Go back

013 Neuromechanical Matching: Everything you need to know (but few do)

from Hypertrophy Past and Present

1h 29m 45s

013 Neuromechanical Matching: Everything you need to know (but few do)

The episode explores a vintage strength training plan from the 1950s by Superior, founder of Iron Man magazine, highlighting its progressive structure where exercise volume increases with experience. The plan includes a mix of barbell and dumbbell movements, such as curls, presses, rows, and an isometric chest pull, designed to be performed three times per week. While comprehensive, it reveals significant imbalances—especially a lack of lat work and excessive focus on elbow flexors—indicating a deficiency in back development and muscular balance. The discussion then shifts to the Neuro-mechanical Matching Principle, a neuroscience concept stating that the central nervous system selects muscles with the best mechanical leverage to maximize efficiency, not joint torque. This principle is supported by multiple human studies and explains how the body reduces effort and energy use during movement. Critics often dismiss it as fringe, but evidence shows it applies in strength training contexts, including high-effort scenarios. The core insight is that the CNS prioritizes efficiency through leverage, driven by evolutionary need to conserve energy. This principle, rooted in movement biology and supported by physiological models like Marcora’s, provides a clear, evidence-based framework for understanding muscle activation, making it a foundational concept in modern exercise science.

Transcription

18142 Words, 101868 Characters

English
Welcome back everyone to another episode. Thank you for joining us. We appreciate all of you as always Chris. How are you doing today? I'm doing very well. Thanks, Jake. How are you? I'm also doing very well. I am doing very very well because I'm actually staying somewhere with lots of very good cafes and it's only 10 o'clock in the morning and I've had five or six coffees so far. So if I'm talking double speed, that's why so apologies in advanced everyone. You guys know the drill. We're going to unpack a topic which is a B topic. It's a topic that gets talked about a lot and I think it gets talked about a lot with a lot of confusion. So it is going to be hopefully an interesting episode for you all. If you are not six coffees, coffee steep like I am, then maybe hit pause and go get one because it might help you. But obviously to get started, I'm going to introduce us to a bit of a silver era workout plan. We'll have a good chat and then we'll jump into the meeting potatoes or the episode. So we have talked about this guy before. So this is period radar. So I think a couple of weeks ago, I think two episodes back perhaps I touched on one of his plans. I briefly mentioned who he was. Superior was a very influential figure of the silver era. He started Iron Man magazine. A lot of people I'm assuming are familiar with Iron Man. And I believe Iron Man is still running. Don't quote me on that, but I believe it is. It obviously has changed hands over that time. I believe he ran it and was a chief editor, whatever for I believe 50 years were there about so very significant and one of the most influential magazines of that time period, I think he started it and he's so very, very, very early on. And he introduced us. I touched on it last time, but he did introduce us to a few different methods and sort of popularized them. I'm not going to talk about those today, but I'm sure at some point we might touch on them in future episodes. But in his he published sort of a lot of different kind of books, a lot of different plans, predominantly stuff around like barbells and dumbbells because obviously this is pretty early on in that time period. The plan we're talking about today is, in fact, let me just just quickly jump back for a moment. I think in a previous episode, maybe last week, I talked or we talked about sort of the idea of rotating exercises and we made the point that it kind of makes sense probably to add exercises in rather than take exercises out on one's lifting journey. And this is really well emphasized in a lot of these types of plans. So the plan we're going to talk about here is what he, I believe he pointed an advanced beginner routine. So I suppose we will call that intermediate. And if you were to compare this chronic one intermediate plan to a total beginner plan, it's very similar, but with more exercises added in. So that's kind of the trajectory that people like period we're going on where it's like, okay, beginner is his, you know, 8, 10, 12 exercises for you to do. And then more intermediate advanced, you know, he's 12, 14, 15 exercises for you to do. And they just sort of add in exercises over time. So this is the advanced beginner routine. This was published in his Iron Man Barbell course in early 50s. And this was, of course, full body as most of these plans at this point of time were. And it was to be done three times a week. Now, as I've sort of mentioned the past, it was a little bit of liberty over that. And often people like period would talk about a cave, you're struggling with that. Maybe you just did twice a week. So there was always like a little bit of, you know, variability and individualization to some of this stuff. So the plan itself, we start off with a barbell curl bearing mind. This is like a set mostly barbells. I think there's maybe a couple of dumbbell that it's almost all barbell work. So we start off with a barbell curl and everything here is three sets. Okay, so we do barbell curl three sets eight to 10. Then we go into a reverse curl three sets eight to 10. And then we've got a overhead press some military press style three sets eight to 10. Then we've got a behind the neck. So we've gone sort of closer grip, a little bit more sagittal to frontal. And then we go to a barbell bench three sets of eight to 10, a bent over barbell row three sets of eight to 10. Heels elevated squat. Now for the lower body exercises, he did just eight to 15, you know, bear in mind some of this is coming out of convenience in terms of the equipment they've got where the people have squat stands, whether they're trying to leverage the bar up. So there's some of that playing into it. And then we have this interesting. He actually coined it. I think he named it off himself, but it was an isometric chest pull. He called it where basically you had like a bar that you could hold onto a vertical bar somewhere and you would hold around head height neck height and you would do an isometric basically squeezing the chest together in this sort of downwards pulling motion. And he programmed that for a belief he said like 20 squeezes. So I guess this is like a second squeezed type thing. It was a little bit vague instructions there. He did provide a diagram that it was it was a little bit vague. So that's an interesting and he did include this exercise in quite a lot of his plans. And then we went into a stiff like the lift. Sorry, we did the no, we did stiff like the lift and then he went back to the isometric chest pull. So you actually did the chest pull twice. Perhaps he enjoyed it because it was named after himself. I'm not sure. And then we finished with sit ups side bends and standing car phrases and interesting point that he made understanding car phrase easy said if you're doing this exercise. It is bad if you're going to do three sets because obviously earlier sometimes I would do single sets. So if you're doing this for three sets do one set with your toes pointed out do one of pointed in to begin with do one set with your toes neutral to sticking straight ahead and then do one set with your toes pointing outwards. So in neutral out and now is the end of the plan. I think that's an interesting note. We'll talk about that in a moment. But before we do, what do you make of that? It's a pretty comprehensive plan. But what do you make of it? Well, yeah, I mean, there's some interesting things to unpack here. I mean, I find I was I was smiling when you were talking about the the isometric chest pull because I was thinking to myself they've even gone to the trouble of getting a bar set up in a position where they could do pull ups and they don't do them. And I'm like, you know, what is this a version that these guys have with pull ups? They just don't like them. But yeah, that would be again a comment that I make almost every time we look at one of these programs is that there doesn't seem to be anything resembling a wide grip pull up, which would give you really great. There is actually only the bento of a ball ball row, which I would expect to be a wide grip. So actually the lat work is very diminished in this program because it would really you wouldn't have either the sagittal all the front or you just have transverse plane pulling more or less. So I think there's definitely a deficit of that work. I mean, they do have a stiff like deadlift, but again, stiff leg and it's obviously low body focus. So a little bit, I think that, you know, kind of deficient, I think. In terms of the other kind of comments, obviously, you know, there's a tremendous amount of volume for the biceps in this program, which really does kind of or elbow flexes, which does look a little bit strange. You know, especially done first, it looks like it's trying to do this three times a week with six sets for the elbow flexes. I think we'll be very topi, you know, especially in that moderate rep range. Similarly, we've got a lot of overhead pressing, although perhaps with sagittal and frontal planes, we're getting a big kind of shift from middle dealt in the frontal to anterior dealt, maybe even to make your peck in the sagittal. So maybe that's not quite so bad. I suspect the elbow flex, so there's probably quite a lot to cross over there. Other bits and pieces, just noticing, I guess that we do have a deadlift variation in this program, which in many of the others that we talked about, we didn't have. And I always said, I don't understand why you again, you can very easily set up a pull up by you can very easily put a ball well on the ground. Why don't we have more deadlift, so why don't we have more pull ups, you know, in these programs, and it's interesting to see that we do have that deadlift variation here. Of course, the comment that you made about the car phrases is called as well, because we can see that, you know, kind of looking for sort of different parts of the gastroc by training with different foot positions, you know, something that only really has been validated in very recent research studies. So, you know, that would be my starting kind of set of comments, I mean, I could I could carry on talking about excise variation, because it's obviously very interesting that not only do we have a lot of volume for the elbow flexors, we do have two very distinct exercises for the elbow flexors one that is much more brachyradialis focused with the pronation one that's much more by its brachy focused to a degree with that supination. You know, I think there's some interesting points there that will segue us into what I want to talk about. Ultimately, I think this is material that we have largely commented on before, you know, the excise selection, a lot of variety, but with some really big gaping holes according to certain exercises or muscle groups that they don't particularly like training, you know, I think this is very much a continuation of the kind of material that we've seen. What do you think that isometric chess pool, so assuming so this is a fairly high position, it's almost like a pullover in a sense, if you think about it, right, like it's the starting point of a pullover. Well, you've seen the diagram and I haven't seen it. If you're telling me it looks like a pullover, then it looks like a pullover. Well, if you think about the function that he's doing, if your hands are very high up and you're doing this isometric pool down, then that would be relatively similar to what's happening in the start of a pullover. Yeah, and if that's, if that's sagittal plane, then I think you're going to get obviously a lot of sternal peg definitely or cost or rather sorry not sternal. a lot of coastal peck and you're gonna get a lot of a triceps brachylon head and obviously a big chunk of posterior deltoid. So you know I think that would be an interesting addition to the program. I mean I mean obviously he has probably picked that or developed that because he felt that it attacked one of his weaknesses or was something that worked for him. Maybe he had better leverages in certain muscles that allowed him to benefit more from that exercise. I don't think it's something that would immediately jump on and go oh this is amazing we should all be doing it. You know I can see why it fits in this program probably not twice but I know I did find that funny the only exercise you paid it twice. I guess what I'm finding interesting here is we've got like the the curl like you said we've got a good biceps brachy exercise and then we've got a focus on brachy radios. Then if we look at shoulders we've got the sagittal overhead press and then we've got the the frontal plane. So he's doing quite well in in you know almost in biasing out the elbow flexors biasing out the shoulders and then we get to the chest and we've got you know you've got even the clavicle chest in the sagittal overhead then you've got sagittal with the the um I'm not saying what I'm saying you've got to do it. I can see it now that you've now that you've said it I can see it so that the bench press you've probably got transverse plane movement so you hitting sternal with a little bit of clavicular and not a little bit quite a bit of clavicular and coastal we're alongside it. Then with the overhead press in the sagittal plane you've got clavicular nailed down and then with the this isometric you've got the coastal part nailed down. Now I can now that you've mentioned that I can see how the peck development also fits in the same pattern as the delta development and the biceps to other and all the elbow flexors development that I was mentioning. And then it's got the calves sorted out so we're just really lacking first and foremost with back the solvable problems of their day with the equipment they had available to them I don't understand why they didn't train lats properly. Yeah that that really does kind of always glitch for me. Yeah most of the other stuff that they're missing is stuff that they just couldn't really do. You couldn't do it feasibly yeah exactly. So aside from from that like you're saying with what they had access to this is a fairly well thought out plan I would say. It definitely indicates that he has been able to perceive the results of the training that he's been programming in the past and gather together a selection of exercises that fit really really