011 Why the idea that a single exercise can train the whole muscle and “bias” a region is false
from Hypertrophy Past and Present
1h 6m 28s
This episode explores the physiological basis of exercise-specific muscle stimulation, challenging a common fitness myth that any exercise can train all regions of a muscle equally. Drawing on historical silver era bodybuilding plans—particularly one from Period Radar in 1955—the discussion reveals a sophisticated understanding of muscle fiber recruitment. The arm specialisation routine illustrates how exercises like leaning forward curls and high-elbow triceps extensions target distinct muscle regions, such as the brachioradialis and triceps long head, through unique fiber activation. This is not merely theoretical; it aligns with the concept of voluntary activation deficits, where the brain cannot fully recruit all motor units during maximal effort, leading to exercise-specific fiber recruitment patterns. As a result, different exercises activate non-overlapping fiber subsets. When programming, this means muscles trained only once per week (e.g., in a full-body ABC format) suffer atrophy in uniquely activated fibers, leading to suboptimal hypertrophy. The evidence from maintenance studies—where long-term training with low frequency shows no growth—directly contradicts claims that such programs are effective. For advanced lifters, who have growth capacity capped in oxidative fibers, this becomes especially critical. While beginners may benefit from varied routines due to greater growth potential, the core principle remains: maximizing hypertrophy requires consistent, targeted stimulation of all fiber groups. The episode concludes that training programs must move beyond superficial complexity to embrace a physiology-based model where exercise variation is meaningful only when it creates distinct fiber activation, not just perceived targeting. This refutes influencer claims of region-specific targeting within a single exercise, which is physiologically impossible. Ultimately, the episode advocates for programs that prioritize fiber overlap and frequency, ensuring continuous stimulation across the entire muscle.
Hello everyone. Welcome back to another episode of high-perture fee pass and present.
Thank you everyone for subscribing and listening, commenting, asking us questions.
I mentioned last week that we boast Chris and I do Q&As every week and we're always
interested in feedback and questions and even potential topics that you guys are finding
can maybe be confusing at this point or you want us to cover. And I did actually
have some really interesting feedback from people over the last week as well.
So thank you guys for doing that. Chris, how are you today?
I'm doing well. Thank you, Jake. Yeah, yeah, not too bad at all. Settling in, everything is going well.
Awesome. So we have a big episode planned today. There's
he firstly cover. So I'm not going to waste any time. I'm going to jump straight into the plan.
I want to talk about and then we're going to cover a very important topic I would say.
Now this is, I know I say this every week and I always say, oh, it's a unique plan. It's a different
plan. This is actually quite a different plan to the plan we've talked about so far. And it's
actually like a whole type of plan that we haven't covered at all. And that's a specialisation
plan. So in the silver era, they did do specialisations. So they would do some phases where they'll
focus on a particular muscle and maybe they'll do that for six weeks to depend on the person
and how they're programming it. The way that those specialisation phases generally looked
was quite different how we might see those phases or plans today. So nowadays, we talk a lot
about, okay, there's a muscle you want to focus on. Maybe you put a start of the program or
get a maybe you whatever add some different exercises. So that muscle, whatever it might be,
typically when you look at these silver era plans, what they actually did is they kind of like
assumed the rest of the body. They said, okay, everything else, you kind of just do what you're
normally doing. You do the standard. Everyone knew what the standard, you know, your barbell plan was
or the standard myelope plan or whatever it was. They're like, look, you just do your standard
full body stuff. And you take out all of the exercises that affect the muscle, your prioritising
or specialising on. You take that stuff out and you add this in instead. That was usually the way
they did it. So what I want to tell you guys about today is an arm specialisation coming from
period radar. I don't think we've talked about any period stuff yet. I'm sure we'll talk about
them a lot more in the future, but he was a very influential person in the silver era especially
alongside some of the stuff that the weeders were doing. There's a lot of politics that was going
down with Hoffman and weed at the time. And period, actually, he wrote several books on bodybuilding
and he wrote a whole lot of plans on like dumbbell only bodybuilding and barbell only bodybuilding
and he actually came up with quite a lot of, I guess, specialisation methods and like sort of
advanced methods. And we're going to talk about some of these in the future because some of them
are quite funky. They're quite interesting. He did a lot of work popularising like a lot of
rest pause type training and what they used to call like more breathing type which was kind of more
rest pause anyway. But this was from one of these books in 1955. You know early on, you know,
where arguably at this point there are some might be hitting the scene in this sort of these
couple of years, 9 and 54. There was maybe some dabbling, probably going to do a whole lot in the
9 and 58, 9 and 59 is where there was more widespread use. So, you know, this being published in 55,
I'm pretty confident that these methods would have certainly been used by naturals and there's not
really any doubt in my mind there. So, without further ado, this is an arms specialisation phase
remembering that you're adding this on top of your normal full body stuff. And, you know, one more point
I actually want to make is sometimes what they would say is if there was too much, what you could
actually do is do your arms work on other days. So, you would do your rest of your full body
Monday and then Tuesday might do your arms stuff. So, this jumps back to a podcast that we've
already covered when we did remind me of the mind me of the bodybuilder's name. I think it was a
crash, we're talking about it. Yes, Clancy Ross. So, we talked about that and we explained
essentially how people were splitting their three-day week routines for body routines into a
six-day week up below a split by essentially taking the upper and lower components of their
full body workout and separated them out across two days. And we talked about the positives and
negatives of doing that with the different types of fatigue that you have to understand in the
mechanisms. And actually, that's the single most for me in terms of when I get asked questions,
it's the single most shared podcast by me to my audience. So, it is the one that I keep
referring back to and people are asking me why, you know, or what does it mean when I split out a
full body workout into a proper lower components? What, what, what decision process do I have to go
through? Literally, that podcast answers that question. Well, it's really interesting that we're
now seeing that concept again coming out in the in the historical material that you're presenting.
Yeah, and this is not isolated either. There's quite a few books and publications and lifters who
did it this way. And there was a lot of personal variability there as well. Like, he wouldn't say,
you have to do this. He doesn't say, look, you have to do this on separate days or even the
frequency, he would say, look, do these three times a week, but a lot of people are going to get
better results during a twice a week. You know, there was an understanding that this is what works
in most people, but some people might have slightly worse recovery. So, this arm specialization phase,
we have 12, I don't know if you'd say exercises, I guess you'd say sets. We have 12 sets, okay.
Now, at this point, the set system did exist, obviously 55. So, it was not uncommon to say, do,
you know, two sets of this exercise or how many sets. So, the way that he's laid this out is not
because he didn't have a different way of doing it, okay. So, set one, we have a barbell curl.
I'll just quickly mention we do eight to 12 repetitions for all sets. Set two, we have a barbell bench. Then we go back to the barbell curl. Then we go back to the
barbell bench, back to the barbell curl for a third time, back to the barbell bench for a third time.
