014 Training Frequency - What the long-term studies actually show
from Hypertrophy Past and Present
1h 14m 41s
This transcript explores a vintage bodybuilding training routine from a 1952 physique magazine, focusing on Floyd Page’s full-body plan involving 12 exercises, three sessions per week, and moderate volume (8–10 reps per set). The plan highlights exercise selection patterns, such as narrow grip bench presses for clavicular targeting and a limited focus on hamstrings, reflecting the equipment and priorities of the era. The discussion then shifts to training frequency, emphasizing that physiology supports higher frequency—three times per week—as superior to one or two due to muscle growth and atrophy cycles. While long-term studies show minimal differences between one and two sessions, all studies consistently show three sessions outperform one. Critics often misinterpret meta-analyses that include non-frequency studies or use indirect measurements, which lack precision in assessing hypertrophy. The analysis reveals that even when frequency studies are limited, the pattern consistently favors three sessions. This conclusion is reinforced by historical evidence: pre-1950s bodybuilders trained three times weekly, and physiological principles align with this. Ultimately, the data and history jointly support higher training frequency as optimal, though the exact optimal point between two and three sessions remains less defined. The episode underscores the importance of understanding study design, measurement validity, and context when evaluating training science.
Hello, welcome back to another episode now Chris, I was thinking this week and I'm not going to not going to do the polite thing
I'd be like hey, do you listen to any podcast because I know that you probably don't so I'm just going to assume that you don't and I don't
Particularly listen to a lot of podcasts either but I was listening to one and I realized it's a normal thing for podcasts to do like
Introductions and have like a song and do like this small talk and talk about people's week and I realize man
That is not at all how we do our podcasts. So if you if you're like used to normal podcasts and you're spacing like a bit of a
You know, here's what we've been doing our lives and everything then I understand this is probably not the normal podcast
You but I'll try to give you a little bit of it. So Chris, how are you doing this week?
I'm doing very well. Thanks Jake because I have any more details to add but I'm doing very well
There we go. That's that box ticked. Okay. Let's let's jump into it
I have a plan to talk you guys over now. The plan itself is interesting. I actually think the context of the plan is the most
Interesting bit now Chris you don't know this so this is the information for you
But this plan it does come from it comes to some of you most people will not be aware of because you know actually one
Missed America miss universe, but this was Floyd page. You can look up Floyd page
He competed in the 40s and 50s early 50s and he did have an amazing physique. He did place
I forget what he placed, but he did perform quite well in Missed America competitions, but you know a very well developed bodybuilder of that time and this plan that I'm going to talk through of his
This is quite to this his favorite routine. Now this actually came from a magazine published in 1952 is
Weed up magazine your physique magazine and what was interesting in this magazine is they actually
As much as you know, we can believe it because obviously we did this love a little bit of marketing
They actually listed out several bodybuilders who placed in that recent Missed America competition and they listed out their routines
And they kind of looked at or briefly outlined some of the similarities and it's interesting just as a
Audience member agreed to actually look at those and compare. Well, what are these people doing? That's similar
What are they doing? That's different and so they have people like Ridge Park and Steve Reaves
And we've actually talked about the Steve Reaves plan on this podcast
In fact, that's really interesting part as well because one of the things that Weed up was massive on was sets
So weed up was really kind of
Competing with Bob Hoffman who Bob Hoffman would kind of say he did the set system
But he kind of did it by different exercises for the same muscle and
Wasn't as like sometimes you would do multiple set but it wasn't like a big feature of his style of training
And so what Weed is doing in this magazine is saying look all these people are using sets
They're all big on sets this thing works and what's so fascinating about that is we've gone over the Steve Reaves plan
And Steve didn't do sets in fact in this magazine this literal magazine
He didn't do sets he did a single set, but he just did multiple
Exercising and so it's interesting that that kind of idea sets is somewhat synonymous actually with just doing more
Exercises for the same muscle so I think that's an interesting piece of like historical context where it's like set doesn't always mean
Multiple sets of the same exercise in that context. It could actually mean different exercises same muscle anyway
Bit of a tangent so this particular plan flow page
It was again full body one more quick tangent all of the plans that they outlined were either full body or and this is quite interesting
They did there was one or two that were
splits and one was almost a bro split
But he did it and I'm probably talking about this at some point, but he actually trained morning and evening on consecutive days
And so he managed to do his bro split over two days
And so he's actually still training with a frequency where each muscle was trained to be 72 hours or 48 hours or whatever it was
So it's interesting that even when they were using splits they realize how actually frequency still matters
But that's a topic for another day. So a flow page full body
Three tires per week as was a standard and he suggests that starting with two sets of
8 to 10 repetitions for each of these exercises
Now you did say after your custom tour and you've been doing it for a while you can add a set and he said if you want
You can add more sets, but he said never go above five sets that in and of itself is actually fairly interesting as well
Because that's something you do regularly see where people will say look start with two or three sets
If you want to add you can it never do more than five
I've heard many bodybuilders in the silver RS. They never do more than five
So there's obviously something that they were finding out there that they thought this was a ceiling for people
So we start with a white grip bench and we move into an incline dumbbell fly into a bent arm pullover
Using a barbell into dips. So parallel bar dips into incline dumbbell curls
Which were popular exercise at this time into a seated dumbbell triceps extension
So single arm triceps extension overhead into a dumbbell concentration curl single arm. I bent over barbell grow now
We almost have a lap pull down. I thought you'd be happy to see this
But it's not really it's not a frontal plane lap pulldown
It is a narrow grip and it's actually like a high to low
So the pulleys is starting in the top position and you're pulling it down into the waist height as well
More like a diagonal lap pull down and then we've got a single arm dumbbell overhead press which again was a philly popular
Exercise at the time a barbell behind the neck
overhead press and then toe press on a leg crest contraption and either a squat or a leg crest
You said you could choose either one. So we've got how many exercises that I think it's 12 exercises
So that that was also a commonality we saw people usually using eight to 12 sometimes up to 20 plus like Steve
But that's a very obviously common kind of pattern as well
So Chris thought well in some ways it as you say fits
Relatively well with the examples that we've seen previously three times a week
They're using moderate loads eight ten reps per set, and it's a four body routine
So you know fits relatively well with a lot of other examples that we've already seen obviously
Yes, I'm very happy to see I mean sagittal plane sort of high low row is kind of the same thing really as a
Sagittal plane row or sagittal plane pulled out really I mean they're all kind of doing the same thing as far as the lats concerned
There's no real difference as there
pair that with your sort of barbell bent over row and yeah
You do have you do have kind of two thirds of what you would want for kind of fallback development
I mean you're just missing frontal plane there and I mean I know that people are yet again sort of questioning this
You know idea that you need different exercises to train different parts of the lats just today
We were talking somebody was making the case that you know EMG data
They believed shows that the entire lat is activated in any pulling exercise
Well, that's not the EMG data. I'm looking at you know
I'm looking at EMG data two separate studies that show very profound
Regional differences in lat activation that track perfectly with the moment times
So I find it weird when people literally say there isn't data. I'm like well, what am I looking at then?
You know are we living on the same planet?
You know so anyway
Got some good exercise selection there for back. I wouldn't say it's perfect
But it's definitely better than some of the others that we've seen interestingly what we have got here is a little bit of doubling up on the overhead pressing
So this is something that goes all the way back to the sundale type era routine that we started with or a little bit later than sundale
But that kind of emphasis on overhead pressing is
Starting to creep back a little bit here, but perhaps just because of personal preferences or targeting muscles that you felt were important to him
In fact in this magazine this exact magazine
I believe is just wanting to a Steve actually comments on on that shift away from sundale as physique
See if you guys and discusses how at this point what is perceived as
Disarriable and bodybuilding has now shifted away from sundale as physique and he actually names that which is an interesting progression
And you know, there's there's that tendency that you've pointed out a couple of times which is to select a number of exercises for the same kind of body area
A body part and get that variety like we've got the wide grip bench. We've got a dumbbell fly
Now I wouldn't have picked those two to contrast each other
I think they're doing almost the same thing really and then you've got the bent arm pullover which is probably a pretty good lower test exercise
Done a narrow grip bench, then that would be perfect. So that that trio of exercises for training packs
Narrow grip bench would do clavicular really really well a lot of people think that it's the incline that makes the
Clavicular pec kind of targeted by bench pressing. It's not it's the narrow grip that you want you want a sagittal playing grip
That does much much more for
Visually not isolating because the notice is thing but for targeting the clavicular peg you want that sort of narrow grip
But yeah, that that trio is getting towards being a really nice trio for the arena fly in that incline position versus doing the fly flat
What difference are we seeing there?