well. You know this is always the point that we're making which is that if you don't have the anabolic stimulus in place then you can look at what is happening with people and your own training and other people's training and you can see what it's doing over a number of years and you don't ever have that confusing confounding problem of the animal it's creating growth everywhere. And I think this is something I'm just going to keep repeating and repeating and repeating until you know enough people realize that it's a problem that we've got to deal with. You know and I think there's this tendency for people to then start arguing about you know is this person nostril is that person nostril? I don't think the argument even goes anywhere it's like you just go back to the pictures of people that we've got or the knowledge of the people that we've got that didn't have that problem and you're immediately jump you know miles ahead of where you were previously in terms of your understanding of this kind of thing because you're putting yourself in a position where they didn't have the problem at all. You know you can of course you can reduce the extent of the problem in your analyses today you can but you can't remove it completely and those guys just didn't even have it. So I think this is really kind of what we're trying to do here is bring this material more into the public domain get people thinking about it talking about to understanding because ultimately it solves a problem that we have that we probably can't actually solve at the moment you know in today's day and age. The only thing we can do is look back and benefit from the fact that they didn't have it. That's the only real way I think that we can move forward on this stuff. Yeah exactly. So we've eased people in with a plan hopefully everyone settled in have the coffee buckled up what's our topic for today. So we're going to talk about the Neuromechanical Matching Principle and the reason for talking about this today is that there is currently obviously a lot of debate about it but also the debate I believe is occurring simply because people don't understand some of the very basics about it. So this is not intended to be a discussion of Neuromechanical Matching that goes into extreme amounts of complex detail is designed to try and see where people are misunderstanding the literature. I don't want to detail you this quickly into the conversation but I think what you've just introduced there is a really important point for people to think about even before we go deeper in that so many of the arguments and the conversations that do happen online happen because people don't actually understand what it is that they're talking about. And you know I've seen this over even we don't get into detail but even you know people talk about stuff that we've been talking about over the last few weeks and making it clear that they haven't even listened to the episodes and just said oh so I've heard on the great wine the person Jacob said this and then presenting an argument against it. You know we obviously don't name names unless it's a positive thing as well but one thing that actually cast them said to me one time was you get a lot further in life if you iron what do you call it iron cloud or iron man someone's argument instead of straw man it. And that's stuck out to me I was like you know what actually that is really good advice if you actually genuinely want to find what's true take the opposing viewpoint and make it as as indestructible as you can give it as like try to make the case see if there's any truth to it before you try to straw man and tear it down and discredit it. And I think that's kind of what we want to do here to show actually you know what exactly are we talking about what exactly is this topic about before people start start trying to discredit because they don't actually understand really what it's even saying. Absolutely that is the purpose of today is to simply explain what it is and comment on why about and comment on why a number of very popular criticisms are simply irrelevant and that's really been been the issue with this topic is that I think a lot of people are simply hearing the words or hearing the discussions and they think they understand enough of it to pass comment on and actually because of the kind of diffuse nature of the internet where people hear something and then somebody else hears something and repeated it and it's just nonsense. And I think that's that's what we're doing today is not is not so if if if you already know if you're listening to this and you already know how near mechanical matching works and you already have a you know full understanding of the of the basics this isn't going to be you know the best podcast for you but if you've never come across neurocognitive matching before or if you think you don't have a full understanding of it hopefully this will absolutely you know deal with that particular issue and give you everything that you need to know that's that's the plan anyway. So starting at the beginning what is the principle of neurocognitive matching or the principle of neurocognitive matching is a hypothesis that has been developed by a group of neuroscientists after a period of 15 or so years of work in their laboratory. So it's got nothing to do with me. All I've done is simply bring it to people's attention. So there are some people running around with the idea that I had something to do with this hypothesis. It's nothing to do with me. I am simply popularizing it and introducing it. So point them one. It actually hasn't it incredibly long. Heritidic goes back to the 1970s and 1990s. It was originally called functional differentiation. That was when people first started to notice that there was a connection between the activation of a muscle in our movement and the leverage that the muscle has. I'll get on to explaining that in a moment in more detail. Gradually over the years that functional differentiation concept you know grew and grew and grew and grew and people noticed more and more and more in that line of thinking and it was renamed I think around about 2007, 2009 as the principal of Neurogenic Matching, when this research group headed by Simon Gandivia, incredibly famous well-known neuroscientist, started to do their own work on it. They renamed it as the principal of Neurogenic Matching to distinguish the precise work that they were doing in that area. And I think they've done or they and related laboratories have done around about 10 or 12 studies on this. So again, if you're coming across people who say, "Oh, there's only one study in Neurogenic Matching and it's in, I don't know, dogs." Then no, that's not true. There are a series of 10 to 12 studies done by this lab. This is ignoring the functional differentiation stuff for the moment. This is just the new stuff on the named hypothesis of principal and Neurogenic Matching. They've got about 10 or 12 and yes, the early stuff was done in dog respiratory muscles. They went on and they have done stuff in human skeletal muscle as well, including finger muscles, crunk muscles, and even another laboratory not theirs has done work in the deltoid, human deltoid muscles. So even stuff that you will see in strength training has been looked at by this kind of series of studies. So and everything that I'm saying, you can validate for yourself. I've got a blog post that I will share on social media, which lists out and links all of these studies and you can literally validate everything that I'm saying. Whereas, you know, other people will be saying there's only one study and it's in dogs, you can easily demonstrate that that is not true by simply looking at the material that is already available on the internet. Okay, so that's the preamble. Let me now explain exactly what Neurogenic Matching says and why it is important that it solves the problem that it solves. So the problem that we have in any human movement or any animal movement, if you like, is that we don't have a guiding principal, or didn't have a guiding principal for how the central nervous system decides which muscle to switch on. That sounds absolutely crazy when you think about it. It's like, well, you know, how does an The central nervous system decide to use my calf muscles to get out of a chair instead of my hand muscles. And you're like, "Now that's obvious." I mean, obviously it sends the activation, because that's the muscle that does that job. Okay, just pull on that thread a little bit, and you'll find your own kind of combatching at the end of it. Because what the principle of your own kind of combatching does is it says that the central nervous system picks the muscles that have the ability to do the movement, rather the muscles that don't. Right, well, of course it does, okay, but keep pulling on that thread. What happens if you've got a couple of muscles that are to joint, and they can all kind of do the movement, but some of them are a bit better at it than others. Well, the CNS will pick the ones that are a bit better at it, or at least it will prefer to, or do those first. And that's essentially all that neurochemical matching principle is saying. It says that, "If you go to a given joint for a movement that you're interested in or that you're measuring, and you look at which muscles or muscle regions have the best mechanical advantage," which is the leverage, so you calculate mechanical advantage by simply saying, "If I produce this force with this muscle, what's the torque that I get out the other end?" Because torque is the muscle force multiplied by the momentum, the leverage. So you can go, "Okay, well, if I'm looking at this joint, and I've got this leverage for this muscle, and this leverage for that muscle, and, you know, which leverage is longest?" So, look at the leverages, and you go, "These muscles have the best leverages, they're going to be the ones that the brain prefers to use rather than the others." So, the problem that neurochemical matching is solving is telling us, literally, all it's telling us, is that the brain or the central nervous system chooses whichever muscles have the best leverage, because that will give you the largest torques for the smallest amount of muscle force. So is it an alternative to neuro-mechanical matching that's been proposed to answer that question of that problem? There have been a number of attempts to provide alternatives to the neurochemical matching principle, but they are very fringe. This is the interesting thing, because when I go to the research literature, you could describe this as the neuroscience, part of exercise science, if you like. When I go to that literature, I only really see the principle of neuro-mechanical matching, and it's predecessor function or differentiation. I only really see that, I don't see any other major hypotheses being tested or addressed. So people often, in the hypertrophy part of the exercise science community, they will say to me, neurochemical matching is a weird idea that nobody believes in, like, "I'm sorry, what if you go to the part of the exercise science community that actually measures and looks at this kind of question, motor control and motor learning, and how does the central nervous system control movements?" It's the only one they talk about, really. I mean, yeah, sure, there's always going to be review papers where somebody says, well, maybe this could be a possibility, and that could be a possibility. Those fringe hypotheses, and I'm not using fringe in the bad word, I'm just saying that, like, non-mainstream in that community, how they do exist, but nobody's actually going and exploring them, measuring them, testing them, addressing them. If you want to actually see the only, only available model of how the brain determines where send activation in the human movement, it's the principle of neuro-mechanical matching, previously known as functional differentiation. So I wonder how, and look, I know this is not the topic of today, but I wonder how much of this controversy is because this is an adjacent field, I suppose, to exercise science, and if this is kind of, you know, quote unquote, "new" to the exercise science field, and maybe that's why there's so much pushback on it. I think that's totally true. I think very simply what's happened is that I have popularized the discussion of this hypothesis, and people have turned around and realized that they didn't have that knowledge, or they hadn't done that reading, and they've kind of rejected it out of hand because it didn't sit or it didn't feel like it was part of their existing education. Well, it should happen, because it's the only way you can explain how the brain selects which muscle to use in the exercise. So it's critical exercise information, really. It seems very relevant, doesn't it? It does, and like, it's not my fault that they didn't have it in their curriculum, it's not my fault. I'm just pointing out, but of course, I'm the person that's easiest to blame, because I'm the one that's presenting them with the inconvenient information. But ultimately, the situation we have is that within the field of people who study this thing, neuroscientists, this is the prevailing model that they use. There isn't really any discussion about that. So when hypertruist searches tell me that it's fringe or it's weird, they're just telling me that they haven't done the reading. They're just telling me that they haven't read that stuff, and they didn't have a model, and they don't like the fact that I'm pointing that out. So it's an ego thing, really. It's like a ego protection thing. But anyway, the next thing I'd like to address is what the principle of neuro-mechanical matching is trying to achieve. Now, I explain what it does. It gives you the answer to which muscle is going to get activated, or which muscle region is going to get activated in the next exercise. But what is its purpose? This is what I think people miss, because there is this assumption in the hypertruist fee and the strength training community that the purpose of a tool that gets you the answer to which muscle is activated in the next exercise is to maximize joint torque. And that's not what the principle of neuro-mechanical matching is clearly trying to do. The principle of neuro-mechanical matching shows us that its driving purpose is to maximize efficiency, not to maximize joint torque. And I think this, above all other issues that I've been looking at in the last week or so, is where people are talking past each other. Because every time somebody who understands neuro-mechanical matching is talking with somebody who doesn't understand neuro-mechanical matching, they have this kind of conflict. Because the person who doesn't understand it thinks, I think, as their basic assumption that we're always trying to maximize joint torque. The person who actually does understand