Go back

018 Pauses, Stretching, and Partials

from Hypertrophy Past and Present

1h 24m 21s

018 Pauses, Stretching, and Partials

Reg Park’s 1952 calf specialization program offers a fascinating glimpse into early bodybuilding methodology, predating modern science with practical, equipment-limited training strategies. The program features exercises like donkey raises, heel-and-toe walks, and knee-forward lunges, designed to train both gastrocnemius and soleus through varied mechanics. A key insight is that pauses are used strategically: in seated calf raises, holds at the top exploit soleus’s optimal leverage, while in straight-leg raises, the pause occurs at the end because the exercise is hardest at the top—aligning with biomechanics rather than random repetition. The routines reflect a deep understanding of muscle leverage and resistance profiles, even without modern data. Notably, the use of high reps and partner-assisted movements (like donkey raises) highlights how practical constraints shaped effective training. While mind-muscle connection exercises like concentration toe presses are included, their physiological value remains unclear. Modern analysis shows that partial ranges of motion are more effective and standardized than isolated pauses for targeted muscle growth, as they align better with muscle leverage and reduce fatigue interference. Ultimately, Park’s approach demonstrates that effective muscle development can emerge from ingenuity and experience, even without access to current scientific knowledge. This historical program remains relevant as it underscores timeless principles of training efficiency, equipment adaptation, and biomechanical alignment.

