015 Training Frequency - Why 3x per week beats 2x even if MYOPS is still elevated
from Hypertrophy Past and Present
1h 12m 15s
The episode explores two central themes: the historical training methods of Sig Klein, a pioneering but under-discussed figure in early bodybuilding, and the physiological reality of muscle protein synthesis (MPS) after workouts. Sig Klein’s beginner workout plan, featuring two alternating full-body workouts with single sets and progressive rep ranges, demonstrates early innovation in training structure—such as alternating routines and targeting both the upper and lower body—though it lacks overhead pressing and back-focused movements, which stand out as unusual for the era. The program’s design reflects the practical limitations of early equipment and training knowledge, with minimal detail suggesting reliance on assumptions. The second major topic addresses a common criticism of high-frequency training: whether prior workouts impair subsequent stimulus due to sustained elevated MPS rates. The analysis reveals that while MPS spikes post-workout peak within 6–12 hours and decline to near baseline by 24–36 hours, any residual elevation is minimal—only 10–20% of the original stimulus—making the concern over frequency-related fatigue largely overstated. Data from studies on MPS, including Philippe de Mars and Bird’s one-set versus three-set comparison, support this, showing minimal loss in subsequent stimulus. Crucially, the effect is negligible under realistic training conditions, especially in single-set programs where MPS returns to baseline quickly. The conclusion is that three-day-per-week training remains superior to two-day training, even with modest stimulus carryover, and that such carryover does not negate the benefits of frequent training. The episode emphasizes context—training environment, equipment access, and historical limitations—when interpreting old programs, and underscores that modern training philosophies should not overestimate the negative impact of higher frequency.
Good morning, good evening, good afternoon to everyone, wherever you are.
Welcome back to another episode.
And as we discussed last episode, we haven't been doing a very good job
of doing the, you know, small talk and you're shaking your head of me.
I was going to get you put on a spot to tell us a story.
But I won't do that. We're going to skip to the good stuff.
But Chris, how are you today?
I'm doing well, thanks, Jake. Yes, it's my evening.
You're morning, I think.
So yeah, good evenings. I'm good mornings all around.
Indeed, indeed.
So let's jump into it. We're not going to expose you to us trying to do any of the small talk.
So I'm going to kick us off.
We have a plan from someone who you've not talked about before.
And this is a guy named Sig Klein.
Now, I want to tell you a little bit about Sig Klein,
because we haven't talked about him.
And he's not someone who comes up a whole lot because he kind of fit
in this sort of bridging sort of time between the bronzer and the silver era.
So, and part of why he's not discussed, I mean, he's discussed a lot in like this
historical sense, but you guys may not have heard him discuss
because he didn't technically win any Mr. America's,
any Mr. Universe, any of these competitions.
Because they simply weren't happening when he was.
He was competing. He did compete in some competitions.
He did win some competitions.
But they weren't like those big sectioned events weren't happening at this point in time.
So we're talking these early 1940s, even late 1920s.
And he did, you know, for example, Sig was voted the,
what was the most, most muscular man in America or a world's best man.
And America, I think he actually was given both of those titles at different times.
And he is an interesting character in that he has like a significant lineage.
He was actually married to the daughter of Eugene Sanders mentor.
So a guy named Professor Tula.
So quite a significant figure in this sort of early late bronze period and early silver era.
Now the workout plan we're going to discuss today, he actually did publish quite a few different
plans and we might discuss some other ones in the future, but this was a beginner plan.
And what I think is particularly interesting about this plan is it was, so was for beginners,
but it actually followed an A, B full body structure.
Now at this point in time and even well into the silver era,
what you almost exclusively saw would be the same workout routine repeated multiple times a week.
So to see this kind of like two different workouts structures that you're alternating
or that you are performing at different times is quite an interesting format.
And you know, there were some people who did stuff like this, but it was certainly the exception.
So we've got two workouts and they were each performed.
So maybe exercise performed was done with single sets.
So this is obviously, you know, we're talking quite early on when the set system wasn't that
popular yet. And I think we have discussed this in the past, but the first sort of integration
of the set system was actually repeating and exercise at a later point in the workout.
So and I think Sieg does talk about this where he would say, hey, let's say your biceps
were an emphasis of yours or priority. What you might you say you're doing a dumbbell curl,
you might do the dumbbell curl at the start of the workout and then you might do it again once more
later in the workout. So that was kind of the way that they were, you know, sometimes
prioritizing or specializing in muscles and end sort of introducing this early iteration of
a set system. But this foundation workout just use single sets. And because it was from before
beginners, he instructed people to start with a weight that you could do about 12-ish repetitions
with work up to about 15. And then you actually encourage people to work back down and drop down
to eight repetitions up the load and, you know, sort of repeat with this sort of eight repetition
range. And in some of these other work, he does actually talk about dropping down to five.
So it does seem for the more experienced lifters he did prefer these low to moderate rep range.
So workout one, again, everything was one set 12 to 15 to begin with. He started with sit-ups
on an abdominal board. So these were like decline sit-ups. Then he went to a two arm curl,
so dumbbell curl into a calf raise, into a pullover with a bubble, which was obviously a very
popular exercise throughout both the bronze and silver era. He then went into a leg raise,
like hanging leg raise, into, well, it may have been performed on an incline bench,
essentially a variant of the leg raise, to a, to, um, like a, a barbell bench,
which obviously they weren't calling it a bench press at this point in time, but that's what it was.
Into a side bend, into a deep knee bend, so a squat, which is like you used to call that a dig knee
bend, and then back into a bench, but he did this with dumbbells, and again, they,
they called it something different at this point in time, but it was essentially just a dumbbell
chest press. So that was a workout, a workout one, and then I know there's a lot to remember here,
but I'm just going to jump into workout two. We had a deadlift, into sit-ups, into reverse curls,
into the leg raise again, so we've got that repeated, into a barbell shrug, so vertical shrug,
into what was called criss-cross in a standing position. Now, I was unable to find an image of this,
unfortunately, I, I imagine, I mean, with this would have been done with dumbbells. I, I,
I'm interested actually, how would you interpret that, criss-cross standing with dumbbells?
It sounds like it might be a slightly more complicated version of a lateral raise.
Yeah, I was thinking maybe like in the ground the wild type, which were popular exercises back
there, but I couldn't find any other references to it being called this. And again, this is part of
the issue being in the bronze, coming out of the bronze era, is a worse and pretty funky exercise,
that didn't actually persist into the silver era, and this may have been one of those. And then he
went into a dumbbell bench again, and so this again, it was called a push away, but it was a dumbbell
chest press into the dumbbell curl, and then he actually used weighted boots and did a leg curl
and a leg extension, and then concluded with a, a bit of like a dumbbell complex, like a,
you know, multiple exercises in one, like a little almost conditioning type thing. So that
were the two workouts, apart from our confusion over our criss-cross standing exercise, what are your
thoughts? So I've got a few thoughts here. I mean, I think maybe you've found the routine with
the least amount of back work in it. I think this is like a quest of yours to find routines that
aggravate me because they don't have any lab work. Because I've got, I mean, there's no, there's no
frontal plane, you know, wide grip pull-downs or pull-ups, there's no, isn't even any societal plane
stuff apart from the pull-over. So the pull-over would have been obviously done with the peak effort
quite a long way overhead, so that would have been very much more peck and triceps long head than
it would have been lab work. So really, apart from the deadlift and the shrug, there's not really any
backward going on here, which is absolutely crazy to me. Other stuff really, I'm very surprised,
given how close SIG client was to the sort of preceding generation, the bronzer or stuff,
very surprised to see a lack of overhead pressing. You know, a lot of emphasis on bench pressing,
very, very little overhead pressing. So you kind of wonder whether he had some kind of
disagreement with that particular exercise because it really seems very strange to go
from a lot of overhead pressing with what we initially started with all the way back at the
beginning, I think we looked at sandals routines. Now we're seeing almost pretty much none unless
there's something in that dumbbell drill. So that really jumped out at me. Again, when we talked
about some of the really early routines, we noticed a lack of deadlift variations, which
seemed strange because you would think they'd be very easy to implement. And we've got one here.
So again, that's another deviation from the trends that we were sort of observing.
