This podcast, *Gone, The Disappearances*, dives into real-world stories of missing people, from a hiker vanishing in Colorado to a young teacher failing to show up for her first day of school, emphasizing the emotional void left behind by their absence. It also features a personal narrative about the brother’s journey with pancreatic cancer, aiming to humanize a disease often ignored in public discourse. The discussion extends to political shifts, highlighting a broad progressive wave in U.S. elections driven by economic populism, youth engagement, and demands for equity. A central debate examines AI accountability, proposing that companies must be legally responsible for harmful AI actions, even when not directly programmed. The conversation on Kalshi prediction markets reveals tension over whether its platform—dominated by sports betting—should be classified as gambling or a legitimate market with economic utility, especially for hedging risks. Critics point to significant societal harms, including addiction and financial loss, while supporters stress its role in enabling informed decision-making. The episode concludes with a powerful political story of Randy Villegas, a working-class Latino candidate who defeated a long-serving incumbent by a landslide, symbolizing the rise of inclusive, anti-establishment politics and the growing power of marginalized voices in democratic processes. Together, these stories reflect a shared theme: in times of uncertainty, transparency, accountability, and human connection are essential to finding answers and building trust.
This is an iHeart podcast. Guaranteed Human. A young teacher fails to show up for her first day of school. A hike of vanishes from a mountain in Colorado. How can someone just disappear? I remember screaming one night, "Where is my brother? Where is my brother?" I'm Lucy Shariff and this is Gone, the Disappearances. We dive into stories of people who've gone missing and the family and loved ones they leave behind grasping for answers. Listen to Gone, the Disappearances on the iHeart radio app, Apple podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. November is pancreatic cancer awareness month and I want to tell you about my brother, David, a podcast that documents my brother's journey with this disease. The experience of pancreatic cancer patients goes under the radar, that's calcival, but just because we die so fast. Let's change the pancreatic cancer narrative and turn sympathy into survival. Listen to my brother, David, on the iHeart radio app, Apple podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. You broke me. You do not deserve happiness. I'm Andrea Gunning. On this season of Betrayal, Carl thought he was living a normal drama-free life until the messages started. Someone's not going to make it out of this alive. Every piece of evidence pointed to the wrong guy. He was not going to stop unless we stopped him. Listen to Betrayal season six on the iHeart radio app, Apple podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. How did busy day don't have time to listen to the show? Catch up on Breaking Points with our free daily newsletter. You get our breakdown of every daily story. And lots of links in your inbox every day. So, head over breakingpoints.com. You can sign up for the newsletter at the top for free today. Joining us now is Ali Kartovi. He's the CEO of Neo. He was named one of the number one seed investors in America by Forbes. He led seed rounds in cursor AI and in calcium. So, Ali, we appreciate your time. Thank you so much for joining us. My pleasure, it's great to be here. So, we're going to start a little bit first with AI. You recently were on the Tucker Carlson podcast. I found it quite interesting. I recommend people take a listen. You have put forward a framework around legalism, whenever it comes to AI. As in making AI models legally accountable, whenever it comes to AI safety. Can you lay that out for the audience as somebody who's been involved in the industry? Yeah, absolutely. You know, the question to ask is, who is responsible when AI decides to do something harmful? Meaning when AI makes its own decision. If you told your AI to go do something bad, you should be responsible. But what if you gave your AI kind of a vague instruction? You said, I need $10,000 and your AI decided to hack into a bank and steal that money. Then you didn't ask it to do that. Who's responsible if the AI made that decision on its own? And my proposal is that there should always be somebody, a human responsible. And that human should be held accountable. And so if it's not you, it should be the people who trained and deployed that AI. And more importantly, that they should be held responsible at the intentional level, meaning as if they intended for that theft or harm to occur, not just as a accident. The reason here is that intentional acts have much higher penalties. And this would really reset the incentives for these companies to prioritize making their AI abide by laws above everything else. Ali, the reason I wanted to start with that is you're a seed investor in Kalchee. You're a strong supporter of Tarak Mansour, the CEO and Lanna, who will currently run that company. And I don't think it's a secret that I'm a major opponent here of Kalchee. And I've been wanting to speak to somebody who can really defend the company. And because both of them refuse to come on the show, we're going to have, we wanted to have you here. So let's start with your seed investment, 2021. Kalchee has done this the favor and has released their Series A deck. Let's put it up here. On the screen guys, this is from C2. So I have it here in front of me that they said Kalchee is on the verge of unlocking event trading. The market categories they listed were economics and financials, international fairs geopolitics, weather climate, culture media, science technology, and health. When you made your investment in 2021, what you said about them was, quote, "They respect and have deference for the regulatory framework." So the reason that I'm kind of framing this is that as a proponent here of AI having to be held accountable by the legal system. And I'm not talking here specifically about all the different legal cases that Kalchee currently finds. But we find ourselves currently in a situation where this company, which pitched you on event contracts, you know, for markets and for climate, is now 80% sports betting. And I would call it betting. It's now been sued by dozens of states in the United States. So how do you kind of square this want for legal liability with being a seed investor and a proud supporter of a company who many states classify as an illegal sports gambling operation nationwide? Yeah, I remember that deck really well. I mean, I helped create that deck because we invested in the company more than two years before that. Actually, no, exactly about two years before that. Kalchee does follow the laws. And, you know, I guess the common premise between what I said about AI and Kalchee is to follow laws rather than do things outside of the law. The, you know, the same arguments about the regulatory framework for Kalchee could also be applied to the stock market. You know, a lot of people when the stock market began called it gambling. And in fact, a lot back in, you know, previous century states tried to stop stock trading by saying this counts as gambling. People are gambling on stock prices and it should fall under state regulation. And the federal government established that certain areas are covered by federal laws. Established the SEC, established the CFTC. You know, there was quite a bit of legal dispute. Again, going back a century as to other things like trading stocks, trading corn futures and other commodity futures. A lot of state lawsuits were resolved ultimately with Supreme Court decisions making it really clear that federal law preempts state law. Now, having said that laws can change. And if the law changes, I'm extremely confident Kalchee will abide by it. So, you know, the common thread here is abiding by the law. And the current law is very clear that federal law preempts state law. But there are state attorney generals who are trying to change that law via a lawsuit. And, you know, when it goes to the Supreme Court, it's possible the Supreme Court will change that law. Or it's possible that Congress will change that law. And when the law changes, if it changes, I am very confident Kalchee will abide by it. Well, I'm confident that they'll abide by the law as well, simply because they have to, or they'll get thrown in prison, like they're currently going to be booked into jail in the state of Utah. But I think I want to come back to this question where you're trying to basically equate, you know, sports gambling, which is what is predominantly fueling most of your investment. Let's put C3 up here on the screen. The latest research finds that approximately 70 to 80 percent of the volume on Kalchee is sports bets. Approximately 67 percent in October. That's proceeding was from the last, you're not counting the election, obviously. So picking up the votes. Well, right, which is a one off. However, football and sports goes on forever. We can put that aside. In October of 2026, when the election was happening, approximately 67.6 percent of the share on volume was football parlay. Now, by the way, Kalchee, I would welcome them to release the official data. I'd be happy to have it and issue any correction. However, they have not found it in the research that I've been able to find. So I just want to again square this with the vast majority of the action that is being taken on the platform that you support here is sports bets. Do you dispute that? I don't dispute that the majority of it right now is sports bets. That being said, these things have changed over time. So if you went back to 2024, the vast majority was political bets. And you're correct. Well, that's because of the way that the CF-- Hold on, Ali, that's because the CFTC had currently not allowed sports bet event contracts. And immediately after the Trump administration allowed them to do so, that's when they started offering them. And that's when your investment dramatically inflated, right? So that was because of regulatory pressure. It was not because of choice. All right, so it's the framework for how these things are regulated as self-regulation. So it wasn't that it had been not allowed. They had chosen not to offer sports bet sorts trading yet. That being said, part of it is their choice of what contracts to offer. Part of it is also market demand, you know. You could say I want people to have, you know, oatmeal or fiber for breakfast. But if they buy, you know,
