Go back

146 The Evolution of American Equality with Michael A. Bellesiles

1h 18s

146 The Evolution of American Equality with Michael A. Bellesiles

In his new book *Inventing Equality: Reconstructing the Constitution in the Aftermath of the Civil War*, Michael Burleels argues that the United States did not naturally embrace equality under the law, but instead "invented" it through the transformative events of the Civil War and Reconstruction. He traces the contradiction between the Constitution’s foundational ideals—like human equality and liberty—and its practical enforcement, which excluded Black people and marginalized other groups from citizenship and rights. Early American writings, including those of Thomas Jefferson and James Madison, reveal deep ambivalence and even hostility toward equality, particularly regarding race. The Constitutional Convention's compromises—such as the three-fifths clause and the fugitive slave clause—systematically embedded racial hierarchies into the nation’s legal structure. Throughout the Jacksonian era, Southern states intensified restrictions on free Black people and limited political rights, even as white male suffrage expanded. Key figures like Frederick Douglass and Abraham Lincoln evolved in their views, with Douglass ultimately embracing the Constitution as a tool for reform and Lincoln recognizing the moral necessity of human equality during the war. Burleels contends that the Civil War era marked a critical turning point when the nation legally redefined equality through the 13th, 14th, and 15th Amendments. However, he warns that American history is not a simple story of progress, but a persistent struggle between ideals and reality, where uncomfortable truths have often been suppressed. The book calls for a truthful reckoning with this ongoing battle for equality, emphasizing that the full realization of democracy depends on continuous vigilance and reform.