In terms of things that make sense, it's interesting that we've got both curls and reverse curls
because obviously that gives us some brachyradialis as well as biceps brachy. And I'm intrigued to see
the leg raises because, you know, for the range of motion that he would probably have worked in,
that's definitely a rec firm exercise. So this really is that kind of inventiveness or creativity
that I have not been seeing and was kind of expecting to see eventually where people would notice
that if you did near extensions and, you know, kind of leg raises, you would get some rectus
from Morris development that you weren't getting from the squat patterns. So it's really interesting to
see that, especially this early, surprising therefore that it wasn't continued because this is a
clear example of somebody doing something that would have made a difference and you would have
expected it to have been picked up, but it hasn't, well, from what I've seen, you showed us so far,
I've not seen that happening. Interesting. You all said the leg curl and the leg extension
is such an early time as well. Obviously these were using iron boots, so it would be different to
what we would conventionally do today, but in essence, you know, training the same muscles.
And to have the lady's engine alongside the leg raise, you know, interesting. He's got two
things hitting the neck them when a lot of the other programs you see have no
neck them work. Absolutely, but of course, what we understand about two joint muscles is that they
definitely do tend to have two distinctive regions, sort of the upper or proximal region and the
distal or lower region. And the distal region tends to be in this case, the rectum more in the
extension, focused on the proximal region, the upper region tends to be more hip flexion focused.
So, you know, it's entirely plausible given that he was working in an environment where,
you know, the only stimulus for hypertrophy would have been his workouts. He's not confounded by
the pharmaceuticals that confound issues today, that he may have noticed these changes happening
and therefore include those exercises. A funny interesting as well that he, in the first workout,
he actually concluded with a squat. And so the early exercises, you know, bicep curls,
car trees, pullovers, like generally these.
not as cardiovascular demanding exercises, and yet in the second work, it actually starts
with a deadlift.
Yeah, that's a really interesting difference, isn't it?
So, yeah, you've got that push everything that's cardiovascular demanding at the end of
the workout mentality, which other people have made that point, you know, even more recently,
which makes a lot of sense, because if you've got a lot of muscle mass and you're doing
sort of higher repetitions, because of course, remember that squat racks today are very
convenient, while they were dealing with back then was much less reliable if it existed
at all.
So, you know, you can kind of understand what they had to do higher reps on the squat, because
you just can't get that bar into the position if you want to, you know, kind of use heavier
stuff.
So, it makes sense if you're doing higher rep squats, you're going to put them at the
end of the workout.
Maybe that explains the deadlift issue, because they wouldn't have had that problem.
So, you could have actually pushed the weight up a little bit more.
You can obviously, you're not prevented from taking short breaks between reps either.
So, you know, maybe that's exactly, maybe the explanation is right there, which is simply
that when you're doing squats, as they would have done them with a bar by then place with,
you know, kind of the need to do higher reps, because you can't rack it very easily, it's
going to be very, very cardiovascular demanding.
In the case of the deadlift, you can load it up to whatever you want and you can do a rep
and you can cluster it, really, or kind of at least leave a intra-intercept pause between
reps or interrupt.
Yeah, potentially.
Yeah.
Like, if he's suggesting laid on to go down to five repetitions, well, that's not really
going to be feasible with a squat.
So, yeah.
Absolutely.
If you're not in that sort of situations where the equipment that they've gotten, whereas
the deadlift is whatever you want it to be.
Yeah.
That's a good point.
I do think it's important whenever we look at these plans, always be thinking, what did
I have access to?
What didn't I have access to?
What did we have access to today?
Did that potentially influence anything?
Because we do see that with this squat all the time.
You know, there's really these squats, 20 reps squats, all this kind of thing.
It's like, yeah, but how else could they have done it?
They didn't have other options a lot of the time.
And I think especially when you pair that with the lack of detail that they had a tendency
to work with, they really left details out and they kind of assumed a lot.
Yes.
And if you pair that, we could be looking at this going, well, we think this means this.
And actually, with the amount of detail they left out, with the assumptions that they
were bringing to the table, the actual picture might have been somewhat different from what,
you know, we would expect.
I think we have a very programmatic approach to these things.
Yeah.
They probably saw a lot of our, the things that we see as program variables that can't be
fiddled with.
They probably saw them more as more kind of guidelines.
Yeah.
For a fixed program rules.
There's so much fluidity, whenever I'm reading any of these old magazines or books, I
mean, like, so often I'll get to a plant and they'll be like, this exercise, do, you
know, two sets of 15 and this one do two or 10 to 15.
And then they'll be an exercise.
And there's nothing.
That's like, just do any reps.
No, do it.
Yeah, just do it.
Literally, it'll be like, just do it so you can't do any more.
Okay.
Three and a half hours later.
Yeah.
Anyway.
Okay.
So we are doing another one of our part two episodes.
I think we did this last week or a few weeks ago where we were doing like a second episode
on a topic we've done previously, maybe last week.
And this is in some ways another part two.
So do you want to introduce us to what we're going to discuss?
Yeah.
So we've been talking a lot about training frequency.
And so one of the questions that we've been seeing a lot recently relating to training
frequency.
And actually one of the claims that some critics have been making about higher frequency
when I say higher.
I mean, sort of three days a week or every other day type training.
One of the, and one of the critics that's been, or criticisms that's been made about
this is this idea of my favorite protein synthesis rates being elevated post workout.
And potentially then if the rates are still elevated in the next workout, that could cause
a problem for us getting the maximum stimulus from the subsequent workout.
So that's, that's basically what we want to address today.
So essentially to give some very brief physiological background, just so that we're all on the
same page, what's happening is we go into the gym, we do a workout, train a muscle,
and then that muscle is all the fibers in that muscle are stimulated by the mechanical
tension that they experience or produce and experience.
And that then signals them to upregulate, increase the rates at which my fibrils are,
all my fibler proteins are being synthesized or made.
So what we're saying is that all of the time muscle fibers are producing, building new
myfibular proteins and having experienced a mechanical tension stimulus, the rate at
which those proteins are being built is increased.
And I'm just being really specific here because sometimes people think that muscle fibers
are not building proteins all the time and that suddenly when you do a workout, they
start building them.
It doesn't work like that.
You have a basal rate at which the proteins are being built.
And then when you do the workout, any muscle fibers that have been stimulated will experience
an increase in the rate at which those proteins are being built.
Now, there's a slight extra complication in the sense that you can have, or we do have
a rate at which proteins are being broken down.
So at any one moment in time, you've got either a myofibular protein synthesis rate or
a muscle protein synthesis rate to more talk about the differences between those two things
later on.
And you also have a myofibular or muscle protein breakdown rate.
So you kind of, if you're looking at a lot of scenarios, you'll see an MPS muscle protein
synthesis and an MPB muscle protein breakdown.
And ultimately, whether or not the fiber increases in size depends on the balance between
those two rates.
So you can have a situation where the protein synthesis rate is high, but your protein
breakdown rate is also high and you end up basically at zero still.
And so you've got to be aware that just looking at muscle protein synthesis rates or myofibular
protein synthesis rates isn't going to give you a perfect picture, but generally speaking,
we do tend to focus on myofibular protein synthesis rate or muscle protein synthesis
rate to a greater extent.
So that's the background that we've got in terms of, you know, we've done a workout,
we've stimulated, you know, muscle fibers to grow.
And they're doing that by up regulating increasing the rate at which they're building these
new myofibular proteins.
And, you know, hopefully that is then successful in terms of hypertrophy across the week.
Now in a previous episode, we've talked about what the stimulus period is, which is essentially
this period of time in which we are in this net hypertrophy state.
Now stimulus period doesn't have to equal the duration of time for which myofibular protein
synthesis rates are elevated because you can have a scenario whereby the repair processes
are pulling all of that net muscle growth as it would be into the places where it needs
to go to rebuild proteins that have been previously removed.
The kind of a scenario where the fiber is largely growing, but you're essentially repairing
damage that you've just created, you know, throughout the post-workout period process.
So what we're going to talk about today then is the idea that when we have stimulated
an increase in myofibular protein synthesis or muscle protein synthesis post-workout,
that stimulus then will continue for a certain period of time.
Now we don't have amazing amounts of data for exactly how long that period lasts.
The hypertrophy literature has a couple of different measurement methods, and originally
we have what are essentially measurements around a point in time.
They took measurements over a period of a couple of hours, and you kind of get what I would
call a point measurement.
It's not a real point measurement, but it's kind of sent to the round of point.
