024 Training, hypertrophy, and recovery for older people
from Hypertrophy Past and Present
1h 4m 25s
The discussion explores how aging affects strength training adaptations, challenging the common assumption that older individuals grow more slowly due to reduced stimulus sensitivity. Instead, research shows that slower adaptation is primarily due to impaired recovery—older people take longer to recover between workouts, leading to accumulated fatigue and diminished performance. Key evidence comes from maintenance studies, where older adults maintain muscle mass at low volumes, indicating that the stimulus isn’t weaker, just less effectively recovered. This shifts the focus from increasing volume to optimizing recovery through fewer sets, moderate-heavy loads, and longer rest periods. The silver era’s recommendations—such as lower reps, one-set routines, and longer rest—align well with this physiology. Additionally, older adults face increased risk of micro-mechanical damage due to reduced dystrophin levels, making extreme range-of-motion movements risky. While speed training helps sedentary older adults improve daily function, it’s less critical for active or athletic individuals. The overall program design emphasizes minimizing fatigue and muscle damage over maximizing hypertrophy, using balanced, low-volume routines with occasional power or isometric exercises to boost motor unit activation. This approach is not only safe but also sustainable over time, especially for those aging into strength training. Ultimately, the core insight is that age-related performance decline is not due to biological insensitivity to training, but to recovery limitations—making recovery strategies far more important than volume or intensity adjustments.
Welcome back everyone to another episode of high-perch free pass, Andrews.
And thank you for joining us again, Chris, how are you doing this week?
Okay, thanks, Jake. Little bit of a cold, but it's not actually showing through in the voice today.
So I was quite worried yesterday I was thinking that today I'll be croaky,
but actually it's not too bad.
I tell it all. And you've released another second episode on the other podcast.
Do you want to just briefly tell people if they're not aware of that, what that's all about?
Yeah, so started a new podcast on athletic training with Rob Mauserius called High Performance Physiology.
It's a pretty short podcast again weekly at maybe 30, 40 minutes.
Just talking about one particular important physiological concept.
And then relating that to training and Rob gives some great examples every time about how he's
implementing those ideas in his training programs for his clients. So I think it's a nice way to
kind of link the physiology with the actual strength training practices. And last week,
we talked about maximum strength. We literally have just recorded a third episode on maximum speed
and how to train for that and what the adaptions are. And we'll release that in a couple of days' time.
So if you're not listening to High Performance Physiology, please do check that out,
stick to my Instagram bio if you want to look at that and be great to get your feedback on that.
You are becoming a professional podcaster. A professional podcaster.
Yeah, I don't think so. I think I'll only probably do podcasts with people that I know.
But yeah, no, it's fun to talk through these things. But hopefully, as I was just explaining
there and obviously tying into what we do, you know, I think one of the coolest things is to see
how the physiology can be translated into practical applications. Because I think that's the big thing
that I'm excited to see happen over the next few years in our industry as people using that
physiology to inform their own training programs and come up with creative ideas.
And you've got one more thing coming up in, I think, a few weeks. Do you want to mention that?
It's, I think it's going to be two weeks. I'm going to do a webinar with a friend of mine
that, you know, we're going to talk about preserving muscle mass during diets. That's something that,
again, is I think going to become a hot topic in our industry over the next couple of years,
as people get into that sort of understanding of what's going on physiologically. So I don't
want to say any more because I can maybe give full details next time we run this podcast because
that'll be just before the webinar happens. But yes, in about two weeks time, I will be doing a
webinar and preserving muscle mass during dieting. I have some very exciting stuff to talk about
on that webinar. And I think a lot of it will be new to many people who hear it for the first time.
So I'm excited to hear about that, but I will give more details next week.
Certain includes like how to sign up. You'll have info like that next week.
The sign up links will be linked probably from my bio or in a pin post or something like that.
But yes, I can give again full details of that next weekend.
Happy days. Let's jump into today's topic. Now, the plan I'm going to talk about is going to give
it away. So I'm just going to unleash and tell you all what it is. And we're going to be talking
about specifically how someone might need to train differently as they age. Okay. So what's
different from a hypertrophy perspective when someone does get older and there's some really
interesting stuff that you're going to cover in a moment. But I'm going to talk about how this
silver era saw this issue and what they suggested doing. So we're going to cover a plan from period
later, which is about period a few times. So obviously here is the founder of Iron Man magazine,
which you know, this was mid 30s, I believe, 1936, something like that. And then he was the head
of Iron Man for about half a deck, a half a half a century. I think Iron Man still exists,
but obviously it's changed hands. But obviously he was very influential in popularizing a lot of,
I guess you could say like bodybuilding systems and stuff like the breathing squads. He didn't
invent them, but he was one of the key figures that was actually putting out some of this content.
So in one of his books, he actually has a section on how to train as one gets older. Now he's
sort of a little bit, I guess, how would you say, flexible with what would constitute older age.
So he says, some men might feel old when they hit 40 or 50. If you know, for some people,
it might be older than that, but it's kind of subjective. You know, when you feel you're getting
old, you feel like you can't recover and you can't perform the way you do when you're younger,
these are some things that you can do. Now, just to be upfront, he didn't write out a specific
plan. What he did is he said, these, this is how you should change your plan compared to the young
individual compared to how you were training. So what I'm going to do is I'm going to tell you what
those guidelines are. And then I'm going to take one of his standard plans and I'm going to tell you
what that would look like with these guidelines. So the guidelines were that for an older individual,
you should look at doing lower repetitions. So as an example, he said, if you were doing 10,
then an older individual should be looking at doing seven to eight. He also suggested fewer sets.
That will depend on if a muscle is a high priority or a specialization muscle or if it's a
lower priority, and he did sort of give it a bit of a distinction there, but he said, you're probably
not going to want to do more than three to four sets maximum for muscle. In general, for general
health and wellness, he said one set per, per exercise or per muscle was sort of his recommendation
for an older individual. He also suggested taking longer respiries between sets and an interesting
addition and maybe we'll touch on this. I don't know if we'll touch on this now or maybe you'll
get to it when you do your part, but he did say for older individuals, it's actually beneficial to
add in a speed type exercise occasionally. And he didn't specifically specifically say what type
effects the size, but he just said something that's more speed related adding that in can have
benefit. And like I said, I'm sure you'll touch on that in in the little bit. So if we were to look
at how this actually would be presented in a plan, this would look like to this is coming from
his standard squat plan because he was a big believer in breathing squats and that form
in the foundation of a lot of his plans. And this could look like the first exercise being a barbell
overhead press. Now this would be done for a single set and it would be done for seven to eight
repetitions. Then we could go into a barbell curl against single set seven to eight repetitions
into a barbell bench or supine press what they call it back then for a single set of seven to
eight repetitions into a bent over barbell row. Now he typically programmed this in the transverse
plane. And this would be for one set of seven to eight and then finishing with a barbell squat.
Now like I mentioned a moment ago, he was a big advocate for the 20 reps squats or breathing
squats. And he did say that for people who had lower recovery or lower capacity or you know,
that would include all the individuals that what you could do instead of doing a single set of 20
was to do two sets of 10. So in this situation two sets of 10 for the barbell squat would be
more suitable. Now that's five exercises. He did say that individuals who are all the maybe can
do you know, up to say, I think he suggested up to about seven to eight exercises in total would
be their probably limit. Somebody said, you know, anywhere between that sort of five to seven is
probably going to be suitable for an old individual compared to say 10 to 12 exercises for a younger
adult. So I'm interested. I'm interested in your feedback on this plan, but also how this ties in
or does or doesn't tie into what you're going to share a little bit later on. I think that'll be
quite interesting. Yeah. I mean, there's some really interesting stuff here. I mean, just starting
with the with the obviously we've got a reasonable kind of starting point for a program with those
five exercises, obviously there's a lot missing. You know, but it does it does kind of cover, you know,
kind of most of the I'm hesitating because it, you know, kind of like straight to it. I'm looking
at what what was not there. You know, there's obviously no really good lab exercise there. You
know, we've got no hamstrings exercise there, you know, and I'm not a huge fan of scapula plane
stuff because it doesn't really do anything well. I'm guessing that's that's kind of maybe just
a variation thing and that most of the time you'd probably be working in the frontal plane. But,
you know, it's it's it's not a horrible kind of starting point for a barbell based training program.
