20 years later in 1762 Catherine the Great appears. She was in fact a German
princess who married the Tsar and then overthrew her own husband in a coup six
month after he was crowned and he died under suspicious circumstances. You know
people have died in Russia under suspicious circumstances for centuries. Nowadays
they've perfected falling out of windows to an art form for political
opponents. People can fall out of windows on the ground floor and somehow die. Back
then they had different ways of getting rid of inconvenient adversaries.
Welcome to History for the Curious. I'm Manor Eisner and I host the
International Renowned Lecturer, Dynamic Historian and Tall Guide, Brabh like
Aubrey Hirsch. Experience our history, confront dilemmas and reveal the
untold stories of 3000 years of Jewish heritage from Paris to Cairo, from the
Russian's art to my monodies and from the sign-in revelation to the French
revolution. Join the fastest growing Jewish history podcast in the world by
subscribing to this channel and discovering the events that shaped us into who we
are today. Welcome back to all the listeners. We are first going to start with an
apology for our two week absence, two and a half week absence, with not much
explanation given. It's due to the usual excuse which is traveling. I traveled
as well a bit but it was mostly a rabbi Hirsch's fault just so you know
spending a week in Vienna. Yes that's true and the Vienna participants want to
shout out so hello. But we are back and for all the people who email us we're
very flattered that you missed it but if you are subscribed which I always
recommend you certainly won't miss another episode even if there is a
traveling glitch and things take longer than plans you'll know that will be
notified when the episode drops. We're back with a brand new series but just
before we start we're going to be covering the history of Russia but just
before we will start with a news item that's been ongoing in England and seeing
that we devoted a full podcast and Trevor S and came in especially to the
studio. We will just quickly discuss the BBC documentary on Gaza which the
whole world are talking about. Yes well so-called documentary it was actually a
propaganda piece that would be a far more accurate description. Perhaps a timeline
for our listeners. On the 17th of February BBC showed Gaza how to survive a
war zone an hour long film supposedly about life and refugees in Gaza and
here's the main point than the rate of this film was a 13-year-old Abdullah.
Which of course not a fluke they chose a chance for maximum a motor response.
Yes and because children are presumed innocent and therefore authentic voices
you know no links to terror organisations is a child after all and what they
are saying will be accepted unquestioningly except unmentioned by the BBC was
the fact that this kid's father was the deputy agricultural minister for
Hamas in Gaza and family members are part of Hamas. In fact his I think it's
great uncle was one of the founding members of Hamas but you wouldn't want to
reveal that because then it would take away from your carefully orchestrated
piece of anti-Israel propaganda. Now BBC subsequently made the absurd claim
that the child's opinion was his own and not to any family members of course it
was and it was only after David Collier created a report which made it into a
number of national newspapers in this country in which he said that the
documentary was one of the worst Palestinian propaganda pantomimes you will
ever get to see it was raw Hamas garbage funded by the British public it was
only then that the BBC responded and by the way far from being a sort of a
camera shy kid this narrator had been on Channel 4 another British broadcaster
in November 23 so three days later on the 20th February the cultural
secretary of state Lisa Nandi discussed the matter with the BBC director general
and chairman and that forced the BBC to remove the so-called documentary from
iPlayer while the investigation would take place there's no apology on TV
and bear in mind that the program itself was seen by at the moment an
estimated 600,000 viewers so pulling it from iPlayer isn't going to help the
original viewers unsee it and then the BBC's chief content officer quits the
personal overall responsible to this offensive production and at that point the
BBC have been outed but three more significant things happen firstly a letter
is signed by 800 film TV and media people including the manoval Gary Linnecker
calling for the documentary to be reinstated and calling the documentary an
essential piece of journalism that offers an all-too-rare perspective on the
lived experiences of Palestinians in fact the letter claims that some of the
criticism of the documentary is based on racist assumptions here we are
racist for asking a propaganda program to be removed but for anti-seemites
like Gary Linnecker we have no rights that's the first thing that happened
secondly camera which is the Committee for Accuracy in Middle East and
Reporting and Analysis re-translated some of the Arabic in the
documentary and found on at least five occasions that they deliberately
mistranslated the Arabic word for Jew or Jews changing it to Israel or even
worse Israeli forces because that's so much less offensive so when a
girl's and woman raged against the Yahudi the Jews for invading our land
somewhere on in the production office tweaked it and the BBC sub titles had her
saying the Israeli army invaded our lands but it isn't what she said she said
the Jews then BBC sub titles show a boy saying he fled his home because the
Israelis destroyed everything but what he really said was that the Jews came
and destroyed us the Jews and then there's a woman saying that Hamas's seventh
