is playing at like a top five level right now. And the only reason I didn't pick him. Like I think if I was trying to forecast who might win it at the end, I would probably pick Jordan love like if this can continue. If I'm just saying what is the first nine weeks looks like, I think I'm still giving it to Josh Allen, but like Jordan love would do my second. So I think probably fair. I think I feel opposite just because and I hope I'm wrong. I love watching love play. But if I had to guess, Jordan love maintaining at this level doing this much of it on his own for 10 more weeks. Sounds really, really difficult. Whereas if we look up in mid January and Josh Allen's numbers are just overwhelming. Am I supposed to be surprised by that? I just think that like production wise with where love is at right now. And honestly, this changes if you remove like the first three weeks of the season where they were playing with like randoms at guard. He production wise, he's not what an MVP should be, but that's why I'm saying like at the end, I'm pretty sure he's going to get there. If you remove the first three weeks, he absolutely. Yeah, he is. That's what he has. I mean, they're right. But when we're only talking about nine weeks, like that does matter. Yeah. Again, I think a lot of that is like played exceptionally well in that Vikings game for three and a half quarters until the wave kind of just hit him. And so again, I think he's obviously been exceptional, but like this is almost splitting hairs to me. Jordan love since week three. It's average 10.1 area. It's per target per attempt. And he has the lowest time to throw in the league. The other quarterbacks who have been possible. If you look at this over the last two years, the other guys who are playing that way, it was like Marcus Marriota being like, I don't care what happens on plays or like Anthony Richardson and he got it in the game. And those that was truly like, I don't know what I'm doing or don't care what I'm doing. I'm just going to throw it. This is Jordan love like seeing into the matrix and making throws. I'm glad you brought up Marcus Marriota saying, I don't care because the meme is that Jordan love does stupid shit. And that is on some degree true because he's just willing to try shit and he has to. But for people who think that that is his game, he's got a better turnover worthy play rate right now than Josh and Trevor. Like like his it's 3.8. It's not low, but it is more than acceptable for somebody who is doing this amount of lifting for his offense. You got to crack a couple of eggs to make an omelets. Sorry about it. These are our two picks. You said by the end of the year, you'll look up and you think Josh I want to be the MVP. I think by the end of the year, Joe burrow will be the MVP of the league. That is also and I will be very okay with that. If I had to bet money on the MVP right now, Josh and burrow would probably be I'd probably put money on both of them and just hedge, but yeah. I want to be where's my where's my ice okay? I want to be you bangle spans. Okay. We've talked so much about Joe burrow this year. And I know all of you are probably losing your minds right now. Joe burrow has been incredible. If you were the first three weeks of his season, his numbers are great. It's 23 touchdowns since the start of October. And I get the receivers are really good. And I think honestly, the tipping point for me with the burrow and love thing is that the the Mary Smith conversation that we had and like the overall past protection quality for the Bengals is just better than it's been for the Packers this year. And so I think playing the way the Packers are playing with the state of their offensive line is just a bigger burden than what Joe burrow has had to lift in that area specifically. But what Joe burrow has done this year, the game that Joe burrow is playing. We talked about it on Sunday. It like he's making the NFL games feel like 2019 LSU games. It's crazy. The level that Joe burrow is playing at. He would be a deserving MVP choice right now. I think if you may, if you said right now, if you pick Joe burrow, which I thought you might, I would have been like, great. Zero pushback. If Joe burrows your MVP, I'm a completely faric over here picking again.