Transcription

8245 Words, 47132 Characters

English
Greetings listeners, and welcome back to the Age of Jackson podcast. I am your host as always Daniel Goliath, PhD candidate, ABD in American Religious History at Stanford University. Kicking off the new year, I have a returning guest Michael Burleels, who joins me to talk about his new book, Inventing Equality. Reconstructing the Constitution in the aftermath of the Civil War, published with Mick Millen, available as an e-book, a hard copy book, and also available as an audiobook. I quite enjoyed listening to the audiobook, just so people know. He received his PhD from the University of California in Irvine. He has been a professor of history at Trinity College in Connecticut at Emory University. He's the author of several books, including 1877, People's History of the US Military. He's now retired and enjoying retirement from what I can tell in a shack outside. Welcome back to podcast Michael. Thank you Daniel. It's absolutely delightful to be here and you're right. I am enjoying retirement in a shack in my backyard. I always like to start off these interviews with origin stories questions, and you've written about all sorts of things, from Ethan Allen to firearms to the military, all sorts of things. Why equality and the Constitution? How did you come to this topic? What's the origin story? Well, thank you for asking Daniel. I think Inventing Equality is really the project of my lifetime. It is a subject, human equality, which I have thought about constantly. I think it goes back to when I was in high school. I took a civics class, which we used to be required, with a rather unpleasant teacher who originated from Alabama, and this was when segregation, that's how old I am, this was when segregation still exists in this country, legal segregation, and this teacher defended segregation routinely by saying that the southerners wanted it, so they should be allowed to keep it, and one day I innocently asked, and I'm using the language of the time, if Negroes who lived in the South were not also southerners, aren't they southerners? And they clearly don't like segregation, doesn't their opinion matter. And I have to admit, I don't recall his response, but I would never forget the look of distaste on his face. My suggestion that anyone but a white person could be a southerner, and I emphasize that they were black and Hispanic students in that civics class, I was very confused, and the next year I took US history, as also was required back then, and our textbook bought into the lost cause mythology, though I didn't know the language at the time, and I learned that the Civil War, was contrary to my childhood's opinion, was thought over states rights, and not over slavery, and that reconstruction was a deeply corrupt period, in which scallow eggs and carpet beggars did more damage to the south and had the Civil War, but who were the scallow eggs? They were southerners, my teacher explained, who like General Longstreet, from the Confederate Army, who sided with the Republican Party, therefore they were not true southerners, and who were the carpet beggars. They were American citizens who moved to the southern states, as was their right. So again, I was very confused, and then in college I had the great advantage of taking Paige Smith for history, and he became my advisor, and he recommended that I take the very first African American history course taught at my college. And in that course, I read mostly, we read mostly source documents, and my eyes opened to the reality of American history. It's where I first heard that there were black troops in the Civil War. I didn't know that, and I ended up writing a paper on the subject in which I searched dozens of contemporary history texts and general histories of the Civil War, and it was not a word on these soldiers. And that's the moment I always have thought that I became an historian, that I thought his history matters, and I've been obsessed with the issue of human equality, especially within the United States ever since. I want to pinpoint two words in the title, inventing and reconstructing. On the one hand, my postmodernist Heavie GVs get riled up when I see words like that, because it could be taken to all sorts of directions. But of course, somebody else could look at that and say, "What do you mean inventing equality?" Maybe we discover equality, but I thought this was self-evident. How do we invent equality? And reconstructing the constitution, that implies that there was something there that was broken. What do you mean? What do you mean? So I feel free to tease out your title a little bit. That's an excellent question. Yes, I do know when I was working on this book that I often would be chatting with other historians and say, "Well, you don't invent equality. It exists. We discover it." And that is true. I agree completely, but I believe the point of my book is that Americans needed to invent the legal concept of equality because they did not accept or practice equality under the Constitution of the United States up until the Civil War period. Thomas Jefferson famously said that these truths are self-evident, that all men are created equal and endowed by their creator with certain unalienable rights that are money's or life liberty in the pursuit of happiness. But was it self-evident? There is no indication that Jefferson thought equality was self-evident. He struggled with it his entire life, which is admirable. It appears constantly in his personal correspondence and his conversations, trying to categorize this notion of equality. But in his practice, in his political life, he certainly did not embrace equality. And the greatest irony, perhaps in American history, as you know, is that the same man who wrote those beautiful words in Declaration of Independence just four years later wrote the first racial defense of American slavery in the notes in the state of Virginia, in which he made very clear that in his opinion that black slaves and black people in general were clearly inferior to whites and whites were superior in all categories. So I felt that it was appropriate to say that a generation of Americans, the generation that was involved in the American Civil War, invented the concept of legal equality in order to correct the obvious flaws in the Constitution of the United States. And that's what I mean by reconstructing the Constitution. They didn't replace it, they didn't delete any key passages except for the Fusion of Slavak. What these amendments to the Constitution, the 13th, 14th, and 15th amendments did, is they rebuilt the U.S. Constitution on the firm ground of legal equality, the understanding that all adult citizens of the United States theoretically share the same rights before the law, and that this was an enormous accomplishment and an incredible alteration in the United States in a matter of just four or five years. The United States went from a country in which legal equality was not accepted, not practiced, and generally derided to seeing those values become part of our frame of government. And I think that is an accomplishment worthy of attention and appraise. - And setting up the context, beginning around the revolutionary and early American period, something you highlight at the start of the book is, first of all, the colonial, republican, emerging republican notion of equality is very different to our own concept of equality. And yes, it is absolutely true, and the crux of the book centering on particularly non-white people's lack of equality. But there's still, you know, at the turn of the revolution, there's plenty of inequality amongst white people and white men. So how do we go to how what does equality mean in this revolutionary era? And how do we start to see a kind of white man's equality emerge and the burgeoning of a struggle for a multiracial equality? What are the birth pains like? - Excellent question. So in the revolutionary period, Jefferson is really responsible along with Thomas Payne for putting the concept of equality before the public. And it was much debated and you