It only means the stuff relating to the older people, I think, though, is fascinating. I mean,
there's so much here that is exactly what I would expect, you know, I mean, one of the first
things that, you know, you've written down in the notes and you've explained is this idea of
dropping down to a fewer repetitions per set, you know, I mean, most of the time when we look at the
fitness industry, people are tending to push older people towards using lighter loads because they
think that, you know, that's less damage. I mean, that's less potential for injury, you know, and,
you know, sure, if you're working with barbells, then no, I don't necessarily think that it's a great idea
to encourage people to use heavy barbells at that age. But, you know, that's a safety issue really
rather than a physiology issue. I think physiologically, heavier loads are going to give us less intro
work out fatigue and also less post workout fatigue. So, you know, given what we're going to talk
about shortly, that's a really, really good thing to do. So, the fact that he's spotted that,
that heavy loads are actually going to be better, you know, with fewer repetitions per set,
and we're better for the older person than, than, than, than lighter loads, I think is really,
really, really valuable insight. Same thing really would go with the, the other variables. So,
fewer sets again, again, we'll talk about this in detail. But, you know, the idea of not creating as
much intro work out fatigue by doing too much volume and not doing creating as much post workout
fatigue by doing as much volume again, I think is going to, is going to be a, a fact that really
benefits the older person, longer rest periods, same thing. It's like, you know, just allowing that
full recovery to take place between them.
sets is going to make a difference to anybody's strength training performance, but the older
person might need a little bit longer because they might find that their cardiovascular system
isn't as efficient or capable as the younger persons. The idea of a speed exercise is very cool
because or a power exercise is very cool because one of the big features that we see with older people
is the suppression of their motino equipment levels. Often if you kind of test an older person,
they've got lower levels of volunteer activation than the younger person, and a speed exercise
is a really nice way of just trying to trigger an increase in motino equipment. Now, we'll talk
about other ways that can be done. It doesn't have to be a speed exercise. That's really an interesting
possibility. Now, for people who are actually interested in working specifically with older people,
not just as a theoretical kind of thought experiment, it is worth mentioning that there is a whole
set of literature which is devoted to exploring the role of power training or speed training with
older people, simply because old people do tend to display greatly reduced levels of maximum speed.
So, from a functional perspective, that might be interesting for certain kind of people working
in that space. I'm less really interested in it per se. I'm not someone who's working in that area.
I don't spend a lot of time reading about the challenges specifically faced by older people,
and I think that, in all honesty, most people who are listening to this, who are either older or
who are working with older people are probably more likely to be working in master's athletes,
rather than necessarily, you know, just general population older people. But in which case,
the speed issue isn't really much of a factor because either you're already doing it because
you're heading for a sport that requires speed. Or if you're training for a sport that doesn't
require speed, then you probably won't really notice much of an issue on the speed side because
you've already got pretty well developed other characteristics, which means that you're
not really noticing much of a problem in day-to-day life for a functional point of view.
Where the speed stuff really comes through is when you're kind of looking at studies of
sedentary older people, and the researchers noticed that a bit of speed work seems to dramatically
affect their capabilities in day-to-day life. But if you're a master's power lifter or a master's,
you know, kind of, I don't know, what kind of sports masters athletes kind of tend to take part
in these days. But if they tend to be more on the sort of the strength and the spectrum,
you're unlikely to notice deficits in your activities of daily life function because you're
pretty functional, really. So that kind of speed stuff doesn't really kind of play into it. But
that's, yeah, that's. - If you have an individual who continues to train throughout
their training life and then just age as part of that, do we see significant reductions in speed
as people age? Like I'm assuming there'll be some, yeah. Yeah, okay, so it's quite significant.
- Yeah. No, it is. It is a really big deal. But the point I'm making is that you've got these two
separate things to think about. Either you're a master's athlete who does need to move quickly.
Let's say you're a master's throwing athlete, you know, then yeah, you're a lot of your attention
will be devoted to try and figure out ways of mitigating that loss in speed, dealing with it,
working around it, all of those kind of things. You will be obsessing over it quite a lot. But
it's not going to have any impact on your day-to-day life really because you're already very,
very functional. The other category of people is the people who are perhaps sedentary and old and
then you are going to see speed deficits playing a role in their day-to-day life. It's not going
to be able to move out of the way of something if it falls over. They're not going to be able to
move themselves around very easily and, you know, very quickly get out of the way of something.
So you will see a meaningful effect of speed training in that situation. But for the person
who's, you know, aging, but taking part in bodybuilding, for example, I just don't see that the
speed issue would come up most of the time. You've got enough functionality just from the strength
trainings, but sort of part of that. This might be something you want to get into later, I'm not sure,
but does the speed reduction, does that correlate fairly directly with reduction in like high threshold
moe unit recruitment or obviously that will play a role. But I think it is definitely separate
in other ways. I think you do see a reduction in mosa faru shortening velocity that is independent
of the motino crewman reduction. You can, one of my favorite things to do when people ask me this
question is go and look at master's track athletes who've spent their life being track athletes.
So they've got really high levels of recruitment, but when you see them run, it's like they're
running through treacle. They're just, they can't move any faster than they are. They're really,
really slow. Even though they've got high levels of recruitment, they're decent muscle mass.
They're just moving slowly because of the factors that have negative, the effective speed at a
fibre level. So, but I'm talking about 80 plus year old people at that point. I mean, that's what we
classify as very old. Just briefly in the literature, we tend to classify people as either 60 or 65
onwards as being old and 85 plus as being very old. That's just the kind of general kind of way
that excise science groups, those ages of people. Okay, so looking at this plan as a sort of whole
plan in terms of the sets and reps and all that apart from some of those excise selection bits that
you would perhaps change or, you know, that you've identified a lacking. Is it anything specific
with the sets and the reps and the longer experience and those sort of dives that you look at,
you're like, well, for all the person, I would definitely do that differently. So excise selection
aside. Now, I like the lower, it's basically what I would classify as moderately heavy. I mean,
so heavy would be one to five and then moderately heavy would be six to ten. I think moderately heavy
is brilliant rep range for almost everybody. You know, it's where I spend most of my time. You know,
I think it's hard to go really, really wrong with that, especially if you're using machine weights.
