And that meant a ready market for kidnappers because one of the clauses in
there was that any Jew caught away from home without a passport could be placed
in the army. So Jewish gangsters and unfortunately when we talk about the
Huppers and the gangsters were talking about Jews. They roved the highways, they
invaded ins, they attacked lone Jews, tore up their papers and delivered them to
the nearest police station, recruiting station and got money for it. Well this
wasn't just to protect their own. No. Welcome to History for the Curious. I'm
Manor Eisner and I host the International Renowned Lecturer, Dynamic
Historian and Tour Guide, Brabhai Aubrey Hirsch. Experience our history, confront
dilemmas and reveal the untold stories of three thousand years of Jewish
heritage, from Paris to Cairo, from the Russian's art to my monodies and from the
silent revelation to the French Revolution. Join the fastest growing Jewish
history podcast in the world by subscribing to this channel and discovering the
events that have shaped us into who we are today.
Brabhai Hirsch, welcome back to part two of our series on Russia. Just before we
start I wanted to tell the listeners about a very exciting upcoming trip. This is
organized by a American tour company called La Leche and they are a luxury
American tour operator. They're doing a high end tour of Italy which is going to
be guided by Brabhai Hirsch and featuring Robert Tets. It takes place from the
fourth to the eighth of May so in a couple of months right after Paisach and
it's almost sold out. The listeners might have seen the advertisements and we
visiting Rome, Venice, Padua and other places staying in beautiful hotels with two
of the best educators in the world. No bias there to find out more go to La Leche
dot com and there'll be more than happy to answer any queries.
Brabhai Hirsch, this is part two and just as a way of very brief recap for hundreds
of years no Jews were allowed to live within the Russian Empire and then
suddenly between 1772 and 1795 Russia swallowed up all of Lithuania, Ukraine,
Belarus, most of Poland and effectively these countries ceased to exist and
Russia now has 600,000 unwanted Jews in the Empire which created a lot of a lot
of issues. The main problem was that there was no niche in society for them. In
Western Europe they were at least tolerated somewhat even emancipated, may have
been excluded from certain jobs and pay higher taxes but they were left alone.
In the east religion was the dominant way of looking at Jews and therefore
they could never be included, never be trusted.
The idea was to put them in a ghetto, a ghetto that would encompass 5% of the
Empire which is very, very large but that still didn't solve the problem. So then
the idea became to exile them on mass to new areas, change their occupations and
quite literally their religion which is where we're up to now, on to part two.
So in effect the Russian way of solving the Jewish problem was to treat this
people like the plague that must be quarantined. As we mentioned Napoleon
brought a halt to the deportation of the Jews but as soon as the French
suffered a setback in 1807 the Russian government decided to proceed and
there's our instructed the governors of the Western provinces that the Jews
needed to be resettled but there's a huge gulf between Russian theory and
Russian practice, things take a while to filter down from St Petersburg to the
governor of the province, from the governor to the chief of police and there are
delays and there are bribes and then in 1812 war broke out for real, France
invaded Russia with half a million men and the Zan now has other priorities on
its hands so the Jewish problem was shelved. In 1817 Alexander comes back to
it and again in 1824, 20,000 Jews are forced to leave their places of
residence and give up their basically sources of livelihood and then the
resettlement is halted again but in an attempt to reduce smuggling Jews were
forbidden to live within 30 miles of the border. Was there no other type of
solution? I mean yes they definitely were you know as we mentioned Russia was and
is a vast place and had a very small population so the interior of Russia was
pretty empty and it was particularly empty of middle-class people the ones who
could develop the country's resources it would have definitely been to the
government's advantage to encourage Jews to settle throughout Russia and put
their energies to work serving Russia's economic needs but the merchants
especially in Moscow wanted no competition from the Jews. Now most of Russia's
population was rural maybe another 5% lived in towns the upper class the
gentry who were only 1% the clergy who were perhaps another percent and you
have the military the merchants and the officials. And you've said that the Jews
were poor was that all Jews was there no one affluence? You can't say no one
because there were registered Jewish merchants and some had money. Let's say
there are 10,000 of them let's say they're 15,000 of them that's what 3% of
the Jewish population and you did have some muscular a few thousand who had
defected from Judaism but that leaves 90% of the Jews without
options and therefore when we talk about the Jews that is
everybody really and from 1815 to 1825 there is a gradual
slide by Alexander towards force and ideas are drawn up for mass
conversions and then he dies in 1825 he's succeeded by his brother Nicholas
the first although rather than breathe a sigh of relief his brother was so
murderously reactionary that in contrast the years before 1825 seemed quite
mild because Nicholas believed totally in the principles of autocracy and
divine right he was made a kernel when he was in his cradle he was a general
at the age of 12 and he was only basically interested
in military matters in fact he never wore civilian dress
the moment he becomes a he enlarged strengthens the army
although army officers had organized a conspiracy with the goal of changing the
system of government and putting a republic in its place
and they struck these plotters in December 1825 just after Alexander
the first died but they were very badly led they were dispersed