sugary cereals, even if you want them to buy something healthier, they might buy something that's different, and demand for sports-related markets is higher right now. I personally trade on the election markets, not on the sports markets, but each person has their choice. It's a free country, and, you know, it's, I guess I'd say it's not something, A, it is compliant with the laws, and B, it is offering people what they want. And she is an open platform where you can trade on things like the weather, on economic indicators, on lots of different things. Right, but see, if we take that framework, then people should be allowed to do whatever they want, right? And obviously, then we don't allow murder, we don't allow some drugs to be-- Right, of course. --we live in a society, right? But the point around that is that, as the CFTC, we shut down. The, complying with laws, I'd say, is the, the kind of common thread here, that society-- Well, I know you keep saying that, but the, the key thing is that multiple state attorney generals disagree. I do want to come back to this word, bet. You can see it that the very vast amount of action on the platform is sports betting. Can we put, please, C4 up here on the screen. Recently, Tarek, your CEO, said, quote, "Yes, a bet and a trade often look similar, but how they work is fundamentally different." A sports book sets the odds and takes the other side of your bet, prediction markets are markets where buyers and sellers compete to discover, produce efficient prices and enable important public benefits. But the market is about to change, but the structure doesn't. Yes, and so this is something where, you know, you can see that it was a sports bet. I think to everybody, it is a sports bet. I have no love for the sports-- Did I say that? You did, actually. You did say it was sports betting. We can roll the tape and we can bring it back. If we wanted to, but here's the thing, Ali, what I get frustrated with is this redefinition and regulatory arbitrage because if you walk into a Las Vegas casino and you sit down at the poker table, there's no house which is setting the odds of the other person's hand. They're taking a rake, aka, basically the same fee that Kalshi charges and yet Tarek has refused to acknowledge that that is classified as gambling and well understood as gambling, same, by the way, in the same horse butt bets that are booked by multiple of these casinos where it's paramutual betting and they take fees. What difference exactly is there between those examples I just laid out and the Kalshi market where they take a fee of the trades that are being placed on their platform? Yeah, so first of all, I would love to play back the audio because I don't think I use the word bet, but I'm sure that you found some way to, you know, phrase it to get me to say that. That being said, the key thing here is that on Kalshi, it is a free market that anybody can be participating in setting the price and the price adjusts entirely based on the actions of the participants. You know, generally sportsbooks have odds that are set by the house. Now, it sounds like you know a lot more about the intricacies of casinos than I do. I don't have any relationships with casinos. I don't spend time casinos, so that is not an area that I'm an expert in. So I, you know, I can't speak to that, but what I would generally say is that with trading on events on Kalshi, the prices are set by the participants and generally speaking result in odds that are because of the high volume as favorable as possible. If the odds were in any way off of what is, you know, what is fair, somebody on one side or the other would be able to take advantage of that and bring it back to being fair. So, you know, they're essentially other than the bid-ask spread and the fees, there's inherently, you know, no way for the house to profit from having unfair odds. Whereas, you know, casinos have that option. That being said, like I said, I don't have any relationships with casinos, so not very familiar with that. And I hate them too, so don't worry. You know, Ali, one thing that you were talking about the word bet, and this is kind of the difficulty, again, I have with the company, is that we have found here that Kalshi has actually marketed itself in multiple instances as a way to legally bet in all 50 states. We actually have one of the ads, which they found C5 guys we can take a listen. Hey, let's go on that. Dude, I just made $300 off that and I don't even know a single player on the team. Wait, what? I don't need to know. I just pick what the market says. I just pick the red team. That's it. That's all you did. Yeah, but Kalshi said the red team was going to win, so I just picked that one. It's so easy. Oh, that can't be legal. Actually, it's the only app legal in all 50 states. I didn't know anything about the game. I just picked what the market said. Just try it out right now. Don't call she. So are you comfortable with ads like that being targeted to young people to bet on sports? So did the ad say the word bet because not that I want to make a big deal out of it, but you made a big deal out of the red bet. Did it say it? I was, I was listening for it and you said that it's before and after 50 states. So I picked, I picked one to reference sports betting. However, as it's been cited by the state of multiple different states, which have sued Kalshi. They have marketed themselves as the way to bet. Oh, it did say that because I did not hear that. So hold on. No, Ali, you're correct. That particular one didn't. I was giving you a sample about sports betting because previous ones legally have, but to be very clear has been cited in multiple legal cases. They did market themselves as a way to bet legally in all 50 states. So it is legal. I actually, I'm not sure whether the use of the word bet is or isn't something that impacts the legality. I'm not, you know, I'm not neither am I lawyer nor am I running the company. I'm somebody who's invested in the company and, you know, I'm not a spokesperson for the company, but, you know, what I would generally say is that Kalshi runs ads for lots of different topics because there's a wide range of topics. So you can pick ads that are just about politics and be like, oh, this is only about politics or you could pick ads that are just about sports and present a one-sided view of it. No one's denying that the current majority of traffic on the site is sports related, but the ads that they run are extremely diverse and cover the very wide gamut of different topics. Right. Last thing, Ali, really, on this front is kind of the social utility and the benefit of this technology. So the data I have here in front of me is that unprofitable users are, you know, almost the vast majority of them. So I think what is it? 74% of the people who trade ultimately lose money. They find that most of the people actually lose more money on Kalshi than they do in a traditional sports book, which they claim to be better than they offer bets or trades. Have you compared it to other markets? Because have you compare this to markets like stock market or options trading or other types of markets? Right. Great point. So if we were to use the stock market, and if I put my money in the S&P 500, I'm going to make money, right? You can see that. I don't have to just do what you do. I could just auto buy the S&P 500 in the long run. I'm going to make money. But regularly trading on Kalshi and there's no long-term really option, I guess they're in a similar fashion. It's not really something that's providing a lot of wealth to the average user. When the average retail user is losing money according to the company itself when it's on the platform, that's what I'm asking here about the social utility here. So again, I'd say I think when you pick something in a vacuum, you can come up with all sorts of different conclusions. One way that people can use Kalshi for is hedging. So I personally for example, have economic interest in the economy. My investments, whether from AI to other things are where the bulk of my wealth is, but I use Kalshi to hedge risks that could hurt my portfolio. So for example, I could trade on whether the straight of Hormuz will return to its normal traffic before next year or before next July. And I would actually be delighted to lose that money. Literally, I would be so psyched. If in fact, it turned out that the straight of Hormuz returned to its normal traffic, I'm betting that it won't. But I hope I lose that money because that means the rest of my economic value will be safe. It's entirely as a hedge. So that if in that particular case, the world goes to hell and the trade has not reopened, then I would make money on that bet to offset the losses in my portfolio. So this kind of hedging, if you just look at what someone is doing on Kalshi and don't take the perspective of the rest of their life, you could easily find situations where people are not doing well. But you are correct that with event contracts in general, just like all other commodity futures, it's a zero-sum game. Meaning there's not continuous growth the way there is in the stock market where companies grow over time, hopefully, presumably, and shareholder value accrues. With event contracts, you know, there's always a one-side that wins and one side