will find it in a wide variety of sources from ministers, sermons through, you know, newspaper advertisements, you will see the use of the word equality, excuse me, and the discussion of how it will impact the country we are creating during the American Revolution. And it was vague. It was not agreed upon. It was not certain. There was a sense that the members of the political community of this new nation of the United States had some sort of fundamental equality of rights, and that those needed to be determined with time, with experience, and in keeping with the laws of nature, because after all this was very much an enlightenment project. And so those laws of nature were fundamentally problematic to use in modern language, but fundamentally open to debate. So for instance, one of the most obvious examples is the difference between men and women. We can agree that, you know, if we were living in the Revolutionary Period, we would agree that women are also inhabitants of this new nation, and they deserve to share certain rights, pardon me a moment. Excuse me, but how do we determine what those rights are without interfering with what they saw as a natural laws separating the genders? Women, it was felt, were definitely delicate and not as mentally advanced as men, and therefore they could not, of course, participate in the political community, and they had no legal rights under British common law. There's, you know, the famous Blackstone's notion of coverture in which the man spreads his wings over the woman to protect her through marriage and acts on her on her behalf. That is the theory again. So there was a lot to work out, and it was not really clear. And when it comes to the constitutional convention and these discussions start to occur, which you can see in Madison's notes, there is this surprise that the real issue is about slavery. The real issue is how do we talk about equality and yet also have a system of slavery? But there's always these twists, because in New England, there's also a great heritage of anti-papacy, of opposition to Catholicism, and a lot of the New England representatives don't want Catholics being included into any definition of equality, of white male suffrage, of equal rights before the law. And so there's a lot of back and forth over how do we qualify the equality that we want to put into the Constitution? It is there. I mean, there's no mistake that the notion of equality is in the very first words of the Constitution of Korea. We, the people of the United States, and it's to secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our prosperity. How do we do that? But can we still exclude people? I mean, this is the fundamental question. So the obvious thing is who are the people? And what the Constitutional Convention came up with, of course, was, first off, a flat-out cop-out. They refused to define citizenship. They refused to say who the people are. They were going to leave that to Congress. They were pushing it down the road for Congress to address when the Constitution was approved. And the second thing they had to do was reach these, and I put this in quotation marks, compromises with the representatives from the Carolinas in Georgia who consistently threatened to bolt the Convention. If anything was said about slavery in a derogatory sense, any limitations placed on it as an institution, anything that implied that black people were equal to white people, none of this could be allowed. And their property rights had to be insured. And that is where we get a rethinking of equality along the lines of white supremacy. Because, as you know, the compromises that are reached, the most important of them is the notion, and they just drew this number out of the air, the notion that a black person is three-fifths of a white person. The debates are instructive. And when they were published in 1840, they would rather shock the nation. These are James Madison's notes, because especially Gouverneur Morris comes forward and he says, you know, if you're going to insist that your slaves are property and should be counted for population, then why isn't our property in cows and horses counted for population? And that will be remain the fundamental pivot of the debates right up through the Civil War. Can you have people who are property? So when the Constitution is ratified, when Congress refuses to address the issue of citizenship, political leaders, ministers, intellectuals of all kind, start to issue the qualifications and equality. Some of them were limited to just white men. We can agree on this. Every white man is equal to every other white man. But others, especially the state of Rhode Island, stands out in Mr. Guards as well. We're not talking about Catholics here, are we? We can't possibly include Catholics into our definition of equal white men. And we certainly can't include the Irish because there's a supposition that the Irish are not even white. So we can't include them. Immigrants in general, we should be quite skeptical of them, as being part of our political community. And that will become a debate that persists right through the Jacksonian period. And again, up until the Civil War. One of the words you use to describe a certain group of the framers and the founders is embarrassed that people like Madison seem to get a little, they seem to not like, as you highlight, they seem to know what they're doing is wrong, bad, hypocritical. But yet there are other people like P.S. Butler, like Charles Pitney, they basically really, they have an unapologetic, they don't see anything wrong with that. So to put these two together, I can imagine an undergraduate student, a curious audience member, how do we square this round hall? If they're so embarrassed, why don't they do more? But if these guys are so pro-slavery, why don't we tell, why don't we say to hell with you and leave? Or why don't they say to hell with you and your anti-slavery embarrassment? Why don't you go away and leave us alone? What would you say to that? They threatened to do that. And they were threatened to do it right up through 1861. And when they finally do, at the Constitutional Convention repeatedly, the representatives from those three southernmost states threatened to walk out. And as a matter of fact, Gouverneur Morris wants to put that in a constitution. He wants to put it into the constitution that we are supporting the institution of slavery. And he wants to use the word in order to keep Georgia, North Carolina, and South Carolina in the Union. So they are embarrassed. And even slave owners, especially from the state of Virginia and Maryland, you know, Luther Martin and Madison and Worth in a whole array of leading southern politicians and themselves slave owners. They're embarrassed because they've just fought this revolution on an international basis promoting freedom. And they know that it's wrong that they own slaves. Jefferson knew it. He talked about it constantly. He understood, as he says, in a wonderful contradiction in notes in the state of Virginia, that slavery makes every slave owner a tyrant. He understood it and they're embarrassed, but they don't know how to attain their primary goal, which is to create a unified nation, which will include all the states, including those three southernmost states. And yet, have our nation represent freedom. While promoting slavery, it is of course a contradiction that does not work. And I think the history of the Jacksonian period and the lead up to the Civil War proves that it proves that Abraham Lincoln was right that a house divided against a self-kindness cannot stand because you cannot treat some people as property and protect property rights, yet still somehow insist that people are free. It just doesn't work. And just even by saying there are three-fifths of a person, it doesn't resolve the issue, as we will see, as time progresses. So yes, they're embarrassed. Of course, they're embarrassed. In Madison, You will see it in the Federalist Papers. There is only one discussion of slavery. And it's presented as the fugitive slave clause. It's presented as