and Nicholas arrested 3000 decemberists as they were called
he hung five of their leaders exiled hundreds to Siberia
and at that point the answer he gave to the cry for reform
was not more freedom but more discipline and in fact part of the new national
anthem was rain that our foes may quake and therefore in 1930
when the kingdom of Poland revolted against Russian rule
Nicholas crushed the uprising with a savagery that
boaded ill not just for the polls but basically for everyone in his empire
and in fact there's our detested minority nationalities within his empire
because he was convinced that they are intrinsically
disloyal and they have to be absorbed into Russian life
so he created a secret police initiative called the third section
he is discipline crushed any criticism and while he was still a grand duke
he had made a tour of Russia and returned convinced that the Jews
were nothing but leeches but although the Jews therefore
didn't expect emancipation under Nicholas they were unprepared
for his ruthless vindictive anti-Jewish campaign
from the outset Nicholas made it clear that he regarded the Jews
as an alien people and in August 1827 an event happened which we are all
aware of Nicholas issued what became known to us as the cantonist
decree although its name actually occurs much
earlier than that because there had been a conscription
law into the army in Russia since 1721 for the non-Jews
and the word cantonist is not a word uniquely used for the Jews
it means the canton the regional schools are required to provide
recruits what changed in 1827 is that the draft of 25 years in the army
becomes 31 years now military service normally starts
at the age of 18 Nicholas the first thought that that's too late
to begin ridding the Jewish conscript of their religious superstitions
so he lowered the age for Jewish soldiers to the age of 12
imposing on these children in extra six years
and
And during those six years, they were sent to Russia's remote interior where, remember,
Jews can't set foot because the Jews are only living in five percent of the empire,
so they are hundreds of miles away from any Jew.
And then these Jewish recruits are trained in the "proper faith".
And then at 18, they start their 25-year service.
25 years?
25 years post these six years.
And one of the most twisted aspects of this decree was its requirement that the Kahals
themselves furnish the Jewish recruits, which would basically destroy the Jewish self-government
in the eyes of its own people, because it wasn't uncommon for wealthier families to bribe
the Kahals authorities into recruiting from poor neighborhoods, and the bitterness of
the Jews towards the Jewish rich, which we come across in the 1700s in terms of the revolt
of Hacidus, reaches its greatest intensity during the conscription era.
And there's a famous poem which they've sort of rhymed into English that "Rich Mr.
Rockever has seven sons and not one a uniform don's, but Paul Widow-Layer has an only child
and they hunt him down as if he were wild".
And what would happen if you had a Jewish community that just wouldn't meet its quotas?
And just wouldn't get conscripted?
The Tsar was absolutely ruthless about this if a recruit was missing, almost anybody
could be taken in his place.
The family's father, relative, and elder of the Kahals.
The Tsar gave them a choice.
You either become kidnapper or you replace the person who's gone missing.
And that means that at one stage every missing Jew would result in Jews being taken off
the streets.
In fact at one time he said three Jews will be taken for everyone that's missing.
Probably presented many moral quantities about escaping.
Well, and what it would do to the families, it's not just what it would do to the Kahals.
And parents basically had to stand by and see their children taken off to the Eastern
Provinces to Siberia.
In fact there's an account from the Hebrew writer Eil Levin who saw a transport start on
its long journey and he describes the scene.
Near a house stood a large and high wagon to which a pair of horses were harmless.
Soldiers brought out children from the house one after another and deposited them in the
wagon.
Soon it was packed to capacity.
Children were sitting or lying on top of each other, like herring in a barrel.
Others, mothers and relatives stood around.
A person who has not seen the agonized parting of parents from their little children and
who has not heard their helpless lamentations that penetrate to heaven does not know real
tragedy.
One father gives his boy a little book of Tehilim, another hand his son Tehilim.
From all sides are heard admonitions.
Remain Jew no matter what happens, hold fast to Yiddishkite.
Mothers ring their hands, the hopeless tears never stop.
Parents of agony and cries of despair resound and the wagon begin to move to the accompaniment
of piercing cries and shouts.
Now the officers in charge were instructed to take the children east by wagon but sometimes
they simply pocketed the money and soon after leaving the village they would drive these
young children on foot and records show these journeys to remote regions could take a full
year and the children slogging month after month through dust and mud and snow and ice,
beaten, sickening and dying.
You have an account from the Russian Revolutionary non-Jew Alexander Herzen.
He was serving a sentence in exile.
He came across a group of these Jewish children and he spoke to their sort of transport officer
and he said, "Whom are you escorting and to where?"
And the answer was, as you see a horde of damned little Jews eight to ten years of age,
at first they were supposed to be taken to Perm, then the order was changed, we're driving
them to Kazan.
I took charge of them for a hundred vests, the officer who handed them to me said, "It's
a misfortune.
A third of them remained on the road."
The officer pointed his finger downwards.
Not half will reach their destination, they die like flies.
The children were lined up in proper formation, it was one of the most terrible sights I have
ever witnessed.
Poor unfortunate children, the twelve and thirteen-year-old lads were still to holding up somehow, but
the little ones of eight and ten.
