149 The Tormented Rise of Abolition in Andrew Jackson's America with J.D. Dickey
1h 2m 55s
J.D. Dickie’s *The Republic of Violence* presents a stark, unflinching account of the violent and tumultuous 1830s in America, focusing on the rise of abolitionism and the fierce resistance it provoked. Contrary to the common narrative of a peaceful antebellum era, the book reveals that the North, too, was deeply entangled in slavery through economic interests and violent repression. Abolitionism began with Black-led activism—figures like Samuel Cornish, David Walker, and James Fortin challenged the colonization ideology, laying the foundation for public resistance. This movement was met with violent backlash, including the infamous 1834 riots in Philadelphia and New York, where mobs attacked abolitionists, destroyed homes, and targeted Black communities. Internal divisions emerged over whether to use violence in resistance, with William Lloyd Garrison promoting nonviolence based on Christian principles, while others like David Ruggles advocated defensive action. The movement also fractured due to internal purity struggles, gender roles, and ideological extremism. Dickie highlights how the nation’s violent undercurrents—rooted in slavery and political conflict—have persisted through history, with modern instances like Portland’s street battles echoing the past. The book challenges mainstream historical narratives by emphasizing the original, chaotic realities of the era, arguing that violence and racial oppression were central to American development from the beginning. It ultimately warns that political unrest and mob violence are not new phenomena but enduring features of American society, shaped by its foundational tensions.
Greetings listeners and welcome back to the Age of Jackson podcast. I am your host
is always Daniel Galota, PhD candidate, ABD in American Religious History at Stanford University.
Today on the Age of Jackson podcast, I am joined by JD Dickie, who is a New York Times
bestselling author of the book Rising in Flame, Sherman's March, and the Fight for a New
Nation. And he's the author of the book American Demagogue, The Great Awakening of the Rise
and Fall of Populism, both previously published with Pegasus Books. His new book, however,
which we'll be talking about today is The Republic of Violence, the tormented Rise of Abolition
and Andrew Jackson's America. JD, welcome to the podcast.
It's great to be here. Thank you for having me.
I always like to start these interviews off with origin questions. So I'm curious, you've
done Sherman, you've done Jonathan Edwards and the first grade awakening. Why jump to,
I guess what you could call the middle section to the Jacksonian period. What drew you to
the Republic of Violence and the Rise of Abolitionism?
Yeah, well, I could say that all my books are interrelated to some degree in the sense
that the end, the epilogue of American Demagogue talks about the second grade awakening, which
has a major impact on the current book, Republic of Violence, in the sense that the second
grade awakening fueled reform movements in the 1820s, 1830s, and abolition was one of them.
But that isn't the immediate reason why I chose to do this book, even though my books
do have connecting threads. The main reason was because I live in Portland, Oregon, and
for most people these days, they're probably familiar with their TV screens and the violence
from 2020. If you remember that, the ongoing street battles between government agents and
Antifa and the proud boys, but it actually went back before that. So in 2018 and 2019, Portland
had its share of violence on the street as well. And a little different from what we saw
in 2020, in the sense that the combatants were familiar to the police. They were basically
Antifa and proud boys, although the boundaries are somewhat loose. And they would show up periodically
to battle it out in downtown Portland. And what was unusual is that at some point the
mayor and the police just let them do it and just basically established a cordon around
where these groups would face off with their fists and paintball and fireworks and everything
else. And then let them battle it out. And that was considered okay. And I thought that
was really unusual because that's not usually the way the anarchic force of urban violence
breaks out, like within with street theater, you might say.
And then it happened even more recently in September of 2021 when a battle broke out and
an abandoned came art parking lot. And again, the mayor held the police back and let them
go after it even though it was in the middle of a neighborhood with a high school right
by there. So this is kind of the climate that's been going on off and on in Portland in
the last couple years. And with that, I just couldn't help but think that there had
to be a way to trace back the roots of this. I mean, there had to be a precedent for
this somewhere in American history. And the one thing I knew was from my first book
in Empire of Mud about the troubled rise of Washington DC in 19th century that the 1830s
were a tremendously violent time and especially for abolitionists. And so contemporary politics
more or less directly led the way toward exploring the past in greater detail than I had
in my first book.
Something you capture very early on in the book and that you've just alluded to that this
is a pretty darn ugly roofless and bloody time. This is not like the oil paintings we see
at the Smithsonian. I know this is a big question and feel free to paint with broad brushes,
but I can already imagine some listeners saying, oh yeah, like sure, like the 19th century
was probably more violent, but like kind of been that more violent. What would you say
to that? How violent could things get?
Well, I would say to what you just said, the 19th century is of course more violent than
the 20th century. And a lot of that had to do with the lack of effective police forces,
a certain tribalism between ethnic groups and a whole lot of other forces, not to mention
and certainly not least and probably paramount being slavery, which was a system that enforced
violence at its very core. But in terms of day-to-day street violence, the 1830s were a serious
peak for that. And of course, violence has riddled American history since the beginning.
I mean, we praise our patriots like Samuel Adams and the sons of Liberty and those are
people who tarred and feathered people. And from one perspective, from the British perspective,
they might have been considered militants and dangerous and terrible. And from our perspective,
we consider them patriots. So that's kind of embedded in any country that starts out with
violent revolution. But in terms of the day-to-day effect of it, in the 1830s, I was just looking
this up because I wanted to get the exact figure for you from my book. The average American
drank five gallons of hard alcohol a year. So that's double the current rate and at a
rate greater than any other country on earth today. So that's about 13 ounces a week.
And alcohol, hard drinking, was used as fuel for social interaction and often for political
engagement. Earlier in the Republic, there would be voting booths set up in taverns and each
faction would have its own officially approved slate of candidates to elect at the time.
