from History for the Curious - The Jewish History Podcast
53m 18s
The Russian Empire implemented a series of oppressive policies targeting Jewish communities, most notably through forced assimilation via clothing and education decrees. A key policy in 1844 mandated that Jews pay taxes for wearing traditional garments, escalating to a full ban by 1850, which led to widespread resistance, humiliation, and public riots. Jewish leaders like the Gerber and Rizhner were arrested for defying these laws, sparking mass mobilization and public protests, especially in Warsaw. The policies were rooted in a broader effort to erase Jewish distinctiveness, with traditional clothing seen as a marker of separation. Many Jews, especially in Hasidic communities, resisted by maintaining their customs, leading to internal conflict, including the targeting and killing of informers who exposed community members. These actions created deep religious and social trauma, with women particularly affected by hair-covering bans. Despite diplomatic interventions by figures like Moses Montefuri, who met the Tsar and advocated for Jewish rights, the government remained unyielding, viewing Jewish traditions as obstacles to assimilation. The failure of these policies to pass peacefully exposed the resilience of Jewish identity and the profound impact of state-sanctioned cultural suppression, marking a dark chapter in Jewish history that remains underappreciated compared to the Holocaust.
The reports from further afield won't be any better because he was told, despite efforts
by the Cosax and other soldiers, despite the abductions and beatings, the Jews of Warsaw
by and large, as well as the Jews in the surrounding towns, refused to change their
clothes and shave their beds.
And the concluding sentence says, "In light of the above, there is no chance that the
law will pass peacefully."
So being the Russian government, they used force. At the order of the governor, the police
arrived at the Gerber's apartment, who was still in Warsaw at the time, the Edelwald
Duke, Geriot, and demanded that he'd sign on the decree. He refused, and they arrested
him. For the crime of basically ordering his followers to oppose the law.
Welcome to History for the Curious. I'm Manor Eisner, and I host the International
Renowned Lecturer, Dynamic Historian and Tour Guide, Bradley Aubrey-Hersh. Experience our
history, confront dilemmas, and reveal the untold stories of 3,000 years of Jewish heritage
from Paris to Cairo, from the Russian Zartomimonides, and from the Sino-Revelation to the French Revolution.
Join the fastest-growing Jewish history podcast in the world by subscribing to this channel
and discovering the events that have shaped us into who we are today.
And welcome back to part 3 on the Russian Empire. We left off last week talking about
the attempts to destroy the Jews through education, as a means to get them to abandon traditional
Jews.
Yes, although it has to be said, the Russians used a number of different forced assimilation
policies, clothing was targeted as we will see later today, as well occupations, leadership.
We also spoke of the Cantonist decree, where with Jewish informants, sometimes the only
option was to remove the Jewish criminals from carrying out that blackmail, so there was
a lot going on in this era.
And in fact, what we've just said as the introduction, these areas overlapped, particularly
in the plague of moisture informants, which is an area that people may vaguely have heard
of, but have no real familiarity with. And having talked about decrees, I wanted to focus
on a few areas that impacted how Jews actually lived their lives.
So I'll quote an extract.
On December 13th, 1838, General Dimitri Bubikov, governor of the southwestern provinces
of the Russian Empire, issued a notice to keep a close watch on what was going on in synagogues
and small study houses. In such places, cases not infrequently occur as a result of which
Jews have been found slain. Such action is the autonomous education by a court of Jewish
rabbis carried out on the basis of their false law concerning the elimination of informants
who reveal their co-religionists' crimes, the greater the crime, the more tricks that
Jews devise to conceal the guilty parties.
So this tells you that the government is aware that somewhere out there there are rabbis
who are saying that informants can be dealt with. And in fact, the historian Saul Ginsberg
who was born in the 19th century in Minsk wrote, "Wether Dnieper able to speak, it can tell
of many informers who were drowned in its waters by decisions of the Kahal in the Shuklov region."
And these informants told the Russian authorities basically the activities of Jews, and they
endangered individuals, sometimes entire communities, and were dealt with where possible according
to the Talmudic Law of the Pseure, the Radayf. Now these informers often did what they
did willingly because they made money on it or other benefits, which could sometimes
be earned from both sides because they would go to the communities and ask to be paid not
to inform. Sometimes, Jews were driven to inform to avenge themselves on the communal
leaders or communities who treated them unjustly. And the information was about people who'd
escaped or disappeared, or who had evaded the army or paying tax, and often placed Jews
in physical danger because the government considered this data highly reliable, it was from
an inside source. And that meant that they were blackmailers in effect, "They must have
been the most hated despised people on earth." And feared, once again an extract that wanted
to mention, there was almost no town without its informer, and in Kamenets too, there was
one, the Itcher Shatus. He was a tailor who patched old clothes, never had to make his living
from it though, because his real work was informing. He wasn't content merely to inform
on individuals, he informed on entire towns, used to go to Grodnor on foot and speak to
the governor, and the town on which he had informed would be reduced to poverty, it goes
without saying that he was paid to stop him from squealing. For his own town of Kamenets,
he had at least a little respect, and the townspeople didn't stint on flattering him, hoping
he would leave them in peace. Now on Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur, he would station himself
on the beamer in the shawl and pray with such weeping that one could not help crime with
him, his howling shook the congruence to the bone. He still saw himself, in other words,
as a religious Jew, although in everybody else's eyes he was despicable. We also have a couple
of letters from archives, which were only really opened up in the end of the 20th century.