And single sets, you know, long rests, that's perfect for, again, it will work for everybody,
but I think it's again perfect for all the people as we'll explain as we go into the physiology side
of things. So let's jump in. Okay, let's do it. So there's a number of different ways that you can
start talking about the question of age in strength training. You can either start by talking about
the differences in the recovery rates or you can start talking about the differences in the
adaptions and then bring in the discussion of recovery rates later on. Historically, when I've taught
this, I've actually taught it recovery first then adaptions. I'm actually going to try and switch
that around today and see what happens. I'm really interested to see if this works better because
I think the assumption is when when I introduce this topic to people, the assumption is often that
older people display reduced adaptions or a speed of adaptions. So like they grow more slowly,
they display increases in strength more slowly, they display, you know, all of the various adaptions more
slowly in comparison with younger people. And it's kind of just this, this starting assumption that
all of that is equally affected. And the really interesting thing is that it doesn't seem to look
that way. So yes, if you go to this sort of high-purchase side of the spectrum, you look at the
hypertrophy literature, hypertrophy literature and you look at studies that have measured rate of
growth in both older and younger people, then what you'll notice is that the rate of muscle mass
increases and they make rate of muscle fiber diameter increases in older people is slower or
are slower than they are in, you know, in younger people. Now, similarly, if you look at
physical length increases or you look at sarcomargenesis in younger and older rodents, then again,
what you'll find is that the rate of growth of both physical length and endurance and sarcomargenesis
or sarcomase and series in animals is slower in older people than in younger people. And so you
kind of like start to build up a picture and you go, oh yeah, okay, well, you know, adaptions are,
you know, generally slower, at least as far as hypertrophy and sarcomargenesis is concerned. But
if you were to go outside of that immediately, kind of, you know, sort of obvious area of literature
and you were to start to go into areas like tendon stiffness changes and fiber type shifting and
other adaptions that are not the mainstream ones that everyone's interested in, you would actually
find they don't behave in the same way. So one of my favorite studies shows that tendon stiffness
in older people essentially tracks increases in younger people. It just goes on for a longer period
of time. Why does it do that? Why do you carry on increasing tendon stiffness in older people
for a longer time than you do in younger people? In young people, tendon stiffness kind of just
reaches a plateau after a couple of months and just starts to, you know, sit there. Older people
it carries on and just carries on increasing. Why? Because they started with much lower levels
tendon stiffness. So they're kind of carrying on to the point where they start to plateau later on,
but fundamentally the rate of change is pretty much the same. You can get the same kind of data with
fiber type shifting. You tend to find that the fiber type shifts drift more or less at the same
speed in older people and younger people and then start to plateau off as the kind of maximum
amount of type 2x5 has been converted into type 2a fibers. So ultimately what's really, really
interesting is that when we start talking about the effects of age on strength training adaptions,
we can't just say that all people display slow adaptions across the board. It's one of, as
people know, and I'm starting to, I think this is starting to catch on now. You can't just talk
about outcomes and expect to, you know, kind of get a sensible picture of what's going on. If that
outcome is an externally measured outcome that represents multiple internal adaptions. So you
can't say all people increase strength more slowly than younger people and expect that to mean
something. You know, okay, maybe it's true, but why is it happening? The increased recruitment to
the same rate, to the increased coordination at the same rate, to the increased muscle side.
It's like, what are all the factors that go into that? And are they all affected equally?
Are they affected differently? Especially what you're saying here, a lot of these sounds like
it's going to affect untrained older people more of the tendons stiffness thing. Well, okay,
if you've had an individual again train the whole life, they're not going to be starting at,
you know, level where the tendons are more compliant than they would have been otherwise.
Yeah, totally, so tendons and fiber type shifting are going to be factors that are mainly
in that kind of category of things that untrained people are going to.
be affected by mostly. So, yeah. But ultimately, the point is that we're seeing a discrepancy
between things that are affected by age, definitely, and things are much less affected by
age. Now, that's kind of like my starting point, my observation that we've got these
differences going on in terms of the rate of change of the individual adaptions that
are underpinning things like strength gains. Now, one of the big questions then is, why
do hypertrophy and psychomyogenesis display a slower rate of that in older people than
in younger people? Now, just incidentally, before I answer that question, it's worth noting
that if you look at fast-collink changes in older people over time, they are slower, but
they still plateau at the same point. So, if you kind of see a plateau happening in younger
people at maybe four, five, six weeks or whatever, then the older people take say 10, 12 weeks
to plateau at the exact same location. So, the fast-collink just takes longer to get there,
but it still gets to the same point, it still plateaus in the same place, exactly as we
would predict based on the kind of way that psychomyogenesis works. But the question
then is, well, why are we seeing such slow rate of adaption in older people? Now, essentially,
you've got two possibilities. Either there is a smaller sensitivity to the mechanical
tension stimulus, so what you're saying there is that each workout that you do, the older
person does three sets to failure, you do three sets to failure. Oh, actually, you do three
sets to failure and I do three sets to failure. And that's a younger person and older person.
So we both do the same workout, three sets to failure. And what you're saying, if you
say the sensitivity of the stimulus is reduced to an older person, what you're saying there
is that that person experiences a smaller adaptive response to that workout because of the
inherent features of their muscle tissue. That's one possibility. The alternative possibility
is that the older person is carrying a cumulative fatigue from the previous workout because they're
not recovering in time between workouts. So you end up in the same place, but the mechanism
by which you get to that result is different and it has different training implications.
Yeah. So if you think that the person, if the older person is experiencing less sensitivity,
then your gut feel is going to be, okay, well, we need to give them a bigger stimulus.
So people start to add more volume. Well, that's concrete.
I would say he's a fairly typical piece of advice. That's something I've certainly heard
a lot where, okay, if you have an older individual, basically you just add one to two sets per
exercise.
You can find that in the literature. Oh, yeah. There's review papers that have argued
that point. Absolutely. But they're not starting from the question is like, is it genuinely
definitively a lower stimulus sensitivity or is it a reduced, you know, kind of ability
to recover from the previous workout, which means that you're suppressing your anabolic
stimulus, literally simply because you're carrying accumulated fatigue that you haven't got
rid of.
And I don't think there's been enough work to actually, you know, kind of, well, I don't
think there's been a recognition of that observation to start with. But, you know, fundamentally,
at the moment, I think most people are assuming that it's a sensitivity issue. Well, straight
to where I'll be questioning that, saying, well, if it's a sensitivity issue, why don't
I see it cropping up with fiber type shifting? Why don't I see it cropping up with tendons
stiffness?
Should it, okay, maybe you can rule tendons out because the tendon is not a muscle, but
still fiber type shifting is not behaving the same way. So, I think straight to where
I'd start asking the question is like, are we dealing with a sensitivity reduction issue
or are we dealing with a recovery issue? That then brings us to the next point, which
is to say, well, everybody knows that one of my favorite areas of literature in the
hypertrophy science is the maintenance studies. I just keep going back to them going, look,
they teach us so much cool stuff. Well, we actually have got a maintenance study in
older people. So we've got a maintenance study in older men, and we were talking about it
just before we came on the podcast, and we were looking at the ages of those subjects.
I think it was like 70s to 75 years old. So properly in the middle of the old category
between 60 and 80. And those guys were training for a period of time to do three sets, three
times a week, and they increased muscle mass. And then they went to a maintenance where
they did three sets once per week, and they kept it. Now, this is super, super important
because we know that three sets once a week is maintenance level in young people. If older
people are less sensitive to the antibiotic stimulus, then what we should see in the situation
of maintenance is that they don't maintain on three sets. They should only maintain
on five or maybe even six. So the people who are saying, oh, no, no, no, no, no, we know
that old people are experiencing a smaller stimulus to a strength training work. I'm
like, okay, explain it, explain the maintenance literature. Because it shows me that the stimulus
that the old person is getting is pretty much identical because stimulus is the same
or they're not at your thing is quickly, which obviously would not. Yeah. Yeah. So straight
away, you've got this data point, which immediately pushes you away from the idea that you actually
are experiencing a smaller stimulus per workout. So the idea then would be to say, well, okay,
so the explanation for your reduced growth in older people is more likely to be reduced
recovery between workout. And as soon as you start asking that question, the literature
explodes in front of you because you've got loads of animal and human data showing that
recovery rates are slower in older people, you know, and that then it's like, okay, so
we know that's true. And we know that the maintenance literature is basically giving
us the same answer in young people and old people that strongly indicates that our issue regarding
adaptions and older people is nothing to do with inherently reduced sensitivity to a stimulus.