No brush could create such horror on a canvas.
Pale, exhausted, frightened, they stood in their clumsy army overcoats, eyeing pitfully
and helplessly the soldiers who lined them up roughly.
Their lips, their eyes, indicated how feverish there were, gusts from the Arctic sea blew
in, without care or help, they were marching on towards their graves.
And as you've heard in this extract, even children as young as eight were taken, there
was no absolute discretion made that they have to be twelve.
If they weren't married, they could be snatched off the streets and sent into the army
at any age.
Jews had to find a way out, and boys still, at the age to be playing marbles, were married.
There's a famous story in Russian Jewish folk humour about a Jew who saw a child playing
on the street and asked him why he wasn't at school.
So the child said, "I don't go to school anymore, I was married yesterday."
So he was asked, "If you got married yesterday and you're now the head of a family, why aren't
you wearing long trousers?"
So he says, "Yes, today I got married, so I wore the trousers.
Today my little brother is getting married, so he's wearing the trousers."
But you know, it's a bitter galechter.
And the stories emerging from this period are a series of tragic memoirs, stories of
the happers who roam the streets at night waiting for an opportune moment to burst into
the house of a family where there is a Jewish child and seizing that child.
Mother's screaming in agony as their offspring was torn from them, of hundreds of boys hiding
in the woods when news of the arrival of a team of these happers reached the community.
And in hiding they lived a nightmare because there could have been an informer almost
anywhere.
What's officially done to terrorize the Jews?
Was there any element of it to actually create a large military?
Yeah, it was not done to create a large military, very rarely, were they taken initially into
the army and they could never become officers.
What were they doing when they got to their destination at the age of ten?
So they hoped, they, as in Nicholas I, hoped to turn them into Christians.
And because the physically unfit were rejected, another root of escape was self-mutilation.
They amputated their own fingers and toes, they deffin themselves, they blinded themselves
rather than enter service.
There is an account by a woman called Mary Antin who came from Plotsk, who said it was
also possible to bribe the conscription officers, which was very dangerous because if the negotiations
leaked out, it wouldn't be the officers who paid the price.
And people basically gave away everything they had to keep their children out the army.
And because the conscription law had 95 clauses, there were openings for corruption.
Parents could save their own sons by supplying a substitute.
So Jewish gangsters, and unfortunately when we talk about the happers and the gangsters
were talking about Jews, they roved the highways, they invaded Inns, they attacked lone
Jews, tore up their papers and delivered them to the nearest police station, recruiting
station and got money for it.
Well, this wasn't just to protect their own.
No, wow.
So they were making money from it.
And as I say, unfortunately we're talking about Jews, a specter that would re-exist in
the Second World War, Schmalz Sofniks.
And many parents tried to keep the birth of their children the secret, they didn't register
a newborn, and these kids were known as Malochim because they lived, but they didn't exist.
And you know, once the children were conscripted, no family, no Jewish family ever expected
to see them again, or at least not as Jews, and they were presumed lost to their people.
And when they left, the parents would say, "Cardish".
I think these ten-year-olds were sort of a false conversion took place.
What did that look like?
Thousands and thousands of these young Jewish boys?
When they got to this destination, this can only be described as a lie.
There was a partial of Kyrgyzher Shem.
They were formed into battalions, and their religious training began.
And every means was used to induce them to convert.
The priests worked on them, and when he failed, which he normally did, the non-commissioned
officers turned to force.
One method was to make the child kneel on the barracks floor when bedtime came,
and if he consented to be baptized, he was allowed to sleep in his bed,
if not he was kept on his knees all night until he collapsed,
and the stubborn ones were beaten or tortured.
If they refused to eat pork, they had more beatings.
They were fed on salted fish and then denied water unless they agreed to baptism.
Kids, right? Most of the younger ones gave up, they were baptized, the older ones,
endured the whippings, the hunger, the thirst, the sleeplessness,
refusing to betray their faith, and some of them were whipped to death,
some of them were drowned.
There were basically few tortures too brutal for the barrack masters to apply,
and sometimes Jewish recruits preferred suicide to baptism.
And there's a famous account when Zan Nicholas,
a Mashaemoy, inspected a military headquarters at Kazan,
and arrangements were made to have groups of Canton Jewish children baptized
in the Tsar's presence, and they were brought to the banks of the Volga River,
and at the Tsar's command the children were submerged and never came up deliberately.
Once again quoting from Mary Anton, she says the non Jews used to wander at us,
because we cared so much about religious things, about food, about shabbos,
and teaching the children, Oshankadish, they were angry at us for our obstinacy and they mocked us.
Do we know roughly numbers of how many children these were?
We'll come to that in a moment when we talk about the numbers,
because it is relevant to how it played itself out more broadly.
Now, as I mentioned, these soldiers, even if they survived, they were not trained for combat,
they were orderlies, and it was a very lonely life, even their next 25 years in Arby's service.