Transcription

17616 Words, 96915 Characters

English
Welcome back everyone to another episode of high-purchwe past and present. Chris, how are you doing today? I'm doing very well thanks to you. I'm also doing well, but I'm a little bit sick. Well, I'm actually feeling fairly good. I've just lost my voice a little bit. So if I sound a little bit off today, that's why I do apologize ahead of time. But hopefully my voice does hold out. Now, let's jump straight into it. I've got eight. Well, let me take a step back for a moment. I'm ongoing the lemma. The people have struggled with forever is how to build their cars. And I still see this online today. People talk about is it genetic? Is it not genetic? Do you need to do something special? What do you do about it? How do you do it? Is it and what I find very entertaining about this topic is the same conversations that being had almost a century ago. There was like very early on when the silver era when you had these authors regarding courses and plans and books and all these kind of things, there were books dedicated to how to build your cars. There were whole specialization courses on how to build your cars. What can you do? They were speculating. There was magazines about it. There were all kinds of funny things being postulated. Is it to do with what kind of activities you did when you were a child? Maybe if you did more cycling, maybe you were able to develop the calf better as an adult. There's all these funny speculations. So it is a bit of a funny muscle just in terms of some people's ability. I guess you naturally would be able to build and develop good cars or not. And I thought what I give you guys today is an early calf specialization phase. So this comes from Reg Park who I thought we'd actually talked about quite a lot but I went back over our notes and we've only actually done one of his courses so far. So there will be more Reg coming up in the future. I'm sure but I assume most of you will be familiar with the name and you probably know Reg for his five by five system. I think we talked a little bit about some of that previously but obviously Reg multi missed the universe winner Mr. America winner. He did come back and compete later on as well. So he was a mentor to Arnold. So he kind of previously in another episode we talked about C Klein and we're talking about C sort of sat in this middle ground between the bronze and the silver. I would say Reg sort of is on the opposite end. So Reg kind of sat I mean he was classic silver but then when he came back he sort of stradled this minute between silver and golden era. So some of his later stuff was kind of more golden era style and he was competing in the sort of sick butt. His early stuff we're talking early 50s. This book that I'm talking about today was published in 1952 I believe and he was winning universes in 1951 onwards. So yeah kind of spanned a decent decent era. Now like I said we know Reg is five by five system we also know Reg because he was the first body builder to ever bench 500 pounds and this was before antibiotics were being used by your uncle. It was it was actually the same year the York later started using antibiotics. So there's no reason to believe that I mean there's no reason to believe that Reg was ever enhanced necessarily we don't have evidence of that but certainly for these early competitions and early achievements it would seem quite unlikely. So he's a very accomplished body builder. Most people I sort of know in the space would say probably Reg is Steve Reeves would be the two in that sort of early 50s period that arguably it may be the best developed silver everybody builders and Reg yeah I mean I don't know if he was a marketing inclined entrepreneurial type person or what but he was quite prolific with their courses and the work out programs that he published. So that makes my life a little bit easier. It's nice to be able to have some of this stuff recorded because obviously it's you know a lot of the stuff we're referring to is letters and magazine articles are hard to find but Reg did publish quite a lot. So Reg is calf specialization phase and obviously he's not saying you should do this you know in lieu of other workouts like he's saying you do this with your full body stuff okay so you've got a muscle you want to focus on you add it to your full body routine okay so yeah there's you know whether you're doing a five by five or whatever this is going to be while you're adding in. Now some of these exercises you guys won't know some of them don't even have very intuitive names but I will just do my best to explain what they entail. Now first up we do have one that you will know is a donkey raise. So this I would say this is probably popularized by Arnold and I don't know Arnold maybe got it off your edge and this usually involved people sitting on your back and you leaning forwards holding onto some kind of handle apparatus bar whatever and doing essentially a like a straight leg calf raise just in a sort of bent over standing position. Now Reg did suggest doing once with your toes pointed out one set with your toes pointing forwards and then one set with your toes pointing in and this was fairly common advice this is generally in the Silvia how this exercise was being performed. Now we did suggest 15 to 25 repetitions again you were generally using human body weight for this exercise you had one to two people on your back so that may be influenced this and he suggested holding the last repetition in the top position so doing an isometric hold or pause in the top arm part of that final repetition then removed into a seated calf raise and again one set with toes pointed out one set with toes pointing forwards and one set with toes pointing in and similar repetitions 15 up to about 30 and here he actually said hold each repetition for pause in the top position not just the final one. So interesting there's a bit of a distinction here. Now the next exercise this was one I believe was popularized by Alan Steven who we've talked about a couple of times and I've never seen anyone do this in the gym it might be a funny one to bring back basically I think they called it heel and toe walk maybe there are some other names for it as well but essentially you would load up a barbell with your knees locked out you would walk up and down the gym floor like walking stepping onto your heel and raising up onto your toe without bending your knees so I gave this a little bit of a go without a barbell last night just to see what it felt like and I did get a bit of a cramp in my calves but I've not tried this loaded and he did recommend two two I don't know what you call stints of this then he moved into a standing toe raise with heels elevated on a block so imagine so heels elevated you got a wooden block or something behind you and then so your your weight is three heel and what you're doing you're pulling your toes up so not a a calf exercise per say now this was unloaded it was just body weights yeah probably not much more to say about that and he did recommend three sets of that and again 15 plus repetitions and then we've got one which I've certainly never seen in the gym this is involved in iron boot I think we've referred to an iron boot before it's exactly what it sounds like you put on your foot and it's heavy and he called it foot extensions and contractions with the with an iron boot so you put it on you would have one leg sort of crust over your other leg um like suspended in the air and essentially you're just kind of what you say just rotating the foot essentially back and forth with his boot on until until you can't move it any further anymore so that's yeah that's a entertaining little exercise and well almost done then we've got a knee forward lunge position so you're imagining you're doing a almost like a split squat like a front foot elevated split squat styles you're pushing quite far forwards and then with that front foot you're starting at a flat position and you're just coming up on the toes you're doing your calf raise just without one foot at a time which is an interesting creative way of doing a single leg calf raise in you know limited equipment context and that was unloaded obviously it's going to be body weight in that position and he just suggested basically doing his many repetitions as you can and then the final exercise and this was a little bit more optional and he didn't know that this was quite a difficult one and that some people had to persist with it for a while to get the hang of it but he he was he did assert that if you did do it it would certainly pay off and he also said look you don't need it all the time maybe you do it once a week you know it's sort of a little bit more optional you know frequency is not as important but he called it concentration toe press now you can have to use your imagination you're sitting down in essentially like a seated calf raise position but your feet are flat on the floor no load nothing and without elevating any part of your foot you're pushing your foot through the floor almost like you're trying to to grab the floor with your toes and you're using he didn't have the language of mind muscle connection but essentially you're trying to create this mind muscle connection in this in this sort of movement and he actually so you know we we've talked about muscle control that was a thing back in the day reds actually called it he called it mental contraction he said mental contraction is better than calling it muscle control I don't know why that is perhaps he was just differentiating himself but it was a yeah a mind muscle control connection isometric type exercise so there's quite a lot there quite a few unique things I'm interested to hear your thoughts or some of this yes quite a few things to pick out really so starting with a macro view kind of looking at everything that's there it's interesting that we've got both straight leg exercises and also bent knee exercises because as we know from the data been collected since that point tend to get a lot more gastroc involvement in the straight leg calf raise exercises and you get a lot more solius in the in the cedar versions and I think here just kind of looking through them I think the idonky raise is going to be straight leg these obviously cedar there's going to be bent leg the heel and toe walk is going to be straight leg a standing toe raise is I think a dorsiflexion exercise really rather than plantar flexion yeah foot extensions and contractions I think is both plantar flexion and dorsiflexion depending on the angle of the foot or whatever, however that's done. The knee forward lunch position is really interesting because I think from memory, from the picture that you showed me before we jumped on this podcast to do this, I think that basically puts it in a very similar position to the seated car phrase. Yeah. But as you say, it's a single leg variation and potentially that allows a little bit more loading because, you know, we are seeing very high reps here and that is almost certainly because of the limitations of the equipment that's available. I mean, we're using barbells and whatever load or boots they can kind of conjure up. So, you know, it's an interesting way of just increasing the load in that particular exercise. So macro view, you know, I'm seeing both straight leg and leg car phrase exercises, which is exactly what we would start. Second level down, I'm seeing again, exercises targeting both lateral and medial gastroc by pointing the feet in different directions. So again, that's something that we would look at if we were looking for maximal, you know, kind of cough development. So, you know, two of the things that I would have on my list because of the physiology and biomechanics date that we've got access to, we're already on their list. Now, there are things that are on my list are not here, but you know, that's, you know, potentially something we can talk about later on today. You know, straight away, I think that's, I think that's starting out really strong as a cough specialization routine, not having access to the information that we've already, that we've since collected. So, I think that's, we need to start by recognizing just how good it is, no, despite the limitations of equipment, despite the inability to have access to the date that we've got. So, you know, straight away, I think it's really, really nice to see just how well they managed to construct this kind of program without having access to the information. In terms of slightly more strange bits and pieces, really, I think it's interesting that they're looking at training antagonist muscles as well. I mean, I think that's, that's a really interesting point. And I think that's one of those things that I would love to have more data on. You know, I mean, is there a point at which you start to run into difficulty if you continually train a muscle on one side of a joint? You don't do anything for the antagonist. I just don't know the answer to that question. I mean, of course, there's going to be people with strong opinions about that, but genuinely don't know the answer to that question. And then the final thing, obviously, is then this idea of, you know, is it to mind muscle connection? Is it something else that he's doing, you know, trying to create some kind of benefit by doing this, this ritual or this routine or this practice that he's got, you know, once a week or whatever that he's doing, by trying to, you know, kind of connect mentally with his calf muscles. And I don't know what he's doing there. I mean, as, you know, we talked a little bit about this before we started today. You know, I don't know whether that's a mind muscle connection, whether it's he's trying to do something else, whether he's practicing, whether he's mentally doing the contraction in his mind. And that's having some kind of practice effect, because we do see that data available. There's some interesting effects of that, but I can't see how it would particularly assist my surgery process. Yeah, I mean, into an opportunity to comment on that one. So, period radar, who we've talked about before, period has a car specialization course as well. Maybe we'll talk about that in the future. But he's a little bit more abbreviated. And he doesn't do this concentration exercise. He instead recommends posing. And I wonder if in his mind, it's like if they're both trying to achieve the same outcome with that. Yeah, I mean, I think that's a really interesting point. You know, I mean, if it is a internal folks' attention idea, then it could be that they're using it as a strategy to try and increase motina equipment, because it does tend to increase motina equipment. And the calves do have a voluntary activation deficit. So that is an interesting possibility, because obviously the more access we've got to high facial motina, it's the more capacitive, you've got hypertrophy. I think it's a very plausible idea. I just, from the description, it's not obvious that that is, in fact, what he's doing. So, and also there are a number of other ways to increase motina equipment. You don't need to use a internal focus attention. You can do it through other methods as well. So again, that becomes a little bit more vague. And I don't want to hijack today by going down that route, because I've got other things I'd prefer to focus on. So, but yeah, no, I mean, just going back to my initial comments, I really like what they've done here, what he's done here, did here. I think, you know, it's always, you know, both gratifying and surprising at the same time to see how these guys were producing routines that are very, very similar to what we would produce today based on an entirely different collection of information. Yeah. The donkey raise, I don't think I showed you that. I'll just quickly mention, he didn't call that a donkey raise, by the way. He called it a toe raised with a partner. It later became known as a donkey raise. The photo is the same. In the image where he describes how to do it, he does in fact have someone sitting on his back like that is how you would do this. And I actually did this exercise on your couple days ago. One of the gyms I frequent has a