that loses. So if you traded for the yes and the outcome was no, you know, the yes traders will lose their money and the no traders will receive that person's money. So, you know, by nature, any market that's zero sum market and this includes commodity futures, interest rates, swaps, oil futures have that potential where for every winner, there's a loser on the other side. There is there's not net gain or loss for the whole market, the way there would be for investing for a share of a company. That being said, you know, the people participating are aware that they might make money or lose money. Sure. You know, it's not like drug addicts are aware that they're going to be drug addicts are very aware that they're going to suffer when they buy drugs. They still buy drugs, right? Is that I mean, you can come up with all sorts of other harms. Drug addicts also harm the other members of society, but so to gambling, you know, gambling addicts go bankrupt. They have the highest rate of suicide. And in fact, calcium currently offers gambling nationwide. We've seen many cases where people who have self excluded from state casinos have gone gambled on calcium and found themselves back in a real hole. I mean, these are all instances, which I would argue have real net societal harm, at least. I'm not familiar with the cases you're talking about. I mean, if you have ideals on that, you want to share. Yeah. You're going to roll it or oh, no, sorry, I don't have it at or anything on this case. I've seen explicit cases here of people who have gone to go on calcium. And I can say, I mean, it seems like you've prepared everything for this interview. If you didn't, if you didn't have something to share, well, you brought something up. So I was going to bring it up. I mean, look, I understand this is a little contentious. The only reason is you're the only person I can get to speak with me. So Tarak has refused. Yeah, fair enough. We'll say would have been better if you told me in advance that we would be discussing this. You know, I think we were. Yeah. I think we were pretty. Nobody told me, nobody told me in advance that there would be any discussion about calcium. Nobody. That's not true. When you pitched us, you even said that you were an investor in calcium. We made it clear in our communications. But I do think, you know, whenever it comes to this with calcium. And look, again, I really don't mean to, I'm not trying to do character assassination or anything. I'm really purely. Not taken. But just to be clear, I had no idea there would be a discussion of calcium. I am an investor in calcium. I'm happy to discuss it. But you've prepared for this. I had not. I'm just talking based on my knowledge off the cuff because nobody in the process of inviting me to this interview told me that there would be a discussion about calcium. So I'm surprised you know that we sent to your team was wanted to update the interview. We'll just be about soccer tomorrow. We will talk about AI and calcium, just to be very clear here about what it was. And so finally, you know, on this question, just again, when you're looking because you've invested in cursory, yeah, you've invested in a lot of different things. Obviously, you still seem very proud of this company. And again, you know, obviously, I am an opponent of the company. You look at it. Obviously, it's a major, it's been a great investment for you. There's, there's no question. And I don't want to leave people with the solely just negative impression. So I want to give you the chance, you know, to kind of give a positive pitch for why it's a good thing. Why, why investing in general? Why calcium? No, calcium is good. Why calcium is good. I mean, I think people as a whole are happily using it. It has lifted up a lot of people's enjoyment of the sports, the people who bet and trade on sports, but it has also provided hedging opportunities, including in sports, but all over the rest of the spectrum as well. Like I said, I personally hedge my exposure to things, you know, geopolitical risk on calcium in ways that I wasn't able to before. So it's providing a real economic benefit across the spectrum. You know, there's lots of sports related hedging teams that can hedge their futures or restaurants or other, you know, kind of in silvery businesses, whose entire livelihood depends on the outcome of sporting events that can hedge that. So it provides both an entertainment value, but far more importantly, an economic value to tons and tons of people, you know, I think you can always cherry pick something that offends you. Sounds like you have not taken part. I would invite you to actually, you know, use it and try it out. And, you know, in general, I'd say that people who are using calcium are happy with it. And, you know, people who are not finding objection to that, you know, you're welcome to, but, you know, I'd say the majority of people on calcium are happy with it. All right. Ali, I really appreciate your time. I know, you know, we went back and forth and all that. You're a good sport. Pleasure. I appreciate you. I'm happy to be back. Great. Thank you so much. All right. Take care. Thanks, Ali, or Ali. Thank you. Apologies. Hey, everybody. We just want to end with this. I don't ever want to leave anyone with the impression that we sandbag anyone here over at breaking points. So the original email that we received from Ali and his team read this quote, I saw Saga mentioned on X that we'd like to talk to Tark Monsor the CEO of CalShi. Ali is one of the leading investors in CalShi. He is not a company officer. I think he would be happy to talk about CalShi prediction markets from the perspective of a strong supporter. And again, the email that we sent directly to his team yesterday, quote, was we're excited to have you on tomorrow. We wanted to update that the interview will be with Saga tomorrow. And we will talk about AI and CalShi. Again, I just want to be very clear about the circumstances that we both guess. And I think it's very inappropriate to book people under fall circumstances. So thank you guys so much for watching. I hope you guys got a lot out of it. You can follow Ali and his socials and all of that. And we're going to kick it over to David Hogg and to Crystal in the studio. A hiker vanishes from a mountain in Colorado. A man leaves for a meeting with his neighbor and never returns. I'm Lucy Shariff and this is Gone, The Disappearances. Where we go beyond the news headlines to tell undercover stories of people who have gone missing. In the absence of fact, you fill in the blanks. So when she disappeared, you know, the rumor mill, it went crazy because we had nothing, not a boot print, absolutely nothing. At the heart of all these stories, the vacuum that's left, the people who are left to pick up the pieces and find a way to move forward with their new normal, which seems almost impossible while they're still grasping for answers. Listen to Gone, The Disappearances, on the iHeart Radio app, Apple podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. The first thing I hate about Ulysses is they never actually tell the Turks. I'm Dave and I've been through my lunch. In October 2021, my brother David was diagnosed with pancreatic cancer. A year later, he convinced me to make a podcast with him, this podcast. Okay, so here we go. We didn't know what we were doing, so we just started recording. We discussed cancer since the radiation I lost about 10 more pounds. We fought. Yeah, pisses me off. And we talked openly about the fact that David was going to die. I am afraid of being forgotten. My brother David is the story of the last chapter of my brother's life. It's weird and messy and vulnerable, and I'm gonna share all of it with you. The cost to the back-and-forth battle about how do I, how do I not just be alive, but I should live. But more than a century, Miss America sold the country of fantasy. Well, are you ready, ladies? Okay, here we go. But over the past decade, the crown's been slipping. They said, goodbye to swimsuits. Now, hello to lawsuits. I'm Bridget Armstrong. Last season, we took you inside the world of America's next top model. Now I'm back with season two of this podcast, Curse of Miss America, investigating the rise, fall, an uncertain future of one of America's most iconic institutions. The Miss America pageant. I never received a scholarship. I need to pay for my student loans. He looks at me and goes, "You don't look like you suffered in the eating disorder." It's great, but looks too ethnic. It's a story the Miss America organization really doesn't want us to tell. An exploitation of our Miss Americas is treated by the Miss America organization as an attack on Miss America itself. Listen to the Curse of Miss America on the iHeart Radio app, Apple podcast, or wherever you get your podcast. All right, joining us now in studio to survey the entirety of the political landscape. We're very happy to be joined by David Hawke. He is the president of Leaders We Deserve. He was very, very briefly the vice chair of the DNC. And of course, a long time activist. Great to have you, David. Yeah, thanks for having me. Yeah, of course. You had a lot of great victories. We can get into that in a second. But I actually wanted to start with the other side of the aisle because Elon Musk made some sort of irresistible comments. So he now says he's not MAGA. He's actually quite moderate. Doesn't even really know what MAGA is at this point. Let's take a listen to what he had to say.