Then we have a new, I wouldn't say super set, it's more like an exercise pair. And then we go to a
leaning forward, single arm dumbbell curl. So, you lean forward, single arm dumbbell curl,
and then that's paired with a flat. He called this a triceps extension with a barbell
in a bench press position. So, basically what, and he said, you have to keep your elbows very high.
So, essentially, we're talking kind of like a barbell scale crusher. Now, I actually played
with this exercise the other day and realized, you know, when you're doing a, a scale crusher,
generally speaking, your elbows do actually move quite a lot that don't stay in position.
So, to, it's an interesting exercise to play with, to keep your elbows high in
that position, not moving them. It's a little bit different. I would recommend people give it a go.
It does feel quite, it does feel quite good outside of the triceps. Anyway, so flat triceps
extension with elbows high and then back to the leaning forward single arm curl, back to the flat
triceps extension, back to this leaning forward single arm curl and the third set for the
full triceps extension. And that was our arms specialization. So, two exercises, well, for each
support exercise in total, alternated 12 cents in total. What do you thought of that?
So, is this the original benching curls workout? I mean, that's the question, isn't it? I mean,
have we, have we kind of found the origination of that, of that meme?
It's, it's really interesting, isn't it? I mean, basically straight away, you can see that
they have instinctively understood that triceps long head isn't going to get a stimulus in a
multi-joint pressing exercise, like a bench press. You need that, you need that single joint
kind of scorecrusher or triceps extension variation. So, that's really interesting.
Also, you can see that they've instinctively understood that, that leaning forward motion,
I'm assuming that's kind of like a sort of a brachyradialis kind of stimulus. So, you've got
that combination, I mean, standing mobile curl is, is definitely on the boundary between an even
kind of biceps and brachy, brachyradialis stimulus. But, so again, I wouldn't say this perfect,
I would probably have a preach curl in there instead. But, ultimately, again, you've definitely
got that clear understanding that those are doing different things. So, I think it's a really,
really nice example of how silver era bodybuilders were able to look through the effects of exercises
and see the effects that those were having because they didn't have that confusing, confusing
effect of the anabolic that are so common today. Yeah, it's interesting, isn't it? Like, obviously,
we've got, like you said, this more biceps brachypotentially focused, obviously, still getting
a brachyradialis, but then the second variation is much more brachyradialis. And the fact that they
were able to include that and even include that the triceps exercises are doing something
differently. And when I read their, their books and the publications, they actually include
this stuff very well. You know, when they talk about these brachyradialis exercises, they make
it very clear. Like, John Grimmick, he's very big on talking about this elbow space. He's like
this space between the elbow that makes the arm look small. He's like, do these reverse curls,
do, and they're very clear on this is exactly what fixes that issue. And I don't see people
diagnosing weak spots like that today. So, it is interesting that the specific exercises
these guys are choosing. Now, I do want to ask you, I'm sure people are hearing this being like,
holy moly, that's so much bullying, what you take on the amount of bullying. Well, as you say,
this is, this is a specialization routine. And I think when you've talked about these before,
you've explained that they're not designed to be run for a long periods of time. There's
expectation that you would do this and then do something else after maybe four or five weeks.
So I think, again, setting it in context, this is not a routine that people would be expecting to
follow continuously for months or years at times. I think straight away, we're kind of
discounting away from saying, oh, yeah, clearly they were doing higher volumes than we think
are reasonable. I mean, no, because this is not supposed to be done consistently all the time.
So, yeah, I mean, and again, as you say, potentially this replaces everything that would have
been done, you know, for those muscle groups anyway, and the other
routines. It's designed to sort of sit alongside there. But yeah, I mean, I wouldn't be comfortable
with, especially in that rep range, eight to 12, you know, which is that perfect in the middle
of moderate load. So it fits with the data that we've got. Sorry, it fits with the analysis
that we've got a lot of data for in terms of recovery ability. I mean, this is a separate issue,
but a lot of people say to me, well, how does recovery ability change when I use heavier loads
or light loads? And like, well, I know directionally what happens, but I can't give you a like,
well, if you do X number of sets, if you take your X days to recover, I don't have that data,
because there just isn't enough study information available. But this fits in that moderate load zone.
So we can say with reasonable confidence that, yeah, they're doing, you know, what is it? Six sets
for each muscle group. And they're trying to do that three times a week. That is definitely off
the top end of the three or four, maybe where you would kind of be seeing recovery ability happening
normally. The interesting thing there is that as you say, they've said, well, maybe two times a
week is going to be something that people would want to do instead. Well, two times a week, you
could do five sets and they recover a bit or two would be fine. So they would actually be very close
to what I would consider to be recoverable work out volumes in the case of a two times two week
frequency. So it's very interesting that despite the fact that so many of the routines that you've
talked us through have been three times a week for body three times a week for body. It's just
the same pattern again and again and again and again. Here suddenly they say, well, you might want
to do this twice a week. Well, you can kind of see why, because the volume just is a little bit
topi for, you know, people who are trying to, you know, make progress over a period of time.
A lot of greatest stuff he does have a lot of the specialization type ideas and methods and he's
certainly one of the authors that is most explicit about, hey, a lot of people are going to do better
twice a week. That's not a theme you see come up as much. You know, often he goes the other way.
You know, Hoffman, he talks a lot about, hey, every other day, if you can do every other day great,
you're probably going to see better results. But it's sort of the opposite direction with you.
Well, with these volumes, with these work out volumes, I'm not surprised at all. I know we have
talked about this, I've asked you about this in the past, but just a flag that obviously there
is regional differences here and what's being biased with these different exercises. And so it's
possible that that would have a difference in damage compared to doing just success on one of
those exercises, isn't it? Yeah, absolutely. It's a very difficult question. I mean, we do see
extreme, I mean, I mean, you asked me for some of these studies and I sent them over to you
a while ago because it's very interesting to see just how different the pounds of damage are when
you look at different exercises. You see totally different parts of the muscle being, you know,
affected depending on what technology you're using to measure that. So what you might,
what you might see is that at the very top end of the motune pool, you've got different motunits
being used in certain exercises than in the other exercises. And as a result, you're not actually
caused, obviously, damage is primarily occurring in the fastest twitch and muscle fibers at the very
top end of the motune pool. So if you change which fibers those are, then yes, what you're going to
see is that even though you've got six sets, you might see something closer to three sets and three
sets on two different regions within the muscle, but it really depends on just how different they are.
And that's one of the great difficulties that we have at the moment, ultimately leading to this
controversy that we're finding ourselves in the moment, which we're going to talk about later on,
which is, you know, just how different our exercises, I mean, how much difference are there? What
does that difference entail? What does it mean? And ultimately, what does that mean for us when
we're programming? So, but yes, absolutely, there is a possibility that you could have, you know,
actually much less of a problem because you are actually creating damage in different regions.