donkey raise machine. And I think I had 160 ish kilos on there, maybe a little bit more. And I still doing relatively high repetitions with it. And you just can't really get much more on the machine. So, you know, I often see these kind of recommendations. And I think, of course, you have to do 20 repetitions, of course. You know, if you have many people, you know, you're going to have a village of people on your back like you just can't do this. And imagine you're riding a course like this, and telling people do five to 10 repetitions on these exercises, like you would have no confidence that that person is going to go get four mates to go sit in the back. They're not going to have one person there, one training partner. And they'll do five repetitions with one training partner when they could be doing 20. So, I think I don't know if that's what their thought pattern was, but surely that necessity informed some of these repetitions that they were using. Yeah, I mean, that makes perfect sense, I think. And, you know, maybe that's one of the reasons why gradually over time people came to believe that calf training required these high repetitions. I mean, that kind of sequence of events has repeated throughout human history. I mean, somebody starts doing something for practical reason. And then a couple of generations later, and everyone's like, well, if you don't do it like that, it won't work. And it's like, well, they started doing it like that for these practical reasons. They had nothing to do with the fact that it doesn't work in any other way. And I think that that could be a really interesting explanation for why we see that tendency for people to keep doing a high rep calf work today. I did have a question for you. I don't know if you have any thoughts on this. In the first exercises, the donkey race or the stiff leg, he was, he didn't do an isometric hold in each of the repetitions, but then in a seated calf race, he did one for each repetition in the top position. Do you have any thoughts on that? Yeah, that's, I mean, that's a really interesting point, and it actually segues into the top of that I'd like to talk about today. So let's, let's just kind of work through what's going on here. So if we look at the seated calf race, the purpose of training the seated calf race is to train the soleus. And the soleus has best leverage in the contract position. So essentially, if you're doing a pause at the top of every single rep in your seated calf race, which is as program, then what you're doing is just spending more time in the exact zone where the soleus has leverage, which is the muscle you're training. So it actually makes a lot of sense to do that. You basically spend your time in the zone where the muscle that you're training has the best leverage. Now, if we look in contrast at the purpose of a straight leg calf race, like a donkey kind of calf race, that situation is different because we're trying to train the gastroc and the gastroc has the best leverage in the straight position. We don't want to be spending most of our time in the contract position as counterproductive to the purpose of the exercise. And that, again, fits perfectly with what we're seeing here. They're only doing that pause at the very very end of the set. Why would they do a pause at the very end of the set? Well, for the same reasons that we've been talking about the high repetition work, it's because basically just given the fact that the calf race has a resistance profile, which makes it hardest at the top, you're going to fail at the top. You're going to fail at the top, because that's where the exercises are. So if you are doing your pause at the top, that's telling you kind of when you fail the exercise, because ultimately, you, I mean, if you did pauses in other positions, you wouldn't be really getting anywhere. I wouldn't do anything. So it kind of like, I think really what they're doing there is they're doing, maybe they're using a 30 rep max, but they're doing 25 reps or, you know, they're all there about. And they're kind of doing that pause at the very very end of their 25 reps, and it just kind of brings them over to the 30th rep, because they're kind of in that zone where it's, it's failing. And I think really for me, when I look at the two descriptions, and I understand the resistance profiles of the two exercises and the leverages, what I'm seeing in the case of the seated calf race and the pauses there, that pauses designed to target the muscle, because that's where the resistance profile and the leverage of the muscle coincide. In contrast, when I look at the gastro, I'm not seeing a pause for the purpose of actually achieving anything, you know, kind of biomechanical. That's just literally looks practical to me. It looks like that exercise is going to fail at the top. You're going to do the pause at the top, and you make sure that you do actually fail on that exercise, you know, despite the fact that you could do a zillion repetitions with it, you know, if you weren't, you know, kind of as you say, having a whole village that you're on your back. So I think we're looking at two totally different situations there, one much more practical than the other. Yeah. Yeah, it's very interesting. It's making the best out of a very limited situation. Absolutely, which is, you know, something we probably don't talk about enough. And when we do mention the limitations of equipment, but at the end of the day, these guys are literally just trying to make a bodybuilding routine out of a few barbells, the odd dumbbell here and there, and some, you know, bizarre bits of I get that they've cobbled together. I mean, I think it's remarkable. cool what they've achieved really. So let's keep on talking about pauses. You've mentioned some interesting stuff there of the solias and the gas shock. Let's get going. Cool. So what I'd like to do today is just give people a complete picture of what's happening with pauses and how to apply that kind of knowledge to any given strength, any exercise that they might be interested in using a pausin. So I'm going to just do a very quick intro to the things that you need to be aware of and then we'll walk through a couple of examples and just talk about it. Now, when we talk about the examples, what you'll find is that it does get messy in places because of the interactions between what the muscle leverages are doing and what the kind of resistance profile of the exercises are doing and where you want to put the pauses. So we have to start out and try and get as much clarity as we can over the nuts and bolts of the situation before we then start implementing the pauses in the exercises that we're interested in. Okay, so starting at the beginning, if you're considering pauses, you've basically got to begin with before you even apply it to an exercise, you've got to consider that you've got two variables that you can alter. You can change the level of effort that you're using for the pauses and secondly, you can change the position of that pauses within the repetition. So when I talk about changing the effort level, generally speaking, in most strengthening contexts, the effort level is going to be slightly less than it would be for your normal dynamic repetition because if you've got an isometric contraction, you're going to find that you're basically capable of producing a high level of muscle fiber force per fiber than you would be if you're dynamic, you're contracting. So you're doing a concentric, you're going to find that you produce less force than you do for an isometric for the same fiber. So you're going to find that your effort levels are a little bit lower, you're coming levels a little bit lower. In certain situations, you can actually do a maximum effort pause. For example, if you get the end of a chest press and you've got a machine that helps you lock it out, you can just push into that and arrange position. If you've got other people that can kind of, you know, slap a couple of extra plates on the machine while you're in the other, you know, kind of the bottom position, for example, you could do the same thing there. So you can change the effort level, but just repeating myself most of the time, people are going to be doing a slightly lower level of effort and they would do in their normal dynamic repetition. But yes, you can change the effort level and you can do what is basically a isometric contraction in the middle of your strength training set if that's something you're interested in doing. It just requires certain exercise context for that to be possible. And then the other variable I mentioned is the position that you're doing the pause in. So you can basically, I mean, obviously do the pause anyway like, but generally speaking, we can kind of say you've got top, middle and bottom positions. So at the top, obviously, you've got the top of the end of the concentric phase. You can do a pause there. That's what we might call a contract position, mid-range depending on the muscle could be kind of contractors or it could be sort of a little bit stretched, but generally it's going to be more contract than the stretch. And then the stretch position, obviously, is at the bottom of the eccentric phase. What's going to be different here? Primarily, you've got fatigue differences. So if you're pausing in contract or mid-range positions, you're generally going to get mostly more metabolite-related fatigue in comparison with calcium-amulade fatigue. In contrast, if you're pausing in the stretch position, you're going to obviously get a lot more calcium-amulade fatigue, a lot less metabolite-related fatigue. So that's going to change things a little bit. And obviously we've talked a lot in the past about how metabolite-related fatigue is very benign in strengthening context. It doesn't really do anything apart from, you know, kind of move you closer towards the end of your set. We're in contrast to calcium-amulade fatigue. If you start creating a lot of that, you're going to find that you don't actually get the stimulus you're expecting. So this is just a really, really important point. The people trip up on a lot. They come to the stimulating rest model and they think, oh, I'll just create fatigue and more fatigue and now I get more stimulating reps. It's like, well, you have to look at the types of fatigue you're generating. You know, if you start generating a lot of calcium-amulade fatigue, you're probably going to start losing stimulating reps in comparison with what you would get if you were not generating that large amount of calcium-amulade fatigue. Obviously, context and magnitude and all of that are going to play a role in situations. Just kind of starting points. Two things to remember, you've got the intensity or level of effort that you're applying in your pores. Is it an isometric where you're pushing really hard? Or is it just kind of a hold where you slightly lower level of effort than you were being on normal dynamic contraction? That's the most normal situation. And secondly, you know, what position in the range of motion, the exercise, and you've got fatigue to consider straight to where when you're thinking about that. And that's going to apply in every single situation, no matter what you're talking about. But obviously, we can now go on and talk more specifically about specific exercises and muscle groups, things like that. But is all of that making sense so far? Yeah, it is. The fatigue point, I think, is very important because you could have something on paper that looks effectively the same. So you could have, like you said, you could have a pores in the contracted position, a pores in lengthened position. Now, someone, like, for example, the red park routine just talked about is that pores in that top position in the contracted position, the fatigue from that, that will dissipate potentially, what, very quickly by the next set, whereas if you did a pores in a lengthened position, the fatigue from that may take what a day? You're carrying it with you really once you've created it, yes. So it's interesting that on paper, you could just say this exercise with pores, but the implication of kind of fatigue that it causes, it could be vastly different. Exactly, exactly. And so it's always worth just ticking those two boxes off and understanding, you know, what is it that we're doing? Because the intensity, obviously, is then going to impact on the impact, on the effect of the position. So if you have an high effort, isometric in the contracted position, you know, you magnifying the amount of metabolite layer of fatigue, okay? No problem. If you now do a high effort contraction in the stretch position, you've got problems because you've just flooded all of your fast-rich muscle fibers with calcium, and you're going to end up with a totally, you know, kind of limited ability then to create the kind of attention in those muscle fibers in the next, you know, repetitions even, that alone the next set. So your effort level is going to magnify the impact of your, you know, kind of position in the range of motion that you're doing your pores in. So not only have we got to think about the intensity level on what that's doing, and the position on what that's doing, but also the impact of the intensity on the position, you've got these, you know, kind of in this interaction effect of the two things. So just like as a background, before we even start talking about what happens when you've got an exercise in the muscle, you're interested in training. Oh, moving onwards, the next thing to do is then to say, well, okay, we've got an exercise that we're interested in. We've got a muscle that we're interested in training. How do we now start to apply pauses in the context of training that muscle in this exercise, or with this exercise? And that's basically where we need to do two things. We need to look at the leverages of the muscle, and we need to look at the resistance profile of the exercise. So the leverage in the muscle will tell us where we want to train it. So if the muscle has great leverage in the contract position, but the soleus does, you know, then it kind of tells us that if we're going to do a pause for the purpose of training the soleus, it kind of has to be in the contract position. There's not any point in doing a pause in the stretch position because that isn't going to train the soleus. Firstly, if you're looking at training the gastroc, you've got the opposite issue. If you got, you know, or the opposite end of the range of motion. It's like, you wouldn't do, you wouldn't do a pause in the contract position to train the gastroc, which is my point about the routine that Redch was doing. You know, he didn't have a pause after every rep in his straight leg calf raises, because it doesn't do anything for the muscle he's actually trying to train. I think it's a really interesting observation. So again, we would do the pause in the straight position if we were wanting to use pauses for training the gastroc. So straight away what we're looking at is a kind of one piece of information, which is that the leverage in the muscle is telling us where we could do the pause. Makes sense? Yep, absolutely. Secondly, we now have to superimpose the resistance profile of the exercise because if you have a resistance profile of the exercise that is a very easier one end, very hard than the other, then doing a pause at the hard end is kind of what you want to do because you're getting that high level of effort, because remember what I said about isometrics involving slightly lower levels of effort for the same amount of muscle fiber force, sorry, muscle force, because muscle fiber force is a higher. So you get more muscle fiber force with a nice metric. So you actually lose a little bit of accruement. So you want to be doing your pause where the exercise is most difficult. There's not a lot of point in doing a pause. I mean, basically, you're having a rest, which is fine. I mean, you do clusters if you want, you know, interest set, rest periods. That's totally fine with us. Not what we're talking about. We're talking about the purpose of a pause for the purpose of, you know, training stimulus. I want to make a point in on that, which