a necessary compromise. And that's why the Southern States, by the way, to answer your question more efficiently. That's why those three most Southern states want to stay in the Union. They want the strength of their federal government to help them retrieve runaway slaves. Now, it's one thing to talk about equality, and letters, and sermons, and speeches. But as your book evolves, the real laboratory of this, the real tests for this, becomes the legal battles, the courtroom dramas, the Supreme Court rulings, even the local and state stuff. What's up with the legality of it? Why is the legal framework of this so important? Again, very good question. You recently had a conversation with Jordan Watkins on your show. It was fascinating. And he raised two excellent points. It really, really captured my attention. The first is, if I may digress for just a moment here, the first is, he linked biblical and legal criticism, constitutional criticism, in a fascinating way. And what he's talking about is how American theologians and ministers became aware of the biblical criticism coming out of Germany, which wanted to place the Bible in its own context, in its own history. And then wanted to say, we're so distant from that. We're 1,800 years later. We need to treat the sacred text as a living document, not as a static one. And that allows us to interpret it. And American legal scholars, most notably Franz Lieber, who was himself an immigrant, I think he even coined the phrase constitutions living document. But they wanted to see the Constitution the same way. They wanted to see the Constitution not as a static, dead document, but as a living document that was open to interpretation and change. And that becomes the heart of the legal and intellectual battle in America, starting as early as 1820s. Because-- and this is the second point of lockings made that I really liked. He says that essentially, the defenders of the static Bible and the defenders of slavery and religious defenders of slavery in America, in the Jacksonian period, they claimed to speak with equal facility for Jesus and Paul and Madison and Hamilton. They claimed that they understood what was met when the Bible was written and when the Constitution was written. And so they promoted the static vision of the Constitution. At least that's what they claimed. It was essentially their version of original intent. They claimed that they understood what was met by the framers of the Constitution. And that's how we should operate. And that supports slavery. But whenever it doesn't suit their purposes, what they would do is they would change history, which is very effective. On the other hand, a growing number of legal scholars in America and of practicing jurists and lawyers started to see the Constitution as a more dynamic document, one which we can interpret. And there's an extremely important example of how this works in 1822 when South Carolina in response to the Denmark-Vasey uprising in the Charleston area, they passed the Negro Siemens Act. Now what most people don't realize is that the US Navy was fully integrated through its history. And so there were, even within the US Navy, there were black sailors. And of course on private ships, there were lots of black sailors. Marcus Radiger estimated something like 1/4 of all merchant Siemens in the United States were black. And they would come to Charleston Harbor, and they would get shorely, and they would come ashore. And they're free blacks. That's a bad example for the slaves in the opinion of the South Carolina legislature. So they passed the Negro Siemens Act, which said that if any black Siemens came ashore, they would be taken and sold into slavery. This is a shocking development. And of course, it goes to the US Supreme Court, and Justice Marshall speaks for the Court-- you know, Adam's Court-- declaring that this act is clearly unconstitutional. It's a clear violation of the equal rights of these Negro citizens of the United States who are working freely as sailors, and as members of the US Navy and the merchant marine, seems that case closed, right? No. Because South Carolina simply ignores this Supreme Court decision. And when the New England states get together and send two legal scholars down to Charleston to try and work out a compromise with the state of South Carolina, the legislature declares them insane, temporarily puts them in a lunatic asylum, and then ships them back up north. And so the Negro Siemens Act remains the law of South Carolina right up to the Civil War. Well, one of the things that's interesting-- one of the things that's interesting throughout the book is the tensions that are at play in this time period, where we are seeing an expansion of white people, particularly white men's democratic rights. Although it is interesting, you have a little bit of-- you have a few sides about how true that is as well, which we could get into because of class distinctions in the South. But at the same time, like, the great irony that historians have been pointing out for decades now is, at the same time, white men's rights are supposedly expanding, or if they are or not. Unquestionably, the rights of free black people and deathly slaves are being more and more and more constrained, particularly, following the Denmark Bayesian revolts. The Haitian revolution puts everybody into panic mode. So there are these two, like, kaleidoscope experiences going on. Yeah, and actually, this is-- I think the Jacksonian period is fascinating for many reasons, of course, but especially for me, in this context, because you're right. Historians, for roughly the last 30 years, have been pointing out that even as the rights of white men in America are being expanded through the 18 teens and 20s and 30s, that the walls protecting the institution of slavery and the inequality inherent in Southern society are being built higher and higher and stronger and stronger to limit ever further the rights even of free blacks. Southern states are becoming very uncomfortable with that concept of a free black person. But what I argue in my book is that there's more to the story, that at the same time that the rights of blacks are being limited. So are the rights of whites, because I think the story is wrong. The Jacksonian America is not a period of the expansion of the rights of white men uniformly. I think that is roughly true in terms of voting rights in the North. But even in the South, the Southern states maintain most of them maintained class distinctions in voting rights, especially South Carolina. They don't change their voting rights laws until after the Civil War. But more importantly, how do we define legally equality and legal rights in the United States? Generally, it is understood that the rights I have, the rights I have, are the rights that you have that they are the same. And they're protected by our legal system. But the opposite was happening starting in the 1820s in the South. And nothing is more evident, makes it more evident than the right of free speech. That is an inherent right in America. I think all of us agree on that notion that even if we limit equality to white men, that all white men should have the right of free speech, yet the Southern states were cracking down on it and that basic fundamental right routinely starting in the 1820s, where it was becoming illegal to discuss any kind of reform, even of slavery, let alone opposition to slavery. But even reforms of slavery could not be discussed. It was illegal to publish any questioning of slavery. And even more shockingly, I believe, the Southern states reserved to themselves the rights to interfere with the federal mail service and to open all letters to look for any expressions of, opposition to slavery. And they then took it the next step. They had just started to expand educational system in the early part of the 19th century and the southern states actually throughout the United States. It was a wonderful step toward universal education, at least at the elementary level, where in the 1820s and 30s, the southern states reversed course. They cut funding