It's actually more about recovery. So now the idea of adding volume is ludicrous. You
actually run away from the idea, go in the opposite direction and lo and behold, that's
exactly what the silver era was recommending. Literally what you started by telling us,
you know, like, do less. Okay. Well, that's exactly what I'm seeing. It'll be interesting
if they were to do a study where even this once week, but you had people, young men,
older adults, do say six sets of seven sets once a week and then seeing what the hypertrophy
stimulus was of that. Yeah. So that would be kind of exploring whether there's a dose response,
per workout difference between older and younger people. I mean, we have got some nice data
on frequency in rodents. They put older and younger rodents through the same kind of frequency
volume combinations. And what they find is that in the younger rodents, they can recover
and continue progressing. And the older rodents, once the volume is slightly too high, immediately
start to see the decrease in performance and they get entering to this overreaching state,
accumulated fatigue state. So there could be a few moving parts in. So I think it's, it's
mainly just that the older person is recovering more slowly from each workout rather than
anything else. Now, there isn't any concern over, like, measurements being different in terms
of, do we know whether there's any difference in how they say self swelling between older
people or younger people or inflammatory response or how long that that timeline is for that
inflammatory response to take place? Could that be influencing anything?
So before I answer that, I will answer that. Let me just quickly, because this ties into
the idea of what's actually happening in the post-workout recovery period. So as everybody
knows, who's listened to any of these podcasts or read the FAQ, basically after you finish
a strengthening workout, you've got a period of time in which you've got calcium ion
relative to your mechanisms that essentially involve proteases, damaging the tissue, and
then secondly, you've got an inflammatory response off the back of that. And it's the inflammatory
response, really, that seems to drive much of the secondary muscle damage effect and also
the swelling associated with that. Now, yes, older people have a slightly disregulated
inflammatory process. So you might have a disregulated muscle swelling occurring at the
same time. That doesn't affect the maintenance literature, of course, because that is.
But in terms of the other research suggesting that there was less hypertrophy, you might
have less muscle swelling. Yes, you might, because you do tend to have a slightly reduced
capability of a robust inflammatory response in the post-workout period, absolutely.
But yeah, in terms of the maintenance literature, there is no one issue because we're recovering
in time for the weekly workout. But yeah, in terms of the other stuff, you might see
a little bit of the fact that the rat studies is not going to be affected by that, because
not, that's not really it. I mean, we're seeing some really dramatic changes in, for example,
strength over time, where the older rats are just the strength levels of tanking, indicating
that they're not recovering from one workout to the next. So you can kind of sort of see
the word for the trees, if you like, in that context. So the interesting thing about the
older people in recovery situation is that, well, there's a few moving parts here. But basically,
if you give a, like say, for example, if you structure a workout to end up with kind of the
same amount of post-workout fatigue immediately post-workout in the older group and the younger group,
then you'll still find that the older group recover more slowly from that level of post-workout
fatigue than the younger group. So you had, you measured the same post-workout fatigue, but
you just saw a slower recovery rate in the older group of people. And that's really interesting,
because that kind of tells you that it's not about older people being more susceptible to
calcium-involved fatigue mechanisms, although arguably there might be a little bit of that there.
It's more about just the ability to deal with them once they've happened, which ties in with
this idea of the inflammatory process being, you know, dysregulated or less effective. So you know,
that kind of is the broad picture. It's this idea that you might have the same post-workout
fatigue, but it just takes you along with the deal with it. And that really means that you're not
going to be able to do the same volume frequency combinations. You can't do probably this classic
routine that we talk about, you know, three sets, three times a week or three sets every other day,
with moderately heavy loads. You're probably going to need to dial that back to one or two sets instead,
which is exactly what your kind of silver era template was showing us at the beginning.
The other moving parts really to be aware of is that there is a reduced volunteer activation level
in all the people so.
generally speaking. So you kind of start off with this problem whereby you're not
accessing as much high threshold motor units. You're not training as many
muscle fibers. So potentially that could impact on the hypertrophy rate, but also
it should reduce post-workout fatigue. So again, it's like if I do end up with
the same amount of post-workout fatigue, it does that mean that I've done
something else that's created more of a muscle damaging effect in the fibers
that I've got actually activated because if you're activating fewer fibers, you
should see less post-workout fatigue, but I'm not seeing that. I'm seeing pretty
much the same. So what is it that I'm doing or what is it that I'm experiencing
as an older person that causes that greater level of fiber level of damage, for
example, you know, despite the fact that I'm activating fewer fibers. And one of
the answers to that could be the reduction in dystrophy in our customers inside
the muscle fibers. So I'm getting less protection from those customers to the
strains. And strains could give me two effects. It could give me great-to-stretch
actoid diet tunnel opening, so more calcium ion influx into those affected
fibers, but it could also create a mechanical damage phenomenon. So obviously,
you know, people know that I think that the vast majority of damage post-workout
is biochemical in nature, but as you lose dystrophy in your fibers, become less
capable of transplanting force, literally, you could start to get mechanical
damage in those older people's muscle fibers. So one of the interesting things
that could be done in the future is to actually look and see whether the muscle
damage that older people experience has elements of what looks like maybe very
mild muscle strain injury, rather than actual muscle damage, you know, because
the two very different characteristics. So there's a few things going on there
which you kind of look at and go, well, you know, is the older person experiencing
something qualitatively different as well as quantitatively different.
Could there be any influence around susceptibility to super spinal
CNS fatigue, like even if there's the same amount of damage, same amount of
information, could that affect an older person more? Well, during a workout,
obviously, super spinal CNS fatigue is going to be mediated by the
sensations that we experience. And this is where your program template with
the longer rest periods was really interesting, because if the older person,
for example, hasn't got as well a developed cardiovascular system, then
they will be experiencing a lot of cardiovascular sensations when they
exercise. That will create super spinal CNS fatigue. And a longer
rest period is going to be very helpful for avoiding that. In the post workout
period, it really just comes down to the inflammatory process and how
how it's functioning. I don't know whether or not the inflammatory
system or the process of the older person experiences with that inflammatory
process. Are they going to experience a bigger or a smaller deficit in
motidocurment? I don't know, you know, I think that's is it's
relatively difficult to pause that. Yeah, so within this session, so obviously
mentioned from a cardiovascular standpoint, you're not familiar with anything
else that would suggest a high susceptibility to within session super spinal
CNS fatigue. So not really. I mean, again, it would come back to the
inflammatory dysregulation. I mean, ultimately, inflammation determines
not only the repair of the muscle tissue, once you've exited the
kind of the caulping process, but it also relates to how we feel,
because the inflammation is constantly going feedback to the brain.
So yeah, I mean, if the inflammatory process is creating more
super spinal fatigue during the workout, then yeah, you would see a
suppression of motidocurment from that purpose as well, which would
then mean that you would see a bigger exercise order effect, which
would then tie into what you're, well, you could get that from the
cardiovascular system as well. I mean, it doesn't have to be
information. For both the cardiovascular and the inflammatory
processes during a workout, you will see an impact on super spinal
CNS fatigue from those two things. So in the event that the older
person is finding the cardiovascular demand more challenging than
the younger person, you'll see an exercise order effect that's bigger.
So you'll find that your last few exercises of the workout are
pretty much junk, ties in perfectly with your template.