I know is not the point you're making, but when I do program classes, I'm very careful about using exercises where someone is not going to be truly rest for the class site in a stretch position. If you were to do like, you know, you can test this out. If you do a leg curl, do a seated leg curl, do a cluster, keep your legs on the pad in a stretch position. It's like a passive stretch. You're not even actively doing anything. And your strength in that class is going to tank compared to doing it in a lying leg or something where you can change position. So I just wanted to put that out there. Totally. I think now there's a different between what we're describing here as pauses and clusters. I mean, technically, we really in a cluster should be aiming to, you know, remove any kind of fatiguing influence whatsoever, even if that is a small amount of activation in a stretch position that you described. You know, the purpose of a cluster is to get rid of that fatigue so that we can carry on applying more stimulus in the absence of a fatigue state. So here, what we're saying then is that, you know, if you're trying to train a muscle that you've identified as having a leverage that means that it's got a solid amount of capacity to contribute to the next size. either a contract position or a stretch position, you need to now look at your resistance profile, the exercise that you are using and identify whether it matches that. So if you're looking at your carphrase and you say do carphrases in general have a resistance profile which is hardest at the top, yes they do. So in fact, whenever you're training in Solis, you've already got everything you need to do contract to position pauses because the exercise is naturally most difficult at the top, the solis has best leverage at the top. You can do a pause and basically what you're doing now is essentially similar to a limited range of motion partial. You're spending more time operating in the zone where that muscle has best leverage, you are targeting that muscle effectively. So partial range of motion, like a contracted partial for the solis in a seated carphrase, which is kind of what a seated carphrase is most of the time anyway. But, you know, or a pause in the contract position, they're all doing the kind of the same thing. What they're doing is they're forcing you to spend more time focusing your set, the stimulus of your set, on one very specific part of the muscle. That's all that's doing, a contracted position partial, that's all that's doing is causing you to spend more time around the area, you're not getting extra stimulus compared to an all strength training set because the fatigue will progress at the same kind of rate. You're just spending more kind of time in the place that is targeting the precise area of muscle that you're interested in training. Does that make sense? - Yeah, it's, I mean, I don't want to take a stand at a different path, but it's the same mentality when people are using a common energy resistance or reverse banding something or whatever, like you're essentially what you're doing, like what you've explained there, you're spending more time in that particular portion of that repetition or where that muscle is best leverage or whatever, all we're doing is manipulating some variable for how much of that set that you're spending where that muscle is best leverage. - Exactly. Where are you applying your high levels of effort? Essentially in this, or even any level of effort, to be honest, because if you come out of that range of motion, you start coming down into a more straight position. You're now starting to create fatigue mechanisms, which have nothing to do with the actual target muscle that you are training with the exercise. Essentially, all we're really doing is more specific targeted exercise around the muscle or instant training. Now, the opposite case is really, really illustrative because any car phrase has a sort of sticking point or the most difficult part of the exercise at the top. It's just how they are, because the entire, you know, kind of plantoplex or complex works in that way. You know, all of the overall leverage gives you a strongest kind of greatest talk in the top position. So if you now start doing pauses in a stretched position, because you're like, oh, well, the gastroc has a stretched position, best leverage in a stretched position, great. Yeah, but does the exercise actually have a sticking point in a stretched position? No, it doesn't. So what you're going to find is that you do stretch position pauses in a car phrase exercise for the gastroc. It's not actually going to do what you think it's going to do because your effort levels are going to be really low. You're not going to get into that top level of motion equipment that you want in order to produce the maximum amounts of muscle growth for that particular muscle. And that's really why, in the case of a stretched position, partial for the gastroc, if you're doing a car phrase where you limit the range of motion, it changes everything. Because as soon as you do a length and sort of partial, you're going to find that you can actually use a lot more weight because, you know, essentially previously, you were failing in that top range of motion because the plantar flexors have got, you know, horrendously bad leverage in that top part of the range of motion. Amazing leverage in the lower part as a group. So essentially, that really, really weak in that top half, and so you use a lot less weight. As soon as you do a length and partial using a lot more weight, and you get a, and if you wanted to, you could actually start doing pauses then as well. But essentially, the length and partial allows you to spend that range of motion doing the targeting of the gastroc in that situation, does that make sense? Yeah, I mean, it's the same thing you see in studies where they do the car phrase, they do go to failure during the full-rom standing car phrase, and then they finish with length and partial, and they get, however, more repetitions out, because like you've just identified there, the hardest bit is, in fact, the top part of that exercise. Clean, exactly, exactly. So if you want to use pauses in the case of, you know, a car phrase for the gastroc, and you're doing a stretch position pause for the gastroc, because the gastroc has best leverage in the stretch position, what you're going to find is that your effort levels are really low, and you don't get into the high threshold motion at poor, and you don't actually end up training the muscle very effectively, just creating a bunch of calcium amuletive teeth that isn't helping you particularly. So much better is to use a limited range of motion, start and just go up to the halfway point, you'll find that you can massively increase how much load you're using, and as a result, you then start to train the muscle and target the muscle in a very effective way. So if you wanted to do pauses in the stretch position with a full range of motion car phrase exercise, you would need the opposite resistance profile from the one you've got, which you could, I mean, there's no way you could standardize this, but if you had a training partner, I say you're doing a total personal leg press, something like that, you could have the training partner actually applying, by pushing into the back of the seat, in that bottom position, making it more challenging, winning the bottom. If you're doing a standing car phrase, you could have someone actually pull down on it. - Absolutely, I mean, there's, yeah, as you say, the standardization is the issue, but fundamentally, the pause isn't going to do what people think it's going to do in comparison with cell length and partial. You know, length and partial use a lot more weight, you can actually kind of start to mimic what the effect you would get with a genuine pause in a contract position for the soleus in a seated car phrase, because that's the sticking point of the exercise. But I think, once you've got the basics down of understanding where you are with things like pauses and effort levels and fatigue, when you actually come to apply it to an individual exercise, you've actually got to look at the exercise and go, "Does my leverage match my resistance profile for doing the pause?" Because if I'm doing a pause in a completely irrelevant part of the range of motion, it's not doing anything. Well, it's not that it's not doing anything, it's probably not doing anything good. You know, if you're doing a pause in a contract position, like for example, pick a leg press. You do pauses in the contract position of the leg press, you know, generally speaking, you're going to create minimal amounts of extra fatigue. In fact, it's probably going to feel like a rest. So, you know, okay, let's say mid-range, just to be kind of like fair, and create a bit of extra matabularity. What's that really doing? Just doing absolutely nothing. It has a neutral effect. It's just going to bring you to failure more quickly. And matabularity is completely benign for that purpose. So it's just bringing you to fail him more quickly. In the case of a stretch position pause, where you don't need it, or where you can't benefit from it, then that's slightly less innocuous, because say, for example, you're doing these kind of pauses in a car phrase, a straight leg car phrase, because you're thinking that's going to work for the gastroc. You're going to get a little bit more calcium amount of fatigue, but you're not really going to get a lot of higher foot contraction than that scenario here. And it's not going to bring you, you know, the benefits of stretch mediator purge for even just normal hypertrophy to the gastroc, because levels of activation aren't that high. But if you do enough of it, and you keep doing it, maybe you've got really long pauses, you might start to interfere with your ability to get stimulating repetitions, because calcium amount of fatigue does reduce the amount of mechanical tension that most fibers can generate. Is that effect going to be really big? Probably not, because the car phrase of muscle itself tends to be relatively, you know, kind of firm, sort of type one, you know, kind of in distribution. So you're probably not going to see an enormous effect, but it's there, and it, you know, is worth knowing about. Talking through another example, people might find this interesting. So maybe like a leg extension, I think it's an interesting example, because it's one way you could feasibly do a pause both in the contracted position, depending on the machine you've got. And especially now you see people with all these, you know, additional kind of, I know if you've seen there's pads and stuff you can get to add on to the leg extension to be able to get a more stretch position, you could theoretically do a pause and that stretch as well. And obviously it's the quadriceps that have best labes throughout that entire range. - Yeah, so leverage from the muscle point two is completely, you've got free reign to do whatever you want. So it only comes down to what's the resistance profile of the knee extension. So you basically limit to, if you can change that, like with bands or if it has a setting that allows you to move it around. - Yeah, like the trim machine. - Yeah, so you could actually do it any way you want to do. And you would get, if you have the capacity to, you could a little bit more stretch media that I'd purchase by doing stretch position pause, but obviously once you pass that, you know, kind of capacity is no point in doing that. So, you know, you could do pauses in the contracted on mid range positions. What's that doing? All it's doing is, it's going to chop some reps off your sat and put in a benign way. It's not going to create a problem for you. You're going to basically just get to failure quicker, quicker, not in terms of time, but in terms of repetitions. So it's completely not to be innocuous. It's not going to do anything bad, but it's not going to do anything good either, really, because there's no reason to do it. You know, an example that would make more sense would be to look at, well, you know, what if we started talking about pauses in a frontal plane over head press, you know, in that scenario, you've now got two completely different muscle groups that are dominating in different ranges of motion. And so now, if you can play around with resistance profiles, you can say, well, okay, I'm going to use a resistance profile that's very hard in the contracted position, and I'm going to basically start to do pauses in that, then that contracted position. That's a really nice anterior adult exercise. I'm going to think of an example where you would do a pause in a contracted position, not for the purpose of biasing a region that. - Well, pauses in contracted positions are pretty much identical. I mean, really pauses are almost identical if you do them correctly to partial range of motion, really. I mean, that's that's kind of how you can think about them. You can just kind of go, if I do, if I do a pause in the difficult part of the range of motion, or if I just limit my range of motion, to that range of motion, that's doing the same thing. The difference is that with pauses, you have to know what's happening in the rest of the range of motion. Because if I said we're gonna do a partial range of motion overhead press and I'm just gonna do the top half of the range of motion, I'm already completely and utterly targeting the anterior adult by doing that. Saying if I do a lower half of the range of motion, which is basically the same as a lateral raise, I'm gonna target the middle though. I don't need to think about pauses or anything like that, I'm automatically targeting that muscle. If you do four range of motion, you're gonna do a pause here to target that muscle, you have to know whether that's the difficult part of the range of motion or not. Or as if you do a partial range of motion, you don't need to know that information. - If you're doing the partial, you know that, that's why you selected the partial. - Yes, but you don't need to mess around with the resistance profile and try and fiddle it to make it line up with the, you know what I'm saying? - Yeah. - Like if you wanted to use a pause in a four range of motion from to playing overhead press to target the middle or anterior though, you would have to fiddle the resistance profile to make that possible. - Yeah. - If you do partial range of motion, you don't need to fiddle it. - If it's the same goal, isn't it? Like, I can't see why-- - It does the same thing. - You would do it. And so essentially, if you're doing a contracted position pause, you're doing it so in the hopes that you make that exercise with that repetition bias one region over another where that other region has-- - That your resistance profile has to let that happen. - Yes, the people are missing. - But then if you're doing a length of position pause, you're doing that, well, I guess you could theoretically be doing it for the same purpose, but you could also be doing it for the benefit of the stretch of mediated hypertrophy. - But again, I only have the muscle has to come up. - If it works, if it works. - Well, it has the leverage in that position. So you still got to go through the leverage journey first. - You need to get there. You need to make sure that it's feasible, but really they're the only triathlon. That's why you would even think about it, no? - So I think really, for me, the partial range of motion is so much more practical, because you don't need to mess around with your resistance profile to make it happen. It's a way better method for targeting a muscle than doing a pause in the range of motion that is targeting the muscle you're interested in, because, practically speaking, if you want to do a pause in a range of motion that targets the muscle, you have to set the resistance profile up to do that anyway. - And it's much easier to standardize as well. - And it's much easier to standardize. Because otherwise, well, it's gonna happen. If you do a pause in the range of motion that's not the sticking point, you're just creating fatigue, which may or may not be a problem. If it's metabolism, it'll take