Go back

2025 Update: Leif + A Conversation with Anna Konkle

58m 12s

2025 Update: Leif + A Conversation with Anna Konkle

The episode explores a deeply personal journey of reconnection and self-reflection through a long-standing middle school crush on a boy named Layf. After years of emotional distance, the narrator attempts to reach out, only to learn Layf had a severe, undiagnosed illness—including Crohn’s disease—that affected his ability to pursue romance. A hidden text exchange reveals Layf had no romantic interest, simply offering a kind, hesitant suggestion for a Valentine’s Day date. This reframes the narrator’s belief that they were "undatable" as a product of insecurity, not reality. The story parallels the emotional authenticity of *Pen15*, where adult creators revisit their teenage years and confront the awkwardness, vulnerability, and friendship dynamics of adolescence. The episode ultimately suggests that romantic rejection is often not a reflection of personal inadequacy but of external circumstances—like health or timing. Through these revelations, the narrator gains emotional closure, realizing that self-worth isn't tied to romantic success, and that true growth comes from embracing one’s past with compassion. The narrative culminates in a deeper understanding of human connection: sometimes, the most meaningful relationships are not romantic, but rooted in friendship, empathy, and shared vulnerability—lessons that resonate across both youth and adulthood.

Transcription

8612 Words, 44725 Characters

English
[music] Pushkin. Hello. Hello. It seems like the spider has become the thing that catches the fly. You're welcoming me into the studio. Am I the fly? No, I guess you're the fly. I'm the spider. It feels pretty good. So, what? Yeah, as hopefully our listeners know by now if they're paying attention. Whoa, whoa, whoa. I was sensing a little attitude towards the listeners. Don't panic, and I was the listeners. That's rule number one in broadcast things. As our dear audience should know, we have been on-quiring some episodes this summer. And usually, at the end, we'll have a little update with the guest about what's happened since. This is going to be a little bit different. I got to interview someone I was really, really excited to talk to. She makes one of my favorite shows. It's called Pen15. Yeah, we talk about it. We talk about it, like, yeah, frequently. We do, yeah. When it was running, we really, we talked about it a lot. I have to say it's probably one of my favorite shows, too. For those who don't know the show, it is made by Anna Conkel and Maya Erskine, who are two real-life best friends, and they play versions of themselves at 13. So it's about their middle school experience. They are playing themselves as adults, and then they are surrounded by literal children, people who are actually 13 playing their classmates. For the first episode, that concept felt like a big hurdle, maybe, to kind of, like, get into the story. But I was, like, over it and into it, like, five minutes in. You stop thinking about the fact they're adults. It's like a magic trick that they pull, and it's beautiful and so funny. It's really great. I really think anyone who hasn't watched it, I would highly, highly recommend it. And I was very excited to talk to Anna. And yeah, we thought it could be a cool conversation to put with this episode, because both of us are revisiting that same age in her case, very literally recreating scenes from her childhood. Yeah. So you guys end up talking about the episode and her show. And about just our respective middle school experiences. So let's get to listening, shall we? Let's get to listening. I'm Kaleela Holt, and this is Havuade. Today's episode, "Layth." ♪ ♪ Right after the break. This is an "I Heart" podcast. Guaranteed human. Every now and then, someone would die. Risk. True stories. No holding back. It comes up behind me, and Whisper's right now here. Nobody knows where you are, and nobody can hear you scream. Some of these stories will make you laugh till you're crying. And then I realize, I'm unconscious. Some will stick with you for life. They catch my mom poisoning my sister. My brother, he died at the hands of my mother. I said, "Mike, don't make me shoot your place," but he did. People say risk makes them feel less alone and more alive. During my time in prison, I discovered a podcast called "Risk." That podcast saved my life so many times. Live your authentic truth. 'Cause you never know who may come to your funeral and turn that bitch out. Risk. The show where people tell true stories, they never thought they dared to share. Wherever you get your podcasts. I'm walking to work one morning. When I spot Layf heading towards me. From the ages of 12 to 14, Layf was my crush. The object of my junior high obsession. I still Google him occasionally, but he's completely absent from the internet. I have no idea what became of him. It's like he just disappeared. So when I see him on the street, I feel my heart speed up. I wonder if I should say hi. I wonder if I say hi. In what tone I should go, Layf? Layf. Oh, Layf. But then, as I draw closer, I realize that the man I thought was Layf is not Layf at all. And in fact, is not even a man. He's a teenager. This makes sense, given that I've not seen Layf since I was 14 years old. Still, having your heart speed up at the sight of a teenager is a sure way to feel like a creep. And just like that, to quote Carrie Bradshaw, Layf is back on my mind. All these years later, and I remember the exact type of pen Layf wrote with. I remember his birthday. I remember how he kept his wallet on a long chain. The first time I'd ever seen such a thing done. And wore a quick silver sweatshirt with holes worn through the sleeves that he'd stick his thumbs through. He was pale with blue eyes, short and slight. I remember him being kind of like, way fish almost, like, kind of almost like a fury all the time. Crushest do not exist in a vacuum. They require gleeful gossip with your friends. And so, I call Lee Chia, who's been my best friend since elementary school, to talk about our old classmate, Layf. He had this like light blonde hair that he died. And it was not like a long, like, down to your butt hair, a long, like, like, a bobbling. But like, shag in the end. Yeah. There you go. A men's bob. Once, while away on a school-sponsored trip, we phoned Layf from our hotel room, me, Lucia, and our other friend, Emily. But three of us huddled together on the scratchy Marriott Comforter, stifling our giddy-ness as we dialed. Oh my gosh. I don't remember if we actually talked to the thing. I remember is that we called-- Do we talk to his parents? We talked to his mom. Our friend, Emily, asked if she could speak with Layf. It's Emily, she said. Emily