Honestly, I think you might see a little bit of a shift towards clavicular not very much
Honestly, I think that the transverse versus sagittal plane is the thing that really matters
So if people are doing a transverse plane kind of exercise like a wide grip bench or a wide grip fly
That is really going to primarily and I say primarily very minimally. It's going to be a little bit more emphasis on the middle
Peck the sternal peck and it's going to do a reasonable job of activating quite a lot of the and
Costal and to target the clavicular much more you would want a sagittal plane movement really
Yeah, look a bit of an incline is not going to hurt but the major difference is going to be that that's a plane of motion
And honestly plane of motion really is one of the biggest factors
That's where we see the differences in the labs for example with plane of motion
Obviously, we've got you know a couple of exercises for triceps we've got I think we do have two
Yeah, we've got two different biceps curves
exercises and we've got the variety of lat exercises. As regards the overhead pressing,
it doesn't look particularly varied to me unless there was a slightly different form.
Well, the single arm often they do that single arm a little bit more sagittal.
No, okay. Well, that would be interesting then, so that would give you a bit more anterior
dealt probably. And then obviously, you know, standard kind of calf training, again, focusing on the
you know, the gastro, and then obviously, you know, squat. So again, if I were to look at it and go
what's missing, I would probably say the same thing that I've been saying throughout the
entirety of this series of podcasts that we've done, which is I'm not seeing very much hamstrings
work, which they could have done with a stiff leg. I'm not seeing that that wide grip pull down,
which I would expect to see as well. Anything else would be a limitation of the time and the equipment,
you know, not obviously seeing a rect fem exercise. I'm not seeing, you know, sort of stuff that
will be more suited to that kind of sort of multi joint, sorry, two joint muscle in sort of single
joint exercises, but that's an equipment issue. Yeah, we know we're using iron boots to try to do
leg extensions. They didn't have machines. Definitely a limitation for sure. It is interesting. But that
really underscores just how similar a lot of these programs were. If we're finding the same
issues in many of them, it kind of just underscores how. Yeah, it does. It does. What I do find
interesting, and I'm trying to work out why this is is half of them do use a stiff leg delift.
Half of them do. You kind of wonder whether people are dropping them out because of some kind of
concern about the exercise or maybe they just don't like it or who knows, but it might be that
there's another reason for it dropping out. And one thing that is came to me actually with that is
you probably seen some of the first straps that people were using. I think Hepburn was one of
the first people behind using those. And they wouldn't have been common at this time. I have heard
a lot of these bodybuilders talk about training grip so that you could do these other exercises.
So maybe that's the limitation where people were just finding that doing something like a stiff
delift was just too much low to actually hold. And maybe that was limitation.
Interesting idea. I mean, that would that would require as really I think to eliminate
a number of possibilities that I'm not historically capable of, as in I just don't know the
history well enough to be able to even comment on it. But you know, alternating grip is not
difficult to use and pretty much eliminates almost all grip issues unless you are literally
absurdly strong. And yeah, I mean, there's there's issues there. I'd be like, I'm not I'm not
educated enough on the history to know what those what limitations are. Yeah. But you know,
I mean, clearly, you're right that there's we do see those stiff delift appearing occasionally,
but they're not routine. And the question is then, is there a reason why they're getting dropped
out? Is it because people is it that they were doing them and they just didn't write them in
because of some reason because they didn't want. I don't know. I mean, I'll be
actually just there's so many possibilities because that's another one you see sometimes people
like he's a plan. And then of course, they do deadly something now. And then it's like, okay,
well, why don't you put it in there? Yeah, interesting. And then there's also the question of like,
I just mentioned Steve Ray's talked about how the the physique, the the desirable physique
had moved beyond what's and now had. And what he emphasizes is chest. And so maybe there's
part of it, which is like, well, we don't really care about hamps because we usually undervalued as
well. So maybe it was this upper body heavy. And that's what people are looking for.
So let's move on. What are we talking about today? So we're going to talk a little bit about
training frequency. So somewhat hot topic at the moment. And we'll probably, I mean, we were
just chatting about how we might structure this discussion and how it might fit into future
podcasts. I think we'll probably end up doing a couple of podcasts on frequency, how they'll
get structured. And I don't think we've we've fully figured out. But what we're going to do today
is give a little bit of background to what physiologically we think is happening with training
frequency, just so that anybody who is new to this topic can at least set it in context of how
it works. And then talk a little bit about the long term training studies because there has been
a trend for a couple of fitness influences to start making the point that or start arguing the
case, I should say, not making the point, to start arguing the case that the long term training
day to say something different from what the physiologically would predict. And I just want to kind
of reject that and point out that that's not really what the long term training day to say at all.
So let me start at the very beginning by just giving a little bit of context and saying what we
think we should find when we approach the concept of training frequency. So training frequency
in the context of bodybuilding refers to how often you're training a muscle per week. So this is
really important just to start out because if you've come to this discussion from say SNC or more
sort of the wider parts of the fitness industry, you might think that training frequency means
how many times a week you go to the gym. And that's not what we're talking about. So sometimes this
can catch people out when they first come into the space and start having conversations, they're like,
what does this mean? How many times I'm going to the gym? No, no, no, no, it actually means
how many times a week training a muscle. So starting from that point of view. So basically we're
thinking about training frequency. And what's going to happen is you're going to train a muscle
and it's going to experience a stimulus. And that stimulus is going to take a period of time
to be processed. And then after that period of time is finished, the sort of the muscle will then
be in an unstimulated state again. So you'll have like a what we call a stimulus period. And then
when that finishes, you're going to a state of not being stimulated. Now physiology tells us that
muscle fibers are always either growing or shrinking. You can't have a state where the muscle
fiber just sits there doing nothing. That doesn't exist. So essentially the muscle fibers are either
growing or shrinking. And they're kind of either what we would say are the anabolic or catabolic.
And so essentially over the course of the week, you're going to have period of time in which the
muscles are all the muscle fibers in the muscle are growing and then period of time in which they're
shrinking. And so what we can say is that your training program will produce hopefully net high
purge free of the week. So we use the word net to indicate that you've had some high purge free
in some parts of the week and some atrophy in other parts of the week. Now perhaps in a later
podcast, we can tackle the actual rates of atrophy into right now. I'm not going to go into too much
detail right now. But we do know that you do have a period of high purge free and the period of
atrophy. Because if you look at maintenance studies, now there's no such thing as a maintenance
stimulus that does exist. Because as I say, fibers are either growing or shrinking. So what you have
is a maintenance workout will essentially give you enough high purge free to equal out the atrophy
later in the week and you'll end up with net zero across the week. So high purge free equals
atrophy and you end up with maintenance. So you can have, it's got some really nice studies,
six month long studies showing that, you know, kind of one workout of three or four sets each week
is like giving you a high purge free stimulus and nets to zero at the end of the week because the
atrophy equals the high purge free. So just in case anyone's questioning this at this point,
if someone is someone's not in the gym, they've never gone to the gym. We're not saying they're going
to be atrophying just normally, right? Like, well, I mean, technically there will be. But what we're
saying is they're maintaining the amount of muscle mass they have because they are still in fact
getting a stimulus. They're just not getting that stimulus in the gym. They're getting
a stimulus from the daily activity and they're stimulus are they getting from the daily activities
enough to grow the muscle to the point that they currently have. And that is how they are maintaining
encroits the amount of muscle mass they currently have. Exactly, which is why if somebody breaks
an arm or a leg and they have the arm or leg put in a cast and it doesn't move,
then what happens when you take the cast off say five six seven weeks later or however long it takes,
then the limb has shrunk down. Now you don't need to do anything to get the muscle to grow back to how it
was. You just go back into your normal way of life and it magically goes back to how it was because
you're loading it in everyday life. And this actually just a very, very brief physiological interlude.