And usually there was a lot of drinking involved when this occurred and fighting as well. So with
all of that as the basis for this, violence became essentially the groundwork for what was to
come later, what was to explode in the age of Andrew Jackson. And so if you take a look at that
in terms of the president coming to power, someone who is known as general and who's fought
all manner of battles, and a dualist, somebody who has led in his body from previous gunfights,
and according to his enemies, a demagogue, someone who speaks in very votuperative tones
and kind of angry speeches against his enemies, you have a recipe there for a very combustible
environment in this country. And so my book covers 1833 to 1838, which was the core of this era
and also a transformational time for American abolition and attempts to explain how the violence
of that era affected the movement and also how that movement came to schism as it went along.
Jumping up to say 10,000 feet at a god's eye perspective,
besides the rise of Jackson that frames a lot of your book, probably the second event that frames
a lot of the movies and shakers in your book is this thing called the second great awakening.
What is the second great awakening in a nutshell?
Okay, so religious history is something that I explored heavily in the previous book, and that
concerned the first great awakening, which was a religious revival in America in the 1740s,
and I don't want to get into that too much, but I will say that that was obviously by the name,
the precursor to what happened with the second great awakening. The major difference was,
and the second great awakening, the feeling of free will as opposed to predestination held sway.
So that meant that any person was responsible for his or her own personal salvation.
So by your acts, by your good works, or whatever kind of conduct you had on earth, you could
affect your presence in the afterlife. And a lot of people felt that the best way to go about
doing this in some quarters was to advance social movements. So the social movements that came
out of this era were things like abolition and temperance. Those were the two most important
from the time, as well as all manner of other reform movements that had their effect in
communes and in terms of group living and people who were trying to better society
through perfectionism. And this idea, it was a minority idea for sure. This idea of Christian
perfectionism was something that affected the abolition movement as well. But for the most part,
it essentially involved the best means to salvation. And that's why you had at the beginning,
people like Charles Grandeson Finney advocating this and other major figures who had a foot
in the abolition movement. And so the discourse was quite close and mutually supportive.
Now, often when we're thinking about abolitionism, I think normal Americans are immediately jumping
to, you know, verge of the civil war, you know, deep divides and north-first south.
You know, but as you point out, and many scholars before you,
that's jumping the gun, quite literally, if we're talking about the Civil War.
Anti-Slavery has a long and complicated history from the colonial period to Revolutionary
Americas today, but something that your book really goes into detail is that this is a transformative
moment for anti-slavery and abolitionism. To help set up the worldview, what is the older view,
shall we say? What's kind of the vibe for people who are even thinking in anti-slavery currents?
What is the kind of status quo and what seems to be emerging out of the second-grade awakening
to start ruffling some feathers? Yeah, so to understand abolition, I think the first thing to
understand, as you mentioned, is the previous idea of it. The idea we no longer accept, and that's the
the notions that held sway from reconstruction through the 1950s, and that was the idea that
abolitionists were essentially religious enthusiasts or fanatics, mostly white men, who tried to
rabble rouse and get attention for their causes. They came from the middle class, and they were
basically a fanatical minority who eventually, through their radical action, pushed various
politicians and more marginal figures to violence, and the violence led the way till the civil war.
But we know that that's not necessarily the case, and this book is in fact something of a
corrective to that. Now, as you said, abolition begins as soon as there are slaves brought to
North America and to the West Indies. But at the same time, the modern abolition movement,
as we think about it, that has real public traction and begins to make a difference,
that really begins, as I mentioned in the book, in about 1817. And it's driven not by white
middle class religious reformers, but it's driven by urban black people. And they rise up basically
in conflict to this expanding notion at the time about colonization, which is the idea that
free black citizens should be shipped to Africa, and removed from the country as a danger to the
Republic. Now, black citizens didn't obviously didn't approve of this and held mass meetings,
and devoted newspapers to attacking the cause. And some of the key figures in that were people
like Samuel Cornish, who was a minister who became an early journalist, and perhaps the first
abolitionist journalist in the country, and established a precedent that from there other more
familiar figures built on, starting in about 1829, 1830, people like William Lloyd Garrison.