October attack was the first time we invaded Israel but what she actually said
was we're invading the Jews for the first time and then in what I would call
the most egregious mistranslation the documentary shows that woman
commenting on Israel's killing of the Hamas leader of Yahya Sinwa in October 24
and said Sinwa was fighting and resisting Israeli forces at least that's what
the sub title say but what she actually said is he was engaging in resisted
and she had against the Jews Hamas hates Jews but BBC won't have that said
because it spoils their carefully constructive anti-Israel narrative so just
change it from the Arabic this is not an era right this is an out an out
libel this is a blood libel and that is the second point the third is today
it is proven that the BBC Gaza documentary production team paid a Hamas
members wife and now a full audit of program expenditure is reportedly set to
be conducted to obtain assurances that the 400,000 pounds of BBC funds
didn't actually go to the terrorist organization now BBC blames
Hoyo films their intermediary for failing to disclose the Hamas connections
despite knowing it and the BBC spokesperson said the independent production
company was asked a number of times by the BBC about any potential connections
he and his family might have with Hamas but as the conservative party leader
Kemi Badanok noted if the BBC repeatedly asked they must have had suspicions
and anyway she rejected the BBC's investigation as being independent
because the department is staffed by BBC employees bottom line as the
researcher David Collier who discovered the documentaries Hamas
connections put it BBC have been producing Hamas propaganda for years the
only difference is that this time we proved it and therefore as mentioned it
is worth listening again to our podcast with Trevor Assassin to understand how
endemic how deeply flawed and biased how anti-Israel the BBC has been for
decades and I personally wrote to the BBC and one of my lines was Jeremy
Bowen must be gutted that we won this round in case this name is unknown to you
he is the vile anti-C might who has produced some of the most apparent content
for over 20 years and who has trained many of the BBC journalists currently in
them at least he and other journalists of his ilk at the BBC have
supported terrorist organisations whom they've refused to label as such
have encouraged activities that these terrorists have carried out and have
whitewashed and lied about their crimes which has resulted in emboldening and
supporting Hamas he is the equivalent in the 21st century of adult Hitler's
propaganda minister Joseph Goebbels and these journalists have fermented
Jewish hatred for decade a blood libel I ended my email to the BBC been lovely
[BLANK_AUDIO]
chatting to you at the biased broadcasting corporation can't wait until you get roasted
next time for lying.
Did you get a response?
Oh yes, they wrote, and I quote, "As complaints about this program have been expedited
to the Executive Complaints Unit, we will not be issuing a further response at stage one
of the complaints process, but we will inform you of the ECU's findings once their investigation
is complete.
Thanks again for getting in touch."
Well, so it is a post script to our episodes for sure about the content and the biased
BBC.
But also, I think it shows what can be done, right, because we discussed what's the
point, if the BBC are such a powerful organisation, and travel is talking about, you know, you poke
holes and eventually there is going to be a time, and who knew that so soon, there would
be such glaring evidence of the bias, and the media that are reporting it now with the
investigation on going, could end up with serious taxpayers' reduction in money coming
in, and who knows where the future will bring.
We hope.
Okay.
Russian jury.
Yes.
We speak of Russian jury often, and in the 1890s, two thirds of Europe's Jews lived in
the Russian Empire.
We know that four million of them would leave, because life was very tough, but millions
more stayed.
The question is, why were they there?
What brought them there in the first place?
So to start, I want to give a very brief overview of 900 years of Russian history, basically
in a few paragraphs.
Russia starts in 862 CE with the establishment of the Rus state.
Before that, there is no such territory or province, although Putin may feel differently
on the matter, of course.
In 882, Prince Oleg of Novgorod made Kiev the capital, and they adopt Christianity
in 988, this is Eastern Christianity and not Catholic.
And at the same time or at that time, there is a Jewish community in Kiev.
Initially, the Jews were in charge of the collection of customs and had freedom to trade.
In the beginning of the 12th century, the Jewish colony there experienced the first
pogrom.
But nevertheless, the Jews continued living in Kiev, Jewish merchants were attracted
towards this growing commercial center, which served as a connecting link between Western
Europe and the Black Sea.
And you have reference to Kiev mentioned by the famous Jewish travellers, who we mentioned
a few weeks ago, Benjamin of Tadayla and Psychia of Rattisbond.
This is both in the early Middle Ages.
And you also have Rabanim in Noboli Tosvus of the 12th century occasionally refer in
their writings to the journeys of German Jews traveling with their merchandise to Russ
and Slavonia, which are the Slav countries.
Now the Jews of Russia had no rabbinic authorities of their own, so they addressed their inquiries
to the Aschievous of Germany, or they sent students to Germany for a Talmudic education.
And sources in the 12th century make mention of the name of Rvietschoch of Chernygov and
Ravmyshe of Kiev, who even sent a question to the gond of Baghdad, Schmolben, Ely.