Again, you get the same thing if the inflammatory process is also
communicating more negative sensations, you'll also see the same
problem. So whether it comes from inflammation or whether it comes
from the cardiovascular system, you are going to still see a
super spinal fatigue that's bigger during the workout, whether it
happens to a greater extent or a lesser extent in the postwork
period, really depends on what the information
process is doing. And I just don't know whether that changes
meaningfully or which direction it changes in in an older
person. I just don't know that. And in terms of tolerable
perception of effort, anything to suggest that would differ?
I don't know. This is now getting into like territory because
my obviously my expertise extends to understanding how
strength training works. You kind of, as you start to push into
different populations to understand how strength training works in
different populations, you kind of understand different
characteristics of their responsiveness, for example.
But obviously there are still also factors associated with simply
being old that I'm not aware of. You know, so I'm sure there's a whole
bunch of other stuff that all people experience that, you know, I'm
just not aware of that might impact on strength training. I just
haven't, you know, come across that yet. And that's what we're saying
before the podcast. At some point, I'm just going to have to go
through the physiology of all people and, you know, get to the
bottom of everything that is relevant. But at the moment, I don't
know whether there are specific perception of effort
issues that older people, you know, kind of face.
My gut feel is that the model will still apply. It's just what you're
looking for is something that is there. You know, if you just,
yeah, if you just feel tired for some other reason, or if you
feel, you know, discomfort pain or any other sensation that is
there for any other reason, it will impact on your maximum tolerable
perception of effort. Or if it'll bring you closer to it, you know,
so I've seen, I was like, I wonder if there's just a perception of
effort just by virtue of being old. I wonder if you just, like I said,
I have to be mediated by, it would have to be mediated by a
feeling. Yeah, but if you're feeling if you're tired, like if you're
based on all the energy, slow way, you've got some muscle, exactly,
joint angles. Yes. But that would all be probably mediated
by, you know, in many cases, an inflammatory process, you know,
we have an inflammatory process that makes us, the brain detects that,
makes us feel more tired for fatigue. So yeah, anything like that is
probably going to cause those kind of issues. It's like an injury in
many ways. Yeah, basically, what we've done then is we've
walked through how adaptions are different in older people,
the compared younger people, we've explained how that then
translates to recovery is the explanation for why those adaptions
tend to be slower. And we've also, as we've gone along, you know,
tied this back to the program template that you explained at
the beginning. So let me just go back to that or a program and
explain what I think that means for training the older person.
So if we are accepting that recovery being slower is the primary
issue, but also we're aware that we're likely to see a reduced
exercise capacity during a workout and also reduced motunit
crewment during a workout, we've got a number of things to
tackle here that we want to kind of wrap up together into a
workout template. And we also want to just be aware that we
might see a bit more mechanical damage in the form of tiny
micro strains of the muscle fibers because of the loss of
distrofin and the reduced costumeric content.
We wanted to briefly touch on that for a moment longer,
just why that might then influence. Like what's the significance
of that? Because there's something there that's important,
people may not know. Sure. So basically the way muscle strain
injuries happen is by repeated micro strains over time,
bringing the failure length of a muscle fiber below physiological
range of motion. So in normal muscle and damaged muscle,
damage is not the right word in this context, but in unaffected
previously unstrained muscle, muscle fibers, the maximum strain length of
a muscle fiber is longer than your physiological range of motion.
So essentially it's physically impossible to cause the
muscle fiber to rupture because it's straining length,
it's damaged ripping length is longer than you can actually
move your joint through. So it's it's like a physical
impossibility. What happens over time, if you
repeatedly create very small micro strain by moving that
muscle fiber to a very extreme length repeatedly, you can and
then not recovering from that, you can create a failure
length that is inside of your physiological range of motion.
At which point you can then tear a muscle if you've
have enough fibers experiencing that problem. So just
briefly, if you've like, for example, there's a tendency on
various social media platforms to post videos of people
experiencing muscle strain injury, which is I think
pretty poor taste, but people do it. And everyone analyzes why is
it that that happened? And they're all kind of looking at the
exercise or they're looking at the running pattern of the
athlete on the pitch. If you see some on it, it's like a
soccer player experience say hamstring strain injury.
Everyone's then like playing on chair quarterback trying to
draw lines or trying to figure out what he was doing this at
that point. And that's why in this I know rubbish.
You know, what happened was previous to that point in time,
the activities that athlete was engaged in were creating
very small strains of the muscle fibers, which were
starting to rip customers off the fiber. That's what happens.
So the strain of the fiber starts to tear away the
customers, and then the fiber becomes much more
terrible at a shorter length. And eventually when you get inside
of the physiologic range of motion, you can tear the
muscle fiber or any length or not any length, but a
reasonably long length within your normal physiologic
range of motion. And it's all about the process of
micro straining of the fiber out that tears
customers off it. And as a result, makes the fiber much
more makes the fiber easy to tear at a shorter maximum length.
Now, as you told me that it makes me wonder when you have
enhanced athletes, obviously there's issues around
a connected tissue with with enhanced athletes anyway,
but it does make me wonder is part of where we see more
muscle injuries? Is that
potentially because these athletes tend to be doing a lot more volume and then tend
to be accumulating some of these damage. Maybe it's got nothing actually to do with
the gear itself and maybe it's to do with the training methods.
So it might be that the anabolic are creating an increase in muscle fiber size without
costumers attaching to any new muscle commands, but I don't know. I mean, ultimately, it seems
to be the loss of costumers, the tearing away of costumers that exposes the fiber to more
damage in the future in the form of mechanical damage. And as I say, old, old muscle tends
to have fewer costumers in it. So as a result, you could get to a situation where you're
more susceptible to that kind of damage, you know, in that, in that group of people.
But equally, when you have fewer costumers, you're also going to get more stretch and
strain of the sarcomers anyway, which is going to translate to more calcium-arulative
teeth as well. So you kind of get both things. Not only do you get the potential for mechanical
damage, which is analogous to a strain injury on a kind of a tiny level, but you also get
the normal kind of damage that we all get from doing strength training anyway, which is
the biochemical stuff.
So yeah, we're kind of looking at a training program. We're saying, look, we need to minimize
the amount of within session supospinal sinus fatigue. And we want to minimize the resulting
post-workout fatigue as well. Now, the interesting thing is there that, you know, and not necessarily
the same set of factors that we would, you know, kind of choose to minimize both things.
You can't, so you have to actually treat them separately. But at the same time, you're
also looking to try and increase motine equipment levels to try and access more mass fires and
create more vestimulus across the whole muscle. So you kind of got multiple things that
you're trying to do. So within the session, you know, obviously, if you're just dealing
with supospinal sinus fatigue, you'd be saying, well, there's no point in doing a lot of
sets. I want to keep my volume relatively low. I also want to keep my rep range relatively,
you know, low and use heavier loads, moderate heavy loads. Probably want to just leave
a rep in reserve here or there to avoid that, you know, kind of not only within workout,
but now this ties into them post-workouts as well. And to be fair, the volume stuff is
going to tie into post-workout. But, you know, ultimately, keep in volume relatively
low, leaving up some reserve using heavy loads. That is going to help supospinal fatigue.
It's also largely going to help post-workout fatigue as well. Also, it may be really careful
about straight position exercises, because again, that's where you're probably going to get
all your damage from. Potentially, we're going to get a bit of mechanical damage from
if that is going to be an issue with the low levels of dystrophy. You know, so the workout
plan starts to look very much like something that I would do.