said Layf's mom. Go upstairs and talk to him. Then she hung up on us. It turned out he had a sister named Emily. So weird. Lucia stepped mom as a photographer. And she once mentioned that if Layf and I ever started dating, she wanted to take our portrait. I don't think she knew I had a crush on him. Layf was just so short and I was so tall that I think she found the idea of us as a couple funny. I was already six feet tall by the end of eighth grade. I got pressured into playing basketball, but I was so meek that I usually just stood there while some terrifying girl shoved by me with the ball. I don't like to look at pictures of myself from that time. Standing next to other kids my age, I look like the teacher or like someone's off-putting sister home from college. None of my pants fit correctly. My socks were always pulled up too high. I used to listen to the song Eleanor Rigby and Panic. In my interpretation, it was a song about how no one wanted to date poor old Eleanor Rigby, just like no one wanted to date me. When I was 13, one day I was sitting by the gym after school with my friend Desiree when she told me, "I picture you getting a boyfriend in college." She laid out this whole hypothetical where me and my future boyfriend reached for the same book at the library. At the time I was offended. College. Other girls at my school, Desiree included, already had boyfriends. The middle school version of a boyfriend were afraid to touch each other and broke up after a week. But still, I had to wait till college. But as it turned out, I did not get a boyfriend before college, nor in college, nor even for several years after college. And so I concluded, the problem was not my circumstances. The problem was me. I was not dateable. After meeting me for the first time, people might say, "Oh, she was funny." But they'd never say, "Is she single?" I was simply not a person that anyone could think of romantically. At college parties, boys would grab my friends and start dancing with them. And I would stay for a while, dancing alongside them, like I was part of the good time. But eventually I'd walk away. It was weird for me to keep standing there, smiling blankly at the wall while they were making out. By now, I'm in my 30s, and I actually do have a boyfriend. Sam and I have been together for four years. We live together. We've taken trips, know each other's moms, list each other on emergency contact forms. And yet, still, I can't shake this feeling that I'm behind, that there's something wrong with me, that I started too late, and now I can never catch up. Sometimes, Sam tells me story is about the girls he used to hook up with, or about his high school girlfriend, or the girlfriend he lived with before he lived with me. I know that he's not trying to get back together with any of these people. I know he's as invested in our relationship, as I am. Still, when he tells these stories, I feel so inadequate that I want to cry. A couple times I have cried, and he's been confused, and suddenly we're in an argument. because I don't know how to explain why I'm crying. I want charming stories like that, want to rhapsodize about my past of young love and mutual discovery. Instead, my past is a wall I smiled at, and the only stories I have about people I've hooked up with are vaguely unsettling to repeat. I liked life at a time before all that. Back when it still felt like romance might happen for me, like any interaction could be the start of a love story for the ages. One time, I brought whole food sushi for lunch, and felt self-conscious because I'd seen the breakfast club, in which Molly Ringwald is mocked for bringing sushi for lunch. But Leif walked by my table and said, "Is that sushi?" and I said, "Yes." And he said, "I love sushi." And I said, "Would you like a piece?" And he said, "Really?" And I said, "Yes." And suddenly, I was proud to have a lunch of whole food sushi. Leif talked constantly about a band called Billy Talent, a semi-yeli, alt-rock group with lyrics about misery. I started listening to them because I knew Leif liked them, and from there, became an obsessive fan myself. Once I ran into Leif at a Billy Talent concert, I pretended not to see him, because I didn't want him to think that I'd followed him there. But he came over and said hi to me. There were little moments where it almost seemed like he could be flirting with me. We followed each other on the blogging site, Zanga. And for a while, there was some sort of glitch where Leif was unable to comment on my page. When the glitch was fixed, he was so excited that he left me 100 comments in a row. Comment 42 said, "On the 42nd day of Christmas, I gave to Kalee. 100 comments, lots of typing, and a pear tree." I still have a journal from that time. In it, I'd write Leif all these vague letters. It is humiliating to read these letters now, to the point where I refuse to quote them here. Suffice it to say that I constantly referred to him as "dearest." Surrounding the letters are my thoughts about myself. Mostly, how I wished I were a different person entirely. Someone charismatic and sought after. Sometimes, I'd have this huge swell of self-hatred that I didn't know what to do with. Once, I tried to cut myself. But the kitchen knife I chose was not very sharp. And so, it was harder than I thought it would be, and I gave up. When I find someone who wants to date me, I thought, "This feeling will go away." I hope that Leif might be that someone. I'd concoct long fantasies about how we'd get together. And sometimes, I'd realize what a good mood I was in. And then, I'd realized the good mood was because of something I'd made up, something that hadn't really happened at all. In the winter of eighth grade, I finally decided, enough with the secret pining. It was time to let Leif know how I felt. And so, I took action. And by took action, I mean that I delegated action to other people. There was a stairway right next to our classroom that was just a single flight, enclosed by doors on each side. It was in this room of stairs that my friends, Lucia and Emily, cornered Leif, and told him that I liked him while I ran home and hid. Afterwards, I asked them what he said. They told me he said, "Okay." That night, in a fit of panic and despair, I got online. I logged on to Zanga, and I wrote a veiled, angsty post about what a huge mistake I'd made. Leif saw the post, as I knew he would, and he I am to my friend Karina about it. And here is where something amazing happened. Because in this conversation with Karina, Leif said he would date me. He said he thought I was cool. He was going to ask me out on Valentine's Day. Seeing couples perform how much they liked each other made me feel inferior. So I hated Valentine's Day with a showy passion. Each February 14th, I'd wear