it is aware that we're not trying to maximize joint torque. We're trying to maximize the torque to muscle force ratio. What I want to do is get the maximum amount of torque for the minimum amount of muscle force input. And that is telling me that I'm always going to be looking for the leverage as my primary function, because that's the easiest way to get more torque for less muscle force. Now, I'm just going to throw a very, very small point out that I'm not going to go into detail in this, but you would expect, therefore, that passive tension would do the same thing. You would expect that passive tension would actually give you a benefit by giving you more torque for less muscle force, or at least active muscle force input. And it doesn't. It doesn't work like that. Passive force doesn't seem to give you that benefit. So, at some point, that problem needs to be resolved. We need to understand why that's happening, and that's a complex part of neuro-mechanical matching. But ultimately, it does simplify the process for us when we're talking about it in practical terms, because we can say, we don't have to think about passive tension. We can just look at leverages, because that is what neuro-mechanical matching is trying to do, is trying to give you the biggest torque for the minimum amount of muscle force. Now, that is an important point. Now, presumably, in my mind, that kind of just makes sense, because if we just think about from an evolutionary standpoint, why would an organism actually care about being inefficient to maximize an action, surely the goal would be to preserve energy, right? Is that kind of the idea behind why efficiency matters so much? So it looks like there might be a number of possibilities driving this, and I think you're probably right. I think it all comes back to the energy conservation stuff. The reason I say there's a number of aspects to it is because, obviously, if we start with the process of how the brain is controlling a movement, when we produce motunit equipment, we produce a perception of effort, and effort is a disagreeable sensation. I mean, like that's a fairly universally accepted concept. We don't like putting effort into stuff if we can get away with it. We'll put less effort, then hopefully get the same result out. So you can see straight away that the CNS has an incentive to minimise effort perception, and it'll do that by maximising or choosing the muscles that have a delivery. But equally, from an energy perspective, your muscle force is what determines your energy input, your ATP usage. If you can use a muscle with that leverage, you'll use less energy to get the same torque output. So ultimately, you can kind of see a number of routes that you can get to the same answer. But I think you're probably right, which is that the underlying governing factor that makes all of this happen is just that we use fewer resources, less effort, less energy, less activation, in order to get the output that we desire. So I think it's a evolutionarily driven process, which is trying to give us the maximum output for the minimum input, whatever that input might be. To my uneducated mind, it seems odd to me that someone would think the opposite would be true. And organism would have all. Well, I think the issue is that people are coming from a teleological point of view. So they're trying to go, "Well, I want to maximise torque, because I want to be strong. I want to live this way." Yeah, I want the outcome. Yeah, but you're not your kind of evolutionary history. You know, your organism was not designed for that purpose, your organisms don't survive. And efficiency is one of the best ways of surviving. So ultimately, you know, the numerical matching concept is based on observations that leverages are closely linked to activations in exercises and movements, but the underpinning philosophy of it is clearly that it is trying to maximise efficiency because if it wasn't, then it wouldn't work the way it does. And so we haven't lost anyone. I know this is teaching telling people how to suck eggs a little bit, but use the terms, you've used maximum force, maximum torque, and you've talked about torque efficiency. Really briefly, can you just describe how those differ? So what we're saying then is that at any joint, you have a couple of muscles that can do the joint action, and if you look at them, you can obviously see that they're producing forces, and muscle forces, the linear pulling force on the tendon. So it's a linear construct. If you then look at the joint, you can see that the joint rotates. So you've got a difference between the muscles pulling linearly and the joint is rotating. When we look at rotating forces which we call torques or moments, then the torque is generated or calculated, sorry, by the product, the multiplication of the muscle force and the leverage, the lever arm that that muscle has on the joint. So essentially what we're saying is that the torque is a rotational force, and therefore it requires two components. It requires the force and also the lever. So you've got the force that turns into a torque by the multiplication of that force by a lever arm distance. And that's really where we kind of sort of talk about different lever arms because you get different torques for different kind of muscles depending on how long their levers are. When I talk about the efficiency of a torque, what I'm saying is essentially how long is the lever? Do I get a really large torque output for this muscle? In other words, does it have a really long lever? So I'm saying the same thing. I'm just trying to emphasize the fact that the lever doesn't cost me anything energetically. So I don't need to do anything to get that lever. It's just there. Whereas muscle force is constantly requiring effort to produce motone equipment. So I feel a perception of effort. I'm requiring to put energy in to make that muscle force happen. The lever is not like that. It's free. It's free torque. If I've got a longer lever, I get more torque for the same muscle force. So if one was sitting in a car and they had the car door wide open, you're sitting in the driver's seat, the car door is wide open and you try to pull the door shut by putting up right up against the door hinge. You'll find that you have to put quite a lot of effort in and a lot of muscle force to make that happen. In contrast, if you grab the end of the door where the handle is and pull it towards you, it's very easy because you've got that huge lever arm that you're now using to make the movement happen. That's what levers are. You can do it. You can talk about it with what we would call spanners in the UK, the Americans call wrenches. I don't know what you call them in Australia, but you can talk about it with those. It's like holding the spanner or the wrench close to the nut or it's holding it further away. There's a number of different illustrations, but fundamentally, you've got to get your head around how there is a difference between linear force and the rotational force, which is a torque. That's the critical step to really being able to appreciate what we're describing here in terms of linear mechanical. With that background and we'll explain then what the principle of numerical matching is doing. We've explained why it's doing that for the purpose of efficiency. I've explained why people are misunderstanding the basics of it because they think that the purpose of this central nervous system control model is to maximize torque outputs or system force outputs and it's not, it's to maximize efficiency. What I'd like to do now is move on to a series of popular criticisms and I've arranged them in order that hopefully will flow, see what happens, but I just want to kind of work through these and explain why ultimately the criticisms are not really criticisms, they're just simply manifestations of ignorance by the people who are asking them. That's not a problem, as long as you, you know, self-correct. Starting at the beginning, I've kind of already explained this one, but I just want to reiterate the principle of numerical matching is not a new idea and it's not mine. So let me just kind of really hammer this one out because I'm getting a little bit annoyed by the number of people who say it's a brand new idea. There's only a little bit to research and, you know, it's all Chris's thing anyway. Like nothing to do with me, I've simply popularised it. It's been around as the under the heading of functional differentiation since the late 1970s and it was, you know, kind of formalised as the new principle of numerical matching in late 2007, 2008, something like that. And we've kind of finally got a review paper to describe all that is shown around about 2019. And there's, as I say, about 10, 12 papers, all of them looking at this concept and it does cover, you know, human skeletal muscles. So if I read one more comment saying that numerical matching has only been measured in, you know, dogs in, you know, kind of, uh, non-skeletal muscles, then I will actually probably pop it because it's absolutely just simply not true. And anybody saying that this is ignorant of the available literature, you can literally check that for yourself. You don't need to take my word for it. So I just want to kind of get the really easy stuff out of me to start with, kind of move on to something that's a little bit more complicated. So the first thing I want to talk about this a little bit more complicated is whether or not or how, rather, the principle of numerical matching is interacting with the size principle. So this is the first point I'm actually going to say that people who maybe have genuinely understood the principle of numerical matching, they might have a query or a question or a doubt regarding how these two principles interact with each other. This is actually a lot simpler than it looks at first glance. And to be fair, even the researchers that have worked on the principle of numerical matching have got themselves tangled in this not in a bad way, but like in the sense that they've wrestled with this kind of issue. Very simply, you can just say, well, the element size principle sits inside of the principle of numerical matching. So sometimes people will go, you don't need the principle of numerical matching because the size principle does that for you. Now, just to kind of reduce that statement to the absolute most absurd possibility. If the size principle is the anything you've got, then every time you try to do any movement, your brain would immediately send the activation to the smallest muscle fiber in or smallest motor unit in your body, no matter where it was. So like, you would probably find yourself blinking quite a lot when you tried to work across the room because the size principle would send the activations and smallest motor unit, which is probably one of the ocular muscles I'm just guessing. Now, obviously that's not what's happening. You know, the brain has to make a decision about which part of the body the activation goes to before it then goes to the process of size principle ordering of the motor units in that area. So you can just say, well, size principle is, you know, we do Venn diagrams a lot on this podcast, but it's basically a Venn diagram. So you've got a circle inside a circle. Your size principle is just going to take over at the point where the numerical matching principle has decided, this is the group of motor units I'm going to work with after that is principle takes over and deals with the issue. So essentially, they're not incompatible. You can see gray areas where they might kind of bump up against each other with physiology is messy. I haven't said that for a while, but I used to say it a lot. I should say it more. Physiology is messy. You don't get perfect clean cut kind of edges between every single thing that you're looking at, but fundamentally, in this case, it's a lot smaller of a problem than people are making out. You know, size principle just governs once you've got the area of the muscle or the muscle regional, the muscle that you're activating. Size principle deals with everything after that. Neurokinical matching is telling you where to go in the first place. Does that all make sense? I hope so. That is fairly straightforward. Hopefully, hopefully that made sense to one. It's literally just locating you, isn't it? Neurokinical matching is locating you. And then like you said, the size principle is this, but in case anyone's not aware of what we mean, my size principle is basically this mode and it's being recruited in smaller first and then larger later basically. Exactly. Exactly. And we're just dropping that as a subcategory of processes once Neurokinical matching is decided, the areas that are going to get used. So another criticism, which is an interesting one, is that and this is a very interesting criticism for a number of reasons. It's interesting because it actually tells you a lot about the critic and the way that they think as well as just being an interesting question in and of itself. So the criticism that I've seen is that the central nervous system has no way of detecting leverage. Now the reason I say that that tells you a little bit about the critic is because we can immediately disprove it by referring to Marcora's psychobiological model of fatigue. So it kind of tells you that the person who's looking at this problem doesn't actually have that bit of the puzzle available to them in their current model of how strange it works. But Marcora's psychobiological model of fatigue tells you that every time you produce a mutinute crewman signal, you automatically produce a perception of effort. Another really well documented element of physiology. Marcora's done an amazing work on that. Really, really cool kind of model from understanding how the brain interacts or connects mutinute crewman with perceptions of effort and ultimately describes how muscular failure is read. Another thing that I expect the hypertrophy researchers will go crazy at me about in six months time when they finally realize that, you know, that's explaining that particular part of their, you know, sort of, I don't know, workload or whatever it is that you could call it. But anyway, so Marcora's psychobiological model of fatigue says that you experience through the sensation of innovation a kind of perception of effort every time you produce mutinute crewman. Okay, so let's imagine that you've got a movement that you're doing and you've got two possible ways of doing it. You've got two muscles that are working in their both kind of discrete single muscles with no regions. So basically, the principle of neuro-mechanical machine can choose one or the other or it can equally divide activation between two. Now, let's say one of those muscles has really great leverage. The other one doesn't have very very good leverage at the joint angle