a case, not really doing very much. If it's calcium, I'm gonna take it, then it probably is causing a bit of a problem. So I think really there is a solid argument for stating that a partial range of motion is a much, much, much more practically usable method of targeting a muscle that has good leverage in a particular range of motion than using pauses in that same position. You know, and that's certainly true of something like the gastroch in a seated, sorry, in a standing calvaries or a toe press type exercise. - So one interesting application kind of point here. So I think you mentioned, if you're doing the pause in a contracted position, then you're getting to failure earlier in terms of the amount of repetitions, because you're getting more of this metabolite builder. And now you've just said, well, really for all intensive purposes, a partial exercise is probably going to be arguably superior to a pause in the contracted position. Now, with the partial, you've got the opposite problem. If the load were the same, you're going to be getting arguably more repetitions than you would be. So say you're doing an overhead press and you're just doing a top partial, you're gonna get more repetitions and if you're doing the same way, you're doing full-grown, right? Even if, even depending on where that sitting point is or that individual, even if the sticking point is in the top position, you're still like it, it's still, you're never gonna get less repetitions. No matter what, you're not gonna get the less by doing that partial, right? And so for me, when I'm programming, so to say I'm traveling and I've got access to limited equipment or I don't have a gym pin or whatever in the machine, so you go very heavy or whatever it is, that's basically the only time I'll use some of these kind of methods, just to essentially get more metabolite fatigue. And I used to use the pause, but I don't like the pause, like I find it is hard to standardize when you like the way it feels, et cetera. So what I do instead is, and the partial won't work because it's going to require more load. So I actually do like a one and a quarter. So I'm doing just that length of partial between each repetition in that contractor position, kind of-- - Contracted partial. - Contracted partial. So that is also allowing me to do fewer repetitions, less time in a stretch position, less damage. It's kind of me, I wouldn't program it, it's hard to standardize, but if I'm traveling, it's the best hybrid between doing this pause and doing purely a partial. Does it make sense? - Yeah, no, no, I see a series saying, and what you're really doing there is you're kind of going for an extra step and you're saying that you wouldn't even use the pauses for the thing that people use the pauses for. - Yeah, exactly. Yeah, the one benefit it has, I think you could-- - I'm kind of arguing that partials are better than pauses and you're kind of going, well, you know, even if you want to use a pauses, it's still better to use a partial. (laughs) Which actually makes sense because partials will concentric are less efficient than isometrics. So if you're wanting to do the pauses for the purpose of-- or contractor position pause for the purposes of, just creating more metabolite activity, getting yourself to failure quicker, a kind of partial, there's actually a better doing that. - Yeah, interesting. - So to go on the other end, the length in pauses, what else do we need to say about those? - So, I mean, really, I think people have focused on length and position pauses because of the stretch media hypertrophy, kind of point of view. You know, and that's fine. I mean, the point I'm making is that the pauses gonna give you a lower level of emotional improvement than a dynamic kind of range of motion. Although obviously, you know, if we're talking about stretch media hypertrophy, then we're obviously talking about the eccentric phase. And anyway, and it's like, well, how much benefit are you really gonna get from that? Recruitment levels are gonna be low. You know, there's a relatively challenging kind of environment to work in. But ostensibly, really, we've got the disadvantage of calcium amolated fatigue and the potential for, you know, a little bit more psycho-mergenesis stretch media hypertrophy. But again, you know, what it comes down to is how high up the mochanic recruitment pool are you gonna be when you do that pause? And that is coming back to the resistance profile. And it's like, you need to, like, the bottom position of the squat, the bottom position of a leg press is absolutely fine. That if you want to start talking about doing stretch position pauses there, or, you know, kind of lengthened partials in those contexts, or with knee extensions, whether hard as part of the exercises at the bottom, fine, all of those situations, you've potentially got the ability to create a bit more stretch media hypertrophy. I think there was even a study that Brad did showing that. So, you know, I think that that stacks up for me. That's exactly what we would expect to see. But again, I would argue that, you know, is there really, I'm just thinking aloud as I'm working through that? How would that work? 'Cause would my lengthened partials be better or worse than my pause in the stretch position? Possibly the pause in the stretch position might be, I don't know. I actually don't know. That's a really interesting point. Would it be better or worse if you have a resistance profile where it's hardest in the stretch position? The pause is actually all the way in that stretch position. I think that would come down to an argument about what you thought Titan was really doing and how it was working. I think that would get physiologically really quite contentious. Because what it comes down to is, if you look at the standard model that we tend to use for the way Titan behaves, we tend to model Titan as producing passive forces in an eccentric contraction, not so much in an isometric. So it would be like, you're getting them in the eccentric and then you can hold that in your isometric position and then you, obviously return and then you come back down again. There is a dual force enhancement effect suggests that you would get a bigger effect the longer that you did your range of motion. So there's a couple of factors here and this could get really, really messy really quickly or not so much messy as really detailed really quickly because you could argue that a larger range of motion of your eccentric and then holding that pause in the stretch position was actually superior to a length and partial but that doesn't seem to be what the data show. So I think where we would end up is arguing or at least trying to investigate what we think Titan really is doing and mechanically in those eccentric situations followed by our symmetric, which is the residual force enhancement effect and then saying, you know, how do these compare in terms of providing that passive mechanical tension stimulus for sarcomberogenesis? And as you can probably tell, I haven't worked through that in my head before. So I'm trying to decide what I think would happen. But yeah, I mean, ultimately both length and partials and stretch position pauses in the context of something like a leg press or squat where the muscles that you're interested in have the leverage in the stretch position and also where the exercise is hardest and that stretch position, I think they're all gonna be much of a much less. They're all gonna work for the purposes of producing that extra muscle growth and actually they'll kind of also target anything that's working in that range of motion. Anyway, I mean, in the context of the squat is a bit relevant or sorry, not squat specifically but the quadriceps pair rather than, you know, if you were targeting a muscle in the stretch position, it would work that way. - So if someone is doing a pause in the length and position for the purpose of achieving stretch, I mean, added hypertrophy, well, obviously that's a short term adaption, right? Like that's gonna piss us. - Yeah, they're gonna get a couple of months worth of that and then they're not gonna benefit from it much further. Realistically, you know, you kind of looking at stuff like muscles that have got, you know, great leverage So, break relative leverage in stretch positions. if you want to start to do that. So, you know, you kind of think you might buy such brachia, you're thinking like gastroc, you think, but again, what I'm saying is you've got to look at exercises that allow you to do that, you know, which is, you're then fiddling around with your resistance profile to make it happen. Much easier is just to do the partial range of motion. - Now, I think you've touched on a little bit, but maybe not extensively. So the difference between doing that pause in repetition with load and doing a pause or a static stretch without load, has the stretching, what's the difference with those? - So basically, this comes back to what we were talking about with clusters. So, if you're doing a pause and you completely relax because there's no load present either machine bottoms out or, you know, there's nothing you need to do to keep the weight in place, then, you know, obviously that changes what you're doing. There's a couple of things that are worth mentioning here. So firstly, you have to be clear what it is that you're describing. So what I mean by that is if you're doing a pause and you're saying, I am doing a pause in the stretch position and I'm holding, you know, load here and I'm actively maintaining the position of the weight, then that's a stretched position isometric contraction relatively, probably relatively low intensity unless the exercise is really difficult in that position. That's, but that's, that's kind of what you're doing. So, in that situation, you've got an activated muscle. That's not a passive static stretch. That's a stretched position isometric contraction. Now, an interesting thing to notice about isometric contractions and stretch positions is you're not going to get to the same range of motion that you would do if you had a deactivated muscle or passive static stretch. Some really nice data on this and we were just talking about a study before we came on this podcast to do this call because there's data showing that for every kind of, I think it's 1% increase in joint torque as a result of muscle activation happening in a stretched position. You lose a couple of degrees to an half degrees of range of motion. As soon as you start activating the muscle and stretch position, you aren't going to get to the same degree of range of motions you would do as if you're completely relaxed. So, straight away, when you're talking about stretched positions and pauses and things like that, we need to be 100% clear what the instruction is that's being given. Are we saying that we're doing like a, you know, intracet kind of static stretch? So, it's like a cluster set. We're pausing, we're relaxing, and we're doing that at the end of each of the repetitions. If that's the case, I mean, that's a really kind of different interesting training method and we can analyze it, but that's not the same thing as doing a pause in a stretched position, does that make sense? So, the pause in a stretched position will not get you to the same range of motion as doing the relaxed static stretch between repetitions. That's, these are completely different animals. So, you're not going to get serious improvements in a range of motions as a result of increase in strict tolerance because you're not getting to match range of motion. So, it's an example of us just a people with super clear. So, if you were to do a full relaxed stretch between repetitions, what's an exercise with that might be feasible? Well, if you're kind of doing your calf raises in that leg press scenario, then often, I mean, I've got hypermobile ankles, so I can bottom out that position really easily. I can get to a sort of silly stretched position and the machine bottoms out, essentially. So, I could now passively static stretch, completely deactivate the muscle, I could go all the way down into a super stretched position. So, you could do that if you wanted to do that. I think you'd be able to adjust the leg press regardless and you should be able to, everyone should be able to do that. So, there's no, you're not feeling any load from the leg press on in that pause position. Well, you're completely relaxing and you're not trying to kind of come back up again, essentially. So, you're totally and utterly relaxing and there's no kind of impact of the exercise, but you're not kind of holding a stretched position. So, however you want to kind of think about, the important thing is, is there activation or not? I mean, technically, you could have somebody pushing you into that stretched position. I mean, there's all kinds of ways you can think about it. I mean, like those calf studies with those boots, I mean, effectively, that's something pushing you into that position. The question is, is the muscle activated or not? Whether you get there from somebody pushing you or you're pushing yourself or there's a load, all of these things are other. I mean, sometimes, I mean, historically, people got much more educated about this when I said to them, you know, the concept of loaded stretches meaningless. Every stretch is loaded. Because that's how you get the stretch. You have to put yourself in the position. Now, you rather pushing yourself. You've got somebody else pushing you or you've got a weight somewhere, it doesn't matter. It's like, is the muscle activated or not? Because if the muscle is activated, then it's a stretch position isometric. And if your muscle is not activated, then it's a passive static stretch. Just the word loaded is meaningless. It really is. People get really, really wound up about it. But it literally just tells you, you know, some minor details about the method that you're using to get into the position of the stretch. So let's keep workshopping this idea of this example. So you're in it. You're doing a trooper as you've bottomed out of the bottom. There's, you've, you're not active in there's no resistance, I guess, being applied. And then you do another repetition. And you do that little pause between each of these repetitions. What's happening in that scenario? - So, so what we're saying then is that there's a difference between holding an activated muscle in a stretch position and holding a relaxed muscle in a stretch position. The activated muscle doesn't get to the same range of motion, but it's going to be creating a lot more calcium-imulator fatigue. The stretch position, you're going to be able to basically create a passive static stretch stimulus in the middle of your strength training set, which is a really interesting kind of idea. Does it, does it, does it benefit us in any way? - Or would we better off just doing it afterward? - I can't, how could it possibly benefit? The how could it be better than doing it afterwards? - Because ultimately, doing it afterwards, if you do a static, if you do a static stretch after a strength training workout, there is no interference of your strength training workout for deep mechanisms on that static stretch stimulus. You should don't need any active tension production. You don't, you could have all the excitation, contraction, coupling, failure in the world going on, and it doesn't change your passive tension stimulus because the passive tension stimulus is coming without any muscle activation whatsoever. In contrast, knee static stretch is going to produce a little bit of calcium-imulator fatigue, which is going to interfere with the concentric repetitions that you do in the strength training set. Walter is no down, there's no upside of doing it, and you know, and you would be much better off just doing the static stretching after the end of your calf raise workout. So just do your normal calf raise workout and then do some static stretching at the end. You're going to get better range of motion than you would do from a stretch position, isometric or pause, and you're going to get a better strength training stimulus than you would do if you'd done your static stretching