But we have to really remember that it's black Americans who started this and who gave it the
momentum to start up well before Garrison. And that's not just ministers. It's also more radical
figures like David Walker, who wrote the appeal to colored citizens of the world, and which he
called for people to rise up against this unjust and barbaric slavery system. And he called out
all levels of government in support of fighting back. And so by 1831, which was the time that William
Lloyd Garrison published his first edition of the liberator, we've already had 14 years of public
action by black figures, both of the grassroots level and the more elite levels. And so Garrison
comes along in 1830, gets a lot of attention because of the character of his editorials,
and follows up on what the thinking had been with those earlier abolitionists. And that is to
demand immediate abolition, not gradualism, but immediatism, as it was called, and to try to establish
a beachhead politically somehow against the overwhelming force of the slaveocracy, as they called it,
or the slave empire. And so with Garrison starting things out, along with people more conservative
figures like Arthur and Lewis Tappen, who were silk merchants, we find that abolition begins to
gain some movement through public discourse and through financial means because the Tappen's
have quite a bit of money to advance their cause. And from that, we start developing this into
the 1830s until eventually by 1838, it becomes a critical point in where the movement is going
to go after it's faced almost an entire decade of violence and force used against it. But that
establishes the precedent. And to summarize about what abolition was, it was a movement of black
and white people by this time of men and women, of middle and working classes, and all kinds of
different segments of the society, religious and secular. But the one thing it wasn't was driven
by politicians. People in elected office would have nothing to do with abolition and often fought
violently, implicitly against it. So you've mentioned William or Garrison, and I do want to touch on
Garrison more later. But one of the great things about your book, and by the way, I'm reviewing
your book for Lauren Liberty. So I should probably give that disclaimer. But one of the things I
very much enjoyed in your book is that there's this whole range of cast of characters that people,
myself included, have only met in passing if they know this time period well or probably have never
heard of. One of the ones that really jumped out to me was James Fortin, I think is how you pronounce
his surname. The Philadelphia sailmaker. I'd love to hear more about him and introduce him to my
listeners. Well, I think Fortin represented a lot of upper middle class black citizens' views,
because he had, he felt that he had been misled because he had been a young man during the
revolution, and he saw the promise of liberty embedded in the Declaration of Independence and the
Constitution, and wanted the government to follow up on that, because it seemed obvious, you know,
that the government would strive toward a more perfect union, and the best way to do that
would be to get rid of slavery. And in fact, early figures like Thomas Jefferson, James Madison,
expressed some regret for the presence of slavery, and there was a feeling at least in some
quarters that it was only a matter of time before it withered. Of course, it did not wither,
it became stronger and more pressive until it developed, of course, into the chattel system,
which had been from the beginning, but that kind of philosophy that went along with it was even more
egregious. And people like James Fortin, industrialists, men of money, really began to despair,
because this wasn't the promise of the country. And by the 1820s, it becomes clear that slavery
isn't going to go away on its own. It's not going to go away through the actions of politicians,
but rather it's going to take public pressure and grassroots action. And that's why James
Fortin has a large role in supporting black-owned newspapers at the time, like Freedom's Journal,
and later the Liberator, Garrison's white-owned newspaper, and eventually begins to apply his
largest to other anti-slavery organizations. So he becomes really a critical figure. Not a radical,
like as with other people with money, he's wary of too much radical action, but he does recognize
that it's important that radical voices be represented, and that immediatism be the governing
philosophy. So he's active in the 1830s, holding positions and funding these anti-slavery
organizations, most notably American anti-slavery society. And his daughter becomes a significant
figure as well, through her poetry, through her writings, and through her role in a women's
anti-slavery society based out of Philadelphia, along with more familiar figures like Lucretia Mott.
And so what's fascinating about this is that Fortin really represents his family,
because all of them were involved in this, really represents not only the growth of abolition,
but also the growth of the women's movement within abolition. And he supported both the work
of himself and his peers, but also his wife and daughters who were trying to establish a
beachhead for women's rights, along with abolition at the same time. So he's a trailblazing figure
in a number of ways. One of the things that's very striking in your book is because of the focus
on slavery, readers going into it might assume, "Oh, this is a southern problem." And the violence,
the mobbing, the feather, tar and feathering, the lynching, the riots, this has got to be a southern
phenomenon. But as you point out very quickly, I'll know, the North has its own streak of violence as
well. Yes, yes. In fact, slavery is an American institution, unfortunately, at the time.
And it's bound up in both the North and the South. So in the South, it's obvious that's where
it happens on the ground. But a lot of those plantations have northern investors and insurance
companies protect them through insurance. And shipping companies help facilitate the transit
of slaves there. And all manner of other means by which the North props up the southern system,
especially in the banking sector. And so it's very integrated into all levels of American society.
and there are a bit of. businessmen in the north with a keen stake in protecting slavery and making sure it continues.
And by the 1830s, they no longer can simply speak out against abolitionists and newspapers.
They have to encourage people to take action against them, violent action.
And so they feel that the best way to do this is to essentially rouse people up the white
working classes at first, white middle classes as well, men, and try to get them to battle abolitionists
in the street through public attacks. And so this force of capital, these businessmen,
these figures, really to protect their investments cynically, they have a large role in attacking
abolitionists and driving the movement to the point where they almost extinguish it at a
couple of times. And it's really a testament to the ability and the power of abolitionists.
They were able to survive this onslaught, because abolition was not a public movement in the south.
It was more or less kept under wraps through the open force of violence, through vigilance
committees, through public hangings, through midnight attacks, and breaking into people's
houses, and a bunch of other lurid horrors, as well as, of course, the enforced terror of slavery.
And so slavery and everything associated with it is as much a northern institution as a southern
one, and that's where the crux of the conflict comes from.
But there's also a conflict inside the anti-slavery movement itself. Besides the debate about
how, exactly, what's the most effective way to abolish slavery, those sort of legal debates,
constitutional arguments, there's more lived experience arguments as well. And that really
center on the issue of, do we or do we not employ violence to liberate slaves? Should we encourage
slaves to resist their enslaveurs violently? I mean, it's a fawny issue, and clearly,
your historical subjects know it's a fawny issue as well.
They do. And I would say that at the beginning of the 1830s, probably 98% of abolitionists
have adopted a nonviolent perspective, that through public pressure, through protest,
and things like that, that eventually slavery will wither. Now, the later incarnation of the
20th century is this is the MLK approach that Dr. King advocated nonviolence in order to eradicate
social injustice and terror. And certainly, it has its roots in the 1830s and well before that.
But by the end of the decade, by the end of the 1830s, a contrary strand emerges in abolition
that would come to be the primary strand by the Civil War. And that is a defensive attack,
not defensive, excuse me, a strong defense against slaveholders. And one of the first and most
prominent figures to advocate this after David Walker, who as I mentioned, wrote his book that
established something of the template for fighting back against slaveholders, was David Ruggles.
Now, Ruggles was a grocer and he was a press agent and he sold newspapers and did all manner of
other things in the 1830s, as well as establishing the first black owned magazine and bookstore.