that you're interested in testing. Now, what's going to happen basically is that if you use the muscle with bad leverage in that movement, you'll have to produce a lot more muscle force, which means that you'll produce a lot higher mutinute crewman level, which means that you'll feel a lot higher perception of effort. Now, incidentally, you'll also churn through a hell of a lot more ATP. So, this is what I was saying earlier about these things being connected. Now, in contrast, if you use the muscle that has much better leverage. then you'll produce lots more and lots of force. You'll experience a lot less effort perception because of the lower level of recruitment and you'll use a lot less ATP. So essentially, what we're seeing here is that the CNS clearly does have the ability to distinguish between muscles that have different leverages. It can instantaneously perceive differences in leverage because it can instantaneously perceive differences in material recruitment for the same output. So if you're doing a particular movement that requires a certain output, your brain will know instantaneously whether what it's doing is maximizing the ratio of torque to muscle force because it'll know whether the effort perception is feasible to come down on. And that's ultimately, I think, one of the most interesting things about the principle of neurochemical matching is because you can actually instantly see how the brain could be constantly able to, in anything you're doing. You do one movement and obviously again, physiology is messy movements. Very little changes occur. Every time you do a movement and the brain will notice if the last time you did it was more effortful than the current time. And you can get a then, you can get an iterative process moving forwards towards a movement that is less effortful for the same output that you're doing. So I think this is really interesting because on the one hand, it tells you that critics haven't read that, that you're not understood it and how it connects with this. But on the other hand, it presents a really nice opportunity to show just how easy it is for neurochemical matching to work because you can connect the leverage of a muscle with the perception of effort and therefore with the desirability of the movement pattern that you're using. - Again, this is hopefully fairly straightforward for people to keep up with. All you're saying is can the CNS detect effort? Like obviously it can. So I think where it gets tricky is that there's words that are being applied that aren't normally being used, right? Like we're talking about leverages, for example. And once someone sees a word maybe come up that he's not part of the normal vernacular, the suddenly they're like, well, that sounds complicated. That sounds like a genuine criticism argument. But it's like, well, not always saying is can the CNS detect effort or changes an effort? - Exactly, which it obviously can because you can. So it's like, you know, not really very complicated. Interestingly, there's also some data that suggests we've got the ability to store information about the relative leverages that muscles have in the spinal cord. So there's been one, at least one study done where they electrically stimulated the brachyridialis muscle while the biceps muscle were doing some sort of movements. And what you get is you get a suppression of the biceps brachy in that scenario. And it differs depending on whether you're in a pronated or a supinated position. So you can see that the central node system at the spinal level is capable. Now whether that's because it's been wired that way by the brain over a number of years or whether there's something else going on as a separate question. But, you know, again, there's complexities here that I don't really want to get bogged down in today because the purpose is more kind of addressing some of these more simplistic. So the next thing I'd like to move on to is this idea of neurochemical mashing and not applying or not being tested in high-effort situations. So let me just walk through this. First of all, addressing the criticism directly and then secondly, explaining why fundamentally doesn't really fit with how we understand physiology to work. So firstly, we do have a direct, and when I say direct, I mean, people who actually want to study neurochemical mashing. So the thing is, you can find what I call indirect studies across the entirety of exercise science, which are studies that weren't originally designed to measure neurochemical mashing, but they have actually done so by, you know, kind of not mistake, but just by virtue of the data that I've recorded. Direct studies, when why people actually sat down and go do muscle activations match with leverages? In other words, if I look at the movement or the isometric contraction, do the muscles that are regions of muscles that have best leverage get more activated than the muscles are regions of muscles that don't have best leverage? Now, there is a study that has measured 75% of maximum force, which is kind of strength training territory, maybe, I don't know, 12 writ max or so, maybe 15, depends on the movement, but you're in strength training territory with that, and it's one of the best validations of neurochemical mashing in human skeletal muscle, it's done in the deltoids, and it uses 75% to maximum force. So if you're going to say that high effort, you know, hasn't been tested, well, that's not true. If you want to say maximum effort hasn't been tested in a direct neurochemical mashing study, that's true, they haven't measured maximum effort, but they haven't measured pretty high efforts. In contrast, if you want to go to the indirect studies, whereas people have inadvertently, it's not the right word I was going for, because obviously you don't inadvertently take measurements, but they've inadvertently given, you know, kind of evidence for neurochemical mashing. It's basically where people have measured the voluntary activation or muscle activation in particular joint positions, and somebody else has got leverages and they've been able to kind of just put them over the top of each other. Now, there's a whole ton of maximum voluntary isometric contractions where people have tested things like glutes, hamstrings, there's a number of other muscles by elbow flexors, and you can literally map the leverage on top of the activation, you'll see that the leverage, where the leverage is high, for example, in the epic sensors, where the glutes have best leverage is in the contract position, they are by far and away more strongly activated in that contract position. Now, some people will point at one or two studies where the activation is slightly higher and a slightly flexed hip position, those studies are in a massive minority. Please don't cite those, that makes us, you know, the vast majority of studies show that glute max activation is maximum in an extended hip or even hyper extended hip position, and the leverage of the glute is by far and away greatest at that point as well. You do the same thing with hamstrings, they have greatest leverage of 45 degrees, and they have greatest activation of that position as well. So there's a number of cases where, in what I would call indirect study kind of evidence, calves are another great one. So, you know, solely us in the contract position, gastroc in the stretch position, again, where they have best leverage is, you can kind of just kind of keep going with these. So I would say that maximum life has been inadvertently tested because we do have the data to show that it does actually work, just nobody's done a single study to show that would happen. Now, that's addressing the criticism of face value, which is people saying, you know, neuroconocamaching hasn't been tested, or actually they tend to be a little bit sneaky and they go, we don't think it applies in maximum effort situations. Now, the reason they don't think it applies is because they don't actually understand what's happening in a maximum effort situation. I explain why. So if you ask them what they think is happening in a maximum effort situation, they will say that the body is activating everything that it can to maximize the system force output. Well, that's fundamentally untrue and you can instantaneously prove it's untrue. So I like these situations because people come at me with these arguments that they think are completely watertight and I can see absolutely massive holes in them because, you know, if you do the reading, you know, half as the other do works, then you can, you know, sort of piece these things together. The reason that there's a massive hole in this is because the brain doesn't use everything that it can in a maximum effort and that's easy to prove by just looking at the bilateral force deficit. You can literally go to the bilateral force deficit and you can see that if the brain is using two arms at the same time, you've got a lower level of motion at recruitment than you do if you're using one arms at time. Instantaneously showing you that you've got what's called a voluntary activation deficit in that two arm variation compared to the single arm variation and in fact, voluntary activation deficits exist in every single strength training movement that we do and the more muscle mass you have involved, the bigger that deficit is. You go down to exercises involving the quads and glutes and who knows what else. You're gonna see 20% deficits. You're gonna see a big chunk of motion. It's not being used. The reality is the brain is still going to try and maximize efficiency in that scenario because that's the way it actually will get you to the maximum talking that scenario in most cases. Now, I'll come onto an exception moment which we can talk about in a bit more detail but let's explain why that's another problem as well. But fundamentally, because the brain actually has a deficit to voluntary activation, you are still going to want to use the muscles and regions that have best leverage, you are not going to activate absolutely everything because you can't, you know, because ultimately, the maximum amount of motor unit recruitment that you can generate across all the muscles that you're using is determined by your maximum tolerable perception of effort, again, Marcora. So, we've got this scenario where we're limited by the effort perception. We're gonna try and piece together whatever muscles have the best leverage because it actually, we've got the best chance of getting us to maximum talk as well as being the most efficient thing that we're trying to do. So, it doesn't need to change its protocol from efficiency in a maximum effort scenario because it's most likely going to be the way that gets you to maximum talk anyway. Does that make sense? - It does, it does. Why did we evolve in a way that we are limited by effort or by essential motor command? Like, why can't we access all motor units? - So, the question that you're asking me is to explain how fatigue works. So, which is a big topic. Basically, the purpose of all fatigue mechanisms and super spinal central nervous system fatigue is what the Marcora Psychobiological Model of fatigue tells you in how it works. All fatigue mechanisms are designed to place limiters on how much energy we can burn through. I mean, that's fundamentally what fatigue mechanism is doing. If you look at, for example, you know, metabolite-related fatigue at the muscle fiber level is trying to slow down the rate of crossbridge binding. Well, that's trying to slow down the rate of ATP usage. That's what it's doing. - Do you have efficiency machines? - Well, it's slightly more than efficiency. It's a protection mechanism. So, what it's doing is it's trying to slow you down in the usage of your energy because if you were to burn through all of the available ATP, a muscle fibers would die, which is an extremely undesirable thing. outcome if you're being chased by a say with teeth tiger, because you would just be lying there on your back, you know, as it munches away at you. So ultimately we don't want that scenario, we want at least to be able to, you know, kind of balance this need for, you know, running away very quickly, at the same time, not catastrophically blowing up and ending up with no muscle fibers that are capable of doing a movement. So it's that very, very kind of interesting matter. Fundamentally, the way fatigue mechanisms work is as protective, kind of as sort of intervention in the movement that we do, is trying to slow us down, it's trying to stop us from using energy too quickly. And ultimately, you know, kind of matching is doing something very, very similar. It's trying to maximize the energy we do have for the output that we want to achieve. Again, all of this is basic kind of, you know, geared towards survival, which is what you would expect. You met a point, a couple of points ago about the indirect data. Now that's something I just want to highlight as well, because a lot of the time people who enter into these discussions, not just on your mechanical matching, but on anything muscle physiology, the argument typically that I see online will be talking about whatever the topic is. And then the person arguing will say, well, what's the study that shows that? And a lot of people don't realize when it comes to physiology and some of these topics is like what you said there with the indirect data is you actually have one study that shows step one, and then you have another study that shows step two. And a lot of the time they do piece together very well. And then you have other studies that have shown step one, other studies that are shown step two. And so it's often not as simple as here is one study that has done step one and step two. It's usually often it's separate studies. I just want to highlight that because I see people not understand that I think, well, no, obviously every single topic has to have been summarized in a singular study. And unfortunately, that's just not the way this stuff works. Absolutely. No, that's important to recognize. And I would add to that and say, ultimately, the easiest way to organize the material that you're working with and understand a lot about strength training is to find key physiological concepts that have been well tested and hold up under scrutiny. Now, because the high-perture research is in the popular fitness influencers that have science-based, you know, stuck to their names have persuaded a big chunk of fitness industry that numerical matching is a fad, it's a new thing, it's not, that doesn't change the fact that it's not that thing. It is actually a very well-established fundamental scientific principle that's been developed over a number of years, if not decades, by some incredibly good researchers, you know, and just because some fitness influencers didn't recognize it and so lost their, you know, kind of marbles when