all black as a sign of protest. Leif's thought was that this romantic gesture might help me to reclaim the holiday. I know all this because at the time, Karina promptly copied and pasted the I.M.s with Leif into an email for me. I couldn't believe what I was reading. I was so happy. Finally, I thought. Finally, the thing that only happens to other people, it's now happening to me. On Valentine's Day, I got up and my mom drove me to school. People were giving out candy and paper hearts. I tried to look nonchalant. I went to science class. I went to lunch. To recess. To math. To basketball. And then school was over and I went home. Leif did not say a single word to me all day. I have no idea what happened or why he changed his mind. Huh. Did you ever talk to him about it? I rehash all this on the phone with Lucia. He never did we speak directly about it. Like we spoke through you and Emily, through Karina on I.M. And like through my veiled Zanga posts. Interesting. And having been my best friend for all these years. Lucia and to it's what I'm building up to. So you, you want to try to find him or? Yeah, but I'm afraid I tried drafting a letter and I was like, do I just have to say? Anyway, so do you think this is completely insane to do? No, I mean, I'm sure you wrote you're a very good writer and a thoughtful person. So I'm sure the way you approached it was good. Since googling Leif had always failed me, I'd turned to a public records database that I get through work. I was hoping to discover a possible mailing address for Leif. And I did. Looks like maybe he lives in Arizona and I saw he had like a from 2020, a court thing from defacing a political sign. Well, I guess you don't know which direction I know. It's a good direction. I want to talk to Leif directly the way I never did back then. I want to know what he really thought of me and why he never asked me out on Valentine's Day. All these years, I've believed the story about how people don't see me romantically. But if I can change the beginning of that story, if I can see myself differently at 13, it could reframe everything that came after. I named dropped you in the letters. I'm so well know. We used to live together, but now we both live with our boyfriend so that he wouldn't think I was like trying to date him now. Hi, Leif. I wrote in my letter. I don't know if you remember me, but we went to near North together. I had a huge crush on you, and I was hoping you'd be up to talk to me about what you remember from that time. I hang up the phone with Lucia, and I walk to the mailbox. Risk, true stories, no holding back. It comes up behind me, and whispers right in the air. Nobody knows where you are. In no way can hear you scream. He touched my mom, poisoning my sister. I said, Mike, don't make the future place, but he did. During my time in prison, I discovered a podcast called Risk. That podcast saved my life so many times. Live your authentic truth because you never know who may come to your funeral and turn that bitch out. Risk, the show where people tell true stories they never thought they dared to share. I send off my letter, but then several weeks go by and nothing. Should they get the letter and decide to ignore me? Or do I just have the wrong address? Usually when reporting a story, I try calling at this point, and I did find a phone number for life. However, the idea of dialing it makes me want to lie down in the middle of the street and simply pass away. And so, just like I did at 13, I recruit someone else as an envoy. And who is that someone else? You. Oh, that's you. Okay, so I'm sort of like that whole quorum of girls, all one adult man. This is regular host of this program, Jonathan Goldstein. I want him to call life on my behalf to see if they've got the letter. I would be open to speaking with me. Yeah, no, I don't think that will be awkward at all. Let me get my pattern down here. Hi. There was this girl. Khalil hold. You should say Kaley first. I think he would know me by Kaley. Hi, I'm Kaley Holt's boss. Wow, that is weird. No. Hi, you don't know me, but I was enlisted by an old school term of yours. Yeah, don't say school. An old flame. A paramore. My confidence is decreasing with every passing second. I won't embarrass you in front of your crush. Are you choking? Choking on this bon bon. As my boss just fixates on a piece of candy, I weigh the pros and cons of just making the call myself. But in the end, I make the same choice I did back then. Better to send an incompetent in my stead while I hide at home. I obsess all day Thursday. I obsess all day Friday. Jonathan doesn't offer me a single update. I can't even tell if he's made the call yet. Then the weekend begins and I still have no idea what he's done. Okay. But whatever you did do, it worked because Friday night checked my email and I had an email from Leaf saying that he would talk to me. Wow. Okay. Well, let me just say, I am almost 100% certain that I had nothing to do with it. Well, really, because it happens that day. Yeah, it is suggestive. Jonathan tells me that he had indeed tried calling Leaf's number. Okay. Here's the call. You're ready? Okay. Yeah. Okay. Hello. Is Leaf there? Yes. Could I speak to him? Yes. This is her. This is Leaf? Yes. I just want to make sure I have the right person. What is your middle name? She can do it. No. No. That isn't the leaf that I'm looking for. I'm on a toilet right now. Okay. Is there anybody else in the house? In his email, Leaf proposed that we talk in nine days, which is kind of a weirdly long time. I can't help but worry that he'll bail last minute. That this will be just like Valentine's Day all over again. So in the meantime, hoping she might remember some clue about what happened back then. I texted my old friend, Karina, the one who brokered this whole Valentine's plan with Leaf on IM. When you texted me that it was you, I was like, oh my gosh. Like, did something happen? Like, she calling me to say that Ms. Bergen died. Ms. Bergen, being our long-time principal. Which she did, by the way, if you didn't know. I did hear that. Yeah. May she rest in peace. I'd felt deranged, texting Karina, that I wanted to speak with her about Leaf. A random kid from her eighth grade class. But Karina responded, I legitimately thought about you and Leaf last week. So just like we used to in junior high, the two of us chat on the phone about a boy. And then he IM'd you shut up. Did I send you the conversation? Yes. And buried in an old AOL account, I find that email from Karina with the whole conversation. Between her and Leaf, laid out. I would like absolutely love to see it. Let me send it to you. I will just write it down. Leaf's screen name was chaotic detortion. Which I think is just chaotic distortions, bell-drawn? Okay, let me read