But along with these things, he was also an advocate for strong defense against slaveholders coming
into the North and kidnapping free black citizens or trying to retrieve fugitive slaves. And he
did that through his New York committee of vigilance and that particular organization played a
large role in turning the tables at the very beginning of trying to establish public and
typically against the actions of slaveholders in the North. And he faced all manner of danger
for doing this. And he was arrested multiple times and beaten up and by the end of the decade,
he couldn't see and his health was failing. He was very much a martyr to the cause by the end
of his short life. But at the same time, he did tremendous work in establishing this contrary
strand of defensive protection for abolitionists instead of just simple nonviolence.
And eventually that strand would develop in all manner of ways through Henry Highland Garnet,
all the way up to John Brown and eventually the violence of war. But in the 1830s,
it was very much in flux and uncertain as to what direction the movement was going to go in.
And it was one of the causes for schism by the end of the decade.
In terms of the more nonviolent approach, if that's even I doubt they would use that language
per se, but on the one hand, you can kind of see the defensive resistance argument really clear.
Particularly the Moses example as well. In terms of looking at the theological, political,
cultural arguments of those who really don't sit well with violence, what are they drawing on?
What arguments are they making against this turning tide of defensive resistance slavery?
Well, we can just look at what Garrison's perspective is. And his perspective is shared
by a number of other abolitionists, much more conservative than he. And his perspective is that
Jesus Christ provides the model for how we should behave. So Christ, when faced with these
Roman terrors allowed himself to suffer for the sins of humanity and get nailed to the cross.
And with that as the example, then why should we do anything different? Why should we go against
what the New Testament clearly says of how you fight injustice? And Garrison was not alone in this
philosophy. It goes well back in US history and continues all the way to the present day.
And certainly many, many others followed him of all kinds of different ideological stripes.
So this was the governing philosophy. And Garrison gave him credit for being consistent. He supported
that. Even to the point where in 1835 he became the target of a mob, had a rope tied around him,
was being led to a gallows on Boston common. And still people said that he handled his soon-to-be death
as he saw it with dignity and grace. And so he had an idea that he would eventually be martyred.
In fact, that many people in the movement would be martyred. And this was a necessary step
in the process. So theologically, they didn't see it as a question. And in fact, I want to mention
something here because I think it's very interesting. Recently you had my fellow author, Ken Ellingwood,
on your program. And it was a great interview. I listened to it yesterday about the press and the
role of the free press in establishing abolition as a beachhead in the West. And the figure that he
chose to exemplify this is Elijah Lovejoy. Now, Lovejoy, of course, died. And he was a press
martyr. And some people at the time called him the first martyr to abolition. That isn't true.
There were plenty of martyrs before that who happened to be black. But Lovejoy himself
was a more moderate figure who became more radical. I believe Ken said this on the earlier
discussion. But the one thing I wanted to bring out about Lovejoy that's very interesting is
that when his death occurred in the East, many abolitionists brought him to greater fame,
has a martyr for the movement. And yet others like William Lloyd Garrison and some of his allies
found his death very distasteful. And they were horrified by it. Not because he had become
martyred, but because Lovejoy had armed himself, that he basically went down fighting with guns blazing.
And for people like Garrison, this was horrifying. The idea that someone would take to arms to fight
against their attackers, not only for religious reasons, but as the tap and said, abolitionists,
if this came to street battles with guns, they'd be completely outnumbered. And so there was a
practical element to it as well. But Lovejoy is critical, not just as a press martyr, but also
as a representative of this schism in the movement between whether to battle back against their
attackers using violence, or whether to accept it and accept martyrdom. Turning back to Garrison,
one of the things that's very interesting to me as you map out is, I don't want to say he's ever
changing. He is consistent, but Garrison seems to be a man who is evolving, perhaps. He
sou is on colonization in his life. He's very optimistic, and then he's very pessimistic about the
progress of anti-slavery activism. He really implores religion, and then he starts to think that
religious allies may not be the most reliable. I mean, he seems like a terribly tough guy to
to track down in terms of his
His intellectual development on slavery or at least to hold down
What do you make of his own evolution as an anti-slavery activist?
I think it's critical to what happened in the 1830s and to the schisms that occurred now
It's critical not necessarily because
Garrison guided the growth of abolition although he was a force behind it
I believe it's critical to the role that schism played to divide the movement at the end of the day
Decade and so Garrison as you mentioned he starts out and he in the 1820s. He supports colonization and
There are innumerable writings where he he takes that position and then eventually through reading black authors
He comes around to the idea that colonization is terrible and he publishes a pamphlet in 1832
expressing those views and
Channeling other views that immediate abolition is the only way to go and he continues down the course of
Nonviolence now
Eventually by the end of the decade he develops more and more of a Puritan streak lowercase p
Of trying to perfect the movement. He even dabbles with Christian perfectionism and dabbles with alternative health regimens and
starts
Having all kinds of interesting allies who are considered fringe figures
Because at the time he was trying to establish himself as the most uncompromising voice for non-slate non-violent
abolition
however
because of that
There were purity tests that Garrison demanded and that were unhelpful to the movement
So if you look in the history books one of the the nox on
Later abolition by the end of the 1830s is the claim that the women's movement and the role of women like Angelina Grimke and
Lucretia Martin others in pushing for women's rights along with abolition
Somehow served to divide the movement and that was a factor of it was a figure
It was an element of controversy at the time. There's little doubt about that
But what is less forgotten what I try to cover in the book is how
Garrison's demand for purity also played a role
In fact in 1837 he comes out and he starts attacking
Congregational ministers for
Their interpretation of the Sabbath and it actually becomes a huge tempest in print and it a major distraction for abolitionist because now
Abolitionists who don't really care when we are the other how the Salah Sabbath is recognized have to line up in support or against
Garrison on this
