017 Exercise Selection - How to pick the exercises needed to maximally develop a muscle
from Hypertrophy Past and Present
1h 22m 27s
This episode explores an early 1950s workout plan devised by C-cline, a lesser-known but influential figure in pre-modern bodybuilding. The routine consists of 18–19 single-set exercises, heavily emphasizing shoulder development through lateral raises, front raises, overhead presses, and side bends—hallmarks of the bronze-era aesthetic. Notably, back training is minimal, with only chin-ups included, suggesting a personal bias toward upper body growth rather than balanced development. The analysis draws on neuro-mechanical matching theory, which posits that the central nervous system prioritizes muscle regions with the best leverage during movement. This principle explains why certain muscles, like the posterior deltoid, are activated first in shoulder movements, while others are left underdeveloped due to neural command limits. Larger muscle groups—such as the quadriceps and latissimus dorsi—exhibit significant voluntary activation deficits, meaning a large portion of muscle fibers remain unactivated despite maximal effort. In contrast, smaller muscles like elbow flexors show minimal deficits, indicating more efficient recruitment. The discussion highlights a sliding scale of exercise variation: while high variation in large muscle groups offers substantial benefits, it often leads to diminishing returns. For optimal results, training should be tailored to muscle mass and leverage, with multi-joint exercises requiring greater attention to regional biasing. Smaller joint exercises, like biceps curls or hip abduction, offer more precise targeting but deliver less overall growth. Ultimately, the episode underscores that effective training must balance biomechanical principles with practical, personalized goals—avoiding overgeneralizations about muscle recruitment that stem from anatomical labels rather than physiological reality.
Welcome back everyone to another episode. Good morning, good evening, wherever you are. Chris,
how are you tonight? Yes, it is tonight. For me, I'm doing very well. Thank you, Jake.
Awesome. Good to hear. We are back at it again. Another fun episode. This is, I'm not going to get away
what we're going to talk about. You'll probably work out what we're going to talk about when I jump
into this plan. We're going to talk about today. So we have, we are going back to C-cline.
So we've talked about C-cline only a couple of weeks ago. So if you haven't listened to that
episode, I would encourage you to do so. I really, I'd encourage you to listen to all of the episodes.
And what I should mention as well is a lot of our episodes to actually build on former episodes.
If you're kind of intimately jumping in and out, we obviously appreciate you guys, but you might
find valuable to go back and listen to the older episodes not necessarily in order, but it is
going to be helpful to fill in some of the gaps. Anyway, so C-cline, in case you forget who he was,
he kind of sat in this interesting period where he was sort of like kind of half bronze,
half silver era. So obviously, well and surely before anabolic, but kind of also before a lot of
the competitions like the Missy Universe began. So he's not, he's not as well renowned, I guess,
for that reason, like he didn't compete in some of those competitions. But if you do go back to that
sort of, you know, 1930s kind of era, you do obviously C-cline pop up a lot. He was a very
influential rider coach and I think as a gym owner as well. So he had a lot of athletes and
clients that he was working with. Now, he was also kind of one of those strong man types as well.
So again, if you look at the bronze era, we've got like a lot more strength feats as opposed to
more of these the typical bodybuilding shows that we know today. So we did talk about a beginner
plan from SIG a few weeks ago. And now what we're talking about is not necessarily beginner plan,
it's a plan that he worked out that he actually did himself. Now, I'm just going to jump into it.
It looks a little bit interesting on paper, but let's let's hop in. So buckle up, there's a bit here.
First up, well, let's make it simple. So every single exercise we're doing is single set.
So I'm not going to say that again. So just one set, 10 to 20 repetitions on average. Some of the
exercises, some of the lower body exercises we've talked about this before, less accessibility to
equipment, what's done, stuff like that. He did suggest going up to the 20 reps, some of the
lower, the upper body stuff was a little bit lower in repetition. The reps were not really as,
you know, as we've talked about before, there was often a little bit of leeway in kind of what
repetition someone would use, but generally speaking, we're talking about 10 to 20. So we begin with
a two arm curl. So a bicep curl, then we go to a lateral raise, and then we go to side bends. Now
we've talked about this before side bends did kind of they, they were common up until maybe the
use 50s and then we see them drop out, but they were a common at this point. We then go to alternating
dumbbell front raise back to side bends and then to a military press or barbell overhead press.
Then we go to the deep knee bend, which is our squats. We've basically just had upper body exercises
so far. Then we've got a squat and we go back to the alternating front raise and then we have a
triceps. It was called triceps push away. I believe there's kind of like a triceps press down
type exercise and it was bending forward to the waist and then we have chin up, which I know you'll
be very happy to see. And then we have a wrist exercise. So there was like a roller type contraption
that we're using and then we go into a leg curl. I've seen there would have been using iron boot
to this point. So there would have been strapping on weighted shoes basically to the link curl.
And we go to some calisthenics. So we had a press up to a handstand on a bench and then we've got
this crisscross exercise we've discussed in the past where I think it's sort of like a lateral
raise maybe in around the world style type exercise and he did this standing and then he did one
lying as well. So more of a fly slash I guess like a lying around the world type exercise.
And then into alternate dumbbell pullovers leg raise bar dips dumbbell curls with the palms facing
in with so like a hammock curl a leg crest. He would have been using a barbell on his feet at this
point and then they did yeah which is very funny when you see the diagrams of that. And then we
have a neck exercise and then we have a squat and a Roman chair which is basically a sexy squat
and then what we're called tiger bends which is another calisthenic exercise. It was kind of like a
almost like a handstand push up but going down to your forearms. So I don't know if you kept up
with me there there's a lot of exercises something like 18 and 19 different exercises and then some
of those you repeated a couple of times as well obviously single sets but if you've got a repeat
then we had two sets of some of those exercises that's a long session what do you make of that Chris?
Yeah there's a lot here I mean a couple of observations straight away there's a lot of shoulder
work so this is kind of taking me back to the sundial that we looked at the very beginning so
we've got a couple of sets of front raises we've got some lateral raises in there we've got
an overhead press the military press and then we've got these crisscross exercises which are
probably quite similar to that so there's a lot of different shoulder exercises in there which
I think is very interesting straight away just from a like you know aesthetic choice point of view
but also from an excise variation point of view. There's also a little bit of excise
a variation in terms of a couple of other muscle groups so particularly interest actually
in quads because a lot of the time we tend to view the quads as very homogenous and now we know
the wreck fam obviously isn't quite so homogenous we've got the upper and lower regions or proximal
and distal regions which you're going to see with a hip flexion and the extension without you know
thinking about squat and leg press type things for moment and so it's cool that we've got a leg raise
in here which is hip flexion because the wreck fam is the primary hip flexor and the first part of
that range of motion. We've also got the Roman chair squat which as you described to me before we
jumped on this podcast to do this it's kind of like a sissy squat so it's kind of like a wreck fam
sort of focused exercise there so it's interesting we've got some excise variety for quadriceps
really now we've got a squat we've also got a leg press I'm not sure that's really going to be
any different from a quadriceps point of view but it probably is going to be different from a hip
extensor point of view because obviously the squat comes all the way up to a hip extension for
hip extension. Now whereas the leg press works in a totally different range of motion it's very very
much more flex tip for the entirety of the situation in which you find yourself so there's some
variety though it's probably not quadriceps related variety just mentioning it because it does occur
with the quadriceps exercises. The thing that jumped out to me as you pointed out is that we do have
chin-ups in this program. Now being chin-ups it probably is sort of a sagittal or maybe a little
bit wider than that maybe more scapula but certainly it won't be frontal because it's really hard
to do frontal plane pulling with an underhand grip it just doesn't really work that well so I'm
guessing that is probably sagittal so okay fine there's nothing else though there's nothing
else for back but unless you argue that the pullovers are doing something for back and they didn't see
that as a back exercise they saw it as a as a lower back exercise exactly and we would say the
same thing now most of the time we find a lot of the things that they said are lining up with what
we would say now from biomechanics and physiology knowledge but it's interesting that yes the choice
of back exercises different from what we've seen in many other of these programs but the lack of
back exercises is not I mean that is a sort of a really distinctive feature of so many of these
programs that we look at is that the back exercises are on the weaker side in terms of the variety
of the other either pull up variation or been overgrown I think really that's the thing that I
keep coming back to which clashes with with what I would understand from a training sort of
point of view and what I'm seeing here most of the time my sort of expectations for what a good
training program would look like are lining up pretty well with what I see in these routines but
every single time I look at the back section of the workout planet just doesn't work properly
and I think that's really interesting that we do have the chin up here but we don't have anything
else I don't even have a deadly variation do I mean there's just nothing here at all and again
that's a strange thing to be seeing because you know given that we're working you know you've got
this leg press ridiculous leg press situation where you kind of balancing a bubble on your feet
you know danger of death danger of death is extremely high you know but you you can't bring yourself
to pick up a bar off the floor and do a deadlift I mean come on what's what's that all about so
there's so many times I have questions I can't be answered but that's kind of my first pass at my
thoughts of looking at this routine the triceps exercise I want to mention that I'm at a mistake
when I said it was like a cable push down type variation I remember now that Sig actually did
this with a barbell behind his back and so if you can imagine imagine holding a barbell behind
your back and then you pivot your like forwards the waist and you extend your arms behind your back
as far as you can so it's almost it's almost like a kick back type exercise but you're using a barbell
and so you're not getting the bend in the elbows when you're doing so does that make sense you can
you visualize what I'm I've talked to you about this a couple years ago I don't know if you remember
and this is an idea I do remember because you're potentially getting some long head in this exercise
aren't you so so what we're saying is this is a shoulder extension exercise yes past the point
to shoulder neutral position so we've gone past the analytical position we're now behind the back
and we're pushing into shoulder extension though
So that would be obviously sagittal plane. So from a lap point of view, be probably pretty similar to the chin ups, not really doing anything different.