This letter was written on January 5th, 1845, and sent to Zal Nikolas by Masha Itskvich Blank,
who was a Jewish convert from Zhitomir, who had taken the name Dimitri Ivanovich Blank
after his conversion. Converts were not allowed to change their family name.
That was actually his name, or there was a blank space.
No, that's his name. And is written in Yiddish with a Russian translation, and it reached
the head of the third section, the secret police at the Zal's private office. And it reads
as follows, "To our Lord the Emperor, his merciful Excellency, Father of us all, may
gold grant him life, peace, blessings, and fortune at every turn, Nikolai Pavlovich,
our Lord Emperor, his mercy rewards many favors to the Jews." This is by the way the Zal
who conscripted the Cantonists into 30 years of our service. With his royal decrees, that
Jews must educate their children in government schools. It is clear to people of intelligence
that in his mercy the Emperor wishes for the Jews to be educated, and to dress as decent
people, the balls amongst the Jews don't understand this benevolence. They call these
"munificent decrees" edicts. They are not worthy of the goodness of the Emperor that
he is bestowed upon them. And the Jews, even on the day of atonement, when they sit in
the synagogue for the entire day, do not say even one prayer for the welfare of the kingdom,
despite that the prayer for the welfare is found in the prayer book. The Jews never recite
this prayer, it is there for the sake of appearances only. This demitry in one of
its blank was the great grandfather of Vladimir Ilyich Ulyanov, known to us as Lenin, the founder
of the Soviet Union. Well, so he had a payback for his crimes, but Halachhoj treats informers
as a roeder, in other words, a man who could legally be killed. Did that ever happen? Yes,
and in fact, if they have a track record, they could even be killed before carrying out
a particular plan. Now, obviously, having happened no halachic authority ever put into writing
their rulings against specific informers, let alone publish them in trievous, but informers
were killed. And as we mentioned earlier, the authorities were aware that there was this shadowy
Jewish secret power that pursued in formers, which meant that when the government caught them,
they treated them with severity. And one of the most famous or infamous episodes was the murder
of two Jewish informers in Isticia, which brought Robysirol the Regina into a protracted
exhausting trial and to imprisonment and finally brought him to flight from Russia to Austria.
The events are almost the making of a novel. The opening scene took place in February 1836,
fishermen from a village in the province of Padolia brought up in their nets, an unidentified
body from the river, from the frozen river. And the body had strong, I mean, severe wounds,
and had been weighted down by heavy stones. The police were informed, but despite an intensive
inquiry, no one was able to identify the victim, or suggest a motive for the murder or identify
the perpetrators, because as we will see, the Jewish community was keeping deliberately silent.
The body is buried, and normally this episode would have entered, as many other cases would,
unsolved. But there was another professional Jewish informer called Isaac Kenecksburg,
who reported to the governor that the murdered person was none other than Isaac Oxman,
a Jewish informer from the town of Urshits, who was well known to the authorities. And according
to Kenecksburg,
The Jews had murdered him together with another informer, Schmolosvartzman, who had also disappeared.
So, the governor instructed the chief of police, Saffronovic, to reopen the investigation.
In reply, the chief of police said, "Listen, we know who this oxman is, but this body
can't have been his because no one identified him."
So, the governor suspected that his officials weren't telling him the truth,
and he sent a personal representative to create an independent inquiry.
They had the body exhumed, and still, no one identifies it.
Now, the governor general gets involved, and he, in fact, writes to St Petersburg,
and it's passed on to the czar, who's informed of the case, and takes a personal interest,
and the body is exhumed a third time.
And this time, they find a doctor, a physician.
Dr. Focalman, who identified this guy because he'd been a patient at his clinic.
By the end of May 1836, Goryev, the general governor, is able to report that, in fact,
many Jews had been involved and arrested, and they are now trying to locate the actual murderers themselves,
who had, presumably, used this few months of gap to escape.
And in June, the czar tells him to submit a monthly report.
So, this is going to the highest echelons.
Now, these two, these Oxford and Schwarzmann, had been, what you would call,
thorns in the flesh of the Jewish Kihilis of the district.
They would tell a lot of people who had evaded military conscription.
And even when the Kihilis tried to bribe them,
they carried on.
The only thing they did is said things are going to get worse.
And therefore, the Jews, in the area, decided to kill them.
And they consulted with the original, who'd been staying in that district over a certain amount of time,
and he gave his consent.
Oxford was probably killed, traveling through the forest,
and therefore his body is thrown into the river and waited down.
Schwarzmann's body was never found, because he was strangled,
while he was doverning in the Ushitschul.
And his body was then cut up and burnt in the furnace of the mikfer.
Is that also part of our lochah, that they don't get a regular burial?
Well, they didn't want to leave any evidence.
It wasn't that they wouldn't normally bury them,
but they wouldn't bury them in the general part of the basic horses for sure.
But here, they did so for completely different reasons.
You're talking now about a murder that's basically committed in public,
and people keep quiet out of communal solidarity,
and they give no information to the authorities.
But by July 1836, 50 Jews arrested,
are now imprisoned in separate rooms in an old building,
which used to be a monastery, and they are interrogated,
and they are both mentally and physically tortured.
And as a result, almost all the details of the affair are exposed.
More Jews are now arrested,
including the Hasidic Rov Michal Averbuch,
who was the grandson of Rubsushia of Anipoli.
And he's also thrown into jail.
And his, in fact, his library is confiscated
in order for apostate Jews to go through the library to see
what response he has on this matter of killing Westerim.
Now, the prisoners' involvement was evident, basically, from the beginning.