And obviously that, yes, overall across the whole body, if you like, you've got the same amount
of damage, but it's distributed and therefore you don't have the same problems in their recovery
process. It's possible, if the exercises were sufficiently different in terms of the
motoriness that we're creating, that it could be akin to, say, doing three sets on biceps and then
three sets on calves. Obviously, you can create a spectrum. It's like talking about the stability
spectrum. When you talk about the stability spectrum, you've got everything from, you know,
kind of standing on a very unstable surface, using an unstable load. And then all the way,
at the opposite end of the spectrum, you've got a dynamometer where you're strapped in and you
can't move. Everything in the middle, you've got three ways and machines and everything,
everything just sits on that spectrum. We're dealing with the spectrum situation here as well.
So, what we're saying is you've named the spectrum at the opposite end, which is like biceps and
calves, you just can't get far enough apart, you know, it's like, sorry, you can't get further
apart. No, you literally got, you know, opposite ends of the body. As you come closer and closer and
closer, you start to get to the point where you've got some, you know, sort of cross-contamination,
if you like, where you're using some fibers in certain situations. Now, I have been at people
have asked me this question. It's like, well, so if I'm doing a multi-joined exercise,
like pull down or a row, and then I want to do curls, what's going on there? I'm like, yeah,
that's, that's in that, in that gray zone of the spectrum where you are using the biceps. So,
you're using a chunk of the muscle fibers, but we don't have a really good way of quantifying
exactly how far the motunit pull you're going. In that example, you just gave,
they're ultimately what you'd say is what you're not using. You're not damaging, right?
Well, you're neither damaging nor training. I mean, that's always the issue. I mean, I hope nobody
is going to run away with the idea that damage there for means training, but I kind of like,
sort of, I have to watch myself sometimes because I think, you know, people run away with an idea,
and then it's all over the internet. But yeah, essentially, it's activation really that it,
what it all comes back to because activation is a starting process for both the hypertrophy
stimulus and also for the damage process. Well, this is very much what we want to be talking
about today. So I might leave the plan behind. Let's just follow this, this train of thought right
now because our topic today is ultimately, I'll, I'll actually just pass over to you and introduce
what today's topic is. So basically, what we'd like to address today is this question of what
different exercises for a given muscle group are actually doing. So, you know, if I, for example,
were to do a preacher curl and then another day or in another part of the workout, I would to do
a reverse grip, you know, easy bar curl, perhaps even against the last resistance or with a
leaning forward position, or just even a standing biceps curl. I mean, how are these exercises
actually physiologically different? Now, the reason that we want to talk about this topic is because
currently there is a very popular idea that it's possible to train all of a muscle or all of a
muscle group with a particular exercise, but additionally target one particular region. So,
for example, you might argue or you might hear somebody say that the, for example, the narrow grip
row trains all of the lats, but it does give a bit more of a focus to the upper region.
The wide grip pull down trains all of the lats, but it gives a bit more focus to the lower region.
You might see somebody say, well, you know, the incline bench trains all of the pecs, but it gives
a bit more focus to the clavicular region, the upper region. So, again, you can do this for biceps,
you can talk about the calves. I mean, the point is that people are saying, influencers are saying
that an exercise trains the whole of a muscle or a whole of a muscle group, all of its regions,
but additionally trains one region slightly more. That statement is physiologically 100% impossible.
And that's basically what I want to explain, you know, the fundamental basis of what we're
going to talk about today, because essentially what we talk about when we talk about differences
between exercises is whether or not the same muscle fibers are activated. That's it. We're not
talking about anything else. So, if you are looking at a narrow grip row, then what you're at,
the question you're asking is, which muscle fibers in the latissimus dorsi are actually activated?
Now, if your fitness influencer says to you, well, they all are, if that's their answer, okay? A,
we've got a question about voluntary activation deficits. Now, come on to that in a moment.
If they argue, oh, well, no, no, no, you know, all of the fibers you're capable of activating
are activated in that exercise. Well, then what you can't then have is a targeting effect. You can't,
because if you've activated the fiber and you're moving slowly, then that fiber is going to get a
maximal stimulus by purchasing that. The only two things that matter are activation plus movement
speed in strength training context that we're talking about. So, ultimately, if the fibers are
activated in that strength training set that you're doing and you've trained close to failure,
ultimately, they've all got a maximal stimulus that you can possibly get for that set.
What you can't do is say, well, no, no, no, no, no, I get an extra stimulus on this region. Well,
how? What's the mechanism? If the fibers are all activated, they're all activated. You can't
activate the fiber more. It's like, it's other on or off. It's like, you don't get that effect
in a strength training situation. So, ultimately, what we're saying here is that you can't have a
scenario where an exercise targets a specific region, but also trains the entirety of that muscle or
muscle. So, this has really big implications. And especially for people who are writing programs,
this is really important because an obvious issue here is either, and even you can bias
different parts of the muscle, which I would assume most people agree that you can. But if that is
true, then that means that we need to really take atrophy seriously. Because if you're using an
exercise to bias a particular part of muscle, then whenever that exercise is not being done,
you're subject to atrophy in those fibers that were bent bias by that particular exercise.
Yeah. So, what you're describing is the correct view. So, I've described the problematic view
that people are hearing in the
industry at the moment which is that fitness influences are saying that you can essentially
have the entirety of muscle activated but additionally a region activated more. No, you can't.
So what you've described there is the correct interpretation which is that if two exercises
are different and one is biasing one region and another is biasing a different region,
what that means is that there are some fibers activated in exercise A that are not activated
in exercise B and vice versa. So the example I was giving the very controversial example
which is that if you've got a narrow grip row and you're in the subject of plane you've got more,
you've got activation happening in the upper latissimus dorsal that is not happening when you do
your wide grip pull down and vice versa. You've got activation of the lower regions of a lat
in the wide grip pool and that you're not getting in that narrow grip row. That's the only way
that is the literal only way that biasing of exercises or sorry biasing of muscles using exercises
is possible. So that's the issue. If you think that biasing of muscle is possible doing exercise the
only way that can happen is if it's actually activating fibers that are not activated somewhere else.