Extra issue that no one had really been debating before this at least not with the same vigor and
In this in other areas he seems to court controversy wherever he goes and
thus
By 1838 and by 1840 when his allies take over the American anti-slavery society
He has really established
Some rather severe perspectives on what it means to be an abolitionist and how to go about affecting the goal eventually later
As as we know he burns a copy of the Constitution in public
He turns away from organized religion in its conventional form and
he
Keeps establishing himself as a radical though as the years go on
There are plenty of more radical figures who are using violence to achieve their ends and so Garrison doesn't quite look as radical
But the entire evolution
that he affects at the time is very much toward a
Quest for this increasing moral purity and of course when you have a purity crusade
That isn't the most politically effective tactic and it shows by the end of the decade
So I'm currently working my dissertation about religious politics and the rise of the Jacksonian Democrats and
I've just was doing some writing today on Garrison and it's one of those interesting things where
Garrison basically hates both political parties the wigs and the Democrats and their presidential nominees
Adjust as bad as each other, but it's interesting. I do see some pushback where it's like dude if we can affect
Change with the ballot box like surely one presidential nominee is
Better than the other like it's very you know
Show surely you know in their perspective Henry Clay is better than Andrew Jackson 2.0
You know, there's there's these interesting things, but he has as you say I like that phrase
He does have these very rigid purity tests for his
his
Followers fan club. Yeah, right. I think that by
Eventually and by the 1860s he begins he begins to get a little better perspective on pragmatic politics in supporting
Abraham Lincoln's Abraham Lincoln's war policy for example
Even though there are still pacifists in the movement who don't support it and yet at the time
Yeah, he is he is an incendiary figure and
with each
Statement that he makes in the liberator with each extreme action
people like the tapens and other conservatives say that he makes it easier for
The movements enemies to caricature them as
fanatics as zealots because they have all the proof they need in the liberator of
Garrison mouthing off at somebody and being incredibly angry over what might some people might consider a minor issue like for example
The Sabbath and how to how to honor it and so yeah, he is he is an unusual figure still I would maintain that
He's unusual enough that he would be radical even today
I I think that if you plucked him out of that era and dropped him into
2022 that he could make a pretty good showing on cable news and be a figure of controversy even still
The book is littered with pretty horrific scenes and violent outbursts
I mean all this different backlash these early abolitionists are facing
You know people should read the book absolutely, but I was curious
When you are writing this book and in this interview. Is there an example or a story I case study if you will that really jumped
out to you that you'd like to share with listeners is there a particularly
horrific or memorable
moment of
Anti-slavery pushback that some listeners should know about
Yeah, it's hard to know it's hard to pick between the New York and
Anti-abolition right of 1834 and the Philadelphia
Anti-abolition riot of the same year both were
Absolutely terrifying and both if I can elide them both followed a similar course and that is
They start out by attacking figures of abolition their churches and things like that and eventually develop into a generalized
Attack against the black community and so in New York you have the initial stages where
Anti-abolition mobs are somewhat diffuse the actions take place over a couple days
There's even a theater riot that has nothing to do with abolition that's thrown in
and certain abolitionists homes are attacked like Lewis tap and the mob invades his house burns his furniture in the street his family is away by that time
and then tries to march down to Arthur tapens silk store and tries to
Burn that as well
unsuccessfully
But after that then the mob turns to various ministers who've supported abolition and
Sacks their churches and then provide the general attack against the black community in the five points by
Rating black citizens houses by taking their furniture out into the street by beating the owners of the houses and
Allowing white citizens to escape the violence by putting lighted candles in their windows
So that's the first major example that the history books will point out of this terrifying violence against abolitionists
but it's followed up a few months later in
Philadelphia and
This the narrative is even simpler. There is a carousel where black and white
people are known to intermingle and amalgamate as it's called that's the term at the time for race mixing which is of course
anathema to
pro-slavery
Enthusias or thugs whatever we want to call them and so
What we find is the carousel goes under attack by these white mobs and then over the course of a weekend
Eventually the mobs start marching down into the moiamencing a district of
Philadelphia if that's how it's pronounced and
attacking black citizens in the street breaking into their houses
lighting their furniture on fire
churches are also attacked and civic institutions to the degree that a number of citizens have to leave
Their homes they have to leave their neighborhoods across the river and camp out in Camden, New Jersey
Now if that isn't one of the most grotesque examples of American violence I can think of I
Can't out imagine what could be worse in the 1830s at least we know it does get worse in the next century with Tulsa and other horrors and
lynchings in between but certainly at the 1830s this is
You might say unprecedented, unprecedented example of barbarism against the free black community in the north.
And that's what really sticks out to me as these twin horrors of urban violence in 1834, in those cities.
Before we get to present us issues and practical questions I had for you, your book ends on a pretty ominous note because it's so focused on the 1830s time period.
Because as we all know, hindsight being 2020, this is heading towards civil war. This is heading towards a sectional crisis.
But these guys don't know that the quest for abolition is only just getting going and it's going to get a lot darker before it gets better.
With that ominous note, I'm curious with your ending in the 18 at the end of the 1830s and where this is unfolding.
Do you get a sense reading the sources, getting to know your subjects?
Where do they think things are going? Do they also think civil war is coming? Do they envision a separation of a free north and a slave, like two nations?
What are they dreading? What are they dreaming?
I think that many people, their opponents as well as the proponents of abolition, certainly felt like the question of disunion was paramount.
And it was talked about quite regularly. There is the question of disunion and the question of anarchy.
Because if you think about it at the time, the 1830s are only about 40 years removed from the reign of terror, which is the 1793, 1794 outbreak of extremism and the guillotine in revolutionary France.
And that was held up at least in intellectual circles as an example of what could happen if the bonds of society broke apart and the mob ruled the street.