this. Okay, at 10-17 pm, nice. And as Karina reads, here for you, dear listener, is a dramatic recreation of that IM exchange, with two young actors playing the roles of Karina and Leaf. Hey. Hey, Leaf. What's up? Kaylee's talking about what I think she is, right? On Zenga? Hold on, let me see. Um, Kaylee likes me, right? Did Lucia and Emily tell you something? Yeah, after school the other day. Yeah, she does. Well, if she comes on, will you tell her something? Yeah. If she comes on, tell her that I'll go out with her. But my health is always groomed with my life so I'm probably not going to be able to be a 100% boy from material. Leaf had some sort of illness the whole time I knew him, but I never knew how sick he was, or what he was even sick with. He sometimes had to leave school early. He was on crutches for a while, and there were days when he just looked frail. But at 13, we didn't think to ask any questions. Back then, Karina just thought it was sweet. He was considering his health. In his role, it's my future boyfriend. Oh, but do you like her? This is kind of awkward. Yeah. All these years later, and that yeah, I mix my heart, start pounding. I was wrong, I think. See, I was wrong. He liked me. He said he liked me. But then it goes on. OMG. Don't tell her. I'm not crazy about her. But hey, she likes me. I don't hate her or anything. And Kaylee school. Yeah, she is. So you want me to tell her that you'll go out with her? Why did you just talk to her on one day? Do you think I should? Yeah, because I mean, I don't think she would believe me. And it would be nicer if you told her. Are you getting her something on V-Day? I guess. One is Valentine's Day. Next, next Tuesday. OMG. You should tell her on V-Day because she hates V-Day. Well, yeah, I will. I always thought it was Lave who came up with the Valentine's Day plan. But it was actually Karina. It wasn't her romantic gesture at all. It was the gesture of a thoughtful friend. But I don't remember anything after that. I didn't even remember that he didn't end up saying anything. Like he didn't end up saying anything to you at all. No, we never talked about it. No, Kaylee, I'm pretty sure he mentioned his health again. Maybe I followed up and he was like, honestly, my health just like really isn't the best. So did Lave not ask me out simply because he was too ill? What's his not asking actually a romantic gesture? Something worthy of a Shakespearean tragedy? Or did he just not like me? I'd ask Lave to talk on Zoom. And I pray I won't break out or have a bad hair day because, you know, I want to look good. The morning of, I put on an eyeshadow that someone once told me was flattering. And wear a t-shirt for my favorite band because I figure it's cool to like music. Then I head to the studio and test the microphone. Hello, hello. All right, that's working. I feel ill. I feel physically ill. Oh my god. Okay, I can do this. Here we go. On the Zoom camera, you can't even see my t-shirt or flattering eyeshadow. So that was a lot of wasted effort. I see that Lave is in the waiting room. I press the admit button and he appears on screen. Hi. Hey. In spite of his deeper voice and tattoos, Lave seems the same. Like, there's no discrepancy between the person I imagined all these years and the one I'm actually looking at. How are you? I'm great. I'm doing great. How are you doing? I'm doing, you know. Unfortunately, faced with the person I imagined all these years, I suddenly can't remember how to have a conversation. It's like I've lost 20 years of social skills. What's your life? My life, well, I, yeah, I don't know. I just do life things, you know, eat food, go to the grocery store. I've got a dog, you know. Sure. What's your dog? What's your dog saying? Ronin. Good. Given that I'm incapable of asking any question more specific than what is your life or who is your dog? Lave takes the lead. They've been doing a lot of activity stuff in Tucson and that consumes more of my time than I probably should let it. In fact, the 9-day delay they fast for was because of his activism. A few weeks earlier, he was at a protest with the stop-cop city movement when he was tased and slammed against the ground by a police officer. He's been recovering from a concussion. At this point, we're 40 minutes into the conversation and I've somehow managed to avoid asking life any questions about 8th grade at all. Even though he knows we're here to talk about how much I liked him, bringing up that time still makes me nervous. What do you remember about me? Yeah, I remember you being very tall and maybe a little awkward, but maybe it's just because of the crush or whatever. No, I was awkward. I know that you told me at some point that you had a crush on me. I have a vague memory of like, there's like that stairwell, Lucia telling me or something like that in the stairwell. I rambled through my memories of what happened after that stairwell moment. And finally, up to the question that I really came here to ask, you were going to ask me out on Valentine's Day, but then that never happened and I don't know why. Oof, I'm sorry, yeah. I don't remember like the Zanga post sounds vaguely familiar. Can I send you, because I in fact have these items between you and Karina? No way. Can I email them to you? Yeah, see what cringy-ass things I have to say. Lief mostly reads through the IAMs and silence, but at one point he makes a face and again goes. Oof. When he's done, he laughs self-consciously. All right, well, that was, that was, that was fun. You have no memory of this. I don't know vaguely I guess like it's obviously, obviously it happened. I mean, yeah, I'd be weird if I typed all this up. Yeah. Yeah, be pretty weird. What part were you goofing at? Oh, just, I mean, don't tell her. I'm not crazy about her, but hey, you know, she likes it, I was just like that, yikes. I don't really know what happened. Obviously, we didn't date. I don't, I don't think we did not date totally forgotten about that. I mean, that would kind of be worse if we did date and you didn't just supposed to go on from your memory. Yeah, that'd be real shitty, yeah. I mean, like, seems like you did not like me. I do remember you being like very funny, but yeah, I do agree, though. I think I like wasn't like into you into you. She is the eighth grade parlance. But then, late phrase is a key thing I've been wondering about. The explanation that he gave to Karina at the time, his mysterious health issues. I was like very, very, very sick. I was like in the process, essentially, of getting diagnosed with Crohn's disease. Crohn's is an autoimmune disease. Dave's intestine was attacking itself, making it hard for him to do basic things like walk or eat. In the years I knew him, though, Dave didn't know he had Crohn's. He didn't know what was