Yeah, so either biasing occurs in which case actually if we will occur and you need to train that
that exact exercise ultimately at a high frequency or biasing doesn't happen in which case there's
no point with exercise variation. Well, this is the point. This is what I was laughing about with
you before we get jumped on this podcast because I was saying the same fitness influences that say
that you can basically train the entirety of muscle with any of these exercises. They're the same
people who try and kind of show their audience a new funky exercise every couple of weeks and go,
hey, I've got this amazing new exercise that does this thing and I'm like, hang on a minute,
you're the person who thinks that every exercise does the same thing. So why are you advertising this
new kind of exercise that you find really exciting? If you think that because ultimately they don't have
a model in their minds of how biasing works, they just think, oh, well, this, you know, activation
is more or no, activation is the process of switching on muscle fibers. So when you have an exercise
that is better at a certain training, a certain region, it means that there are more fibers activated
in that region during that exercise than you get in any other exercise. Well, that now means that
as you've pointed out, if I want to train those muscle fibers multiple times per week, I have to do
that exercise multiple times per week. If I've got an exercise that's brilliant at training a
particular part of a muscle, I can't just do that once a week because if I just do it once a
week, then what's going to happen is I get that atrophy occurring for those fibers that are uniquely
trained by the exercise in the rest of the week. Before, even though I'm training the same muscle
two more times that week, it's not actually activating those fibers and it's not training those
fibers and I'm not getting that stimulus except for that single training session that I do that
exercise. That's exactly right. It's huge programming, programming implications. Yeah, and this is
why we keep saying everything comes back to muscle fiber. Yeah, atrophy, hypertrophy, muscle fiber
specific. Exactly, because ultimately if we understand that all these processes, damage, hypertrophy,
whatever are muscle fibers specific, then you have to then say, well, okay, if I'm activating
different fibers in different exercises, then the hypertrophy processes are unique to those
fibers that are being activated in those exercises. Suddenly, the idea of kind of doing an upper
lower split with one exercise for one for the muscle like a narrow grip row on one day and then
doing a wide grip row down a different day of the week and that's your training program for the
last in a week. It's not going to work because you're literally just training that unique set
to fibers that are trained by those exercises once, but yes, there is overlap. Absolutely. You're
going to get over like you're going to get some hypertrophy happening, but you're not going to get
that top chunk of the motunit pull at the very top end kind of trained effect. So my observation,
when I sort of take a lay in the land and I look at how people are programming, I would say that
the vast majority of people are in fact programming this way where one exercise might be repeated
once a week and they've got it might be up a lower up a lower it might be even full body,
but these are all unique workouts. And sometimes it's even beyond a week and actually see this a lot
in quote unquote the science-based lifting world where people will be doing multiple rotations.
It'll be like say up a lower up a lower four times a week, but then they've got like eight
different workouts of the cycling over two weeks. And so what we want to make really clear here
the physiology is this can not work. So what do people need? When we say can't work, it can't
maximize the hypertrophy across the whole muscle. What's going to happen? You've got to basically
think about the exercises for a given muscle as having fibres that are shared with other exercises
and fibres that are not shared with other exercises. So essentially if you've got a narrow
row on one day and a wide grip pull down on another day, you've got a number of fibres that are
shared across those two exercises and hypertrophy will happen relatively effectively across that training
week. So people need to be able to imagine it in diagram. Right. It's a diagram exactly.
So the overlapping fibres? Exactly. And in some cases as I said before, this is because this is a
spectrum effect. In some cases you might have like imagine if you did a flat bench with a transverse
plane, I like a really wide grip, and then you literally just elevate to the bench by 10 degrees
for your second exercise. The overlap there would be incredibly close. You would be almost identical,
but there would be a tiny difference. If you start pushing the incline really high, you're going
to see massive differences. So ultimately it's a spectrum effect and the more different the exercise
and generally things like plane of motion like coming from sagittal plane to frontal plane is a
really big effect. You know, so like that's why I've always argued very strongly that the lat
situation with sagittal versus frontal plane is they're completely different regions that are
being used there. It's just like pecs. You know, that's pecs. Fundamentally it's working the same
kind of way. So we call it imagine a Venn diagram where you've got some shared fibers and some
unchared fibers and the unchared fibers, you're suffering this effect where you're only going to get
a training stimulus for the number of times per week that you do that unique exercise. Yeah, so
that Venn diagram, it can be moving closer together. It can be more overlap or it can be less overlap,
but there's always going to be something coming out of those edges. Yeah, I mean, whatever you do to
change things, there's always going to be some degree of, I mean, the example that you gave when
we were talking about this planning this podcast, you said, well, what about the difference between a
squat and a leg press? And that's a brilliant example of something that you're going to see a lot
of overlap, but you're probably going to see some little bits around the edges, especially with
the hip extensors, because the hip extensors are moving through completely different ranges of
motion in a squat from a leg press. With leg press, you're pretty much kind of squashed into hip flexion
the whole way through. Whereas in obviously the squat, you come up all the way into hip extension.
So you would expect there to be differences there. How can we quantify that? I don't know. I really
don't know it. It's going to be very, very difficult to get at. But ultimately, those are the kind of
very small differences that are interesting to speculate about. More importantly, for programming
points of view, and that's why I've created that muscle resources or muscle regions resources guide,
you know, where I said, look, these are the big rocks. These are the massively different areas
that you can target. And this is basically explaining how that targeting process work.
So hopefully what I'm about to say makes sense. The way I see it is a lot of these people who are
programming this way, I guess it's like trying to have your cake and eat it too. So they're saying,
look, I'm using this different exercise because it biases this region or whatever, right? And ultimately,
either they need to be making an argument that actually there's hardly any biasing happening. So
therefore, we're not really losing much because obviously if we're biasing significant portions of
the muscle, like you said, if you only train that once a week, it's a very, very inefficient way of
doing it. Or they're saying, hey, look, this is a great exercise because it really biases this
region. And so then that Venn diagram has even less overlap. And that means there's even more
inefficiency or more you're kind of losing out by doing that. So is it like, is it better to be
have more overlap and biasing something less or is it better to be biasing something more like
either way to lose loose situation in that scenario, isn't it? Exactly. The position that these
influences taking is completely untenable. The physiology doesn't allow them to make the arguments they're
making. Either biasing doesn't happen and every single exercise just uses the same muscle fibers
and we can address that in a few minutes and why that's impossible. But either in which case,
you could just literally pick ten or so exercises and just do those for the rest of your life. And
it wouldn't actually matter that you'd never did anything any different at all. You could just do
those exercises and you would never see anything different occurring from changing them. Or alternatively,
there is biasing happening. And if biasing happens, then suddenly now we're in the zone that we're
describing, which is that different exercises are omitting some fibers that other exercises
are training. And in that scenario, you get into this place where you've got this frequency problem.
And I just want to kind of segue that into something that we again mentioned when we were
planning this podcast, which is that a lot of people are asking me and I think they're asking you
as well. Why can't you do full-body ABC? Now, let me say full-body ABC, what that means is that the
workouts of the week, three workouts of the week, three times a week is the conventional kind of
frequency for full-body. So three times a week, full-body ABC means you're doing a different workout,
A, B and C workouts on. I intend to interpret that for one moment because there's actually,
I've had a lot of questions on that exact topic because I sometimes will program three different
exercises. Yes, but you know what you're doing. No, but also sometimes what I'll do is have two
lots of exercises that are like each exercise repeated twice over those three workouts is what I'm
saying. So the workout itself may look unique, but the exercises are in fact being repeated.