in between repetitions. - Is it possible that the fatigue or the perception of effort from the strength workout will reduce stretch tolerance if you should then do the static stretch afterwards? - So that's a really interesting one. I think really that's one of those things that's never been tested. There is some interaction between the perception of stretch and the perception of effort, but they're not identical. So I think really would be an interesting one to kind of test, to be honest. I mean, if anybody's kind of listening to this and they've got a, you know, they're looking at a project for their master's degree or maybe they've got some kind of, you know, even a bachelor's degree type sports science experiment that they might be capable of doing in the final year or something like that, then really interesting thing to do would literally be to test range of motion before and after strength training workouts. So literally just do, and you could do this non-locally and locally. So you could do a, you know, test range of motion in a muscle that you're about to train and you could test range of motion and another muscle that you're not going to train. So you could maybe do a lower body workout and you could test upper body and lower body flexibility, do the workout and then immediately afterwards, you could test upper and lower body flexibilities again and see what happens. You know, my gut feel is that you'll probably see either no changes or a slight improvement in range of motion rather than a slight decrease 'cause generally speaking exercise tends to have a little bit of an analgesic effect. - Yeah. - So I would actually expect you would improve range of motion a little bit rather than making it worse. But potentially as you've outlined, if you're still, if you're feeling like you're suffering a little bit after the workout and you've got that sort of a super spinal CNST going on, you know, does that then reduce how much pain we can tolerate in this context of a static stretch? Well, as I say, nobody's ever tested that. There are some, I mean, this is outside of the scope of today's conversation. There are some interaction effects that I've talked about on the FAQ. But I don't think there are absolutely identical. We're well and truly beyond the point where people would recommend passive stretching before a strength training workout. Like everyone's so nice. - Exactly. - So why would you put one in the middle of a strength training set? - Exactly, yeah. - Yeah, I mean, it's like clear that it doesn't, it probably doesn't do anything good to do the stretch before or during, you know, and there's clear reasons to do it afterwards because there's no interference really with it. You know, I think it's interesting, you know, it's like people are always looking for ways to make an exercise better, you know? And what we always want to do is interrogate these things physiologically and go, what do we think is going on? And like I was saying with the case of this stretch position, you know, kind of pause versus the length and partial, you know, in the context of a leg press or squat, you start to analyze those, you know, this is really interesting. I'm not sure I can really put these together and argue one over there. other. And that comes down to a lack of clarity over exactly what Titan is doing in these particular situations. And the models that you use will give you different answers depending on what model you prefer. And I think it's probably a little too messy to really get to the point where I've got a firm answer on that. But other situations is a lot clearer. You can kind of go, well, clearly there's no benefit of doing that. You might as well just do this instead. So I think it depends on the context. But what I was really trying to do with this podcast today was just kind of introduce people to these concepts that need to be aware of, starting with, you know, what types of fatigue they're creating, you know, what effort levels they're likely to be experiencing. And then how the moment arm of each individual muscle in the over the joint tango-regimotion and the resistance profile that you've got, interact with each other to create the individual effects of pauses, then having understood that, compare that with what you would get from doing a partial range of motion in the range that the muscle has the best leverage. Because ultimately that is a far superior way of approaching these kind of goals that you might have for targeting particular muscles by doing pauses. You actually get a much, much more pragmatic, practically usable solution by doing a kind of either a contract or a, I guess, mid range as well. But, you know, doing a partial range of motion is going to be most of the time far easier to standardise, far easier to get the effect that you want without really messing around with, you know, elastic buns and all kinds of other things. So it sounds like you're saying that there's probably not a scenario where you would be personally programming a pause in, well, in either a lengthened or contracted position. I think I would always prefer the partial range of motion in almost any situation. I mean, I can see a scenario where you could argue that pauses like in a stretch position, say, a leg press or something like that, you could argue for that. But as I say, you would be starting to have to argue for one or other mechanisms by which Titan might work, you know. And when I say mechanisms by which Titan might work, I'm not like arguing against the fundamental basics of it, which is that, you know, Titan is being stretched in the course of an activated, kind of eccentric contraction to a greater extent than it is in a passive static stretch, not arguing that. I was saying exactly precisely what Titan is doing, is it winding? What are we actually describing here? And how does that play out in the context of an isometric kind of pause at the end of a eccentric contraction? No. Because often, you know, a residual force announcement effect tends to show greater effects when you have larger ranges of motion leading up to your isometric. So, you know, there's some really interesting things that you can get into there. And I don't know, honestly, which side of the fence that I would probably come out on, I'd have to really spend some time thinking about it. It's quite rare, actually, that I get presented with these kind of ideas. And I'm looking at, I genuinely haven't thought about it, you know, I mean, that's a really interesting one. That's kind of, that's kind of irritating, you know. I'm sure we'll see in FAQ on the scene. Might be a few months. But yes, I think there'll eventually be an FAQ on what I think is happening with length and partial versus pauses in stretch positions in situations like the leg press where you've got, you know, the resistance profile is already benefiting you, so it's that everything is happening in that stretch position already. Would a four-range emotional eccentric actually get you a bit more residual force announcement in your pause compared to your length and partial? I don't know. I'd have to really pause some data together to see what I think is going on there. You may have made the point, or you have made the point, several times about active and relaxed stretch, or the muscle being active, relaxing there in a stretch. And I'm confusion I see online is people justifying a pause in, like in a set where they're muscles active and using evidence from studies where they did stretches in a relaxed position and saying this is why I'm doing that. I think you've probably covered everything you need to do there, but I just wanted to point out that those are clearly not the same thing. No, they're not the same thing. And that's why I said, when we're talking about the stretch position in something like a seat, obviously it is seated if you're doing it to the toe press, but that's not the point. That's why I brain kind of goes, well, I'm sitting there when I'm doing this exercise, so I must call it a seat exercise, but it's a straight leg, a straight leg calf raising, you're trying to, you know, train the gastroc and I'm like, okay, so how can we focus the exercise on the stretch? Interestingly enough, you know, the same people who are arguing about this stuff, you know, they are quite happy to argue for the neuro-mechanical matching interpretations when it suits them. And neuro-mechanical matching tells us that the gastroc has best leverage in the stretch position, so that's where we train it. So, you know, we're training the gastroc in the stretch position, you know, do we use a pause? Is that pause, you know, how does it all work? Is it like a Bosch or whatever? Now my solution is just use a lengthened partial because you'll use a lot more weight and you end up creating a situation in which the gastroc has to do a lot of hard work in that stretch position, fantastic problem solved. As you pointed out, some people are now kind of saying, well, you know, can I not just use a pause and do a four-inch emotion ball? No, because you can end up using a lot less loading in the stretch position and so you're not getting the same benefits as you would be doing for the gastroc because the effort levels are too low. Now, this is why I said, you need to be then super clear. Are you referring to a stretch position pause where you're holding the activation on it or are you taking these mini breaks between repetitions and, you know, kind of doing a completely relaxed or static stretch? Well, those are separate things and if you're, if you're queuing, if you're telling people to do that, then, you know, be clear about it. But as we've described, it probably isn't going to help you because all you're doing is breaking the strength training set up with little static stretches, which is going to create a accumulation of calcium amylate fatigue and start to reduce the stimulation of your strength training set. So you're making your strength training set worse by taking these little breaks to do static stretches between repetitions much better as everybody who knows anything about this subject has been saying for the last kind of day or so much better is just to take these static stretch out of that part of your workout and do it at the end. You know, I mean, this is all really kind of logical physiology. It's messy because we're describing things that are, you know, not immediately, you know, kind of clear to everybody, but fundamentally the physiology is very, very logical. It's like, if the muscle is activated, this happens, if the range of motion is doing this, this happens and it's like, just work through the variables that you've got and, you know, the answer will drop out at the end. Now, I think, you know, the activated stretch position contraction is a very different animal from a passive static stretch in the same kind of, you know, ish range of motion. They're doing different things. The other one final question for you, hopefully it's not too messy. Let's say, let's keep going with this calf example. You know, we've talked about how the calf can experience stretch made air hypertrophy. And so you're doing this pause in this length of position, potentially getting some of that stretch made air hypertrophy for a period of time. And if you don't get into graded ranges of motion, then you're going to see a plateau that. But if you do achieve graded ranges of motion, then you're going to continue to see stretch made air hypertrophy occur for as long as you continue to do so, which would allow one to see longer adaptions in stretch so they can achieve more stretch made air hypertrophy, doing a passive static stretch afterwards, or does it matter when you're doing it, or doing a stretch where the muscles active, like what people generally recommend at the moment because they're calf areas. Well, this is what I was mentioning when I said, if you look at studies that have measured the impact of activation in a muscle on range of motion, even a tiny little increase in torque as a result of activated muscle starts shaving degrees off your range of motion, maximum range of motion. So you're not going to have an extra range of motion. So that's to say you do that, say do that stretch, active stretch, and then you measure passive stretch afterwards, does that increase range of motion and passive stretch or not? So eccentric, okay, this is the problem. So if you look at eccentric training studies, you'll find that maximum range of motion in the trained muscle increases. So like people look at those and they go, "Oh, I can do active, active stretch." Well, some research is called eccentric training, doesn't matter. You can activate the muscle and stretch it, and it will give you an increase in range of motion in the same way that a passive static stretch gives you an increase in range of motion. I don't believe these are working for the same mechanism. I think that all your increases in range of motion in an eccentric training context are fast-collect related. So I think basically you're changing the structure of the muscle to make the range of motion increase. I think that's what's happening in situations of length and parcels and stretch positions, sort of pauses and any stretch position, strengthening exercise that also gives you an increase in range of motion. I think they're all basically doing it structurally with an increase in physical length. Static stretching kind of gives you a stretch tolerance improvement at the same time as you're getting your smaller increases in physical length. Now I think if we were to look at, and I don't think these data exist, but I think if you were to study the effects of eccentric training over a longer period of time, you'd find that range of motion stopped increasing around about the time of a physical length stopped increasing, so a couple of months. So if you've got either you did some long-term eccentric training studies in trained people who've already maxed out their psychomyodensis, or you just kind of followed people for like four, five, six months, I think either way what you would find is that eccentric training stopped or any kind of strength training that's producing psychomyodensis, stopped producing increases in range of motion after a couple of months. I don't think you would get a continued effect. Static stretching tends to produce an increase in range of motion for as long as you do it, as long as you keep pushing it to new engines of motion, it kind of obviously gives you those new engines of motion. Now, the interesting thing about that is that, as you push into those new ranges of motion, the circumvention process continues happening alongside it. So your static stretching is going to kind of work with you for a much longer period of time, subject to your ability to continue increasing ranges of motion. So if you've got, I mean, and this is another one of those really wild kind of observations because, you know, the people who are arguing about this stuff, you know, are people who've already got more than three months of strength training experience and probably can't experience circumvention as a result unless they go into new ranges of motion. And to do that, they're probably going to need a static stretch with a relaxed muscle. Yeah. To make that happen. Yeah. So you bet off doing that steady stretch with a length and partial, then you're. So you better off doing the length and partial with the gastroc to train the gastroc, and afterwards, do your static stretch. I mean, that would be the perfect workout for training the gastroc. You would do the gastroc length and partial, not for the purposes of circumvention, because it's not going to happen in that range of motion. But for the purposes of targeting the gastroc, you would, by making it to partial, you would make the resistance profile. I mean, ultimately, it was just some of this stretch way to happen. Look, is when you're getting. Not if you're trained, you won't. No. Because, well, okay. So, if you have the ability to set the machine up to allow you to continue going into more and more ranges of motion, I mean, they're going to be able to access because you've been doing the steady stretch. Because you're doing the static