for public education, only essentially, only those who could afford even an elementary education were receiving it. So by the time the Civil War occurs, there are many efforts on the part of Union soldiers to determine how many of these southern soldiers could read and write. And the general discovery was it was a neighborhood of a quarter. So roughly three quarters of these white men who were supposedly equal from the southern states could not read and write. Their fundamental rights are being taken away from them slowly but certainly through the Jacksonian period. In bringing back the Constitution, something that's pretty well established, but when it comes to someone like Frederick Douglass and William Lloyd Garrison, particularly with Douglass's divorce from that version of anti-slavery abolitionism, but I wanted to blow it up to more the what's going on in the larger circles. Because when it comes to the Constitution, as you highlight, on the one hand, there are these anti-slavery activists who see the Constitution as this is the poison pill, this is the chain, this is the very means that in protects and enshrines slavery forever and ever, and until we get rid of this, until we basically this compact whip hell, you know, that's the end game. But others, which eventually someone like Douglass is converted to, which we can talk about later, they like, no, this is the means of slavery's destruction. The Constitution is a scalabuck, like it is in the stone, we have to, we can utilize constitutional arguments of the very, that we can use this document to undo slavery. What the heck, like how do we have these two, these two rival schools were such approaching differences on the Constitution? And, you know, do we have a sense of where they're popular or who makes them popular in the legal realm? Oh yes, definitely. The problem, of course, is the essential one, that the Constitution is self-contradictory. There's no way of getting around it. The way it was originally written, it contradicts itself routinely. I mean, you can see it even in article four, article four section two, this was an article of the Constitution that was beloved by both sides of the debate because, as you know, it begins, the citizens of each state shall be entitled to all privileges and immunities of citizens in a civil state. This is what gives us the right to move from Georgia to Connecticut or Ohio to Alabama, and we will have the same rights. You know, that is just simply fundamentals, right? They're in the Constitution, and those who saw the Constitution as a compact for freedom, they almost always refer to two things, the preamble of the Constitution and article four section two. Ta-da, but the third paragraph of article four section two is that no person held to service or labor in one state under the laws there of escaping to another shell and consequence of any law of regulation therein, be discharged from such service or labor. This is the runaway slave clause, but you know, so it seems like, you know, those who say, no, no, no, the Constitution is not about human equality. There's nothing in there about equality. The word doesn't occur. It's said it's a compact that establishes how on laws were function, and in this regard it's saying clearly that it's responsibility of the federal government and of the several states to return runaway slaves, and you cannot pass laws in your states to prohibit that, to which those who want to see the Constitution as a document of freedom say, aha, but look, it says no person. So these slaves are people, and there, again, we have the contradiction. Now, on the other hand, you have those like Wemlaud Garrison who say, that's the problem. This is a compact with the devil. It's not a legal compact. It is in fact so contradictory that it cannot function, and we need to get rid of it, or we need to, the free states, we need to leave the union. It's actually kind of ironic in the 1840s, particularly, you see both sides of the debate talking about succession, talking about leaving the union, because the Constitution can't work as it's worded. It has too much that indicates a respect for freedom, and too much that indicates support for slavery. In bringing up, you know, if there was an application for greatest American ever who's lived, my application would be for the man, Frederick Douglass, but in zeroing in on Douglass, for listeners who may not have realized that he is converted, I'd love to hear about Douglass, the constitutional thinker, grappler, engager. What is Douglass's relationship with this document, and how does he change his mind over time from seeing it as a document that enshrines slavery to a glorious liberty document, as he calls it later? Wow, that is a fundamental and large question, and I would immediately recommend David Blight's biography in this regard. Just, yeah, I agree. Frederick Douglass is one of the most brilliant and subtle minds of the 19th century. I'd put him up there with Abraham Lincoln in this regard. And, like Lincoln, I admire Frederick Douglass so much because he's able to change his mind in important ways when the evidence directs him that way. So, yes, Frederick Douglass, when he started, he was a runaway slave. He stole himself. He was a rebel without a doubt. He broke the laws of Maryland when he taught himself to read. He broke the laws again with the death, facing the death penalty when he taught other slaves to read. And then, of course, he ran away. And the fact that he had to essentially go into exile in Europe for many years, and that he had to hide whenever he was in the United States because slave catchers were after him, not surprisingly, made him think that the Constitution was not a document, supportive in any way of freedom. In fact, quite to contrary, the fugitive slave clause, the three-fifth slave clause made clear that it did not treat black people as human beings. So, yes, he agreed with Garrison that the Constitution should be eliminated or that we should, perhaps the country should separate into two sections and have a different constitution for the Northern Free States. It was perfectly understandable that he had this view. And in his very famous speech, now, I'm happy to say very famous speech in 1855, to the slave is the Fourth of July. He made clear why he was angry at the Constitution, why the Constitution was deserving of our disrespect, and why the framers had made a terrible mistake in trying to square that circle of property in people. It cannot work. You cannot have freedom and slavery together. But starting around 1850, Douglass began to look and think, I believe, much more carefully and, and again, subtly, cleverly about what the Constitution says. What actually matters in the Constitution? For Douglass, two things mattered. One is that it does promote freedom. That preamble, which is such beautiful language, makes clear that the Constitution exists to promote freedom. And other parts of the Constitution, including, of course, the Bill of Rights, makes clear that its general intent is to promote freedom. And more importantly, still, in this regard, he goes back to the framers. And he doesn't claim, like the white supremacists, to speak for the framers. He lets the framers speak for themselves. What did they say over and over again? They said they knew slavery was wrong, and they knew that it had to be addressed, and that the. Constitution, while it promoted freedom, must include these unfortunate compromises with the Southern elite in order to hold the nation together, but it's about freedom. That's what they believed, and that's what Douglas came to believe. And the second beautiful thing of the Constitution, he thought, is that you could change it. It's right there in the Constitution. It's not easy, but you can change it. In order to change the Constitution, you have to change people's minds. And that is what Douglas then devoted, I believe, the rest of his life to trying to do, to trying to persuade the American white people that black people are their equals, that all men, in fact, are created equal, and Douglas, and I have