016 Training Splits - Why upper/lower, torso/limbs, push/pull, and other split routines face the same problem
from Hypertrophy Past and Present
1h 14m 15s
This discussion explores the evolution of bodybuilding training through the lens of Joe Weider’s influence and early program design. While Weider is known for popularizing split routines, his foundational 1940s full-body plan featured single sets of 5–10 reps, emphasizing heavy loads and structural exercises like deadlifts and rows—yet notably lacking pressing and balanced development. This reflects a period before bodybuilding competitions established clear judging standards, leading to training focused on aesthetics over balanced muscle growth. The analysis then shifts to the physiological basis of post-workout fatigue, showing that muscle damage from calcium accumulation triggers both local and systemic effects. These include reduced strength in trained and untrained muscles due to secondary inflammation and super-spinal central nervous system fatigue. This fatigue is not isolated to one muscle group and can impair performance across the body, especially in split routines where volume is high. Training on sequential days increases cumulative damage, reducing recruitment and hindering recovery. The takeaway is that effective hypertrophy requires not just volume but strategic programming—avoiding excessive volume and focusing on recovery. While some minor factors like protein intake may aid recovery, the most effective strategy is prevention through lower volume, balanced exercise selection, and frequency management. Ultimately, the shift from unstructured to structured training in the 1950s aligns with the rise of standardized judging and performance goals, marking a critical turning point in bodybuilding history.
Welcome back everyone to another episode of hypertrophy past and present good morning, good evening, good afternoon, wherever you are. Chris, how are you my morning, your night?
Cheers. Cheers my late evening over here. I'm doing very well, thank you.
I hear you are sitting through an electrical storm just a moment ago, so hopefully your internet holds up.
Yes, hopefully so, please bear with us if any problems arise. It was pretty impressive, but you know, part of the course really.
So let's jump into it. Let's do a straight cracking today. I have a plan from Joe waited to talk about now.
I don't know if we've talked about Joe, but I think his name's come up a few times, but we haven't discussed any specific plan to him yet,
which I think is quite impressive. Actually, we've made it this far without talking about him too much because he's obviously one of the most recognizable names in the silver and then into the golden era of bodybuilding now.
One of the interesting things for Joe, obviously, he sort of had a, what would you say, sort of a posse of bodybuilders that he acquired over time and he was definitely known as quite a marketer.
And part of his mission or his sort of strategy was to promote these sort of, you know, new ways, new methods of doing bodybuilding and he would publicize these in his magazine and he would get sort of.
You know, leading bodybuilders of the time, he got Arnold under his wing and he would promote sort of his methods with these very big names to try to, I guess, in essence, kind of take over the bodybuilding world with his methods and he published the weed of methods and this sort of evolved over time and he was inject competition with Bob Hoffman and we've talked about a lot of Bob Hoffman's plans, you know, where there was was very big in sort of pushing bodybuilding more towards what we know bodybuilding to be today in this sort of.
You know, more down the kind of pageant way of doing things as opposed to this strength sport, you know, kind of strength athlete, Olympic lifting type stuff that Bob Hoffman was doing.
So there's a lot kind of that weed is responsible for and how this is shaped up over time.
And again, we'd a influential marketer, he would often promote sort of new cutting edge strategies that sort of undermined what else has been done at the time. So, you know, if you read his magazine, it's always like he's having a back and forth with Bob Hoffman a lot of the time where he's he's not naming him directly, but he's speaking directly to something that Bob is just put out of you know, something that is published or a method that he's just talked about.
And weed is largely responsible for a lot of their kind of push toward not just higher volume in terms of the set system, but also in terms of splits, and he did sort of popularize a lot of splits that did emerge, you know, coming into the gold near and even at the end, late stages of the silver era, our weeder was certainly promoting some very early iterations of split training at that point.
So, when people think about Joe weeder, they often sort of associate him with this kind of more, you know, split type system routines that I caught Arnold was doing. And yet, he did actually start off as a huge component of full body.
So, the plan we're going to talk about today is actually a plan that was published in his first, 1940 issue of his magazine. Now, it wasn't written by Joe, this plan is written by Jim Bell, but it was in Joe weed his magazine.
And what I thought was interesting about this was to go back and look at this guy who's so well recognized for promoting splits that even he was actually promoting full body training early on.
So, this plan standard kind of structure three times a week full body who is a single set. So, this is a single set of five to ten repetitions. So, very much mirroring what we see is some of Bob Hoffman's plans for even even stuff like the Milo Barbell company.
Their plan was quite similar with that single set of five to ten. So, this was a very, I guess, common structure at this time.
So, we start off with a standing barbell curl, then we go into a barbell shrug, a vertical shrug, into a bent over barbell row, and you'll be happy about this one.
We've got a stiff leg barbell deadlift into an alternating overhead dumbbell shoulder press, into a barbell squat, which I think was supersetted with a barbell plover.
They tended to do those back to back. And then we've got a neck exercise. Now, this was a little bit difficult to do. Usually you had a partner, you could do it with a tail.
Basically, you were doing, like, neck circles with some resistance, and then they went into a Jefferson or, like, a straddle lift, and into a seated calf raise.
So, we've got ten exercises in all, including the neck exercise, and a single set of five to ten repetitions. With the exception of the neck, they did that for a time duration as opposed to a certain number of repetitions.
This is really interesting. When you first sent it over to me, I thought it was relatively generic, but actually, the more I looked at it, the more I see things to talk about.
Before I talk about exercise selection, I just wanted to focus on this structure of the program, because firstly, we're dealing with sets of, or, in the case, obviously, their singles.
We're dealing with sets where we're doing five to ten repetitions, and in the notes that you sent over, it says, with as much weight as possible.
So, this is really, you know, it couldn't be more perfect for the kind of, you know, the shift that we've been talking about over the last couple of years, as we've been saying, look, you know, to avoid post-workout fatigue, you actually want to be doing that heavy or moderately heavy moderate.
So, heavy being maybe one to five, and then moderately heavy being that sort of six to ten. So, heavy or moderately heavy kind of weights. And, you know, we can see that being done by this group of people clearly, you know, in nineteen years as well pre, you know, kind of the animal I care.
Really, really important anecdotal evidence there for, you know, the optimal kind of rep range that we want to be using.
Then, couple that with the fact that they're doing three workouts per week, three, four body workouts per week, and they're doing single sets.
So, that, that again is, you know, such a really nice residence with what we've been talking about with the higher frequency, four body training approach.
Now, you know, not saying that everyone should do single sets three times a week, but it is a really good program, you know, you can do two or three sets, as we'll talk about later on today.
But, the point is that three times a week, four body programs, single sets is just such a such a good way of training, and it's nice to see that was one of the kind of the early sort of programs presented in that in that magazine.
Now, looking at the exercise selection straight away, it contrasts a lot with the kind of the sundial focus on pressing.
So, we literally just got the one pressing exercise, which I think is very strange, very, very interesting.
Then, counterpoint to that, we've actually got two deadlift variations in here. You know, we've got the Jefferson lift, and we've also got the stiff leg deadlift.
Again, these are differences with some of the other programs that we've seen, and it's interesting to, again, speculate on why that might have been.
You know, two deadlift variations here, one, which is more hamstrings focused, and one is perhaps a little bit more sort of, I would classify as generic.
Hip extensor has a really interesting choice.
As you said to me, when you sent it over, there's no kind of pull ups in there, so I'm going to be disappointed.
But, you know, there is a decent chunk of back in there.
We've got a shrug, we've got a bent over row, you know, and you could argue a little bit of, you know, the deadlift variations on the pullover mic kind of fill in a bunch of gaps there too.
So, I'm seeing like a definitive lack of pressing here as being my main kind of criticism, I guess.
Obviously, you know, bench press at this point wasn't super popular, I guess, anyway.
Yeah, I think we just a little bit too early.
Yeah, yeah.
But ultimately, I think this definitely does contrast.
And I guess as we start to look more and more of these programs as you bring more of these for us to consider, you know, maybe the exercise selection is just a personal thing, you know.
I mean, we have seen some interesting trends there whereby, you know, you've seen people put together plans that have some really nice exercise selections where they fit together wonderfully.
Well, they're doing this for this region and this for this region works to get up brilliantly, you know, and then you look at a program like this and you like this reads like somebody who is trying to develop certain parts of the body and is not particularly bothered about other parts, you know.