Remember, they're separated from faith, from community, they couldn't become officers,
and a high proportion of those who completed their service, who lived through it,
entered it as invalids, and returned to civilian life still as Jews, and therefore second-class
citizens. In Western Europe, army service brought the Jewish soldier equal rights, not in Russia,
and there is an account from Maurice R. Cohen, who talks about his childhoods in the town of
Neshviz. He recalls the frequent visit to his home of the water carrier, who was an old man who'd
been a soldier in Nicholas's army. He'd been taken away from home as a very young boy,
and kept in some non-Jewish institution until he was 18, and then spent 25 years in the Russian
army in the Crimean War, and after his discharge, he comes back to Neshviz, he gets married,
and on his meager earnings as a water carrier brought up two adopted children, and whenever he came
to the house to deliver water, this Maurice Cohen writes that he and my grandfather would exchange
stories of the olden days. Now, as part of the problem, and we will define how deep this problem
becomes, three categories were exempted from the army, registered merchants, graduates of Russian
schools, and rabbis, so the burden of military service fell on the poor Jews. Why were rabbis
exempted? We'll come back to this. But what it means is that the Zahs' conscription plan turned
the Kahul into police dogs tracking down recruits. It created professional informers. These
Mosrim became a plague. They threatened to inform against the Kahul whenever the Kahul took steps
to avoid the draft by things like false registration, and they asked bribes in return for silence.
A gang of these informers operated in Minsk, and one of their victims was the father of
Ephraim Zitsky, who wrote what happened to his parents. When it came time for my father to serve
in the hated Russian army of the Zahs, his widowed mother, whose sole support was my father,
hit on the idea of changing his elder brother's name and entering him in the town's death records,
this imaginary death earned my father the right, as the first born, to be exempted from military
conscription, but to live the rest of his life without papers. Unluckily for him, however,
my father passed from the frying pan of military service into the fire of these informers.
They learned of my grandmother's ruse and proceeded to make my father's life miserable.
Under the threat of denouncing him to the authorities, they extorted money from my father.
They visited her home from time to time, loudly banging their fists on the table they would yell,
"We're assessing you so much and so much. You have to deliver it by this date or we will turn
you in." And vainly, my father and mother pleaded with them to have mercy, and they basically had
to hand over money that they saved by stinting on food. One day, the informers dropped in on my mother
when she was alone, and told her that they were holding my father at one of their hideouts,
and they would hand him over to the police if she didn't pay up within an hour.
My mother was pregnant at the time, in the seventh month, her heart constricted with anxiety.
Where was she to get the money? At that very moment, she went into labor,
knelt, and gave birth to a live child for once. But she was alone in the house and fainted
during the birth. When she regained consciousness, the infant had died. My mother recovered physically
from this old deal, but lost her mind. And that was what Jews were doing to other Jews.
These blackmailers terrorised communities to the point where assassination became the victims
only means of self-defense in one neighbourhood in 1838. The court indicted 80 Jewish elders
for murdering two Jewish informers, 20 of whom were sentenced to convict labor camps.
With this amount of Masira going on and self-defense, which I don't know how logically where that stands,
but where would there be a bottom in all this? Were there any history statements on what to do?
So I will talk about Masira more next week, but to understand in terms of the conscript,
the worst and most permanent outcome of the Cantonese decrees was not how many children were taken
to get back to two of the points that you raised earlier. The worst thing was the destruction
of the Kehilla and of the Rabbinate, especially because the rabbis were exempted as we mentioned earlier.
Because the actual Cantonese quota was four children for every thousand. So in total numbers,
it was thousands every year, not hundreds of thousands, but the fear, the brutality, the corruption,
the fact that anyone could be taken as a replacement and the goal that the Russians had
of destroying the morale of the Jews, that became all pervasive.
And some Rabanam did what they could at great risk. There was an organisation to rescue
children forced into military service run by Rabnachem Mendelschnerson, the Temarterek,
bribing the kidnappers with exorbitant sums who would in turn report to the authorities
that the children died on route. And wherever his sort of underground railroad couldn't operate,
he instituted a secret program to try and instill in these children a resolve to remain faithful
Jews and they sent Khasidim into the main area of Russia to army bases just to try and offer
encouragement so they should meet a Jew. But how many did it help? The very few. And the
Rebbe was held under surveillance by the third section by the secret police. Yorsevropisrael
Selant. He was only 17 when the first decree came out in 1827, but by the 1840s he was known
across Eastern Europe. And in his town, his stettle of Selant, there was a quota that they had
to deliver one child for military service. And the rich people began looking at the poorer parts
of town to try and find someone. And then a poor widow comes to town. She went from house to house
with her music box, getting stucker accompanied by her orphan son. And the heads of the community are
happy at this stroke of luck. They did get hold of the boy. They changed his name to one of the
local children and enrolled him for military service. They're by fulfilling their quota.
And the widow is beside herself. She runs from house to house banging on the doors of the communal
leaders to no avail. Now at that stage, Rebbe Selant was no longer living in Selant, but he came
back for Shabbos. He arrives in town and this woman sees sort of, you know, a respectable looking
person in front of her. So she falls at his feet and she begs him to save her son.