Jordan love and I'm picking against Joe burrow. What's going on? So Joe burrow is absolutely his having he is having an MVP caliber season. I do think by the end of the year, Joe burrow will probably be the MVP of the league because he's going to throw for 5,200 yards and 50 touchdowns. And I also think if you're trying to make the case of like we're not we're not trying to forecast us on the point of the show necessarily. But if you are, it's like what they're doing weirdly feels the most stable because I think there's always just an inherent up and down with the way that Josh Allen might play sometimes. And what the what the Packers are doing and what Jordan loves doing is obviously incredible. You can still see a world where like eventually this gets to them. Yes, I kind of expect it to right that he's walking a tightrope, but that's why he's might play that's why it's impressive. But you can see that. Yes, where it's like I washed the bangles and I'm like, maybe it would, but like the offensive line is now it feels very sustainable. It's been as good as it ever been. It feels frighteningly sustainable. The past catch, the two past catchers are like, short of Marvin Harrison and Reggie Wayne, like the best of my lifetime. Like they are playing at an incredible level. And again, like I do think it's worth reiterating the offensive line thing. And this is not to take away from Joe burrow. What Joe burrow was doing two, three years ago in the offensive line was not impressive. Was not good was impressive for a different reason. The fact that now he is under much less the rest than ever and really gets to just like see everything and pick defenses apart in this way. It's pretty cool to watch, especially with the way that these two guys are, but even like his latent down creation is it's ever been like the climbing the pocket plays that he is making. He is playing an exceptional level. Brock party. If you want to pick Brock parties, you're MVP. I'm fine with that. I've been a place now. I've said this a bunch of times. I don't know if Brock party could do this at this level, other places. I don't know how many people could do this for the Niners to the degree that Brock party is. He's also, you know what I've got with that. He's never going to have to know. But to me, I would turn it on its head like could Brock party do what Jordan love is doing with Packers? No. Could Jordan love be doing what Brock party is doing in San Francisco? I don't know. Like he is a perfect player for what the San Francisco 49ers offense is supposed to be. He is so, so good at the version of quarterback because he is being asked to play within that offense. And that's not to call him a system player. He does plenty of stuff outside the system. He's a credible creator. Like I Brock party. If that, if he was your MVP, I'd be totally fine with that. If you want to pick Trevor Lawrence, fine. I think that he's being asked to do a little bit less like the idea that they can win blowout games. Rethrows it all 12 times. It's just a little bit tougher. But getting pulled in the fourth quarter is not great for your MVP candidate. He's going to say he is, he's like, he's worth mentioning though. He absolutely isn't. I think he's playing like out of his mind. I weirdly think he's going to get like drown out because there's so many other. Yes, you just have like incredible cases, but he won it next year. Exactly. Like he's, he's still playing of that level. I just like, I think Joburo narratively, like what Jordan love is doing. Josh Allen, it just weirdly feels like he's going to get drown out. But like statistically, he's playing as well as any MVP before. Like he's awesome. Drake may still deserve as much in this conversation for like what he has done with an offense that's completely banged up. The two other guys I would throw out since week three. Okay. Everything that we've just said about the bank, the packers, the bangles, they're passing games. Since week three, who leads the league and dropback? Any paper dropback? Do you know? It is C.J. Stratt. Yep. And then Jordan lover doing similar stuff. Do you love loving Stroud's numbers or next to each other or anywhere you look? The numbers and also the structure of the offense, care on the ball. Sit back there in the gun on like 80% of their dropbacks go to work, buddy. That's what Jordan love has been doing. That's what Joburo has been doing. That's what C.J. Stroud has been doing. So C.J. Stroud is playing such incredible quarterback from the pocket this year. And the other guy I throw out, I don't think he's going to win it. I just wanted to acknowledge like what he has been for his offense. And I think he's playing as well as he's ever played in the NFL as Jared Goff. I don't think he's the MVP of the league. But in like in these sorts of conversations, he should be mentioned more often than he is playing exceptional football. The other, the only, did you think about any quarterbacks? The only reason like I didn't really put many non-corderbacks in here is because there's enough quarterbacks that have like really convincing cases. And if I could pick one, a non-corderback would have to win MVP before I really thought. J.S.M would be the only one I would probably survive. I would think about Ken Walker. Like what he's been for the chief's offense is pretty crazy. Well then how has he not your offense a player of the year if you think he's a legitimate MVP can? Because I still think Jackson Smith and Jake was also like, I think J.S.M is also, okay, okay. I thought you were saying like Ken Walker's the only one. Okay, okay. I think that's right. By the way, I was looking at I was looking at it earlier. On running back runs this year, I was said that the lions were in negatives. Yeah. On running back runs specifically this year, the bad, the chiefs have 17 total EPA. Ken Walker has 14 of that. No other team in the league is above four. And that's why I was like, I would say two touchdowns K nine and JSN are the most load bearing non-corderbacks in the league right now. I would put Gibbs in there as well. And just the lion's offense is just so stacked like there are just so many places you can turn, but Gibbs is incredible. I think he was my preseason pick for offensive player of the year. So no, no big argument here. But yeah. That is all we've got for midseason awards. We will be back tomorrow with the week 10, the preview for now. That's all we got. Appreciate you guys. Listen, we'll talk to you very soon. Thanks for tuning in. Make sure to hit that subscribe or follow button so you never miss an episode. If you enjoyed what you heard, please like, comment, and leave a rating. We'll see you next time.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
David selects Jackson Smith as the offensive player of the year, citing his elite efficiency, target share, and dominance despite limited receiving options and quarterback inconsistencies.