But yeah, maybe there's, but I don't know. I mean, this is the issue that we face with from a triceps point of view, this is the issue that we face with when we're talking about things like dips and so forth.
You know, what does shoulder position pass the anatomical position due to the triceps brachylong head? Just don't know. I don't know of any day to the exists.
The wood would allow us. I mean, some people have speculated that the long head may become a shoulder flexor at that point. You know, I mean, not saying that's right. Well, that's wrong.
I don't think there is any data at all that would tell us what that is, muscle is doing at that point.
But yes, so potentially that might not even be a triceps exercise. It could be something completely different.
Interesting. You've got dips in here as well. We haven't seen dips utilized that often. I think maybe maybe one or two of the plans so far, but not a whole lot.
And these obviously got the calisthenics work in there as well. So from an exercise selection standpoint, this is somewhat different to a lot of the plans we've talked about so far.
It is. I think there's, yeah, as you say, maybe 18 or 19 exercises and a couple of repetitions repetitions mostly on the shoulder stuff again.
Yeah, interesting kind of aesthetic choice there. So we're definitely seeing a throwback to that, you know, kind of maybe bronze era of focusing on that shoulder development, not so much on peck development.
But again, you know, as we always kind of say when we look at these routines, sometimes maybe there were personal reasons for choices.
People have felt that they were very well developed in some areas and not so well developed in other areas. So maybe they put routines together the favored them personally, you know, so sometimes I think I can't always say, well, this is what they were doing for aesthetic reasons or this is what they were doing because they thought it was best.
Sometimes it's like, well, maybe they were just doing that because that's what they needed to do.
And maybe he felt at this time that shoulder development, what he needed, but the variety is really what is fascinating because there's a lot of variety going on here in that in that respect.
Yeah, and I will just quickly mention this workout was actually documented relatively late. We're talking early 50s, even though these exercises are very much bronze era type exercises.
So I suspect we are also seeing this summer's six, you know, personal bias or preference, then in terms of what he maybe, you know, desires and physique in terms of the exercise selection.
No, absolutely. No, that makes sense.
So 18 and 19 exercises, a couple of double ups. I mean, this is interesting as well because at this point the set system did exist and he was choosing not to do the set system.
He was choosing not to do, you know, multiple sets in a row who's actually choosing to eat a couple of exercises, which I think is interesting in and of itself, but maybe a topic for another day.
So it's a lot of different exercises and we're going to talk a little bit about the necessity to perform many different exercises or not.
So do you want to introduce us to this idea?
Yeah, so essentially this is a continuation of the neuro mechanical matching discussions that we've had previously on this podcast. So if neuro mechanical matching is a new idea to you,
then I would strongly recommend that you scroll back on our list of podcasts and find the one in which we've gone through the entirety of the idea in totality and discussed the various criticisms and what we know about it.
Why we think it makes the most sense as a way of talking about or a way of describing how the central nervous system decides where to send its neural drive during a movement.
Now what we're going to talk about today is a much more practical kind of aspect of that, which is, you know, where do you draw the line in terms of biasing specific regions?
Now when I say bias, you have to think about that in the context of what new mechanical matching is actually doing.
So let me give a very quick outline of what's happening. So essentially what neuro mechanical matching says is that the central nervous system will always prefer to use muscles or regions of muscles.
And you can you can kind of do a Russian doll thing and go down to the smallest level if you want.
So you know muscles and then regions and then sub regions and nothing you want to do there will talk more about that later on. Essentially it always prefers to use the muscle fibers of specific motions which have the best leverage and it'll try and use those first and then move on to muscle regions or specifically the muscle fibers associated with motions that have worse leverage later on.
Now essentially an example of that would be if you're doing a sagittal plane pulling motion, whether it's a pull down or a row, you'll find that if you look at the leverages, the posterior deltoid has by foreign away the best leverage of any muscle in that kind of that can work in that scenario.
So generally speaking, what will happen is that the posterior deltoid will receive a lot of the motions in that posterior deltoid will receive muscle activation preferentially to muscle fibers or motunits in the in the last course, the posterior deltoid doesn't have a lot of motunits in it.
So what you're going to find is that the brain will start sending center motor command to the posterior deltoid and as you start increasing your effort level and producing more and more center motor command, you'll run out of places to send that center motor command in the posterior deltoid and you'll end up sending it to the thoracic region of the lab.
Now, eventually you'll end up kind of capping out because there's a maximum amount of center motor and you can actually generate according to the norcora's model of the psychobiological model of details is that we reach our maximum section of effort, we can't produce any more center motor command and you're going to cap out.
So essentially what this is showing us is that the posterior deltoid probably doesn't receive the majority of the center motor command.
I mean, this is an interesting point, actually, is to this is why biomechanists can get really confused and they go, but I don't understand principle of numerical matching because the latter is the prime mover or the thoracic latter is the prime mover and the subject of playing pool motion.
So how are you saying that the posterior deltoid gets preferential treatment? Well, because the posterior deltoid comes first, so the brain sends it first and then when you get to the top of the activation of posterior deltoid, you move on to the thoracic lat.
And yes, the thoracic lat has more total motor units. So if you look at the total amount of center motor command that has gone to the thoracic lat and the posterior deltoid at maximum effort, more center motor command has gone to the thoracic lat, but it didn't get sent that activation first.
So it wasn't preferentially activated. There's an interesting distinction there to be made and that's why biomechanists are getting really, really confused about what nearly kind of commuting is telling us.
Don't know if you ever did this on acidity camps, you know, school camps and stuff like that as a child and one of the camp tricks or little games that people would do is they would stack glasses and you'd have, you know, four or five glasses stacked together and then you would pour water in the top and in the first one to fill up and then it would overflown to next one, you would make it fountain basically.
And essentially it's not perfect, but that's kind of what we're getting out is there might be a smaller glass atop. It fills up and then it overflows.
And so there might be a larger glass beneath which is getting more water or eventually once you've once you've finished emptying the jug of whatever you're pouring onto those glasses.
Yes, you'll find that the larger glasses do carry more water, but they weren't filled first. And that's exactly what's happening. You're right. That's exactly what's happening in this example.
But I mentioned that as an aside that the thing I'm pointing out here is that the way that neuromaconic imaging works is to preferentially send activation to those muscle regions or specifically motor units that have the best leverage.
And then obviously move on to ones that don't have quite so good leverage that still do fundamentally the same joint action just not as efficiently because efficiency is produced by having a large momentum because you get a larger joint talk for the same amount of muscle force.
That you are producing with the motor units that you're activating. Is that all okay so far? Yes, awesome.
So essentially then what we need to do is to say, well, okay, how do we know what number of exercises might be appropriate for a muscle group?
Because we've talked just now about how maybe the thoracic lat is, you know, the main region of the lat that gets used in the size of the plane motion. And I've mentioned before that the lumbar and pelvic regions of the lat tend to be the best have the best leverage for frontal plane motions for that.
One of the reasons why I always look at the programmers of these silver and bronzer bodybuilders and I kind of am very critical of the back kind of side of things, the back training side of things.
You can do the same thing for the delts. I mean, you know, bodybuilders are very, you know, well aware that you need multiple exercises for the delts that there's very specific regions.
And the same thing applies to the pecs. You got, you know, kind of a particular middle, sternal and lower coastal regions of the pecs. It's all kind of like these various different regions.
So, you know, what point do we stop? I mean, I think if you kind of just come back to this Russian doll idea, you know, one of the interesting couple of interesting studies that have been done over the last couple of decades
have shown that our classical representations of anatomy, where we say, look, you know, the lat has these three major regions.
When look, the delts have these three major regions and the pecs have these three major regions. And then maybe somebody will come along and go, well, hang on a minute.
You know, if you do this much more careful analysis of the cadavers or the electromography or whatever they may be using to inform them about what's going on.
You can say, well, actually there's seven regions here. There's not three. You can subdivide some of these regions.
And going back to this Russian doll idea, you can probably subdivide the subdivisions, you know, because ultimately, where you know mechanical matching works is on a motor unit basis.
So you can go right the way down to motor unit and all the muscle fibers of that motor unit will react to it. You can't go any lower than that because muscle fibers don't get activated separately.
If they're part of a motor unit, you know, they will get activated. It's kind of like once you get down to motor unit level, that's as far as it will go.
So you can go no subdivide your subdivisions. So I think there's a really interesting conversation here.
This is the topic of today's, kind of, the topic of the physiology part today's podcast
is to say, "Well, how far can we go?"
And what I want to do is just share some ideas that will help us refine, you know, where
that limit might arise.
But ultimately, where I want to start is to say that we're going to end up describing
a sliding scale whereby you can move in a direction and you'll get essentially diminishing
returns.
The further you kind of go with this, it's like you can get quite a long way with a
little bit of exercise variation, but you can get further with a bit more exercise variation.