always respected him for this, extended it to women too, all people are created equal. He believed that, and he tried to make it part of the Constitution, and he deserves our respect for that. Before we wrap up, because there's so much more of the book that deals with the Civil War era and the Reconstruction era, particularly with the radical Republican amendments that come in. I wanted to end, before we turn to more practical and present-tissed issues, I wanted to bring up perhaps the runner-up for the greatest American who's ever lived, Abraham Lincoln. Lincoln has his own complicated relationship with anti-slavery and anti-slavery constitutionalism. Because, you know, if you, you know, it's funny how these things never change, something I like to show students, as many of the back-and-false we're having today, about how hardcore was Lincoln anti-slavery, was he really just a pushover and didn't really care, like, no, he actually was sincere. It's interesting to me, like, reading Wigg and then later Republican opinions about, like, oh, he's a black Republican in hiding, or like, no, he's going to sell the farm, and before you know it, we're going to have traders and slavers running the show again, because Lincoln's a weak need. I'm curious, what do you make of Lincoln's anti-slavery efforts and sentiments and opinions? What does Lincoln fit into your thinking on inventing equality? I do think Lincoln is one of the great Americans, and I think he has the characteristic that I most admire in the United States is the ability, again, to change one's mind for solid reasons. Lincoln, like, pretty much every white politician in America, up until 1860, was a white supremacist. It's right there in the Lincoln Douglas debates, but Lincoln was without a doubt anti-slavery, his whole life, his whole adult life. He had a profound sense of moral pugments towards that institution, and again, that comes across in the Lincoln Douglas debates, and in pretty much anything Lincoln ever said. And he had, and I recommend Daniel Allen's book, our declaration on this issue, that Lincoln understood, again, deeply, that what the United States promised, and that it's there in the Declaration of Independence, and that's why he wanted to essentially make it one of our founding documents. What's there in the Declaration of Independence is notion that each person is best able to decide for him or herself their own best interests. What a radical idea. That people who say, "This is for your own good." Don't know what they're talking about, and he has this beautiful comeback to Stephen Douglas during the debates, when Douglas is saying that slavery is for the good of the black people, he knows it's for their own good. And he says, "Well, then name me any white person who would willingly become a slave. It wouldn't happen. No one wants to be a slave, and telling them it's for their own good is just a con job." And he understood that, I believe. So, sure, he's a white supremacist. Sure. And he's anti-slavery, and for him these things are not contradictory, because what he aimed for, and what he made clear in the 1860 election, was that he wanted to limit the spread of slavery, and he wanted to promote freedom. Absolutely. But he was willing to accept the continuation of slavery in the 13 states, where it existed. And he was a supporter of what would have been the 13th Amendment to the Constitution, the core amendment, as it's often called, though it was actually written by William Seward, which is kind of intriguing. And this amendment would have guaranteed in perpetuity slavery in those slave states, and guaranteed that Congress could not alter the institution that only those states could get rid of slavery. That was the compromise Lincoln was offering. He was offering the southern states everything they claim they wanted, except for the expansion of slavery into new territories. He would not go there. So, not that anti-slavery. He's not an abolitionist without a doubt. But here's the part that is the heart of my book, Inventing Equality, is that white Americans discovered, learned, invented the legal concept of equality because of the experiences of the Civil War, including Lincoln's, and to focus on Lincoln for a moment. What became clear to him as the war progressed was that one, they could not turn back. This amount of bloodshed had to be for a reason that would win God's approval. It had to be for a reason that the American people would be not only satisfied, but proud that they had sacrificed so much for something solid and good, and that would be human freedom. That was one of the impetus for his shift in attitudes. The second, I believe, is that one that first interested me when I was an undergraduate, 270,000 black troops, and not just simply the troops who enlisted, but all the black people who supported the cause of the union, while so many white southerners did not. This shift in Lincoln's attitude was an enormous significance because he, by the war's end, by the last months of his life, as he made clear in public speeches, though he was still willing to accept some qualifications on black rights, he felt it was important to acknowledge their human equality. I think he spoke for the whole country. According to some more presentess issues and practical questions, one of the things that's pretty interesting right now that it's kind of many historians of the Revolutionary, Colonial, Jacksonian, and Civil War era, many of us have stumbled into relevancy, myself included in yourself, thanks to the ever going on debate of the 1619 project, and how this dialogue never seems to end when an opinion column comes out, and just how big the divisions are getting. One of the things that's interesting to me about your book is you seem to have two lines that would upset everybody. To say American history, quote, "American history can be seen as a battle to reconcile the large gap between our stated ideals and the reality of our republic. It is a struggle that cannot honestly be cast as one of steady progress towards greater and greater freedom and equality, every step appears to be matched by a step back." But, Niva can dismiss this history as a series of sad footnotes in a losing battle against intolerance. So, to me, right there, Michael, you seem to be annoying both sides of this debate. So, if you want to expand on that, I would love to hear your thoughts. Thank you. Yeah, over and over again, history matters, and there was no doubt in my mind. Again, I'm old enough, I've seen these history battles, history wars. repeatedly in my lifetime. And I know for a fact that it is a tradition in America, if you go back again to the Jacksonian period, how do you deal with the contradictions? Well, you either lie about history or you don't talk about the embarrassing parts. After the Civil War when Reconstruction is defeated, how do you address the fact that all those black soldiers fought for the Union and proved their equality? Well, you don't talk about it. You just deny it. And how do we address ourselves as a nation that claims to believe in freedom and equality and democracy? You do the same thing. You lie or you ignore. One of those or the other and you can then feel comfortable with our nation's past. But it just isn't the truth. And I do believe in truth with a capital T. This is again, being raised Catholic, I believe in truth. And the truth of America is that it's in my opinion, is it's a constant battle to reach our goal, our stated goal of establishing freedom, democracy, and equality. And you cannot have democracy without equality. That's just impossible. You can't say that we're a democracy if some people can vote, some adult citizens can vote, and some adult citizens can't. And I think it's vital that we acknowledge that it's a battle. There are those who do not, no matter what they might say to the contrary, who do not want this to be a democracy, who do not want people to be equal to one another. And it's a battle that we have fought and we have to continue to fight. But we have to acknowledge that it's not one that we have won yet. In