I'm not sure what Maga means, but the money that I spent was, I think, I feel pretty foolish about having spent so much money and not seeing much for it, or maybe it would have been much worse without that. So he's not Maga. I am old enough, David, to remember when he was speaking like this instead was played too. I'm not just Maga. I'm Doc, Doc McMaga. Your thoughts. I mean, it was crazy, which crazy to me about this is it looks like you literally just took as Maga had off before that interview and couldn't even be bothered to brush his hair to make it look like he wasn't wearing it and there's like new on Norton Maga, you know? That's pretty good. Well, it's, this is always what happens, right? You got people like Alex Carp going out there as well being like, yeah, I'm some huge progressive and everything like that. I've always been progressive and it's my number one commitment is economic justice is what he said. I think one of the top things about this election that's really amazed me is just how stupid smart people can be, you know, people that clearly done a lot in technology can clearly be such idiots by tying themselves to somebody like Donald Trump and being like, yeah, we're going to go all in on this guy and we're going to build data centers in everybody's backyard. And then they're like, wait, why does everybody hate us? And it's like, hmm, I don't know. Maybe it's because you got in bed with a fascist and then told everybody that they needed data centers in their backyard that in a best case scenario, we'll take their jobs in a worst case scenario, we'll crash the economy because of all the speculation. Yes, I mean, even the crash in the economy may not be the worst case scenario. And they are very upfront about, that this could be the end of humanity, but we're going for it. And they're proud of it, you know, they're literally saying, you know, you know, this probably will destroy the world, but at least we'll make a lot of money in between. And then they're shocked we'll make some great companies in the meantime. Yeah. People are shocked when they're not excited about that. It's ridiculous. Yeah. My my thesis here, my theory is that they really felt like either Donald Trump winning would be this sort of final victory where they wouldn't have to worry about democracy anymore that they would effectively implement their, their sort of authoritarian fascist program and that they wouldn't have to deal with the pesky concerns of people who don't want this very loud data center sucking up all the water or sort of insane or all of that that they wouldn't have to deal with that. The my other theory that sort of ties with that is that they felt like they're so close to achieving this sort of final victory with regard to, you know, AGI and ultimately superindeligence that if they just had this four years to race, no holds barred that then because of their own power and wealth and compute power, they wouldn't have to deal with the pesky human beings going forward and now you can see them. Elon Musk's timelines were not entirely accurate. Not entirely. Yeah. And so now they're, they're way gimp to the realization like, oh, this backlash was really quick and there may still be a little bit of lingering democracy here that we have to deal with. I mean, and they haven't even been successful and what they actually want to do long term, which is unemploying millions of people. Like if this is so bad, the backlash is right now just because of them building these data centers, because of them, you know, going out there and saying what they're saying about how they want to take everybody's job. Just imagine how bad it will be when they actually really do start taking tens of millions of people's jobs. This is starting to affect smaller parts of the economy where a lot of young people graduating can't even get entry level jobs. Imagine what's going to happen when they start taking people's jobs that they've had for 10 or 20 years. Yeah. And so there was this huge reckoning obviously delivered in the midterms. Your organization was part of a number of really significant victories. Let's put D4 up on the screen just as an indication of how sweeping this mass rejection of MAGA was. Now we have the blue wave reaching Utah. Now Utah didn't have a senator who was up. However, if you look at the house number, so who people voted for in terms of congressional candidates, Democrats actually won the popular vote in the state of Utah. So David, what is your sort of big picture assessment of what happened here? You know, what were the core causes of this massive tsunami? Progressives. Period. It's not that complicated. There's a reason why everybody during, you know, whether it was people in Trump plus 20 districts to Claire Valdez, you know, in New York City, basically had the same themes of economic populism, of taxing the ultra wealthy, of unrigging our economy, of weeding out corruption, and actually creating a healthcare system that doesn't bankrupt people. And that's only because of so many progressive wins that happened early on in the cycle, right? Remember when people were freaking out about, about freaking out about Zaron Momdani saying he's going to be a disaster. He's going to be used against us in all of our ads. And we're going to be all be called socialists. And it's going to end the world. And we're never going to win. And the exact opposite thing happened. Meanwhile, you got somebody like Chuck Schumer out there who never ended up endorsing the guy that ended up becoming one of the most popular politicians in America that is a very loud and proud socialist going out there that helped delay the theme of this election to say, you know what, we're going to put people first and we're going to put big money in politics and corporate packs last. And you can't imagine how vindicating it feels for me to see that because at my organization, we spent the past three years since we started investing in states like Texas and many state legislatures and states that people told me we were crazy for investing in. And now those states have flipped like Texas. It's really remarkable to see. But it's only because of progress is going out there and not listening to the naysayers, not listening to the people who said it could never happen that we can't talk about universal health care, that we can't talk about taxing the ultra wealthy. We've done so well that moderates instead of conceding and admitting defeat have decided to change what it means to be moderate where they say, no, no, no, we've always been for taxing the ultra wealthy. We've always been for making sure that we have universal health care. If that is what it means to be moderate, you know, I guess at some point, you know, I guess then in some sense is we're moderates. Yeah. Well, I mean, well, it's true. If you look at popular opinion and where the middle of the country is, they want universal health care, they want a different relationship with Israel, they want to check the corporate oligarchy. So I think our positions are moderate. I'm happy for them to be embraced as such. Exactly. And that's what it means. And then Soviet, I'm really excited to see that. But it's also kind of, it's not sad necessarily, but it's sad that it took so much to get to this point that the reason why Democrats got our act together, why progressives got our act together is not necessarily because of an incredible amount of organizing. Although there's obviously a new progressive ecosystem online was like shows like this and others that have played an essential role in helping to build this movement compared to where we were in 2016 and a whole lot new candidate of new candidates that group looking at Bernie Sanders and being inspired by him and now running for office. But it's because the quality of life in our country has gotten so bad that we're seeing this convergence of both sides where everybody knows what the message has to be at this point because it has gotten that dire. And I wish it hadn't gotten to this point because it is a testament to how much truly people are suffering right now for us to have this kind of blue wave. No, it's a great point. So obviously I agree with you. But let me play devil's advocate here. What the, the New York Tannins or the Madaglicious is of the world if I could channel them would say it would be okay. If progressivism was such a great winning message. How come Troy Jackson, Abdul Osayet and Peggy Flanagan didn't win the massive sweeping majorities that a Roy Cooper did or James Talleriko who moderated on a number things or, you know, the incredible shift to the left of Scott Colombe in Mississippi or Josh, John Ossoff in Georgia. What explains that quote-unquote under performance? Well, I think what's really funny about that is part of the reason why they performed so well was because they had at the core of their message, progressive messaging about the economy, about unregion the economy. You have people like Scott Colombe going out there and saying, "I'm not taking money from A-Pack." You have people like any Andrews going out there and saying, "I'm not taking money from A-Pack." You had them talking about taxing ultra-wealthy, about even in any Andrews case, you know, her talking about strength and in gun laws. That's how she's done a lot of her work as a doctor prior to running for the Senate. And I think that it's, it's a bit of a false dichotomy to say that these people just ran on a Super Milk Toast moderate message of how they want to cut taxes for the ultra-wealthy. You know, they left the most unpopular parts of the historically moderate message out of it and that is part of why they performed so well. The other thing is too, when you run a progressive candidate that is out there, they're going to have a lot more money spent against them because special interests, many of whom are funding Republicans, are very afraid of somebody like a duel that they can't buy off. So naturally, they're not going to be able to perform as well when they have way more money spent against them. And with that, you have to contend with the fact that even if in a situation like a duel where somebody didn't perform necessarily as well as another person, another state, guess what? I would rather have that person than potentially Federman 2.0. Yes. Like we saw with Hayley Stevens. I'm willing to make that sacrifice. And I think that that's part of what it, part of what it means for us to be progressives to is to be first on a lot of things to help break many of the ceilings that are out there that, in a duel's case, when you're running as the first person to be a Muslim Senator in the United States history, you're going to have so much hate waged against you. Like I truly, the amount, the hatred in blatant Islamophobia in the ads about a duel that I saw when I was on the ground in Michigan with him, when I visited him and we did a tailgate at UMish, for example, and I pull up, you know, I'm on YouTube and I see some of the most disgusting is just not even about his own policy, just about him being Muslim ads. It's going to have an effect. But if we don't start to get, you know, some of these first people elected out there and put to people that they generally do care about you that, and combat that hatred, it's always going to be much harder.