But what you can find as we talk this through is that the benefits of extreme exercise variation
are going to get much, much smaller and potentially become only interesting to the most advanced
people, which is potentially a trend that we have seen in the past whereby, as you've
pointed out, you kind of become more advanced, you add exercises and then you end up with
this great exercise variation with more advanced training.
Before you jump into it any further, I have to have a question.
So you've mentioned regions, sub-regions, is there like an actual definition for what
will class a region versus a sub-region or is it, are we just kind of working on this
sliding scale, like you're saying?
So before I answer that question, I'd probably not going to answer it very well, but before
I answer, I just want to mention that when we're dealing with terminology, we have to be
extremely careful that our terminology is rooted in physiological reality.
So one of my criticisms that I often raise, and I repeat this when I do my mentorship,
is that the central nervous system doesn't know that we've given all these different
names to all the muscles at the body, it doesn't know that.
It doesn't know that we've said, oh look, this is the hamstrings muscle group.
We're going to call this semi-tendonosis and this is a completely separate muscle called
the semi-membranosus, doesn't know that.
We've done that from an anatomical, from dissection studies in the past, looking at all the different
muscles and anatomically studying them.
But the central nervous system doesn't know that.
All it knows really is that these motunits have these leverages.
So ultimately, the central nervous system thinks in terms of motunits and then what we do
is we map the anatomy on top of that and we say, well, in this exercise, what we're mostly
seeing is motunits in the semi-tendonosis working.
Okay, but the CNS doesn't see it that way, it just sees leverages.
So ultimately, anatomical descriptions are only ever going to be like a map placed
onto a terrain.
The map is not the terrain, you know, it's close to it, but it's not the same thing.
So you kind of got a mapping effect where you're saying, this is what we are describing
as being these muscles and these muscle regions, but the fundamental reality is that the physiology,
the brain, the CNS and all the various parts of that only respect the existence of motunits
with specific leverages.
And what we're doing is just placing a template on top of that and saying, this is what
broadly seems to work when these exercises are done.
We see those regions, but that's not what the CNS is thinking.
Does that make sense?
Yeah, I think that's a good, that's really helpful, I think, for this conversation.
So we've always got to be very careful about when we're, because one of the rather unpleasant
consequences of naming something is that you think you kind of now understand it, you
know, and I think that's a very, very difficult kind of, it's a very, very easy trap to fall
into and it's a very difficult trap to extricate, so from when you fall into it is like, because
I've named it, I now understand what it does, it's like, ultimately this is the base of
all the problems that bodybuilders have when they go, this exercise trains the hamstrings.
What they've just done there is they've named something, the hamstrings and they've described
an exercise having an effect on that thing that they've named and they've gone, this does
that.
Well, physiological reality isn't, that isn't what's happening, you know, there's a messiness,
there's a kind of yes, there's a bunch of motunits that are being recruited, but they're
not going to map perfectly onto what you've named.
There'll be other stuff going on and not every motunit in all of the hamstrings, it's
going to act, it's going to be recruited in response to the exercise that you've done.
When we say, oh, this exercise works that muscle straight away, you fall into a trap because
that's not what's happening.
Now, I know we use that shorthand and we say that and we're like, oh, yeah, this exercise
does this and this exercise does that.
Not really, that's not really what's going on because there isn't a mechanism by which
that can happen.
Oh, no, you know, the brain is switching that muscle on, that's just not what happens.
The brain controls motor units.
That's how it works.
And if those motunits happen to be scattered across this part of the muscle and someone
another muscle, then fine, that's what's going on.
But there isn't a scenario where, you know, you do this exercise, oh, well, I'm working
the triceps.
So many times you open up, you know, Instagram or TikTok or whatever and somebody is talking
to camera going, oh, this exercise works, the triceps, oh, this exercise works the entire
lat.
I mean, like, that's just not physiologically what's happening, you know, but this is the
track that people fall into when they don't start with what physiologically is going on.
They don't look at Neumann can't go much in there and understand what is actually being
done.
So ultimately, you know, when you want to answer questions like, you know, what definitions
do we have, which was what you asked me, you asked me, what is the definition of a muscle
in the sub region?
Because ultimately that's just not something that the CNS understands.
You can get anatomical definitions of these things and you can say, well, you know, what
is the anatomical definition of the anterior glute medius, well, yeah, you can get someone
to draw a line on an anatomical one, a sort of picture for you and show you what the borders
of that muscle region are, but it doesn't tell you anything from an exercise selection
point of view because ultimately it's about motine, it's not about regions.
And potentially if we were to try to come up with barriers of what class as a sub region
or not would probably be looking at that from a leverage standpoint in terms of what does
this function?
And then that would actually change potentially from person to person as well.
It will do.
Absolutely.
Broadly speaking, obviously, if you think about it, if you have a few backing up one step,
motor units are usually what we call quasi randomly distributed inside muscles.
So what that means is that you'll get a bunch of motor units and the muscle fibers that
they are, you know, kind of sort of hesitate to use the word governing.
But the muscle fibers are the part of that motor unit.
So if you've got a motor neuron that's innovating a bunch of muscle fibers, those muscle fibers
will tend to cluster in one particular area within the muscle.
There's a tendency for people to think that, you know, if you have a motor unit, the
muscle fibers are all over the place.
There's not how it works.
So you get like a specific area inside a muscle and you'll find that all the muscle fibers
associated with that motor unit are all going to switch on in that particular area.
Not like in a single fascicle, so they're not grouped in that logical way that we might
think they are going to be quasi randomly sort of located in a particular area.
Essentially what that means is that your motor unit has a specific leverage effect because
if you think about a muscle fiber in a particular part of a muscle and then you look at the
most fibers near by it, by definition, they're all going to have similar leverages because
they're all in the same place, you know.
So you get your motor units, therefore if you have a bunch of motor units, which are
all kind of in the same sort of area of a muscle, they're all going to have a similar
leverage.
So when we talk about regions, what we're saying in a very kind of fuzzy way is that these
motor units that are operating in this area because they will have muscle fibers that are
very sort of close by each other, they will have similar leverages.
And so we can kind of just draw a rough circle around it and say these motor units kind
of have a regional kind of characteristic to them and you can say, well, this bit and
you can point at it and you know, this bit here of the lat, you know, I mean, some really
nice electromography studies that show that might even be lateral medial variations in
lat kind of function and you can just kind of draw a circle around it and go, well, this
bit of the lat maybe does a bit more of this and this bit of lat maybe does more of this
because the brain will preferentially activate it.
So more of it will end up getting switched on, I'll explain how that works in a minute.
But ultimately what we're saying then is that you can't really kind of just say, oh look,
this precise area here, like a steak, you might sort of identify as sort of if you're kind
of thinking like that.
But you know, you kind of got this section on the muscle and you can say like, well, this
does this.
Well, no, that's not the way the body works.
It doesn't work in terms of, you know, anatomical chunks of meat doing different things.
It works in terms of motor units, which are loosely mapped across regions, but you
do get enough of a kind of connection to be able to say, well, yeah, the anterior, you
know, glute medias tends to do most, you know, it tends to be highly activated.
Lots of motor units get accreted when you're doing internal, you know, hip rotation, whereas
the posterior tends to get more exercise next on that rotation.
And so you can kind of go down that route of loosely mapping the food things on top of
each other, but just remembering that when we are naming stuff anatomically, that actually
doesn't connect logically with what's happening physiologically, we are literally just mapping
in the same way that you might say, try to think of an example, you might say, I don't
know, maybe you've got a couple of businesses in a particular area of town and there's
a small kind of square with a bunch of coffee shops and all these businesses at lunchtime,
all the people, the employees come out and they go into the coffee shops and they drink
their lunch and then they go back to their work.
Now, you could say that because of just the sheer volume of customers that you're seeing
from those businesses, that if you were to go in a coffee shop and you were to ask everybody
who works at these three businesses, if you put the hands in the air, you know, you'd probably
find the majority of the people in that coffee shop were from one of those two businesses.
But you'd also get people from other places as well because they're a coffee shop, it's
public.
kind of place. And you've got people, do you see what I'm saying? So it's like, you can't
map directly these things on top of each other because they aren't actually connected.
So there isn't a scenario where you can go, oh look, in this exercise, the entirety of this,
you know, kind of thoracic reason that that is being used. No, it's just not how it works. Yes,
we talk about that from a short endpoint to view. No, that's not how it works. So you end up with
a Russian dollar effect where you can go all the way down to motor units, but that's the lowest you
can go. That's the smallest Russian dollar you can reach. Everything above that is very, very fuzzy
because as you pointed out, there'll be individual differences, but yeah, the fuzziness doesn't
detract from the truth of the matter, which is, yeah, you will find that most of that area,
the motor units in that area tend to have the best leverage. That's just the way it works.
In terms of, you know, finding the massifiers with best leverage is going to be, they're going to be
located in that particular area. So naming stuff and saying, this is a region and it automatically
means that that region is fully accurate. No, that's not what you can do, but you can loosely say,
yes, most of the notifications that have preferential recruitment status because they have us,
that we will be found in this area. And same way that, you know, if you go to the coffee shop,
most of the people there are going to work for those two big businesses. Yeah, great. And obviously,
that also means that there'll be motor units that are conventionally, we would say part of a different
muscle or muscle region or whatever that might also be. Absolutely. You could just find that
something weird gets recruited but won't be very particularly, won't be very big. I wouldn't
have thought they would just be, you know, here or there. So again, we're mapping the way that
the CNS works onto our understanding of human anatomy and they're not going to line up perfectly.