Yeah, this is about exercises. This is not okay. So another question that I get is if you do,
If you have a workout and you reorder the exercises, but you do exactly
to the same exercises each work out.
Is that ABC or is it something different?
I would say that's A dash on A dash to A dash three.
Because what you're doing there
is you're doing identical exercises
from a hypertree point of view, that's identical.
That's work out A done three times.
It's just what you're trying to do
is change the recruitment levels slightly
to make sure that you at least capture some degree of,
and again, that is gonna cause the similar kind
of problem for you if you're not careful.
- But it also isn't necessarily,
like that's a really interesting topic
because it is causing the same problem,
but it's a problem that has a benefit as well.
Because if you are saving the last exercise first
and you are causing multi-unit recruitment increases in that,
you're still getting that benefit next session
where you have that exercise last.
- Exactly, it does come with a concomitant sort of side effect
that you are using to help yourself.
So even though you've got the same problem
in the sense that yes, you are losing fiber access
because of that super spinal CNS defect,
you are still gonna see some benefits from doing it
'cause as you say, the earlier exercises
are more likely to see increases in recruitment
as an adaption.
So, but the point is that that is not identical scenario
to saying work out ABC.
ABC, what we're saying there,
is that you've chosen different exercises
for each muscle like you might do.
Narrow grip ground one workout,
wide grip pull down the second workout
and a pullover in a third workout.
I mean, like just picking three exercises
or you're doing climb press and pack deck
and, you know, whatever else, again, pullover, I suppose.
And you could say, well, those are my three PEC exercises.
Well, that would be ABC.
Now, what you've got there is that each exercise
is gonna have some unshared fiber activations
with the other exercises in that week.
As a result, those fibers that are uniquely trained
in each exercise will only get stimulus once per week.
Now, if you're training full body three times a week,
you're gonna be doing probably around three sets
per muscle group per workout
or you're in three sets per exercise
if you're only doing one exercise
for that muscle group per workout, which is probably true.
In that scenario, you can't get growth long-term over time
because maintenance is at three or four sets
per for a single workout per week.
So if you've trained those fibers,
those uniquely activated fibers by the exercise
only once per week, you are not gonna see
growth long-term as a result of doing it.
And just to kind of really emphasize this point,
when people say to me, oh, no, no, no, no, no,
maintenance studies don't really mean that.
They just mean that the rate of growth is really, really slow.
No, look at the maintenance studies.
Some of them run out for six months.
This is not like four weeks of maintenance.
This is like some of them are running out a really long time
and they're still not seeing any growth as a result
of doing those once per week training sessions.
So the maintenance studies are literally the slam dunk
for the atrophy question.
You can't get around them.
They've got nothing to do with muscle swelling.
You can't see muscle swelling happening
with one workout with three sets once a week.
That's not happening.
You know, it's not about, you know,
a really slow rate of growth because the studies run out
for a really in a period of time.
You know, ultimately, maintenance,
completely, maintenance,
literature completely destroys every argument
that everybody's got against the atrophy question,
which is why they never talk about it.
I mean, that's an interesting observation in of itself.
I always look at what people don't talk about
because if they don't talk about it,
it means that it undermines their argument.
But ultimately, it turns literature completely destroys
everybody's argument against a atrophy occurring quickly
because it's controlling for the problems that we see elsewhere,
which is things like, you know, the muscle swelling problem.
And to me, certainly clear,
when we're talking about full body A, B, C,
and you've just said, if you're doing three sets per muscle,
then it's not going to grow.
We are talking about the Venn diagram again.
And we're saying that on the Shared Fibers,
the unshared Fibers, exactly.
Only those fighters.
Obviously, you can follow this and get bigger.
We're not saying you can't.
Again, this is one of those weird things
it's like people say to me,
oh, well, you say that brosplets don't work.
I'm like, where did I say that?
- Uh-huh.
- I literally, I've got a weekly net stimulus model
that shows you that brosplets do work.
And then you're telling me,
and you're now making stuff up about me,
you're saying that I've said that they don't work.
I've not said that.
But people have got these kind of like two-dimensional brains
where they think that if it's like,
if I say it's less effective, oh, no, it doesn't work.
And no, no, no, I didn't say that.
I say it's less effective.
- It doesn't work as well.
- Like, it doesn't work as well.
- Why does it work?
- It's like, it's like, it's like,
you know, the weekly net stimulus model, if it gives you a positive number,
that means it's going to produce net hypertrophy every time.
So basically, this hopefully answers,
and I'm going to start linking this podcast,
"Oh, and people asked me this question in my Instagram questions."
This hopefully answers the problem of why four-body
with an ABC workout format across a week,
training three times a week,
can't optimize hypertrophy.
It's because those unshared fibers that are unique to specific exercises
are only being trained once per week,
with probably a maximum of three sets,
and that isn't enough to create hypertrophy over time.
- Yeah, perfect.
So what else do people need to know about this topic?
- So the other interesting thing is,
well, how does training status play into this?
Now, training status is a really interesting thing,
because a lot of people will say,
that study was done in beginners,
therefore I can ignore it.
I'm like, okay, please describe to me
the physiological differences between trained and untrained people,
and why you think you can therefore ignore
that untrained population study.
And they can't give you an answer,
because it's emotional for them.
They're like, I self-identify as a trained person,
therefore I can ignore everything that's untrained,
because it's not relevant to me.
So that's not scientific process.
Tell me what the differences are,
and then that will then allow.
And again, people do this when they say,
I'm just going to ignore animal studies,
because I'm not a mouse,
and I'm like, I'm sympathetic to that viewpoint,
but ultimately there are differences,
and there are similarities.
If you know what they are,
you can control for that in your poor processes,
and you can use studies that are useful,
and ignore ones that are not.
But anyway, coming back to the more serious question
of advanced versus kind of, you know, beginner lifters.
In those situations, it's like, well,
what's the physiological difference between,
or what are the physiological differences
between untrained people and more trained people?
Well, straight away, that things like soccer mode
and this is going to be really difficult
to create in all our trained people,
so you can kind of use that as an observation.
And that's a really interesting one,
because you can say all those untrained studies
that have been done, you know,
straight to mediate type urge for you can ignore those.
And it's like, again, people like to use them,
but again, they're all in untrained people.
But you can't.
And then the difference is relevant for us, though,
is that if we look at the way the size principle
of striated muscle works,
which is not ham and size principle,
it's a different size principle.