But the police understand that if they arrest him,
there are thousands of Jews who are going to be up in arms,
so they're not sure quite what to do.
And it's only in September that this career, the Governor-General,
realizes how, as he put it, the unlimited power of Hasidic rabbis,
how broad it was, and therefore, he says, one way or another,
we're going to have to deal with this.
There was a trial.
And during this trial, one of the Muskelim,
a radical muskel called Joseph Pearl from Galicia,
presented evidence to the judges in March of 1838,
not only of the crime and the prisoners' involvement in it,
but that there has been an extensive appeal for funds
carried out in Galician Poland to pay for the suddix court expenses.
And even though you've got to, obviously, discount the layers,
the thick layers of anti-hasidic invective in Pearl's writing,
but you still understand how important the original was to his Hasidim.
And this Pearl adds that, notwithstanding what the prisoners have said,
it's quite clear that the original wasn't just involved,
but he was the reason that the murder took place where and when it did.
And what was that verdict in this case?
The court's verdict, so it was actually very harsh.
Six of the Elden E. Perna Sim, probably those who had first proposed the idea of murder,
were sentenced to lashes, hundreds of lashes,
banishment to Siberia and hard labor,
whereas the others were sentenced to confiscation of property,
exile, or police surveillance.
And when the authorities carried out the verdict,
the lashes were almost a guaranteed sentence of death,
especially for anyone who wasn't in very good form,
you know, the Olden the Week.
And many of the Jews died while the punishment was being administered.
And this of Michael Averbach was rescued on his way to Siberia
by a group of Jews who helped him flee Russia,
and he ended up initially in Galicia,
and then he moved to Hungary, where he died and where he's buried.
Is this angry with you? Is Pearl was the only one who was not put on trial?
Yes, there's a number of points coming together here.
The prisoners not being very open about the prisoners' involvement.
Even on the torture.
Even on the torture? Absolutely.
As you see from the court records,
and there was a lot of bribing going on,
so things were slowed down.
And as we mentioned, the authorities knew
that if they took any drastic action against him,
if they put him on trial,
they'd basically have to sentence him to lashes, they'd kill him.
And that would start a war.
But he was arrested.
He was arrested by the Governor-General of Beditrov,
brought to the czar,
and the czar was told that the reber is creating opposition to the government,
so the czar ordered the reber jailed for seven months,
and then he was placed in solitary confinement in Kiev for 15 months,
and they now decided they were mulling over whether they should exile him.
They wouldn't be able to carry out any punishment,
but they would just get rid of him by sending him to Siberia.
And this went on for a couple of years
where he was interrogated a question, shall we say, and imprisoned,
obviously uprooted from his town,
and from his hotel, his court in Rizhon, separated from his family.
And a rebel who didn't speak Russian is accompanied by an interpreter
who was the father of Ashr Ginsburg, the grandfather of Ashr Ginsburg,
the famed Zionist writer called Ahad Ham.
And this grandfather translated the investigators' questions,
gave them more ability to evade answering questions accurately
because between the translation and the response, so you have more time to think.
Must have been a major effort to try and release him, shall we?
There was, and there was nothing they could do, the maximum they were able to achieve
was occasional visits, and they could bring him food.
But beyond that, no.
Now, this isn't the first time that Hasidic leaders
have been arrested by the Russian authorities,
but in this case, there is real danger.
And the Sarshalam of Bells once said that he'd gone blind in one eye
because of the many tears he shed while the Rizhonah was in prison,
and the Kotska, who was not normally drawn into these things,
said that the Rizhonah is a real hero because he'd challenged the Tsar
as he put it to subdue the powers of that clipper.
And even outside, further afield, the Khassam Sofah was involved,
and as we mentioned, there was a financial appeal in Galitsia.
But on the 19th of February, 1840,
which was actually Shushan Purim,
the rapper was suddenly released,
by then the verdict had been carried out on all the other prisoners.
But because he was still accused of opposing the government,
he was placed on the police surveillance,
and for the next year and a half, he's in Rizhon,
[BLANK_AUDIO]
completely cut off from his recidim, he is not able to be a rebel, so he decided to move
to Kishenev, where the governor was likely to be more lenient.
But why would they allow him to move town?
Oh, I see. Well, that's because he said that he is now abandoned, the Robonus, and
he's now a merchant. He is in partnership with a Jew in Kishenev, and he needs freedom
of movement to make money. And because he was a member of the second merchant's guild,
there were three layers, three levels of it, it should be allowed to travel. And he moves.
And the Kishenev find out that the Tsar is still planning to go ahead with his idea
of exiling the rebel to Siberia, so they said, you know, going as far as you've gone,
he's not enough, you've got to get out of the country, you've got to get to Moldavia.
And literally, as he was leaving, the government orders for his arrest and deportation came,
the rebel leaves town, gets to the capital of Moldavia, and his plight is now a sort of
a cause celebre. People all over the world, even non Jews, are aware of what's going
on. And they decide that since Moldavia is too close to home, and the Russians had a
strong presence there, and they had an embassy, etc. So they got hold of a professional smuggler,
a guy called Nassen Shimon Horovitz, whose wife was in the admirer of one of the other
Sadikim, of May of Pramishlan. And he smuggled stuff across the border all the time, so he
had, let's say, good relationships with the Austrian border officials who received regular
bribes from him. And the original sets out with his shamers, and with his sheikhut Yudl
Landau, on a freezing cold night in January 1842. The road is blocked frequently by heavily
falling snow, and eventually the only way they can get across is by going across the river,
which is the natural geographical border into the Austrian Empire, the river's frozen.