Rebbe Selant listens to what's going on and says, "Come back after Shabbos." And that Friday night
Shabbos morning, Rebbe Selant comes to Dovening, he says nothing at all. After Dovening and Shabbos,
all these sort of local dignitaries, they host him in a kiddish. They had just finished drinking
their wine from kiddish and Rebbe Selant gets up and began calling them names. You murderers,
you kidnappers. He knew them all individually. He turns on them one by one. You, he says to the first
one, you're such a sadik that you tore your hands.
retrieve around your neck on chabbos even when there's an air of, yet you don't wander
or bother about the posseuk that Gwynev Ishrumahari Moisumus, that somebody who kidnaps somebody
is five mises deserving of the death penalty, he turns to the next one, you're so careful
about your mitzvus with the khaluk of a hamura, but you don't have a problem handing over
a Jew to forcible conversion, he starts with the third one, you only eat schmura mutter
and you have the nicest esurug, and you don't care about al-mona mistreating a widow,
the punishment for which is misubidation of maim, and he carried on with the fourth and
with the fifth, no one said anything, and he sat down, and then he changed his mind,
he jumped up, and he said it's forbidden to keep company with such criminals, and he left
the house, and he walked out of town, middle of chabbos, and the new spreads about the
Tzadaqadir has denounced the local congregation and fled, and they are publicly disgraced, and
finally they get Raviliyau of Kretinger who'd been at that kiddash to find Ravisrul,
so he's searching around, you know, outside of town within Trumshabbos, and he finds
Ravisrul, and Raviliyau says to him, "la hachriv ilami yaitsasa, have you left your anonymity
in order to destroy my world? Because this is what the bus curl, this is what the heavenly
voice said to Ravisrul and Bayehai, after he'd been in the cave for 12 years, and he comes
out, and everything he looks at is burnt." Now he must have been right Ravisrul and Bayehai,
because otherwise things wouldn't have been destroyed when he looked at them. Nevertheless,
the bus curl says, "Have you come to destroy my world? Go back to the cave, it's impossible
for the world to exist." And Raviliyau said to Ravisrul Salant, "It's a Makassamadina,
it's a country-wide curse, and that was, of course, the bottom line. The tragedy was
that the Jews and the Rabbinim could do almost nothing."
"What was the end of the story? Was the child freed?"
"Yes, but in a way, how does that help? The killer still had to deliver a child to
the army." "What's else thinking? When Ravisrul Salant was saying all those things to the
kiddish, then I'm assuming he was talking about the fact that a child was chosen, rather
than it being selected somehow from heaven, like by Lacha."
"A lottery or something, yes. But nevertheless, what he was experiencing is how we describe
Meshir Arbenu, Vajarbosivlosa. Meshir couldn't save the Jews in Egyptian slavery, but
he could empathize. He could be Meshdatev in their pain. Feel it. And that is Musa's
most famous line made famous by Ravisrul, "Mahevasi Baulami. What is my duty in this world
from Meshir Arbenu?"
That question is true even when you're unable to make a practical change. And we need to
understand that Musa, the Musa movement, wasn't conceived in an historical vacuum. This
Cantonist decree was part of the impetus behind creating the Musa movement. The Guzera had
the effect of destroying people's ability to act Yosherr, turned people into accomplices
of the Russian government. How do you survive this? Not that it creates self, but you yourself,
the destruction of the Kehilla. This period would redefine the Klaal and the Yochhe, the
visual and the community. And we come out of the 19th century and nothing is the same
again. It is a swamp, a force and fraud created by the Russian government and the Jews became
demoralized because you could be drafted at home or kidnapped on the streets. Jew turned
against Jew. And the sense of insecurity in a non-Jewish world, you know, that had been
around since exile, but now there were terrible new pressures exerted by the Tsar. And all
of this is only part of it because constription is not the end of Jewish disabilities. The consuming
hatred of Nicholas I for the Jews was so all-encompassing that you almost wonder that he found
time for anything else. In the 30 years of his reign, he issued 600 degrees against them.
In 1835, even though he did not expel them all in the same way as Alexander had intended,
but the Jewish area, the zone in which they could live was drastically reduced. And by
1855, when he was still around, the pale of settlement was smaller than Poland had been.
And he didn't abandon his efforts to bring the Jews in through agriculture. In 1835, the
government opened the wastelands of Siberia to colonization. And they promised not to conscript
the children of Jewish farm families, which is no small incentive. And several thousand
Jewish families migrated eastward to Siberia, northward. But the few Jews who survived the
long trek found the Siberian soil frozen. The tools and equipment which had been promised
to them had been confiscated or sold by corrupt officials. And of the 14,000 Jews who reached
Siberia, the majority of the died or returned to the pale in rags and destitute.
Which makes the Holocaust in a way even harder to understand from historical perspective.
This was only one hundred years before, from man who had clearly a lot of time on his hands,
issued six hundred degrees to make Jewish life almost unbearable. Then you have Hitler
who came around a hundred years later who just decided to kill them all. To get, integrate
them into society, just kill them.