they saw it presented for first time and got really upset about it. That's irrelevant, you know. The fact is, it is a well-established principle, as is more core of psychological mobility and a bunch of other stuff. And if you start with those big rocks, you can actually, from that point, make some very clear assumptions that are not actually that shaky. So the difference between what I'm doing and what a lot of other people are doing is that I'm starting with fundamental physiology that's not the contentious to the people who understand it. A lot of other people are kind of going, well, you know, what about this idea and what you've just pulled out of your hat, and nobody takes that seriously in the area of research that deals with that thing. But you think it's relevant because, you know, you don't actually understand that there's a gigantic iceberg of information over here that you haven't taken into consideration. So we've got to start with, I think we start with these big principles and yes, you know, single studies are not going to give people the answers that they seek, doing the proper reading and understanding the shape of exercise science and where these big principles are and starting with those, I think will help them a lot and perhaps lead them to situation where they don't find themselves asking for single study, you know, kind of references for things that don't need single study references. So I've saved one of the most interesting and complex criticisms to last because I was hoping that if people dropped out by this point, it wouldn't matter because I find this one fascinating. I actually really love talking about this and people think that it's a slam dunk and it's absolutely not. So there is a single study floating around which used a musculoskeletal model, which they built using assumptions and some of those assumptions are not being rude, but they're shaky because the data isn't good. So it's not their fault. It's just that the data isn't good. So they've got data they're trying to, you know, kind of use to make a model and the data that they're using for, like, for example, you know, glute, the psychomellance is not is not good. So it's a difficult musculoskeletal model to defend if you know what you're looking at. And this model basically says that or showed that the biggest contribution of a glute to hip extension talk is not at zero, it's at 45 degrees. And essentially this is kind of this study is kind of being waived around as like, oh, this proves new and mechanical matching is not working or that new and mechanical matching has to take the length, tension, relationship into account when it's, you know, doing its thing in addition to leverages or, you know, instead of leverages. So I'm going to start just by setting the context, new mechanical matching has, as I say, 10 12 studies really well established pedigree of validation in a number of different contexts and number of different muscles. And it shows that leverage is the thing that determines where the brain sounds activation. So straight away, please don't wave a single musculoskeletal model at me with dodgy assumptions and expect me to take it seriously when I've got this enormous body of data over here with a very established principle. Secondly, the idea that the brain would choose to use the length tension relationship in its calculations of which muscle to activate to its joint angle is impossible. And it's impossible because of the way sarcomerogenesis works. So again, what we're doing now is we're saying, let's go and look at the sarcomerogenesis literature and see whether this idea that the brain uses the length tension relationship to determine the muscle to activate a particular joint angle can possibly be true. So this is what I always do. I look at the neighboring areas of literature that are very well established and I go, does this actually make sense in the context of the claim that's being made. Now sarcomerogenesis literature tells you that if you activate muscle fibers repeatedly in stretched positions, they add sarcomers, right? That's not contentious. If you activate muscle fibers repeatedly at short lengths, they start removing sarcomers. Okay. Well, these two observations, which are absolutely easy to validate, you can go and check this. I mean, I've got like FAQs on this, but this is not controversial stuff really. I mean, I'm sure you can find somebody out there who disagree with it, but that's the internet for you. Now, if you now think about this, right? If the brain used the length tension relationship to determine which muscle length to activate to muscle at, it would never be able to create sarcomerogenesis and it would never be able to create loss of sarcomers because it would only ever activate muscle fibers on the plateau of the length tension relationship. So you'd never get sarcomerogenesis and you'd never get loss of sarcomers. It would just never happen because you'd always be activating exactly on the plateau. And that's not what we see. We regularly see sarcomergenesis happening or the opposite, we get loss of sarcomers. And that's because what the brain is doing is activating a muscle according to leverage. And that isn't going to correlate perfectly with the length tension relationship. Now, what then happens is that your length tension relationship will move and it'll move actually, ironically, to exactly the place where the muscle has best left, because that's the place where you're up. The muscle length that you're repeatedly activating those muscle fibers at. So you end up with the migration of your length tension plateau towards the place where the muscle has best ability, which is incidentally why immediately when I saw the study showing that the group wasn't activated or didn't have a length tension relationship, which is maximized at zero. It was maximized at 45. I'm meeting here. It can possibly be true. If you look at the way that muscles work, they will move their length tension relationships to the point where the muscle has the best leverage. You can see this in the brachyridialis. It's the only elbow flexor, which has a different length tension relationship from the others. All the others have an ascending limb followed by a plateau. The brachyridialis, which is activated at short lengths, has a plateau followed by ascending limb, because it doesn't get activated normally in the stretched position. So it doesn't create sarcomergenesis, so it doesn't move its plateau. All the others move their plateaus to the end position, because that's where they repeatedly got activated in accordance with their leverage being greatest in the stretched position, relatively speaking. Do the same thing with the gastroc, same thing with the solos. You've got leverage better for the solos in the short position. It tends to have a plateau there. If you look at the gastroc, it has a plateau in the stretched position. This is a really, really consistent pattern. I think it's very, very interesting to see how the sarcomergenesis literature shows us exactly why neuromacanacomatching is working the way it is, and it can't possibly take the length tension relationship into account. So I said I'd come back to this idea that sometimes force might not be maximized, sorry, joint talks might not be maximized by the neuromacanacomatching principle the way it works the moment. Yes, theoretically, you can have a situation where for a period of time, the length tension relationship will give you a bigger total joint tour, because it's giving you more force to different joints angle from the one where the brain is activating the muscle according to the leverage. But what will happen is your length tension relationship will migrate over time to coincide with the place where the brain is activating the muscle according to leverage, and you'll end up in the place where your maximizing talk production as well as maximizing efficiency. So that's why I said 10, 20 minutes ago that you actually get to the same place with neuromacanacomatching maximizing talk as well as maximizing efficiency in a maximal effort of leveraging the contraction, eventually you do, because what happens is you repeatedly activate the solcomers until you add or subtract solcomers to get the length tension plateau happening at the same place as your leverage is best. That's just how physiology has to work. because that's how the muscle fibres were responding to being activated at that muscle length. If you have a scenario where you say to me, "No, we still think the length tension relationship determines where the brain activates the, you know, which joint angle the brain is activating the muscle at," then you've got to explain to me how sarcomeregenesis and sarcomere loss work because you can't, because they can't work the way that we think they do, if that's what you're arguing. You're essentially creating an insistent that we currently believe with working, you're creating a circular reference, you're creating a circular reference because the brain is using information to decide where to activate the muscle and it's then changing the muscle length, sorry the number of sarcomeregenesis, based on that information. So it actually can't possibly work and I think this is one of those important things that again, if you start with fundamental aspects of physiology and you put them in a sort of a row and you go, "These are things I know are true where I'm very confident are true." Then when you look at these studies that come out and people, "Oh, you've got to throw all the numerical matching out now because this single study, you know, can be a break." You know, even given the fact that it's a single study, even given the fact that the data input are by necessity a little bit shaky, even given all of that, it still doesn't work because you're trying to violate fundamental physiological principles. So save that one to the last because it is the most complicated. I think I've got a post going out on it tomorrow, actually that hopefully sets all of this out, that will help people understand if they want to look at more detail. I say tomorrow, but it'll be probably about the same time when the podcast goes out just because of the way that that works. Is that making sense? I know it's complex, but is that making sense? Is that, I mean, just predicated on that glued study? Yeah. Do people make it is? Yeah, okay. Interesting. Well, it's the one that is the only piece of evidence that has been provided. Interestingly, in these discussions, the requirement upon me to provide evidence seems to be very high and the requirement to people who make things up seems to be very low. So, for example, you've got people who go, "We don't think the mechanical matching is relevant because we think line of, you know, kind of direction and muscle fibers is important." I'm like, "Do you have a single study? Do you have one, one study that shows anything that is possible to connect? The choice that the brain is making or the choice that the mental nervous system is making, for which muscle to activate, and which region of muscle to activate, and the fiber direction. Pick it. Nothing. Because you've got absolutely zero. There is nothing. It doesn't exist." That's, I think that's really interesting. People can go, "Oh, well, we don't think it's new." I'm like, "What data have you got?" It's crazy. It really is. It's like this mismatch. They're like, "Oh, no. We need you to provide 17,000 references for every single point that we've got. We've got nothing to justify our unicorns that we're pretending exist." I'm like, honestly, it is very silly. Just to come, a quick comment on line of action, line of pull, line of muscle fiber direction. So, technically, finishes are really messy here because if you look at the literature, you'll see reference to line of action or line of pull. Now, strictly speaking, line of action, which can also be written as line of pull, is part of the way that we can calculate the moment time. So, if you take the joint center and you've got the line of action, then basically your leverage is the distance between those two things. That's just a calculation method that is often used. Now, if you've got a complex muscle, you're going to need to do that many, many, many, many, many times to get an idea of what the whole average moment times of the muscle look like or the lines of action and the muscle look like. That's totally fine. You can do that. If you've got enough elastic bands, you're going to need a couple of hundred, but you can do that. It's valid. One is not, but the more complex muscle, the more elastic bands that you need. That's not the same thing as fiber direction, because fiber direction is literally just looking at the direction that the fiber's running. Now, people confuse these things and often the influencers will confuse them and they'll go, oh, well, you know, line of pull is this and then they'll show you a picture of muscle fibers running in a certain direction. Like, hang on a minute, you're confusing fiber direction with line of pull of the muscle from whatever, you know, origin it's got to whatever insertion. Now, fiber direction is not related to line of action. It can do different things because of pennation angles and they even change during the muscular contraction. So it's not the same thing. So yes, there is a relationship between line of action or line of pull and the moment time, although again, you need lots of them to make it work. Not the same thing as fiber direction, but you can have situations where fiber's running in the direction that you think is very advantageous and it actually doesn't really make a lot of sense because they don't have a very big moment time. And as I say, there's nothing connecting fiber direction to the way that the brain organizes activation during an exercise. So if you've got a fitness influence and they're talking about line of action or line of pull, you're going to need to just look at the pictures they're using or the descriptions that they're giving and trying to establish what they mean by that. If they mean the literature definition of line of action, then essentially they're saying the same things to me because they're saying moment arm, just it's an indirect, it's the other part of the triangle. Geometrically, it's not, I need different from what I'm saying really. I just measuring a different part of the triangle, but if they're starting to draw pictures and show you directions of muscle fiber, you know, lines of directions that they're going in, then that's not the same thing. And you've got to kind of realize that they've confused those two things and that's that's problematic. So yeah, technically line of action is going to fit into the same geometrical puzzle that moment on does so they're saying the same thing. The fiber direction does not. And you're saying that if you look at fiber