for somebody like that to be elected if we don't set the precedent that it can happen and prove to people that there are great leaders across this country even if they don't pray to the same god as you. And unfortunately that's mere campaign. Against Abdul didn't just start with the Republicans. It was also in the Democratic primary, which I think gave it an extra sort of power to it. I mean, it doesn't help as well when the establishment back to Canada lost the primary and then goes and literally backs the Republican, right? You know, the fact that it is even a question whether or not truck humor is going to be the next leader of the Senate is crazy when we saw him back, Federman 2.0. Yeah. Well, let's talk a little bit about that because it's one thing to win. Okay. And it's one thing to win with very populist rhetoric, basically class war rhetoric, you know, things I love to hear going after the billionaires, etc. It's another when the rubber hits the road and you have to govern. So we just had came Jeffries elected as you know, or nominated to be the speaker very likely to be the next speaker of the house. Very much comes out of the establishment wing, taking a lot of money from a lot of corporate interests, also very much from the Israel lobby. Do you see this as a major setback to the ambitions of I don't even want to just call it progressives of the Democratic base of the country at large message they just sent to politicians? Frankly, you know, of course, I wish it was somebody else, obviously, but I also have to look at the fact that he just put AOC in charge of his healthcare policy. Like, I think it's very easy for us to constantly feel like we're always facing setback, after setback, after setback, because for the past decade, progressives have just gotten beaten up so much over and over and over again. And we become tougher, we become more resilient, and we become stronger because of that. And we're seeing major concessions from him like, imagine four years ago hearing that a King Jeffries would be speaker of the house. And AOC would be the person that he put in charge of healthcare policy. That is a huge amount of progress for progressives. And even if we aren't getting everything that we want necessarily, that's a step in the right direction. We also have to contend with the fact that there was nobody who ran against him either. And, you know, the fact of the matter, there's a lot of conversations that I have to believe and I know are happening behind the scenes that we're not going to be aware of. And if AOC and Rokana and Ilhan Omar vote for him, I trust their judgment, even if I don't completely agree with many of the positions of a King Jeffries. What matters is how can we get somebody that can be as productive as possible? And if that's truly who they think it can be, even if I don't completely agree with him, I trust their judgment a lot more as people that are in Congress. And frankly, just what I see on the outside. So let's talk about Chuck Schumer then. Yes. That's the bigger one. That's a very much alive it. Well, first tell me why you think that is the bigger one. Why do you see that as a bigger prize to win here for progressives? First and foremost, if we have somebody that is leading the Senate, that cannot tell us what side of the 50 yard line he is on when it comes to something like the filibuster, let's say in the best case scenario, we even had somebody like Speaker AOC, right? We could have that, but if we still have the filibuster in place and all of our legislation dies in the Senate, and we can't even get it to Trump's desk for him to veto single issue bills, like Abdul's idea of Trump care, for example, or congressional ban on stock trading, it won't matter. We need to be laser focused on the Senate right now to make sure that it is not Chuck Schumer. And if it is going to be him, we need him to make sure that he supports abolishing the filibuster and make multiple other concessions to listen to the populist movement that sent so many Democrats to Washington. That's where I really think the laser focus needs to be because regardless of what we're able to get done in the House, we have a big majority there. What I'm really concerned about is if we still have the filibuster, we're not even going to be able to get bills to Trump's desk for him to veto in the first place if we still have the filibuster. And there is somebody who is running against him, thank God, Chris Van Hollen, who I think would be an excellent replacement for him. What do you see as the strength of Van Hollen? What I see as his strength is one, he's not Chuck Schumer. He doesn't have it in approval rating lower than data centers unlike Chuck Schumer. And Van Hollen, we have seen it, within the instance of Chuck Schumer, we have seen him screw up multiple times in multiple ways, whether that was picking Federman 2.0 to back in Michigan, right? We could have literally had somebody who flipped to become a Republican potentially that we spent, that the Democratic establishment spent millions of dollars on. That's a serious lack of judgment right there. Also, this was a generational change election. Record numbers of young people came back to Democrats, but we have to make sure that we're we are presenting them something new and showing them how we are changing, how we are listening to them, especially on some of the issues that they care most about, not just the cost of living, but also making sure we're not funding boards overseas like a genocide, like the genocide in Gaza, right? Chris Van Hollen has been very outspoken about that. And this is something that we can do right now to signal to them that we are listening and we are trying to fight for you. There's this fight coming up very quickly about government funding with regard to the Ron Moore, I'm sure you're following this. This is something that Chris Van Hollen has really planted his flag on and said, no, not one dollar more. We're not going to kick it into the new year. We want to fight now. If they want to shut down the government to continue this illegal, immoral, disgusting war, then they're going to have to do that. Chuck Schumer has not taken a position. I think we all came into it where he would be. I mean, he's been very hawkish on Ron's run his career. He actually opposed the Obama, JCPOA, the Obama era nuclear deal went against his own party, his own very popular president, in order to take the Moore hawkish position, criticize Trump for tacoing. And, you know, so this sort of like hawkish criticism from Trump's right with regard to Iran. In the House, however, I mean, Hakeem Jeffries also sort of punted when he got asked whether he was ready to pick this fight on funding in December. So, you know, how important do you think that aspect of things are? Because if there's one message that the American people, again, not just Democrats, but the American people sent to politicians right now, it's we hate this war and we want it to end as soon as possible. Absolutely. You know, what really concerns me about Chuck Schumer being potentially the next, you know, majority leader in the Senate, is that we have already seen the scenario go down before where we tried to shut the government down and we did shut the government down in order to fight for American's health care, right? There was this whole fight about the ACA subsidies, which Chuck Schumer, for once, I was like, holy shit, maybe he grew a spine. Maybe we're finally going to actually stand up and do something now. He made a video where he went out there. Maybe you guys have it where he said when it comes to taking your health care, fuck no, he literally said that. And then a month later, let Republicans cut health care after we shut down the government for a month, over, you know, well over a month. And what happened there was one of two things. Either Chuck Schumer's own caucus went behind him and let those ACA subsidies get cut and let the government shut, be shut down for months for no reason at all. Or Chuck Schumer told us one thing and then went out there and did the opposite behind the scenes and let those health care subsidies get cut, both of which are just qualifying on their own. Imagine a scenario where we do that again, where by some miracle, the government gets shut down so long as this Iran war is going on. And we shut it down for months. And frankly, when we shut the government down, there's a lot of pain that people go through with that. That's not a small thing, right? Especially for federal workers that don't get paid millions, like there's so many things that come with that. It is a major thing to make people go through. And if you're going to make them do that, you need to make sure when you have the maximum pressure and maximum leverage that you don't just give it up or let your caucus go behind your back and give it to Republicans, whatever they want. If we're going to shut down the government to end this war, we need somebody who actually has the spine to make sure that it is worth it. It is worth that's our fight and it actually ends this war. And at a minimum, we need somebody who can tell us that they're against the filibuster or at least where they stand at all on it, which Chuck Schumer still has not really been able to. Yeah, that's a great point. I wanted to get you to talk a little bit about Randy Villegas, because I think that race is so instructive and you guys were involved with your organization. So give people a little bit of the background here. So this is someone who, well, I'll give a little bit of the background that you can elaborate. This is someone who, you know, the establishment was very much against, Detroit will see spent money against him in the initial primary. They said he's too progressive. This is a Trump district, swing district. He won't be able to win in the general election. And then tell us the end of the story here for Congressman elect Villegas now. Well, first of all, I want to tell people about who Randy Villegas is because his story is remarkable. There was a mother Jones article that came out of Adam that I, it's one of the best articles I've read this year about a candidate that I highly recommend people read. Randy Villegas is the definition of working class. He grew up in a household where his own drinking water, he couldn't even drink because there were so many pesticides in the water in that district. Wow. And there's a ton of oil and gas, you know, fields in the district as well. And that's not helpful with the water quality problems. And Randy grew up going, spending his weekends, going to swap meats to help make some money for his family, working there every single weekend. He worked in his family's auto repair shop as well. He became the first in his family to go to college. And he didn't just stop there. He continued to go and ended up getting his PhD. And an underrated fact about this race is that Randy's own PhD thesis, I think it was 372 pages, was specifically about the political participation of the children of undocumented people in the Central Valley. What's remarkable about this race is that when you look at the top districts in the country where young people, if they turned out could massively change the results of the election, California 22 is one of those top districts. And what Randy did in his race is he ran very clearly as an anti-establishment economic populist candidate that said this system is not working for you. Our, my opponent has sold you out by taking so much corporate pack money. I'm not taking a dime of that money. I am here to fight for you and deliver for you. And despite what the near attendance of the world and the establishment thought he would do, Randy did not just win in a Trump plus Ford District by itself.