I know I was thinking that actually when we're preparing for this, this episode, it's like
I isn't going to be telling you all this. Looks like my kind of program. You know, it's
just to sort of, you know, not actually that many exercises per session, maybe, you know,
like full body, but maybe only eight exercises, you know, and actually full body AB and alternating
between more contract and more stretch position exercises. And people go, "Oh, you're not
getting them maximum benefit." No, I know I'm not, but I'm only doing my stretch position
exercises one and a half times a week, which is actually a great benefit, because I get
a lot less muscle damage. And I'm running lower risk of these, kind of, this potential
for micro strains creating a, you know, a loss of costumers, you know. So I think it's
not massively dissimilar from how I would program Gen Pop. It just slightly fewer exercises,
longer rest periods, a little bit less kind of focus on maximizing hypertrophy and a little
bit more focus on minimizing muscle damage across the week. I mean, it's all the same things
that would normally consider it. Yeah, totally, totally. It's just, just, just,
a little more tips. A bit further away from optimizing stimulus. And a little bit more towards
avoiding excessive post workout damage. And also, just taking a bit more care in the workout
itself to keep rest periods longer, avoid doing excessive volume or proximalism to failure
or anything like that. And but of course, equally, something that would not be in my program
because it just isn't necessary would be, you know, something that is like designed
to increase recruitment. Now, in the template that you explained, this was a speed movement.
I actually prefer isometrics. I think that is a much more elegant and easy way of doing
it for most people most of the time, as I say, just doesn't feature in my programming
because of my athletic background. It's just not, not needed. But for people who are perhaps,
you know, coming into strength training later in life, I definitely think that it makes
a lot of sense. Do you know what would be an interesting idea here? And I don't know if
this would work, but I think it would be fairly close would be you mentioned having length
and position exercises on one of those two workouts. And I think that's something that
for some muscles, I'm conscious about that when I'm programming, but I think in all
honesty, I feel like a lot of people are able to recover from some length and positions
within two days usually. But this is a situation where you'd be more conscious of it. But given
the benefit of the isometrics here, potentially having like an isometric focus workout on
one of those days, where you're using more mid-bus shortened positions and then having
that length and position day on the other workout. So you're getting the motor unit recruitment
benefits from the isometrics, you're reducing damage, but you're not sort of impeding
another capability within that next 48 hour period that could be an interesting template
to play with. Yeah, I mean, I think that would probably require a specific mindset, because
I mean, a lot of the time within the context of talking about all this stuff, we have to
recognize that people are still people and it really helps them to see progressive overload
happening over time. And that's why I really love isometrics for the motor unit recruitment
benefits. But unless you've got a load cell that tells you what the number is when you're
doing the isometric, I'm not a fan of them for strength training programming because they
don't tell you that you're making any progress. So I really like the physiological side of
it. And so I would do it just as a warm up. I would be like, let's do two or three isometrics,
different ones. And remember, if your goal is to increase recruitment with an isometric,
you don't need to worry about frequency. This is the thing that people paint me as the frequency
guy. But reality is, it's only frequency if it's an adaption that disappears by the time you've
got home from the gym, you know. And that option doesn't mean that you can't be achieving
multiple adaptions with that thing, right? Not at all. No, you can, absolutely. But in the
model that I would start with, my template for all the people would not be using isometrics
five-perch, I would use it just for the motor unit recruitment benefits. And there's actually
a subtlety there that I think is worth drawing out because if you start to use isometrics,
this is the same idea as I talked about this a long time ago. If you go to the gym and you've
traditionally been doing three sets of an exercise and I ask you instead, for the next two weeks,
to only do single sets, I guarantee you will blow your numbers out the water because people go to the
gym and they do three sets. And even though they're trained to failure on the first set, it's not.
What it is, and it isn't. I mean technically it is, as I've always said, to failure is task failure
when you reach task failure. But it's not the number of reps that you could do if I said to only
do one set, don't do three. That's absolutely true. And I see that like literally all the time
in my groups all the time. I say it with myself when I started doing single sets or so.
And that's a someone who, when I actually found that it was me that it affected as well
as other people, I was like, okay, this is real. 100%. That's it. Yeah, because I would always
take sets to failure. Multiple sets, I would take every set to failure and then something being
single sets and I'm seeing my number is like, I'm always double-checking my number. Yeah, jump up,
I want a two reps. Some people listening to us don't believe us, right? Just try it. If you've
been doing like three sets, four sets, five sets, whatever for an exercise. Next time you go in,
just do one and try and like just annihilate your first set numbers that you would normally get.
Absolutely guarantee that unless you are really, really good at a particular exercise, the chances are
you will absolutely annihilate your numbers. It's just absolutely remarkable how big the effect is.
But I think some people should know with that though, is that progress does not stay consistently, because
sometimes I get people contact me and they'll be like, oh, I was progressing so well. I started doing
single sets at first few weeks, like numbers were blowing around the water and now I've hit a wall.
It's like, no, what's happened now is this is like ultimately your true rate of progression and
muscle growth and you need to adjust that expectation. And I think at some point we need to
do a podcast on this about, I guess, rate of progression or progressive methods or stuff like that.
One of the biggest mistakes I see people making is having when they start doing what I would say is
an intelligently designed program, whether not changing exercises all the time, they have actually
a high frequency of exercises, they quote unquote, hit a wall within six weeks, eight weeks and they
think they're not progressing because they're used to progressing so much quicker because of these
neural adaptions and things that are not true muscle growth in the past.
Totally, totally. Yeah, absolutely. No, I mean, when things start to grind to a halt, that's
a great sign. That's the indication that you're now only achieving hypertrophy driven progressive
overload, really, mostly, mostly, mostly hypertrophy. But I argue that the same thing is applicable
to the isometric training situation. So if you want to use the isometric, trigger an increase
in protein and accruement, use it for that purpose because if you try and use it for hypertrophy purposes,
your first set will not be a maximum effort anymore, not in a true maximum recruitment sense.
So if you just got one max effort, isometric to do, then yeah, you'll probably give it a really
good shot of triggering an increase in recruitment. If I give you three, five sets of isometric to do,
bearing the number of motines that you're recruiting and comes flying right down,
yes, it works by hypertrophy. It probably doesn't work that well for increasing recruitment anymore.
So given that my purpose for using those would always be a recruitment stimulus,
I don't like also using them by hypertrophy in the context of the same workout. I would always
kind of treat those two things up.
Does that make sense?
- Yeah, it's interesting, interesting point.
And presumably then in that situation,
when you are using it for motor unit recruitment,
then you could also employ an internal focus of attention
as well.
- Yeah, you could, you could.
Because that would, I would really send activation
to the location that you're kind of trying to activate
and trigger the adoption more effectively.
I'm hesitating because when I do them,
it kind of feels like, like a life or death experience.
- Yeah, I think it would be exercise dependent.
I'm thinking because sometimes I do it for bicep curls.
And that will be a situation where that would work quite well.
But I can understand there might be some exercise
where maybe it wouldn't work as well.
- Yeah, I mean, like when I do it when I'm trying to
pull something apart, it doesn't feel like my brain
has the ability to activate the muscle deliberately.
It feels like it's trying to pull the thing apart.
I'm trying to pull apart.
It tends to be quite task focused, which is external.
But, you know, yeah.
I mean, I think there are muscles,
especially single joint stuff.
I think when you pull something apart or push something,
the brain naturally tends to tilt towards goal-orientated
behaviors, just maybe out of habit.
But with single muscle, yeah, I think you probably could do
that absolutely.
- So if someone were to use isometric single set,
let's say a five to 10 second,
that would be enough to see those motivated recruitment.
- I would probably even keep it to five, really.
I would say keep it to five.
I mean, I notice a drop off between three and five, actually.
So I think a lot of people with athletic experience
do tend to peak earlier in the sort of the three,
five second zone.
I get a extremely negative sensation
if I try and hold more than four or five seconds.