terms of writing a book that has such a large, big question with a large time period in scope, I was curious as a writer, as a historian, as a researcher, you mentioned off-air that quite a bit of this book was edited out. I'm curious from a craftsman standpoint, how do you go about organizing and researching and putting together a book with this bigger scope? But that is designed for a more lay audience. Seems like a bit of a herculean task. - Well, yes. And I have to admit, it's not when I came too easily. And I happen to have an extremely good agent and reader in Dan Green who constantly forces me to abandon or to ameliorate my didactic qualities, which I think all historians have. But I believe that the true joy of history is research. That that is what those of us, and I'm willing to bet you feel the same way, those of us who write history, what we really love is during the research. We love getting back into another time period and really trying to feel it and understand the people and not see them as all one thing or another, but seeing them as complicated, just like us. And none of that research has wasted ever. So yes, I admit that this book was originally if it had been published as I originally wrote it, it was 450 pages and no one would have read it. It would have sat on a shelf. But it's important to gather all this research together and then to, if I may, suggest, step back and think about who you want to talk to. And for me, it's always been essentially my family. You know, we're working class background. We're lucky to have gone to some outstanding public schools except for in terms of history and the teaching of history. And we love to read all of us. But I'm the only one who got an advanced degree and that's cool. And I'm talking to them. I'm writing to them. I want my brothers and sisters and cousins of which I have far too many sometimes to understand why this is so important to me. And I hope that they feel when they're done reading these books that I write, that is important to them as well. - Now, hopefully the pandemic is subsiding and things are getting back to normal. But while we're still being cautious and old jazz, one of the things I noticed during COVID is a lot of people are getting into cocktail making while bars were closed. So for listeners who may not recall or don't know, you are actually quite the barman in your day. So I'm curious, what have you been drinking in quarantine? - You are so kind. Yes, I'm actually also retired bartender. Decades of attending bar, I love being a bartender. It's a great job. I recommend it to everyone. But to answer your question, I do spend a lot of time with those. We have our little pod of friends that come over and I love inventing drinks within my current favorite that everyone seems to want too many of because it's low alcohol, so it's good. It's called, I call it a gothic queen. I named it after my wife, who is my gothic queen. And it is casice noir, which is a beautiful Italian, excuse me, I'm beautiful, French Le Cure, and pomegranate juice. And I use a teaky bitters and lime and top it off with champagne, sparkling wine. And again, it's low alcohol and it's absolutely lovely and it makes quarantine seem okay. So I am drinking my ever-ready Nagroni. But I'm drinking it. Yeah, I have been such converted to the Nagroni faith. It's probably not good. I'm drinking the MW Brown version, which uses one ounce, monkey 47 gin, free quarters compari, one ounce sweet vermouth. And rather than an orange peel, it uses an orange slice. And it will knock your socks off, but in a good, relaxing way, it's fantastic. - It's an excellent choice. Absolutely, especially if you're using some really good sweet vermouth at Carpano and Tika. What I love about Nagroni is that it's essentially three ingredients and you can play with them. Take out the gin and use bourbon. And as you know, you have a boulevardier. And, but there's so many other things. Try different liqueurs. Try apparel sometime instead of compari. And it's just, it's stunning. It's much, it's lighter. It's beautiful on a summer day. Anyway, I could go on and on. - Well, what I, I'll move on, but what I love about it is that it's the right balance of easy and impressive for friends. Because it looks like you're, it looks like you're doing a lot, but really you're not. But it's not so simple like a gin and tonic where it's like, oh, I could do that. Like, Nagroni, it makes it look like you're really talented when really you're just like adding, you know, in the most basic form, one ounce of everything and an orange peel of slice and an ice cube boom. Like, oh, yeah, this guy knows what he's doing. - However, however, you have already identified the true artists skill, which is to emphasize the gin by adding a little bit more of that. And that's what gives the Nagroni its special quality in my opinion is the, the slant you bring to it when you make it. - And I, I know you're enjoying retirement, but are you working on another book that you could tease my, or another project? You could tease my listeners with? - Of course, I am. (laughs) Thank you for asking. - Yes, I'm doing a book called Centennial Journeys, which is about, it's Journeys of Discovery in America at the intervals of our Centennials, 50 years Centennials. I reread when I was working on a Ventini quality. I happened to reread CREF course, a wonderful book. And his observation on America, 'cause this is a country that changes so fast, we can't really speak about its character unless we come back 50 years from now. So that's essentially what I'm doing. - Oh, that's very appropriate. And I'm sure your agent is putting, you know, putting pedal to the metal to make sure that book is out for the next Centennial, I'm sure. - Absolutely. And I hope you're, you know, from your lips to God's ear. - Yes. You have been listening to the Age of Jackson podcast. I have been your host. Thank you, a lot of PhD candidates, ABD in American religious history. And we've been talking about the-- The book "Inventing Equality Reconstructively Constitution" and the aftermath of the Civil War published with McMillan, available in hardcover, in digital form, and as an audiobook. Michael, thank you so much for coming back. Thank you Daniel. It's been such a delight speaking with you.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Michael Burleels argues that Americans "invented" the legal concept of equality after the Civil War, as the Constitution originally did not recognize or protect human equality for all citizens.
  2. The framers of the U.S. Constitution, including Jefferson, expressed contradictions: while declaring equality in the Declaration of Independence, they simultaneously upheld slavery and racial hierarchy in private writings and political practice.
  3. Key compromises at the Constitutional Convention, such as the "three-fifths" clause and the fugitive slave clause, reveal a deliberate exclusion of Black people from full legal personhood and equality.
  4. Throughout the Jacksonian era, Southern states restricted free speech, education, and political rights for Black people and even white populations, demonstrating a growing system of inequality despite expanding white male suffrage.
  5. Frederick Douglass and Abraham Lincoln evolved in their views of the Constitution: Douglass shifted from seeing it as a tool of slavery to a document that could be reformed to promote equality; Lincoln, though initially a white supremacist, came to believe in human equality as a moral necessity during the Civil War.
  6. The book highlights how American history is not a steady progression toward freedom but a continuous struggle between stated ideals and entrenched oppression.
  7. The failure to acknowledge Black soldiers’ contributions or the reality of racial inequality post-Civil War reflects a national tendency to suppress uncomfortable truths.
  8. Burleels emphasizes that the Reconstruction amendments (13th, 14th, 15th) were revolutionary in legally establishing equality, marking a pivotal but hard-won step toward a more just constitutional framework.