stretching afterwards, then you'll start to see some combined effects of that. Sorry, I don't think like this, because my ankles don't really let me do that. But. Basically, yes, if you were in a situation where you could continue going into your ranges of motion in your strength range, because the machine's set up in a way that lets you do that, then yes, your static stretch done, I mean, technically done any time, but we would program it afterwards. I mean, you could do it any time, but done afterwards, you know, would start to push you into new ranges of motion. So, yeah, they do actually have a synergistic effect, to the extent that you, you know, your set up is allowing you to do that. I mean, if your set up is soaps that you bottom out each, right at the end of each repetition, then you can't go into new ranges of motion because your set up isn't allowing you to go into new ranges of motion. You have to set it up so that you can go into new ranges of motion, most of the time for that to happen. Phil, happy with that conclusion. I feel like that is, for someone who's wanting to really focus on calf growth or gastro growth, that's probably the formula that's going to get one there. Absolutely, you know, I think that length and partial, pair that with a seated calf raise and do some static stretching afterwards for the gastro, I think that's a really interesting, you know, and it's not enormously, you know, kind of burdensome, you know, we're not, we're not kind of in comparison with Reg Park's program that we looked at, in comparison with that, you know, you could just do, you know, one, one set of seated calf raise, one set of length and partial, you know, to press and throw a static stretch on the end. I mean, any opposition was interesting? Get some. Sure. And that would be the next level up. You would absolutely look at that, but only in the to press. Yeah. And then because really, for the soleus, it's not relevant. Something you could do to increase mobility and at your treatment, maybe single leg is something that'll be an interesting next level as well, potentially. But of course, we would always do that for any, make sure that we were focusing on, exactly. I think we did it. We solved the calf question. Is there anything else you want to know? Well, you know, the, the important thing is that, and this kind of pairs with the observation that I made on social media today and that I've mentioned to you, the important thing is that, you know, we're demonstrating or walking people through the line of reasoning that gets you from, you know, the beginning to hear, because if you want to be able to assess, and people ask me this question all the time, how do I assess, you know, the information that this person gives me, the information that that person gives me, the information that somebody else gives me, you know, not being an expert in that subject, you know, because that's the silly thing where, you know, you're kind of putting yourself in a situation where you're requiring of yourself the ability to compare two expert opinions and judge between them. Well, that's just silly to begin with. I mean, if you state it like that, it's obvious it's impossible is you're kind of claiming to have more expertise than the two experts you're assessing. Well, if that were the case, why are you even listening to this podcast? Because you already have the expertise relevant. I mean, I spend zero time listening to other experts, zero. You know, all my time is spent looking at source data. I don't spend any time looking at other expert opinions. So, you know, it's, it's a really interesting question. So what I think we're trying to do here, or I've been trying to do here, and you know, we've been working through together, is demonstrating that the outcomes that we are recommending, explaining, suggesting are the output of a series of physiological observations or, you know, physiological kind of phenomena that, you know, are relatively well described, and you can just put them together and you end up in this place. So, you know, understand a little bit about fatigue, you understand a little bit about motina accruement, you understand a little bit about, you know, you're kind of matching, and you understand a little bit about sarcoma regensis, and you put all of that together, and you end up with these outcomes, and it's very logical step-by-step process. You know, it's not a kind of, oh, well, I want to get this, I want to get to this outcome that I prefer to do. So therefore, how can I justify an argument that gets me there? It's like, hopefully, even though the listeners may not be able to evaluate the, the scientific claims being made here, hopefully, they can at least see that the process is logical. You know, whereas in many other situations, a fitness influence might be explaining something to you, and it is kind of a little bit disjointed because there isn't a logical process that's being followed. It's like, they have an outcome that they want to argue for, and they piece together an argument that gets in that. You know, whereas what this is, is a starting from the ground up, physiological series of observations that ends up in place that we're at, and it's pretty much the same series of observations and the same set of physiological data that we refer to in any situation. So it's like we have a pattern that's always applicable. Hopefully, that counts for something. That's what I'm saying. You know, hopefully that counts for a little bit in terms of giving people some reassurance that even though they may not be able to evaluate the expert claims made here, with the expert claims made somewhere else, at least they can see that the ones being made here follow a very logical pattern, if nothing else. Yeah, that's interesting. The difference between the process or the outcome of just starting with the outcome and then working backwards is not the same thing of starting with the process and the physiology and working out where does that lead us. You know, and just like the fact that I'll get halfway through explaining something and I'll suddenly realize that I haven't thought about one of the possible rubber holes that goes off the edge of that thing. And you know, on one hand, that makes me look a little bit silly because it's like, well, what haven't you thought about that? On the other hand, it's like, well, that's because this is a process driven, you know, kind of conversation. You know, every time somebody asks me a question, I start with, well, what do I know? And then I work my way up to the answer. I don't go, oh, well, that answer is this answer because here it is written on this page in this textbook that tells me what the answer is. That's not how it works. It's like, well, what do I know? You know, I know how muscle contractions work, I know, you know, how team mechanisms work, I know how I'm reaching out. And so you kind of build the, you know, the knowledge base up that we're always referring to. And then you build up your outcome. And the outcome is, or the outcome we use the word outcome for other contexts. But the answer to the question that is being posed is derived from the process of working through these physiological concepts. And the physiological concepts never change, you know, it's just the question might be different in certain circumstances. So hopefully, even the fact that I kind of get myself into a role that I haven't thought about before is illustrative of the fact that we're not just making stuff up for the sake of, you know, kind of, oh, well, I think this, therefore, I'm going to make some reasons up, you know, it's like, no, I believe in this set of physiological concepts and whatever answers they throw out is what I'll kind of go with because that's my model. My perspective, it makes the application conversation much more interesting. If I can start with what's the physiology telling us? And then how can we creatively apply that? I find that a much more interesting conversation than here's this arbitrary technique of method that people are using. Let's just hope it works. Let's try to justify it or whatever, you know, why I like that. That's exactly what happens. People come up with something and then they try to justify it. And so they're kind of running around looking for reasons. So what reason can I find that justifies this thing that I've already decided is cool. It's like we're doing things completely the opposite way around. We're going, what do we know and where does it take us? And sometimes it takes you places that you don't expect. I just say, part of the fun, part of flexibility, part of the excitement of doing it kind of, sometimes you stumble across things that you haven't put together before. And you're like, actually, that's really interesting. Exactly. And it's stuff that I wouldn't naturally want to do a lot of the time. Like some of their, their sort of methods and ideas that we might come up with from looking at some of this stuff, talking about some of this stuff from a gym perspective, like that's not what I would have ever been drawn to or not what I would have naturally wanted to do. But it's like, oh my god, that makes so much sense. Let's try it. And then it's like, oh, that, you know, it feels good. It's working. It's, it's getting results I want. You know, let's, let's stick with that. So it is, it's, I've, I've kind of done both, right? Like I've come out of the world where it was like, this is how you do it. Don't question it. Just, this is it. And it, it didn't feel fulfilling. And then to get to a point where it's like, we can actually start to be great, even part of that creative process because we understand the physiology. That's like, oh my god, this is, it's like, it's a revelation. It's like, we could do this. Like I'm so excited to come to you. It's like, hey, have you thought about if we could do this and we, you know, there's this sort of, you know, like we were talking about classes the other week and the internal focus of attention with classes. It's like, "Oh, what about if we do this?" It's like, "Oh, that actually makes sense." And it just changes and it just changes the conversation becomes so much more rewarding when it's actually anchored in physiological meaning as opposed to this symbolic meaning of this is how you're meant to do it. Yeah, absolutely. And I think a lot to the resistance. And I was talking with a couple of other people about this as well. And I think a part of the resistance that people have to this approach might call it physiology-based, you know, kind of programming is that it takes a lot of your power away. Because at the end of the day, you're kind of surrendering to the algorithm that you've kind of created and you kind of go, well, like, people ask me questions like, well, does this split work better than that split? And I already made an algorithm that gives you my best answer. So just use that. Like, I may not agree with it like emotionally all the time, but it's my best effort in terms of like what I think is happening. So I'll just defer to it. And I kind of like surrendered the kind of the power to the to the model. And so, well, whatever the model kind of so throws out is my best guess. You know, now you don't, of course, you don't like and outcome. You don't like the way of training. You don't have to train like this. Like not everyone has to train perfectly all the time. It's like, well, this preference is no kind of thing to go on. But at least it gives you a starting point of knowing what you think the best kind of way of achieving a particular goal might be. But I think the reason that people object to is it really does take the power away. People have got accustomed to being, as you say, being able to say, you know, I think this way of training is the best way of doing this. And because I'm this authority and I have all this in all these social media followers and tens of thousands of people doing my programs, I am justified in claiming that this is the best way of doing it. And I think people react that they're going to accustomed to be able to do that. And when you come along with an algorithm that kind of says, well, maybe it's not the best way to get very upset. But at the end of the day, I think, as you say, it opens up more doors in terms of creativity, in terms of enjoyment of programming and that ability to be flexible. But I ain't said to you the other day. And again, I'm now rambling a little bit, but this is a really important point. I said to you the other day that I have strongly felt for a long time that most of the complexity that people write, you know, strength coaches write into the training programs is literally friend attainment purposes. And it actually is counterproductive to the purpose of the program, you know. And I said, it's very, it's almost unheard of for me to ever see a complexity element, something that made the program more complicated than literally just full body grease as a wee. That was better than something as simple as full body grease as a wee. And then you came up with a few things recently and had me come up with these reasons. And I've just been sitting back going, this is the first time I've seen complexity that actually adds any value. And that's because of what you've been doing with the template that we've got in terms of the model and the physiological reality. And you've been actually starting to push into territory that, as you mentioned, potentially within tunnel focus on clusters and things like that, you're actually starting to make changes that I think have actual added value that aren't just entertainment. That's really exciting because that feels like we've started to open a door into a new space where you can kind of have that complexity again. And yet also have it work and add value rather than just be entertainment for the purposes of making the client feel like they're getting more value. Because ultimately that's really what it has been in the past. It's like, you know, client looks at full body three times a week and go, why am I paying this person to program like this for me? Well, because they knew it was better than what you were doing before, but as a separate question, you know, but, you know, recognizing that people do have a tendency to see value in complexity is there a way that we can actually have both. Can we have a value added complexity? And I think, as I said to you very recently, when we looked at some programs together that you were writing, I am starting to see the possibility of that happening, which is very, very cool. So I'm kind of mentioning that as a way to kind of wrap up my ramblings on this, on this very long podcast that we've kind of done. Okay, we'll call it there. Thank you. Thank you everyone for listening. We appreciate you as always. We got lots of good feedback last week. So we appreciate that. Thank you for sharing. If you want me to be liking all that stuff, please continue to do so. And we hope you'll join us next week.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Reg Park’s 1952 calf specialization program includes unique, historically grounded exercises like donkey raises, heel-and-toe walks, and foot extensions.
  2. The routines combine straight-leg and bent-knee movements, targeting both gastrocnemius and soleus with different biomechanical efficiencies.
  3. Reg emphasizes high repetitions and specific positioning, such as isometric holds at the top of reps, to align training with muscle leverage and resistance profiles.
  4. The donkey raise and seated calf raise both use pauses, but the purpose differs
  5. Exercises like heel-and-toe walks and knee-forward lunges demonstrate creative, low-equipment solutions to build calf strength without modern training tools.
  6. Mind-muscle connection techniques, like concentration toe presses, are included, though their effectiveness remains speculative due to limited data.
  7. The program reflects early bodybuilding wisdom, where practical limitations shaped effective training methods, such as high reps due to lack of equipment.
  8. Modern biomechanics reveals that pauses and partial ranges of motion are more effective and practical than isolated pauses for muscle-specific targeting.