More recently, most of the hypertrophy research has gone down the route of looking at daily
protein synthesis rates where you don't actually know what's happening at any one point
during the day, but you do know what's happened over the entire 24 or 48 hour period you're
in.
Studies which take those 24 or 48 hour period of measurements are really bad for actually
knowing whether rates are still elevated at any given point in time, because if you take
a measurement to 24 hours and another measurement at 48, and that's encompassed the previous
24 hours, you don't actually know whether rates were still elevated at the end point of
that 24 hour period.
You just know that the net effect over the 24 hour period you're in has been sort of
above baseline levels.
So really when we look at what I call point measurements, which is as I say, are not real
points, but they're just kind of a couple of hours around a point in time.
They only really go out to about 32 hours there or thereabouts.
So we don't really have any data for my hypertrophy of protein synthesis rates, and I don't
think we've got much data for muscle protein synthesis rates either past that kind of time
point.
Actually important is I think people might not realize that.
So essentially, like, let's say you worked in nine to five, and then someone said, okay,
on this day, you made $200.
It's like, okay, great.
But did you make 124th of that at 11 p.m. or did you make $0 and 11 p.m. and you made
all of it by 5 p.m.
And what you're saying is most research on this is just telling us what's a daily total.
We don't know if it's stocked at 5 p.m.
Anything passed about 30 hours or so, if you see a study that says, you know, we're measuring
my op, so 48 hours post worker, just look at it and it'll probably say that it's what
it will say that it's integrated my op, so what that means is that they've got an understanding
of what the entire area under the curve was between the 24-hour mark and the 48-hour
mark between the zero mark and the 24-hour mark.
They're not telling you what the rates were at 48 hours, they're telling you that there
was a overall effect area under the curve, or average rate, if you want to express it
in that way, that was above baseline levels in that 48-hour window.
But you're absolutely right.
It could have been that the first 12 hours of your second day was where it all happened
and after that 36-hour point, you were back down at zero, back down at op true zero at
baseline levels as again.
which reiterating that we're always making those proteins, but, you know, when I say zero,
I just mean we're back down to baseline at normal levels that, you know, you would experience in a
muscle fiber that hadn't just been through a workout situation. So, yeah, we're limited in terms of
what data is available, but, you know, that's kind of part of the process. You just have to make
do with what you've got. So coming, that's all kind of background. So coming back to the question,
you know, the question that we're wrestling with today is, if we do a workout and we stimulate
an increase in myfribular proteins synthesis rates, and that stimulus has caused all the damage,
it could be either, and that has caused us to be still observing an elevation in myfribular
proteins synthesis rates at the point when we do the next workout, what is the implication of that?
So let me just talk that through again, because I think I probably didn't do a very good job.
So we do a workout and we stimulate, or again, I'm getting myself wrapped up because I want to
be clear that I'm not differentiating here between my ups rates that are elevated due to stimulus
and my ups rates that are elevated due to damage. You do a workout, you produce both the stimulus
fiber and you also produce some damage. Then you come back and look at it 48 hours later,
when you're about to do your second workout, and you can see, because in a fault experiment here,
you can see that you've still got elevated amount. Now, you don't know whether that's due to
stimulus, whether it's due to damage. Okay, what's the implication of that? Or the implication of
that is that there's going to be some restriction on your ability to benefit from your
muscle protein synthesis rate elevations in that second workout. Now, why is that?
It's because we have cellular machinery that synthesizes proteins that can only synthesize
a certain rate. You imagine you got a factory that's capable of pumping out units at a certain
rate number per hour, and you can't go above that rate. You're limited physically by the machinery
that you got access to. So, essentially, imagine that you could do a workout that would push you
up to 100% of your capacity to make proteins, and then, of course, it would then come down again.
And let's say, when you got to the next workout, you were still at 10%.
What you're now saying is that you've only got 90% to play with in your next workout. So,
your next workout is going to be 10% less effective because you've still got 10% doing things,
and it could be stimulus processing, or it could be damage. And I'm not arguing either of those
things right now, since it could be either. It doesn't matter. The point is that you're using it
from the previous workout to do certain things that need to be done. And therefore,
you've only got 90% to play with in that next workout. You're going to find that you're stimulus
in the next workout is approximately 10% less effective. Is that making sense?
Yes. Yes. I think that's fully clear. I do have one question. I don't know if you want to answer
it now or later. So, in that thought experiment, we assume that that first workout did, in fact,
max out that sort of peak of my ops. Now, either ways that someone can stimulate my ops and not
max it out. And so, let's say you only had an 80% elevation, and then you still have a 10% elevation
when you go and do it again. Does that now, if you don't do another 80% doesn't now go up to 90%
or you're still tapping it out at 80%. Does that question make sense?
That's a very, very, very good question, because ultimately, that is going to be a key point
that we have to return to when we talk about the practical implications of this. Because ultimately,
the reason I talk about a maximum level is because in order to understand what you are losing,
you have to have a maximum to express it relative to. So, your machinery can make this this rate,
and that's your 100% rate. You can now say, well, I've lost 10% of that rate. If you only did say
a 50%, a workout only bumped my ops up to 50% of your maximum, then, of course, when you come back
down to your next workout, you've got 10% of your maximum that is still being used for other things.
You've got to be able to express that 10% against your 100%, you can't express the 10% against
your 50%. Otherwise, you think it was 20%. You have to have an understanding of what your maximum
levels are, and you're absolutely right, because it entirely possible that you could add your 50%
onto your 10% and you'd now be at 60% and actually, what's happened there is that because your
workout wasn't anywhere near your 100% limit, you're perfectly capable of operating within the
structures that you're in. And you don't need to worry about that. Hang over, if you like,
from the previous workout. So, essentially, you're absolutely right. We've got to look at things
in practical context and go, did my workout, or does my workout actually hit 100% of my capabilities,
or am I substantially below that? You do make a point that muscle damage is wrapped up in that,
and I don't know if you're going to talk about that more a little bit later on, but it is just an
interesting thing to keep in perspective when someone is programming, to understand that actually,
if I'm programming in a way that minimises or does cause more muscle damage, that is all actually
wrapped up in the same machinery that's causing hypertrophy. Yeah, so if you create a lot of muscle
damage, then what's going to happen is not only are you going to have fatigue mechanisms that are
creating problems for you in terms of stimulus, you've got that muscle damage, it's going to create
a reduction in the force producing capacity of the fibers, reduce the tension, reduce the stimulus,
you've also again got the inflammation that reduces the amount you know, equipment through the
super spinal sinus fatigue effect. What you're dealing with then is a specific effect just from
the fatigue mechanisms of your stimulus, but we don't often then talk additionally about the point
that you just raised, which is that if I'm still processing proteins, and I'm still building proteins
for the purpose of repair, nothing to do with the high protein stimulus at this point, I'm just
dealing with you know, in and out, so I've got breakdown equaling my synthesis, it doesn't matter
that breakdown equal my synthesis, because I'm still actually having to make those proteins.
Yeah, so even though my breakdown is meaning that I'm not net, you know, kind of in protein
accretion, I'm actually in that zero, I'm still actually having to use my machinery to build those
proteins that are basically just in and out. Now essentially that means that if I do produce a lot
to muscle damage, I've got to then build that into my subsequent workouts of the program,
and expect that my stimulus could potentially be impacted by those as well. So if I'm doing,
you know, workouts that are quite the long way apart, but very very damaging, that could be an issue.
So really, all I would like to do today is to discuss two sources of information or two
studies that we could use to try and put some numbers, very rough numbers, onto the magnitude of
this effect. The reason I want to do that is very simply because when I look online, I see people
saying that if my ups rates are elevated from a previous workout, then hypertrophy stimulus is
impaired. Okay, nobody's really disagreeing with that. What we're disagreeing with is what's
the magnitude of the effect? So you might find somebody who says, oh, well, actually, if my ups rates
are even slightly elevated, then you don't get any stimulus from your next workout. Well,
clearly that's just silly. That's not happening, you know, whereas no, somebody else might say, well,
actually, maybe the effect is very tiny. Well, let's look at it and see what data we've actually
got because, you know, especially at the moment, some people have been claiming that there isn't any
data that would give us any insight into this whatsoever. And there's actually two really nice
studies that we can use to give us some insights. Now, yes, little bit of extrapolation,
but not as much as you might think. So essentially, there's no real good order to talk about these two
studies. Both of them have disadvantages and advantages. And actually, they mirror each other in
terms of where one has an advantage, the other has a as a disadvantage in vice versa. So let's just
start with one of my favorite studies, which is the review paper by Philippe de Mars, which covers
muscle protein synthesis. Now, straight away, you can see that the disadvantages that we are
looking at data concerning muscle protein synthesis rates and not my fibular protein synthesis rates.