Summary:

In his new book *Inventing Equality: Reconstructing the Constitution in the Aftermath of the Civil War*, Michael Burleels argues that the United States did not naturally embrace equality under the law, but instead "invented" it through the transformative events of the Civil War and Reconstruction. He traces the contradiction between the Constitution’s foundational ideals—like human equality and liberty—and its practical enforcement, which excluded Black people and marginalized other groups from citizenship and rights. Early American writings, including those of Thomas Jefferson and James Madison, reveal deep ambivalence and even hostility toward equality, particularly regarding race.

The Constitutional Convention's compromises—such as the three-fifths clause and the fugitive slave clause—systematically embedded racial hierarchies into the nation’s legal structure. Throughout the Jacksonian era, Southern states intensified restrictions on free Black people and limited political rights, even as white male suffrage expanded. Key figures like Frederick Douglass and Abraham Lincoln evolved in their views, with Douglass ultimately embracing the Constitution as a tool for reform and Lincoln recognizing the moral necessity of human equality during the war.

Burleels contends that the Civil War era marked a critical turning point when the nation legally redefined equality through the 13th, 14th, and 15th Amendments. However, he warns that American history is not a simple story of progress, but a persistent struggle between ideals and reality, where uncomfortable truths have often been suppressed. The book calls for a truthful reckoning with this ongoing battle for equality, emphasizing that the full realization of democracy depends on continuous vigilance and reform.

FAQs

Michael argues that Americans did not naturally accept equality under the Constitution until the Civil War era. They had to 'invent' the legal concept of equality as a response to the contradictions of slavery and the Constitution, establishing a new framework where all adult citizens were seen as having equal rights before the law.

His high school civics teacher defended segregation, leading him to question whether Black people could be considered Southerners. This moment, along with learning about Black soldiers in the Civil War in college, sparked his lifelong dedication to exploring human equality in American history.

The Constitution’s founding language of equality was vague and exclusionary. It did not define citizenship, left slavery intact, and included the controversial 'three-fifths' compromise, showing that equality was not a foundational principle but a concept that had to be debated and developed over time.

Despite the Constitution's language of equality, Southern states enacted laws like the Negro Siemens Act that restricted free Black people’s rights. These laws were later ruled unconstitutional by the Supreme Court, but were ignored, showing a legal system that often contradicted the principles of equality in practice.

Douglass initially saw the Constitution as a tool that protected slavery. Over time, he came to believe it promoted freedom and could be used as a vehicle to abolish slavery, especially through constitutional amendments and by advocating for the equal rights of all people, including women and Black Americans.

Lincoln was initially a white supremacist and supported the continuation of slavery in the South. However, as the Civil War progressed, he came to believe that the nation's survival required recognizing the human equality of Black Americans, especially in light of their service in the Union Army.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.