There doesn't seem to be a very big focus on pressing triceps really, I would say is definitively lacking pack is pop from the pullover really, really going to suffer from this program.
And then of course, the other stuff that is machine specific is obviously missing as well.
I mean, are these the kind of thoughts that you are having as well?
Yeah, I do think we are seeing that the point in time where maybe we just haven't seen a shift more towards pack development.
So maybe that's why that's sort of missing out. It was interesting because obviously we tend to see a lot of hamstring work tends to be neglected and we've actually got some here and we've got, you know, like you said, a bit of back work as well, which tends to be what was dropped out.
So that is interesting.
And I do think, you know, maybe not until the late 40s when these bodybuilding competitions becoming a little bit more popular, maybe that's where we start to see more of these balanced training programs emerge.
I mean, up until that point, yes, people still modeling off, you know, sound out or whatever they have in mind.
And maybe the judging in their more general perception of what a bodybuilder should look like just hasn't quite emerged at this stage.
No, that's really interesting. Absolutely.
I mean, when we first started these podcasts, I think the very first episode you talked us through the process that Sandao I believe went through in order to establish what he.
was trying to achieve. It was like it went to measurements and tried to figure out what would be necessary to achieve those
particularly for seats. So you can kind of then use that as a template and go well if they were doing that then for that purpose then later on as you said maybe like 50s or whatever you start to see
guidelines and judging and people starting to train for the test if you like there maybe there's a period of time in between that where it's kind of like well there's nothing really driving anybody towards
particular outcome, so clever in no man's land. Yeah, it's like people are just kind of doing
stuff that they like. So maybe that's what we're seeing here. Maybe we're just seeing a bit of
preference coming in or some other factors that aren't being directed towards specific outcomes,
which ultimately would suggest that these are less of less value to us in terms of understanding,
you know, connecting, you know, anecdotes, evidence with, you know, kind of outcomes that those
anecdotes achieved. Yeah, because if you look at Sunday, you go, well, he was trying to achieve
these things and he chose those exercises to achieve those things, then that's really, really
nice sort of connected set of data. And then you look at maybe the judging standards of the 50s,
and you go, that's what they were looking for. And these are the exercises they were doing to
meet those requirements. Again, you've got connected data. When you look at this, like, well,
what's he trying to do? What do you make of these neck circles, these neck exercises? Because
this tends to be something that was quite popular this, this point in time. You see this in,
so the bronzeria and then coming up into the 40s. And then you see almost all the drop off into 50s.
Yeah. So I kind of wonder whether anabolic don't kind of do that anyway, you know? I mean,
there is data suggesting that anabolic may be work and I'm outside of my comfort zone now. So
this is not, don't, if somebody who actually knows stuff about these pharmaceuticals tells you
different, listen to them, don't listen to me. But I think that there are differences in the
receptiveness of muscles around the body to anabolic steroids. I think that's true. And I think
the trapezius and that area around the shoulder girl tends to be more responsive than other parts of
body. That's my understanding. If that's not correct, then somebody who's an expert in the area,
please do correct me. And I think that might be an explanation for why you see that kind of stuff
drop off because people just don't need to train it when it's growing already. I had this conversation
with a strength training practitioner quite a long time ago who I respect greatly. And they were
trying to argue with me that vertical shrugs must be better than horizontal shrugs for the other
contagious because if you look at all the Olympic lifters and people do a lot of vertical shrugging
motions, they have huge traps and so forth. And I was like, I'm not convinced that you can use
today's strength athletes as an example of what those exercises do because of that confounding
effect of those pharmaceuticals. Unless you've got an athlete that you are 100% certain is not
using those substances, I'm nervous about using them as an anecdote because I don't know what they've
done. Yeah. And if that's not insinuating that every single natural, I'm just saying, I'll just
don't know. Yeah. No, because that's an equity takeer here quite often because I'll say that as well
and the people will be like, oh, but you know, this person's natural. You can't say that everyone's
not natural. I'll be like, okay, sure, but let's say you show me five natural and let's say
through the mind to the mind, we don't know the two that aren't. Well, how could I use that data?
It doesn't work. The data is unusable. It's not it's not criticizing anybody. It's not making
accusations at all. It's literally just saying that I can't use that data for that purpose.
Yeah. Because I don't know. And yet this data we are describing now pre the existence of these
pharmaceuticals can be used to that purpose because there was no possible way that it could create
a problem. I think people do get really emotion about this stuff and they want us, you know, sort of
you know, make grand statements about who is using these things and who is not using these things.
I mean, it's simply in a relevant question yet another. I'm just not interested because there is
no way of establishing the truth with complete certainty. So just don't bother. You know, you've
got a really nice data set. Pre that point. Just go and do that. Just go and use that. Yeah. So
Joe, wait a full body. Like I said, he did move into some splits, which will cover some other time.
But we're going to talk a little bit about splits today. Do you want to introduce us to where we're
going to go? Yeah. So obviously, people have heard me talk about fatigue a lot and about post-workout
fatigue, a reasonable amount. What we'd like to do today is just walk through the impact of post-workout
fatigue on subsequent workouts and specifically in the context of training splits. So to walk through
this, what I'm going to do, as I always try to do, is walk through the physiology of what we're
actually describing the post-workout fatigue effect. And then apply that to the situations that we
are interested in the training splits and go from there, talk about practical implications and that
kind of thing. So the physiology basically is that every time we do a strength training workout,
we're going to produce a set of post-workout fatigue mechanisms. And those post-workout fatigue
mechanisms will produce what we call fatigue, which is a temporary reduction in exercise
performance in both the trained muscles and also in non-trained muscles. That's called a non-local
fatigue effect. And I'll come on to that in more detail later on. So when we do the workout,
we perform some repetitions with a particular exercise. And in the process of doing those repetitions,
we're activating the muscle fibers relatively high up in the kind of motunit sequence. So we end
up activating some fairly fast twitch muscle fibers. As you activate those fibers, especially for
longer durations of time, as tends to occur as you approach muscular failure, because obviously each
repetition as it slows down, it lasts longer before it's finished. You end up with an accumulation
of calcium ions inside the fibers. Now, why does that happen? It happens because every time you send
an electrical signal to a muscle fiber, you need to convert that electrical signal into a chemical
signal to get the cross-bridges to form. The cross-bridges are inside a fiber. You can't send
electrical signals inside a fiber. So you have to convert the electrical signal on the outside
of the fiber into a chemical signal on the inside of the fiber that the cross-bridges will understand.
And that chemical signal is calcium ions. So you send the electrical signal from the brain,
goes all the way down the spinal cord motor neurons into the muscle itself, and it reaches the
muscle fiber travels along the cell membrane, as it's communicating the action potentials.
And then, at various points, it goes just inside the fiber and converts into a calcium ion signal.
But the calcium ions, as they used for the signaling inside the fiber, they build up. And so, of
course, the more you're activating these fibers, and the longer that process goes on for, the more
calcium ions you accumulate, and the more processes can then occur that respond to the presence of
calcium ions. This is why I talk a lot about a thing that I've named calcium ion-related fatigue
mechanisms, or calcium ion-related fatigue. It's just fatigue mechanisms that are derived from this
process of calcium ion accumulation. So we've got these calcium ion accumulating, and they are going
to then cause a number of specific fatigue mechanisms. Now, what we've got? We've got excitation
contraction, coupling failure, which is a little bit of a specific damage to the junction where the
electrical signal converts into a chemical signal. That junction is called the triotic junction.
We've got that process, that can occur. We've got another process, which is damaged to the cell
membrane. That occurs through a sequence of events that ultimately start, again, with that
accumulation of calcium ions. And then you've got actual damage to the working parts of the
muscle fiber itself. So we call that often myofibular damage, but it can be damage to other bits and
pieces inside the fiber as well. And that happens because when calcium ions accumulate inside the
fiber, you get a calpaine response. Now, calpains are proteases, so they are triggered to be released
in response to the presence of accumulating calcium ions. And calpains start to digest enzymes,
they are basically, and they will digest bits of the muscle fiber internally, and that is going
to then produce some damage. Now, off the back of the purpose of that being, look, why does that occur?