Now, some people might immediately say let's throw that out in the window and just not
talk about it. Let's work through it because what you're going to see is that when we look at the
next source of data, which does cover my fibular proteins and this is rate innovations,
is not actually that different. So you end up in a more or less the same place. And I find that
very reassuring. Basically, you can look in the review paper that Philippe de Mars has done,
what you can see is that immediately post work out muscle protein synthesis rates jump up a very,
very large amount. Now, they then come flying back down again, and about 12 hours, they're much,
much closer to baseline than they were in that first kind of 12 hour or sort of six to eight out
period at the beginning. So you've got the huge spike in muscle proteins in these rates that come
you know all the way back down. And just to put the numbers to it, if you start out by saying that
you kind of, you're at 0% a baseline, which is clearly not the case because we've got a baseline
level of that level, you then jump up to about you know, 160% of that in that first, you know,
kind of six to eight hours. And then by the kind of 12 hour point, you down around 40% again
or above baseline. So you can see that you've got this enormous spike happening in the first,
you know, kind of six to 10 hours or six to eight hours post worker. Now, I believe, and I've argued
this in other places that that's where a lot of the hypertrophy is actually happening. Now,
if you look at these studies that Philippe included in his review, they're all using quite a lot
of volume. They're using between six and 12 sets per muscle group per workout to get these rates
to increase. Now, I would regard that as a maximal rate. So I really like this review paper for
that reason because you can see that essentially you're kind of capping out the stimulus you capable
of achieving. So when we hit that number of 160%, that's probably your mission.
machinery, capping out, really, most likely, that's probably as much as we can push it.
And then of course, it comes all the way back down again.
And it comes down to about 40%. And then it kind of just gradually tinkers down to about
so the 20% by, you know, kind of a 25% dish, by about 24 hours. And then by about sort
of 36, it's down around about the sort of 10% mark. Really, what you can do is you can
look at this. And you can say, if 160% is my maximum rate, and again, we're dealing with
NPS here, not my ops, but if 16% is my maximum rate, if I'm looking to do another workout
at 48 hours, and I'm down at say, you know, kind of 15 or so percent, then realistically,
you're kind of saying you're about 10% problem. You've still got an elevation of NPS above
the baseline, which is about 10%, and that's 10 to 15% sorry. And of your 160, that's
around about 10% ish, 15% is about 10% of 160. So the problem would be that you would only
be able to, if you want to then stimulate another maximum amount of muscle protein synthesis,
which I don't think you'd be able to do with 6 to 12 sets, because I think you'd still
be experiencing quite a lot of fatigue. But if you were able to do that, you would probably
only lose 10% of your 160, you'd be at 150 instead of 160. Sorry, now that's mixing my
percentages, sorry, I'm not mixing my percentage, you'd be at 145% because there would be 15%
not 10%. So you'd be, yeah, you'd be 145%, you'd essentially have 90% of your 100% stimulus
again, bearing percentages around, but that's where you would be at. You'd be at 90% of what
your maximum capabilities would be assuming the curve was exactly the same shape in both
situations, which it may not be, but let's assume that it would be. So essentially we're
seeing that we're losing time. Is it all of that making sense? Yes, yes. Hopefully we
didn't lose any one of those percentages. It's just confusing because we're talking
about 160%, as opposed to 100% being the maximum. So ultimately you're just saying there's
about a 10% reduction. If one were able to train again at that period of time and fatigue
wasn't an issue in this example, obviously it would have been, but you're saying obviously
it doesn't attenuate the full potential for that hypertrophy stimulus. It doesn't, you
know we're talking relatively small amount here that would actually be lost. Exactly. And
we can then look at a single, that was a review paper that covered a number of different
data sources. We can then look at the single study by bird, which is very famous, which
is the one set versus three sets comparison. Now if we look at the one set, we don't have
a problem because my ups is back down a baseline by about 35, 36 hours. If we look at three
sets, we can extrapolate the line just as a linear extrapolation and it gets down to zero
around about 60 hours. So implies you've kind of got about 12 hours of problem in your
subsequent workout post workout period. If you're training every 48 hours or three times
week. So you've got this 12 hour period. And if we look at the rates, the baseline rate
is 0.03. The peak rate at three sets is around about 0.08 you will take. So you kind of
got 0.05 of difference. And at the 48 hour mark, you're down to 0.04. So essentially 20%
of your three set stimulus max is being chewed up by your previous workout. This comes back
to your original point, which is that if we went and did another workout at 48 hour mark,
would we go up to 0.08, which is the previous three set max or because that three sets
is almost certainly not our tree maximum, because you can carry on pushing that higher
with, you know, kind of three, four, five, six sets or whatever, you know, would we just
simply have a high peak because you clearly capable of doing that. So it's unknown. And
I think that's the why we see a 20% difference here. And we saw a 10% difference with the
mass extrapolation because ultimately here, we're dealing with a much lower peak because
three sets instead of six to 12 sets, but fundamentally 10 to 20% is the kind of ballpark
data that we're dealing with. You're losing about 10 to 20% or 15 to 20% there or there
about off your, you know, subsequent workouts stimulus, assuming that those kind of muscle
proteins synthesis rates or my favorite protein synthesis rates are still present are still
being elevated from the previous workout. Now, is that all, is that all making sense?
Well, I've just described it. Yeah. And in this example, that's worst case scenario because
like you said, it's, it's possible that obviously that peak could be higher than we could just
increase to higher than what we actually stimulate in their first workout. So worst case scenario
here, we're talking a loss of 10 to 20% of that initial stimulus, but it may actually
not even be that. It may not be that for two reasons. Firstly, it may not be that because
as you say, we could probably post this initial spike higher if we were only doing three sets,
which is the maximum you're ever going to do in a high frequency program. Anyway, secondly,
it only applies for the first 12, in the case of the bird extrapolation. It only applies
probably for the first 12 hours of your subsequent 48 hour window. So it's only applying for
a quarter of your subsequent stimulus period. So it's probably four times smaller than you
think it's going to be eyeballing the percentages. I think, you know, working with a 10% or
a 15% is 10% probably is the number I would bet on. You know, 20% I think is way over
the top, absolutely way over the top. But if you wanted to, you could go to a like model
like mine, like the weekly next stimulus model. And you could say, well, okay, I'm going
to discount all of the higher frequency stuff, either the three sets of three sets, three
times we call it, you know, bear in mind you won't have this problem with single set programs.
You can't do this with single set program. If you're on a single set program, you're not
going to have this problem because you give me back a baseline anyway, you can see that
from the bird study. So if you're doing one set three times a week or once every other
day, you are absolutely not going to have to do this correction. If you want to do a correction
for say a three sets because you can see from the bird that you've got that little problem,
you could say, well, I'm going to discount my workouts by 10%. You can absolutely do that.
And that will be based on the exploration we've done here. If you're discounting my 20%,
you're probably somebody who's trying to make a point other than somebody who's trying
to track this through logically, but you know, you could do that. If you do that, you're
going to find that three sets is still better than two sets. Sorry, three times a week
is still better than two times a week in any recoverable volume combinations you want
to use. So if you look at the standard kind of comparisons of three sets, three times
a week and you compare that with five sets twice a week, the weekly next stimulus model
gives you a difference that's bigger than that 20% that you've just carved off the top
because you think that my favorite proteins in this race might not be back down at zero.
Does that make sense? Yeah. So there is a bigger difference between three times a week
and two times a week with max volumes than there is by this very tiny correction. I actually
really like this. The reason I really like this is because every time I look at the weekly
next stimulus model, I think that three times a week outperforms two times a week by more
than it should. And I look at it, I go, why is that happening? Why might that be the case?