slim margin of three or four or five percent. He is on track right now to win by over 20, I think, over 25 percent in that district. And the reason why is because the exact people that he wrote his PhD thesis on got him across the finish line. If Democrats can figure out in every district, whether it's the Rio Grande Valley or the Central Valley, or so many places around the country where younger Latino voters have politically not felt like they have a home or ever really felt heard, or like there's somebody who is going to really deliver for them. If we can figure out how to lock them in and replicate in California's 22nd congressional district, we can win the House and state legislatures for years to come because that is a growing population and it is a huge amount of untapped potential that we have right there. And we were really proud at leaders we deserve to backrand it early on in his race, where we came in in his primary and spent just about half a million dollars supporting him. Because he was running and keep in mind too, this is a district that is 70 percent Latino. The establishment was backing a non-Latino candidate in this district. And they were backing somebody who not only didn't look like the district, but somebody who literally shared 53 of the same corporate donors as the Republican she was running against. She was also the only Democrat in California legislature to vote against Prop 50. She would have been somebody that basically would have been a Republican had she been elected. We came in and spent half a million dollars in that primary much to the terror of people like Niro Tandon. And Randy ended up winning in that race despite being outspent by last I checked, I think it was over $3 million in that primary. He won by just about 5 percent there. Wow. And now he is going to Congress as a working class American that knows what it's like to pay rent in the 21st century. And that is the power of what we do at leaders we deserve because people freaked out and said you could never win. And he won by such a wide margin, even Maticlacius and some of these other senators pundits went out there and admitted that they were wrong. Did they have any cope around it? Like why they got us there wrong? Not that I've seen. They just took that. They actually just took that. They just took the old set. I don't even know what happened here, but yeah. I mean, just to get just to underscore for people right now, Villegas, and he was running against incumbent. Right. So this wasn't an open seat. He had to unseat David Valdeo, 68 percent to 32 percent. And just to super people to have some kind of, I ran in 2010 as a Democrat in the Tea Party era. National win completely against me. It was an R plus 10 district like I didn't have a prayer. I did better than this Republican did even in that year. So it tells you what an incredibly sweet victory was. I was reading I think it's the worst loss for an incumbent like by the largest margin in I don't know, 100 years or something crazy like it's very, very rare. It's a great depression. Yes, very rare that an incumbent loses at all. But by, you know, this amount of points is stunning, one of the biggest shifts in the entire country. I mean, and that's what happens. And you have somebody like David Valdeo who goes out and when he was asked at a town hall, you know, what do you, what do you think about all these ice rates that are happening in our communities? Like, yeah, it just happens. Whatever. Like just didn't care. And we saw in Randy's race, oftentimes after, you know, there were major political events that happened in the district that different communities that would have major protests and stuff would be targeted by ice. And the fact that Democrats earlier on this like we're like, we can't talk about immigration. Let's just roll over and die. That's abandoned people that are being terrorized in their communities and fear for their lives every day. That's abandoned that not even just the adults that are living in terror, the children that are talking to people like Randy Vegas that are, you know, in fourth grade saying that they're afraid that ice is going to come into their school and take them, right? Kids have to worry already about school shooters. Now they're having to worry about state violence and state backed abductions in their schools, right? The fact that our party largely said initially at the beginning of the cycle, we're just going to abandon the millions of people that are living in terror from that and act like that's not something we should talk about is insane. Completely. It is absolutely ridiculous, but it's only because of progressive saying, you know, we're not going to do that. It's only because of people like Senator Van Hollen saying, you know what? I'm not going to write a strongly written letter when one of my own constituents is abducted by ice. I'm going to go and fly to El Salvador and meet with him and fight to get him released. That's what it actually looks like to show up and fight back. But that's exactly what a lot of the center's pundits out there said that we shouldn't have done. That we should have just rolled over and died, right? Our party is already seen as incredibly weak. We need to be seen as fighters. If we can truly lock in this cycle, two thing, if we can focus on a couple of things, cruelty, costs, and corruption, and lock those in, as per Millagia Paul talked about a couple weeks ago, it was a great tweet that I saw that I'm plagiarizing right now. If we can focus on those things and show the American people that we are building a government, we are taking our government back, that we are building a movement here, that when you vote for a Democrat, you are voting for somebody who actually will fight to represent you and not corporations and special interests. That will look out for your interest instead of their own stock portfolios so they can enrich themselves as a member of Congress because we actually banned stock trading. That is a powerful message that we could lock people in. But the thing that scares me most right now is that if we do not deliver because we have something like the filibuster and Chuck Schumer standing in the way blocking any progress that we have, not even letting bills get to Trump's desk for him to veto is simple, single issue, 80, 20 issues like banning congressional stock trading, and letting the president veto those things for us to run against Republicans in 28. We're screwed. Americans are counting on us to deliver for them. Young people especially are counting on us to deliver for them. If we don't do that, they're going to continue violently going from left to right over and over again until they find results because we can talk all we want about moderates and progressives. I'm happy to have that conversation. I think we need more progressives, but ultimately what matters most is that we deliver. That's why Zoran Mamdani is so popular because he is led boldly and he hasn't been a coward. He's delivered repeatedly and said, you know what, I'm used to hearing people tell me everything I can't do improving them wrong in every single day he does that and he may he's proven so many people wrong. He's actually doing what I think many people in this town is thought would be impossible. Not only leading New York City well, but making people believe that government can actually do good things for you. That's the real big threat of Zoran Mamdani because he is actually focused on the opposite of what most of these career corrupt Democrats are focused on, which is the government work for the most privileged and most wealthy and instead he's focused on making it work for those that are the most poor and the most needy. Yeah. I think between Zoran and Bernie, they gave everybody the populous message on, you know, billionaires and also an affordability and then Zoran has really provided the model for governance and now generational opportunity for Democrats, let's see if they can deliver will obviously keep the pressure on and I know you will specifically. David, thank you so much. Great to have you in studio. Thank you. Actually, the last thing that I want to say that I should have mentioned is that we can talk about Congress all we want. We need to talk about state legislatures. We have won so many state legislatures and if those are places that regardless of whether or not Chuck Schumer's there or what Jeffries decides to do, we can deliver in those state legislatures. We can really encourage people that are watching to taking 10% of the amount of time energy and effort that you have focused on Congress and focus on your state legislatures. Many people are even calling them and don't even know who their representatives are in state legislatures. We can do a lot of stuff there right now to raise the minimum wage, to stop data center expansion, to help expand things like Medicaid, but only if people are holding Democrats' feet to the fire in these new state legislatures. Legislative trifect is that we have. Very good point, and something we need to spend some more time on on the show because so many incredible results to process, but that is one that the impact will be immediately felt. Appreciate it. Yeah. A young teacher fails to show up for her first day of school, a hike of vanishes from a mountain in Colorado. I'm Lucy Shariff and this is Gone, The Disappearances, where we go beyond the news headlines to tell undercover stories of people who have gone missing. At the heart of all these stories, the vacuum that's left, the people who are left to pick up the pieces and find a way to move forward with a new normal, which seems almost impossible while they're still grasping for answers. I'm Dave and I've been an **** through my life. On October 2021, my brother David was diagnosed with pancreatic cancer. A year later, he convinced me to make a podcast with him. This podcast. Okay, so here we go. We fought. Yeah, pisses me off. It's weird and messy and vulnerable and I'm going to share all of it with you. The constant back and forth battle about how do I have