So they make their way across on the horseback, but all of a sudden, the ice breaks beneath
the hooves of one of the horses, and the carriage starts sinking. So this smuggler carries
the original on his shoulders over the frozen river, and the river ends up in Sadikir.
That's how the original becomes Sadikir. And in that town, 40 years beforehand, a 10-year-old
boy, called Ysrold Domenfeld, had disappeared without a trace. And the river presents himself
as being that long-lost boy. And eight Jews testify, "Yep, this is who he is," and
he was born in Sadikir. "Present himself that way for the authorities."
Because this way, yeah, he's an Austrian national now, right? But the drama isn't over,
because the Russians are determined to bring him back and put him on trial for now fleeing
justice. They picked up his tracks, and of course, they didn't believe one word that this
Domenfeld story. And therefore, in July 1842, the Russian cult sealant requests the Austrian
authorities to extradite their escaped Russian subject. So his chasidim helped him buy
a property in the town, and they show that he's got the 20,000 crowns for his support,
which would enable him to get citizenship and the protection of the Austrian government.
And at the same time, he is trying through the efforts of Samosa's Montefuri to prevent
extradition. And there were, in fact, many people involved, one of whom, interestingly,
was Baron Solomon Mayer Rothschild, some of may aren't sure, who appealed to Metanik,
the Austrian Chancellor and Foreign Minister, who was a friend of his. Metanik was the most
important single figure in the Austrian Empire, definitely a pre-1848, and he gave instructions
not to extradite the Tudyk, and eventually, the Rebus family was finally allowed to join
him, they had to relinquish all rights and never go back to Russia.
And whilst this entire drama unfolds, due to the saga of them-formers.
Yes, due to most of them. Yep, it was a constant plague in Eastern Europe. And even though
what we've just described was an extreme case, but the community suffered on an ongoing
basis. And it was also another real undermining of the Kahal, and of the ability and authority
to function them and the Rabanim to have any say. So that's one area that Jews had to
live with constantly. The next area-
Well, you move on to the next area, is there any way we can understand this sort of
saga in history? Because as Jews, we'd like to believe that we all protect each other,
really naively, but the level you're describing is almost worse than the stories we used to
hear in World War II. It's people who are doing it for financial reasons, not for survival,
for money. How do we wrap our heads around this?
What you're finding, for instance, you have a town, maybe, of 5 or 10,000 Jews there,
and you've got three of them, three people, who are rotten eggs. It's a tiny percentage.
But with devastating effects. Yes, absolutely. And of course, once some existed, more are going
to come to, you know, scum will float to, you know, rise to the top of the water. That's
what's going to happen. Would you say it was more desperation than greed? I mean, you
needed money to survive then, again, just trying to justify it.
It is both. It might have started out that way, but definitely there were a number of these
most of them who were making a good living off what they were doing. And once you get into
that zone, you don't look back. I'm not sure if there is any other way back, but you definitely
don't. Okay, so let's move to the clothing decree to ban basically Jewish traditional clothing,
which is unbelievably ironic, because for centuries, Jews had been targeted and forbidden
to wear regular clothing. They had to be marked with specific Jewish symbols. And now there's
a 180-degree turnabout. They're being forced to abandon any type of distinctiveness. Now,
originally in 1804, under Alexander I, you do have some rules, but they only affected the few.
Any merchant who wanted to move to St Petersburg had to adopt local dress, and in fact, the police
were ordered to remove anybody from town dressed in Jewish clothing, and we even have a copy of
these rules translated from Russian into Yiddish. It's funny. We're talking about clothing. We've
had quite a few requests to do a podcast series specifically on clothing, the evolution of clothing,
and how Jews used to dress and how we've become more black and white now and how that sort of
evolved. So what did maybe we could just start off here? What did Jewish clothing look like
back then? Didn't they just dress like the local mobility? So yeah, that's pretty much the case.
In Eastern Europe, in Poland, etc. Once the era of having to wear a Jewish marking a yellow
clothing, or whatever it is, a yellow mark on the clothing had been dropped. So if you're talking
maybe the 17th and 18th centuries, at that point, they tended to adopt the type of clothes that
nobility would wear, particularly for Shabbos. In fact, I remember on my first visit to the Kremlin,
it wasn't by invitation. I went to the museum. So I saw on display, and I've got a photo of it,
Peter the Great's strimal. Looking very similar to the ones you would have seen, you know,
50 years ago, complete with the black velvet in the middle. The only difference is that
emerging from the middle of that black velvet was a cross, but in all other aspects, it's a strimal,
coloring, composition, etc. So that's what they would wear on Shabbos potentially,
and the rest of the time they would wear a long coat of cuffed-on. Obviously their hats were
distinctive, they would have beards, payers, and for women they would have head coverings, obviously,
and dress botanyers. Now, the Tsar viewed Jewish garments as visible sort of markers that
prevented assimilation into Russian society. And in fact, you find an official document that this
Jewish attire is called "repugnant". And when he is sitting with the ministers like Ovarov that
we mentioned last week, in the late 1830s and the early 1840s, dealing with education, he's dealing
with all areas where Jews need to be assimilated into Russian life. But in this particular area,
the Muskelem expressed great interest, because broadly speaking, there are two types of Muskelem.