But this actually shows you why hypertrophy is muscle fiber specific because ultimately if you move
sort of across the room, you go to collect something you come back, you fetch a book,
you walk into another room, you walk up some stairs, you walk down some stairs. While you're doing
those slow movements, the muscle fibers that are being used in those situations are being loaded
very, very highly because the force velocity relationship allows you to produce very high forces in
those fibers. So that's your growth stimulus. People where how can I get a growth stimulus from
walking across the room? Well, it's like, well, if you're not understanding that, you don't
actually understand anything about hypertrophy because the stimulus hypertrophy is on a fiber level
and the force velocity relationship, the movement, slow movement that you're doing allows the high
loading that then causes those fibers to grow. So whatever fibers you use on a daily basis, unless you
literally sort of almost teleport across the room every time you move, unless you move really fast
speed to all the time, you're guaranteed to get a slow speed movement somewhere. And as a result,
you're going to get hypertrophy happening in the fibers that you're activating. And that's why
we end up with this low level of, this level of muscle mass, which is just like what we have from
moving around. And why some people who have a little bit more physically active life or maybe they
do manual labor or whatever they are doing in their life that just has a little bit more level of
kind of force requiring a force producing requirements, they're a little bit more muscular.
Just because of you, it's aware like you're waiting for this. Or if you were to wear a weight
to the vest and you were to walk up and down stairs and you'd find that you started to increase
muscle mass as a result of doing that. And people will go, how is that possible? You know, I'm not
producing high levels of effort. You said that hypertrophy occurs with high levels of effort.
And I'm like, yeah, well, maximum hypertrophy is going to happen with maximum levels of effort
because you're hitting as many muscle fibers as you've got access to. But that doesn't mean that
you're not going to get high hypertrophy at lower levels of effort. It's just you're reducing
the number of fibers that you're exposing to that. So basically then, or
What we've got is this net hypertrophy concept where we've got hypertrophy happening in
being processed in the stimulus period and then you're losing a little bit of muscle
mass towards the back end of the week when you're not doing that workout if that's how
your frequency is working.
And of course you end up with the net hypertrophy at the end of the week.
So first important concept to understand from a physiological wide-divine, whatever you're
thinking about frequency is that you've got these periods of time in which the muscle
is growing and you've got periods of time which the muscle is not growing, it's actually
shrinking very slightly.
And if you have a low enough frequency like once per week then you can have this situation
where you'll get the end of the week and actually netting out so it's that your three sets
on Monday as we've said or four sets on Monday is used up by the end of the week and you
end up with a net zero situation.
Now of course one of the things that then becomes very contentious is how long is that stimulus
period.
Now we have done a podcast on that very concept and I think it was one of our very first
podcasts and we'll probably have to do another one on it again because it continues to be
a contentious concept but I'm not going to go into that now because I'm just presenting
the conceptual basis for understanding training frequency.
The next thing you need to be aware of is this idea that hypertrophy is dose responsive
to volume.
In other words that's a fancy way of saying that you do more volume, you get more hypertrophy.
But the important thing about that dose response is it's non-linear, it actually has diminishing
returns.
Each extra set you do in a workout has a slightly or quite a lot less impact on the hypertrophy
that you get from the workout.
So most hypertrophy really is going from the first set and incrementally a lot less sequential
sets.
It probably does plateau somewhere and again we can really dive into that data at another
time and start talking about exactly where we think that plateau might happen, I would
actually probably find that quite interesting because it hasn't been something I've looked
at for probably about a year or so.
So what we say then is the second idea is that the hypertrophy that you get from a workout
is dose responsive in a non-linear way and that now means that you cannot say that you allocate
your sets anyway you like across the week and get the same amount of hypertrophies.
For example, you can't do three sets on Monday and say that that equals one set on Monday
Wednesday and Friday and just let me reiterate, this has got nothing, this is a separate concept
to the hypertrophy concept, totally separate, yeah?
So what we're talking about here is a completely separate idea that means that a higher frequency
is going to be different from a lower frequency, not just because we've got the hypertrophy,
hypertrophy issues going on but because we're getting a different amount of stimulus from
each set in a workout if it's positioned in a different place.
So if I position my set first, I do three first sets a week, I'm going to get totally
different magnitude of stimulus from if I do all three sets on a Monday.
So unless, so what you're saying is unless you were doing a second set in a workout or
for an exercise, unless that second set produced as much muscle as a first set, then obviously
frequency is going to matter, like splitting screening that volume of hypertrophy of the
day is going to matter, unless it's exactly the same amount of muscle growth on that second
set, then the first set and we have ample diet to suggest actually that's not how that
works and there's very clear diminishing returns.
Yeah, so we've got two reason metronauties.
We've got the Brad Schermfeltz metronauties from quite a few years ago now and we've got
the recent one by Pelland and both of those metronauties clearly show a non-linear dose response
and nice curve.
Now they have different shaped curves and we can again, when we talk about dose response
again in the future, we can dive into that and explain why we think that difference might
exist.
The point is though that both are non-linear and if you have a non-linear curve, you are
saying that your second set is smallest to me as in your first set, your third is small
in your second and so on and so on and so on.
Now again, you can argue the magnitude of that effect and that's totally fine but no
matter what the magnitude doesn't matter the magnitude, if that non-linear relationship
exists, which it does and actually physiologically you predicted would because you've got fatigue
occurring from set to set which reduces the level of accruement, reduces the level of
mechanical tension and you've probably also got what we call a saturation of stimulus.
So you get a really big stimulus from the first because you've got nothing going on at
the time and then you try and stimulate a bit more and it's like well, how much more
can you really stimulate when you've already applied a large stimulus?
So you don't get as much stimulus for the second time, simply from a stimulus point of
view and the capacity to produce that stimulus in addition to the fatigue that's having.
So physiologically this non-linear dose response makes perfect sense and it's exactly what
we would expect.
So you've got these two really important concepts, you've got the hypertrophy and atrophy
effects going on and you've got this non-linear dose response and if you have been following
along you should notice that both of these are telling you that higher frequency is going
to beat the socks off lower frequency.
You just can't get away from that.
The question really only is, you know, what's the upper limit on frequency?
Can I train every five minutes?
I mean it's like, you know, reduce it to the observed level.
No, obviously we can't, but you know, that conversation is something that requires a lot
of digging into the data to understand what's in my big.
Broadly speaking, if we can get the fatigue out of the way, because we mentioned before fatigue
is a big problem for triggering a stimulus, if we can get the fatigue out of the way then,
you know, we're probably in a good place to be able to stimulate hypertrophy again.
So that's really where the limitations come in.
Now again, we can go into what, you know, the role of my ops being elevated from a previous
workout, plays, what role that plays, we can talk about that again in more detail, but
just I'm hoping to give people a framework that they can start from physiologically and
we can use that to talk about training for you.
Does that make sense?
Yeah.
I think it's fully clear.
So if one we're budgeting to go on a holiday, you've got two options.
You can either look at how much money's coming in, you can work more hours, you can get
a second job, or you can look at how much money's going in.
You can start eating out less, cutting it back on expenses.
That's the same way that muscle crew is working.
We can look at how much muscle we're actually building, stimulating the growth of, and then
we can look at how much muscle we're losing atrophying over the period of time.
And the net growth is ultimately a combination of those two factors, and you're saying both
of those, ultimately the answer to both of those is high frequency.
We just need to work out how high that frequency can be.
Yeah.
Where we've got these two concepts, we've got the hypertrophy side of things.
How much are we losing by not being in this stimulus period?
And we've got this dose response effect, which is telling us that if we position the sets
at different times in a week, we'll get a better response than doing it all together.
Actually, it kind of like, you know, when the social media marketers tell you and they
say, look, you need to space your posts out across the week so you get a better response
because every time you do a separate post on a different day, you get a good response.
If you try to do all three posts a week that you're going to post and you do them all
in five minutes on a Monday, you're not going to get the same benefit.
It's kind of like, that's the kind of idea that we're talking about with those responses.
Like, the algorithms don't favor you if you post everything at the same time.
So we've got these two ideas we've got that physiology is telling us we should be aware
of, and they're pushing us towards this idea that higher frequency is better.
Now, obviously, I've kind of created a weekly net stimulus model, which takes these concepts
into account, and it allows you to vary them according to what you think the numbers
might be, and I give guidelines for what I think they probably are, but you can use that
calculator to figure out what training frequencies are like when you compare them and see which
training frequencies are slightly better.