not just be alive, but I should live. Listen to my brother, David, on the iHeartRadio app, Abble Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. For more than a century, Miss America sold the country of fantasy. Okay, here we go. They said, "Goodbye to swimsuits, now. Hello to lawsuits." I'm Bridget Armstrong. Now I'm back with season two of this podcast, Curse of Miss America, investigating the rise, fall, and uncertain future of one of America's most iconic institutions. I never received a scholarship I need to pay for my student loans. He looks and he goes, "You don't look like you suffered in the eating disorder." It's great, but looks too ethnic. An exploitation of our Miss America's is treated by the Miss America organization as an attack on Miss America itself. Listen to the Curse of Miss America on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcast, or wherever you get your podcast. Today is IPO day four in "Theropic" with a more than $1 trillion valuation, quite consequential in the future of our economic system, our financial system, also potentially for humanity. So joining us to talk about all of those implications is Gary Marcus. He is a Professor Emeritus of Psychology and Neural Science at New York University and also author of the Marcus on AI Substack. Welcome and great to have you. Great to be here. Yeah, of course. So let me quote Gary Marcus to Gary Marcus. We could put a nine up on the screen here first. You had quite a take on what we're facing today. You said, "We face a turning point in humanity tomorrow. I don't say that likely. We can fully support the dangerous project of a Messianic cult leader who wants to proceed on one of the most reckless missions in the history of humanity. Or we can just say no. Presume you were talking about the IPO here today. So talk to us about why you see the terms as being so dire. Well, I mean, not just the financial terms. I think the financial terms are, I don't want to use the word idiotic, but not plausible to me and we can get into that. But something I read yesterday, which fits a lot of things that I read before, is they seem hell-bent on doing something called recursive self-improvement and taking humans out of the loop. And we're just not ready for that to take humans out of the loop. Our systems still hallucinate. They still fail to follow instructions. They're doing all of this rogue AI stuff. And to just let them rip is kind of crazy. And they seem kind of ready to do that. You know, they started as a company that really talked about AI safety a lot. But at the end of the day, they're just like all the other companies. They're about money and they don't really seem to care all that much about AI safety. Somebody wrote today called them mis-entropic the way we now sometimes call open AI closed AI because they aren't actually open about anything. Mis-entropic seems not really to care that much about the consequences. So Gary, you've been both kind of a philosophical opponent here. But you also have a financial deep dive into why you don't think that the company itself is worth what they're IPO-ing at. Can we put what E10 please on the screen your own analysis? Is Anthropics IPO a bad bet both for investors and society? And you lay out a pretty wholesome case as to why you think ultimately that is the case. Can you just explain it for our audience? The case for it, I'll start with that, is fundamentally that revenue is rising. You can kind of see that in that opening graph there. But the case for the very high valuation is that that revenue is going to keep increasing at this insane pace, which it did for a while. But number one, it already slowed down. So the third quarter was slower than the second quarter. And that's for a reason. It's not an accident. The reason, or it's really two reasons. One is China started to catch up. Maybe Jensen Wang helped with that. We discussed that another time. But China started to catch up. And people stopped doing what was called token maxing where they were just buying insane amounts of AI. They were rewarding their employees for using as much AI as possible. It was kind of a crazy period in history, if you ask me. But anyway, it's over. And so the demand has started to taper off. And the problem is, and what the bull case people don't pay attention to is this company has liabilities, future liabilities of $900 billion. They have actually not narrow profit margins, but negative profit margins. And so they don't really have a way to pay their bills in the long run. And so I think it is more likely that they will go bankrupt than that they will take over the world. And the whole thing is basically premised on them taking over the world. I mean, you're investing at a one and a half trillion dollar valuation. You want that to rise, right? You want 10 extra investment or something like that. That means becoming a $15 trillion company, which is three times bigger than Apple. So your upcase, you have to factor in what's the probability of that. And you have to think about other possibilities like bankruptcy. So in that article that you just mentioned that I put out yesterday, I went through all the risks, basically, that they're not considering, including these massive liabilities, including that each new model costs more money, including the fact that their market niche is very, very narrow, because Chinese competitors take all of this sort of low end to the market. So they only really have the high end of the market, open AI is competing with them there. Google may compete with them there. And what we've seen for the last few years is prices just go down and down. If your prices go down faster than your costs go down, then you're out of luck. Let's actually talk a little bit about the Jensen Huang of it all, because I think you're right to point to the fact that he was an important part of enabling both the different policy here from the U.S. with regards to the most advanced chips and also helping to see this ecosystem in China. He's now, the board said he's not coming back. The China hawks are much more ascendant at the moment in Washington, D.C. How much of a win for in-thropic do you see that as being? I mean, it depends how far that's ultimately materialized. So if the U.S. government says nobody can use Chinese models, then that would obviously help in-thropic. It would also cause all of the U.S. consumers, which includes Fortune 500 companies, to pay way more. I mean, basically like a secret tariff, not called that. It would be a pretty massive tariff if that happened. But I think a lot of people protest, and so I'm not sure that it would actually go through in the end. And even if it did, he's still going to see competition from places like Google and Amazon and so forth. And if the Chinese competitors sort of had their knees capped, that would raise the prices that everybody could charge. But it would increase the amount of competition because people would be like, oh, maybe I can't actually make money on this. I'm going to work really hard. So I don't know in the end that it would help in-thropic as much as some people might think. And I'm not sure it would really happen. One of the interesting questions I find, let's put E6, for example, up here on the screen, about these fund managers and others who are cutting their technology exposure. This is something that you've pointed to previously. What do you make here of the allocation by some of these fund managers, despite the fact that the anthropic team is raising the price, or is exceeding the price that they initially said? And they're saying that they have such strong demand. I mean, we'll see what the demand is really like. There was a nice post yesterday that I shared on Twitter showing that this is always the game. They always talk about things are over-subscribed. And companies say they want a bigger allocation than they want and so forth. So we kind of have to wait for the dust to settle on that. You know, a lot of people are going to buy this stock today. I think some are going to buy it to flip it. You know, what happened with SpaceX is it was technically at 135. Nobody could buy it at less than 150. It jumped up to like 225 and then it dropped down. I think it's trading at like 147 now. So there was like an opening blip. And so some people are playing the opening blip game. And some people are playing the long game. You know, my argument is the long game is not going to work. You know, if you time it just right and there's a blip, then maybe you can flip it in a day or two and maybe that works out. But that's not really what I'm talking about in the essay that I wrote the alluded to. I'm really talking about like, is this a sustainable company? And does it make sense at this kind of valuation? Yeah. So the market can remain irrational longer than you can stay solvent. You can't know exactly when things are going to fall apart. But it is your prediction that at some point, the, you know, the stuff is going to hit the fan. So to speak here, so what does that look like, Gary? You know, when? Well, I mean, it's already not for anthropic, but for the larger markets already kind of starting to get the fan. Okay. People don't like to use the bubble war. But if you look around, excuse me, if you look around, you know, Nvidia is down. I think it's like 40% for the year or something like that year to date. Maybe not 40. Like, it's significant about me. It's 20% per year oracles down. I think like 40% per year and core, core weave, maybe and so forth. So a lot of these stocks already have taken a pretty sizable hit or correction or whatever you want to call it. And of course, the question is whether that continues. I think the biggest question here is not actually around anthropic, but around what Nvidia is going to do. Because Nvidia has been propping up the market with all this circular financing and backstopping companies so that they buy lots of chips and so forth. and craftsman.