orientation or fiber direction, there isn't any evidence to support that that is in somehow. Well, it's not even there's no evidence. I don't think anybody ever even studied it. I don't think there's even a study. I mean, I'd love for somebody to prove me wrong and send me something that's been done. I've missed because I mean, I think that's one of those weird things that when you've read as much as I've read of the literature, you know, like the joy of finding something new over overwhelmed a lot by quite a lot, the embarrassment of not having read that particular thing. But I would just be really cool. And I think that that's definitely the case here that I'd love to see something. I think that everybody who is, I think everybody who is referencing a fiber orientation, that's the terminology I've been searching for. Everybody's referencing that is confusing the terminology line of action with that in the literature. They think they're referring to one when they're referring to the other. And that's an important distinction. Is that all okay? It does. I mean, ultimately listening to it all, you're like, well, there's, I guess I went into this podcast expecting there might be some arguments that at least held water. And it feels that most of them are either terminological. Yes, issues. Or simply not looking outside this scope at all. Two things like fatigue or just looking outside that immediate literature that that person's familiar with. And really walking through it, it's like, well, hang on, there's not really any challenge to any of this at this point, is there? No, I mean, I think I would add one more issue, which is that some people, I don't understand what Numeric cutting machine is trying to do. They think it's trying to maximize force, not efficiency. And therefore, they misunderstand the philosophical kind of underpinnings of what the purpose of it is. The evolutionary purpose of it is to maximize efficiency, not to maximize instantaneous talk app. And I think you end up maximizing talk app, but just because of the way all the other physiology aligns. But it's not what it sets out to do in the first instance. And I think there's a misunderstanding there. And I think what that causes people to do is lock on to the length tension relationship and go, well, I must always be working on the plateau of the length tension relationship. Well, you are going to end up doing that. Honestly, you are. But that's not what the brain sets out to do in the first instance. It just happens as a byproduct of activating the muscle, a particular muscle length. And again, not understanding the stalk emergency literature, which seems to be a particular speciality of high-perture research is to ignore that literature, because they obsessed with stretch mediator to virtually not being that. Then I think, again, that will for blindness to that literature source, I think, has caused them issues here as well. At the end of the day, this is a series of issues, but I think where we are in terms of understanding the model and how it relates to the rest of physiology is actually pretty strong. The thing that I'd like to kind of mention just at the end, and that's because a couple of my mentorship clients have messaged me saying, please, will you address this? Is a couple of practical points? And that is, how do we how do we use this in practice? And what happens under certain situations if I've got this data and that data and the other data? So question number one is, if I've got a number of muscles that are particular joint, and one of them is a small muscle, like a great example of this would be the posterior delt in a exercise, and it has amazing leverage for the joint action. So posterior delt has amazing leverage for sagittal plane pulling, so shoulder movement in that sense to plane pulling downwards. Now, people kind of get worked up about, well, okay, but I'm training lab there. Why is what's happening? What does that mean? You know, how do I understand this? Well, basically, even kind of a matching will look for the best, most efficient way of producing the movement, so it'll start and go, oh yeah, great, fantastic, posterior delt has amazing leverage, and it'll send a whole chunk of activation there. But obviously, small muscle, you can then carry on and recruit a whole load of other motifs and other places. And actually, there'll be situations where there'll be some motifs of the lats that have better leverage than some motifs of the posterior delt, so you get a switching over between those two at some point. But fundamentally, yes, the brain will prioritize the posterior delts out of the leverage. Now, subsequently to this, people get confused about the terminology prime mover. And there we go, which is that mean the posterior delt is the prime mover, and like, stop. And here we're going to go at you is telling you how the brain decides where to allocate, you know, your activation in the next size. the term. The terminology prime mover is telling you as a biomechanist what's doing the most work. Those things are not the same. So if I've got a really large muscle and this is going to be very difficult to try and get through to people, I think, if I've got a really large muscle, then yes, if that muscle has worse leverage, like the lat does compared to the posterior deltoid, the brain will start preferring posterior deltoid and then it will move on to the parts of the lats that it can do in that situation. The lat is still the prime mover from a biomechanical point of view, but that doesn't mean that lat is getting higher activation in the posterior deltoid, because it's not. So it's called the prime mover because in terms of its contribution to talk, it's large because it just fundamentally is a big muscle and biomechanically that you can't get around that. But from a high-perchard point of view, that doesn't matter. That's why I say to people, if you're only interested in a hypertrophy, just remove the words prime mover from your vocabulary. Well, that's exactly what I was saying. Why would you say that? Absolutely. Don't use that, exactly. Don't use that. That's what you're creating, ask closely to a model and you want to understand for some purpose what muscle is contributing most to that joint. Maybe you're in rehab and you want to know, for this person to be able to do that movement, how much of this muscle do I need and amateur? Yeah, fine. Great. No problem. You can use the words prime mover because they're meaningful to you, but if you're looking high-perchard without useless, they don't do anything and yet people will carry on using them and they'll keep saying, well, the brain looks at it and it sees it's a big muscle and it stops, no, stop, it doesn't do any of those things. You're making stuff up, and people say to me, well, the brain prefers the latina in a lap pull down or in a row because it's a bigger muscle, but you're talking rubbish. There's no data that suggests that it does that at all, it literally making stuff up. Now, the brain picks stuff based on leverage. What Neuron Kanukamatchin shows, we've got a whole series of studies doing, you know, just because talking heads on the internet say that that's not true, doesn't mean that it's not true. You know, I've got the citations, I can't show you. So it's like, importantly, prime mover is not a useful concept. Yes, the brain is going to pick a muscle that has best leverage even if they're small. So if you could get, so say you've got, let's use the example you just gave there, you're doing the Rome, we're talking about posterior deltima, talking about latas, well, if you were to identify all the motor units that can be involved in that movement and then let's say you color coded them to posterior deltima to lat, what we would see is that the ones that color coded to posterior deltima are largely going to be used earlier, referentially, in that movement. And it's, it's almost like a, it's the same principle in essence as, like, henomen size principle. Like there's, we're just talking about in what order are these motor units being used? And then what you're going to see is all their posterior deltima units that are color coded yellow, they're going to be used earlier because, like you said, they've got better leverage part, they're going to be used up quicker, more quickly than the ones for lats, which are then going to make up a large chunk of our, our colored chart there. That doesn't mean that the lats have better leverage, it simply means that they're going to be contributing more. And it doesn't mean the latas is recruited preferentially because it's big. This is what happens, you see, people go, no, I need to find a way to reconcile the fact that this, you know, the lat is more important to me in this exercise, no, no, it doesn't work like that. You know, it's literally a very simple, single principle. There's so many mistakes that are being made online based on this exact concept. So I'm hoping that people are hearing what it is, in fact, that is being said here. And I'm just going to ask you a couple more questions around it. So you've talked about obviously issues with maximal recruitment and you've just talked here about how the posterior deltima in this exercise has, you know, greatest leverage. Is that mean that if you were to do an exercise in which the lat was not as involved is a posterior delt getting a higher level of recruitment than it is in this exercise? So in practical terms, what you're saying is we compare a, like, a real adult fly with a, uh, sexual row, sexual row. That's a really, really cool question. I think I think we probably would see at the most granular level, yes, that you're getting a little bit less recruitment in the posterior delt. And the reason for that, though, is because, and this is going to lead on to the next topic that we mentioned in this section, is that I think there will be parts of the posterior deltima that don't have better leverage than big chunks of the lat. Yeah, I wondered. And that's, that's really where it comes down to is the color code things that I've talked about. Yeah. You get some yellow posterior deltima that's sprinkled higher up, but that's, that's physiology being messy again. Yep. You know, so. But the fact that you're using an exercise that fundamentally has a capacity to achieve a high level of motor recruitment in the working muscles that you're using, I think you probably get more in the real adult fly. I don't think it'd be a lot more, but I think you probably would get at the very tiniest granular level you would get it. Yep. Yep. And just to really rate a point, which I think you've made anyway, but again, I think you've misunderstood, we're not saying that therefore in the sagittal row, once the posterior delt is, is, I don't want to use the term maxed out, but ultimately that's kind of what I'm saying here. It doesn't mean that you then can't move on to recruiting more of the lats, right? Because people seem to think, you know, the posterior delt is the limiting factor here. It's now maxed. But again, that's confusing terminologies that people are going, because I'm, I'm now assigning the role of prime mover to the posterior deltima, I'm assigning this role. Yes. You're fundamentally trying to apply your existing framework for how you thought exercise was controlled into a new framework, which is correct. Your old one was not correct. And you're trying to do a hagelian dialectic and smash the two together, and you can't do that because that's not what we're talking about. You know, ultimately, you've tickled me philosophically there. Well, I kind of know that you're interested in that stuff, so I kind of like to throw it in occasionally. But yeah, that's what was happening. People are trying to smash the two things together. And that's just not going to work, you know, because you're dealing with two totally discrete systems, both of which are trying to explain how, you know, the brain chooses which I must have to use in the exercise and the process it goes through. And you can't because they're separate systems. So, you know, you've got to just start with near my kind of matching and go, what does near my kind of matching tell me is going to happen? And then walk through it. And you end up with, yeah, most of the part that posterior deltima is going to activate the impreference to most of the lab. Sure. Does that mean that the posterior deltima is limiting? Of course, it doesn't. You know, you limit to buy everything that you've got available until you hear the maximum tolerable perception of effort. Now, obviously, then the extension of that would be to say, well, if you talk out the necessary or the requirement of the posterior delt in that movement, then there's more central mode of command available for the lats. And so, obviously, we see people following that train of thoughts thinking, well, if we can isolate or buy us a muscle region without more muscle that we don't want to train in that exercise being used, obviously, we can get more recruitment. Absolutely. So, yes, that is also true. Well, that's just like going from a, going from a pull, a, like a row or a pull down to a pullover, isn't it? I mean, that's the concept. Yes. Yes. And I don't think I have to talk too many contentious. I mean, like, I think bodybuilders deliberately choose those exercises to focus on those muscle reasons. I think when people say, oh, no, you're wrong about, you know, kind of singled your deck size is involving higher levels of recruitment and the single joint muscle compared to the multi joint. Are you, are you living on the same planet as me? Yeah, it's like, obviously, I think some people just like to disagree with you for the sake of disagree with you. Now, you say there's another point you wanted to make on the second, the second question I've been asked by my mentorship clients to address on this topic is what happens if you have two muscles, which have very similar leverages to each other, but one has a bigger leverage than the other. And in another scenario, you have two muscles with very different leverages from one of them. So, what they're asking me is, does the magnitude of difference between the two leverages make a difference or is it just like binary off and on? So if a muscle has better leverage than the other muscle, does that mean that, yep, straight to way, the muscle with better leverage automatically gets all the activation and the other one doesn't get any and conversely, you know, is it a great sort of a great scale or starting scale? Well, I've kind of answered that question already in what I said about the posterior delt and the lap, because if you have two muscles that have on paper, like massively different leverages, I mean, a nice example of this would be like something like the, you know, as I know, he said, it's a nice example and then he kind of changed his mind halfway