There are those who are still relatively traditional and relatively religious. They just felt
that the way forward for Jewish emancipation is with greater entry into the world of non-Jews,
even if in certain ways you would now act like a non-Jew. But you have Muskelem, who were completely
convinced they were enamored by non-Jewish culture and education, and they were prepared to use
any means to move Jews away from anything that had been Jewish or Jewish communal life until that
time, and they had no problem in bringing the government on board, even though it was a Russian
government that had at their core a desire to eradicate the Jews or Judaism. And by 1841,
This decree had already been approved by the Tsar of Chenzhen.
clothing, but it was delayed in order to let the educational decree go first, and therefore
at this meeting, once again that we mentioned last time, where Rev. Voloshen and the Semachtetic
were present, so Rev. told the Russian Committee that if this clothing law became a rule for
all citizens of the Russian Empire, then the Jews would follow, but not if it specifically
targeted at the Jew, because he was of the Halachic opinion, that it's not Yohorig Valyava,
meaning it's not something for which one has to give up one's life for, it's not an area
of absolute emphasis, and if need be, Jews should go along with the decree, although it must
be said in this he was opposed by the Semachtetic, who felt that no, you actually need to go
out and fight with all your strength, and their difference of opinion is based on the
Gomorrah, it's based on the Gomorrah and somehedrin, that says that in a period of apostasy
of Shmud, not only are you allowed to resist, but you're allowed to give up your life to prevent
changing the way you tie your shoelaces, and we discussed this in the series on the
Rambam, and but surely the goals of the Tsar, what was apostasy, wasn't it?
Well, the question is, when there's no actual life and death situation to the Gazera, to
resist Shmud, do we still apply the definition of the era being one of Shmud, and therefore
this is a real halakhic question, it was a debate, and it affected hundreds of thousands
of Jews. Now, in 1844, the law now comes into being, initially it didn't force a change
of clothing, it just made the Jews pay, it taxed them if they wore Jewish clothing, and
you know, particularly in the merchant class, not only did each member over the age of
ten have to pay, but they had to pay a higher amount, it's ruinous, and this decree was
to run for about five years till 1850, after which all Jewish clothing would be forbidden,
and it covered the tax and the law, covered wearing silk, certain types of wool, the
puffed-on ghattles, strimal, a Yarmulka, a short Jewish style trousers, knee-high lace
trues, so having long pairs was part of the decree, and in certain areas having, in certain
places, having bids was also forbidden, and it has to be said that initially the Jews thought
this is going to blow over, this is just like, you know, insane, it's a radical, and therefore
their first reaction was, we'll just bribe the local authorities, we're not going to make
any change into the clothing, and you, for instance, have Ravyusha-Bear-Salvatri, the
Basel-Avy, the Father of the Prime, since he felt that this decree was within the term
of Yorugvaliavo, he fled to Galicia until the decree would be repealed, which he thought
would be, you know, coming in the next, who knows, months, year, or whatever, but the
decree wasn't simply on paper, the third directory brought the police in, Jews would be stopped
and arrested, if they hadn't paid their clothing taxes, the police would line weight, particularly
for Yorugvaliavo and they would remove their outer clothing in the street, and the enforcement
was often violent, there is an account which describes an incident on a train to crack
out, with three Jewish merchants, police officials confronted two of the men, they forcibly
cut off one of the men's payers, they stripped him of his, you know, sort of Jewish style shirt
and jacket, and then they attempted to cut their bids off, and there's another account
that tells us that in Minsk, the governor gathered horse-mounted police who sort of corraled
the Jews into courtyards, and by force, they cut off people's bids, and they cut their
coats so that no longer the longer type, all actions which humiliated the Jews.
We can visualize this, obviously, from the photos we have at the Arnold Coast.
Absolutely, yes, and the decree, I mean, to give you the scope, it also forbade wearing
a Yomelker Kippur, and in 1848, you had to pay five rubles a year to wear it, which is
about two weeks' worth of salary, so it's hundreds of pounds or dollars annually just
for this one item of clothing.
But isn't the fact that they allowed you to wear it for money, perhaps it was just greed,
rather than trying to get rid of it, why would they not allow you to buy your women?
No, because it allowed you to buy your women.
It was quite clear when it started that there will be five years, and that in 1850 the
law will forbid it altogether.
It wasn't that there was. It didn't get out. Yes, it wasn't that they sort of changed their minds five years
later and said, "You know something? We're going to go and make it a forbidden item."
That was always behind it.
So assuming the Jews didn't have the money to pay for the rights to wear their Kippur,
that meant they walked around bare-headed?
No, they were allowed to wear a Russian type of cap, but they couldn't wear what they're
the hat that they'd be wearing.
And by the way, women's dress was also subject to specific restrictions, particularly
mid-covering.
There is the law number 25113 is about the women being forbidden to shave their hair,
which was common practice, many married orthodox killers.
And also in some places they were forbidden, all type of hair covering, like turbans.
And this prohibition, a created, serious religious dilemmas, and in fact, according to one
religious source, is where the sort of adoption of wearing shatles of wigs as an alternative
form of hair covering comes from.
We have a memoir of somebody well known, Pauline Vengerov, which is a very valuable perspective
on the impact on the Russian Empire of these clothing decrees, especially on women.
It captures the loss experienced by orthodox people to whom dress was, you know, deeply
part of their religious identity.
And she writes that many Jews refused to leave their homes in the immediate aftermath
of these decrees, and that Cahillus had acts of mourning.
They had fast days.
They had trillus in order to try and bring this to an end.
And she also talks about the husband-wife impact of these laws because it created a
particular tension.