Now among abolitionists, the mob were the white people who were attacking them and among the pro-slavery forces, the abolitionists were the mob.
So it was a convenient metaphor, regardless of who was promoting it. But that question of anarchy and public danger and disunion and the dissolution of the country was raised throughout the entire period.
And some people didn't want to come close to even threatening something like that, like the tapens. They had too much to lose and they truly feared what would happen if the bonds of the country were broken. They thought it could be reformed through political action or through social action.
Whereas sometimes people like Garrison and some of his more radical supporters, especially by the 1840s, assumed that the union could not go on as it was, that the constitutions implicit endorsement of slavery was so terrible that in fact the country might have to suffer because of it, might have to break up.
And in fact, the original sin from Garrison's perspective caused him to burn that copy of the constitution in public.
So a lot of people did have a feeling about union versus disunion and were prepared to take a stand either in favor or usually against disunion, but the threat of it was very real.
And so that a civil war occurred in 1861 wouldn't have surprised them. And in some ways, I think some of them might have expected it closer to 1850.
And it certainly could have happened if a number of variables hadn't occurred. So the question definitely hung in the air at the time.
Now, you've written several books and I'll ask you later if you're working on anything new, so hold that in your mind. But a lot of students listen to this podcast, budding academics, my colleagues, I always like to find out particularly with productive writers like yourself.
Do you have any writing advice any tips of the trade to offer students and writers how they can get across their own historical research?
Yes. So I have two and they're the best things I can offer. And I wish I had known them when I was writing earlier when I started writing about 25, 30 years ago.
And the number one thing I would say is that anyone can write, but a writer edits.
So the process of writing is the process of revision. Now, I know there are people like Jack Kerouac with his scroll out of his typewriter who just feel like that writing can come automatically.
And the art is in the creation of words as they go along and flow out of one's head. But I've found that not to be the case, at least I don't really write like that.
And my main goal when I start out on a first draft is just to get something on the page. I don't believe in writer's block. I think you put something down even if it's bad.
You just don't wait for the inspiration. Get it down. Get a purely mechanical dry first draft down. And then when you go back over it, you have a better perspective on it, especially the next day.
And for me, that's critical because I do find that the inspiration that enables a perfect paragraph to be written can be fleeting. And often it's the revision that makes the better writing.
I mean, I can think on one hand, perfect paragraphs that I've written that stayed that way in by the time of the publication of the book. But for the most part, it's revision. And I have kind of an example of how sometimes circumstance can undermine your attempts at having immediate inspiration.
And that is I had finished all of this book and got around to just needing to add the authors note, which is short. It's only two pages long, but it all came to me visually.
I could see how I would do the authors note and it'd be great. There'd be some clever turns of phrase and it bring people in and everything else. And so I sat down to write it because I thought I could just write it in five or 10 minutes and be done with it and not have to mess with it again.
And so what should interrupt this stream of consciousness, but my cat and the cat was like destroying things and leaping. I had never seen anything like it is, you know, he's one years old, but what are you going to do?
And he knocked something over and broken something. And so I had to get the cat under control before I could even begin to write this thing. And then by the time I had the inspiration was gone. And so I had to just go through it like I go through everything and just build it from the ground up.
So my first point would be wait for don't bother to wait for inspiration, but get something on the page and expect that you're going to revise because a writer revises and that's the primary duty of a writer, I think, to make things better.
The second thing is exercise, I, for me, it's, it's critical and it's, it's undervalued. And I've, I've gone through so many creative blocks, not writers blocks, just like structural issues and how to, how to solve them.
Just by pacing or taking a walk or exercising a treadmill, whatever it might be, and sometimes that's enough to do it. Often it is as long as you don't have your earbuds and are being distracted. And so those would be my two best examples of advice would be to edit and exercise the two ease.
I'm sure there's a third one as well. I just can't think of one at the moment. Maybe eat. Eat. Oh, that's it. Yeah, you eat. The brain needs energy. That's, that's great. Did someone else said that on, on your project?
No, it's funny though. I'm sure this is one of those fake quotes. This is wrongly attributed to him, but one of my favorite quotes that's attributed to brandis is there is no good writing, only good editing.
Yes, I completely agree with that. And that's certain. I'm sure there are savants out there that can sit and create perfect pages of pros or whatever they need, but I'm not one of them.
And for me, the difference between the amount of editing I do is anywhere from three drafts for a solid chapter to as many as eight. There are two. I won't mention what two chapters, but there were two chapters in this book.
That were quite a challenge to create. And in another chapter, I found that I had an entire section about an unrelated riot, a political riot that I wanted to showcase, even though it didn't really deal with abolition. And I couldn't, it was hard to integrate. So I just put it in italics.
You know, over three or four pages to set it off. And it's the only section like that in the book, but it does kind of show you the example of how mobs operated at the time. And it's the only section like that in the book.
But it does kind of show you the example of how mobs operated at the time before they got their hands on abolitionists.
Now, because you use the Portland Presence Example, it does seem that we are in.
of renewed, I don't know if that's the right word or reinvigorated or just a perhaps even just
new, a new kind of politically violent era, mass shootings, political violence, of course,
January 6th, you know, the riots that happened over the summer, like things are happening,
movers and shakers. And of course, you know, the issue of what is the best thing to do, for example,
I remember everyone got a big eyebrow raise when the New York Times published it's
in defense of looting and rioting, I think it was called, you know, so a lot of people reacted
to that, and you know, there was also, you know, the question of how culpable the former president
is in stoking the January 6th, when Richard Spencer got punched, that was a big debate,
is it okay to punch neo-Nazis or not, on and on and goes. I'm curious, after spending so much time
in this Jacksonian period of violence and then looking out to Portland and the wider United States,
do you think there are lessons to be learned or maybe lessons we need to to avoid, perhaps even,
from the Jacksonian era, or are they just so different, we shouldn't really compare the two.