Now this printipality, I guess you'd call it, of Kiev and Russ, lasts for a few hundred
years, until the Mongol invasions starting under Genghis Khan, which continued with his
successes, who eventually overran the entire Kievan Rus in 1240.
And then, a short time later, and for the first time, Moscow becomes an important regional
place.
It's still under the Mongol overlords, but they grant the title of Grand Prince of Moscow,
and then Moscow's prestigious further improved when it becomes the centre of the Russian
Orthodox Church, which moved from Kiev, of course.
So it almost sounds like current events, with Kiev and Moscow being bent as about, where
the capital was, how it's spread.
Exactly, it's even worse, because Russia starts in Kiev, and then it moves over to Moscow,
it's part of the same country.
It's not an invasion by one country or another, it's very messy, and it's a thousand
years of mess, very much so.
So yeah, that part of history is, as you say, coming back.
So it explains there are similar sort of people, similar sort of culture?
Well, it definitely explains that both of them feel very strongly about what does it mean
to be a nationalist, which is very much the conversation at the moment.
Anyway, by the middle of the 14th century, after 140 years, the Mongol Empire is on its way
out, and Moscow ceases on this and becomes independent, and it expands its territory
through purchase of land, through war, through marriage.
And from this moment, for the next 400 years, they decide no Jews will be allowed to live
in Russia.
Get back to this, but just to continue till the point that we are more familiar with, this
period of time, 1400s, 1500s, is the time of Ivan the Great in the late 1400s, and Ivan
the Terrible, in the mid 1500s, who actually made Russia into an empire and first used
the term "zar", but Russia's empire didn't quite go to plan because his son had no children.
So in 1598, Russia entered a period of chaos of civil war, and in fact the Polish and Lithuanian
kingdom, as well as the Swedish armies, they attacked, they devastated the country, they
reached Moscow, they installed their own ruler, and in 1610, they burnt Moscow to the ground,
almost.
Although finally, in February 1613, the Pols were expelled from Moscow, because by then Poland
and Sweden had a bit of conflict of their own, and Michael Rumanov is elected to the throne.
He starts a dynasty, which rules Russia for 300 years until 1917, until the Russian Revolution,
and this is the Russia that we know of.
How big is that Russia, the same size as the Russia we know today?
Once it got its monarchy in 1613, and for the rest of the 17th century, Russia conquered
land, the Siberia, in fact, all the way across Asia, and becomes the largest country in
the world, basically goes from the Baltic Sea to the Pacific Ocean.
But the vast majority of that land is unoccupied, it's a population of around 14 million.
Why was that the case?
Why was it so unto the world?
Because the reason they managed to capture so much land in such little time is because
it wasn't developed and it wasn't occupied as a country.
This whole area was centuries behind in terms of economic development, travel was slow,
and that meant that the great majority of the population of these 14 million was involved
in sort of the actual land on which they lived, in other words, agriculture.
Russia remained isolated from the sea trade to the south because it didn't have a port there,
and then in 1721, Peter the Great makes, and Peter's bird, the capital of his empire.
So, when we're lying back, you were talking about the Jews were banned from the 14th century
for a hundred years.
Yeah.
There were hundreds of thousands of Russian Jews.
When and how did they arrive?
Jews were barred, especially from the big cities.
And people came here and there, they traveled through, but there's no community.
And therefore, really, for those centuries, there's very little to say in terms of Jewish
history, although interestingly, somehow during this period in Moscow, there arose a religious
movement which became known under the name of the Judeanizing Heresy.
And according to the Russian chroniclers, this Heresy starts with a Jew whom they call
Shkaria, probably Shkaria, who had emigrated to the old Russian city of Novgorod, or Novarodok.
And it appears from these chronicles that Shkaria got in touch with some of the church clergy
and somehow succeeded in converting them to Judaism.
These leaders of the apostates who were ex priests, Dennis and Alexius, they went to Moscow
in 1480.
And this Heresy is now becoming entrenched amongst the nobility of Moscow and in court circles.
The daughter-in-law of the Grand Duke, Helena, apparently was one of them, although it was
eventually wiped out.
How it got off the ground in the first place is a little unknown, but they are chronically
calling it "not us".
Yes, it goes sort of beyond religion almost, it's theological, because Russia, and in
fact the Russian Orthodox version of Christianity, had nothing to do with the Pope or European Christianity.
And therefore they saw the land as the inheritor of Rome, and the land is holy, it's holy
Mother Russia, and therefore they cannot allow Jews to contaminate it by settling there.
And this idea, by the way, in Russia of the country being the Motherland was used continuously,
just by religious leaders but by Stalin and others it's very
very evocative for them. No Jews, therefore, can be allowed to share this motherland.
What didn't mean the motherland? We all know that. We all know that sort of statement. Russia, the motherland.
Did they think they were on a higher racial superiority in our society?