And the data that I've seen when playing with this model based on this physiological
concept, these physiological concepts, shows that broadly speaking, three times is better
than two times, two times is better than one times a week.
Broadly speaking, if you're using the same number of sets for a muscle per week, three
is going to be better than two, two is going to be better than one, and that's the concept
that I've been arguing with the weekly net stimulus model, with the ideas that we've just
walked through as a basis.
Now, as I say, we can dive in and talk about those in much more detail later on, but just
fundamentally, that's where we're at.
So that brings us then to this kind of topic that I wanted to sort of discuss today, which
is that some fitness influences have started arguing back and saying, we don't think your
physiologically aligned model is valid because we think that the long-term training studies
that have been done on training frequency don't agree with that model.
And I'm like, okay, well, let's look at the training studies that we've got and see
whether that's true.
So depending on when you're listening to this podcast, if you're listening to this podcast
shortly after it was first published, then you'll be able to look at my Instagram and
see I listed these studies straight away because it's the last post I did, I posted it
earlier today.
And what I did was I started with the meta analysis or actually it's a network analysis
because they used a slightly different type of statistical analysis than I'm accustomed
to seeing.
It's called a network analysis, it doesn't really matter.
And I started with that list of studies that this research group used for their study
because that meta analysis is the one that people are attending to refer to when they're
talking about these frequency studies.
Essentially, I went to that meta analysis is called Currier 2023 and I went to that study
and I downloaded the list of studies that they incorporated in that meta analysis and
I went and I looked for all the frequency studies.
Now I'm just going to make a very quick comment on what that meta analysis did just so that
people understand what's going on.
So the meta analysis had, I think about 120, 119 separate hypertrophy studies in it.
Now only about 16 of those were actually frequency studies.
So you've got 119 hypertrophy studies, we sound like a really big number.
So when people say, oh, you know,
look at this meta-analysis, it had 119 hypertrophy studies in and they found this answer about
training frequency. Therefore, we should, you know, accept that as an answer or a source of
data. As I say, only 16 were comparisons between different training frequencies. The vast majority,
like 87 or so percent of the studies incorporated in that network analysis, were actually studies
that didn't measure differences in training frequency. Maybe they measured differences in,
you know, repetition range or volume or whatever else, or maybe they just had one training group.
I mean, a lot of the studies, when I was going through the list, a lot of them just had one
training group and one control. So, what I did was I grabbed the 16 studies that just measured
the difference in training frequency and I went through them and I excluded stuff that was DEXA
or, you know, kind of not sort of a direct measurement of hypertrophy. I just want MRI ultrasound
that kind of stuff, CT. And that got me down to 9 and I looked at it and I thought, that's a bit
strange because, was it 9 or is it 8? I can't remember. I looked at that, it's a bit strange because
I thought there was a shown felt frequency study that compared one and three times a week and there
is. I mean, and it wasn't on that list. And I don't know why. I mean, I didn't look at the
exclusion criteria to figure out why. So, it just wasn't there. And I also noticed that there was
another one that was missing, which is probably the date because the Nevis paper on frequency was
published in 22. And if this study got finally published in 23, there's probably just an overlap
in terms of dates. So, I don't know why the shown felt admitted, but I can understand why they never
got admitted because the dates didn't probably allow them to have access to that paper at the point
when they submitted it to peer review. So, that ended up with, as I say, around about 10 or 11 studies
and I kind of just put them in a table and that gave me comparisons between one and two and two
and three and one and three. And I excluded this stuff that was comparing like one and five and,
you know, two and five and stuff because, you know, really most people want to know the answer
between, you know, what do we know about the famous three frequencies for training and muscle,
which is one, two and three. And no, there's no date for every other day. We just don't have
that kind of data in the literature. So, I kind of ended up with only about 10 studies that
are direct high-perture measurements. Now, that was my process for getting that list. I did not
do an exhaustive literature review of the entire PubMed system to see if I'd missed anything.
I did double check from my notes in the past and I couldn't see anything that I'd missed, but
if you're listening to this podcast and you've seen the post on Instagram and you've gone,
"Oh, well, why didn't you include xstudy please send it to me? I would love to add it in." That
was my process so that you understand that I went through a process that was largely independent
of my own biases. I started from the metronasis that I had been shown the kind of results of
and that was being used to argue that training frequency studies didn't agree with the physiologically
model. So, I started with my opponent's arguments, data source, if you like. Yeah, absolutely. So, I ended up with these studies and basically what I found was about, I think,
more or less three or four studies for each comparison, one and two, two and three and one and three.
And essentially, there was no difference. There's no significant differences using the statistical term.
There are no significant differences between one and two or between two and three. For any of the
studies included in the group that we've just gathered up. So, that kind of starting point
tells you that, you know, maybe frequency doesn't matter, which is actually the view of a big chunk
of the hypertrophy research community who basically say that if you apportion your volume
across the week, in any way you like, you'll get the same result as long as you're doing the same
number of sets to failure. And there are people who still say that. There are people who still say
that. As illogically, it's impossible for the two reasons that we start with when we explained
the beginnings of this composition. Like, you can't have a volume dose response, there's non-linear
and you can't have maintenance studies showing net hypertrophy and sorry that hypertrophy is zero
because you have hypertrophy and that frequency. You can't have those two observations existing
and also say that as long as volume is equated frequency doesn't matter. So clearly, there's a problem
here. And the likelihood is that we're just not capable of detecting the significance with the
current power, you know, powers that we're using and the current study designs that we're using.
So, frequency probably does matter. It's just that we're not seeing it. And that brings us to the
third category, which is that if you look at one compare one and three, every single study shows you
either a significant benefit of three versus one or a non-significant benefit of three versus one.
So, after the three studies, two of them were significant, they better with three times versus one
time and the third was non-significant benefit. So, that is really, really interesting because
what it tells you is that if you've got one and three being different from each other, that tells you
that the fact that two and one weren't different from each other and that two and three were
different from each other, this is just a statistics issue. This is just a significance problem.
It's the fact that because we get this with some volume studies, like I say to people,
if you look at a lot of volume studies, what you'll find is that they may be compared one set,
two sets and three sets or one set, two sets, three sets and five sets or something like that.
And you get the same issue. You get something like one set and three sets are different,
but two sets not different from three sets and two sets not different from one set. It's like,
how can that be? And it's just the way stats works. If you don't have a big enough difference,
it won't pick it up. And that's what we're probably seeing with frequency. You've got one and three
are clearly different, but two isn't different from either one or three. Well, that's just telling you
you've got a you've got a sliding scale, isn't it? It's just telling you that two is worse than three,
probably, and two is better than one, probably. And the only real difference is you picking up
because of the statistical capacities are one and three being different. But this then comes like
what is your process for making decisions about how strength training works?
You know, because and this is the point I've been arguing, like if people are taking this kind of
maximum of this point of view where they go, I only look at long-term training studies. Now interestingly,
this is like an evidence-based idea where you can only use long-term training studies as evidence
and this parts of that community, you think that. And it's like, well, if you're going to do that,
then the only thing you can possibly say is that three sets is better than one set. You can't say
anything about two sets at all, really. The only thing you can say is that three is better than one.
And so really, if you've got like a logical brain, you'll go, well, I'll just do three times a
wee then because I can't say anything about two. People are like, oh, well, no, no, you can,
because you can say that two is not as, you can say that two is the same as three and not really,
because you can also say that one is the same as two. And that really cancels out the benefits of
saying that two is the same as three. So you kind of, you kind of can clearly see that three is
better than two, really. So I think if you like, I've got this set of data and you look at it,
you can say that long-term training studies are not inconsistent with the physiological model
that we started with, which is that a higher frequency three is going to be better than two,
which is going to be better than one. That's not inconsistent with what these frequency trials
are saying. Now, do the frequency trials long-term training studies support the physiological model,
you know, unequivocally? No, they don't. They're messy, they're vague, they're in their gray zone.
But they don't contradict it. And that's the argument that I'm kind of being hit
with at the moment, which is that people say long-term training studies contradict what you're
saying. Now, why do they say that? They say that because the career meta-analysis, which was done
on 119 studies, had a effect size for all of their studies that showed that hypertrophy at two times
was better than hypertrophy at three times. But that's not what we're doing here, because we're not
looking at those studies, those 119 teams. We're looking at only frequency studies. So a couple of
questions people or critiques or criticisms, one of the pushback that people might have. So one is,
you briefly mentioned the difference between direct and indirect measurements. Can you unpack that
a little bit more? Yeah. So a direct measurement of hypertrophy is one that measures one specific muscle
using a scanning or an imaging technique. So if you're using ultrasound, which is very common,
the cheapest and easiest and most accessible form of measuring hypertrophy, that's totally fine.