Size principle of striated muscle says
that fibres stop growing when they get to certain sizes,
and the more oxidative a fibre is,
the smaller it will get stuck at.
So it will get stuck at a smaller size,
it will plateau at a smaller size
than a more glycolytic fibre.
What that means is that as you look at the motunit pool,
when you go from oxidative to glycolytic,
the fibres will stop growing earlier, you know,
in the hypertrophy journey,
they'll stop growing earlier
than the fibres to higher up the motunit pool.
So if you've got an advanced person,
it's quite a lot like it's still growing earlier.
Like they have their size.
They'll stop growing to smaller size.
So they'll hit a, yeah, they'll be capped
at a smaller diameter or cross-section area.
So if you've got a more well-trained person,
the probability is that if you were to look
at the lower end of their high threshold motunit pool,
they couldn't grow any of that stuff
because ultimately that is capped out,
because it's quite oxidative,
so the fibres can't really grow very far.
So what you're looking at then is this situation
where the advanced person probably has only growth capacity
right at the top end of the motunit pool.
Well, that's precisely where your unshared fibres are located.
If you're talking about different exercises,
it's like now suddenly we're kind of saying,
well, you know, if you're a really advanced person,
you can't be making this mistake.
You know, this mistake is going to stop you
from progressing quite effectively.
If you're at the well-trained end of the spectrum,
as a beginner, you're going to have much more capacity
to see growth happening.
Still, we're going to express the same problem,
but you're not going to be basically trapped
in that place where you can only achieve growth
in those unshared fibres.
So this is interesting because people
who are programming these different rotations,
you know, Apple are Apple.
But that's because people see complexity
and they go, oh, well, you know,
there's a more sophisticated problem
because a program, because it's more,
you know, it's mitigation comes from understanding
how physiology works.
But they have superficial complexity
because most people are fooled by that.
Well, I don't say most is quite rude,
but many people are fooled by that.
Yeah, so it looks complex and people is female.
This is going to be better for a complex
or an advanced lifter.
And in fact, what you say is the opposite.
I don't program that way.
But if I were like every now and then,
I might for a beginner actually program an ABC.
And despite what I mentioned before,
and the reason I would do that is because as we sit,
the Venn diagram analogy, there's a lot of overlap.
Yes, it may not be optimal,
but what I'm doing is I'm trying to work in coordination.
So I might give them an excise ABC
because I want to use those exercises later on,
knowing that there's some fibres that are missing out,
but each excise is still causing growth in that beginner.
For an advanced lifter, as you've illustrated there,
if there's sufficient differences,
there's not like that bit that's not overlapping,
is a bit that's causing growth in that advanced lifter,
doing that approach is really going to be quite redundant.
Exactly.
I mean, I think you can, as you say,
if you have different goals for a training program,
then you can make a case for programming ABC.
But that situation you're ceasing to program
a pure hypertrophy goal or into program.
And you now have like a longer term view,
you're developing characteristics that are very useful
for that person over the long term,
but it's not short term kind of maximizing hypertrophy.
I can see what that makes sense.
So, okay, where have we learned it so far?
We've said that if biasing occurs,
which I mean, it's hard to make the argument
that it doesn't occur,
then you're laughing at that.
People still try to--
I'm waiting for people,
because ultimately when you kind of,
Like, you kind of explain these things
and the internet starts to understand how they work
and then they start to question the influencers
on their social media and the influencers starts
try and find an exit.
Where's the nearest exit?
How can I get out of this problem
like I created for myself?
Then this, the obvious answer is to just deny
that biasing happens.
I mean, ultimately that's the only exit they've got
is to deny that biasing happens.
Any other exit is- - Let's get rid of all the exits.
- Let's just like, for the exits here.
- That's not strategically very sound
because you should always leave your opponent room
to perform an orderly retreat.
Otherwise, things get really messy.
- So anyway, let's do this.
That biasing dilemma question, you know, obviously,
even if we don't get into the physiology of it,
what we said there is, well, if biasing doesn't happen
then there's no point doing these other exercises.
- Yeah. - If biasing doesn't happen,
you can just pick your favorite 10 exercises
for the whole body and just do them forever
and it won't literally no physiological benefits
will accrue from doing anything different.
And as I said before, the corollary of that
is that when your influencer says,
"Oh, I've found this new amazing exercise
"that targets X, Y, or Z."
And well, no, it can't happen because you can't do that.
- Yeah, you're right about that.
- That's if you take that philosophical viewpoint.
Now, I absolutely don't agree with that
and I can, you know, make a case for Y in a moment,
but ultimately that's that one sort of place
you could stand and make an argument from.
And so then the next exit I've seen people try to take
is saying, well, hang on a minute.
It does recruit all voting units, all available voting units,
but it just provides more of a stimulus to some of those
and then you do another exercise that biases something else
and provide a little bit more of a stimulus
to one region, but you're still getting activation
and stimulus and everything else.
- That's the nonsense.
That's physiologically impossible.
That's where I start this kind of podcast explanation
because there is no explanation
of what that stimulus is coming from.
It's like when they say there's a great stimulus,
where, how?
- You can't say if it's at the five or more.
- Yep.
- So it's either on or off
and you've got the loading caused by the velocity
and the velocity is the same across the whole muscle
more or less, okay, you can argue that differently,
but it's not going to be a factor.
- And people might try to then say, well, hang on maybe
it's that it's not active until the last repetition or two,
so when you're getting one or anything.
- Well, no, because stimulating rep theory kind of tells you
that you've got the last five reps or so of the set.
So you covered with high maximal levels of recruitment.
That's not it.
- That doesn't make sense.
- You can, yeah, there's no exit at all.
As I say, philosophically, you could make the case
and just say, well, no, you can just do the same exercise
forever.
I respect that viewpoint, people want to start,
because at least it's consistent.
It's intellectually consistent.
The nonsense is this bit in the middle
where people say you can't have a muscle
that's fully activated within reason,
within capabilities, but simultaneously biasing one area.
That's a physiological impossibility.
I mean, it just can't happen, you know?
So that's the thing I wanted to really kind of squash
with this podcast.
The physiological rationale is this kind of thing
I kept mentioning and not explaining,
which is the voluntary activation deficit.
So when we say that something has a muscle,
has a voluntary activation deficit,
what we mean is that we can't access every single
muscle fire in the muscle.
We can't maximally recruit every single
note unit voluntarily.
And we know that because of tests like the interpolated
twitch technique, which measure voluntary activation
and they say, here, we're going to do a maximal effort
contraction, notice maximal effort contraction.
So when people say to me, oh, no, no, no,
this is not maximal effort.
Well, these are maximal efforts.
You do maximal effort and then they apply
intellectual stimulus to see if they can find anywhere
in the muscle that's not activated
and they don't actually look very hard.