So the purpose of all fatigue mechanisms is the same. Every single fatigue mechanism serves exactly
the same purpose. It's essentially going to stop us from running out of ATP inside the
muscle fiber. So let me just walk through this and show you how that works. If you have a, what we
call central nervous system fatigue, which is a reduction in the magnitude of the signal brain
sends to the muscle, you are going to stop activating muscle fiber. Now, clearly straight away,
you can see that that's going to stop you using ATP, because if you can't switch a fiber on,
you can't use ATP inside that fiber. If you look at what calcium ion fatigue mechanisms do,
whether it's excitation and traction coupling failure, whether it's a damage to the cell membrane,
or whether it's, in fact, damage to these structures inside the fiber itself. What they are all
doing is essentially stopping you from using the ATP, because they will stop the fiber from
activating. So let me walk through excitation and traction coupling failure, because this is the
most obvious one. If you damage the triotic junction, which is the length between the inside of the
fiber and the outside of the fiber, then your electrical signals, which are being sent to the fiber,
no longer will convert into chemical signals. So essentially, you will now stop
cross bridges from happening. Now, if you stop cross bridges from happening, you've just removed
a big like source of ATP usage inside your fiber, because obviously the excitation
contraction coupling process uses ATP, but the primary source of ATP usage inside the fiber is
the cross bridge formations. If you stop the cross bridge formations from happening, you again
stop the ATP being used. The metabolite relative to mechanisms are another great example, because
all of them slow down the rate of ATP usage by slowing down the rate of cross bridge formations.
So again, what you're doing there is you're stopping the muscle fiber from burning through the ATP
as quickly. A lot of people think that fatigue mechanisms are related to
energy usage. Oh, I'm running out of energy because that's how it feels. The reality is,
fatigue mechanisms are stopping you doing that. They're actually actively preventing you from
churning through the ATP to avoid getting to the point where the fibre did run out of ATP.
Because if you did get to the point where the fibre run out of ATP, the muscle fibre would die.
We know that because if you look at the ischemia studies where they remove the supply of oxygen
to a muscle fibre and blood to a muscle fibre, then after a period of quite a long time,
actually, it actually kind of goes necrotic and dies. So these fatigue mechanisms are explicitly
stopping us from creating problems. That's their protective. That's what all fatigue mechanisms are
for. So if we look at these calcium amuletive fatigue mechanisms, as I've said, we've got these
three major ones. We've got this trionic junction damage, which is called excitation
junction coupling failure. We've got damage to the cell membrane, and we've got damaged to the
mouth. It was another bits and pieces structurally inside the fibre. All of that is going to happen
more or less, I mean, not exactly at the same time, but more or less simultaneously. And it's going
to, or at least be started more or less simultaneously. And it's going to be produced in more or
less the same kind of relative amounts. So if you pour calcium ions into a muscle repeatedly,
into the muscle fibres repeatedly, because you're doing loads and loads and loads of sets of maybe
higher repetitions, then what's going to happen is you're going to get quite a lot of all three of
these fatigue mechanisms. Some people think that, you know, oh, well, this type of exercise causes
a lot of excitation junction coupling failure. Maybe that type of exercise causes more muscle damage.
No, it doesn't. It's all just related to the same ultimate cause. So if you have a lot of,
you know, kind of muscle activation taking place for a long period of time, or high levels of
muscle activation taking place for a long period of time, you are going to get quite a lot to all
three of those fatigue mechanisms. Now, what can happen next? Once you've started that damage
process, you're going to experience that build up of proteases inside the muscle fibres. And that's
going to start causing damage. And that damage process takes several hours, probably four to six
hours of calpane related damage inside the muscle fibres post workout. After that, you're going to
trigger an inflammatory response, which is going to come in and start creating even more damage.
So a lot of people have probably heard me talk about how damage processes take most of your first
day post workout to actually process. The damage doesn't even exist immediately post workout.
You've got several hour period of calpane proteases causing damage. And then after that, you've
then got a whole load of time where the inflammatory process is doing even more damage. Now,
we call it damage, but the reality is it's kind of like clearing away the partially damaged
materials that the calpane's the enzymes have produced. So you can kind of think of it as like
the enzymes going in and creating this superficial level damage. And then the inflammation process
comes in after that and goes along and looks at the things and goes, well, that's been damaged.
So let's remove that and it takes it away. And of course, taking it away means that you no
longer have that myofibral or that structure that could produce force or transmit force. And
so you start to see reduction in strength, which is what we measure as fatigue. So this is called
the secondary muscle damage effect where you see period of time post workout, several hours post
workout where strength drops again. You know, you have the drop in strength immediately post workout
and then strength starts to recover a bit. And then you get this secondary drop in strength caused
by this inflammatory process, which, as I say, is called the secondary muscle damage effect.
It's been observed in both animal models and also in humans. So let's just hold on to these things.
Okay. Doesn't often get measured in humans for the simple reason that almost with like a very
tiny number of exceptions, almost every post workout fatigue study in humans takes a measured
takes a measurement immediately post workout and then another one at 24 hours. Well, by that point,
that's gone. So it's somewhere between those two time points. I think it probably varies a little
bit because I think ultimately the inflammatory process is being responsive to the calpain
induced damage. So if you've done a workout where you've created an enormous amount of calcium
unaccumulation, you're going to get a lot of calpain related damage. That's going to take a long
time before the inflammation can really come in and do the job. You've got to think of this as
like contractors working on a building project. In building projects, you have like a group of
contractors will go in and do some work on something. And until they finish their job, you can't
send the next guys in to do their bit because their bit depends on the previous stage that has to
be completed. So you can kind of think about the calpains and the inflammation is being two
separate groups of contractors. The calpains are doing their thing, which seems counterintuitive,
but they're doing that thing. But then the inflammation will come in and just clear away any
of those damage structures. And that does make more sense to us because it's kind of simultaneous
damage. And you know, some people have called it repair. It's not really repair. It's clearing the
decks. It's clearing the space so that you can replace those lost sections because what we see
after a workout, after damage models, you see these proteins being lost. You see actins of
motions being lost, well, they've been lost because the inflammation is pulling them out if
they've been damaged by the enzymes. So you've got this two phase process and the inflammation is
delayed. And I think it probably is delayed more if the damage is greater if that makes sense.
So I would expect that in humans doing normal strength training workouts of the kind that we
describe, one, two, maybe three sets, something like that, you would probably find that the secondary
muscle damage effect is maybe six to eight hours, something like that post workout. If you've got
somebody doing more of a bruspit type thing, it might even be right at the end of that first day.
It might even be pushed into the second day. I don't know. It would be like a graded,
sort of just one to my understanding is you see like you're raising neutrophils about four hours or
so after. Sure. Absolutely. Ultimately, this is kind of where you see in a lot of signaling stuff,
in a lot of, you know, kind of inflammatory stuff, you see a very, very sort of slow ramping up,
as you start to see a trickle of this. You don't kind of like click over six hours and suddenly
it all appears. It takes time. Yeah. And the same thing you see with signaling. So signaling kind of
ramps up, they don't really see these kind of like instantaneous. But I think you, you know, you
kind of like look for where the peaks are starting to appear and that kind of is the zone that you,
you know, you kind of identify as being where most of the activity is happening. So I'm definitely
remember. I'm going to put it in number two. I know you're not super happy. It is. Let's for
hypothetical purposes, say about eight hours or so, maybe is where this inflammatory kind of peak
sort of sits in. So I think it would be later if people were doing more sets, but yeah,
more damaging. Yeah. So up until that point, there will be a reduction in strength in that muscle
that was trained. But well, this is, this is where we're then going because like that inflammatory
process so far, I've only described what it does locally. It also has a global, as we call it,
effect across the whole body because that inflammatory process contains. So every inflammatory process
has lots of layers to it. You start out, as you pointed out with neutrophils, you can have multiple
layers of all kinds of different things, including interleukins, those kind of small signaling oriented
inflammatory molecules will go into the bloodstream and they'll be detected by the brain.
And when the brain detects them, it'll respond by producing feelings or sensations.
And those are what are then going to cause super spinal central nervous system fatigue,
that affects the whole body. So yes, what you've got is you've got a period of time post workout
when you don't really have much super spinal central nervous system fatigue at all because
whatever you had during the workout is probably dissipated within maybe half an hour and hour.