And I go through all my assumptions and that, well, they're all airtight. There's nothing
I can do. This is the first time I've actually seen something that might help me move three
times a week. Just take it down a little bit because it looks like even for somebody who
is a fan of this kind of way of training, I looked at it and go, that's just too much
better than, you know, twice a week for my comfort. So I'm really, I really like the fact
that this, this starts to just take the edge of three times a week and make it look a
little bit more reasonable. I'm actually wondering whether it would be feasible to introduce
a term into the weekly next stimulus model to just shave 10% off or you can give people
the option. Do you want to shave, you know, 10%, 15%, 20% off? I think if you're shaving
more than 20% off, you're clearly not looking at the literature and you're clearly making
a point that you think, you know, that two times a better than three times without really
having any data to support that. But, you know, I think within that 10% to 20% range, there's
clearly data here that would allow you to, you know, take a little bit of the benefit
of higher frequency often and move it closer to a slightly lower frequency. Still doesn't
change anything. Everything stays the same. You still end up with three times a week being
better than two times. It's just not quite so horrendously superior as it was before
the correction. And that's, again, obviously, assuming multi sets. If you're doing single
sets, like you said, you can't do it for single sets because because we can see from the
bird study that single sets comes back down to baseline 36 hours. So you can't argue
that there's any elevation of my favorable protein synthesis that would cause you a problem
at 36 or 48 hours in the case of doing single set programs. So for people who want to do
single sets, you don't need to think about this. This is totally and utterly relevant.
I would argue probably two sets probably comes down to, you know, if you split the difference
between 36 and 60 hours, you can probably argue that two sets is coming down around 48,
even just literally on the bird numbers, not on anything else. I mean, I look at the fatigue
data and I see three sets coming down to baseline 48 hours anyways. Honestly, I think that
you kind of, this is an extremely kind of, what's the right word, picking kind of thing
to do to sort of, because ultimately we've got other data suggesting that it may not matter
and that the rates probably are down to baseline by 48, but extrapolating literally just based
on the birds to the insane, you know, okay, we've got maybe sort of 10, 20% elevation
still present. What does that really mean in practice? Well, yeah, you can just give
the three times a week a haircut and take it down a little bit.
notch. It's not going to change anything in terms of comparisons between two times and three times
because the difference is too big anyway. In case anyone's not aware you have a week and that's
some of this model calculator, there might be some people listening to this who don't realize that
you can in fact go and play with these numbers yourself, right? So these are way outside. Yeah,
absolutely. And if you want to do a correction to them, you can just, if you're using three sets,
three times a week or three sets every other day, that's the only scenario where you would do this.
The only scenario you would do this, you can just choose to look at your arbitrary units value.
So let's say you go to the weekly and it's similar as calculator, which as Jake was just saying,
it's click, link in my bio and you can go straight there. There's a calculator button,
you can just press that and it'll pop a calculator up in front of you. So you can then just put in
you're doing three times a week and if you're doing one or two sets three times a week, you just
don't have to do a correction. If you want to do a correction for this excess
my horrible proteins, and this is a rate of the patients that the next worker, you just take
10 or 15 or 20% off the number. And then you can compare that corrected number with any,
you know, kind of other program you might be doing two times a week, five sets, four sets, three sets,
whatever. It's not going to change anything. You're still going to end up showing that the three set
program is better. Keep saying three sets. It's because I'm thinking about the bird study being
three sets whether versus one set three times a week is still going to come out as better than,
you know, once or twice a week is just too much better to make a difference. This 10 to 20%
which is, you know, the number that we can kind of get to in terms of, you know,
my horrible protein synthesis rates maybe still other rates are very slightly the next worker.
It's really not going to change anything. But yeah, they can use the calculator and then if they want
to, if they've done a three set protocol either three times a week or every other day,
you could apply this correction of 10, 15, 20% and get a slightly more, you know, kind of maybe
accurate number. I don't know. I mean, ultimately looking at the demass paper, it's not clear whether
or not you would still have elevated MPS at kind of 48 hours. It requires you to really extrapolate
quite aggressively. The bird does allow you to extrapolate relatively simply just a straight line.
It comes down to 60 hours with a three set protocol. But their mind, the bird,
we're doing 14 rep maxes, more or less. Now, I think if you were to do an eight rep max
or even heavier, I don't think you would still have any muscle damage kicking around at, you know,
48 plus hours. So again, the validity of doing this correction is questionable. I'm being
extraordinarily generous to make the point like I was making the point with the frequency studies.
You know, I think a lot of people messaged me saying they really appreciate the fact that when I
did the frequency analysis that I did recently and I used the evidence that the people who are
criticizing me were using. I said, I'm starting from that point. Therefore, let's talk about that and
let's go from where they are to where I am and explain the differences along the way. What I'm
trying to do here is do the same thing. You know, people are saying that their main issue with
higher frequency is that they don't think my ups rates have come back down to baseline by the time
they do the next worker. I'm like, well, let's look at the data that allows you to assess that
and see how big the problem is. And the problem is probably around 10% at my best guess. I think
20% of you being extraordinarily uncharitable, but I don't think you can go any higher than that.
And assuming obviously like we've said that you're not able to reach a higher peak. So this is
really. Absolutely. This is this is absolutely beyond worst case scenario. I'm just kind of enjoying
kicking around an idea that might enable me to make the weekly next to me as model better. I have
no real kind of expectations beyond that. It could turn out to be completely not a nothing burger.
I mean, it could be nothing here. There's just no reason really that I can see that means it's
definitely happening. It's just here are two extrapolations that we could do that get to very
similar numbers. That's it really. And assuming someone were doing three times a week,
then obviously if you've had two days off over the weekend, then that first workout wouldn't be
impacted by this even if this were to occur. So you would only be doing that 10% calculation
on the second and third training session for the week. Exactly. So you could even carve it
back a little bit. You know, you could say it's it's got to be corrected. Yes, if you're doing
every other day, you're going to have that problem. But if you're doing every other day, your numbers
are going to be so ridiculously high compared with two times a week that it's not even going to be
worth doing. You know, you're never going to see a difference there that's worth even talking about
with this 10% 20% discount. Yeah, what you mean is, what I mean is that every other day is going
to obliterate two times a week so badly that no amount of discounting is going to change anything.
I mean, I don't think any of the amount of discounting is going to change anything with three times
we can either. But with every of the days going to be so ridiculous, it's not even worth talking
about. Now, a question that people I've seen come up about this is, okay, the single set is
back at baseline 24 hours and three sets is let's say 36 or whatever you want to say, how does that
change the weekly net stimulus? How can you compare different set volumes with different potential
myops timelines? So are they are they asking here about stimulus periods then? Because yeah,
basically, ultimately, the problem is assuming that stimulus rates and they're assuming that myops
is anonymous with that. So you can't you can't actually do that. So you can't say that if myops
is elevated then we're in a stimulus period because you're not seeing what muscle protein breakdown
is doing. Also, you're not seeing where the stimulus is, sorry, you're not seeing where the
synthesis is sending the proteins to. So there's four really good situations in the literature
where we can go and we can see where elevations in myfribular protein synthesis are happening and
hypertrophy is not happening. So we can look at what I call non-exercise muscle damage.
So like a contusion of bruise, anything like that. There's a bunch of different animal models
you can look at. And what happens is the researchers will do a small intervention. They'll create a
small amount of damage in the muscle in a way that's not exercised related. And then they'll look at
what happens to muscle protein synthesis rates and it elevates, it increases. Now, this is one of
those really interesting things that I've talked about previously, which is that the elevation is
quite delayed and the delay tends to be longer the more severe the damage is and processes that
need to occur take longer. So generally speaking, if you produce a rather unpleasant contusion in a
rodent muscle, then it will probably take about 48 hours before you see a meaningful increase in
muscle protein synthesis rates. Now, some people have kind of just jumped on that and gone,
oh, muscle damage only starts repairing after 48 hours. Well, no. If you create an enormously
severe contusion in a rodent model, that's what happens. If you're creating a lot less severe damage,
then the processes that are required to go through to finish the process of dealing with that
damage happen a lot quicker, more quickly. So I think that in human muscle in response to
strength training, you're probably dealing with about a 24 hour period in which the processes
necessary to complete the damage are occurring. And then your second 24 hour period, that's when
you're repairing the damage with the elevation in muscle protein synthesis. So I think if you looked
in humans, you would see that it's day two when your damage repair is happening. It's the very
severe contusion situations that we see in the rodent models, that's when you see it being pushed
out longer than 48 hours. So that's the category one. Category two would then be a aerobic exercise.