through. No, you can see some pretty big differences between the lower and upper regions of the lap in Sagittall and Fronterplane pulling. You can't like sort of quite substantial. You can see some pretty differences between the anterior and the middle delt and obviously in Fronter and Sagittall playing pressing, but, you know, those kind of big differences and then you can see other smaller differences as well, like maybe between regions that are pecked. So the question is then, does the magnitude of the difference make an impact on how much of one region gets activated at preference? Do you know? Well, it does because what you're looking at is the average. So if you've got two muscle regions and they have massively different average leverages, then what you're saying is that the majority, if you kind of draw a histogram, the majority of your muscle is going to fall in that category of having that leverage and the majority of the other muscle, the other muscle region is going to fall in the category of having much worse leverage. If you have two muscles that have on paper are similar average leverages, one is starting more than the other. You're going to find your histograms overlap, your distribution is overlap. So essentially, you've got a distribution of muscle fibers that, you know, kind of maybe you're going to see some popping up earlier and some popping up later. So the question is already answered in the sense that, yes, the magnitude difference between the two average leverages will change how much of one muscle gets activated before the other because it changes how much of one muscle has better leverage than how much of the other muscle. So this is why, when I'm having arguments with people and they're saying, "All of the lat is all activated during a frontal plane exercise and all of the lat is activated during a such a plane exercise." the fact that that statement is immediately verifiably untrue because the botanetractivation deficit exists. You know, it's like if a botanetractivation deficit exists, then you can't make that statement straight away. You can't say that all of the lies activated in anything because it is not. So the fact that botanetractivation exists means straight away you've got that some muscle fire was not being activated. The question is, is it the same muscle fire was not being activated in the front of plane versus the side of the plane? Well, if you look at the difference in leverages between those regions, you can immediately see that leverage difference is huge. So there must be differences in which muscle fires are being jettisoned. Essentially, what the brain is doing inadvertently is saying which muscle fibers the target access to are the most useless possible muscle virus for this action and couldn't possibly help him. It might actually pull me in the opposite direction. And I'm going to push those to the top end of the sequence and hopefully never activate them. You know, that's what it's doing. A really nice example of this is the gluteus medius because you've literally got antagonist functions in the same muscle group. You know, it's like you've literally got a part of the muscle that will do that external rotation and the part of the muscle that do external rotation, internal external. So the anterior will be internal and posterior to external. You can't activate those at the same time because you would literally be producing an antagonist who kind of forced couple with its own inside its own muscle. So at what layer, what level is this happening? Is it happening at a region level, at a motor unit level? I think it's a motor unit level, so essentially we think in terms of anatomy drawing, don't we? We're like, oh, you know, that's a muscle brain, brain doesn't work like that. It thinks it does a motor unit because that's what it's controlling. It's like you could imagine the brain is like a pianist with, you know, fingers able to go on keys and each key is a is a motor unit, you know, it doesn't think in terms of muscles in terms of chords, it thinks in terms of, you know, motor unit. So the question you were just answering in terms of averaging the leverage was, that was in reference to if different fibers have different, no, in reference to if you have two muscles or muscle regions and they have massively different leverages, but then in another example, you have two muscles and they have very similar leverages, but one is definitely still bigger than the other. Does it mean that those two situations produce the same outcome? Right. Like you're just going to use one region first and then the other as opposed to the laughing them out. Because in you've provided additional information to help people understand that which is that the brain doesn't see muscle regions, it sees motor units because you could argue then, well, yeah, ultimately we're just looking at a motor unit level. Yeah, I didn't even realize that that would be an argument or a confusion in that topic. I don't think it's interesting. I think it's an attempt for clarity in programming because what it means is that if you're looking for exercises that really do target a particular muscle region, you really do want to look for those big leverage differences. It's not sufficient to say, well, it does have, you know, two millimeters of better leverage and like, well, no, you don't want to do that. You want to maximize your opportunity. So that's why incidentally when people are looking for a exercise what you need to target a muscle, what you need is a set of training adjustments that you can make. I run through these in various places, but it's like, you don't just want to look at joint angles. Some people go, well, just use different joint angles, we'll just train them up everything and to contract them, everything into a straight position and therefore I'll cover all my bases. Doesn't work like that because sometimes you've got joint rotation effects, like we're talking about with a calf, like we're talking about with the elbow flexes where you've got pronation and supination. And so you can introduce these other factors that make a difference, peanut motion, obviously a massive one when you're talking about shoulder stuff, you know, totally different effects when you're working. I find it funny actually, all this fuss about the last, not being different between frontal and sagittal. And it's like, nobody thinks that about the deltas, it's like, oh, no, no, no, the deltas are different, you know, okay, sure, okay, you know, so actually very similar leverages between the delts and between the different regions of the last, but that's beside the point. So yeah, it's a very interesting programming point where you have to say, well, okay, how can I maximize the differences? I'm not just going to use range of motion to push things towards the back of your rear shoulders, I'm not just going to train contributors, I'm going to use pronated grip as well because I'm forcing as much as I can, you know, on to the scale, I'm tipping the scale as much as I can to make sure that as much activation goes towards that muscle. Yeah, that's a really good point. In case people haven't followed that. So it would be common to say in the case you just gave their bracket radialis compared to biceps bracket, it'd be common to say, well, if that movement is hardest at the top, then that's naturally going to be more bracket radialis, right? But you can make it even more bracket radialis by using a pronated grip at the same time. Exactly. So again, if we use our color analogy, you're going to see sure by making it higher to the top, there's going to be more of the bracket radialis colored mochi units early on. But this is going to be some biceps bracket if you're doing that in a supernated position. And you're saying, well, how unless also do this pronated, and now we're going to see more of those bracket radialis colored mochi units earlier on. And this is important because, and I've been guilty of this, using terminology of saying, well, we want to train that region where it has best relative leverage, just slightly best relative leverage. As you pointed out, it's as best relative leverage as you can possibly make it. Yeah, absolutely. So, and that's why I've gone through, and there's an FAQ on this precise topic, I've literally gone through and gone, what adjustments can you make to an exercise that will do that. And there's four or five of them, you know, and you can go through and you can sort of say, well, can I, can I do this? You know, because sometimes a joint won't let you do it, you know, you can't, you can't do, you know, sort of rotation or stuff for certain joints, because there's only one plane of motion to work in, you know, so you can't start changing plane of motion. You can't start, you know, moving positions of proximal distal joints, because there's nothing to move. And so you've got to kind of go through the possibilities that are available to you. And sometimes there's more possibilities available than others, but generally speaking, all of those things as much will have an effect, it's not just about one thing, not just, that's why you can't just say, well, we're just train everything at one end and everything at the other end and, you know, shorten and lengthened and that, that would do it, and it weren't, because you've got other things that work as well. Yeah, yeah, yeah, because that is also something that is obviously commonly repeated. I just do a short and position, like contract position, a length and position. And the way I look at that is I think, well, without better information, that generally covered some of the bases. That was probably the best someone could do at that point in time, but with more information that doesn't, like, it's not the best thing. Yeah, I mean, I'm sympathetic to that view, but equally, you know, if bodybuilders were already using pronated grip, you know, kind of to target the Brachioridialis in the 1950s and before that, it kind of doesn't really, if you're, if you're kind of sort of rule of thumb or your kind of training recommendation that you're kind of devising, you know, length and a shorten, there's best way to cover everything. If that doesn't cover stuff that silver-air bodybuilders already knew, then I don't think you really should be, you know, kind of trumpeting it from the rooftops, because it's not better than what we've already got, you know, because really our contention is that, you know, silver-air bodybuilding programs are better than pretty much anything that you can find on the internet today. They are, you know, literally just by looking at physiology, you can see that they are. And as I said at the beginning, and I hopefully argued reasonably well, that you would expect them to be, because they're not confused by the confounding effect of antibiotics. So, you know, I think we've got, anyway, we've got the number of factors that you can use to change exercises and you can make use of the entire toolbox, not just joint-tangle range of motion. I think that's what we're saying here. I think hopefully that has been a nice overview of exactly what it is we're talking about when we say neuro-mechanical matching, why a lot of these kind of arguments I guess that are being thrown around are generally a miscommunication of someone not understanding what it is they're actually talking about. Is there anything further to this topic you wanted to finish on? No, I think probably already gone way over in terms of detail and time that I was hoping to kind of present today, but yes, I agree with you. I think we've covered the basics, we've covered the major common criticisms. I've probably missed a couple, but you know, if you're listening to this and you think, oh, I didn't answer my neuro-mechanical matching question, I'm sorry, please ask me in my Instagram questions, I tend to do them on a Friday or Saturday, you know, just ask me and I will do my best to answer it there or if there are enough of them, then we could even do another episode, but I think we'll probably be able to pick them up as we go along. And my hope is that when the conversation does come up over neuro-mechanical matching that now there will be a whole lot of people in those comments sections who will be able to point to some of this stuff and be like, well, no, that's actually not what it's about or you've missed this bit or this. And because I'm seeing that more and more often, where people, influencers, potentially talking about topics that maybe they are misunderstanding and just the not often not even coaches, these are just everyday people who have an interest in this stuff, actually able to go there and be like, well, actually, no, that's this is what you're missing there. So I love seeing that. So you guys who actually interested and passionate about this stuff, you guys rock, but hopefully this has been, I think, like you said, this was a longer episode for us, but there was a lot in this topic and I think it's valuable doing some of these longer episodes to actually walk people through what can be a more complex topic. So thank you guys, it's you, and if you made it, what an hour and 40 minutes Jesus has been a longer episode, thank you. If you made it to this point, and hopefully you will join us for another probably shorter episode soon.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The episode discusses a silver era workout plan from Superior, founder of Iron Man magazine, which emphasizes adding exercises over removing them as lifters progress.
  2. The advanced beginner plan includes barbell curls, reverse curls, overhead presses, rows, and a unique isometric chest pull, with three sets and specific foot positioning for sit-ups and side bends.
  3. The plan features high volume for elbow flexors and overemphasizes biceps and shoulder movements, leading to concerns about imbalanced muscle development.
  4. A key deficiency is the lack of lat pull training; the program relies heavily on sagittal plane movements, neglecting transverse plane work crucial for back development.
  5. The isometric chest pull is noted as a potentially effective exercise with functional similarities to a pullover, though it is used twice and may not be universally applicable.
  6. The discussion introduces the Neuro-mechanical Matching Principle, a neuroscience-based hypothesis stating that the CNS selects muscles with the best mechanical leverage to maximize efficiency, not joint torque.
  7. Critics often misunderstand the principle, claiming it’s fringe or untested, but multiple studies in humans—including in deltoids, glutes, and hamstrings—validate its application in real movements.
  8. The principle aligns with evolutionary efficiency; the CNS minimizes effort and energy by favoring muscles with optimal leverage, and this is supported by physiological evidence like Marcora’s model of effort perception.