I can't. You cannot say this region, that region, the other region with absolute certainty.
There's always going to be that fuzziness. It doesn't mean we can't try and it doesn't mean we
can't be, you know, as accurate as we possibly can about saying, well, yeah, mostly this region,
mostly that region. There's always going to be that uncertainty. So what do we do with that? Talk
is over this sliding scale. So basically, where we get to then is to say, well, what do we know
about the way in which motor units are recruited in different exercises? And how does that then
translate to understanding what occurs in this kind of, this Russian doll kind of situation
that we're talking about with Neurokake Imagine? Well, what we're going to look at is this idea
of voluntary activation deficits and how voluntary activation deficits will change according
to the exercise that you're doing. So essentially, imagine that, well, let's talk, let's talk
through it from two perspectives, one from a muscle perspective and one from an exercise perspective.
So if you look at it from a muscle perspective, if you go through the list of muscles and their
voluntary activation deficits, now a voluntary activation deficit means that you can't voluntarily
hence voluntary to wait all the motor units in that muscle in a maximal effort. So if you look at
a standard knee extension test, the voluntary activation deficit for a knee extension test
is generally around about 10 to 15%, pushing 20% in some situations. So a big chunk of the
motor units just not being switched on, despite the fact that people are giving it everything
they possibly can in that situation. How do we know that? Because we have something called the
interpolated twitch, which is where you superimpose electrical stimulus on top of the muscle while
you're doing the maximum effort. And that gives you an index of how much more muscle fiber
area you could actually activate and contribute to the contraction. It doesn't tell you if you are
not activating muscle fibers that don't have leverage though. So this is something really important.
So let me just go down another quick rabbit hole. I know that this is turning into a massive
kind of rabbit hole ridden. Well, if people understand what you're about to say and what you've
just said, it will actually have a really important implication for how you choose exercise
selection in right out program. So I think you should pay it.
The voluntary activation test that we use is called the interpolated twitch method. Now basically,
as I say, involves doing a maximalisometric contraction. So you're giving every bit of effort
you possibly can for three to five seconds. And that should basically recruit all the
motunits. I mean, in a perfect world, you would recruit all your motunits that have leverage to do
that particular exercise. Now, some people think that it also recruits motunits that don't have leverage.
Now, this kind of will work through that in a moment. But basically, the electrical stimulus
that's placed on top of that maximal effort then tells you whether you've got muscle fibers that
have leverage that are not being used. And in quadriceps, situations in the extension, you get about,
as I say, maybe 10, 15% a little bit more. Now, as you start to look at smaller and smaller muscles,
you'll find that a voluntary activation deficit gets smaller and smaller and smaller. And it
gradually grades down from the glutes and the quads all the way down to maybe the elbow flexors,
where you start to see maybe two, three percent deficits are really, really tiny. If you go past that
and you start looking at like wrist muscles and finger muscles, you don't generally see any
voluntary activation deficits at all. So, what that's telling you is that the reason that we are getting
a voluntary activation deficit is because the amount of centromotic band is bigger when you have
more motunits because that's what you generally find is the bigger muscle have more motunits. So,
you've got bigger muscles and more motunits. You need more centromotic band to get to the top end
of that sort of sequence of motunits. And you don't get there. You actually stop before you get
to the top. Now, Henneman's size principle obviously is applying. So, you're going to start with the
easiest to sort of recruit motunits with the fewest number of fibers and work you wear at the top.
But, you know, essentially, Henneman's size principle is going to work inside of the
principal pneumocannic matching. You're always going to start with the chunks of muscle that have
best leverage and, you know, kind of work up from that. Now, when you get to the top of your
sequences, you're doing any extension and your sort of voluntary activation deficit measurement
is telling you that you've got, say, ten to fifteen percent of the of the fibers that have good
leverage are not being used. That's not telling you about the fibers that don't have leverage
because they can't produce force and they can't produce force in the voluntary contraction,
sorry, torque. They can't produce torque in the voluntary contraction because even if they had
the ability to be activated, the muscle force wouldn't produce torque. Yeah, having leverage.
And similarly, in the involuntary contraction, if you electrically stimulated some muscle fibers
that didn't have any leverage, this wouldn't add any torque, so you wouldn't measure that either.
So they don't hit either side of the equation. So you're literally invisible to you. So it's
entirely possible that when we talk about voluntary activation deficits, which is not entirely possible,
it's absolutely guaranteed. It's absolutely guaranteed that not only are we missing the activation
of muscle fibers that have leverage because that's what a voluntary activation deficit measurement
tells you is happening. You're also missing stuff that's not being activated and doesn't have leverage.
So when we say that, you know, say, fifteen percent of the muscle is not being activated in a
in a maximal voluntary adjustment, that's massively underestimating what's actually happening
because if you don't have leverage, then muscle fibers wouldn't be activated anyway,
they're even contributing torque. So there's other stuff that's not being used and therefore
voluntary activation deficits are actually a lot bigger than they appear to be. But as I say,
they get smaller and smaller and smaller as you progress down to smaller and smaller amounts of
muscle mass. Now the same thing happens in exercise selection. So if you start out with a squat or a
deadlift or something like that, your voluntary activation is going to be huge. You're going to miss
huge chunks of muscle that you just can't physically activate because you can't get the amount
of centromate command to be produced in order to recreate those motions. As you come down to a more
sort of smaller muscle mass exercise, like a leg press or a knee extension or a single leg
extension, first example of course being the bilateral force deficit when you go from single leg,
sorry, two leg to single leg, you increase the amount of motions that are being recruited,
10%, 15%, or so. And you massively increase the amount of activation that you can achieve.
So amount of muscle mass really in both of these examples, whether it's muscle mass per muscle
or it's muscle mass across a bunch of exercise, sorry, across the exercise that you're doing,
or because you need more muscles to do, more complex exercise or you need obviously two limbs to do
two limb versus one limb to do one limb. You find that it's literally because the brain is
capping out at a certain effort perception level and the more centromate command you're sending
to more places, more motunits, the earlier you're going to hit that limit. So what we're going to
see then is that any discussion of regions and regional targeting has to take into account a,
the size of the muscle mass that you're working with. So like it's different question to talk
about biasing parts of the elbow flexor group, from it is talking about biasing parts of the hamstring
muscle group, for example, or the lat. I mean, it's just a different animal because you're working
with a completely different amount of muscle mass in those situations, you know. So, but also,
if you're talking about biasing when you're doing bench press variations or squat variations,
that's a different conversation. From if you're talking about biasing, when you're doing single joint,
triceps or single joint elbow flexion type stuff, you know, the conversation needs to take place
in the context of voluntary activation deficit because the bigger the voluntary activation deficit
that you are working with, the more motunits are going to get excluded, even if they have leverage.
So if you start with something like a really small amount of muscle mass, like elbow flexor type
exercise, mostly what you're going to find is that the muscle fibers that get excluded, they're just
going to have any leverage at all. And you're not going to see much of voluntary activation deficits
as a result. In fact, some people get really exercised when I talk about voluntary activation
deficits in the context above flexors. And they go, oh, no, no, no, we've seen really tiny
voluntary activation deficits. Therefore, we don't think that there are situations.
We think that every single muscle fiber in their reflexes is accurate whenever we do any kind of
biceps curl. I'm like, do you not understand what voluntary activation deficit is doing?
Not tests is literally not testing muscle fibers that don't have taught producing capacity.
So, if you have a situation where the muscle fibers that don't have leverage, they won't get
switched on.
There's so many important things you said there. I just want to recap a couple of those things.
And the last one you're saying there, I don't know if people realize how important that is.
So, give you an example earlier of the re-adults in a row. And that's when I give the glass analogy,
and you're filling up the glass with the jug of water. And there's a difference between the
re-adults in a row and the elbow effects and muscles in whatever elbow effects exercise you're doing,
because what you're saying is, yes, even though the elbow effects have a high voluntary activation,
so you can almost, a whole elbow effects degree, we can activate almost.
You're saying that if there's any modalities within that group that simply don't have the
leverage to do that exercise at all, then they're obviously not going to be recruited.
Whereas if we're talking about the re-adults in a row, the re-adults have the leverage to do that
row, so that we're going to have maximum recruitment of re-adults. So, that in of itself, that tells you,
from an exercise selection standpoint, it tells us we need to be looking at leverage.
We can't just be looking at voluntary activation, because voluntary activation is not the whole
picture. If there's any, like you said, if there's any modalities that don't have leverage in that
movement, voluntary activation is always going to be misleading. We can't just be working off that.
What is not going to tell you what you think it's telling you, if you're misunderstand that.
So, as I say, there's been a lot of people who said, look, we found this study and it shows that,
you know, you've got, you know, sort of no voluntary activation deficit or minimal voluntary
activation deficit in the crisis bracket, in this, in this asymmetric contraction involving the
elbow flexors. I'm like, yeah, okay. Well, that doesn't mean that there aren't other elbow flexor
motinets that are simply not being switched on, because they don't have any leverage for what you're
trying to do. And that's totally, you know, kind of within the scope of what we talk about,
when we talk about neurochemical matching. So, I think.
So, there we have people. If you've got the way to think about it, it's just like, if you have a
voluntary activation deficit, the only thing that you can be sure about is that there are motinets
with leverage that are not being switched on. If you don't have a voluntary activation deficit
or if it's minimal, then you can be sure that any motinet that has leverage is being used.