Then you've got a period of time when there's not really very much of that at all. And then,
you know, kind of as you say, maybe starting six to eight hours after a normal strength training
workout, a sensible strength training workout, you're probably going to start to see some super spinal
CNFT kicking in. And this is why I often say to people, you could be a little bit careful about
if you're doing two workouts on the same day, splitting your four body into two halves,
it should be a little bit careful about where you put them. I would be so much happier really
with them on sequential days if the volumes are sufficiently low or actually done relatively close
together. So kind of like, I think you've described before where you maybe do half a workout,
then going as far as just then come back and do the other half of your workout. I think that's a
really nice strategy, you know, because you're actually slotting that in before you've had a chance
to get to that zone where that super spinal CNFT just started to kick in. Yeah. So what you're saying
so far is until that information point is, whenever that occurs, six hours, eight hours, whatever,
up until that point, the muscle you train, there's still some damage that's occurred there,
so there'll be reduction in performance in that muscle, but other muscles that that damage
hasn't occurred in, there shouldn't be reduction in performance in those muscles.
Yeah. So what you're going to see is that post workout, you've got your excitation
and direction coupling failure, you've got your damage to the cell membrane, creating the same
effect as excitation and direction coupling failure. You've also got a little bit of
losses of calcium and since 2013, so the muscle fiber, and then you've got this damaged
with the mindfulness, which is starting to increase as the calpenes do their job over the first
several hours. And then as you said, inflammation process kicks in, maybe some over between four
and eight hours and starts to build and then you start to get damage from that as well.
The issue is that stuff like the calcium and sensitivity probably clears relatively quickly,
damage to cell membrane tends to repair relatively quickly, so you've got
different体 mechanisms moving in different directions.
So at the same time as we're creating,
life of a damage with calpains
and let it run with with information,
you're actually getting rid of the theme mechanisms
that you had with the damage to cell membrane
or the losses of calcium ion sensitivity.
Now, this is what makes post-workupty
relatively difficult, relatively difficult job together,
handle on if you want to do it mechanism by mechanism.
And that's why I found it useful to describe
calcium ion related fatigue as a group of mechanisms
because when you put them together as a group,
you can see what they're all doing
'cause they're actually all doing the same thing,
which is reducing single fiber mechanical tension.
And when you understand that that is a problem
for hypertrophy and they're all doing the same thing,
you can just go well on a group level,
generally speaking, what you see is a bit of a recovery
over the first four to six, four to eight hours,
and then a secondary drop in strength
because of the secondary muscle damage effect
'cause the inflammation really clears away
a load of slightly damaged biofuels,
which were previously producing force,
but now aren't doing anything 'cause they're gone.
And then you can sort of see the shape of things,
but trying to go, well, you know,
what's this mechanism doing and how does that then change?
You're gonna end up with things moving in different directions.
It's very, very hard to get a clear picture.
When you grip them together,
you can see that you've got this initial slow recovery,
and then you've got this kind of secondary drop in strength
when the extra minor fibroid damage happens
due to the inflammation.
And that, as a whole, then starts to sit
relatively well together.
You just repeat one thing I mentioned earlier,
I just want to say it again.
The issue here is that all of these mechanisms
are going to respond similarly to a specific workout.
So if you look at the way the inflammation responds
to the post workout kind of cow pain damage,
it's going to be proportional like I was explaining.
So delay, as in the more damage you create,
the more it will be delayed, but bigger.
So if you create a lot of cow pain related damage
because you've created a lot of calcium on accumulation,
you're going to have a bigger inflammation effect,
you're going to have a bigger secondary muscle damage effect,
and you're going to have a bigger,
super spinal center nervous system fatigue effect.
And this is why I often say to people
that post workout fatigue mechanisms are a package deal.
So if you create a large amount of post workout fatigue,
then that is created by a large amount of all mechanisms.
There is no scenario in which these are going to,
like, there's no pick and choose.
It's like trying to get less of one and more of another.
It's a package, because they ultimately all come
from that calcium on accumulation.
Even the inflammation comes secondarily
from that calcium on accumulation,
because it's responding to the damage
created by the proteases, which is responding
to the calcium on accumulation.
So it's absolutely all tied together.
So if you do a workout that has a large damaging effect
on a local level, you are going to automatically create
a large effect at the super spinal fatigue level as well.
That's kind of really, really important
for where we're going next when we start to talk
about the practical side of things.
So let me just insert two minutes on the,
on what super spinal central nervous system fatigue is,
because I often get this question,
and I keep answering it, and I guess people
maybe haven't listened to some of the older stuff.
So every time we produce a maximum effort,
muscular contraction, we are limited.
We can't produce any more moatine accruement
than our maximum tolerable perception of effort.
So Mark Horus' psychological model fatigue says that,
every time we produce a central moat command,
which is designed to create recruitment,
obviously the magnitude of that central moat command
relates to the magnitude of the recruitment,
the bigger the central moat, the more the recruitment,
the higher the level of moatine accruement you can achieve.
The maximum level of recruitment you can obtain
is limited, because every time you create
that central moat command, it copies itself
to the other parts of the brain, which sense things,
and it copies itself as a perception of effort.
So when you reach your maximum tolerable perception of effort,
in other words, when you reach the sensation of effort,
that you cannot go past,
because it is too discomforting, too painful,
then you will stop producing central moat command,
because if you did produce any more,
it would go past your maximum limit,
which by definition is impossible.
Now, that essentially gives us a feedback loop,
whereby the central moat command,
if we have no other sensations going on,
the central moat command determines,
is determined, sorry,
by the maximum perception of effort associated only
with that central moat command.
If you start to feel other sensations during exercise,
if you have pain or some kind of discomfort,
a common example during exercise
will be the heart and lungs producing,
cardiovascular sensations.
Those sensations also add to your effort perceptions,
and they start to bring you closer
to your maximum tolerable perception of effort,
but they're not adding central moat command.
So if you have a lot of sensations during exercise,
that are discomforting or painful,
then what's going to happen is,
you are going to reach your maximum tolerable perception
effort at a lower level of central moat command.
And that means that you have a deficit of activation,
what we call a super spinal central nervous system,
for the effect.
We call it super spinal,
because it's above the level of the spine,
it's actually happening inside the brain.
Now, what we're describing here is inflammation,
leaving the muscle, going into the bloodstream,
circulating, being detected by the brain,
or across the bloodstream barrier,
circumventricular organs,
and producing a sensation,
which then does exactly the same thing,
as the sensations that we experience during exercise,
which then create a reduction in the central moat command,
which then produces this super spinal,
central nervous fatigue effect.
So it's a global effect.
So you can literally do a, you know,
create super spinal sense fatigue
from doing an exercise with the quads,
and it'll show up when you then try and do an exercise
with another part of the body, like,
you know, hamstrings, or the glutes,
or the delts, or whatever you want to do.
It doesn't matter.
It's going to be affected by the same fundamental problem.
It's all of that making sense.
- And there's studies where they'll do,
like, certainly, you know, maybe one leg
will do a set of lady's sentience to failure,
and then they'll, they'll,
the other leg will do nothing,
and then two days later,
they'll do, you know,
volunteer activation assessment,
and the leg that didn't train,
and there was a, there's a deficit due to
super spinal scene, SVT.
Do they have studies where they've checked entirely
unrelated muscles?
- Post workout, not sure.
Definitely during workouts,
you can get those studies.
And the studies done across a parallel body,
the studies didn't done quads and hamstrings, I think.
I'm struggling to remember if there is a post workout,
non-local fatigue study.
There aren't actually that many non-local fatigue studies
out there.
There's this, maybe five or six, I think.
Normally, instead of using the non-local fatigue,
like just testing a different muscle entirely,
what they normally do is test voluntary activation.
So they do a interpolated twitch test,
and they look at the level of recruitment
that you can achieve in a muscle relative
to the maximum level that you could achieve
if it was electrically stimulated.
And they're pretty, pretty good indications of SVT.
They don't allow you to differentiate
between super spinal and spinal,
but given that we've got a mechanism
that we understand and it's relatively well described,
extremely well described in animal models.
I think it's relatively, I can be relatively confident
that it's the same thing we're talking about.
But yeah, so basically, we end up with this reduction
in the level of recruitment that we can achieve
in any muscle of the body as a result of that muscle damage
that we've experienced in that muscle that we've just trained.