Summary:

The episode explores a vintage strength training plan from the 1950s by Superior, founder of Iron Man magazine, highlighting its progressive structure where exercise volume increases with experience. The plan includes a mix of barbell and dumbbell movements, such as curls, presses, rows, and an isometric chest pull, designed to be performed three times per week. While comprehensive, it reveals significant imbalances—especially a lack of lat work and excessive focus on elbow flexors—indicating a deficiency in back development and muscular balance.

The discussion then shifts to the Neuro-mechanical Matching Principle, a neuroscience concept stating that the central nervous system selects muscles with the best mechanical leverage to maximize efficiency, not joint torque. This principle is supported by multiple human studies and explains how the body reduces effort and energy use during movement. Critics often dismiss it as fringe, but evidence shows it applies in strength training contexts, including high-effort scenarios.

The core insight is that the CNS prioritizes efficiency through leverage, driven by evolutionary need to conserve energy. This principle, rooted in movement biology and supported by physiological models like Marcora’s, provides a clear, evidence-based framework for understanding muscle activation, making it a foundational concept in modern exercise science.

FAQs

It is a hypothesis stating that the central nervous system selects muscles with the best mechanical leverage to produce movement, maximizing torque for the least muscle force input, thus improving efficiency.

It is not new; it originated in the 1970s as 'functional differentiation' and was formally named in 2007–2009. It has been validated in numerous studies on human skeletal muscles, including strength training areas.

Yes, research shows the CNS prefers muscles with greater mechanical advantage (leverage) because they produce more torque with less muscle force, leading to more efficient movements.

It does not aim to maximize joint torque. Instead, it prioritizes efficiency—achieving the greatest torque with the least muscle force—by selecting muscles with optimal leverage.

The CNS perceives effort during muscle activation. Muscles with better leverage require less force, resulting in lower effort perception, which aligns with the principle of efficiency and energy conservation.

Yes, studies in strength training (e.g., 75% max force) and isometric contractions show that muscles with best leverage are more activated, even under high effort, indicating the principle applies in real-world training.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.