wrong with him. He was just getting worse and worse. It took over two years of waiting rooms and misdiagnoses before he finally got to a doctor who helped him. At that point, he was so sick that the doctor pulled his mom aside to say that she thought life might die. They immediately admitted him to the hospital, where he stayed for three months. I'm not a monster, so of course I'd never say that I'm happy someone was so ill they almost died. But hearing all this, I can't help but feel kind of relieved. Because if life was that sick the whole time I knew him, then it wasn't about me not being good enough. I probably just wasn't any space in his brain for dating and crushes at all. So I put this to life. I for sure had crushes. Well, there goes that theory. Can I ask you how to crush on? Yeah, yeah. I know I had a crush on Sorka for a while. I was going to ask you that actually. That's what I always suspected. You got me figured out. Sorka had shown up at her school one year from Ireland, and all the guys instantly loved her. Somehow in that one year, she dated three or four people. I, as someone who'd never dated anyone, found this profoundly unfair. Like what about the rest of us? In my moments of insecurity, I always used to think there's no way life likes me because I'm pretty sure he likes Sorka. So while on the one hand, it's validating to hear that my read was right. On the other hand, it's devastating to hear that my read was right. I move on to my next theory. Do you think that any of it was height-related? Uh, I don't think so. I don't think so. So what was my problem? I asked Lief if I had some defect that prevented him from seeing me romantically. And although he really thinks about it, um, he can't come up with an answer. I'm just trying to think if there has ever been anyone where I'm like, I'd love to date this person, but they've got this defect, you know? Who he falls for, Lief says, has always felt beyond words, especially in the eighth grade. Well, how do you feel about talking? No, not at all. It's fun to catch up and like, hear what you remember. It's really nice to talk to you. Yeah, you too, Kayleigh. Talk to you soon. All right, talk to you soon. I'd felt good while I was talking to Lief. He was cool and nice as he'd always been. And yet as soon as we hang up, I suddenly feel really sad. I sit there for a while, alone in the studio. And then as I always have in times of stress, I call my mom, I fill her in on the conversation and how the only logical conclusion seems to be that yes, I was right. I am in fact, undatable, who wouldn't want to date you, you're awesome. Thanks. And I mean, I know I'm your mother, but that is also true. I feel like that's true in terms of like, people wanting to like be my friend, but I don't feel like that's true for like, dating. You feel it not just from when you were younger, but you feel it even now? Yeah. It makes me feel kind of sad, I'm sorry, don't be sorry. It makes me feel kind of sad, and it makes me feel mad at people that don't see you. I don't. Yeah, I think I'm having a hard time characterizing it because I do feel like weirdly emotional, but also like he was nice in the conversation was good, you know, so I don't want it to seem like I thought he was like being an asshole or anything like he wasn't. I don't hear that from you at all, I don't hear anything about any judgment about him. Yeah. You're trying to piece it together for you. Yeah. Yeah, give yourself a little space. I give myself several weeks of space. And then as I keep trying to piece it together, I decide there's one more person I want to speak with. I'm very excited to talk to you, so thanks for being up to do this weird thing. Yeah, no, it is weird, and I definitely feel weird about it. This is Serka, the Irish girl that lay in the rest of the entire fucking class was into. As in case it's not weird enough to reach out to my crush after nearly 20 years, why not also reach out to my crush's crush. Always suspected he had a crush on you and he said, yes, did you know that? And like Jesus, like he would like he would like burn CDs for me and stuff. Shoot it. I feel like he also gave me a sticker that said George W. Bush is a punk ass chump. So like yeah, I had an awareness. I want to talk to Serka because I think of her as the anti me. Like here's how Serka's Valentine's Day went in junior high. She walked up to her boyfriend at the time holding a Hershey's kiss and said, do you want this or do you want a real one? I wanted to tell me how she achieved such a romantic success, what she had that I didn't have. I laid all this out in my initial message, sir. So I said this morning. husband. And he was kind of like, well, it's obvious, isn't it? Like you were just new and different. And I think that's exactly it. Like you guys had all been together from the age of two. Do you know? So I literally was just new and different. I honestly think it was that simple. I think that's part of it. But I feel like there was something about your personality too. Like I feel like there was some like charisma or like confidence or I don't know. I feel like I think that that has got to be fake until you make it though, doesn't it? Because looking back and looking at the challenge that was laid up my doorstep, I probably just lent in to some kind of confident persona. Circa only attended near North for a single year. And it wasn't an easy transition. Because of her mom's job, she was upgraded at 12 years old and plopped down in a foreign country. Her dad, all her old friends stayed back in Ireland. She remembers the day she came to visit our school for the first time. And I remember crying and I remember saying, I don't want to go there. My memory isn't of feeling invincible or anything like quite the opposite. Like like, overwhelmed and shut down, you know. It's that sense of panic, Circa thinks. That made her act so confident when she started school with us. It was her way of managing. Still, in the year I knew her, she often felt insecure. And dating didn't make that feeling go away. Anyway, you cut it. Boyfriend, no boyfriend. Junior high is hard. Circa tells me she's been married for about a year and a half now. How did you guys meet? We met on Tinder. I asked Lave the same question about how he met his partner. Actually, through Tinder, we are a Tinder success story. I met my boyfriend through Tinder too. Nice. Circa, Lave, me. Even though I always felt like they had some power I lacked. Almost two decades later, we all ended up in the same place. Living with people, we met on Tinder. But back when I talked with my friend, Karina, I'd asked her what her impression had been to me when we knew each other in junior high. Oh my gosh, Kaley, I adored you. I remember you being very intelligent. You were