But what you can't say is that there are motinets that don't have leverage that are still being used.
That's not a valid statement. You know, if they are, if they have kind of,
if they're part of the same group that they don't have leverage at that particular joint angle,
then it's highly unlikely that the CNS would turn them on. I don't believe the CNS would turn them on.
And you wouldn't detect that with a voluntary activation deficit measurement. That's the key.
So, say you've got an exercise like a pull down or a row. You've got some kind of back exercise,
and which I know is ironic, given the conversation so far, call in a back exercise. But then you've
got people saying, well, biceps, you know, obviously high levels of recruitment in a back exercise.
Therefore, you're going to see biceps growth doing these back exercises and you don't actually need
to do any biceps curls. How is that different to the example we've given with the row in the posterior
delt? Essentially, what we're talking about, where is that glass in order of that fountain that I
suggested? And if the biceps bracket had the best leverage for that back exercise, then theoretically,
that would be correct. Wouldn't that you wouldn't actually need? Well, as long as in terms of the
motor use that have leverage in that particular exercise. So again, we're getting it's a little bit
confusing here. But essentially, if the biceps specific exercise or a single joint exercise didn't
have, oh, wasn't recruiting motor use that had leverage that didn't have leverage in that back exercise,
then you could argue you didn't actually need a single joint biceps exercise, couldn't you?
Yeah, I think you probably could make that argument. I mean, the end of the day, you know,
you have to look at what the weak link in the exercises. You know, what's the, what's the,
what's the muscle that is really kind of going to be the sticking point? Because that's kind of
way you need to start if you if you're looking for the muscle that's going to end up with, you know,
the majority of the motor units being being activated. And I don't think that's true in a case of a
pull-up or a pull-down situation. I don't think that the biceps bracket or the elbow flexors are
the limiting factor. I say that because you can modify the pull-up exercise. I used to do this
quite a lot when I was doing one on pull-up training. And you can place, say for example, we have a pull-up
rack and you have the ability to place another bar, maybe sort of six to nine inches below that first
bar. So where your, where your hands are grasping the bar, the bar is maybe like sort of two-thirds
of the way down your forearm. There's now another bar blocking you from going forward underneath the
bar when you do your pull-up. So essentially what it does, it turns the pull-up into a sort of
like sort of almost like a biceps curl combination with a pull-up because you put up maybe a pad to
allow some, you know, comfort for your forearm, but basically then just rotate and do a biceps curl
really with your body weight. And that's a really interesting training exercise for one on pull-ups
if you find that your elbow flexors are limitation, like they were for me. You won't be able to
anywhere near as much weight when you do that as you would if you were doing a pull-up. So I think
there's some really interesting kind of tests that you can kind of play around with, but ultimately I
think, you know, I don't think many people are going to find that their elbow flexors are limitation
on pulling exercises most of the time. So they're not going to be requiring them to work maximally
and they're going to have that deficit is going to be largely on those muscles really rather than
that will be on something like the lap, for example, or the posterior dot. So essentially what we're
talking about so far is a resource allocation issue, like we've got a certain amount of central
motor command and exactly, regardless of whether we're talking about an exercise, we're talking about
muscles, we're just talking about where are we sending that central motor command? Exactly, that's
really what's going on. And, you know, the CNS is trying to make the exercise happen in the most
efficient way possible. And so what it's going to do is it's going to start with the stuff that needs
activation because it's the limitation. And that has best leverage to overcome that limitation.
So you can literally state it in two sentences, you know. So if your primary limitation in a
pulling exercise is the is the shoulder extension movement in the side of the plane, you're going
to find that the posterior deltoid gets a big chunk of activation ahead of anything else. But the
issue is we've always got to see this in the context of, you know, what muscle groups are we dealing
with? Are we dealing with big muscle groups? In which case we are going to have a
voluntary activation deficit issue. And we are going to leave our unit a recruitment on the
table because we just can't get there. Or do we have a big muscle mass exercise issue? As in,
are we doing rows and pull downs and presses and stuff like that? Squats and deadlifts? In which
case, again, we're going to have issues. And the more that we work with big muscle groups in large
muscle mass exercises, we're going to have a bigger voluntary activation deficit to work with,
we're going to end up with a bigger likelihood that more regions of the muscle are going to get left
behind. So anything the size of elbow flexors that are before this voluntary activation deficit?
Basically, yeah. But as I say, again, sliding scale. So the more you move up the scale with,
so like you're using big muscle mass exercises with big muscles, you're going to have some really
big voluntary activation deficit issues. That's where you want to focus your attention in terms of,
you know, region biasing because that is where the money is going to come from, you know. And I think
when people were talking about saying, well, I'm doing, you know, hip thrusts for glutes and that's
all I'm doing. I'm like, if you're looking for my glute development, you're probably going to need
another exercise. That's not going to be it for the, yes, I think glute bridge and hip thrust are
the best glute exercise you possibly do. But it's a massive muscle muscle muscle to begin with.
And you are doing a multi joint exercise. So looking at possible ways of biasing upper and lower
regions. And I think the hip thrust already does a decent job of biasing the lower region,
looking at the upper region exercise like a hip abduction, C to the production, for example,
is a very good idea because you are straight away looking at multiple regions. When people are
looking at saying, oh, I want to try and bias multiple regions within the elbow flexor group,
you're on a totally different end of the scale then. You're looking at a much smaller,
and I'm not against it. Absolutely not. I've said a number of times I think brachy radialis versus
brachy is a really, really important one to think about biasing. Fundamentally, the amount of
value you're going to get out of that extract out of that variation is going to be a lot smaller than
the amount of value you're going to extract from biasing the hip thrust with the glute max in the
hip thrust versus the C to the hip abduction. Yeah. And incidentally, it's a
little bit unrelated, but it's related in a way that would mean that that techniques that you're
using methods are using to increase moody energy treatment are going to be potentially more effective
than some of these muscles with a larger voluntary deficit, activation deficit, then say something
like the biceps brachy. So if you were, you could do something like that that potentially
would make more sense for quads. Yeah, I mean, you could find yourself going off the end of what
you need to go on. You need to do, if that makes sense. So if you're trying to maximize growth in
the elbow flex complex, and you've picked a couple of exercises that you think one target's
brachialis, another target's price is brachy. And you're kind of asking yourself, do I need something
to target the brachialis as well? You might find that the value that you're able to extract there
is really small because you've kind of almost capped out the brachialis already because you are so
close, it would only really apply if you genuinely didn't have any motunits that had leverage for
those other two movements in the brachialis itself. This is how that works. So it's like the value
you can extract is progressively smaller and smaller and smaller, the less muscle mass you're using
and the smaller the muscles are that you're trying to target. So if you consider it like, for example,
we talked at the beginning of this podcast about shoulder development with the choice of lots of
different exercises for the shoulders, you know, the issue that you've got there is that, you know,
we've got a very complex
sort of muscle group that does a lot of different things. Now, this brings another dimension to it
because if you have a muscle group that has extremely divergent functions as parts, then there's
a higher probability that you're going to have motines that simply don't have any leverage at all
for some other things that you're doing. So, I mean, for obvious example, if you're doing some kind
of transverse plane pressing exercise, bench pressing exercise, you know, you're not going to get
anything on the posterior side of that delta complex doing anything at all. Whereas if you're
working in the frontal plane, there's a high probability that you're going to get some stuff
from the posterior side working as well as some of the stuff in the anterior side working.
The issue here is that when you got a big divergent, so I'm going to sort of sort of start to see
losses happening more, you know, obviously in that, in that snow. So, this would be a lot simpler if
we had this information, which we don't, which would be imagine you've got 100% of possible
total motor units and muscle. And then if we were able to say in what I've exercised, I'd say 80%,
we've got a voluntary activation of, you know, potentially 80%, but then we're saying that
or if we worked out the way we say 90% of these motor units have leverage in this exercise,
but then we've only got volunteer activation of 70% of those. So, it would be able to actually-
That's a really good way of looking at it actually. That's a really good way of looking at it. So,
it's like saying, you know, I don't go about the loot example. You might say, you know, the problem
we've got is actually primarily voluntary activation deficit related because you might say, well,
the upper glue is actually pretty decent hip extensor. So, it could contribute pretty well if it
were allowed to. You can't get it to because you can't get that high. So, what's going to happen
is that the CNS is going to just recruit all the lower glutes as much as it possibly can,
and then move into the upper glute to the cups out. It could carry on. If you have the ability to
carry on going, you can't. Yeah, see, that would be really interesting information because then
what you could say, because if we have an issue where you've got, let's say, it's like the glass
analogy again, a glass holds a hundred mil, but you've only got 80 mils of water. This is a central
motor command issue. Then what you would do is you would just say do single limb or you'd do
something that just means there's less muscle mass being used. But if we're saying, well, it's not
a matter of how much water, it's a matter of some of those motions aren't able to just don't
have leverage, well, then it's not about reducing the amount of muscle mass. It's about actually doing
something different entirely. It is. But equally, if you were to stick with the shoulder example,
you could still do a whole bunch of different pressing exercises in all kinds of weird directions,
and you still have a long tractivation deficit problem because it's just a lot of muscle mass
that you're using. Again, you've still got the same issue, it's just that your priorities have
changed. In the case of the glute, your priority is largely voluntary tractivation problem because
you just can't get there. With the case of shoulder, your issue is primarily a, I can't use these
motions because the brain won't switch them on because they just don't have any leverage. But I also
have a voluntary tractivation problem. If I do a whole bunch of different pressing exercises,
I'm still not maxing out my potential in those situations. Then you kind of start
into looking at why sig blind might have had so many weird different shoulder exercises because
that's pretty much the only way you can get to the point where you can really maximize
all the relevant to that muscle route because you've got a deficit if you use bigger muscle mass
exercises. If you start using single limb exercise, you get a lot closer. If you start using
single joint stuff like he's doing these front raises, these left raises, starting to move into
the territory where he's trying to maximize region specific hypertrophy in that way. So it's
it's fundamentally impossible that someone could say I can do this single exercise and maximize
development in ex muscle. The only, where your wrist flexor, wrist, wrist curls, you could probably
argue that for if you really wanted to. I'm not sure it really is true because I think you still have
a neurological matching issue. Broadly speaking, I mean, just if somebody thinks you can do one exercise
and maximize growth for a whole muscle like a lat, they don't understand voluntary activation
deficits and they don't understand the principle of neurological matching. I mean, that's just how it is
because if you got voluntary activation deficit, you are not recruiting all the motunits and so straight
to way, they could say, oh, this, this rearing exercise or this pull down recruits the whole lat.