If they find anything that is, you know, kind of implies
that there's probably a lot more there as well.
So they're massively under, in my opinion,
they're massively underestimating the deficit.
But anyway, you get a lack of stimulus,
which increases force production.
And that tells you that you are not fully
activating the muscle voluntarily,
that your capable of actually producing more force
if you were able to access more motor units.
Why is there a limitation on that?
Well, this is, you know, kind of sort of psychobiological model
of fatigue basics.
Ultimately, there is a central motor command
produced by the brain.
It's limited by a maximum tolerable
perception of effort.
The central motor command produces recruitment.
Once you hit your maximum tolerable perception of effort,
you can't increase recruitment anymore,
because you can't increase central motor command anymore.
Ultimately, that means that you've always got deficits
and the bigger the muscle or the bigger the muscle group,
the bigger the deficit tends to be.
The glutes quads, you can get deficits of 20 plus percent.
You tend to get smaller and smaller deficits,
the smaller muscle that you're trying to activate makes sense.
So ultimately, if you've got a voluntary activation deficit
and if you're following your own kind of matching
and you're basically using whatever motor units
in the order that is most efficient,
as you start to increase towards your maximum level of effort,
you'll take a different path with one exercise
'cause you'll use a different set of motor units
than you will for another exercise.
And when you get to your maximum number of motor units,
you can be clear what you'll find is
that the ones that are not activated, not recruited
are different in each of those two exercise situations.
So the presence of voluntary activation deficits
completely destroys the argument
to those people who are saying,
new mechanical matching doesn't apply in maximum efforts
because the body activates everything, no, it doesn't.
That's what a voluntary activation deficit tells you.
So if you can just look at the literature
and see that voluntary activation deficits exist,
you would know that your argument
against new mechanical matching in maximum effort situations
is completely and utterly invalid.
And again, it just comes back to knowing
how physiology works and being able
to put all these things in place.
So with a voluntary activation deficit,
we know that you take a different journey
in your motor unit recruitment order
with certain exercise, you recruit different regions
and the unactivated or deactivate as you don't even get
to activate them, it's not like deactivate
'cause you're not deactivating.
The unactivated muscle fibers,
the ones you haven't switched on
are gonna be different in each case
of those exercises that you are doing.
So that's why I think that there is a definitively strong case
for arguing that different exercises
do activate completely different fibers
at the top end of the motor unit pool,
simply because of the way that
new mechanical matching works in conjunction
with presence of voluntary activation deficit.
- Which is a similar thing that we see
with the bilateral deficit, isn't it?
- So the bilateral force deficit
is underpinned by a bilateral motor unit recruitment deficit.
So essentially, when I do two,
when I use two arms or two legs to do an exercise,
I have lower level of average force across the two legs
than I do with a single leg or a single arm.
And similarly, I see a lower level of recruitment
across the two legs than I do with a single leg or a single arm.
So what's happening there is that the brain is capable
of sending more activation to a single muscle
because it doesn't have to send
centromatic band to two places.
Now it's not linear, you know?
And that we're 50% activation in each leg.
But it's probably about a 10, 15% difference.
So it's really, really meaningful.
- So people would then just go with that a little bit further.
So then people might ask,
well does this apply then to unilateral exercises?
Like if you were to do a single arm curl one day
and then a bilateral curl the next day,
did that therefore mean that there's a trouble?
And that would take us back to what I mentioned.
That is the same issue as the exercise order problem
with the workout A-1, B-3.
Because what you're doing there
is you're actually using the unilateral exercise
to increase motor recruitment levels
as an adaption over time.
And that then gives you that kind of ability
to push your levels of recruitment higher
in your bilateral exercise variations.
So you're not necessarily using the unilateral exercise
as a way to increase muscle size.
You're using it more as a way
to increase motor recruitment capacity.
Now, if you're using it in a specialization routine,
you'll probably be doing it more than once per week.
I think if you're using a unilateral
for hypertrophy purposes,
then yeah, you are gonna have to think about it
as a different exercise from your bilateral version
that is the same exercise.
I agree.
- I have a few more, I guess, practical questions.
Is there anything else you wanted to touch on
from the physiology perspective?
- No, that's already quite a lot
of physiology for one podcast.
But this question has, as I said to you,
before we jumped on and started.
This question has aggravated me
and I don't aggravate very easily.
It's aggravated to me because ultimately,
as you pointed out, as we were going through,
it all stems back to the observation
that hypertrophy is muscle fiber specific.
And it's the one thing that I think people get wrong.
And whenever they get it wrong,
everything just falls apart.
My hypertrophy researchers get it wrong,
fitness influencers get it wrong,
even when they understand it, they still get it wrong.
I mean, we've had this conversation before, I think,
where you pointed out that there's a difference,
there's some fitness influencers
that just don't understand it
and therefore the programming doesn't work
because they don't understand it.
But then there's also some fitness influencers
that understand it cognitively.
But then when they actually program,
they don't program in a way that takes it into account.
And that's really interesting.
It's kind of like their brains are stuck
in that kind of historical traditional way
of programming that they've grown up with.
I'm not saying it's traditional
in the true historical sense that we talk about,
in the sense that they're journey across the last,
sort of, however many decades.
When they look at it and they go,
well, no, I don't like programming like that.
But then there are cognitive parts
of how they understand the physiology
and their programming practical parts
aren't and meshing together.
So this has aggravated me.
I'm a little bit upset about the fact
that people don't seem to be able to sort of connect
the teaching that I've been providing
with the implications for that.
So I wanted to try and, you know,
kind of cross that, cross that, or connect
those two things together in this podcast.
- I mean, it is really important
because it just doesn't fit with the model.
So people who are advocating for the model,
but then doing this in the product.
- Exactly, exactly, it doesn't make sense.
- One little bit, but all that I've heard floating around,
I'm not sure where, but people keep asking me about it.
We say the hypertrophy is muscle fiber specific
and people say, well, no, it's motor unit specific.
Can you just speak that for me?
Well, the motor unit basically, you know, kind of comprises the motor neuron and all of the motor,
I'm sorry, all of the muscle fibers that the motor neuron innovates. So, I mean, that's the
description you're going to read in a textbook, you know, the motor neuron plus the muscle fibers.
So physiology researchers get a little bit testy with me when I say this, but I like to call
the motor unit a group of muscle fibers and they kind of go, no, no, no, no, you can't say that,
it's more, you know, kind of complicated than that. And like, yeah, but for, you know, the audience,
I'm talking to most of the time, it's valid to say that a motor unit is just a group of muscle
fibers. So if you say that hypertrophy is motor unit specific, what you're saying is that it is
group of muscle fibers specific, fine, no problem at all. What we're saying then is that when you've
got unshared motor units or unshared muscle fibers between two exercises and what you're going to find
is that you have a difference in the location of the hypertrophy that is being produced by one
exercise compared to the other. You're literally just saying exactly the same thing, just using
different terminology. And as I think you point today, one of your stories recently, people use
terminology to confuse and distract and obfuscate, you know, what they're saying so that people
can't argue with them. But ultimately, motor units, muscle fibers, we're saying the same thing.