I start to dial back on my recruitment levels
because my perceptions of effort
coming from other stuff is starting to rise.
So I would say that if you try to increase recruitment,
they're on the shorter side of the isometric
rather than the longer side.
- And that's enough to see any increase there.
Because again, sometimes it's getting worse.
- Yeah, these things like obviously,
if we look at this, then you've got this model,
we might assume that someone might need
three or four or five stimulating reps to see hypertrophy,
but things like moating into recruitment
is not the same.
You don't need multiple bounds to get that adoption.
You just kind of need it in that one moment in time.
- You need to hit your threshold.
That's it. - Yeah.
- Now, that's the cool thing about it.
You really don't need to go mad at all
with the amount of repetitions you can just focus on the quality.
And like you said before, you could actually rotate that
so you could do a couple maybe two exercises,
one exercise, whatever you want. - Because it's not lost.
Exactly, because there's no frequency issue here.
So you can literally do, like you could literally say,
I'm going to do a bit of hamstring kind of isometric.
This week, I do some quads, foreign week,
I do some cars, I do some biceps triceps.
You could literally spend three months rotating
through different exercises if you wanted to.
And then just start again.
You don't have to do these things all the time
because it's not an option that detrains, not really.
So honestly, I wouldn't, and actually from my experience,
'cause I have done some of this stuff
and I know if you do it properly,
it's actually mentally quite tiring.
You wouldn't want to do a lot of it.
Maybe this, I know there's some TikTok kids
doing some crazy stuff with this.
But for me, and I regard myself as a reasonably
better template for all the people,
then I would say what am I doing?
I wouldn't want to say to the other person,
oh, we're going to do a max effort isometric
for every single muscle of the body.
And then we're going to do an almost, no, don't do that.
It's not necessary because you don't need
to do every single muscle all the time,
because you don't have that frequency problem.
And similarly, it's just going to prejudice
the rest of the training session,
because it's just going to end up being a training session
in and of itself, but one that doesn't really
get you the hypertrophy that you want.
So I would just pick one or two isometrics each workout.
I'm just rotating them.
I wouldn't go crazy with lots and lots of isometrics
in this situation.
Okay, fine, you know, I'm not, and I've said before,
when people pick up the physiology that I've explained
and start to go in interesting directions,
I'm all for that.
I support them, fantastic.
I know that other people think that some of the things
that they're coming out of the TikTok scene
are absolutely crazy,
but the point is that they're at least starting
from physiology and trying to explore different directions
and what they can do, that's creative,
that's exciting, that's interesting,
and I'm all for that.
But just in the context of what we're talking about today,
which is how would you kind of construct a training program
for muscle mass increases and older people?
I think that I would limit the amount
of max-effortisometrics I did to probably
one or two per training session.
Are there any other methods you think would be beneficial here?
Like one thing I'm thinking here would be given
the most susceptibility to within session
super spinal CNS fatigue,
given the lower motor unit recruitment,
potentially more single joint staff,
or maybe in a machine exercise,
as exercises where people using smaller amounts
of muscle mass or even unilateral exercises,
potentially they could have benefit.
So all the normal rules apply, absolutely.
So everything applies as we would normally do.
The issue is, of course, that when you start doing
single joint, single limb, anything like that,
you're now incorporating the requirement
for more exercises in totality.
So the reality is I would probably want to just try
and find an equilibrium point,
and I would probably personally
on the machine exercises to obviously maximize
the stability problems,
but I would probably err on the multi-joint stuff,
just because I don't want to give an old person
a list of exercises, you know, so this long,
I'd rather give them a more condensed list
that covers all the bases,
and okay, there's some compromises there,
but at the end of the day,
we get them in and out the gym in a sensible period of time.
So I, even though you're absolutely right,
the single joint, single limb stuff
would give you the recruitment benefits.
I think you would start to see the tail-off
towards the end of the workout
with just the volume of stuff that you were trying to cram in.
- One thing I, my experience personally
is that that works better for me as well.
- What do I use occasionally in my programming is,
and a lot of people, again, think I'm making a mistake,
if I'm a frequency standpoint,
I might program a unilateral exercise on workout,
and then in the next workout,
I might give you different unilateral exercise
and do that one bilaterally.
And so yes, there's gonna be some muscle fibres
that might not be recruited in that bilateral version,
but I'm using that unilateral for some
of that multi-unit recruitment as well.
So that potentially could be one way of doing it
where, you know, maybe every other,
so workout A, if you other workout A,
you might do one exercise unilaterally,
and then on the other one,
you might do a different one unilaterally.
They could be some creative ways
that people could do some of that.
- Totally, and you're just kind of doing,
you're kind of doing the isometric job for you.
- Exactly, exactly.
- I'm taking unilateral instead of isometric, exactly.
- Yeah.
- So it kind of, you end up in about the same number
of things that you're getting done,
and you've just done it in a slightly different way.
- Yeah.
And some people may find isometric's more enjoyable,
or unilateral training more enjoyable.
Like I know, you know, I've got some clients
where I'm never gonna give them isometric
'cause I did it once and they hated it.
So I'm not doing that, I'm in that category.
It affects me mentally.
I literally feel like I'm gonna rip off my body off.
That's kind of what I experience when I do an isometric.
- It's quite mentally demanding for me.
I mean, I've done it.
- And you've got an idea.
- And obviously though,
'cause I remember when I used to be in the gym,
I'd have clients where I'd give them isometric,
so I just knew that they were not applying themselves
'cause they didn't enjoy it, so they wouldn't.
And so you've got people on both ends
and the fence where you, it's destroying your soul,
and then other people wouldn't work that.
- Just trying my soul.
It definitely feels pretty life or death if I do.
But the issue is, it's about matching the strategy
to the person.
I think there's a number of ways of getting to the same answer.
It's just what suits the person in their scenario.
So, but the point is to try and drive recruitment levels up
because in the older population,
they do tend to be quite suppressed.
And that then means that we've got to.
But incidentally, and this ties into perhaps,
we can kind of raise this topic
because I get this question a lot,
which is if an older person has spent their life
doing strength training, how does that then change
how they respond to a strength training person?
Do they, are they just like a younger person
or are they just like an older person?
Is untrained or they something completely different entirely?
Well, stick around and I'll tell you
because I'm in that category.
So if you just keep listening to the podcast
over the next five years, you'll find out
'cause I'm older than I actually look.
So there's some interesting kind of possibilities there.
Anyway, the thing that I think we can say at the moment
is that obviously the older person
who is a lifetime strength training,
kind of participant, they're sort of unlikely
to have the most unit of recruitment deficits
that a sedentary older person would have,
at least perhaps until they get to very old territory.
So for most of their kind of 60s, maybe 70s,
they're likely to still have pretty high levels
of recruitment in my opinion.
But I don't think they're going to get around
the slow recovery rates problem.
I think that the slow recovery problem
is probably something that is age-specific,
not training history pursuits.
So I think actually if you were to,
and I'm maybe leaning too hard
into my own personal experience here,
but I think you'll probably find that the group
of people who are old but also lifetime strength trained
are probably going to be the most susceptible to
the muscle damage problem that you can find.
I think that group of people is going to be people
who have high recruitment,
but also all of the same recovery problems
that the older person has.
Now, some of it will be tapered by the fact
that I have a ton of customers already in place,
and that does protect them to a certain extent.
But I think that the suppressed information response
or the dysregulated information response
coupled with the high level of recruitment
is probably going to give you the worst of both worlds.