Straight to way, I can prove you wrong because I can literally do it one arm and I've just
activated more motunits. So you need to know exactly. You don't even need to wear that wrong matching.
No, I can do it from bilateral false deficit. I can literally tell you you're wrong because I can
just switch to a single arm variation and I've just recruited more motunits. So straight to way,
anybody saying that this exercise recruits the whole pack or this exercise recruits the whole
lat, just simply wrong because the bilateral false deficit proves you wrong and you can do it yourself
in a gym and prove that it's correct because you'll get more reps for the same relative, you know,
kind of take, you know, 50% of the weight and you get more reps if you do a single arm version or,
you know, if you're doing two separate, you know, dumbbells is probably the more accurate way of
thinking about it if you're doing a pressing boost. But then from a numerical matching point of view,
you know, you're going to have all one two motunits that just don't have leverage. So don't get
switched on. I mean, I don't understand people when they say, well, we think that these motunits
or go switched on, even though they don't have leverage. I'm like, in what universe would an animal
have evolved to do that? I mean, it's no sense at all. It literally is evolving to be less efficient
than another animal that doesn't do that. So it's just not going to happen. Well, it's, I mean,
that's a really important point because I don't know the people understand that either. Like,
it actually will disadvantage that organism to do that. And so he like,
that adoption actually persists because if it could all be an occur in the first, it wins. So it's
going to literally pass on that better adoption. So just couldn't, we couldn't get to this end point.
Couldn't even get to that point in the first place, you know. So very, very strange. So yeah,
from deficit point of view, and also from a numerical matching point of view, you can't have a
situation where an exercise is doing everything is not. And just to be 100% clear on this,
if somebody says, oh, well, I'm not arguing the tip perfectly trains it maximally. I'm just saying
that it will maintain. I'm like, well, then you don't understand the size principle. Yes. Because,
you know, literally what we're saying here is that, you know, if a exercise is producing a
small stimulus, the only way it can do that is by not recruiting some of the motifs. Again,
people are thinking that a muscle is like this homogenous thing that you can train. Oh, this exercise
trains that muscle. Come on. That's not his bodybuilding talk. You know, that's not what we're doing
here. You know, that's not the way the CNS works. That's not the way exercise selection works.
You know, if you're getting a smaller stimulus, it's because you're recruiting fewer motifs.
Mechanical tension in the single fibres that are activated, that test failure is going to be identical
because the velocity with the same. So the only thing that changes is the number of fibres that
being activated. And so the stimulus is less because you're not training as many fibres. You're
not recruiting as many motifs chunks of the muscle and not being used. So you cannot say that
oh, well, no, it's just a maintenance stimulus. Those are just rubbish. Just absolutely garbage idea.
It can't possibly be true. Yeah. And muscle fibres either getting the same stimulus it would have
gotten or it's not getting any stimulus. Exactly. Exactly. You know, so, you know, I think where we end
up is that there is a sliding scale or a graded progression and people can really, I mean, if you're
listening to this and you're actually following along and you're thinking, this sounds interesting.
This sounds really cool. How can I use this? This is huge. If you want to go and play with this,
you could do some really interesting work because what you could figure out is that there's basically
like a grading system for every scenario in which you would start to try and buy us regions.
Buying regions is going to be so much more effective where you have either the potential for a big
voluntary activation deficit. You're dealing with big muscles or you're dealing with a muscle
area group like the delts where you have massively divergent functions of the motor units in that
group. You know, so if you've got very homogenous kind of group like, you know, so the quadriceps,
you're not going to see a lot of variation happening. Now, you know, you can kind of get into
arguments about how much various you think they might be, but ultimately, you know, it's very,
very homogenous. Delts, very, very in the modulus, very, very different functions of the different
parts of that muscle group. So you can start to put all of your muscles that you're training
on a sliding scale and go, you know, down at this end, I'm expecting to see lots and lots of
problems. And at this end, I'm expecting to see relatively small problems. Interestingly,
discussions over the last kind of couple of years on this topic have tended to focus on
stuff in the middle, and at the end, which doesn't probably benefit that much. So people have
argued till the, you know, as we would say in England, until the cows come home about, you know,
whether the lat can be biased and regions of the lat can be biased. And to less extent, whether
the peck regions can be biased. And they've argued about sections of the triceps and biceps.
And I would say what you're arguing there is about stuff in the middle and at the least likely
to benefit. And you really want to get into the areas that are going to benefit. You need to be
thinking about the bigger muscle groups, which have diversion functions. You know, so we'll be
thinking more like deltards and, you know, hamstrings, you know, glutes, you know, stuff that has
like the capacity to have a big volunteer activation deficit or a meaningful volunteer
activation deficit, and yet has diversion functions. I actually think the peck is a really
interesting one. I think we under sell the peck a lot in this regard, because we've
Well, look, you know, all three regions of the pack can do transverse plane, you know,
sort of horizontal bar flexion, so, or horizontal adduction depending on how you want to define it.
They can all do that. The interesting kind of use of terminology, they can all do that.
Well, yeah, they can. They have motunits that can perform that function.
Can you get them all to be switched on at the same time? No, you can't.
So, what are you losing? Well, you're going to lose the ones that have the worst relative leverage
and it means that your, your external region is going to get a really, really high stimulus.
You're going to miss a little bit to the top end of the clavicular, you're going to miss a little bit
the bottom end of the, of the, of the costal. And that's just how it's going to work.
Now, if you go from transverse plane bench press down to a peck deck,
you're going to benefit because you've just changed the voluntary activation deficit.
So, what's interesting with that is if you had an exercise that was like you use the example of saying a peck deck,
and it is, there's multiple regions that have good leverage for that.
Well, you can make an argument that would be a really good exercise to do unilaterally.
Yeah, fantastically so because you've taken out that really big factor that was limiting you in that situation.
Even then, I think maybe there's an argument so we might still be losing a little bit to the top end of the clavicular.
Sure, it should be losing, but don't think if you're running an abbreviated plan,
you just need to move to the bottom. You could pick an exercise as using a lot of different muscle regions and do a single limb.
Unilaterally. I agree, I agree, I agree.
But this is what I'm saying when I say if somebody's following along here,
and they want to start to think practically about how to bring value to this space
and think about classifying exercise, they could do some amazing matrix style allocation.
There's some really interesting work to be done here.
I'm going to follow that and do an abbreviated plan because I think actually that's the opportunity.
If you could only do seven exercises in a full body or whatever it is time permitting,
I think that's a really interesting way to use exercise selection.
Yeah, I think that the single impact deck is a perfect example of what we're talking about here.
I mean, I think that is one of the best exercises that would show the best examples of how you're fighting
against that vulnerability deficit in the context of a cos ultimately what I'm getting at here is
you couldn't do the same thing with a lateral raise. So we're talking right.
Okay, so just if you've got the peck, you've got three separate regions.
And okay, there's like we talked about at the beginning, you can go Russian doll effect and you can start talking about
individual sections of individual sections of individual sections until you get down to motor unit level.
Ultimately, no team to say anything that matters, but that's by the by.
You've got three major anatomical regions of the delt, so essentially what we've got there is a comparable scenario.
We're talking about, you know, a horizontal movement for the peck and doing the peck deck,
and we're talking about a vertical movement during the lateral raise.
Technically, those are comparable situations. You've got the curricular, journal and cost of pecks
and you doing your horizontal flexion movement for the peck and you're probably capturing a big chunk of the motor units in all three regions.
You're not going to get the same thing. You're not going to get the posterior anterior and middle delts all contributing to that lateral raise.
Despite the fact that essentially you're doing the same thing in two different planes.
But if you did it for the quads, if the lady sent you will.
And the reason for that is because we've got very, very divergent functions of the motor units in the delt compared to the peck.
So this is keep, this is coming back to this problem that we've got.
We've always got a voluntary activation problem and we've always got a motina accruement problem from numerical matching point of view.
And the problems are going to be slightly different size according to which muscle groups you are working with and what exercise you're doing.
So ultimately, if you were to say, well, okay.