And she is speaking from a personal perspective because her husband, Honon, had basically
lost his faith and began pressuring her to abandon orthodoxy, including covering her
hair.
And in wealthier families, it was not unheard of that the men abandoned tradition and the
women wanted to hold onto it, and her husband's basically relentless pressure broke her resistance.
She had to abandon a kosher kitchen, and she wrote in her diary, "I have fought for
15 years to maintain my principles.
They are in my heart, my flesh and blood, now however they are shattered."
And these decrees removed authority from Jewish women in the sort of domestic religious
sphere.
Women had significant roles in their cushurists and hair covering.
It's very much the women's domain, and now they are doubly marginalised by the government
restrictions and by modernising Jewish men who embraced assimilation.
I wonder if the authorities knew the extent of the devastating impact it would have?
Because with men, it's one thing.
I mean, we dress traditionally, we have to cover our hair, it doesn't really make a difference
to any amokane, a cat, but for women, that's their essence.
How would you compare the impact of the clothing decree versus the education, or was clearly
both very devastating in their different ways?
The difference is that the education law was almost optional.
In other words, they were incentives, because if you enrolled in their schools, you exempt
from the Cantonese decree, but this was across the board.
It was intrusive, it's humiliating, it's applied in the public sphere of the street.
And that's supposed with education, you can always educate at home, that they had no
control of.
Right.
Now, being that Poland was obviously part of the Russian Empire, as we explained.
So a similar story unfolded there.
The difference is that the Chasidim were far less inclined to change any item of clothing.
Now, there's no single view.
The Kotzka was of the opinion that they should give in on clothing.
As was the Rizhner.
In fact, the way the Rizhner put it is Yaakov got the blessings from his father Yitzhak,
wearing Asov's clothing, Halavai, we should get those type of bros, that's what he said.
But you have Jewish killers adopting various adaptive strategies, some, basically reluctantly,
abandoned traditional dress entirely, others modified the appearance enough to avoid the
most severe penalties, but kept the essentials.
Some try to do so secretly, or they tucked in their payers under their hats, or they pinned
up their garment, but it wasn't a permanent change, or they only wore a couple in shawl.
And…
Is that where we get different Hermann Hagen, of where to put the payers?
Absolutely.
Yep.
And Rizhner went to meet with the Rizhner to figure out a strategy.
And one of the things they decided to do was write an official request to Samosa's Montefurian
England and ask him to do it.
to travel to Russia to meet the Tsar or one of his officials they didn't know who would
actually get to because Moses Montefuri had recently gotten involved in the Syrian blood
libel in Damascus and now seemed an opportune time to ask him to intervene on behalf of
Russian jury.
And presumably he would come with a full backing of the British government.
Yes, that's right and the Queen was he was a favorite of victorious.
So they write to him and the letter is dated to the Friday Pasha's Kisavai, written from
Warsaw and this was one of the main reasons behind his visit.
That's where the Jews are at in Poland.
On the non-Jewish front the police decided to concentrate their forces on Warsaw and
make it an example, especially because the Muschilim told them that the Khadusheorim,
first-guerreber, was the main troublemaker.
And there was a report given to Paschewicz who was the governor of Warsaw a week after
the law was supposed to come into effect, which said two-thirds of the Jews of Warsaw are
under the absolute influence of the Khadusheorim of Rabiachamea Alta and they are ready to go
through fire and water to obey his word.
And the reports from further afield weren't any better because he was told despite efforts
by the Cosax and other soldiers, despite the abductions and the beatings the Jews of
Warsaw by and large, as well as the Jews in the surrounding towns refused to change
their clothes and shave their bids.
And the concluding sentence says in light of the above there is no chance that the law
will pass peacefully.
So being the Russian government, they used force.
At the order of the governor the police arrived at the Gereber's apartment, who was still
in Warsaw at the time and demanded that he'd sign on the decree.
He refused and they arrested him.
For the crime of basically ordering his followers to oppose the law, the law had taken place
already by then a week earlier on April 1st, 1850.
This is already at a time where you could no longer pair tax where you now had to change
your clothing and a week later midnight April 8th the Khadusheorim is arrested.
And the new spreads, Jews in their thousands, come in the middle of the night and they march
on the prison.
And the government officials find out in the morning that from surrounding towns, Jews
are swarming towards Warsaw.
And you've got in this crowd, misnugged in Moschilim, even who felt at least the more
religious ones that this had gone too far.
And you even had Polish non-Jews that the government was finding a pretext to harm
one of the greatest men in the Polish nation, bearing in mind that you're talking about Polish
non-Jews who anyway didn't want to be controlled by Russia in the first place.
So Paskovich realizes his mistake.
And then there is a rumor that prison guards had forced the rebel to shave his beard.
And there's a riot that starts.
So he is released, part of the reason he was released because the Russian commander
was the brother of Zarnickelus of a very different type to his brother.
And he also had said, "Yeah, you've got to release the rebel."
And after Shabasagodil, the news came through, but that didn't mean that it was happily
ever after.
It is portrayed that way in certain quarters.
In other Khudusharim was released, and Boruch Hashem, the decree, came to an end, it's
complete fiction, because the episode continued if everything had got worse.
So that in 1855, Nicolas Zarn dies, and in many places, things quietened down as a result,
but not in Poland.
In Poland, it wasn't before 1863.
And you're talking besides for actual clothing, Jews are not allowed to walk in the street,
wearing talus and fillin, and Rabanim are not given any greater allowance, and every
shul has to have a copy of these decrees, every shul, every steable.