Summary:

Reg Park’s 1952 calf specialization program offers a fascinating glimpse into early bodybuilding methodology, predating modern science with practical, equipment-limited training strategies. The program features exercises like donkey raises, heel-and-toe walks, and knee-forward lunges, designed to train both gastrocnemius and soleus through varied mechanics. A key insight is that pauses are used strategically: in seated calf raises, holds at the top exploit soleus’s optimal leverage, while in straight-leg raises, the pause occurs at the end because the exercise is hardest at the top—aligning with biomechanics rather than random repetition.

The routines reflect a deep understanding of muscle leverage and resistance profiles, even without modern data. Notably, the use of high reps and partner-assisted movements (like donkey raises) highlights how practical constraints shaped effective training. While mind-muscle connection exercises like concentration toe presses are included, their physiological value remains unclear.

Modern analysis shows that partial ranges of motion are more effective and standardized than isolated pauses for targeted muscle growth, as they align better with muscle leverage and reduce fatigue interference. Ultimately, Park’s approach demonstrates that effective muscle development can emerge from ingenuity and experience, even without access to current scientific knowledge. This historical program remains relevant as it underscores timeless principles of training efficiency, equipment adaptation, and biomechanical alignment.

FAQs

Reg Park's calf specialization phase involves adding targeted calf exercises to a full-body workout. It includes exercises like donkey raises, heel and toe walks, standing toe raises, foot extensions with an iron boot, knee-forward lunges, and concentration toe presses, all designed to specifically develop the calf muscles.

In seated calf raises, pauses at the top are recommended because the soleus muscle has optimal leverage in the contracted position. In straight leg calf raises, pauses are only at the end of the set to account for the exercise’s resistance profile, which is hardest at the top, ensuring effective muscle activation without counterproductive fatigue.

The concentration toe press is a mind-muscle connection exercise where the individual pushes their toes into the floor to improve neuromuscular control and mental engagement with the calf muscles, though its effectiveness in driving hypertrophy remains debated.

Exercises with a resistance profile that is hardest at the top (like seated calf raises) benefit from pauses at the top to target the muscle in its optimal leverage zone. For exercises like straight leg calf raises, pauses in the stretch position are ineffective due to low effort and poor muscle activation.

Straight leg raises target the gastrocnemius with better leverage in the extended position, while bent-knee exercises emphasize the soleus. This dual approach ensures balanced development of both major calf muscle groups.

No, it is not effective because the gastrocnemius has best leverage in the contracted position, and stretch-position pauses create low-effort, high-calcium-amide fatigue, which doesn't effectively stimulate hypertrophy.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.