So if I'm doing single arm peck decks, why wouldn't I then also do single arm lateral raises?
Now that will because probably in the lateral raise, there's not that many motina.
It's being recruited anyway because there's just not many motions have leverage to do that thing.
You've got more of the opposite problem.
So really, if you can identify muscles that have these leverages differences, then you're going to be better off with a higher number of excise variation.
And if it's more of a voluntary activation deficit issue, then unilateral is probably going to be as valuable if not more valuable than actually different exercises.
Yeah, I think you've got an exercise that has the, if you have an exercise like the peck deck, which has the, for which a lot of muscle regions have great leverage.
You're probably going to want to have a, you know, lateral variation, because otherwise you're just going to be missing stuff off the top.
And not because you, not because the brain doesn't want to activate it just because they can't.
That's really, if you want to, if you want to put it in simplest possible terms, you would say one problem is the brain wants to.
But can't, Neil, yeah, the other problem is that the brain doesn't want to, because it's no point.
You know, and that starts to tease the situation.
So like in the situation of the, of the peck deck, the brain wants to activate more motions as you can't actually have a voluntary activation deficit issue.
And in the case I'd love to raise the brain to just want to, because there's no point in doing that.
I think this is very interesting.
This is a whole different lens one can use when looking at excise selection.
This is ultimately what happens when you kind of just riff off the physiology and you just start with what physiology is telling you must be the case.
And you just start exploring, you know, kind of where it takes you.
And I think this is where physiology based analysis of strength training is so powerful because you start with principles.
And then you just keep going and following them to the end of the string.
And in many situations, you know, I haven't been to the end of some of these strings.
And I think some people get surprised by that.
It's like, well, that's because that's just not what I do.
I focus on always trying to figure out what physiology is saying.
Now, when people then ask me questions about, well, how does that apply in the strength training situation?
I then start applying it live.
And then I find things that I haven't found before because, you know, I just never thought about it because it's just not my area of speciality.
I'm not really, you know, a kind of a fitness influencer in that respect. I'm a physiologist who happens to talk about this stuff on the internet.
So I think this is, yeah, this is an amazing opportunity.
I think as we talk through it, I've realized just how valuable this could be for people to think.
Well, you know what's going to happen? I'm going to hang up and I'm going to have half a dozen more questions for you.
And we're going to spit in the nestled up, we're shopping this.
But yes, I think it does sound like there's a lot of mileage in this.
We could always do a follow up if people have questions.
I think this has probably been a, but I would describe as a rough and ready sort of draft of these ideas.
I think I can probably find some better ways of communicating some of this stuff.
But yeah, this has been fun.
Well, you know what's going to happen out of this is I'm pretty confident.
We're going to keep talking about this and we're going to identify these are the muscles that exercises where it makes a lot more sense to the union lateral and these are the ones where it doesn't.
And I think what we're going to see is because at the moment, I feel like union lateral exercises are applied really haphazardly.
It's just like, let's just show this there. Let's use this for this exercise.
I don't feel like there's a lot of continuity or even logic behind when one uses them or when they don't because obviously we don't know.
To be fair, you can use it all the way down to the elbow flexor complex.
I mean, you can use it for everything down if and it will have an effect.
I mean, we know it does have an effect. You mean you can test it for yourself doing biceps curls with alternating dumbbell curls and you can see that the effect is going to be so much smaller.
The effect is going to be so much smaller than it would be for a bigger muscle mass exercise.
So I think what we'll do is we'll identify some exercises where just logically kind of almost always makes sense just to do it.
There's definitely going to be a sort of a greater effect where the effect is going to go.
I mean, it's trying to think things through carefully, but at the bottom end, if you take things down to a really tiny amount of muscle mass, you're not going to see any effect at all because you're already maxing out.
So there's nothing.
So as you, as you come past the elbow flexor complex, you're going to see an effect there.
You should see an increasing effect and then if I'm modeling this correctly in my head as I'm thinking about it, it should plus 0 because there's only a certain amount of extra motor command that you can create.
So yeah, so what you should happen is you should see is a is a curvilinear line where you have nothing happening at the lowest end, the smallest amount of muscle mass.
If you're doing finger exercises or something like that, you shouldn't see any shouldn't see a bilateral force deficit effect really down the end.
And as you climb to bigger amounts of muscle mass, you should see a relatively fast increase in the bilateral force deficit or not just a bilateral force deficit, but the amount of muscle mass you're using should.
Change the amount of motina crew and you can achieve relative to the maximum amount that exists, but then it should tape, taper off because you should actually find that there isn't anywhere else to go because there's only a certain amount more motina crew you can physically create.
So what you might find is that above light, I don't know, peck size, there isn't anywhere else to really go with it.
What I'm saying is it might be the case, the problem is just as big for the peck as it is for the glute. Do you see what I'm saying? Yeah, you'll get the maximum return at a certain point, but it's still you're still going to get that same value.
It's as big as what we might find, I need to think this through, what we might find is that there isn't a bigger impact on the glute compared to say the pack.
Yeah, because the zone is like you're any get that just essential mode of command isn't enough like if doing half of that muscle.
with doing their, their unilateral insights, you're still limited, you're still limited by
the same thing. I think that would be the case for the biggest muscle certainly. So I think
you probably would plateau at a certain point, but it's still is giving you the best opportunity
you've got. Like it still makes sense to do that. Yeah, absolutely. I'm just saying I don't think,
I need to really just kind of model this out in my head, but I don't think it would be different
once you got above a certain size muscle. I mean, even for pets, I don't think it's going to solve
all that troubles. It's not going to mean that you might still benefit from doing a
cyclovicler peck focused exercise, a bioseccesse. But the magnitude of the benefit is going to be
smaller than that. That's the key thing. So the difference between saying, well, if I do three shoulder
exercises, um, and I do three peck exercises, but it's a totally different animal. That's the issue.
And that's what I think this sickline program was really perfect for demonstrating is that if you
got muscles groups that have extremely divergent functions within them, you're going to have a
way bigger motivation to look for a whole bunch of different exercises, then you would do if you have,
you know, kind of muscles have regions that are all doing similar things, but that's where you're
going to chase the voluntary activation deficit issue. So the lats as an example, they're going
to fall more towards the voluntary activation deficit side. The lats are kind of halfway in between
the two. Oh, a pack and the doubt are kind of like either ends of a spectrum, not to pure spectrum
here. We're still dealing with a kind of, but they are pushing ends of that spectrum. I'd say that's
in the middle. So you've got both problems at the same time, I would say. So like an exercise,
let I know everyone's very in love with it. The moment they can and flat, I'm sure you've probably
seen it. If you're familiar, describe me. I've never done it. So it's doing a lap pull down,
and in the frontal plane, and taking out any other movement. So it's using like a pullover,
it's like a pullover, but a frontal plane version. Yeah. I apologize if I've explained that
incorrectly. Can anyone else use it? As an aside, I think naming exercises after yourself
probably needs to stop, because all it does is mean that people who don't like you don't use it.
I didn't name the stimulating reps model after me. I could easily have done that. Other people have
done similar things and named after themselves. You know, if you name something after yourself,
you are limiting how much people use it. If you name something and think that, you know,
like Brett Contreras, probably, is in terms of exercise selection, the most influential
SNC coach fitness influencer on planet in terms of introducing an exercise. He didn't name it after
himself. He could have done. He's talked about it. He's talked about how he could have named after
himself and he didn't. You know, and, you know, as a result, partly as a result of that,
obviously the success of the exercises because it works. But I think that he helped that exercise
succeed because he didn't name it after himself. You know, I think it's a very short term approach
to name an exercise after yourself because people who don't like you will not use it. If you want a
widespread adoption of a concept of an idea of a belief of an exercise, don't name it after yourself.
You know, all you're doing is taking a short term approach to it. So I think just as a general
observation, then I'm not criticizing the person in specific case here. Well, to be fair,
what I'm gonna mention, I don't know whether he even named it. It's possible that someone's
identified him in an applied environment. Exactly. Exactly. You know, it may not even be his
initiation. So, but the point still stands, which is that if an exercise gets named after somebody,
then people who don't like that person will just argue against it for the sake of being argumented.
Against that person. Yeah. And as against that person. So as I say, I think one of the reasons
why they hit thrust has had global success and is the success story about getting a new exercise,
you know, into a common usage is because it was named something very, very generic. And I think
that principle definitely applies. So if, you know, I don't know what to say at this point, other
than what I've said, but that's just something I've noticed over the last couple of decades
of seeing this, this, this play out. So to go to the exercise itself. To the exercise in question.
No, exactly. I mean, it's a, it's a, it's a really cool idea, because essentially by taking out
some muscle mass that you don't, you know, need for training the muscle that you try to train,
you raise the potential for increasing the amount of motine accruement in the target area. So
absolutely function in the same way that I mean, really, it's the same logic as the,
the pectite versus the transverse plane bench press, because you're removing it. It's the same logic,
but it doesn't have the same effect. And that's why I ask you are the latter fully more on the
deficit side than on the leverage side. Well, I think you've got things upside down because
the pect has all three regions that can contribute to horizontal flexion or adduction, depending
on how you want to classify it. So the issue there is, it's, it's a pure voluntary activation
issue. Yes. Delts, it's almost exactly the opposite. It's almost a pure kind of varying function
issue, but the lab being both at the same time, you're going to have both issues. So ultimately,
you're going to find that you have got a voluntary activation problem. And you've probably also
got a diversion function problem. Yeah. So the key in fact, there's not solved the problem
in the same way that a single limb unilateral pectite. Single limb vibration. Yes. We,
yeah, no, I know, but that's what my point is that if we're looking at the pects, like you said,
obviously, clivically or costal external all have really good leverage for that movement,
but you're saying if we're doing single limb frontal plane. It's solving, it's solving the
voluntary activation problem. It's all the half of it. For the lumber and pelvic lats,
it's not going to touch the thoracic lat because the thoracic lat doesn't do anything.