We've got some really nice day two in humans showing that aerobic exercise workouts elevate
mindfulness synthesis rates for quite a few days. Now, when those same workouts are done in a
string to form the training program, you don't get in the hypertrophy happening. So again,
you can see that aerobic exercise is elevating the synthesis of the proteins. That's not translating
into hypertrophy. It's just that you're dealing with higher turnover, you're not dealing with higher
protein accretion. You can also see it in situations where we look at, say, static stretching,
causing sarcoma redenesis. If you have static stretching, causing sarcoma redenesis,
then what you're going to see then is protein accretion occurring with additional sarcoma
in series, but you're not going to see anything related to the diameter of the fiber with additional
myfibral. Now, if you put some animal in a cast and you cause sarcoma redenesis by sort of leaving
the limit and mobilized position for a long period of time, the mobilization will cause the loss
of myfibral, but the stretch will cause the addition of sarcoma. This is basically why sarcoma
redenesis and myfibular addition cannot possibly be stimulated by the same thing. That's a separate
composition. But here we can see that you can have an elevation in synthesis rates adding proteins
onto the end of the fiber to make new sarcomas, but then not actually causing the addition of
myfibral because you can see them being lost in the atrophy processes that you're doing.
And then finally, you can basically just eat some protein, and that will elevate your muscle
proteins in this race. And it won't cause the muscle to get bigger. It won't cause protein
accretion. You're just having a higher turnover. Now, some people get very upset when I say that
because they go, "If I eat protein after a workout, then the muscle grows more than if I don't eat
protein." Yes, but that's not what we're saying. The stimulus came from the workout. The protein
feeding was just allowing that to be maximised or optimised. If you eat protein on its own,
it doesn't change the accretion of protein in the fiber. You can't eat protein and magically make
the fiber's bigger. If that was possible, then when a mobilization situations occur, such as in
cases of, you know, maybe somebody has to go into hospital or they've some kind of operation,
and they're in bed for a few days, and they lose muscle mass. If you could just feed them protein
and stop that happening, we would do that. It doesn't work. It's been tested a whole bunch
of times and it doesn't work. People still believe that it works because somebody tells them
that it does online and it doesn't. You know, so we've got these four scenarios where you can clearly
see elevations in myops or MPS are happening.
You know, and you don't actually believe that.
I believe all kinds of weird stuff.
Like it's, because it's something that I saw a lot back in the day, you know, this is
when I was sort of hanging out in my body building forums and stuff, and I hear people
talking about going on vacation, it's easy protein.
And I guess I sort of have changed my circles and don't see that as much anymore, but every
now and then I do still see it pop up and I think it is still a pretty prevailing belief
amongst a lot of people that if you just see, if you can't train, you're going away on
vacation, you seek whatever, you just eat more protein and it will somehow, and maybe
you won't mitigate all of it, but it will certainly prevent atrophy to a large extent because
it seems to, you know, the increase in MPS is going to build muscle and what you said
there is, it's not a stimulus.
It's, you can eat all the protein you want by itself.
It's never going to be a muscle-bully stimulus.
I think nothing is, nothing is changing there.
So that's just an illustration of four places that you can go and look in the literature
and see that elevations in my ops or MPS happen without a hypertry stimulus being present.
So it's very clear that you cannot just go to a study and go, look, my ops rates were
elevated for this period of time.
Therefore, that's the same thing as the stimulus period.
No, it's not.
It's absolutely not because if you've got damage repair happening and damage repair is very
well established to take a very long period of time in certain situations.
So if it really does drag on and on and on.
You know, every time you look at a damaged model, there's a whole bunch of these.
As I've said, you've got contusion models in mice.
They're even now developing contusion models in humans where they'll put a plastic tube
on top of your quadriceps muscle and they'll drop a small weight down the tube from a fixed
height and it'll cause a small bruise and the quadriceps and then they can go and measure
that and explore what's happened.
So they've got these models, they also have extremely fast eccentric contractions which
if you do them fast enough, pretty much have no cross bridging happening.
And you just get literally tearing of various sort of membrane structures and the whole
of the calcium mines flooding into the fire and creating all kinds of damage.
And you can get the same kind of thing.
If you look at a post injury profile of what the NPS or my ops then does, it really does
just kind of bump along just above baseline, showing that it's doing things, it's elevated
but it's not doing the spiky thing that we get with a workout.
We do a workout, you know, it's a ridiculous spike in NPS post workout for the first kind
of six to eight hours.
You create damage and it just bumps along above baseline because it can't really, you
know, kind of do what it needs to do at the same kind of speed that, you know, the hypertrophy
thing can do.
Is there an initial spike with the damage?
No, not at all.
In fact, there's actually an initial drop because what you get is a drop in NPS as the damage
repair processes or damage kind of completion processes really is what we should call them
because they're kind of tiding away the stuff that's been damaged.
It's kind of like clearing the ground, if you like, for the new structures to come in
and replace the old structures.
So you kind of got debris everywhere.
You've got this just junk lying around all over the place and these kind of inflammatory
cells come in and they clear it all the way.
And while that's happening, you can't really have the builders in doing what they need
to do.
You know, the clearing process got to happen and you can bring the builders in.
And you get a drop, you get a drop in NPS as this is happening because you can't do
the work you need to.
And then it kind of comes back above baseline and then you get this kind of grind, long
slow grind of things, you know, being done.
So and that's a absolutely, absolutely ubiquitous finding across all of the damage models.
You just get this long slow process happening.
So I think, you know, realistically, it would be damage I would expect to create this
kind of issue.
I question people may have when they look at the mild stuff is, okay, if the first portion
of this is preferentially shuttle towards hypertrophy in the second portion, more damage
repair than why do we not see a spike after the hypertrophy is mostly completed.
And then the damage repair begins.
And that's something I've seen so clear quite a lot as a critique of this.
And so ultimately what you've just said there is, well, you wouldn't expect to see a second
spike.
That's not the way damage repair works.
No, not at all.
Not at all.
All of the damage models show this long, slow kind of grind as it deals with stuff over
a, over a period of time.
Now, obviously, after remember that damage models are extreme and they're designed to produce
effects that we can see and they do, therefore, have that bigger delay and they have a longer
timeline.
I mean, in rodent models, you can see muscle damage out for weeks, you know, I mean, that's
because they're looking to create an effect that they can track and observe and, you know,
not have to worry about the stats because the effect is so big you can't miss it.
You've got to kind of bring that down and say it's a much smaller impact when you're dealing
with strength training workers.
Now, added onto that, we can of course program in ways that avoid that problem.
You know, I mentioned earlier, one of the reasons why I think the bird can be extrapolated
out to 60 hours is because they're using 14 rep maxes, you know, if you were using
eight rep maxes, I don't think you would see that effect.
So in terms of kind of how this matters, remember looking at programming.
So there's one idea that you sort of dispel there that, okay, if my office is elevated,
it's protective and there's no attributes that can be occurring and that is safeguarding
these muscle fibres and at the same time, there's two parts of that.
So firstly, it's protective and secondly, it inhibits you building or stimulating more
growth.
Yes.
It's funny, isn't it?
Because I've actually made this point a couple of times online on Instagram recently and
I had a bunch of hypertrophy searches message me saying, is this really contentious?
Do people actually think that, you know, just because my office is elevated, the muscle
is automatically in an animal state and can't shrink?
I mean, it's like, you know, these were people who'd actually read a little bit outside,
I think, of the immediate area, though, that I know them and they're well-read people.
They're like, well, you know, the Sock Mergenesis literature shows you that.
You know, all the protein feeding literature shows you that, you know, there are kind of people
who've done some kind of extra work outside.
I think there are people in the hypertrophy community who think that, yeah, if my office
is elevated, then the muscles in an animal state, it can't possibly shrink.
I'm like, well, here are four situations that prove you wrong.
And I think people have kind of just got it nailed into their mind that, if my office
is elevated or MPS is elevated, then the muscle is in a stimulus period.
That isn't what the day to show you.
It clearly shows you you can have MPS or my office elevations without being in a stimulus
period.
It kind of got to be very clear about what you think is going on with hypertrophy stimulus
and the damage of repair processors.
And any simple review of the damage literature will show you that it's a long, slow process
and it requires those clearing away things to happen before you can actually start building
new proteins.
I almost don't bother responding to people when they say, we don't think that you're
correct.
We think that damage repair is happening in the first 24 hours.
I'm like, well, you're just telling me you haven't done any reading because it's really
obvious that that first 24 hours, you need that period of time to actually clear the ground.
Damage is actually still ongoing in that period of time.
And clearing away the damage is also ongoing in that period.
You don't get the opportunity to build anything until probably 24 hours.