Well, I think violence is so ingrained in American society, there's no way around it. I mean,
the country's birthed in a violent revolution, and countries like that tend to be violent. France is
similar. France, even though much safer in terms of street violence in the United States,
also has its share of social violence. And I do think there's something about the DNA of a country
that when violence is the reason towards birth, that it carries through its history. You can find the
contrary example with Canada. The official birth of Canada was not born in violence. If we consider,
I believe it was 1860s, that it got its freedom from the British Empire. And it's obviously not
free from violence, but has much lower levels of it than the US does. A famously H. Rap Brown said,
"Violences is American is cherry pie." And there's something to that. And we can identify certain
periods where there are these outbreaks of mass violence, 1830s, famously, also the 1870s and 1880s,
with labor conflict, the 1910s and the 1920s, and of course, the 1960s, which a lot of people remember,
which might even be a more socially violent period than today in terms of bombings and kidnappings
and things like that, not to mention hijackings of airplanes. So it's been with us. We just, I think,
forget sometimes that this is a significant strain in American life. And it's cropping up again,
and it's based in politics and society, and that's where it's often lodged. So I can't say I'm
terribly surprised by it, but in the reference to Portland, what did surprise me was the theatrical
aspect of it. The fact that the mayor and police could establish a cordon and just watch it take
place, time and time again, even up until last September, and not do anything about it. Now,
sometimes they did, but often it was just set off like something that was separate. And I think
that is unusual. And I haven't done a comparative study of this, but I would think that that
sort of thing might be germane to a certain type of way that Americans settle their conflicts.
And I hate to think that's true, but having written this book, I inclined to increasingly believe
it. And so that's why I don't try to sugarcoat the situation. And even in the introduction,
I mentioned that this is not a book with a happy ending. This isn't, this is a book that leads
to war. This is a step that the book depicts a nation coming apart that eventually will fight
itself. And in fact, it's still fighting itself in a more minor form in this political and social
violence. So I think it's been with us from the beginning and probably will always be with us
as long as the US is a nation. It seems one of the things that's fascinating for us as historians
anyway, something that the Twitter storyans are involved in is one of the reasons that we are
fighting is the imagining of our country's origins, the 1619 project, the 1776 project,
was America born in sin or was it born flawed and is trying to overcome, overcome its prejudice
and, you know, real progress has been made. No, it's been terrible from day one and has basically
flatlines. I'm curious, what do you make of the current quote unquote history was?
Well, I don't think there anything new. I think this has been going on for a while that every
once in a while, like in the 1950s. There's a sort of establishment history or what they call it,
this time, consensus history about how things operated that tries to play down differences and
establish smoothness in American history in terms of playing down some of the tumult.
But I think that this is a long running perspective in American society and you can take any
historical epoch and find people fighting against each other over one issue or another. I mean,
before the nation united for World War II, there was a 1930s and the conflicts brought about by
the depression and the rise of Roosevelt and the New Deal. And those were vigorously fought times
as well, dangerous and, and, and sendiary. Some of the figures at the time like Father Coughlin,
I don't even think could get on cable news these days. I mean, some of that was just rather extreme
and rhetoric. And we find this again and again going back to your point where people try to establish
different perspectives on history and try to write it in a certain way that enables them to
underscore their own view of what the history is. Now, in my own case, I don't take an opinion on
the 1776 project or 1619 project. What I say is a slavery and segregation racial turmoil has
been a part, racial turmoil and depression has been part of the country since the beginning.
I think that's a good point now. Is it primary? Is it, is it essential? Is it the core element?
That is something that those entities can fight over. The historians behind those things. I think
the reason that I step away from it beyond just the question and addressing the paramount issue,
or critical issue of slavery in American history, is just that I usually try to stay away from
comprehensive histories of things, like a toy, a toy and be approach or kind of an overarching
narrative for history because I don't really, I'm not sure I believe that. And I don't want it
affecting what I write about. I don't want someone else's narrative arc to history to affect
how I write about a few years in the 1830s. I want to uncover the story as it goes along,
even if it's dark, even if it reinforces someone's perspective on the narrative arc of history.
I'm a little wary about establishing those kind of things because I think it does a disservice
to the complexity and chaos of how history actually develops and how we can find different things
in it while acknowledging the terrors and oppression that are certainly there and that I've written
plenty about in my four books. Well, I guess speaking of writing about terror and oppression as
a current theme, is, do you have another book in the works? I've got to get out of the Northeast.
I've had the last two books have been said in Boston, Philadelphia, in New York, that triangle
up there. And you know, there's a lot there historically. My first book was in Washington, D.C.
And the second one opened up a bit more because it was about the Western theater of the Civil
War and William Sherman. So I'm probably likely to go back out West. If I can find a subject,
oriented around the West Coast or the Great West, I probably will just for a break because
I need something like that once the dust clears from this book. And so that's that would be my
answer to shift the narrative a little bit and do something new. And is there anything I didn't
ask you that you'd like to talk about? Or if anything that listeners should know about the
Republic of Violence, that's you didn't get to mention. So for me, I think the main thing about
writing this book and something to understand following up with what I mentioned about history
is this notion that often when people come out with a book that exposes a different aspect to a
certain era, era, someone will say because it goes against the grain, oh, this is revisionist
history. That's one of the favorite insults and people's arsenal. But I look at what
was being said at the time and try not to rely too much on secondary perspectives, although
secondary research is important, primary research is critical, more critical, and that's
because often what happens is that the perspective of the time, say in the 1830s, revolves around
a certain perspective on what abolition is, the controversies where it's going.