If you've got access to MRI or CT or whatever like that, you can use that. Now, if you're using
something like DEXA to measure lean body mass, then that's an indirect measurement. And generally
speaking, hypertrophy research is kind of just drop indirect measurement studies when they're doing
large-scale meta-analytical review type things, because indirect is messy.
It's vague, it's imprecise, it's really not helpful. Again, it's much more of a public health type
measurement than what we're interested in, which is this particular muscle growing. So I just
excluded the indirect stuff. Now, if somebody wants to do another analysis and show what happens when
you put the indirect in, I don't think it will change anything, particularly, but I'm just not
interested in that data source. I don't think it tells you anything. And then another point you made
is you differentiate between what was statistically significant and what was insignificant statistically,
but was trending towards that way. And then obviously we've got another earlier meta-analysis
on frequency, the shown filed one. And it could take people to make his three times per week
was trending towards beta-beta, but it wasn't statistically significant. For people who are unaware
of that language, can you unpack that? Yeah, so essentially what statistical tests are trying to do
in layman's terms. So if any stats savvy people are listening to this and they don't like my
vernacular, they can, they can have a go themselves.
explaining it to lay people more than willing to listen to that, but basically what statistical
test is trying to do is not tell you how big an effect is really. It's not trying to tell you
that something is massively different in size from something else. It's trying to tell you that
the difference that you're observing is not being caused by randomness. It's not being caused
by chance. So you're trying to establish a probability, a good probability, that what you're looking at
is a genuine difference caused by a genuine effect rather than just by life being random at you.
So essentially, historically in sports science, we've followed a very kind of, not rigorous,
as the wrong word, very rigid, almost, model of using stats in a certain way. The Bayesian stuff
that we talked about today, the network analysis is totally different from that. It's new people
are starting to use Bayesian probabilities. I don't like the Bayesian stuff because I don't agree
with most of the research priors that are used. So Bayesian analysis kind of requires you to stop
from having a prior and my prior is completely different from everybody else's unless they follow
me. And so we would pretty much start with different starting points. But the statistical analysis
that most people use excise science and all of these studies that we've listed that or I've listed
out on my on my table that we've talked about today, all of those use the same statistical analysis
methods. And essentially they're just looking for what we call p-values. So people are kind of
going, you know, does my p-value get to less than 0.05 or 0.01 or whatever threshold
of their science significance? And then basically, you know, as I say in layman's terms,
getting below that threshold means that your effect is not random or judged to be not random.
That's what it is. So essentially, if you have a numerical difference, which is large,
but it doesn't what we say reach this threshold for statistical significance,
then what we're saying is that even though the number is large, it could actually be due to chance.
If the number is really large, then you kind of look at it and you go, well, does that mean you'll
study was underpowered to be able to detect that difference and that's a possibility. And you can
kind of do a bit of fiddling around and see from the numbers that the study provides you with whether
you think that's the case. But the reason that I mention the numerical difference in this third
study is because it's the third of three of which the other two showed that effect. So if you think
about it, if you've got three studies and two of them show statistically significant benefits
of three times and your third has a number trending in the same direction or the numerically is
the same thing, then that you've kind of got a bit more comfort because you've seen two studies
that have reached significance. Your third one is trending in the same direction. You're like, well,
let's mention that because I've already got the comfort of the other two pointing, you know, in
the same direction. If the numerical difference had been the other way around, I wouldn't have said
anything. Now people go, oh, I'm going to jump all over that now because Chris is saying that
he's biased. No, I'm saying the time using Bayesian reasoning because I've actually started
and noticed that my priors are being created by the two significant results and therefore my third,
I'm expecting it to go in the same direction. When it does, I'm then happy about that.
Fine. Great. You know, so it's kind of like the only reason I've mentioned that number is because
of the other two pointing in the same direction. So it gives us kind of a three for three really.
And interestingly, in that third study, which had a numerical difference, the strength differences
were huge and much better for three than for one. So not only did it have, and I actually got a
bunch of other studies that show that three is better than one for strength, but that's by the
bite. So you've kind of got this situation where we can see the strength is supporting the
hypertrophy numbers. Of course, you know, perhaps this is a subject for another time,
but we can't talk about why strength gains are a really good reflection of hypertrophy in most
cases. Just came out another study showing that a really nice paper done in the UK actually
showing that strength on hypertrophy are very closely correlated over time. Strength gains,
sorry, and hypertrophy relatively closely correlated over time. So the fact that strength gains
were also better in three than one in that particular study, I think gives me comfort in the numbers
probably being meaningful, just not statistically significant. And again, I'm trying to explain this
in Lama's terms, my vernacular first statistical analysis probably is not correct, but yeah,
you can yell at me on social media if you want to do that. So let me just rewind very, very briefly.
One of the rules, not rules, but one of the guidelines of meta-analyses is that if your meta-analysis
gives you an answer that is not supported by any single study in your meta-analysis, then stop.
So if you're doing a meta-analysis of some particular thing and you've got the answer and the
meta-analysis tells you that the answer is clearly that x is better than i, but every single study
you've got doesn't show that x is better than y, then you need to stop and you need to figure out
why that is. So some people have, and that's kind of like it used to generally accept a principle
of doing a sense checking your meta-analysis. If you do a meta-analysis and you look at your
underlying data and none of your data shows that 2 is better than 1, and your meta says that
2 is better than 1, you need to stop and you need to go and try and figure out why your meta is
giving you nonsense answers. Now, so essentially you can literally just eyeball your studies and go
what are the studies telling me, and if you've got, like we've got pretty much a clear pattern of
3 being better than 1 and nothing else happening, then your meta should tell you that 3 is better than
1 and nothing really else is happening. That's what it should tell you, more or less. And if that's
not what it's telling you, then you've got a problem with your meta in answering that particular
question. Again, I'm repeating myself, but I don't think the career was really trying to do that.
I think that the fitness influencers who are using the career to, and I really hope that nobody
in the career paper team get this podcast and they think I'm insulting them or upset, you know,
being rude about what they've done. I think that fitness influencers are using that paper incorrectly.
They are jumping on a numerical value that has been calculated, and they're comparing two numerical
values, one for three times, one for two times, and they are claiming that they've meaningful.
And I don't think it is. I think that the way the analysis was done doesn't allow you to draw
that conclusion, because they're including studies that are not really comparable, or at least the
frequency elements of them are not good. So where does that leave that? So someone's asking a question
of, well, is one time a two times or three times every other day? What's best? What should I do if
I want to maximize growth? How can one actually look at that question and answer that with any
confidence? Because ultimately, it sounds like we don't have enough actual outcome data there to
rely on. Exactly, which is why we don't just use outcome data. We use a combination of physiology,
outcome data, and actually we can look back at bodybuilders of pre-1950s and see that they train
the same way as the physiology would predict, and broadly speaking, the outcome data predict.
They've long-term training studies. What we've got is a long-term training data set of studies,
which tells us that three is better than one, and we can infer that maybe that means that two
sits somewhere in the middle between one and three. That would be logical. The physiology tells us
that three is better than two, which is better than one, so that gives the same pattern.
And the bodybuilders of pre-1950 train three times a week most of the time. We've got a full house
here, you know? I mean, nowhere in this group of points is anybody pointing at two saying,
"Well, look, two is clearly better than three." Well, where? No, where? That's an interesting point.
Yeah, it goes. Zero, zero places. There are zero places where two comes up at the top of the
list. It doesn't come up in physiology. It doesn't come up in the bodybuilders pre-1950,
and it doesn't come up in the outcome long-term training data. Yes, there is a effect size in a
metronasis of a bunch of studies that didn't compare training frequency that has a higher value
for two than three. Honestly, stop sending me that chart. If this podcast achieves anything,
please stop sending me the chart of that effect size comparison, because it's not answering the
question you think is answering, because it's not using data that's designed to answer that question.