They think the land had the Havdil-Elef Havdollars culture.
Yeah, absolutely.
Nothing to the religion.
Well, it comes initially from there, but then it becomes a sort of rallying call.
You know, you've got Ivan the terrible who said that he's not prepared to allow Jews to come with their good to Russia,
because there's a lot of evil that comes out of it. They bring poisonous medicine, and they lead stray Russians from Christianity.
And to give you an idea of how much he hated the Jews in 1563. Russian troops occupied the Polish border city of Polotsk.
And the Tsar gave orders to have all local Jews converted to the Russian Orthodox faith.
And any who refused, who refused baptism in other words, they would be drowned in the river.
And a hundred years later, in 1654, when the empire pushed its way into the territory of Lithuania until then it had been expanding to the east.
Now it goes west, to into Europe.
And they come across in this territorial grab. They come to Vilna.
And they see what to them was an undreamed of sight, cities, in which entire cultures were populated by these Jews.
And these Umen-Liten Moskovites knew nothing about Jews except that they had once upon a time crucified their savior.
So Mikhailovich and his military commanders set out on what you could almost call a crusade.
In two of the cities including Vilna, Jews are murdered, many fled the city including the Baragoyla and the Shach.
And in Vitebsk, the Jews are made prisoners of war, but there's no quarter given to them because they cannot exist on Russian soil, even if the Russian soil has been acquired suddenly and through war.
So it's like a simplistic hatred, a hatred of a lack of knowledge?
Yes, yes. And with so many people in this empire and so few Jews, in other words most Russians never saw a Jew in their life.
The Jews were almost a myth, a, I don't know, demonic group.
But at the same time they hold a fascination for some of the nobility at least, those that could read and write.
And in the 1700s history repeats itself, you have a tax farmer in Smolensk called Borach Labov, who even after he'd been expelled continues to cross the forbidden Polish-Russian frontier.
And he comes into close contact with a guy called Alexander Vosnitsyn, a retired captain and a navy, and he seduced him into Judaism.
So Vosnitsyn studies the Bible under the guidance of this Jewish friend and he realizes that, you know, the whole dogma of the church is garbage.
And he makes up his mind to embrace Judaism. He will brave, you know, dangers with such a step.
And he goes to the small town of Dubrovna, where the son of Borach Labov resided, and undergoes Brismila, and undertakes. Yiddishkaity undertakes conversion, Geirus.
This conversion gets known, and this captain and his teacher Borach are brought to St. Petersburg and turned over to the chancellery for secret inquisitorial affairs.
They are put on the rack and they confess to their crimes. Vosnitsyn admitted that he had embraced Judaism and uttered blasphemous words against the church, and Labov said he'd seduced Vosnitsyn from the path of orthodoxy, and they were burned at the stake.
In St. Petersburg in a public square on July 15, 1738, and this one isolated incident, rekindled in the government and in the masses a fear of unbaptized Jews it was publicized.
Then, a few years later, in the 18th century, we have two women Zarina's in Russia, and they are as bad as the men, we have Elizabeth Petrovna and Catherine the Great, for a period almost continuous, or 55 years, 1741 to 1796.
In 1741, Elizabeth issued a decree, in which, she most graciously commands that from our whole empire, both from the Great Russian and little Russian cities and villages, little Russia is the area that had just been conquered, which included Estonia and Latvia.
From this area, all Jews male and female shall be immediately deported with all their property abroad, and shall henceforth under no pretext be admitted into our empire for any purpose unless they be willing to accept the Christian religion.
Such Jews having been baptized shall be allowed to live in our empire, but they shall not be permitted to go outside the country.
This was printed and spread across the entire empire so that people understood the proper sentiments to have towards the haters of the name of our Savior.
As you say, it was a hatred of religion, although the Empress calculated wrongly because the expulsion decree did not draw one single Jew into the fold of the church.
You have, at the time, the non-Jewish administration of the province and the city of Riga, modern-day Latvia, and when they heard of the expulsion that all Jews in the suburb will be within six weeks kicked out, they complained to her that the expulsion was going to cause great injury to the exchequer, and commerce might be destroyed entirely in the region.
An Elizabeth responded in December 1743 from the enemies of Christos I desire neither gain nor profit.
20 years later, in 1762, Catherine the Great appears. She was in fact a German princess who married the Tsar, and then overthrew her own husband in a coup six months after he was crowned, and he died under suspicious circumstances.
You know, people have died in Russia under suspicious circumstances for centuries. Nowadays they've perfected falling out of windows to an art form for political opponents, people can fall out of windows on a ground floor and somehow die, back then they had different ways of getting rid of inconvenient adversaries.
And through her, she is now the Tsarina, the inability in Russia comes into contact with European culture and the French language especially, but the bulk of the population were peasants, who remained in a state of serfdom almost slaves.