very funny. I know you, like, you were tall. Just, you know, at that age, I feel like you always look at everyone else and like, don't form your confidence or like, embrace every bit of yourself until later in life. I remember being like, she has so many things going for her. I hope that she becomes more confident. My past self was tall and awkward, and the boy I liked didn't like me. And all these years later, I'm still tall and still awkward, and I still often feel left behind by romance. But then again, the junior high me would never have had the courage to have these conversations at all. So maybe I did become more confident. And some people do want to date me. I'd want to date me. These days, I don't think too much about Valentine's Day. It turns out that I don't like being one of those performative couples anymore than I liked watching those performative couples. This year, on February 14th, my boyfriend made dinner. I did the dishes. "Happy Tuesday," he said. "Happy Tuesday," I said. Then we watched TV. It was nice. "Now that the furniture is returning to its goodwill home, now that the last month's rent is gaining with the damage deposit, take this moment to disaster. If we mentor, if we try, we're felt around for five to one. Hello. So as promised, my conversation with Anna-Conkel, co-creator of Penn 15, we talked about how emotional and viscerally bizarre it is to return to that middle school space again as an adult. I mean, it was so humiliating. The first season, especially, nobody knew what it was. The crew didn't know what it was. So people signed up to come on set, and a lot of them haven't even read the script. They're like, "What the fuck did I sign up for?" Day one, Maya's in her bullcott, masturbating. We're really going to try to play 13. This is so embarrassing. Then being surrounded by the real kids and stepping on stage, we're like, "Where are you?" "We don't really think we are. We're 30." The night before it came out, I just got in the fetal position on the floor and was like, "This is so embarrassing. What did you do? What did you do?" And you know what the truth is, is it felt embarrassing for years after, actually? People would come up to me and say, "I love it." And I'd be like, "What are you doing today?" I couldn't hear it. I felt so naked. How was it for you making this, versus when people started listening to it or have you had waves of this? Writing it and putting it together and playing it for people here was actually positive. I felt like, "Oh, I'm really expressing what I felt, and it's connecting with people." Then I feel like once it was out in the world, it was a bit more of a mixed bag than I was expecting. I mean, how people felt. Yeah. There were people who really connected with it, but there were a lot of people who hated it. Really? I loved it. I mean, but obviously, I'm going to love it, I guess. I mean, that is something I was curious about. I feel like there were people who just don't understand why a middle school would be important or why you would want to think about it or go back to it. Like, have you run into that at all? Are there people who just don't think about it? There's something about it that makes people really uneasy. Yeah. From the pitches of us for talking about it, so many men in particular actually, like, had to get up from a table, or would be like, "I'm getting nauseous, sorry, hold on." Maybe it's like physiological disassociation that a lot of people can do. What was it like, like, working with the kids? Like, do you feel like you had to translate to them, or did they kind of get it? Most of the kids, when they're actually 13, aren't at an age that they're going? Oh yeah, I get why that would be. They're like, I didn't do that yesterday. Right, if that's true. So in it. And even, like, seeing the social dynamics play out on set, that was very meta. There would, I won't say who, but it would be like, oh, okay, he's the most popular. He's the most popular. All the guys are texting her or whatever. And we always sound the right kids. I thought the kids in your podcast were great. Thanks so much, my dad runs a community theater in Iowa, and he helped me cast those kids. So that was very sweet. Yeah. Did you do community theater going up? Yeah, I was never very good, but because my dad, like, ran these, like, kids summer camps and stuff, I did always go. That's a lot of pressure for your dad to run it, and then, like, auditioning for your dad. Yeah. I think I wanted to be more of a, like, a star because I wanted to be, like, close to my dad, you know? I relate to that too. I remember going on, like, some work trip with him, and I remember, like, going to a pub. And they're being karaoke and a girl went up and saying, no, we're man, by the Beatles. And he was like, oh, she's incredible. He almost, like, cried. And he was clapping in a really intense way. Yeah. I don't remember what song I sang next, but I sang a song. And I remember, like, finishing and, like, waiting for the same eye and missing half and being like, I'm right here, that. Yeah. And he was like, no, that was good. It was awful. Hitchie. I had been estranged from my dad. I mean, this is another actually crazy layer to the whole show. It's like, I hadn't seen my dad in five years, but I'm, like, acting with the TV version of my dad. And the one that I missed. Yeah. And about a year before we started, in the last season. My dad and I had sort of been like communicating more and trying to fix things and then he called me and found out he had cancer. Oh man. And filming started. Whoa. So I was like trying to like manage nurses and all these other things and be there as much as I possibly flying back and forth and filming the show. But there were these scenes that were like overlapping with these huge moments where like my dad went to hospice and I had to go back to LA and film the scene where Curtis moves out of the house and gets an apartment and he has like a midlife crisis and gets this sea bring convertible. Yeah. And we're in the convertible. Like the camera's right on us as we're driving at night with the top down in the air, the cold air blasting, which is like what my dad and I always did. And he had had that same sea bring and we're having the talk about him moving out. Just as my dad's gone into hospice, like moving out of the world. Yeah. Yeah. And I just lost it. I was about feeling like a kid has an adult. There was something about the extremeness of what we were trying to do. Like, oh, we're building sets that look like our real houses. Yeah. It was like stepping into a memory. Were there particular scenes that were particularly intense to shoot? The definitely the first day of filming at my house and a cones, you know, house. I had given so many specifics about it was nicer