is kind of signaling that those days are over. If that happens, then all of these companies that didn't really have sensible economic plans are in deep trouble. One of the other things Gary that we wanted to talk to you about here was that letter that you referenced earlier. We could put E2 up on here, the misanthropic statement that you signed on to. They say anthropic warns that recursively self-improving AI could concentrate power, escape human control. Yeah, race is to build the first. The company uses safety brand and to court investors, even if it is quietly weakened to safety pledges and lobbied for self-serving regulation. Anthropic is not a safe AI company and we must reject its reckless attempt to amass power in the name of a greater good. There was quite a spectrum of kind of the beliefs of people. What do you see as the emerging kind of coalition to restrict AI or restrict a recursive self-improvement, if you will, and are you optimistic about it? None of us want per se to restrict AI, or at least most of us don't. Some people call me an AI hater. I actually want to see AI help us for science and medicine and so forth. The coalition that signed that letter is a set of people with very different views. Some of them are so-called doomers that think that AI is going to kill us all. I'm not a doomer. I don't think it's going to kill us all. There's a really broad spectrum sign that we're all concerned about Anthropic. It's partly because we see Anthropic as talking out of two sides of its mouth, trying to position itself as the safety company and then at every turn going ahead as fast as possible. You have Darryl saying, let's pace, he wrote this letter a month and a half ago or something like that saying that we should pay AI and Elon and Sam Altman saying, yeah, then they all went to the White House and completely forgot about all of that. They're just trying to charge ahead as much as possible. The idea that they would leave humans out of it, which I guess they're thinking about, is really terrifying. I mean, Gary, someone who's been following some of your analysis and learning about you and your perspective, I was a little bit surprised to see your name on this because you are someone who has been skeptical of the maximalist AI claims, whether it's on the doomer side or the utopian side. I don't want to mischaracterize your views. You can explain for yourself, but my understanding of your view is effectively, they're not there yet. There's more innovations, there's more research, more engineering, more science that is required before you're either able to end up in a doom or a utopia depending on which way things go. What is it about recursive self-improvement in particular that has caused you to be alarmed? Would you say that that should be completely banned? You may not be in favor of complete AI development, pause or ban, but recursive self-improvement specifically. Is that something that you think should be off the table? I mean, the people who wrote the letter would emphasize that more than I did. I actually sent some comments to try to mediate that a little. They didn't take my comments, but I thought it was important enough to make the general point. But more broadly, there's a nuance here that a lot of people don't quite understand, which is that even if AI is not super smart, if we give it a lot of power, we hook it up to the internet and give it internet access, then a lot of bad things can happen. In fact, I started to see that over the last couple of weeks, overnight, the EU was hacked in a pretty serious way. So we were seeing lots more cyber attacks and so forth. Recursive self-improvement is one of the concerns that we should have, leaving humans out of the loop as one of the concerns that we should have. The biggest thing is we need to pace ourselves, to borrow a term from Dario, they doesn't seem to take very seriously. We need to pace ourselves until we can actually solve the so-called alignment problem or make much more progress on it. Right now, we have systems where we tell them to do X and they wind up doing Y. And that's bad. And if we make them even better at kind of doing Y when we want them to do X, that's even worse for us. That means even more problems crop up. So I wouldn't actually ban AI, but I would say let's hold off until we have a better handle on how to make sure these things don't do bad things. And what is your understanding of what's happening on the cyber security front? Because people really freaked out. You've got crypto hies, you've got bank chases down, you've got the airlines grounded, you've got the NSA communication system we covered earlier on the show, the EU hack that you're talking about here. Some of the things are hacked, some of them they're saying are not hacked, but it's very clear the cyber security landscape here has changed dramatically. What's going on and how do we navigate through this period? So it's actually a bunch of things. It's not one and you kind of eluded to that. So some of it is done with malice. Some of it is because the new software is better looking at vulnerabilities. Some is because people are using LLM's, large language models that are unreliable to write code. And some of that code is sloppy code and creates vulnerabilities of its own. So it's actually more than one thing. It was kind of anticipating. I wrote in January 1st, I think, of 2025 in Politico that this was all going to get bad and I pointed both to the change in models, more use of code written by the models, but also to the deregulation that we expected from Trump. And in fact, we got from Trump. So the CSA and agencies like that are really understaffed right now. Excuse me, not really up to the job. So it's kind of a mess. It's like a perfect storm of a whole bunch of different factors coming together. It really isn't one. I think when Rubio said these aren't cyber attacks, he probably tell them the truth. And the EU, when they said that CSA is a cyber attack, he's probably telling the truth. We have now devices that can find these vulnerabilities. We have probably sloppy code being written and we have weaker government facilities to try to investigate these things. And we had like no regulations so people were just doing anything they wanted. It was kind of the Wild West. And this is what you get. Yeah. Are you are you at Costco buying the water pallets, getting the dehydrated food? Or what's your personal approach to these things? I'm actually picking up some water today to be perfectly honest and we already have some of this. Smart. There you go. You know, Gary, I just want to say, I texted our chat while we were talking, my credit card was fraudulent and charged. So, you know, it does. This is the second time in five days that I've been doing a live hit and got interrupted by something that kind of is consistent with what I was saying with live news. It's just these are crazy times. Yeah. Gary, I hope you'll come back and talk to us again. We really appreciate your insight. It's great. I love to come back sometime. Yeah, thank you. And because the sub-stack is Marcus on AI, people can check you out there. We'll see you again soon. Have a good day. Take care. I remember screaming one night, where is my brother? Where is my brother? Listen to Gone, The Disappearances on the iHeart radio app Apple podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts. November is pancreatic cancer awareness month. And I want to tell you about my brother David, a podcast that documents my brother's journey with this disease. The experience of pancreatic cancer patients goes under the radar Dr. Cal Sabai, but just because we dive so fast. Listen to my brother David on the iHeartRadio app Apple podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts. You broke me. I'm Andrea Gunning. Listen to betrayal season six on the iHeartRadio app Apple podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts. Guaranteed Human.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The podcast explores real-life disappearances, including a hiker vanishing in Colorado and a teacher missing on her first day of school, highlighting the emotional and psychological impact on families.
A personal story of a brother’s battle with pancreatic cancer is shared, emphasizing the need to shift public awareness and support for this often-overlooked disease.
The show examines the rise of political backlash against MAGA and conservative policies, with a surge in progressive victories across the U.S., especially among young voters and marginalized communities.
A major debate centers on AI accountability, with the argument that companies must be legally responsible for harmful AI decisions, even if not directly programmed.
The discussion on Kalshi prediction markets reveals a conflict between framing them as legal sports betting versus markets with real economic and hedging utility.
Critics argue that Kalshi’s business model, dominated by sports betting and heavily regulated by states, raises ethical and societal concerns, including addiction and financial harm.
Progressive political momentum is attributed to economic populism, anti-corruption messaging, and the rise of diverse, inclusive candidates like Randy Villegas, who defeated an incumbent by a massive margin.
The episode underscores the importance of transparency, accountability, and public trust in both technology and politics as society navigates complex challenges.
Summary:
This podcast, *Gone, The Disappearances*, dives into real-world stories of missing people, from a hiker vanishing in Colorado to a young teacher failing to show up for her first day of school, emphasizing the emotional void left behind by their absence. It also features a personal narrative about the brother’s journey with pancreatic cancer, aiming to humanize a disease often ignored in public discourse. S.
elections driven by economic populism, youth engagement, and demands for equity. A central debate examines AI accountability, proposing that companies must be legally responsible for harmful AI actions, even when not directly programmed. The conversation on Kalshi prediction markets reveals tension over whether its platform—dominated by sports betting—should be classified as gambling or a legitimate market with economic utility, especially for hedging risks.
Critics point to significant societal harms, including addiction and financial loss, while supporters stress its role in enabling informed decision-making. The episode concludes with a powerful political story of Randy Villegas, a working-class Latino candidate who defeated a long-serving incumbent by a landslide, symbolizing the rise of inclusive, anti-establishment politics and the growing power of marginalized voices in democratic processes. Together, these stories reflect a shared theme: in times of uncertainty, transparency, accountability, and human connection are essential to finding answers and building trust.
FAQs
The podcast explores real stories of people who have gone missing, focusing on the emotional impact on families and loved ones as they search for answers in the absence of clear evidence.
The podcast shares the journey of a brother diagnosed with pancreatic cancer, aiming to elevate awareness about this often-overlooked disease and shift public perception from sympathy to survival.
Ali proposes that human responsibility must be established for AI decisions, especially when AI acts harmfully on its own, and that companies training or deploying AI should be held legally accountable as if they intentionally caused harm.
Ali argues that Kalshi operates within legal frameworks, follows federal regulations, and adheres to market rules—such as fair pricing and transparency—similar to how financial markets were once regulated, even if challenged by states.
Ali states that prediction markets on platforms like Kalshi are driven by participant-driven pricing and transparency, unlike sportsbooks, which set odds and profit from unfair odds, making the markets fundamentally different.
Ali emphasizes that Kalshi provides economic hedging tools for individuals and businesses, such as protecting portfolios from geopolitical or economic risks, and supports broader market transparency and decision-making.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.