And it's going to kick in, like we were saying,
around about the eight hour mark, maybe if it's more damaging,
I would expect it to happen later.
The thing is, the reason I'm cagey about this
is because in a lot of animal models,
they create insane amounts of damage.
You know, they do electrically stimulated eccentric
contractions and they just pile the volume on.
And you can see like delays for days
after those kind of situations.
It's just, and like I'm a big fan of animal studies,
I think they tell us an enormous amount
about how physiology works.
But at the same time, I also know
that you have to do corrections
when they're doing different things that have effects.
So if you know, which we do,
that the more damage you create,
the more delayed the damage effects are,
then you do a, like a mouse study.
And you see, act in a mouse,
you've been lost four days post-workout,
and you look at it, it's because they've done like, you know,
150, maximally electrically stimulated contractions
at some silly velocity, you know?
It's like, that's just, that's just telling you
what the extent of the damage is.
It's extreme.
Now, absolutely off the top end of anything
that you would ever see in a human being ever.
But you know that that's what's happening,
and that's why you've seen this extreme delay.
You know, you look at human studies
or more sensible animal studies,
and they generally will have that delay
being much shorter, and the damages are done
and over with within the first 24 hours.
You know, some people got,
no, I think they're wrong end of the stick
when they're looking at delayed damage,
and they look at some of the animal studies
and they've gone, oh wow, you know,
the damage is delayed for 48, 72 hours.
I can never, never train, you know, this close together,
I can never do a workout this close to another workout.
And someone, no, you've got to understand
that if you just produce a small amount of damage
because you've only done one, two or three sets or whatever,
then you're not going to be in the zone
where you're gonna have that problem, you know,
72 hours later.
You know, the bird study shows that my ops is back down
a baseline after a single set after just like 32, 35 hours,
36 hours or something like that.
So there's absolutely no way there's
muscle damage repair happening at that point.
If you've got no my ops at a rate of elevation,
you haven't got any damage repair happening, you know, it's done.
So I think that's a really nice illustration of how,
you know, damage just goes on.
The process is really, really extended.
If you start to, you know, create more of it,
the problem is delayed and it tends to take
a longer time to be fixed.
So that's kind of where we are
with this team.
mechanisms. So let's now start to relate this to training splits. And you know, we've already
mentioned a few things about this. But basically, you know, if you're doing like the program
we've looked at today, you know, three times a week, single sets, you know, arguably there's
a bit of two sets there because some of the exercises were a little bit kind of similar.
But, you know, let's say we're dealing with something like single sets, then, you know,
basically, you're going to have your fatigue processes are going to happen. And they're
going to be washed out probably by, you know, the sort of 36 hour point, I would say, in
most cases, two sets, you might be pushing that up to 48,000, three sets, you might get
a little bit of a drift over like we talked about, I think in the last podcast. But ultimately,
more or less are going to be, you know, kind of done for the next workout. And because
we're doing full body, we don't have anything happening in that interim period of time.
So we've done full body workout. We have a day of rest. We go back and do another workout,
you know, and okay, if we've done three sets, we might have a little bit just tailing off
the edge. But the super spinal science team, you know, as I say, it's going to be linked
to the damage. So it's all just going to be affecting us equally because we're doing
full body workouts, training exactly the same thing all the time.
If you start to do split routines where you're training on sequential days, and you're
going maybe upper lower, or you're doing a more complex split, put your fundamentally
training different muscles on different days, what's going to happen is you are going
to arrive back in the gym the following day, and you are going to be in full on super spinal
CNST state from that previous day. And the more you split your workouts up and the more
volume you do for those specific muscles, the more of a problem you're going to have. So
if you're doing five sets, you know, because you're maybe doing max, like the max you can
really do with full body is three sets per workout or two times. If you do five sets
for up below, which is kind of the max you can really do with twice a week, then you
say come out, because that's basically recovery. That's the recovery. Yeah, I mean, like,
you know, obviously technically you could do whatever you want. There's no, there's no
laws about you know, how many sets you kind of got. And also you are talking about moderate
loads. Yeah. So yeah. So if somebody's doing heavier loads, contract positions, leaving
reps and reserve, you can change these numbers. But we don't have good date for what that
looks like. You know, I'm talking about people doing moderate, moderately heavy loads of normal
training exercises and training to failure really. Now in those scenarios, three sets probably
about max you can do for full body three times a week or three and a half times a week.
People could and probably do do four or five sets for, you know, sort of the upper
lower splits. And they're going to be technically recovering for the next workout because on
the timeline of judging upper to upper and lower to lower recovery is going to happen.
But you are reducing the level of recruitment that you can achieve in the workout that you
do on the second day of that sequence. So if you're doing upper lower Monday, Tuesday,
you come back in on Tuesday, you are going to find that your level of recruitment is not
as high as it would be if you hadn't done that workout the previous day. And that's literally
because of this super spinal scene at Sinus fatigue mechanism that we've been describing.
Now, a lot of people say, well, yeah, I can feel that. Yeah, that's the point is first
to be able to, you know, it's like that's that's what sinus fatigue is. It's a creation
of a feeling in the brain, which means that as you approach your maximum level of effort,
you can't get to the maximum level of recruitment for that maximum level of effort, which is
another great point to address, which is that some people go, oh, well, I'll just try hard.
I'm like, well, no, you're already trying as hard as you can. That's the point. The point
is that even at maximum level of effort, you are now feeling like you've hit your maximum
level of effort. But that's not now corresponding to the same level of motunit recruitment because
you already had effort perception from something else. So yes, you are absolutely giving it
your best effort and you're producing a maximum possible level of effort you can. I believe
you. That's not the question. The question is that the level of effort that you're producing
is now associated with a lower level of recruitment because you've got efforts sort
of already banked from other things that are going on inside the body. So no matter what
this super spine of sinus fatigue is taking up some effort or it's it's creating a perception
of effort and sure someone could say, well, what if I'm really motivated and therefore,
I can actually tolerate more effort. It's like, yeah, okay, that's great. But you could
have been motivated and not suffering from sinus fatigue and you'd be even better off.
There isn't a way of fixing it so that you come out in the same place, always get whatever
strategy you come up with to try and increase recruitment, you're always going to be worse
off than you would be if you didn't have the sinus fatigue in place. If you compare
like for like, because what you'd have to do is you'd have to say, well, I'm comparing
me having sinus fatigue, but being motivated with me not having sinus fatigue, but not being
motivated, how does that work? You're basically comparing something that's completely unfair,
which is to be honest, what a lot of people do on the internet all the time. But the
point is that you can't find a scenario in which this is going to be fixable in the sense
that you can completely get back to a state that it is, or as if it wasn't there because
you can't, it just isn't as durable. So you've mentioned if you're doing say single sets,
it may not be as much of a problem than if you're doing multiple sets, right? So you say
you did a single set 24 hours later, you're training again, most of that damage is probably
repaired. Come, that's that point if you're doing heavier loads. Now, this is the issue
if we're looking at splits, you know, we obviously know based on the maintenance studies
that it probably takes four sets or more if you're training once a week to actually produce
it in that hypertrophy outcome. So the broader that split is, that naturally means you're
going to be training with a lower frequency per muscle. So if you've got full body, obviously
every time you train that each muscle is getting trained three times a week, obviously that's
a high frequency. If you've got upper lower, you're doing four sessions and obviously because
you're splitting it across two sessions or two different workouts, we now have a default
lower frequency per muscle. Now suddenly you go to push pull legs, then we're further dividing
or divvying up that volume across fewer days, well, more days with fewer frequency per muscle.
So each time we take one step further out, we need to have more per muscle volume within
that single session. So you suddenly have a five day split or six day split or whatever
that might be, some kind of roast split and that muscle is going to train once per week.
You're now probably training that muscle with five six sets and you're training another
muscle the next day and you've just done six sets, sets worth of muscle damage the day prior,
that's going to have a bigger impact on super spinal scene SVT.