And when Catherine arrives at the Senate, on the agenda was the question of the admission of Jews into Russia. The senators felt that their admission was useful, but the Empress permitted all foreigners to travel and settle in Russia.
Cromier Gidoff, except the Jews. Very soon, however, and this is really where everything starts, Jews enter the picture, and over the second half of the 1700s, they will transform the Russian Empire from one with a policy to prevent single Jew living there into an empire with the largest population in the world over a 30-year period.
So what happened? How did they suddenly arrive? Jews didn't come to Russia. Russia came to the Jews. Russia would swallow up land and inherit the Jews.
In fact, in all the time of the next 130 years, no Jews would live in the Russian Empire of what we would nowadays call Russia.
They would live, even though we call them Russian Jews, in areas which on a map are Poland, Lithuania, and Ukraine throughout the 1800s.
And the reason is Poland was governed by nobility and they elected a king between them. There was no dynasty. And in the 1700s, Polish kings are elected, deposed, exiles brought back, all of which made Poland weak and vulnerable. And then between 1772 and 1795, Poland, Belarus, Ukraine, Lithuania, all of them ceased to exist. Russia took most of it, Putin style.
Austria seized Galicia, which is southern Poland, and Prussia helped herself to the province of Poland in the west of Poland. And it was disastrous for the Jews.
The change of regime of empire wasn't just simply who controlled them. It was an enormous loss of power, along with many issues that Jews were already dealing with. Life was tough.
How many Jews are we talking about at this point?
Well, before we deal with how many, let's deal with how come there were Jews in this area. So, briefly, after 1500s, or 1500s itself almost, because of pogroms and expulsions, all the Jews living in Europe were more or less concentrated in two empires in the east and in the south of Europe.
In the south is the Ottoman Empire, and the east is the Polish Lithuanian Kingdom. And they arrive where. They are already Jews living, but given their numbers, they swallow up everything that exists there.
So, for instance, in the cities of Greece and Turkey, the Romaniate Jews become now sward him.
In Poland and Lithuania, the local Jews become Ashkenazim, not from Germany, but that's what happens.
The religious practice becomes Minigashkenaz, one form of prayer.
And to answer your question, we are talking 600,000 Jews out of a total probably of 1.2 million
in Europe and another 1.2 million in North Africa and the Middle East.
So, it's one quarter of the entire Jewish population.
You said there wasn't simply a change of rulers. It was a complete disaster.
But from what we've seen in the past, there weren't exactly best friends with their
Polish next door neighbors. I mean, there'd been a mess because of 1648-49, tough at that.
How different already could this new Russian regime be that is spelling out such a disaster,
like the square thing? Okay. Now, the valid point, Tachvatat did happen,
although I would blame Ukraine far more than Poland for it.
Malnitsky was Ukrainian, and there's a town in Ukraine to this day called Malnitsky,
but during the 250 years that Jews had been in Poland before 1790, the nobility were powerful.
They were independent of even of each other, and they sort of ran their own
mini empires on whatever particular pieces of land that each nobleman owned.
And you have perhaps 30 or 40% of the Jews linked to the estates of nobility.
So, you know, the Jews may have run an in or manage the rents from the peasants or cut down the
lumber. They might have run distilleries, flower mills, and when they were employed, so to speak,
by the Polish landowner, they would do more than one type of work. For instance, if they had an in,
where the peasants would come to drink his vodka, they would also have a store where he could buy
tools or nails, and it was a road in, so there was lodging and stables for the horses.
And this Jewish leaseholder, which was obviously in a place owned by a Polish nobleman,
would run this entire economic setup with his wife and sons and daughters,
and that's where you get all these sort of stories from, of, you know,
hiring a millumbed to come there, etc. And they played the Jews, played a very important role
in the rural economy of Eastern Europe, but you could almost say an indispensable role.
Sounds similar to today. I mean, it sounds like they were propped here. No, they didn't own
any land. Their fortunes are linked to the fortunes of the land and of nobility, but they didn't
own anything at all. And under Russian rule, all of this will change, because Russia wasn't a
Western country. It was noocracy where all power resided in one person, the Tsar. He isn't the,
simply the chief of the army, or, and he's definitely not the people's choice, he is the state.