And ultimately, in fact, the Khudusharim was forced by the government and by circumstances
to sign his consent to the Russian clothing decree, along with the chief rabbi of Warsaw
of Haim Davidson, and the head of the basting of Praga, and we've got copies of that.
In the edition in Polish, clearly he must have held at that point, that it wasn't Kuzerius
Hashemad.
He told us this letter that he signed.
Well, it says, for instance, that anyone between the age of ten and sixty may not grow
long pairs, may not wear a strimal, may not wear a couple in the street, and it goes on
to say that we repeat this warning so that everyone carries out the laws of the government,
and the partial resolution that they got to was that in 1853, the government gave the Jews
in Poland to options.
They could wear Western European clothing, or they could wear Russian clothing, which
is where the dusk, the small caps, you know, that like the train drivers wear, that you
see in all these photos pre-war during the war, that became the common apparel of Hasidim
of Poland.
Whereas in Lithuania and other places, they often chose Western type of clothing, which
is why Haba changes from the strimal that they'd been wearing to a bent-down hat.
Now there is a fascinating addendum from the Orachasulchun.
He was one of the major Polish-Majahalachic authorities of the 19th century, particularly
in Lithuania.
And he writes in the halachas of the nine days, "The Medieval Authorities of the Roshrenim
require you to wear weak-day clothing on the shabbos before Tishabov."
And he adds that the previous few generations have changed that suck, and they allow you
to change to shabbos clothing, because otherwise you'd be observing public mourning during
shabbos.
To which the Orachasulchun asks, "But surely the Medieval Authorities of the Roshrenim knew
that public mourning is forbidden on shabbos, yet they told us not to wear shabbos garments,
what changed?"
And the answer he gives is exactly what we've been saying, that in the times of the Roshrenim,
the main difference between the two sets of clothing was not the appearance, but basically
the material it was made of, and then how new it was.
And therefore, wearing weak-day clothes wasn't a major departure.
Whereas more recently, so the 18th century, shabbos clothing was very different, especially
the hats, as he writes, "our hats in wearing a strimal" or "bashabos strimal".
By the way, his litvac, strimals were not specifically chasiddish in any way.
And that's why they had to change, in other words, the halacha, to wear shabbos clothes
because it would have been a very big difference.
And then he concludes by saying, "In our days, the late 19th century, shall peep
kudas ha malchus, that by degree of the Tsar, kvahech lafnut muna sabagodim, the clothing
has changed, vah shabbos vahchul muna aachas lahem, and shabbos and weak-day basically look
the same."
Now, it is my opinion, says Eurachashul Khan, that we should wear weak-day clothes on
this shabbos khasayn.
Wow.
I just want to rewind back for a minute.
You mentioned Samoza's Montafiori's visit.
Yes.
What happened with that?
Yes, so we entered last week with it, and we've touched on it a couple of times this
week.
So, yes.
He did meet with the Tsar.
He did discuss the situation facing the Jews, but he had significant obstacles.
There was, in his visit, what you could call success and failure.
Because historic journey to Russia in 1846 is one of the most significant diplomatic interventions
by a Jewish leader in the 19th century.
You know, the Tsar has ruled for decades over millions of Jews, but had never been forced
to speak to one as an equal.
It was unprecedented for this dictator, this Jew-hater.
Now, Montafiori obviously wanted to alleviate the conditions of Russian jury and encourage
Nicolas to follow the example of Western European countries which would grant the Jews equal
at least greater rights.
Now, firstly, he wasn't fully aware of how dire the situation was, although that wasn't
necessarily relevant, because the main problem was, despite Montafiori's diplomatic skill and
his credentials, the Tsar resisted any of his proposals, and he complained about the
negative influence of the Talmud that the Jews segregate themselves by wearing clothing
and their language, and they are involved in questionable economic practices, their smugglers.
So, you know, he wasn't given an inch, but as the first Jew to speak directly with the
Tsar about the condition of Russian Jews, he established a precedent, and likely contributed
to the longer term development in these Russian Jewish relations, because he comes back to
Russia in 1872, and therefore it is somewhat of a crack in the wall of official hostility
towards Jewish concern, and there's, of course, the symbolic value of his mission.
His journey showed Russian Jews that they weren't forgotten, and that a prominent and respected
Jewish leader was willing to brave considerable hardship to advocate on their behalf, and during
his stay, first of all, he met with delegations of Jews from across the Pale of Settlement.
He in fact, doesn't, with Jewish soldiers in St. Petersburg, in their army barracks,
and when he traveled home, because on the way there, he had deliberately not gone through
the Jewish pale.
settlement. On the way home, there are 30,000 Jews in Vilna, who come to see him, and
over 30,000 in Warsaw, and they welcome him as a hero, almost, you know, Mashiach. And his
visit becomes part of the folklore of Russian Dury, which is retold for generations.
Well, just don't stand one thing. Montefuri was educated. He had a Western education.
He wore Western clothing. Yeah. How did he actually view the Russian
degrees, which were basically saying to do what he probably did on some level?
Okay, so the first thing to understand is he's there to represent the Jews, and they're being
discriminated against. Although what you're saying is valid, because we mentioned that the
masculine were quite involved in trying to get clothing to be changed. And in fact, they were
almost anticipating positively Montefuri's arrival, because they were convinced that, as you say,
as a man of the modern world dressed in Western clothing, he would see their point of view.