So it's actually very, very clear in the literature and it's a great shame that I think
a more hypertrophy researchers don't actually read the muscle damage in the, in the particular.
It'll be interesting to do a study where they did, like say, shorter position, isometrics
and then mapped out what that was doing from a myob's timeline, like something that
involved very little damage, but still a high degree stimulus and seeing how long that
lasts.
Well, I think you get pretty close to that with what bird did with this single set protocol.
Yeah, but could we, could we achieve a higher peak and still be back down relatively quickly?
If you re-did the bird study with like six, seven, eight rat maxes, then I think you would
probably, what you would see is an almost identical profile in the first 20 hours, 18 hours,
and then you would see it start to go back to baseline much faster after that.
That would be my prediction.
Okay.
I'm not protecting you from hypertrophy occurring, it's not in there and not ensuring that you're
in this anabolic period.
My office has got to be balanced by what's happening with breakdown rates.
You can't just say, it's like you've given some really wonderful analogies over the last
couple of months.
We've been trying to explain to people in terms of budgeting money or filling bathtub
with water or whatever.
Basically, you're pouring water into a bathtub with the synthesis rates and if you've left
the plug out or if you've got a really big hole in the, in the, in the bucket, that's
your breakdown rate.
Now, essentially, yes, you've got a balance between those two rates, but if you've got a really
big hole or multiple holes in the bucket, then it doesn't matter really how much water
you're pouring in the top, you're going to see a serious, a kind of net outflow.
So the synthesis and breakdown rates have got to be balanced or you've got to understand
the, the relationship between the two and you can't just say synthesis rates are up
therefore, I'm in a nanabolic state and I'm going to have that protein accretion across
the way.
Well, no, not necessarily.
And like you discussed earlier, then obviously it doesn't inhibit you from achieving a secondary
stimulus.
Worst case scenario, you just, like you said, shades that top 10% are so off it if we're
being really quite some of the worst case and assuming that we can't increase the peak
any higher.
So there's, I mean, there are the two primary arguments that I'm seeing people present
about this that it's protective and it stops you from experiencing another gross stimulus
and clearly both of those don't particularly make any sense.
is anything else that's important to know about all of this?
So, I think we've covered all of the important details there.
I think what I would like people to take home, though, from this podcast is that there is a very
clear reason why my ups' rates being elevated might cause a problem, you know?
And that reason is we have cellular machinery that makes proteins, and if it's still doing things
from the last workout, it has less capacity to do things for your next workout. That's it.
That's the rationale. That's what we're all talking about. So, the question is, how big is
that effect? The question is not, you know, is it happening or is it not happening?
That doesn't really tell you anything. I mean, okay, sure, if it's not happening,
then you can discard it. But if it is happening, you still don't know how big the effect is.
I think there's a lot of people running around with the idea that you have to get my ups back
down to baseline, all the other workout is pointless. Now, that idea just needs to go,
because that is not what anybody is talking about who understands this stuff.
You know, anybody who starts to dive into how ribosomes work and what we're dealing with
when we're talking about producing, you know, their new proteins, they are aware that we're
dealing with a capacity for producing them, that is kind of more or less fixed,
unless you kind of increase it with training, which is what happens. But in the post workout period,
that's not really change very much. So you've got a temporary ability to increase the rate of proteins
up to a fixed point. Now, then you've got to say, well, how much does that impact me?
Now, what we've seen is that the maximum impact really is around 10 to 20%.
And that assumes that you are trying to max out your stimulus, which you've made the point
we're not with three sets, you're not. Maybe with six to eight sets, you are, but with three sets,
you're not. So it might actually be a completely and utterly irrelevant point for people who are
training with one to three sets, or is it absolutely years for one server, it might be a
completely irrelevant point for these sets as well. So the maximum possible magnitude of this
effect is around about sort of 10 to 20%. That's what I'd hope people can take home.
And again, like we said, there's a calculator, they go, have a play, plug these numbers in,
and you can, you can do all this stuff yourself, and you can see you can compare two times a week,
three times a week, different sets, and you can. Exactly, and just to be super, super clear with
people, because I've had a couple of people message me saying, I don't understand what this number
is telling me. They've kind of put that current program into the calculator, and it's given them
3.1, and they've gone, is that good? I'm like, well, that's not what it does. You put two programs in,
and you compare the numbers, and the higher one is better. You know, I mean, within kind of boundaries
of what's possible. The only thing you can tell you in absolute terms is, if the number is positive,
then you've got net hypertrophy over the week. If the number is negative, then it doesn't work.
That's the only absolute thing you can draw from the program. So if you put your program in,
and you're doing two sets of knee extensions once a week, and you're interested in whether your
wreck fam is going to grow, it'll tell you it won't. It'll tell you it's not going to give you a
number above zero, because it won't. If you put in three or four sets, and depending on what your
assumptions are, it might give you a slightly positive number. But ultimately, that's the only case,
and a number is going to mean anything on its own. You're supposed to put two programs in that
you're comparing, not simultaneously, of course, but one after the other, and then you. I have to do
these disclaimers, because people, I'm trying to put both programs in, and it's not working. I'm
like, just put one in, and then press calculate, and then put even two tabs. You can do that.
You could even even do tell. That is allowed. But you know, it's just compare two programs that you're
interested in that you like, and it will tell you which one is likely to be better than the other.
Once you've done that, a handful of times, you'll see that there's a fairly clear pattern,
and it's going to give you a very, very predictable answer. Now, if you're a super user, and you want
to get into the really nitty-gritty stuff and start putting in, like, changing between data sets,
appellant and Shermfeld, and playing around with stimulus period durations and all that stuff,
you can use it for that purpose. But that isn't what it was originally for. It was originally just
a thought experiment to show what the physiological assumptions that we can rely on would predict
about training frequency, and it shows, broadly speaking, that if you're using recoverable volumes,
you're going to end up with three being better than two being better than one, and every other day
is probably better than I was trying kicking and screaming into admitting that, because I don't like
training that way, but you know, 3.5 is better than three, which is better than two, which is better than
what. Now, what you'll find is that the long-term training studies only kind of, or we did in
the last podcast, only map loosely on top of that. They show the same direction, but they don't
give the granularity. But that's what models are supposed to do. They're supposed to give you more
granularity over areas that you haven't got clarity over. Be confident about your assumptions,
you make sure it does directionally track with the long-term data, which it does, and then you can
move forward with a bit more confidence that your model is telling you, you know, useful things
rather than rubbish. And that's kind of where we are. I mean, it's just really fascinating to watch
people tie themselves in knots to try and find ways to criticize this picture, because I think it's
relatively clear, you know. Obviously, people have vested interests in arguing against it, you know,
so it's fun to watch, but there we are. I mean, you mentioned that you were drag kicking and
screaming about every other day. That's for me, and you know, you just said, hey, you can play
with these different datasets, you can do xyz with the calculator. And like, I've done that, you know,
I've sort of plugged in, okay, absolute worst-case scenario that doesn't, I don't think even physiologically
make sense. What would need to occur for xyz split to be better or worse? And it's not that either
of us are coming to this wanting necessarily a particular split to come out on top. I mean,
like you said, you were drag kicking and screaming with every other day. I was the same with full
body. I didn't want full body to get better. I was super resistant to that. That was everything
against what I was taught and what I enjoyed. And I make this point to people online all the time
that enjoyment, I think first and foremost, and maybe I'm sort of projecting here, but I think
enjoyment comes from what works. And when people tell me, oh, I don't enjoy full body, what I
see with my clients, not every single one, but I'd say probably 90% of the time is when they start
getting better results, they start enjoying it. And they might have thought they'd been the
enjoy full body, but hey, you know, when this is the best result I've had in the lifting career,
suddenly they start enjoying it. But that's really hard to argue with that feeling of motivation,
you get where things are going your way. Yeah, yeah. But you know, that's an aside, like we're not
where the two full body, when you look at this physiological model, it makes sense. When I look
at what people did before steroids, it makes sense. It's what they were doing. When I look at the
anecdote and yes, it's anecdote of the hundreds and potentially thousands of clients I've used full
body with now compared to other splits, it's producing better results. If suddenly the reality
of the universe changed and another split started to outperform that, I'm surely going to jump
over to that. I don't want full body to be better. It's just what all of these data and evidence
points are telling us at this point. Yes, I mean, I think you can get a lot of, I mean, I know that
people are still, I know that some people are still dragging their feet a little bit about the
lack of clarity in the long term training studies. And I'm very sympathetic to that, you know,
I would be much happier if the long term training studies were definitively showing three
as better than two, two as better than one and, you know, all the rest of it. That's just not
the world we live in. We don't have that clarity in the frequency data. We have to gather what
information exists and we have to map it out on top of each other and we say does, does a pattern
exist here? And we've got, you know, as I made a point recently on TikTok, yes, I'm back on TikTok.