Kenneth Walker and Jermir Gibbs are highlighted as strong contenders due to their exceptional rushing production and efficiency, with Walker leading the league in total rushing EPA.
T Higgins is noted for a remarkable resurgence, with 83% of his catches resulting in first downs and unprecedented volume of middle-of-the-field targets, signaling a transformative impact on his team’s offense.
Derek favors Fred Warner for defensive player of the year, crediting his return from injury with a major defensive resurgence, including five forced fumbles and a league-leading reduction in middle-of-the-field explosive plays.
Will Anderson Jr. is acknowledged as a dominant edge rusher, though Derek argues for Warner’s greater impact due to his effect on team performance and defensive structure.
Blake Cashman is praised as a key figure in the Vikings’ dominant defense, embodying the team’s defensive identity through versatility and relentless pressure.
Chase Young and Dexter Lawrence are highlighted as impactful defensive rookies and performers, with Lawrence altering Bengals’ defensive schemes through spacing and coverage.
The show advocates for expanding the NFL awards to include position-specific honors, such as best interior offensive or defensive lineman, to better reflect the modern game’s complexity.
Summary:
The mid-season awards discussion on the Athletic football show centers on standout players across offensive and defensive positions. Offensive Player of the Year goes to Jackson Smith, celebrated for his elite efficiency, high target share, and dominance in a system with minimal alternatives, while Kenneth Walker and Jermir Gibbs are named as strong contenders due to their exceptional rushing production. T Higgins is recognized for a transformative rise, particularly in middle-of-the-field play, with a high rate of first downs and explosive targets.
For defense, Fred Warner is championed as the top candidate, with his return from injury significantly improving the 49ers’ defensive metrics, including a league-leading reduction in explosive plays in key areas. Will Anderson Jr. is acknowledged as a dominant edge rusher, though Warner’s broader impact on team performance is emphasized.
Blake Cashman is lauded as a pivotal figure in the Vikings’ defense, showcasing versatility and consistency. Other notable mentions include Chase Young and Dexter Lawrence, whose defensive schemes have reshaped opponents. The show concludes by advocating for a more comprehensive award system, recommending position-specific honors—such as best interior lineman—to better reflect the modern game’s strategic depth and player roles.
FAQs
David recommends Jalen Smith as the top contender, citing his elite target share, efficiency, and dominance despite limited receiving targets. He highlights Smith's 49.9% target share and his ability to perform consistently even with backup quarterbacks and injuries.
T.J. Higgins has made a significant impact in the middle of the field, with 83% of his catches resulting in first downs and half of his middle-of-field catches turning into explosive plays. His target volume and efficiency have skyrocketed this season, making him a top contender despite not being a traditional top receiver.
Fred Warner is the top pick due to his transformative impact on the 49ers' defense. He’s responsible for five forced fumbles and has drastically improved the team’s defensive stats, especially in middle-of-the-field play, where the 49ers have allowed only 31 yards per game.
Blake Cashman has been dominant as an off-ball linebacker, leading the Vikings in pressures and sacks, and has been instrumental in their defensive success. His ability to rush the passer and make key plays in high-pressure situations makes him a standout rookie.
Will Anderson Jr. is consistently dominant, with 9.5 sacks and 44 pressures, and is one of the best edge rushers in the league. His performance has been especially effective this season, despite the Texans’ overall struggles, and he’s been a key reason for their defensive resilience.
The show gives credit to the Baltimore Ravens' offensive lineman, despite not being a high-volume player. He has allowed the fewest pressures among rookies and has been a steady presence, especially after being asked to play center, showing durability and consistency in a struggling offense.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.