And therefore, Polish nobility who owned the land, who had leased it out to the Jews,
are now part of an empire where decisions are made without them. And their land assets are simply
confiscated, and many Polish estate owners emigrated or perhaps fled to the West. And as a result,
the Jews, who were only tenants, are cast out, and they are now forced to seek other types of
livelihood. In addition, from 1791, the Jews are severely restricted as to where they would be
allowed to live. It would be formalized in 1835 as the infamous pale of settlement. And we'll
deal with this more next week, but it start immediately from the Russian occupation, and this is
another major change. So to rewind back a moment, you said 30-40% of the Jews were land-based,
but that leaves at least 60-70% of what have heard, I don't know, life continues usual by the
sounds of it. It's true that the rest of them, which could be up to 2/3, had trades, they were
fur-making and watchmakers and tailoring and peddling. But there were other changes, and as a result,
the whole setup changed dramatically. In Poland, while Poland existed as a country, the Jews were
tolerated. They might have been unliked, but they weren't seen as foreigners. But under Russian
rules, that's not the case. Jews were unwished for. If they hadn't conquered this land,
they would have continued with their policy of never allowing a Jew to step foot on their soil.
As it was, they sort of explained it away by, this is not really Rodina, this is not really the
motherland. And therefore, there is plenty of xenophobia, of contempt, of suspicion. And the Jews
in this region are the most religious and the poorest of the Jews in existence, so they had no
redeeming features for the Russians. In fact, if you recall, we had an episode on 16th century Poland
about the Vada Arbaraotseis, where Poland, Lithuania, are governed for 200 years by what is called
the council of four lands. And these were almost like parliaments, because you'd have each region
have representatives who would come together at these trade fairs. And they would be responsible for
collecting Jewish taxes from the Jews for the Polish government, because every Jewish adult
in the entire kingdom had to pay a poll tax. And they would organize it. And they would set the
quota. They would set how much each region would have to come up with. And they also, these councils
represented the interests of the Jews to the government when the Jews are accused of blood libels.
So, you know, the Vada would have lobbyists who would bribe government officials or would just
talk to them, reason with them, etc. And this Vada Arbaraotseis sets up a Kehilla structure.
And it helps the Jews cope, which means that during those 250 years, the Jews in Poland aren't
being conscripted into the army, they aren't being forced to change their way of dress or language
or religion. For those days that was called pretty good. Exactly. Yes. You know, they're not free,
they're not rich, and they have to cope with endemic anti-Semitism, but they're left to their
own devices. And to give you an example of their being able to be left to their own devices,
they lived in this country, and they didn't speak the language of the country, they didn't write
documents in anything other than Yiddish, because they were left alone. Internally, the Jews governed
themselves. When Poland is abolished, this autonomy is undermined, and therefore all sort of 100%
of Jews are now affected. Just as an aside, in a previous podcast, you said that Poland's soldiers
saved Europe at the gates of the year. Did they not part any resistance to lose their entire
country in, you know, 20 years effectively? You're giving me a lot of questions from left field
this way. You've been gone for two weeks. Right, okay. Trying to give you a run for your money.
Okay, listen, at one stage, the Polish Lithuanian kingdom was the largest in Europe,
but in the 1700s Poland went downhill, and Russia dismantled the Polish army, although in 1794,
led by Tadeusz Koshkuszko, an engineering officer who had fought alongside Washington in the
American Revolution, the army rose up against the Russians, and their leader led the army to several
victories in the vicinity of Krakow. And the Jews, in fact, made financial contributions to
the rebellion, particularly in Warsaw, but in addition, and this is not well known, perhaps virtually
unknown, a Jewish-like cavalry regiment was created under Berik Yoselevich. He had been in France
during the Revolution. He comes back to Poland in 1789, and he's, you know, imbued with revolutionary
idealism, and in 1794, Yoselevich applied to Koshkuszko for permission to form a special regiment
of Jewish volunteers, and he is given the rank of Colonel. He commands 500 Jews until November of
that year when an onslaught in the suburb of Warsaw called Praga by the Russian troops kills 15,000
Poles, and the basically almost the entire regiment of Yoselevich, who fled to Galicia and then
to Italy, and then comes back and dies in a clash with Austrian forces near Kotsk on the 5th of
May 1809, and there's a very famous painting of that battle, which meant that, yes, there had been
an army but by 1794 it was all over, and when Warsaw fell in that battle to the Russian Empire,
basically, both practically and symbolically, was the end of independent Poland.
And the parts taken over by Prussia and Galicia, the Polish Jews
had a different history? Oh yeah, very much so. I mean, oppression Jews, they're not many Jews
there, but this does become the first area in Poland where Jews achieve emancipation. Although
unfortunately, many of them started identifying as "prostions of the mosaic faith" rather than
as Jews. One reason for that is that Berlin was the capital of Prussia, which was the main source of
Huskala, and then you had Galicia, which is the southern part of Poland, they had definitely greater
freedom and rights than Russian Jews, because as we mentioned a number of times in the podcast,
there was the edict of tolerance in 1781 from Joseph I. It was far from perfect, but Jews weren't
in prison. They weren't hated. And even though there was substantial immigration because they were
very poor there, as we saw in the episodes of Vienna, but they nevertheless had a tolerance.