If you haven't seen me there, I'm now there. I made a point on TikTok just to say that, you know,
the pre-1950s bodybuilders and their records of what they did is the most reliable, the very best
source of anecdotal evidence you're ever going to see. You know, every single bit of anecdotal
evidence I see online at the moment, I just simply ignore because I don't know that I can trust
it, you know, now you go back to that period of time and you've got much more confidence because
they didn't have anything that was creating a antibiotic effect other than the strength training
programs. You know, you map that and everybody's training three times a week. You then look at the
physiological data that we've got and what that predicts and that predicts three times a week
or three and a half sometimes split ahead. And then you look at the long term training trials
and it gives you three as better than one and everything else is a bit kind of unclear. And it's like,
all together that is pointing in the same direction. Yeah, I would I would love to see better
long term trials but we just haven't got that data set. So anything else that needs to be said
or is that I feel like I think we're good. I think we're good for the day. So we shall see how the
internet responds to my back of the envelope calculations using those two studies. I'm sure they
will have a list of reasons why they think that I can't do what I've just done and which I will
studiously ignore and carry on doing what I do. It just seems to be a trend where people basically
wait for me to say something and then explain why they think I'm wrong. But we should see what happens.
Yes, it is a trend that is true. I think and you know, I don't want to make this a whole conversation
but there's an expectation. I don't know. I shouldn't have even cited this. There's an expectation
that, you know, people will make you critique or something we've said or you know, video you put
out or whatever and that you're expected to always respond to everyone making demands on and
it's an odd belief and I just kind of just want to name it. The hey, this is that is what that
belief is expecting. That hey, it's what it is. It is entirely more than what I call it out but it is.
And someone is able to respond to that. I have no issue. Someone says, hey, I want to respond to
every single person who's talking about me or making a claim about, okay, go for it. And I think at
the same time, you also have a right to not do that and to enjoy your life and do other things
and put out information and people can do and say and think what they want about it.
It's the trend that we see now, I think, for people to try and shame you for not responding.
So I'll see like some comments. We'll be direct to them and they'll say, why aren't you
responding to so and so about this or, you know, why have you, you know, kind of ignored
that particular critique? And like, well, because I don't have time, because I don't think
it's worth talking about, because I think it's a weak argument. But any number of reasons,
I'm just like, you know, feel free to tell me that, you know, there's a critique that
people are getting. I mean, I don't get it, don't get me wrong. You know, I'm not going
to get upset with people for telling me that there are critiques out there. I mean, please
do that. I mean, I find it fascinating to see what people come out with. But yeah,
sometimes you feel like people expect it to have you and it's like, well, that's not really
how this works. I do wonder if it's just said inequality in people's spare time.
Well, is it other people who make me believe in that? Yeah, maybe because they think they've
got the time. They could, they could spare the time that they think you could spare the
time. That's probably fair. But, you know, I'm, I'm, I'm not averse to hearing these things.
People say, you know, I'm, I've heard this criticism by all means, you know, do that
comment, share it with me, whatever. I don't object to hearing it. I was just commenting
that I find it odd when people, you know, kind of try to shame you for not addressing
these things because it's not well, where, where are you getting the idea from that you
have that kind of right to tell me why I should be spending my time on? That doesn't
really seem appropriate. But I'm, yeah, I find it fascinating to see what mental gymnastics
people come up with for wriggling out of the logical quandaries that they find themselves
in and no doubt that this podcast will be very similar because I'm sure that the people
who have been arguing that elevated life of the proteins and this rates cause problems
in high frequency programs will listen to this and be very distraught that the data don't
really support it being that bigger problem after all. And, you know, challenging the
status quo is always uncomfortable for people who follow that or have benefited from that.
So, we will no doubt see a lot of unhappy people, I'm sure. But our goal is always to provide
value and not to waste. I'm going to say our goal is not happy people. That is, that's
the goal of this podcast, unhappy people. No, we always want to provide you go to value
and not just add noise to the space and I think we've transitioned into adding noise right
now. So we're going to stop. That's it. I've done today and hopefully you join us again
next week.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Sig Klein was a significant but overlooked figure in the early transition from the bronze to silver eras of bodybuilding, known for winning major muscle-related titles despite not winning formal Mr. America or Mr. Universe competitions.
His beginner workout plan featured an innovative A-B full-body structure, alternating between two distinct workouts, which was rare for the time and showed early signs of structured training progression.
The workouts included single sets with rep ranges of 12–15 initially, then down to 8–5 for experienced lifters, reflecting a practical approach to progressive overload and muscle adaptation.
The routines featured exercises like deadlifts, pullovers, leg raises, and dumbbell presses, with notable inclusion of leg curls and extensions using weighted boots—indicating early recognition of compound muscle development.
A key observation is the near absence of overhead pressing and back-focused movements, which contrasts with typical training trends and raises questions about Sig’s unique philosophy or access to equipment.
The lack of detailed progression or rest periods suggests that early training programs relied on assumptions and limited equipment, making modern interpretations highly context-dependent.
Research on muscle protein synthesis (MPS) shows that elevated rates post-workout decline within 12–36 hours, with only a 10–20% reduction in stimulus possible in the next workout, challenging claims of significant impairment from high frequency.
This data supports that three-day-per-week training remains superior to two-day programs, even after accounting for potential stimulus carryover, and single-set routines avoid such carryover entirely.
Summary:
The episode explores two central themes: the historical training methods of Sig Klein, a pioneering but under-discussed figure in early bodybuilding, and the physiological reality of muscle protein synthesis (MPS) after workouts. Sig Klein’s beginner workout plan, featuring two alternating full-body workouts with single sets and progressive rep ranges, demonstrates early innovation in training structure—such as alternating routines and targeting both the upper and lower body—though it lacks overhead pressing and back-focused movements, which stand out as unusual for the era. The program’s design reflects the practical limitations of early equipment and training knowledge, with minimal detail suggesting reliance on assumptions.
The second major topic addresses a common criticism of high-frequency training: whether prior workouts impair subsequent stimulus due to sustained elevated MPS rates. The analysis reveals that while MPS spikes post-workout peak within 6–12 hours and decline to near baseline by 24–36 hours, any residual elevation is minimal—only 10–20% of the original stimulus—making the concern over frequency-related fatigue largely overstated. Data from studies on MPS, including Philippe de Mars and Bird’s one-set versus three-set comparison, support this, showing minimal loss in subsequent stimulus.
Crucially, the effect is negligible under realistic training conditions, especially in single-set programs where MPS returns to baseline quickly. The conclusion is that three-day-per-week training remains superior to two-day training, even with modest stimulus carryover, and that such carryover does not negate the benefits of frequent training. The episode emphasizes context—training environment, equipment access, and historical limitations—when interpreting old programs, and underscores that modern training philosophies should not overestimate the negative impact of higher frequency.
FAQs
Sig Klein's plan is unique because it uses a two-workout A-B structure with alternating routines, which was rare at the time. It also introduced early forms of the set system by repeating exercises like bicep curls at different points in the workout to prioritize muscle development.
His workout included decline sit-ups, dumbbell curls, calf raises, pullovers, hanging leg raises, a bench press variant, side bends, and deep knee bends (squats) performed with dumbbells.
He repeated key exercises like dumbbell curls at the beginning and again later in the workout to emphasize specific muscles and simulate an early form of the set system, where the same movement is performed multiple times with varying intensity.
Overhead pressing was a dominant exercise in earlier training programs, so its absence in Sig Klein's plan—despite his proximity to the bronze era—suggests a possible disagreement with its effectiveness or a lack of access to proper equipment.
These exercises target the rectus femoris and help develop the anterior chain, which was innovative for the time and shows an early awareness of muscle-specific training for improved muscle development.
Muscle protein synthesis rates spike post-workout due to mechanical tension, but are also influenced by protein breakdown. The net muscle growth depends on the balance between synthesis and breakdown, not just synthesis alone.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.