Yeah, absolutely. The really annoying thing about the way that volume works, and this is
this is something that people keep asking me about and it's like, well, this is just how muscles
seem to work, is that the more damage you create in one event, the longer the process is to fix all
of that. And this is kind of reflected in that delay that I was describing. So I think some people
have kind of taken the view that or made the assumption that more damage just means more damaged
fibers, which is not really what's going on. You're actually damaging the fibers to a greater extent
individually and that then takes more time and it is because in part, because when you create that
greater amount of calcium and accumulation, it creates the greater calcium response, that then
requires more time to go through its process. It's like you're telling the fiber to go through
process that is fundamentally longer. And then the inflammation process again is then longer.
So ultimately, you do five sets or something for a particular muscle group. You're creating
damage, which is going to take a long time to then fix and it's just going to sit down until it
goes through the process. You are then basically creating a super spinal CNS T problem that's going to
take, you know, at least all of the following days, not the day after that as well to deal with.
And you're then going to be, you know, kind of suffering from that effect. When you do your workouts,
they involve other parts of the body because super spinal CNS T is literally just happening inside
the brain. So let's say somebody doesn't want to train full body, that they want to do full body
three times a week or whatever. What are some ways that they could minimize the impact of super
spinal CNS fatigue on successful or future workouts? So first of all, I'm going to clarify that there's
not very much that you can do once you've triggered post workout fatigue to do anything to alleviate it.
That statement is almost 100% true. There's a little bit that you can do to mess around with it,
but ultimately it's far better to work on prevention rather than trying to fix the problem once
it's happened. So first things first is adjust the training program rather than trust in, you know,
magic widgets to reduce the magnitude of the post workout fatigue effect because it's not,
there's not really very much that's going to happen. There's a little bit of data here and there
that's just, if somebody is not eating sufficient protein, that they increase protein levels,
that will accelerate the rate of post workout fatigue recovery. Yeah, not very much else. There's
a couple of tiny little things here and there, but maybe I'll do a thank you about that.
So ultimately we're talking about structuring the workout to try and avoid the problem.
And really first things first would be everything that we know that affects post workout fatigue,
which is essentially you're going to start with your volume, which we already talked about. So
volumes can't be top end. Now just pausing a moment, this is really important because a lot of the
way that the, you know, people are advocate for two times a week being, you know, as good as all.
you know, some case people play it was even better than which is crazy but
you know like two times program is just as good as your three times a week program
and like well hang on a minute because you know if you're wanting to
pit these two programs together and I'm now explaining that you can't go up to those
high volumes in order to be kind of competitive then straight away we're starting to
make two times a week look even less attractive than it previously was um
ultimately you can't get to a maximum level of hypertrophy if you're constantly in a
state of super spinal cnst where did the podcast about this didn't we where we talked about how
I hope I remember this correctly I'm very embarrassed if we haven't done a podcast about this
I'm sure we did a podcast about what training variables affect our maximum possible hypertrophy
am I dreaming we may have maximum hypertrophy was that when we were talking about the full body
upload split I think we talked about how how certain things will affect the maximum possible
hypertrophy you could achieve and other things would simply affect the rate of hypertrophy yes
yes yes we did do that we did a lot of podcast I think we did do what the topic was yeah we did do
a podcast weather I will always read to the same outcome that's right yeah I really enjoyed
that podcast I thought it was a great a great narrative to walk through um yes so so yeah so we're
talking about two times becoming even less attractive because now with with constant high volume
two times a week training so you're doing five sets twice a week you you never training the top
motor units ever you can't so you can't get those those last few pounds of muscle mass because
you can't access the fiber so it creates that problem that might only really be recognizable in
advanced people pushing the boundaries but you know got volume as being a key factor I obviously
got stuff like rep range you know you just can't start talking about doing you know anything higher
than 10 reps really if you wanted to to to do uh sort of uh those workouts where you're doing
back to back you know training to failure is probably not a great idea either probably because
the way that calcium ion accumulation works is it's quite non-linear and it tends to
so to go exponential in the last two reps of a moderate load set so you'd probably want to be
starting to dial back the reps and reserve this is just really like darling back volume in in effect
because you're taking away stimulating reps so again you then look at the programming oh well
if I want to train two times a week I kind of got to do fewer sets and I've got to leave a
rep in reserve here and there or maybe even two and now it's starting to look very much like you
just doing the same volume as a full body but like two times a week in terms of apple hour apple hour
or push pull yeah yeah yeah exactly so it doesn't really matter whether you're doing them as a
six day week programmer or a four day week program you're still hitting the same problem in the sense
that you're having back to back gym days and therefore you're going to have the super spinal
seen as peak effect occurring and so you've got to look at the post workout fatigue variables and go
you know I've got to look at my volume I've got to look at my proximity failure I've got to look
at my rep range and then from a stretch position because stretch produces more calcium ion accumulation
you then look at your eccentric phases and you've got to look at your resistance profiles we may
not have much choice over that because your eccentric might be determined by the equipment that
you're using more or less as long as you're not already being silly with it and you stretch position
you might be needing to do those exercises because either those are the ones that are available to you
or because you want to train certain muscles according to neuro mechanic matching really you
kind of limited with your volume rep range which hopefully nobody's doing silly high reps anyway
but you're limited by your volume and your proximity failure but the point I'm making is that
if you go after those two things volume and proximity failure okay fine I'll do kind of a bit less
volume and I'll lose some reps in reserve you're going to end up doing you know pretty much the same
of stimulating reps as you do in a you know three times a week program except you ready to do
twice a week well how is that going to work I mean which is why we did that podcast talking about
splitting a full body into up low and one thing we did talked about was doing that on the same day
but then we also talked about up lower up lower up lower six times a week where each session had
lower volume then if you were to do it over four days if you take your your full body three times
a week amount of volume and put it over six days then we're talking each muscles getting you know
one set worth of whatever each one of those sessions absolutely I mean when we talked about that
which is one of the most quoted episodes I I keep sharing that episode when we talked about
Clancy Ross and his program and then we talked about this idea of splitting a full body into six
up lower days basically you've got the decision to make is do I do everything in one day where I
don't have a super spinal sinus t problem the following day but I do have quite a super spinal
sinus t problem at the end of my workout because I'm absolutely cooked so I just don't want to do
anything by the time I get into the workout because of all those sensations associated with exercise
which is the same thing it's just they're called by different originators so I'll cause by the
damage and the information it's called by things like the sort of activities of the cardiovascular
system and the subsequent information from that and but if you split the workout out then you've
got the following day you've got super spinal fey effect but you've got super spinal super spinal
super spinal sinus t effect from the exercise itself on the if you do it more or more and go so you've
got the same problem caused by slightly different things now you know coming back to your solution
which is to you know or one solution that you've described which is to do half the workout
you know go and have a small break for food and drink and then come back and do the other very
happen really you know but that's that would probably be the perfect scenario because it would
basically mean that you wouldn't be falling into either of those two issues of course we're now
describing someone who's basically a professional fitness influence yeah it's it's not necessarily
going to fit with everyone so what you've given an outline of theirs the things that you can do
you can modify to essentially reduce the the effect of the calcium ion related fatigue right
so these are variables within a training exactly exactly now on on the other end of that training
session so ultimately you said there's not a lot that can be done kind of you just need to give it
the time that it needs and so that means that any and we've you know said there's multiple times
any workouts split any training split that has successive days is going to suffer some problem
there so obviously the natural solution be something like a full body with the day off in between
each session but you could even and I've been I've actually been thinking about programming this
in one of my groups if you were going to do something like a upper lower it might even be and
this becomes a scheduling problem for some people and that's why I haven't done it yet but you
could even do like a upper day off lower day off upper day off lower day off instead of doing two back
to back sessions and that would give you if you alternated like that well each every four days you
repeating a session so that would look in theory similar to a full body AB if you're doing an AB
full body when nothing was being repeated over either those two sessions so someone had a long
enough exercise list that they simply weren't able to repeat or do you know half of that work out
and each successive session that could be a viable option for them yeah that's that is literally
the slowest that you can go yeah if you're doing single sets if you're doing single sets but in
that single set in that scenario that is as slow as you could possibly go doesn't mean it's bad
because you're still making progress but you know it would be the slowest that you could possibly
go doing two sets would probably be my choice in that scenario but again yeah which I don't think