And it was also in the first decades of the 19th century that Chasidus came to dominate religious
life in much of Galicia. I come in next and that Chasidus happened start then, right? No, I mean,
it's a much longer sort of answer, but in short, whereas some of the challenges of, or the reasons
for Chasidus was in response to internal problems, which we discussed in that two-part podcast on
the origins of Chasidus, and it was a struggle over leadership, your rights in the sense that Chasidic
leaders became popular because beyond charismatic leadership, so to speak, they did take over social
and economic functions in a society that was impoverished. But to get back to the Russian Tsar,
the Tsar suddenly has the largest Jewish community in the world, 600,000 Jews,
and they have no understanding of them. And now the number of Jews will rise rapidly in the 19th
century, in the Russian Empire. There are 4 million in 1880, 5.6 million in 1910, and there now
is a discussion in Russian government circles. There are two positions about what to do with the Jews.
The first held that the Jews need to be reformed. They can be granted limited rights if they abandon
some of their sort of harmful characteristics and their autonomous status, whereas the rest held
that the Jews can't be reformed. But either way, it translated as undermining the Jews' traditional
way of life to restructure their communal, their social patterns and direct them into useful non-Jewish
occupations, encourage their assimilation, because their whole world view of these Russians is
based on the conclusion that the Jews were a harmful element, and they are an outcome of their
fanatical religious beliefs. And Jews keep themselves separate from non-Jewish society.
They have no loyalty to the country in which they live, and they avoid any hard work, any physical
labor, which they feel should be performed by the inferior peasants, and therefore they concentrated
themselves in unproductive and parasite type of occupations, which depended on the exploitation
of society. And therefore the Tsar would transform them into useful subjects. And of course,
with St. Petersburg as the imperial capital, where basically no Jews lived or were anywhere near,
the Jews were far away from the bureaucrats who drew up all these regulations for them.
And what happens is, in practical terms, as follows, from 1795, so from the time that the Russian
occupation starts, the power of the Kihilla is restricted. They don't have judicial functions.
From now on, they can deal with religion, marriage, divorce, stuff like that, divine service,
prayers, whatever, but they're not, for instance, allowed to impose any taxes of their own.
And the only reason the Kihilla survived or the Kahul survived in any form is because it was
useful as a tax collection agency, as it had been in the town of the Vada Arbaraotseis.
So the government couldn't get rid of them completely. But they also weren't allowed to carry out
Khaira many more, the rabbinical ban of excommunication. And back then in the day, it was the weapon
of the Kahul. You step out of line, you put in Khaira. And therefore slowly, the Jewish community
would crumble. There would be a breakdown of traditional leadership, and eventually weakened
links to traditional Jews. It sounds quite similar to the experience of Western Jewry.
Yes, there was a breakdown there as well, but there's a crucial difference in the West. It was
by choice. And then the Tsar Alexander I, who reigned from 1801 to 1825, ordered the creation
of a committee for the amelioration improvement of the Jews, which could consider all aspects of
the problem. And the government gets this Senator called Derjevin to create a memorandum of
the Jews of Belarus, which he calls the opinion of Senator Derjevin regarding the avoidance of
the grain shortage in Belarus by curbing the trade of the Jews. So we know which direction he's
going. In preparing it, he took advice from locals, from Jesuits, and from two Jewish muskilim.
One of them, Nutter Nottkin suggested, that the Jews should be resettled in agricultural
and cattle-braiding colonies, and the other of the muskilim advised radical religious reform.
So that was very useful. The report in its final form concluded that the Jewish religion had
nothing to recommend it. The education provided for Jewish children was a hotbed of superstition.
Morality was entirely absent from the Jews. They have no concept of lugging kindness and
other virtues. All they did was a mass riches in order to satisfy their earthly desires.
They are deceitful people, lazy, and they need to be moved on mass from their present locations
and occupations. And by the way, this will be, this is the first time, the Russians come to
grips with what the Jews are, who the Jews are. This will be their guiding ideology for the next
hundred years. And the only thing that would happen to the Jews is that life would get progressively
worse because of this conclusion. Now, initially, immediately, the Jews in Belarus and Lithuania,
they had some idea of the contents of his report. And they react as you can imagine with alarm,
they're all going to be moved. And they responded with their traditional result to lobbying.
In fact, there were so many complaints that the Javin was removed. But the government was
determined. And in 1804, a constitution was published using many of his ideas. And this was the
beginning of the long nightmare of Russian life of a ruthless governance. Now, yes, the
constitution granted Jews access to all public schools and universities in Russia. But of course,
it's basically a blind for conversion because the Minister of Education was a notorious
basically missionary. And he made sure that public education in Russia was suffused with Christian
spirit. And in the constitution, Jews would be denied the right to hold leases on any land,
operate any ins. They would be expelled from all villagers and sent to the larger towns and cities.