And he arrives in town without knowing that these two opposing camps exist, and that were at
complete log-aheads. And when he is in Warsaw, the masculine understand that Hasidim want to
meet him in private. So all the way during his stay, they kept in his company. But the very last
day, the Khadusharim, the Vorkareber, and a number of wealthy Hasidim meet with him. And this is a
famous conversation they told him if Jews are forced into secular education, it will destroy the
chinoch of generations. And Montefuri answered that, surely from McGillis Ester, we see that Mordechau
was only able to save the Jews, because he spoke the languages of Bixon Viserache, who were plotting
against the king. He understood their language, to which they answered that no, that is a proof for
the exact opposite. Because if every Jew would have been known to speak all these languages,
then these two wouldn't have spoken in front of him. It's because it was so rare that the
salvation came about. And he was actually taken by the strength of their opinion on education,
but not when it came to clothing. He did feel they should change their clothing,
and this may or may not have contributed to the Khadusharim's ultimate conclusion, obviously
not halachically, but politically. See, this week's episode, as one of the last weeks,
just surprises me that we know so much, I say we that the messes know so much less about this
era in history than the Holocaust, because other than obviously the genocide is the main difference.
But this is recent history, and Jews, you know, target to debt, unable to wear clothing,
unable to be educated. This was as devastating in many ways. What we're not finished with
the Russian Empire, aren't we? Yes, we have so much more to cover because, I mean, to give you as an
example, people are aware of the Groms in Russia, which are yet to come. We haven't covered that,
which caused millions to leave, because by then they had grown from 600,000 to closer to 6 million,
but there are three SARS, there's Alexander the second, Alexander the third, Nicholas the second,
and then there is the revolution, and I don't mean the one in 1917, I mean the one in 1905.
So that's for next week. Robert, here's thank you, as usual, any questions, any feedback,
please send podcasts at jaleigh.org.uk, don't forget to subscribe, and thank you for listening.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The Russian Empire enforced strict clothing decrees targeting Jewish traditional attire, forcing Jews to either pay heavy taxes or abandon their distinctive garments, including strimales, yarmulkes, and long coats.
These decrees were met with deep religious and cultural resistance, especially among Hasidic communities, who viewed traditional dress as central to their identity and faith.
In response to violent resistance, authorities arrested leaders like the Gerber and Rizhner, who refused to endorse the laws, leading to public riots, arrests, and the eventual forced signing of compliance by Jewish leadership.
Jewish informers were systematically targeted and sometimes executed by Jewish communities, especially when they revealed evaders or evaded conscription, creating internal conflict and fear.
The government’s suppression of Jewish religious practices—such as banning hair shaving and head coverings—deepened divisions within Jewish communities and undermined rabbinic authority.
Despite diplomatic efforts by figures like Moses Montefuri, who met with the Tsar and advocated for Jewish rights, the Tsar remained resistant, prioritizing assimilation and control over Jewish autonomy.
The clothing and education policies were not isolated; they were part of a broader campaign of forced assimilation that disrupted communal life and created lasting trauma.
The resistance to these policies, including public mourning and acts of defiance, demonstrated the strength of Jewish identity and the deep-rooted cultural significance of traditional dress and practice.
Summary:
The Russian Empire implemented a series of oppressive policies targeting Jewish communities, most notably through forced assimilation via clothing and education decrees. A key policy in 1844 mandated that Jews pay taxes for wearing traditional garments, escalating to a full ban by 1850, which led to widespread resistance, humiliation, and public riots. Jewish leaders like the Gerber and Rizhner were arrested for defying these laws, sparking mass mobilization and public protests, especially in Warsaw.
The policies were rooted in a broader effort to erase Jewish distinctiveness, with traditional clothing seen as a marker of separation. Many Jews, especially in Hasidic communities, resisted by maintaining their customs, leading to internal conflict, including the targeting and killing of informers who exposed community members. These actions created deep religious and social trauma, with women particularly affected by hair-covering bans.
Despite diplomatic interventions by figures like Moses Montefuri, who met the Tsar and advocated for Jewish rights, the government remained unyielding, viewing Jewish traditions as obstacles to assimilation. The failure of these policies to pass peacefully exposed the resilience of Jewish identity and the profound impact of state-sanctioned cultural suppression, marking a dark chapter in Jewish history that remains underappreciated compared to the Holocaust.
FAQs
The Russian government introduced a clothing decree in 1844 that initially taxed Jews for wearing traditional clothing. By 1850, the law completely banned Jewish traditional attire, including strimales, yarmulkes, and long coats, forcing Jews to adopt Western or Russian-style clothing.
Jewish communities resisted because traditional clothing was deeply tied to religious identity, especially for women, who covered their hair as a religious obligation. The decree was seen as a direct attack on religious practice and cultural heritage.
Police forcibly removed Jewish clothing from citizens, sometimes using violence. In 1850, the governor ordered the arrest of Rabbi Geriot, who refused to sign the decree, leading to a mass protest by Jews who marched on the prison, forcing the government to release him.
Yes, some religious authorities, like the Orachasulchun, argued that the change in clothing was a significant departure from traditional practice, especially since in earlier times, the difference was only in material and newness, not appearance.
The decree banned women from shaving their hair and wearing head coverings, causing deep religious and emotional distress. Women like Pauline Vengerov described the loss of identity and the pressure to abandon traditions, especially when their husbands pushed for assimilation.
Yes, in 1853, the government offered Jews in Poland a choice: to wear Western or Russian-style clothing. This allowed some to adapt, though many, especially Hasidim, continued to wear traditional garb in private or secretly.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.