Yeah. I mean, that's a really important point. Is that often studies get thrown around online,
and there might be an image or a chart or a graph or a table or whatever, and that becomes
very shareable, but people don't realize what it is that that is actually based on, or what the
question was, that analysis was answering, or what the studies that were included were looking at.
It's very easy for something to suddenly become so collated and become gospel, when in fact it was
never intended to even answer the question we think is being asked. Exactly. That chart includes
data from studies that didn't compare training frequency. People are running around with the idea
that because there was a big number of studies incorporated in that chart, it's like 119 studies,
wow, imagine all that data. It's not allowing you to get at the variance that is ascribed to
training frequency. There's too much variance ascribed to other variables like which subjects
trained or entrained elderly. There's a whole ton of elderly people studies in that,
metter and arses, you know. So explaining to you before we jumped on this call, I actually typed
every single study out into an Excel spreadsheet because I wanted to see for myself to understand
the data perfectly. I actually physically wrote every
single study name out on a spreadsheet, and I wrote down whether it was IPertry study,
whether it was a strength study, whether they compared frequency, or whether they didn't.
So I actually did my own legwork and went through every single item on the list.
And that's how I know they missed the shown filter out.
Now maybe I just had a blackout moment, I missed it off the list, in which case I apologize
profusely to them for saying that they missed out, and maybe it missed their exclusion criteria,
maybe it didn't fit their inclusion criteria, maybe not an error, but, you know, that
that's just kind of the process that I went through, and making sure that I'd done the
necessary work to understand all of the frequency data that was being used to calculate that
answer all that job.
I remember when this study was becoming popular, obviously it's two years old, but it kind
of came to surface larger than social media six months ago.
And another claim that was being drawn out of that study, out of that analysis was that
single sets were useless, and I remember going in and looking at the studies, all looking
at the single sets, first multi sets, and going into a specific one and realizing this,
if we look at direct comparison, they'll have the exact same problem.
The exact same problem will exist.
So what you'll have is you'll have a bunch of studies that use single sets, a bunch of
studies that use multiple sets, and you'll have exact the same problem.
Now they might say, oh, well, I don't want to make comments about their team, because I
don't think they're answering questions that were interested in, I don't.
So I don't want to assume that their purpose in the way that they've gone about their analysis
is the same as our purposes, because I don't think it is, and therefore it's inappropriate
for me to criticise their analysis, because it's done for different purposes.
I'm not criticising what they're doing or have done, this is not a criticism.
I'm saying that for our purposes, it doesn't help us with that comparison, because if we
want to be very specific about answering the question of multi sets versus single sets,
we would want to actually separate out the studies that have compared those directly
and then do a metronascist of those studies.
And that's the way that you would exclude variants that is not attributable to your question
of interest, which is either frequency or volume in this case.
So for our listeners, they've listened to this, listened to what you've had to say about
his analysis, and then suddenly 10 minutes later, they're going to see your post online
and someone's going to say, oh, there's no outcome data that shows it three times a week
is better.
And he is a new study that shows it twice a week is better as good or whatever.
What's your advice to, how do you make sense of this space?
How do you make sense when suddenly there's another loud voice, he's yelling the opposite
and saying, no, no, there's no outcome data that shows this, what someone meant to do?
So the only thing you can do is go and look at the source of the information they're quoting
which in this case was the in many cases regarding this conversation was the career metronascist.
So you'd have to go back to that metronascist, you'd have to pull up the paper which is not
difficult to do and you'd have to then look at it and see whether or not what they were
saying about the paper was in fact correct.
Now, if your expertise doesn't extend to doing that, then you're in trouble really.
And honestly, what are you even doing listening to people giving that information if you haven't
got the ability to interrogate it?
Yeah, that is.
This is an issue that I face all the time when people come to me and say, you know, they
send me videos or they send me clips and they say, we've just had a week in which we talked
about neuro-mechanical matching last week on the podcast, we answered a whole bunch of criticisms.
And as a result of that podcast, a whole bunch of talking heads started to pump content
out about neuro-mechanical matching and most of it was negative.
And people sent me a look at that stuff and they said, this person is saying this and
this person is saying that and how do I understand it?
I'm like, well, if you think those are criticisms, then you haven't understood the podcast that
we did on neuro-mechanical matching because almost every single one of those criticisms
involved arguing against a non-existent imaginary form of neuro-mechanical matching that is
not what is describing the literature.
You know, neuro-mechanical matching is about maximizing efficiency.
It tries to maximize the torque output for the minimum amount of energy input.
It's not trying to find prime movers.
It's not trying to maximize joint torque.
It's literally just trying to maximize efficiency.
The only way you can do that is by sending as much activation as you can towards muscles
that have better leverage.
That's it.
Very simple.
But we've got a whole load of talking heads who are trying to argue against something that
doesn't exist and people are believing it because they haven't done the work to understand
what it is in the first place is actually being argued about.
But this is human nature.
People just want to be entertained.
If that's what your purpose is for going on social media and the fitness industry and
you just want to be entertained, then yeah, you are being entertained.
You're not being educated because you're not, because you're not, and people are no,
no, no, no.
I want to see both sides of the argument.
I'm like stating that there are two sides of an argument completely ignores the fact
that each group of people that you're referring to are not talking about the same thing.
You know, you can't, you know, if one group of people is saying, look, this is how neuro-mechanical
matching works.
And we think that it is the best explanation for how the brain allocates center mode to
come out of the next slide.
And the other group of people are saying, here is what we think neuro-mechanical matching
is, which is completely different from what, you know, the other group are saying.
And we think that it's wrong because this imaginary version that we've created doesn't
do what we want it to do.
I'm like, well, if you think there are two sides of an argument, you're delusional.
Yeah, it doesn't help you get to the truth, it does it because it's ultimately, it's
a straw man argument.
They're not even two sides of the argument.
People say, I want to see both sides of the argument.
Along that, well, those two things are not two sides of the same argument.
One group is presenting an artificial, like, picture of something that's nonexistent.
And the other group are trying to explain to you how something works with literature.
If, like, the other group who is criticizing are capable of explaining how the principal
is supposed to work and then pointing out errors in it fine, that's two sides of an argument.
But I mentioned this on my Instagram story.
People say, how do you deal with all these people?
How do you deal with all these detractors?
And I'm like, well, it's not a detractor until they can state my position correctly.
They're arguing against a fictitious version of me that doesn't exist with opinions that
don't exist.
They've made it all up in their own mind because they haven't done the reading to understand
what the actual thing was.
Now, people go, oh, no, no, no, no, you're just arguing, you know, this is a rhetorical
device.
You're spitting hairs.
It's semantics.
No, it's not semantics.
It's literally one model is defined as efficiency maximization.
The other model is defined as talk maximization, they're totally different models, you know.
What they're calling neurocometing is not neurocometing.
It's something that made up as a straw man, maybe inadvertently because they think that
it should work like that and that's not the way it works.
I think we get this problem all the time.
And obviously, I don't really have any actionable advice for people to solve that problem
because you don't, I'm the last person in the world that would be able to help you with
that.
What you need, if you want to actually find somebody who can give you advice of how to
navigate that terrain, you would ask somebody who doesn't already know everything about
that subject.
I know more about this subject than anybody else on the planet.
I mean, that's just a fact of me spending the last kind of 10 to 15 years reading all
day.
You know, I know this list of people who do this for a living, but I'm doing this out
of a obsession, not that of a living.
And I think that I'm therefore, and I'm not saying that therefore, oh, therefore everyone
should listen to me and ignore everyone else.
No, I'm saying that I'm not that for the right person to ask.
Well, ultimately, in a sense, you failed at that, didn't you?
Because you, you, you saw, you went down this path of having to figure it all out yourself
because you weren't satisfied because I wasn't satisfied with the answers I was being
given.
Great.
So I don't know how to solve that problem and I'm the last person in the world that would
be able to answer that for you, because as you point out, I failed at being able to
find a reliable source.
So I went and established the answers myself.
All I can really say that I think is even remotely helpful is find the source that the
person is quoting and get that source in your hand.
That's all I can say that I think is even remotely useful.
You know, if people, because that would have fixed the problem in this particular case,
it would fix the problem in the case of Neuronganic Imagine.
If somebody is confused about the frequency debate and they're confused, why do I, does
the career materenists say this?
Why do you say that?
Get the career analysis in your hand and read it.