you're someone to split into an upper lower then normally not going to be doing single set per muscle
because that session is going to be 20 minutes yeah I mean so you know again but we're talking about
pretty slow rates of progress and that's not right the the the full body AB I think is is interesting
because you do get a decent trunk of overlap which you're not getting with but as you said that
that was the advantage of that so you kind of you get the speed of the kind of every other day
progress which is which is pretty fast for most of the muscle and then you get the speed of
you know kind of the the every four days for the bits that aren't shared which I think is a nice
compromise I think upper lower every other day is started to go really really slowly I think but
you know with single sets yeah again with single sets yeah I probably wouldn't be
had someone would do it the way I try to get around with upper lower or push pull or something
like that with this excessive days is I find you know we we talked about this last week where
I think this last week I'd mentioned to you we used to say that full body was the hardest split
to program full and you made the comment that once you started using AB it became so easy and for
me I never find upper lower or a two way split the hardest program full because you end up being
so limited in there's only like a few scenarios they kind of work fairly well and one of them like
you've talked about in terms of reducing volume estimated volume of fatigue you end up kind of
getting locked into where I get locked into lower repetitions like often I'll do multiple sets of
of very low repetitions sub five repetitions or you know obviously all you're limited just with the
amount of volume in total the types of exercise that you can do and it ends up being almost like
these are the options I've got there these very small handful of options to make this work well
whereas I look at something like full body and it's like well if I want to do high repetitions it doesn't
matter you want to do a single set of high reps who cares or you know there's so many things you can do
it becomes so liberating that everything is on the table but with upper lower to do it well
this it's just not not that many options is there I guess I don't spend a lot of time trying
to program like that so I don't I don't really know I think I think really for me it's been it's been
a very interesting process to look at the routines that you've been sharing with us because I think
that has shown how
How many people were simply just doing full body same workout three times a week, and how
popular that was, now common that was, that it's kind of shifted my sort of baseline on
my benchmarking. That now has become my new kind of starting point. It's like, whenever
I look at the program, I'm like, if I were to just do eight or ten exercises three times
a week, once at each, two sets each, maybe if I was feeling really energetic or for some
of them, would this new program I'm being shown be better than that? And now, sort of nine
times I have ten, it's not. And then if I look at a program, you know, that I'm looking
at for some of the more advanced, and they're looking at bigger exercise selection, and they're
really gaining muscle mass quite slowly over a long period of time. And I go, you know,
if I were doing full body AB alternating, you know, that's my huge selection of exercises,
they can do 20 exercises at each time, maybe more, you know, is anything that I could possibly
throw at them, could anything be possibly better than that? And again, nine times I have ten,
there isn't anything, you know, and it's like, I was saying this to you the other day, so
much of the programming that I've seen in my time over the last 15, 20 years of looking
at this stuff. So much complexity is just complexity for the purposes of looking good, and it doesn't
do anything. It doesn't do anything. In fact, nine times I have ten, it makes program worse. And I
said to you the other day that I thought one of your programs or a couple of your programs were
actually introducing complexity that was interesting that works, that actually had a value, and it was
such a shock for me to see it, because I was like, every time I see complexity in a program, it's
not adding anything, it's not working. It's not better than a program that was written by somebody
in 1940, 1950. You know, that's just a bunch of exercises done three times a week for a single
set or two sets or maybe three sets. It's really difficult to add complexity to a program and have
it add value, I think, you know. The baseline, the benchmark, this is horrifying actually when
you think about it, that the baseline level of programming that was reached in kind of the early,
which may be, is as good as we can do now, really. The only thing that you could point at and go,
this makes bodybuilding better is the availability of machines. Yeah, it's an exercise selection,
that's an exercise selection. Because ultimately they're using four body training three times a week,
they're using relatively heavy loads, heavy or moderately heavy loads. Probably not training to
fail on every single set, giving themselves some space here and there, but I wouldn't point to that
as being an enormous factor. They're doing everything you could possibly think of that would make a
training program work really, really well to point to a feature of a training program today and go,
oh, well, but we're doing this. There's better and they weren't doing that. The only thing I can do
is point to exercise selection. That's all I can do because everything else is rid of that. It's just
horrifying. It's like, how have we been wasting our time or is it just that, is it just there's
there's a way else to go? Arguably you could say, well, you know, the three and a half times
week guys who want to train every other day, they've kind of, yeah, okay, fine, I'll give you that.
People who are training three and a half times a week, rather than three times a week, yes,
they've managed to find a tiny little bit of an edge there. Which they said back then anyway,
Hoffman back in 40s. They said that. You have to kind of say, well, would societal pressures have
stopped you from doing that? Yeah, literally. Bob Hoffman says the problem with this is you have to
train on a Sunday. That was it. So I don't think we can even claim that as in you. But that would be
the only thing I could think of really. It's very, very interesting, you know, and you know,
perhaps there's an entire conversation there around why that is and why we haven't managed to
make progress. Is it, is it just because there isn't any progress to be made? It could be. Well,
it's not, it's not even just not making progress. Is it like we have actually generally gone further
away from what seems to make sense physiologically? And you know, I was just reflecting on this.
I don't know if I said it to you or not, but only about a year ago, maybe two years ago,
I felt I couldn't give clients an AA or AA format. Well, that's the thing is because we've
actually changed the industry. So it's going to be really, really interesting to watch the trick
with an effect as because, you know, pre my kind of model, you know, we had most of the scientific
kind of part of the of the of the internet relating to the fitness industry was just kind of going
along with the meta work stress muscle damage kind of ideas, which essentially just supported the
way that, you know, kind of post-hannibalic era bodybuilders wanted to train. Yeah, you know,
that was just saying like, yeah, you know, smash the muscle to bits and that's great loads and
loads of stress inside the muscle on all this tubular accumulation, train with high reps and short
rests and all this kind of stuff. And so it was just mirroring that and it wasn't really trying to
connect physiology with what, you know, was going on. And that was bracketed now. We said, okay,
physiology says this, look, that's exactly how pre steroid era bodybuilders used to train.
And that's a really solid narrative, you know, especially at the same time as the kind of scientific
assessments of things like meta work stress and muscle damage being drivers of hypertrophy are
completely fallen over or they've been actively destroyed actually and to be fair to some of the
researchers who've done the work on that. And you know, they've gone after those hypotheses quite
aggressively and shown them to be invalid. So at the same time as that edifice is falling down,
we're showing people that, you know, look, that's where people trained, that's our greatest force
to bang out your loved ones. Here is what physiology tells us should also with a case it matters perfectly.
I think that is going to be a tremendously powerful story for people to the resonates with people.
And I think it'd be fascinating to watch over the next few years as it trickles down.
And as I keep saying to people on such a media when they say, yeah, but aren't you worried about
these people criticizing it? And I'm like, no, I'm not worried because you don't replace beliefs
with criticisms, you place them with new beliefs. So until somebody comes along with a better
model, a better explanation, a better belief system than I'm presenting you with, I'm not going
to worry because the stimulating rest model is going to win. Has already won really, you know,
maybe somebody will pop up tomorrow with a better one. Fantastic. I'll be the first in line to
congratulate them. But, you know, until that happens, criticisms don't matter. So I think it's
going to be fascinating to watch trickle down effect and watch how that starts to change the way
people are training. As you say, you and many other people will be able to recommend programs
but our full body and people will be like, yeah, no, that makes sense. Yeah. I mean, even full body
itself, like that's another thing that only a few years ago, the majority of the industry would say,
well, no, that's for beginners. You don't do that as an advanced lifter. And now that's okay.
You know, the narrative is shifted. And we've seen that narrative shift with the AA or repeating
workouts. I used to have to fool people like I would write ABC workouts. I mean, how many times
do we talk about this? You know, we've been on a club like, you know, what do you think of this
workout? Swap a buy-well for dumbbell so I can get them doing the same thing, but they don't
realize it or, you know, try to get a machine. And now, and now, now, now what happens is people
will contact me and be like, why did you program ABC? I remember that. I remember seeing those
questions and you're like, well, yeah, that's. You said, people have just cognitively shifted
now. And it makes me seem to go back to what we've been talking about the upper lower.
Pete, a lot of the, a lot of the way upper lower is being programmed, it is still ABCD. Yeah,
ABAB. I mean, no, what do I mean? Yeah, they're doing different workouts on each day. They might
do a squat on one of the days and they might do any extension on the other of the days. And so,
they're only training rep from once a week. And so unless they're doing five sets, they're not
going to see any growth there. So you've got the problem there of students you've just said,
but you're getting the worst of all worlds because you're still causing this super, super, super,
super, super, super, super, super. I kind of, I kind of got, I got people getting very,
I rate with me because I said that upper lower is the, is the, is the, I'm trying to remember why
I actually said people have accused me of saying it's the worst possible training split. And it's not.