Yep. What if it's very, very little. So it's kind of falling halfway between the
double issue and the so I wouldn't say there's no point in doing it. There is a point in doing it
because no, no, no, that's not what I'm getting at. I was just, it was more when people were saying,
do we need multiple exercises for lats had they not been a leverage issue? One could argue,
well, maybe if you were doing something unilaterally, we're taking out a lot of muscle mass,
maybe you could get away with just one exercise, but what you're saying is no, no, we've got this
leverage issue. You've got a lever, you're still a leverage issue. You are, you are going to
find, but it won't be as big an leverage issue as the dealt. So, so with, with a lot to raise,
it's like nobody on the planet, I hope, thinks that a lot to raise is going to give them anterior
and posterior as well as middle dealt development. I hope that's true. My reason is because they've
got very divergent functions and everybody can see that. It's really screamingly obvious.
Peck is the opposite. And that's why the problem is the philanthropic activation issue. The lat
is halfway in between. So, you kind of can see that there's a logic to going down the root of
essentially doing a single armpit deck, which is what this kind of exercise that you described
towards is doing, more or less, but in sort of frontal plane adduction for the lat. But it probably
still doesn't get you all the way into the thoracic part of the lat because it's just too divergent
to function. It's less of a divergent function than you'll see with a dealt, but it's still a divergent
function. After one more question. Okay. I'm aware we've gone way over. So I'm not going to keep
us going for too much longer, but I do get this question all the time. And in this context,
I think it's interesting. So people will ask, what do I need to maximize quadricep development?
And usually the question will be, do I need a leg extension and a squat? And obviously, we could
talk about psychomyogenesis and if someone tests up the leg extension in the right way, then they
might be able to achieve some of that stretch mediated hypertrophy. So let's assume that they're able
to do so. Well, if someone was saying, I'm just doing a leg extension, is that enough? And in
obviously, maximize is a tricky word, but is that enough to get, you know, very, very high levels
of development? Well, based on our conversation so far, I would be inclined to say, well, if you're
just doing a leg extension and your goal is to kind of just do as little as possible to get as much
development as possible, you may be better off just doing a single limb leg extension than actually
adding in a second exercise, like a squat. Of course. I mean, that's that's the thing. It's like,
if you do a single limb knee extension exercise, I think that is probably the one that's going to
give you the most kind of chance at maximizing quadriceps development. Personally, I think that the
knee extension prioritizes the rectum. There's long-term training data suggesting the
rectum grows preferentially to other muscles. Now, the only real way that can happen is if the lack
of motine accruement is being experienced by the the single joint quadriceps. So you obviously don't
see that with a leg press because the rectum isn't working or a squat because the rectum isn't
working. So my preference really, and you know, people have pointed out that, you know, this is
divergent from a lot of other people who are following my model, that I would prefer to have both a
single leg leg press and a single leg knee extension. But if you had to choose only one, it would
always be the single leg knee extension because you don't get any rectum in the leg press or squat.
But as I say, if you look at long-term training data, you will find that the rectum outgrows the
other quadriceps muscles in knee extension training. And that, for me, suggests that it is not allowing
full accruement of those single joint quadriceps in the knee extension exercise. What if the scenario
were, you've got a lady's tension, and then someone says, if I want to grow more of the quad's
minus rectum, should I add in like a bilateral squat or leg press or bilateral? That's the interesting
question isn't it? I mean, single leg, for me, it's not really very difficult to answer the question.
I would straight away say, well, my approach would always be single leg leg press, single leg
knee extension. That, for me, is you've covered everything. If you're saying to me, well, I can't do
using a light light press.
I want to do two leg leg press. I'm not well, seriously, because honestly, it takes less time to set up to do single leg, and you can probably do it in more machines.
You can probably do single leg leg press in a selectorized machine, probably, unless you're absurdly strong, you can probably use a selectorized machine.
You're probably going to need to use a kind of loadable plate loadable machine to do two leg leg press on you.
So honestly, if you're saying to me, well, I don't want to do single leg leg press because it takes more time. I'm saying, I bet it doesn't. I bet it takes more time to do the two leg.
I can get two lots of single leg and get both sides, single leg press, single leg knee extension done in absolutely no time.
No, no, I get that. I understand it's not really a single leg doing a theoretical.
Yes, yes, but I guess what I find interesting about is this is potentially a situation where one exercise would be better than two if they're one excise were unilateral, and the two exercises weren't.
It's just another, I think it's just another layer to think about.
You don't really don't know because it would depend on which ones you're comparing. If you're saying to me that you're comparing two leg, well, bilateral knee extension.
No, no, a unilateral leg extension saying that one exercise probably better overall quad development than a bilateral leg extension and a bilateral leg press.
That's really tough, but you might be right. You might be right. That's very tough because you're changing two variables at the same time.
Because what you're saying is that you lose what you're losing in the case of the single joint quadriceps because the rectum is taking over or still not going to get back that from the two leg leg press because there's too big of an intractivation deficit.
That's totally valid. You could argue that, but again, we don't, I don't know of any data that would enable us to get close to that.
But big intractivation deficits flying around lots of muscle mass, lots big, big muscles being used. It's entirely possible.
Okay. That's, I'm going to stop quizzing you in these very specific exercise questions. Is there anything else you wanted to finish with before we wrap up? No, I'm definitely definitely done.
Okay, okay. Thank you guys for listening. I hope you found that enjoyable as me. Maybe it was just me, I'm not sure, but I do hope you'll join us again next week.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
C-cline’s workout plan from the 1950s features 18–19 single-set exercises, emphasizing shoulder development over back training.
The routine includes a mix of calisthenics, dumbbell movements, and leg exercises, reflecting a bronze-era aesthetic focused on symmetry and form.
Shoulder exercises are abundant, including front raises, lateral raises, overhead presses, and side bends, indicating a strong emphasis on upper body structure.
The back section is notably limited—only chin-ups are included—raising concerns about insufficient back muscle engagement despite its importance.
The program reflects personal bias and historical context, possibly shaped by C-cline’s own physique goals and era-specific training norms.
Neuro-mechanical matching theory explains how the CNS prioritizes muscle regions with optimal leverage, activating them before moving to less efficient ones.
Voluntary activation deficits reveal that larger muscles (like quads and lats) have significant unactivated fibers due to neural command limits, while smaller muscles show minimal deficits.
Exercise selection must consider muscle mass and leverage
Summary:
This episode explores an early 1950s workout plan devised by C-cline, a lesser-known but influential figure in pre-modern bodybuilding. The routine consists of 18–19 single-set exercises, heavily emphasizing shoulder development through lateral raises, front raises, overhead presses, and side bends—hallmarks of the bronze-era aesthetic. Notably, back training is minimal, with only chin-ups included, suggesting a personal bias toward upper body growth rather than balanced development.
The analysis draws on neuro-mechanical matching theory, which posits that the central nervous system prioritizes muscle regions with the best leverage during movement. This principle explains why certain muscles, like the posterior deltoid, are activated first in shoulder movements, while others are left underdeveloped due to neural command limits. Larger muscle groups—such as the quadriceps and latissimus dorsi—exhibit significant voluntary activation deficits, meaning a large portion of muscle fibers remain unactivated despite maximal effort.
In contrast, smaller muscles like elbow flexors show minimal deficits, indicating more efficient recruitment. The discussion highlights a sliding scale of exercise variation: while high variation in large muscle groups offers substantial benefits, it often leads to diminishing returns. For optimal results, training should be tailored to muscle mass and leverage, with multi-joint exercises requiring greater attention to regional biasing.
Smaller joint exercises, like biceps curls or hip abduction, offer more precise targeting but deliver less overall growth. Ultimately, the episode underscores that effective training must balance biomechanical principles with practical, personalized goals—avoiding overgeneralizations about muscle recruitment that stem from anatomical labels rather than physiological reality.
FAQs
C-cline's plan featured 18–19 single-set exercises with 10–20 repetitions, focusing heavily on shoulder development and calisthenics, including bicep curls, lateral raises, overhead presses, squats, and chin-ups.
The plan reflects a bronze-era aesthetic preference for shoulder development, with multiple variations like front raises, lateral raises, and overhead presses, suggesting a focus on balanced, symmetrical upper body growth.
Yes, it included chin-ups, but lacked other back exercises, which is notable given the era's emphasis on back development and the potential for better muscle recruitment in such movements.
Neuro-mechanical matching explains that the central nervous system prioritizes muscles with the best leverage during movement, activating them first before moving to less efficient regions or muscles.
Larger muscle groups (like quads or lats) have significant voluntary activation deficits, meaning many muscle fibers aren't fully activated; smaller muscles (like elbow flexors) show minimal deficits and are more efficiently recruited.
Yes, but effectiveness decreases as you go from large to small muscle groups—targeting regions in glutes or quads offers greater growth potential than in small muscles like biceps.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.