It's because of technology that he was much more successful. And if we go back to what
we mentioned last week, 1648, 49, it was an absolutely terrible time, horrific time. But
because they were killing Jews by hand, there's a limit to how much damage they can inflict.
The Germans who were the most advanced nation on earth at the start of the Second World
War managed to bring all of that technology to bear. And that's why they managed to unfortunately
wipe out the numbers they did. I think most people on myself definitely don't usually
think of the Holocaust as a way that as it happens in modern history, just because of technology
you think that the Germans were somewhat unique. But no, since the beginning of time and
you want to have the ability, you would have carried this out.
Correct. Now Nicholas amongst his decree so you know,
Schaul's can't be placed near churches. And he puts their entire spiritual life under
surveillance. Jews were not allowed to use Hebrew, Yiddish, in documents or commercial papers.
Then the police begin a censorship drive against Jewish svarima books. Printing presses and
private libraries were subjected to continual and heavy-handed ransacking. Thousands of
books were burned. And the Russians understood almost nothing of what they were doing. You
find in 1844 that the Minister of the Interior, Center Report to the Tsar, containing a piece
of information that there was a secret Jewish volume called "Rumbum" which required Jews
to kidnap Jewish children, murder them and drink their blood. And in another report that
the Minister of Education submitted in 1850, the Rumbum was recommended as a textbook immorality
for Jewish youth. And then the government decided that books coming in from abroad are
dangerous. So they were ordered to bring all these books that had not been screened. They
were being forwarded to St. Petersburg. And then the Tsar decided that far easier just
let's just burn all of them, which is what they did. But it has to be said, if conscription
failed to amalgamate the Jews, if the harsh taxes, if the expulsion degrees and the other
systematic abuses didn't drive the Jews towards Nicholas I, but rather into adamant resistance,
then I guess it's hardly surprising that this brutal and clumsy censorship would also prove
fruitless. Now, finally on the Catherine II and Alexander I, as we mentioned last week,
the Kahals were deprived of much of their authority. They basically had no fiscal rights or really
administrative functions. The Tsars, Nicholas I's solution was even simpler. In 1844, he
ordered the in the liquidation of the Kahal. And the Jewish community is now under Russian
administration. But the Tsar hadn't reckoned on community discipline. He could suppress
the Kahals, but there were self-help associations, which were called chevres, and they became the
real guardians of Jewish communal life. They answered to an extraordinary wide variety of
occupational, educational, religious, and philanthropic needs. There was a chevra devoted
to chevracaditia, right? They're undertaking burial, et cetera, and finding plots in the
cemetery. There was a chevra which maintained orphanages and homes for the elderly. There
was a chevra for each made a craft, for the cobblers, for the carpenters, which provided
if a member became destitute. There was even a chevra that walled the Kahila if the
the hoppers were in the vicinity, and they were all voluntary, but every Jewish town and
village had one. And now, because the Kahal and the Rov is no longer seen as an authority
by Russian law, so it's voluntary to go to the Bezden, but that's what they did. He
regarded his Jewish subject with unqualified loathing and presented them with two alternatives.
You can become Christians, or you will die one way or another, a slow death or a quick
death. With all this going on, what did Jewish life look like there? Were you able to remain
a Jew at all? In spite of every conceivable repressive measure, the Jews remained a cohesive
mass. In the main, they were devout, in religion, and they were separate, and the more they
were abused, the more stubborn they became. In a typical Jewish state, so the shawl remained
the religious, cultural, educational, and social centre. And there was always a shawl, even
if it had to be built by borrowing money from neighbouring communities. Now, we're not
talking about imposing shawls. It was a slate grey house, which was dilapidated and leaking
and ugly by any aesthetic standard. But it was there, and in large Achilles, there were
private shawls by occupation. The butchers had their shawl, the tailors, even chimney sweeps
had their shawl. And crimes of violence were virtually unknown. Yes, you had tax evasion,
smuggling, inevitable, from the disabilities that were imposed. But infidelity or drunkenness
were extremely rare, because the gomara and shukhalarach had a profound influence. And this
influence also accounts for the extraordinary amount of siddhaka they did, the soup kitchens,
the poor houses. And I have to tell you that the people handing out this stokka were
themselves with few exceptions on the borderline of poverty. But as long as you had, you
gave, you know, life in the pale was completely insular. There was basically no interaction
between the Russians and the Jews except in the marketplace. The Russian peasant was
on a far lower cultural level than the Jews, and they had no interest in them. But what
it has to be said, and this needs to be understood for what it is and for what it created
to this very day. Russian policy towards the Jews was changeable and contradictory. Sometimes
the government headed in two directions at once. At other times, it suddenly reversed
itself. And they on the lower level, whatever came from St. Petersburg, you know, they could
ignore it or reinterpret it because they were bribed or because they had their own ideas.