And if you fully understand it, then you'll come to the conclusion that I've come to.
When I solve the Neuronganic Imagine question, go and download the publicly available review
paper on Neuronganic Imagine.
See what the people who have come up with the hypothesis and built the model have said
about it.
But you'll understand this about efficiency, it's about maximizing talk for the amount
of energy input.
And so you're straight away see that that's the answer.
So what I would say is if you're trying to navigate this terrain, you have to go back
to the source.
Now, the nice thing about the way that I've presented all my material is that you can
just do that because you can go to the FAQ.
You can find the thing you want to look at and in the FAQ, every single citation will
be there.
So you can look at the citation.
You can go and put it into Google Scholar and you can pull up the paper that you're
interested in learning about.
So I've done it in a way that satisfies that requirement.
A lot of other people will just talk about study and not tell you what it is.
And so you'll have to ask them, I'm sure they'll tell you, but you might have to ask
them.
Does the only thing I can do, I do this sometimes when I post online, sometimes I don't
include the citation and I do that on purpose.
And what I do is I'll include keywords that are very obviously used as part of that study
will include say, participant number, maybe the year.
the study, some things like that, because if someone says to me, how do I find the study?
And I have included very obvious details that tells me you don't actually have this skill
to understand that study.
This is a really interesting conversation.
I don't want to have this now, but I often do stuff that is kind of similar in the sense
that I will exclude information that I think people aren't qualified to assess.
So I include a citation.
So if somebody wants to pull up the paper, they can go and pull up the paper and now have
every single piece of information that's available to them. And if they've passed that threshold
of searching for the paper and pulling up, which is a very low threshold, to be honest,
then they can then and they can do some assessments.
The thing I never include in any of my infographics is the number of participants in a study.
Never. Never. Not once.
The reason I don't do that is because people who think they know something about research
analysis will tell me that they think a study is underpowered or overpowered, not overpowered
ever.
It's always a study that they don't like is always underpowered.
And they'll just look at the numbers subjects and I'll go, "How have you deduced this
underpowered?"
And they go, "Oh, I think it should be 20 and it's only 18 or whatever."
And they're, "How did you know?"
And they don't. They don't have the first idea of what a power analysis looks like.
And so I never do that.
If you've got the ability to pull up the paper, then okay, you can make your own mistakes
and you can decide whether you think a study is underpowered or not and you're probably
wrong.
You know, you've at least demonstrated the capacity to pull up the paper on your own.
What I'm not going to do is give people the ability to do that based on my infographic
because I'll spend my entire day commenting, saying, "Have you done a reverse parallel
system established or are you just set it correct?"
And then they're going, "What are you talking about?
I'm just looking at the number of subjects and I can see what you're doing in this garbage."
You know, so I do similar things in the sense that I don't allow information that I think
people are going to misuse.
But with the citation, if they wish to, they can go and access to it, whatever.
So I think we're doing the very similar thing in the sense that we're trying to
screen people a little bit so that they don't find information, it's just going to distract
them from something educational.
I mean, at the end of the day, this comes back to, "Are we trying to educate or are we
trying to make money by building an audience?"
You know, and I think that's, unfortunately, a route, a question that a lot of fitness
influences probably can't answer very honestly.
I'm inadvertently educating because I'm just talking about stuff that I find interesting
and I make infographics because it's the best way of taking notes that I've found when
I come back and look at study, I want to know why I thought about it when I read it and
the infographic gives me that answer.
So really, what you're doing when you see my infographics is you're seeing what my note
taking looks like and everything else is just me organizing my thoughts on subjects.
If that's helpful to people, fantastic, but I'm not trying to, you know, really do anything
more than find out how these things work.
Unfortunately, there wasn't a simple answer there.
You know, ultimately what you're saying is, you go back to the source and I think that's
good, but unfortunately, going back to that source is likely to take one a day, half a
day, just to go through that source material depending on what it is and hopefully understand
it.
Well, it took me about five minutes with the courier to realize that what we were doing
with is something completely irrelevant to the question.
So I think if you, you know how to read a research paper, you might be able to disallow
certain situations within five minutes, you can clearly see some of these things.
Yeah.
I really didn't expect this, this courier method is to be quite such a shoe in.
I thought I'd be traipsing through studies trying to figure out what was going on for
like a day and a half and I knew within five minutes of picking up the paper that it was
irrelevant.
Yeah.
So it was then it was just an interesting process really.
So I think it really depends.
But yeah, what we've got I think really is a whole bunch of people who, the financials
attached to a particular person or tribal identity and then they just kind of go along with
whatever's being said.
And if somebody publishes a little chart that says with no citation written on it, with
no information about how the data was gathered, you know, and they are like, so 119 studies
and it gave this result and everyone's running around with their hands in the air.
Well, okay, well, how did you get 119 frequency studies?
I thought even possible.
I mean, that should have been okay.
So if you want to take a step before the step of getting the source material, you know,
if somebody posts a chart that says this chart includes 119 studies and it's a chart telling
you about training frequency, hopefully that would set alarm bells ringing because you
should know that there are not 119 frequency studies available.
I mean, I hope you know that.
Maybe you don't.
So like, ultimately, there should be some alarm bells ringing just in terms of like, does
this even pass the sniff test and then the second thing would then be get these source
material.
I mean, hopefully, educators would know that the trouble means people who just want to
have what they should be doing.
And I know I say, hopefully, because most people, those people just want to know what they
should be doing in the gym.
You know, they don't want it.
Oh, they shouldn't be following me then.
I mean, honestly, come on.
I mean, like, they can follow you.
I mean, that's what your account is designed to do, designed to help people understand exactly
how they can either obtain a program that will give them the best results, what are
willing, or they can even write their own based on the education you provide.
And they have the confidence that is based on pre-1950 bodybuilders who were doing things
pretty much without the aid of any extraneous, you know, pharmaceuticals.
And so it was pretty much the best anecdotal data that exists and has ever existed, you
know.
So, you know, I think that's what your account is brilliant at, but if somebody's coming
to my account and complaining that I'm not giving them, you know, education and how to
write a program, then sorry, I'm not intending to do that, you know, I'm for the tiny fraction
of percentage of people on the industry who want to, I want to understand how this works,
not just what works, but how it works, because that's my obsession is figuring out how it
works.
You know, one of my, the few things that irritates me is when somebody comes to my account
and tells me what they think I should do to help them, and it's like, no, I'm sharing
what I think is interesting.
If it doesn't help, you go and follow somebody else.
Yeah, can you do content like this?
No, I can't.
I'm doing content because I find it interesting, you know, 160 or 1000 people also find it
interesting, which is fantastic, but I'm not going to change what I do to appeal to
most because I'm not really that commercial.
I'm just doing stuff that interests me.
I mean, hopefully people should realize that by now.
If I was trying to do stuff that attracted attention, I would not do random technical
infographics on the stretch shortening cycle, you know, I would not do stuff on, you know,
kind of like, how does, I don't know, I'm trying to think of something random that I've
done recently that was completely irrelevant to 99.9% of the planet, you know, most, there's
infographics I post that people are looking at going, why would you post that?
And I'm like, because I find it interesting, because it helps me understand how this
physiology works.
So I did study and I did notes on it.
And one more question for you before we wrap up, and I know again, this is, we've gone
down with a tangent here, but it is somewhat relevant.
So if we don't have as much sort of, you know, outcome data perhaps as people might, you
know, lead others to believe that we do, one option we have is to look at things like
physiological models.
And so you've developed a weekly net stimulus model.
And I'm sure we'll talk about that in more detail, perhaps in future episodes.
But in a nutshell, what is like, what is a model?
Why does a model, why does a physiological model actually help us answer these questions
that we're lacking enough outcome data on?
So basically, a physiological model is a very useful tool for two reasons.
Firstly, it starts by establishing some really strong physiological observations, which
were confident.
So we're very confident, for example, in the two physiological observations that we
started with today, which is that there is hypertrophy.
It's always either, muscle fibres are always either growing or shrinking, and therefore we've
got a possibility of net hypertrophy over the week being zero, because you have hypertrophy
followed by hypertrophy.
Secondly, we're very confident that the stimulus you can create in a strengthening workout
is non-linear, that you don't like stack sets onto, again, physiological reasons for that.
If you then build a model on the basis of those really strong observations, you can tinker
with some of the numbers, but ultimately the shape of the model is always coming broadly
the same.