It's just it doesn't do anything. Well, different. I think what I was saying,
it doesn't do it. It doesn't solve a problem. That's what I was saying. It doesn't solve a problem
workouts have. So if you like, look at a, you know, kind of a training split that you like.
And you know, what, what problem might it have? And does, you know, this other training split
solve that problem? Well, you can't really say that upper lower split really solves any problem,
especially if you do it with different exercises on different days because you end up basically
doing it kind of once a week training. And I can't remember what else I was saying about it,
but that I remember that was that, that was the vibe I was going for. It was, it doesn't solve any
particular problem. That was the context of me saying that I'm not saying that it's worse than
bro split. I'm saying that it doesn't solve any particular problem. Which I think is an interesting
perspective or framework for people to use. If you think about it, you know, we're not, I mean,
I'm not, I don't know if you are, but I'm not saying everyone should be using a full body
program. I mean, I know you're not saying everyone must do anything either, but you know,
I don't use modal verbs. Exactly. I don't, I don't play obligations on anybody.
But if you start by assessing a split against a full body program, you can at least see,
is it superior or is it inferior? And you've got two options there for full body. You can do AA,
or you can do A, B, repeating, and those will cover basically all needs in terms of how many
exercises one needs.
to do, etc. And then you can take it up below our ABCD or upper lower ABAB or push pull or
arms, torso, limbs, whatever splits it out there. And you can wait up against full body AAA or
full body AB and see is it solving anything? Is it doing anything better? And I would hazard a
guess that they're probably all going to come up inferior in terms of what they offer.
And then of course you're going to have people popping up saying, but I like training like this
and what I like is important. I'm like, sure, but again, there's separate questions. So understand
that you are, you know, kind of sacrificing some, you know, kind of rate of gains because you
want to train a certain way. And that is a totally acceptable decision to make. And you know,
nobody can tell you not to do that. Or I shouldn't really. I mean, I'm using modal verbs.
It's like you can't have anyone. But what you can't really claim is that your choice, your
preferences are going to make one program automatically, you know, equal to another program that
fundamentally physiologically is better than that. It just isn't something we can really count on.
It's just not valid. And to be honest, I kind of find it a confusing argument, even beyond that.
If someone says to me, I don't like full body. I think I mentioned this last week. My first
challenge to them is, well, give it a go and see it. But even if you didn't, even if someone
said, I don't like training, you know, too many leg sessions with my upper body or whatever.
Okay, well, this is where AB can work really well because you can wait one of those sessions more
upper body and one, you know, less lower body, et cetera. So you've got so much flexibility in
a full body AB that I fail to see that anyone could could not program that in a way that they
did in fact enjoy. Yeah, absolutely. I mean, when people say to me that I don't want to train
legs three days a week, I'm like, well, there are ways of training legs that aren't as, you know,
kind of uncomfortable as probably what you're doing. You know, you know, this, I think I'm
absolutely sold on single leg leg pressing. I think it's absolutely fantastic. You know,
I think it's one of those kind of exercises that you can put in the program and it doesn't feel
like you've, you know, crushed yourself, you know, I think, you know, somebody's like, well,
I feel like I have to squat every time I do leg down. Well, why don't you alternate squats with
single leg leg presses and you might find that it starts to work for you because you're not now
suffering in the way that you suffer when you squat as an example. Well, if you really wanted,
you could do quads on one of them and you could do hands on the other. Like you could you
want to take it a step further? I mean, then losing a little bit into you are you are, but if someone
is so against it, they didn't want to do so against it. But you know, there's, there's, there's
ways of, of kind of, as I say, you know, if, if you kind of locked yourself into the mentality where
you feel like you have to squat every time you do leg day, then maybe reassess that, you know,
because there are ways of training legs that are not necessarily quite so painful. Yeah, yeah.
Is it any other split worth mentioning? I mean, ultimately, what we've arrived at is every split
that has successive sessions or days on on consecutive days is going to suffer from this problem
and that's the message really. Yeah, I think that's the message. So any any any any program that you're
doing where you're in the gym back to back two days in a row, you need to look at the program and go
watch the impact of that previous day session on what I'm doing today. And even if you're training
completely different set of body parts, it doesn't matter if you did a couple of sets for a muscle,
you're probably going to have a problem the following day. That's really the issue. If you did a
single set borderline, but if you did multiple sets for a muscle group, you could probably got a
problem. And if you're training with a split that is doing different muscles on different days,
you're almost certainly doing more than set for muscle, really. Yeah. Because otherwise what you're
even doing, I mean, okay, well, hopefully that helped you guys understand Super Spinos CNS fatigue
and at least how to evaluate a split, you know, take look at compare it to full body and see,
is it doing something better? Is it doing something worse? What's going to work best for you? So we
hope you guys join us again next week and thank you as always for listening and subscribing and
commenting and all the good stuff.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Joe Weider, a prominent bodybuilding marketer, promoted split training systems despite initially starting with full-body routines.
A 1940s full-body plan published in Weider’s magazine featured single sets of 5–10 reps, aligning with early bodybuilding practices and emphasizing heavy or moderately heavy loads.
The program included two deadlift variations and minimal pressing work, highlighting a lack of balanced muscle development common in pre-1950s bodybuilding.
Post-workout fatigue involves calcium ion accumulation leading to local muscle damage and secondary inflammation, reducing strength performance across muscles.
This fatigue manifests as non-local effects, including super-spinal central nervous system fatigue, which impairs recruitment in untrained muscle groups.
Training splits increase the risk of cumulative muscle damage, delaying recovery and reducing recruitment capacity in subsequent workouts.
Volume and intensity are key drivers of post-workout fatigue; higher sets or heavier loads prolong recovery and amplify secondary muscle damage.
True hypertrophy requires balanced training, and the lack of structured, outcome-driven programming in early bodybuilding suggests a "pre-competition" phase of unguided training.
Summary:
This discussion explores the evolution of bodybuilding training through the lens of Joe Weider’s influence and early program design. While Weider is known for popularizing split routines, his foundational 1940s full-body plan featured single sets of 5–10 reps, emphasizing heavy loads and structural exercises like deadlifts and rows—yet notably lacking pressing and balanced development. This reflects a period before bodybuilding competitions established clear judging standards, leading to training focused on aesthetics over balanced muscle growth.
The analysis then shifts to the physiological basis of post-workout fatigue, showing that muscle damage from calcium accumulation triggers both local and systemic effects. These include reduced strength in trained and untrained muscles due to secondary inflammation and super-spinal central nervous system fatigue. This fatigue is not isolated to one muscle group and can impair performance across the body, especially in split routines where volume is high.
Training on sequential days increases cumulative damage, reducing recruitment and hindering recovery. The takeaway is that effective hypertrophy requires not just volume but strategic programming—avoiding excessive volume and focusing on recovery. While some minor factors like protein intake may aid recovery, the most effective strategy is prevention through lower volume, balanced exercise selection, and frequency management.
Ultimately, the shift from unstructured to structured training in the 1950s aligns with the rise of standardized judging and performance goals, marking a critical turning point in bodybuilding history.
FAQs
It was a three-times-per-week full-body program featuring single sets of five to ten repetitions for ten exercises, including a neck exercise performed for a duration rather than a set number of reps.
It shows a shift toward higher volume and split training, and contrasts with the more balanced, pressing-focused routines seen in later decades, indicating a transitional period in bodybuilding methodology.
Single sets with moderate to heavy weights help minimize post-workout fatigue, aligning with modern training principles that emphasize high frequency and reduced fatigue for optimal hypertrophy.
Bench press wasn't widely popular at the time, and the program appears to focus more on back and hamstrings work, reflecting the bodybuilding priorities before the rise of competitive pageantry.
After a workout, fatigue mechanisms—especially inflammation—cause a temporary drop in strength across the body, reducing recruitment in muscles trained on subsequent days, especially in split routines.
It’s a global reduction in muscle recruitment caused by inflammatory signals from muscle damage, which spreads to other muscles and impairs performance even when they weren’t trained directly.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.