And that meant that basically with one stroke of the pen, it would have eliminated the livelihood
of half of the Jewish population of Russia. Besides the fact that the constitution had
contradictions and self-defeating cruelties, but it was unfortunately going to be preserved for
all the way basically until the Russian Revolution. The only reasonable element of the constitution
is those families who would settle in the new territories of areas which Catherine the Great
had seized from the Turks on the northern shore of the Black Sea. They would be exempt from
some of these rules and they would have five years tax exemption. And therefore, in 1789,
in Odessa, there were only six Jews, but in 1855, there were 17,000 Jews and in 1900,
there were 140,000 and they needed an heir of. And as soon as the Tsar's report was made public,
a flood of petitions poured in. Alexander remained completely unmoved and in 1807, he said he is
going to proceed with the expulsion. And then God intervened through international politics.
At this moment, a thousand miles away, Napoleon Bonaparte had convened his sunhedrin in Paris.
The Tsar realized the sort of implications of the sunhedrin almost immediately. Because he had
only recently been at war with France, he lost to them in 1805, and the last thing he wanted to have
was Napoleon invade this area.
of Russia when hundreds of thousands of people living there would provide the
French with new allies, allies living on, so to speak, Russian soil. So on the
very eve of the expulsion, Alexander decided to announce a temporary
suspension of his plan, but it still existed on the law books. It was never
completely abrogated. Who were there a bonham at the time and what would they, how
would they react to all of this unfurling? So the most well-known reactions come
up from the chasiddic leaders. I mean, we're talking Poland more than Lithuania,
so you have at the time that the Khoshenitsa Mugid, the Khosev Leblin,
there's Romulachemendal of Rhymenov, in other words Talmedim of the Nomilibelach,
and very much the Balatania. Now bear in mind that Napoleon at that time already
controlled Warsaw and he was gaining the upper hand in Europe. So in terms of
Napoleon versus the Tsar you would have assumed that the Robonim would now back
Napoleon to finish off the job and reconquer Poland because life's gonna be
better, but there's a very famous letter written to Mushremisels by the
Balatania, who speculated about the consequences of Napoleon's possible defeat
or victory and he wrote as follows. On the first day of Ryshashonah performed
with Sith, I was shown, say he had some sort of so-to-speak vision, that if
Bonaparte is victorious, the wealth of the Jewish people will be increased and
the dignity of Calisrael will be restored, but Leviusrael, the hearts of the
Jews, will become distant from Aviyem Shabashramayim from their father in
heaven, whereas if our Lord Alexander triumphs, even though the poverty of the
Jews will be increased, and indignity will continue to be their lot. The hearts
of the Jews will be gathered together and united with their father, with
Akadash Boruch, and then he wrote at the end of it, "Lomana Shabashram for the
sake of God burn this letter," which clearly didn't happen, but the
Balatania felt that a society where Jews are equal would be an open road to
assimilation, and the truth is, if you contrast Germany with Russia between 1815
and 1930, it's true, and that's something obviously we have to look at, but
that was the feeling, it wasn't of all those Qasidyshe Qadalim that I have
quoted, they were split down the middle, some favoring Napoleon, some
favoring the Russians are, but this gives you an idea of how a far broader
perspective is being brought to bed, not just thinking about will I be able to
regain my lease on land from nobility or not? It's an idea we're far into
because back in the day you look through Jewish history where Jews were always
struggling, Jews were always impoverished, the idea of Jews living in prosperity
and in wealth always came together with assimilation, which is something we're
not really used to thinking about in the last 100 years since the war where
Jews have been living. They can manage both. Yes, is this the first time we've
been able to amest great wealth and comfort? Spain did have an era of that, but
you're right, that post-World War II, there has been a balance that was struck
pre-World War II though, the American Dream destroyed Yiddishkeit and therefore
exacted an extremely high price, so you can very much understand this
sentiment because you see it, you see it happening in history more than once.
Anyway, we have now seen why there were Jews in Russia, they weren't really in
Russia, they were in the Russian Empire, we see why they were badly treated
from the start and we will come across over the next couple of weeks the
Cantonists, which we haven't dealt with yet, the pogroms, it's a word that is
created in Russia, although at the same time in the 1800s you have the Yashiva
movement, the Musa movement, secular Judaism, Eastern European Zionism, which is
very different to Herzl's, they will all occur during the 1800s, it is the
era of early modern Jewish history and it needs to be said that alongside the
Holocaust, the experience of the Jews in Eastern Europe, of which there were
millions of Jews, will shape the Jews into who they become post-World War II in
America and in Arizona in particular and that's all to come.
Thank you very much and apologies again for the listeners, that was episode one,
please make sure you subscribe and like this episode, send any feedback to
[email protected] and make sure you come back for episode two for the
continuation of Russia. Thank you and good night.