If you've got a whole lot of outcome data that don't fit that, or they're very what I
call gray data in the sense that they just don't tell you anything, then your model can
add to your outcome data, your long-term training data, and give you a steer on what you think
is happening.
Now, that's exactly what we've seen today, which is that the physiological model tells you
that three is better than two and two is better than one, definitively.
The very gray, messy kind of outcome data tells you three is better than one, but two are
not really sure about.
So straight away, you just put the two together and you're, "Oh, okay, I can see what's
going out."
No worries.
So it allows you that extra kind of steer on your training studies data to be able to
put the two together and form a very clear picture of what's going on.
Secondly, if you have a model, especially one that has had a calculator built on it, or
you can run in Excel, you can fill in the gaps that you don't have.
So somebody says to me, "What happens if I train every other day?"
And the outcome data maximalists will say, "Oh, well, we don't know, it could be anything,
you know?
It could be anything.
You could be teleported to Mars."
I mean, we just don't know.
And yet the model will tell you exactly what happens.
So it fills in the gaps.
It fills in the gaps in the data that you don't have.
Essentially, it's good for those two reasons.
It allows you a bit more confidence on your training study data and it fills the pleasures
the picture out into it and then secondly it allows you to answer questions.
that you just can't answer from the mountain trainators and of course practically from a personal
point of view it allows you to literally put your training program into the calculator and
and totally whether you could manipulate it in one direction or another and get a better result.
So from a practical point of view it's actually very interesting as well as he is usable in a
kind of programming sense but you know not giving the game away too much but it will pretty much
tell you just to train like a pre-1950s bodybuilder. I mean that's always good to tell you so I kind
of like take great comfort in the fact that you know yes the outcome data is a bit gray it doesn't
tell you everything you want to know the model sits really well with the outcome data it tells you
a lot more and the bodybuilding community pre-1950 basically tells you to train how the model tells you
to train. So for me I don't see how anybody can argue with this with a straight face. I think
that anybody who wants to argue with this has got to say why does the outcome long-term training
data not show that two is better than three if you think two is better than three it doesn't
show that. Why do pre-1950 bodybuilders not train with two times a week or a pillow spurs?
This is didn't and why does the model not give you two times a week but in three it doesn't.
So you know there is no part of this matrix that supports two times a week it just doesn't
exist everything supports three now some support three better than others but they all kind of
lean in that direction some strongly some weekly and I think ultimately it's just being pushed
the idea that two is somehow the same as three or better three it's just being pushed by people
who like to train like that you know that's what it is people decide they like training like that
and therefore because that ego requires their preferences to be perfect they can't really
you know kind of get themselves out to the mindset that their preference might not be perfect.
Yeah yeah I mean it's you can't overwork I guess ecumen psychology and all of this and in
these topics and questions that come up on social media obviously full body at least in
the world that I was part of full body was not the norm those okay for beginners but that was
it nobody but they would do that no advanced lifter would do that and so the status quo was either
gross lit or upper lower and anytime we challenge our status quo there's people who stand to lose
something from that and there's going to be you know emotional attachment to that and keep
back to that and I guess ultimately that's kind of what we're seeing and it'll be interesting to
see what we see over the next couple of weeks and I'm sure there'll be a lot of emotional I guess
responses to what we're saying but you know the question is ultimately like why are you doing
what you're doing you know if someone has a good justification why they want to seek to
upper lower by all means I hear it well nobody has to justify to me how they train they trade
over their life I mean I literally I've got no judgment on anything whatsoever the only thing
that I'm interested in is you know what physiologically is happening and in the absence of any human
factors what would be the best training program you know leaving aside whether somebody likes it
or dislikes it what would be the best training program I mean I think that's a massive red herring
when people say you know you can't argue that two is better than three or three is better than two
because somebody might like two and somebody might like three and I'm like no that's just simply not
the question it's literally a relevant question we want to answer this question first physiologically
what is the best possible outcome and then separately after that you can make a decision about
what you want to do exactly it's a coaching question it's absolutely a coaching question you know
okay we went down some pathways that didn't expect us to go down but hopefully there's
there's something there for people who followed us this have fun we go out and half hopefully
you guys have kept up I think this is really interesting topic I do think that this is one that
you know obviously it's frequently or yeah yeah I mean you know full body upper lower splits
so you can see all of this stuff it has a huge amount of application it's really interesting
physiologically it's where all of this sort of converges so I'm sure we'll do future podcasts
on some variants of this topic but you know as always we're interested in what you guys are
interested in as well so if you've got questions feedback ideas based off of this or just
doing other topics as well please let us know it send them to me because Jake doesn't read his
diary messages you can put him in my Q&A that's fine as well I see that I just get overwhelmed with
DMs as too many so put in my questions I'm amazed that you check your DMs that feels like inverted
to what I'd expect but sure okay anyway thank you guys for joining us and we do hope you'll
join us again next week
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
A 1952 physique magazine documented routines from bodybuilders like Floyd Page and Steve Reaves, revealing early use of full-body training and sets.
These routines often featured multiple exercises per muscle group, with a focus on moderate reps (8–10) and three training sessions per week.
The plan includes a mix of bench presses, rows, pulls, and overhead presses, with limited hamstring or leg-specific work, indicating era-specific equipment and design limitations.
Exercises like narrow grip bench and incline fly are noted for targeting clavicular pectorals, highlighting the importance of plane of motion in muscle activation.
Training frequency is physiologically supported by muscle growth and atrophy cycles, with higher frequency (e.g., three times/week) yielding greater net hypertrophy than lower frequency.
Long-term studies show no significant difference between one and two sessions, but consistently demonstrate that three sessions outperform one.
The absence of direct, frequency-specific studies in meta-analyses and the dominance of indirect measures (like DEXA) limit their validity for assessing frequency effects.
Historical bodybuilder routines and physiological principles align with higher training frequency being optimal, despite some contradictory claims in popular fitness discourse.
Summary:
This transcript explores a vintage bodybuilding training routine from a 1952 physique magazine, focusing on Floyd Page’s full-body plan involving 12 exercises, three sessions per week, and moderate volume (8–10 reps per set). The plan highlights exercise selection patterns, such as narrow grip bench presses for clavicular targeting and a limited focus on hamstrings, reflecting the equipment and priorities of the era. The discussion then shifts to training frequency, emphasizing that physiology supports higher frequency—three times per week—as superior to one or two due to muscle growth and atrophy cycles.
While long-term studies show minimal differences between one and two sessions, all studies consistently show three sessions outperform one. Critics often misinterpret meta-analyses that include non-frequency studies or use indirect measurements, which lack precision in assessing hypertrophy. The analysis reveals that even when frequency studies are limited, the pattern consistently favors three sessions.
This conclusion is reinforced by historical evidence: pre-1950s bodybuilders trained three times weekly, and physiological principles align with this. Ultimately, the data and history jointly support higher training frequency as optimal, though the exact optimal point between two and three sessions remains less defined. The episode underscores the importance of understanding study design, measurement validity, and context when evaluating training science.
FAQs
Training frequency refers to how often you train a specific muscle per week, not how many times you go to the gym. It's important because muscle fibers are constantly growing or shrinking, and higher frequency provides more stimulus, leading to greater net hypertrophy over time.
Yes, training frequency affects muscle growth. Higher frequency (e.g., three times per week) generally leads to better results than lower frequency (e.g., once per week) because it provides more consistent stimulus and reduces muscle atrophy during rest periods.
Muscle growth follows a non-linear dose response, meaning each additional set in a workout contributes less to hypertrophy than the previous one. This makes training frequency more effective, as spreading sets across multiple days maximizes total stimulus and avoids fatigue from high-volume workouts.
Bodybuilders from the 1950s, like Floyd Page, commonly trained three times per week using full-body routines. This aligns with modern physiological understanding that higher frequency leads to better muscle growth, showing a long-standing pattern consistent with current science.
Many long-term studies do not directly compare training frequencies. Some include studies that measure other variables (like volume or reps) or use indirect methods (like DEXA), which makes it difficult to draw clear conclusions about frequency’s impact on hypertrophy.
While most studies show no statistically significant difference between one and two sessions, nearly all show a significant benefit of three sessions over one. This suggests that three times per week is superior to one, with two likely in between.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.