And laws on the national level could be the opposite of those on a local level. And
every bureaucrat was corrupt. Jews lived those 150 years by bribing, by smuggling, always
on the brink of poverty, always on the brink of expulsion. And you need to understand that
if you spend 150 years with a government which you hate, which you distrust, which is looking
for your downfall, that you avoid the government and you create your own run-arounds and it's
hard-baked into the Jewish psyche. You will almost by definition do the opposite of what
is being suggested. And it won't disappear when you move to working class-deprived conditions
in London or New York or when you survive a Holocaust. I've spoken to survivors of said
to me, the only reason we survived is because it was ingrained in us to ignore orders. And
in the eyes of Eastern European Jews and their descendants, the government could never
pay back the damage they had inflicted, deliberately inflicted for centuries, aimed at harming
Jews and Judaism. And now you have to think about the effect that has on their descendants
generations later. It's made its mark on them, on us.
Yeah, I mean this is not just the podcast in general isn't just talking about eras and
history. Jewish history is very much a constant. Yeah, it's not theory. Yeah, and we learn
from it. And I guess what stands out most about this episode in particular is the irony
that all these Jews, if left to their own devices, they probably would have assimilated.
They probably would have, I don't know, changed their education, changed their dress, which
is what was happening all over Western Europe. Yeah. And ironically because of these. The force. Yeah, they kept strong. Yep.
Now, in 1840, the Tsar asked his Minister of State Count Kiselev to convene a committee
to produce new ideas for solving the Jewish problem. And their report suggested that the
root of the problem was religious fanaticism and separatism, which came from the Talmud,
which fostered contempt to the nations of other faiths. And they therefore, these Jews
had the desire to rule over the rest of the world. And the only solution is to abolish
Jewish autonomy and affect major changes in Jewish life, change their education, their
clothing, their leadership. And Nicholas read this report and noted his complete agreement
in the margin. Now, as we mentioned last time, in terms of education, Russian schools
had a theoretically been open to Jewish children since the days of Alexander. But there were
very few Jewish families who were willing to expose their children to Russian teachers,
whose job it was to create devout Christians. So the Tsar wanted greater ingenuity. And
he found it in his Russian Minister of Education, Count Ovarov. Ovarov remembered a visit he'd
made to Prussia in the 1830s. And in Berlin, he'd been astonished at the sight of great
numbers of thoroughly westernised assimilated Jews. And he learnt that these Jews had been
brought completely into contact with Western culture and abandoned their preoccupation
with the Talmud. This, basically for him, was the re-education he'd been looking for.
And he had no intention of creating what he saw in the West, i.e. Jewish secularists.
He wanted to wean them off the Talmud. And then they could be exposed to Christian
principles. So in a memorandum of 1840, he suggested to the Tsar that the conversion
repurpose of Jewish re-education be very well disguised. And what they should do is start
by making secular education much more palatable. And the way that would really be achieved
is if you have an entirely separate Jewish school system. If you force them into the Russian
system, we've seen that these Jews won't take it up. But this way, create Jewish schools.
And officially you will allow Hebrew and religion to be taught there. And you would therefore
gain their trust. And eventually you'd be able to do what you need. So you know, the Tsar's
very impressed, but they said you need to Jewish-educate in charge of all of this. And Varov scours
the Russian Empire and then further west to find somebody and got hold of a guy called
Max Lilliantal in Rika in Latvia. This Lilliantal was originally a German Jew who'd been
educated at the University of Munich. He was a doctorate in philosophy. And in 1840 he'd created
a secular school for the Jewish children there. And he spoke German and Hebrew, and I guess
when necessary, Yiddish. So Varov brings him to St. Petersburg in 1841 and tells him he wants him
to create a Jewish school system for the entire pale of settlement. For all the, by then,
over one million Jews that were there. So Lilliantal is flattered, but he's suspicious. Why are you
going to make a special effort to educate the Jews? So Varov assures him that this is just
in order to get the Jews to become more emancipated. So Lilliantal takes this at face value,
and he travels through the pale of settlement in order to meet and convince the Jewish communal
authorities that this is, you know, manor falling from heaven. But things didn't quite go to plan
for him. And in his memoirs, he talks about coming to Vilna. And he sits there telling the
Rabani and the elders what the plan is, and they say to him, "Doctor, are you fully acquainted
with the leading principles of our governments? You're a stranger. Do you know what you're undertaking?"
The government intends to have one church in the whole empire, and therefore we're sorry to say
we've got no confidence in the new measures proposed by the ministerial council. And in fact some
communities didn't even allow him to speak. In certain places like Minsk, he has Hasidim following
him shouting at him, and when he tried to address a mass meeting, the audience became so disruptive
that they had to summon the Minsk Fire Department to break up the meeting. So Lilliantal sees that's
not going to make it happen. He tells the Zah, Varov, "They need to convene a conference of
rabbis, one for each of the 17 districts where the Jews lived within the pale, and you need their
approval. Varov approved this idea. Submitted it to the Zah, and the Zah said,
four people maximum. They had one Hasidic leader, one Litfischer leader, one merchant, a registered
merchant, and a muskil. And they come to St Petersburg. On this commission was Ravitsila of
Valojin, Ravnachmendel Schneerson, Tsemakhtedek, Michal Halprin, who was a banker in Baditrov, and
Tutelsternu as a muskil. They met for two months. And during the entire time, Varov and Liliantal are
insisting that these educational reforms would not be directed against the Jews. And they said that
the alternative is mass exile. And there's one interesting episode, because there are no real notes
of it. But in Tereshrabal Pair, hand it down, one story is Varov, questions Ravitsila about his
very large and visible cities, compared to Liliantals, which are far less conspicuous.