than my real house, probably. And but, you know, my parents in real life divorced. They told me in seventh grade or eighth grade. And I just had such a hard time accepting our divorce and walking in and seeing the house with like both of their things. Yeah. The cops being like together like the loon blanket that I described my dad having or the kind of lounger, you know, that he had that went to his apartment and what my mom got to eat. And it was like it was all intermingled. And then on the bookshelves are all of these like half funny, half devastating pictures of me between two loving parents. And they're my, you know, set parents. So it was like silly, but I just wanted to cry. I was like going back to when to the good times, you know, and it was a better version of the good times than when I had really, we didn't have a lot of pictures the three of us. I mean like after doing the show and like being in those moments again, do you see anything in that time differently? Like to change your perspective at all? I think it's interesting how people at that age have such different relationships with their own sexuality. Like that part in your podcast and the episode where the sort of popular girl goes up to the guy and gets her, her she kiss and says like, what does she say? So do you want this or do you want a real one? That's like the, I was like, I was like, I was like, well, I don't have that DNA. Like I don't understand. And then she sort of went on to say, I think I created this persona. Right. But how much is that persona? And how much is that just a different physical comfort? I was always like such a goody two shoes in that way and like kind of known as a prude. And I was just not physically interested in guys like that. And if somehow they were like sensing because my friends were comfortable with that. Yeah. No, it's a good point. I think similarly, I was not the most comfortable with it either. Like I would have these infatuations with people. But yeah, we're going to have this mental connection where we understand each other. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Like it was romantic. Yeah. I remember when we first conceived of Penn and our agents or something being like, you need to add like character descriptions. And we just knew how we'd play them. But we hadn't been putting words to it. And that was one distinction that I finally was like, she's romantic. Do you remember what else you said in your character description? I'm like, I would find it so hard to have to like sum myself up in a character way. Yeah. Yeah. Um, I think like tall, bad posture. I think that I would have had the like hand over my stomach that I always did loyal to a fault friend probably like gets her identity from how much she admires Maya and the fact that Maya admires her back gives Anna confidence. I mean, that's another thing I feel like you guys captured so well was just like the energy that having a friendship like that gives you where you're like feeding on each other and amping each other up. Yeah. That was the saddest part I think about it ending was like that innocence of friendship as actors and adult best friends of going like right now we get to live in this world where playing 13 is like you are just glued at the hip. And as you get older, you know, so many of us will lean on their romantic back to, you know, life to romantic partner. I feel like that's part of what's sad sometimes about being single as an adult is that everyone does lean so much on their partner and you're like wait where am I now I'm not anybody's number one because their number one is the person that they're with. Yes. Yeah. Yeah. I think it's something I've really struggled with to be honest and adulting. Yeah. Is that expectation? Same. You know, I'm lucky that Maya and I think they're a little bit aware of it and we will go to the doctors with each other like you know, there's things like, but I think it's not the norm. Thanks so much to Anna and to everyone who helped put this episode together. And for all my fellow Penn 15 fans out there, you can listen to my full conversation with Anna if you subscribe to Pushkin Plus. I was very excited to get all this insight into making the show and I don't want to hoard that insight from other Penn 15 heads. So go to pushkin.fm/plus to sign up. We'll be back next week with our final encore of the summer. And then the new season of heavyweight begins September 18th. Hey heavyweight listeners. I'm here to talk to you about a podcast called Proxy. It's hosted by Yahweh Shah who you may remember from MPR's Invisibility Up. Sometimes the person you need to talk to is someone you don't know but who's been through the exact same thing that you're struggling with. On Proxy, Yahweh helps guests solve emotional mysteries and predicaments by putting them together with someone who's been in their shoes like a woman who's having an affair with her married boss and can't live with the guilt or a dog trainer who realizes that she doesn't like her own dogs. Yahweh finds them the perfect proxy to talk to. It's funny, surprising, and sometimes a gut punch. Listen to Proxy wherever you get your podcasts. This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed Human.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The narrator reflects on a long-held crush from middle school on a boy named Layf, recalling vivid details about him and their shared experiences.
  2. After years of emotional uncertainty, the narrator attempts to reconnect with Layf directly, only to discover he had a chronic illness, including Crohn’s disease, which likely made romantic involvement impossible.
  3. A key revelation comes from a text exchange between Layf and his friend Karina, showing Layf had no romantic interest in the narrator and was simply being kind by suggesting a Valentine’s Day date.
  4. The narrator realizes their own self-perception of being "undatable" may have been shaped by insecurity, not reality, as Layf’s health issues, not rejection, explain the lack of a relationship.
  5. The episode parallels the emotional journey of the creators of *Pen15*, who return to their middle school selves and confront the discomfort and vulnerability of re-experiencing youth.
  6. Both the narrator and the *Pen15* creators find that adolescence is defined not just by romance, but by friendship, authenticity, and the emotional weight of unspoken truths.
  7. The story underscores how people often misattribute romantic rejection to personal flaws, when in reality, health, timing, or personal circumstances may be the true barriers.
  8. Ultimately, the narrator finds peace in recognizing that being overlooked or misunderstood at 13 is not a flaw, but part of a broader journey toward self-acceptance and emotional maturity.