And only later, with people's synthesized histories, with the layers of myth that
accrete and develop over the years, do we get this sort of, how would I describe it?
Sort of a white-washed version of history.
And then if that history is challenged, then one is accused of being revisionist.
So I think the key is to try to provide the original vision before the revision.
In other words, to go back at a time and see what people are actually talking about, see
what the controversies were, and not worry as a writer about whether it's revisionist
or standard history, and just try to provide some interest, and in my case, from a narrative
perspective, in trying to draw people in and trying to make people realize the parallels
with now, and then try to realize what violence, for example, has its fundamental to the country,
and also to find what's heroic and inspiring that I mentioned in the author's note, to
try to have a new cast of figures that we can appreciate instead of just the familiar
names.
And so that, to me, is what the core of writing history is about, is trying to find out what
history was when it was being lived, not as it was later interpreted.
The book is the Republic of Violence, the tormented rise of abolition in Andrew Jackson's
America.
You are balancing to its author, J.D. Dickie, and the book is published with Pegasus
books.
It's available online and bookstores everywhere.
Is it available as an audiobook?
It's not yet.
No, we haven't got rights secured.
No.
Okay.
Hopefully audiobook coming.
J.D., thank you so much for joining me.
Yes, absolutely.
Regarding audiobooks, the previous three are in audio form.
So if you want to take a chance on one of those, have at it.
I can vouch for American DemiGov.
That was a good, that was a good listen.
Okay.
That's great.
You have been listening to the Age of Jackson podcast.
I've been your host as always, Dan Nicolotta.
Catch you next time.
Please subscribe.
Click the podcast five stars.
Share it with your friends.
J.D.
Thanks again.
Thank you.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The book *The Republic of Violence* explores the violent, turbulent 1830s in America, particularly the rise of abolitionism and its violent backlash, challenging the myth of a peaceful antebellum era.
Abolitionism emerged not from white middle-class religious fanatics, but from grassroots Black activism, with figures like Samuel Cornish, David Walker, and James Fortin driving early public resistance to colonization and slavery.
Northern cities like Philadelphia and New York saw violent anti-abolition riots in 1834, including mob attacks on abolitionists, their homes, churches, and Black communities, revealing that slavery was a deeply entrenched national institution.
A key internal conflict within abolitionism was whether to use nonviolence or defensive resistance—Garrison championed nonviolence based on Christian principles, while figures like David Ruggles advocated for resistance against slaveholder violence.
The movement was fractured by ideological purity tests, gender dynamics (e.g., women’s roles in abolition), and growing radicalism, ultimately leading to a schism by the end of the 1830s.
Violence and political unrest were not confined to the South; the North actively protected slavery through economic ties and violent repression, showing the national integration of slavery.
The book draws modern parallels to current political violence, such as Portland’s 2018–2021 street battles, suggesting that patterns of state tolerance of civil unrest have historical roots in the Jacksonian era.
The author argues that history is often whitewashed, and modern "revisionist" labels are a reaction to uncovering original, chaotic, and violent realities that were suppressed in mainstream narratives.
Summary:
D. Dickie’s *The Republic of Violence* presents a stark, unflinching account of the violent and tumultuous 1830s in America, focusing on the rise of abolitionism and the fierce resistance it provoked. Contrary to the common narrative of a peaceful antebellum era, the book reveals that the North, too, was deeply entangled in slavery through economic interests and violent repression.
Abolitionism began with Black-led activism—figures like Samuel Cornish, David Walker, and James Fortin challenged the colonization ideology, laying the foundation for public resistance. This movement was met with violent backlash, including the infamous 1834 riots in Philadelphia and New York, where mobs attacked abolitionists, destroyed homes, and targeted Black communities. Internal divisions emerged over whether to use violence in resistance, with William Lloyd Garrison promoting nonviolence based on Christian principles, while others like David Ruggles advocated defensive action.
The movement also fractured due to internal purity struggles, gender roles, and ideological extremism. Dickie highlights how the nation’s violent undercurrents—rooted in slavery and political conflict—have persisted through history, with modern instances like Portland’s street battles echoing the past. The book challenges mainstream historical narratives by emphasizing the original, chaotic realities of the era, arguing that violence and racial oppression were central to American development from the beginning.
It ultimately warns that political unrest and mob violence are not new phenomena but enduring features of American society, shaped by its foundational tensions.
FAQs
Dickie was drawn to the period because of its high levels of street violence and the connection to modern political unrest, especially in Portland, Oregon. He also found that the 1830s were a peak period of violence linked to the rise of abolitionism and the political instability of the Jacksonian era.
The 1830s were a peak period of daily street violence, fueled by alcohol, political conflict, and the violent enforcement of slavery. While violence has always been part of American history, this era saw a surge in mob actions, attacks on abolitionists, and public clashes that were both widespread and intense.
Yes, the Second Great Awakening promoted the idea of personal responsibility for salvation, leading many to believe that social reform—like abolition—was a moral duty. This movement provided the ideological foundation for abolitionist activism, especially among religious and middle-class citizens.
The movement began with Black leaders like Samuel Cornish, David Walker, and later William Lloyd Garrison. These figures were foundational, and the early momentum came from urban Black communities who opposed colonization and called for immediate abolition.
Early abolitionists mostly advocated nonviolence, inspired by Christian teachings and the example of Christ. However, by the end of the 1830s, a defensive, violent strand emerged—led by figures like David Ruggles—advocating for resistance against slaveholders and white violence, which eventually contributed to the movement's internal divisions.
Violence was widespread in both North and South. Northern cities like New York and Philadelphia saw violent attacks on abolitionists and free Black communities, showing that slavery was deeply embedded in the national economy and society, with Northern businesses and investors protecting the institution.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.