Sir Vitsila replied that the Mitzvah, the commandment of cities, was given in order to remember the
Mitzvahs. And everyone's memory is different. This Liliantal, who's an educated man, he might need
less of a reminder than Vitsila, who's an old and simpler man. But after two months, Varov felt
that's enough. Foundations have been prepared, and they established these schools. The Talmaters
were not abolished, but the Crown schools exempted students from military conscription. And then,
behind the protective facade of Liliantal, the government begins to appoint staff to the
school, in basically every instance, the principles of the elementary and secondary schools were
Christians, and the, you know, from the drags of the country schools. And these goyem had the right
to appoint the Malumden. And their familiarity with Halacha was nonexistent, and therefore Jewish
families avoided it like the plague. And it got even worse, when in 1844, a memorandum was leaked,
in which his intention was made quite clear, and I quote, "the aim pursued in the training
of the Jews is that of bringing them nearer to the Christian population, and eradicating the
prejudices fostered in them by the study of the Talmud, to which Varov answered that the
new system of Jewish education would eventually be replaced by instruction in the catechism,
in other words, in Christianity." And once that made its way through the kehilla,
the thing just completely collapsed. You have, for instance, in, by 1852, in Sklov,
which had a Jewish population of 10,000, there were 27 Jewish pupils. In Vitebsk, there were 19
students. And in 1848, Varov resigned because the failure of his experiment had made his position
untenable. Well, he'd been, at best, a useful idiot for the government, as many muskiling would be,
and by 1845, he leaves Russia quite suddenly, and three years later, he admitted publicly that
only when the Jew will bow down to the Greek cross will the Tsar be satisfied.
Now, with all these decrees happening and will close with this, we understand a visitor who came
to Russia in March 1846. Unusually tall, clean shaven, traditionally observant, and inordinately
wealthy, an English Jew, who crosses the Dvina River in a luxurious private carriage,
braving the thoyn ice flows in order to travel along Russia's notoriously poor roads to St. Petersburg,
the capital. His appearance was extraordinary in every sense, and he meant it to be so.
He arrived wearing the Scarlet uniform of a sheriff of London, with gold epilets,
a plumed hat, and a sword by his side. Once in the city, he made his way up the ladder of official
dam, first meeting with Tsar Nicholas's important ministers, and ultimately with the Tsar himself.
It was Moses Antifuri, his first visit to Russia, which we will talk about more next week.
The cliffhanger. Yes. How would you say it, Robert Herschen, sort of summary, because it was quite a
heavy and intense episode. It was almost an appropriate fetish above to hear this level of
suffering, and it's permed this week. Can you make some sort of a how we to view this whole
episode in history? Well, in fact, it is appropriate because, as you say, it's permed this week.
What is permed? So, you know, people say it's stressing out, it's a schluch monos,
the actual basic idea of permed is mysterious nephesh. They are an exile, and for the first time ever,
the entire Jewish nation is threatened with genocide. That's what it was. This is an echo
of that original Purim, where 10-year-old kids are holding out, where Jews are facing poverty,
and absolute hatred, and they hold out. There is a tremendous pride of mysterious nephesh,
and ultimately, as we mentioned last week, Torah remains in Russia, unlike Western Europe,
and perhaps we will leave it to the Temar Tadek, who is intimately involved in all of this,
and understood the pain and understood what they were going through, and he wrote,
"La hovin inyan le kichas anche chael mi israel biyadnochrim." To understand why Jewish soldiers
are being taken by the non-Jews, he said Hashem graves, the masiras nephesh of Jews,
which is awakened during difficult times of Gzerus. The pain that the Jews feel from not being able
to keep Mitzvahs is enough of a merit to keep the whole world in existence. And it was amazing
that even a single Jew remained religious, and that even those who became a religious became
staunchly Jewish. And in fact, next week we will see what happens when the decree comes to an end.
And not just Purim, we are pace up and around the corner where we'll be saying,
"Om temaleno le chaliseno" and it's behold over there, and what you've described with the level of
thought, the level of effort. And we're not just talking about, you know, peasants and the
Kazakhs, we just wanted to murder Jews for, you know, drinking Christian blood, we're talking about
trying to set up schools. Sweptitiously, yeah. Just the amount of effort, just it's quite mind-blowing,
and yet here we are. So Robert Hirsch will be seeing you next week for our final episode on Russia.
We're going to be two more. Ah, yes. There's more to it. There's too much. Okay, and I urge the
listeners to subscribe not to miss them. And I hope you have a wonderful Purim. Please do send
any questions, any feedback, and any suggestions to
[email protected]. Have a good night.