Not trying to, you know, kind of be too much of a doomer,
but I do think that, you know,
[BLANK_AUDIO]
people go, "Oh, no, no, no, no, no, I won't have the problem of aging with strength training
because I've trained my whole life." I actually think you're going to have the bigger problem because
you're going to have better access to high threshold motor units, but you're going to have all the
problems of dysregulated inflammation that old people normally have anyway. And that certainly
plays into my experience, which isn't my recovery is just tanked, since I kind of got into that
sort of within shouting distance of that particular milestone.
So maybe let's conclude with this, someone, because we've kind of given a template there for
someone who maybe is older coming into strength training. So let's say you have an individual who
is getting to that age where they're feeling like they're not performing as well as they were,
they're not recovering as well as they were. So what might they look at adjusting,
you know, not compromise their kind of, I guess you're also moving forwards. You know, obviously,
I guess it's sort of just incrementally making some of the changes we've talked about so far,
but, you know, one thing might be that, hey, maybe you don't need to jump down to a single
set immediately. If you're used to doing three sets every other day, maybe you just jump down
to two sets. And you say that if your performance increases and recovering increases from that,
or, you know, maybe it's reducing repetitions one or two per set or keeping one more repetition
in your deserve, or, you know, my personal, like my one-on-one clients, I don't have that many older
clients, but sometimes I have some kind of getting to that maybe 60, 65 mark. And generally,
what I'll do with them is just add one extra recovery day between those sessions. So instead of
two rest days, we're just going to add a third rest day. And maybe I'll try, first of all,
reducing down a set, but if that doesn't do the job, then I'm just going to push those workouts
out one extra day. These would be kind of some of the tools I guess people could look at using.
Is anything else you would add to that? No, exactly right. I think really it's a match of starting
with a template that you've developed over your life that you're happy with. And then gradually
just very slowly, dialing back a little bit of volume, a little bit of proximity to failure.
So you might take a set off here or there, take a rep off at your normal, like sort of reps and
reserve, do a little bit further away from very. And then eventually you're going to find that
you have to start messing with frequency as well. So you might have to go from, as you're saying,
training every other day to train three times a week or training two and a half times a week or
whatever it is. You start to mess around with that. Maybe even you end up with twice a week.
I think that you can, unless you are really, really kind of genetic outlier, you probably
always going to be able to train twice a week with, um, the kind of full body single sets,
a rep and reserve, you know, I think don't think you're going to get to a point where that becomes
impossible to recover from personally had any clients where that's not been achievable.
Yeah, I mean, the older I get, the more extreme I seem to think my physiology is. I think I'm
really very much up against it in terms of recovery capacities. And I'm still fine three
times a week, single sets, even to failure. But I think I probably will gradually start it,
have to leave a rep and reserve here or there. Maybe start to move towards strategies like,
well, even, you know, like sort of full body AB, you know, you are moving the time as you're around
a bit, moving yourself a bit more recovery past. So that, I really like that. That immediately
takes all the pressure off me if I do that. But I can see a scenario within five, ten years,
I will be training twice a week. I don't think I'll be able to train three times a week forever.
I just, I just don't respond like that. It recovery is an issue for me. But yeah, I think
gradually just about identifying specific factors in the workout that are creating post-progaptive
and just figuring out the least bad option in any given moment. So for me, yeah, volume would be
the first thing that I reduced. Then it would be proximate to failure. And then it would be maybe
like exercise selection. And then finally, it would be frequency. I really would pump frequency
as far as possible, you know, because as soon as you start reducing frequency, you've got all kinds
of other issues to deal with. Okay. Hopefully for all the 65 to 80-old listeners, there was an
enjoyable podcast to hear that yeah, I just got to get old. This is true. I just bookmarked this,
say this for the next year. Anyway, guys, hopefully that was, I mean, especially for coaches,
a lot of people listen to this eye coaches, there are people working with older lifters and older
clients. So hopefully that was helpful for you guys. Otherwise, like you said, if not book markets
save it for when you do get old. Thank you guys, joining us and I hope you'll join us again next week.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Older individuals experience slower recovery and increased post-workout fatigue, not inherently reduced muscle adaptation sensitivity.
The silver era recommended lower repetitions, fewer sets, longer rest periods, and occasional speed/power exercises to align with slower recovery.
Maintenance studies show older adults maintain muscle mass with low volume (e.g., one set per week), indicating that reduced adaptation is due to poor recovery, not weaker stimulus.
Reduced motor unit recruitment and tendon stiffness changes in older adults are offset by slower adaptation rates, but not universally—some adaptations (like tendon stiffness) progress at the same rate.
Older people face higher risk of micro-mechanical damage in muscle fibers due to loss of dystrophin, leading to increased strain susceptibility.
Training programs for older adults should prioritize low volume, moderate-heavy loads, and longer rest periods to minimize fatigue and damage.
Speed or power training is beneficial for sedentary older adults due to deficits in movement speed, but less relevant for active or master’s athletes.
Recovery limitations stem from cardiovascular inefficiency and inflammatory dysregulation, not intrinsic muscle sensitivity, explaining the need for reduced volume and rest.
Summary:
The discussion explores how aging affects strength training adaptations, challenging the common assumption that older individuals grow more slowly due to reduced stimulus sensitivity. Instead, research shows that slower adaptation is primarily due to impaired recovery—older people take longer to recover between workouts, leading to accumulated fatigue and diminished performance. Key evidence comes from maintenance studies, where older adults maintain muscle mass at low volumes, indicating that the stimulus isn’t weaker, just less effectively recovered.
This shifts the focus from increasing volume to optimizing recovery through fewer sets, moderate-heavy loads, and longer rest periods. The silver era’s recommendations—such as lower reps, one-set routines, and longer rest—align well with this physiology. Additionally, older adults face increased risk of micro-mechanical damage due to reduced dystrophin levels, making extreme range-of-motion movements risky.
While speed training helps sedentary older adults improve daily function, it’s less critical for active or athletic individuals. The overall program design emphasizes minimizing fatigue and muscle damage over maximizing hypertrophy, using balanced, low-volume routines with occasional power or isometric exercises to boost motor unit activation. This approach is not only safe but also sustainable over time, especially for those aging into strength training.
Ultimately, the core insight is that age-related performance decline is not due to biological insensitivity to training, but to recovery limitations—making recovery strategies far more important than volume or intensity adjustments.
FAQs
As people age, they experience slower rates of hypertrophy and sarcomargenesis, reduced motor unit recruitment, and decreased tendon stiffness that develops more slowly. However, adaptations like tendon stiffness and fiber type shifting occur at similar rates in older and younger people, suggesting that reduced recovery, not intrinsic sensitivity to stimuli, is the main factor limiting progress.
Older adults do not have inherently lower sensitivity to mechanical tension. Instead, their slower strength gains are primarily due to reduced recovery between workouts, leading to accumulated fatigue. This fatigue suppresses anabolic signaling, making it harder to achieve the same adaptation levels seen in younger individuals.
Older adults should use fewer sets—typically one to three per muscle group—and lower repetition ranges (e.g., 7–8 reps) to reduce post-workout fatigue and allow for better recovery. This aligns with historical recommendations from figures like the founder of Iron Man magazine.
Longer rest periods between sets are essential for older adults to recover fully, especially due to slower cardiovascular and inflammatory responses. This helps prevent accumulated fatigue and supports better performance and recovery during subsequent workouts.
Yes, occasional speed or power exercises can improve motor unit activation and functional performance in sedentary older adults. However, this benefit is most noticeable in individuals with low activity levels, not in active master’s athletes who already have high functional capacity.
Reduced dystrophin in aging muscles increases susceptibility to mechanical damage from micro-strains, as muscle fibers become more vulnerable to stretching. This can contribute to long-term muscle damage and a higher risk of strain injuries over time.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.