Summary:

The episode explores a deeply personal journey of reconnection and self-reflection through a long-standing middle school crush on a boy named Layf. After years of emotional distance, the narrator attempts to reach out, only to learn Layf had a severe, undiagnosed illness—including Crohn’s disease—that affected his ability to pursue romance. A hidden text exchange reveals Layf had no romantic interest, simply offering a kind, hesitant suggestion for a Valentine’s Day date.

This reframes the narrator’s belief that they were "undatable" as a product of insecurity, not reality. The story parallels the emotional authenticity of *Pen15*, where adult creators revisit their teenage years and confront the awkwardness, vulnerability, and friendship dynamics of adolescence. The episode ultimately suggests that romantic rejection is often not a reflection of personal inadequacy but of external circumstances—like health or timing.

Through these revelations, the narrator gains emotional closure, realizing that self-worth isn't tied to romantic success, and that true growth comes from embracing one’s past with compassion. The narrative culminates in a deeper understanding of human connection: sometimes, the most meaningful relationships are not romantic, but rooted in friendship, empathy, and shared vulnerability—lessons that resonate across both youth and adulthood.

FAQs

The episode follows a woman who, in middle school, had a deep crush on a boy named Leif. Years later, she tries to reconnect with him, only to discover he had a chronic illness, including Crohn's disease, which he concealed from her. The story explores themes of unrequited love, self-worth, and how past experiences shape self-perception.

Leif never asked her out because he was too ill and didn't want to burden her with his health issues. She learned that her insecurities about being 'undatable' were based on a misperception—his silence wasn't due to disinterest, but because of his illness. This helped her reframe her self-worth and realize that her feelings were valid.

She discovered it through an old IM conversation between Leif and his friend Karina, where Leif admitted he had been very sick and eventually received a Crohn's diagnosis. He had been on crutches and often missed school due to his illness, which he never shared with her.

Karina was the girl’s best friend and acted as a mediator. She helped broker the idea of Leif asking the girl out on Valentine’s Day and later revealed details of their private messages, showing that Leif had actually liked her but was hesitant due to his health.

She realized that her feelings of being 'undatable' were not due to a lack of worth, but because she had internalized the idea that romance was something only certain people could achieve. Her journey helped her see that confidence and self-acceptance grow with time and experience.

No, Leif never asked her out on Valentine's Day. He had planned to, but he changed his mind, likely due to his health. The girl never received a direct message from him, and this event left her feeling rejected and insecure for years.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.