Basically saying multiple muscle fibers, like it's just a group of muscle fibers. If you want to do
that, another say, physiology researchers get very testy with me when I say that, but it's not
fundamentally wrong as far as we're concerned. The implication is the same. Now, everything we've
said so far regarding an exercise once a week or once every two weeks, depending on how people
are programming it. These are the same issues that one might face from phase to phase. And so if you
are, in fact, maybe programming correctly and you're using an exercise twice a week or three times
a week and you're doing that for four weeks or six weeks or eight weeks, and then you go into a new
phase and you're not using the same exercise and using an exercise which you need to go back to the
Venn diagram. There's there's overlap where it wasn't training something or isn't training what
was previously been training being trained. You're falling to the same issue, aren't you?
Exactly. And this is really where I am very, very negative on on periodization because there are
a hundred ways that you can make a mistake when you're writing periodized training programs.
Absolutely a hundred ways. And you can you can end up doing some really good work for a couple of
weeks or months and then on picking that over the following couple of weeks and months because you've
omitted to you know train a muscle or region of a muscle correctly in that specific phase and
you end up losing the benefits of what you've worked so hard to get. Not periodizing people think
again it's like this complexity must be better. You know not periodizing people look at you and go
you know you're a beginner do you not know what you're doing or why are you being so simplistic in
the way that you're programming because it's actually better in the long term and I've taken to
saying to people you know when they ask me about periodization and this applies to athletic
situations as well you know if something is important do it all the time if it's not important
don't do it at all you know it's like pick the out and again we both do this on when we're giving
advice about how to write a training program you know first start with everything that you want
to do in terms of exercise selection start with that list and then abortion it you know because at
least then you've got a chance of making sure that you've got all of your basis covered in
every single training block that you do it's actually a really good way to fix periodization
problems is to start with the list of things that you know you need to do so you don't miss anything
out I mean that's cardinal sin number one is missing something out getting like you know kind of
two months down the line and realizing that you've not got exercise for the wreck fam or you know
something kind of you know this really just going to drop out in other scenarios you know make
sure you got your list and then and then abortion it now in the apportionment you made this point
earlier today you have to make sure you at least getting your twice a week stimulus for each region
if you're doing four body three times a week or up below six times a week whatever you want to do
and you do need to make sure you're getting that two or three preferably three but at least two
times a week otherwise you're going to find yourself stuck on maintenance now this is really important
because what I've just shown you there is that if you've done if you've started with your list at
least the worst thing that can happen is you end up on maintenance you know if you miss it out
completely then you're going to go backwards quite quickly and if you at least got it in
there once a week then you'll be on maintenance so that's the worst that can happen if you at least
covered your bases for each block that you do after that making sure you've got twice a week
preferably three times a week is even better but ultimately I think that would be the way that
would approach it but honestly for me the a lot of the periodization stuff is just again this idea
of people trying to write stuff that looks more complicated or complex because they think that
is more attractive to the audience that they're writing. You made the point of starting by running
at all the exercises you need to train what you want to train and and that second part there
what you want to train I think that's really important and I think a lot of people miss that because
people now I see you need an exercise advice here to region and not everyone necessarily wants that
and needs that and that's made very clear when we look at a lot of these silly area guys there's
whole region sometimes that wouldn't simply not be trained and yet their physics were amazing
so obviously we're advocates of biasing and training regions if someone wants maximal development
but we need to understand that a lot of people in the gym who just want to look a bit better don't
necessarily need to do that and so and this this is important because it means as a programmer you may
be giving someone something they don't need and then you're kind of stuck needing to continue to do
that or you've wasted their time so if I give I'm going to use React fam as an example you've
brought it up I've got a female client who do not want bigger quads or they just want you know
maybe a little bit more quad development but they're not interested in growing the React fam I don't
need to give them a legacy center I don't need a train of React fam and if I do if I want to maintain
that I'm stuck having to do that forever yes what I noticed in a lot of the silver area programs is
often they're adding stuff they're not really taking a whole lot away as someone gets more advanced
usually adding more on top of it and that's the way I would look at it as someone gets advanced you
just add new exercises you don't drop stuff out you just stuck adding more things and so if you don't
need it in the first place don't add it or you're stuck having to continue to do it absolutely no
absolutely right I mean we've we've taken that journey on this podcast series and when we started
out we talked about the aesthetic choices of you know they're kind of right the very beginning the
Eugene sunday type kind of approach is where they had a lot of deltoid development and pretty much
no pectoral development and you can kind of then see the choices that people are making every time
and you point it out you know for e-cathletes and other people in different situations everybody's
got their own preferences and that those preferences are valid you know I don't think it's
appropriate to look at somebody's program and go oh you don't have this in your program therefore
it's inferior to mine which has more coverage it's like well those are just potentially aesthetic
choices it's like everybody can make their own choices about what they want to achieve you know
there's definitely stuff missing in my programs from some people's point of view for my own training
and from other people's point of view that's my choice because I don't want certain things in my
program so ultimately I think you've got to start with the list of things that you want to train not
the list of things that somebody else thinks you should train now I'm not saying that other people
don't have important input and might have recommendations and they might know that things might
help you or if they're I mean I'm thinking about athletic situations I mean an athletic coach might
say well if you train this muscle then that will help you with the sport and you weren't
planning on training that muscle quite so much you know a good example of big loops and sprinters
it's like no no no no you really do need to train that muscle it's going to help you a lot
and they're like I don't want to train hip thrust but well it's probably the single exercise I would
recommend for a sprinter um so you know I think again it's not that other people don't have
valuable input it's just that it's your list not somebody else's list. Maybe a couple of years
ago now when we'd sort of been talking about a lot of this stuff and I was writing programs and
I was hitting my head against this wall of exercises that you know maybe I've used in earlier phases
with clients and you know they're not they're not priorities by any means but I don't want to lose
results I've achieved in that particular muscle regregion and so I'd be sitting there trying to
piece together this programming like do I just give it to them once a week but then I have to do
three or four sets or like just to maintain or is it better for me just to do one set twice a week
and hey they're actually going to be making games on that but like if I'm trying to structure I've
got a certain amount of volume I can do in a particular session I just couldn't get to a point
where I could justify giving someone four sets for an exercise that wasn't even important to them
it just didn't make sense to me and like if someone said hey it makes sense to them by all means
do it but it just emphasizes hey like even if something is a low priority it's actually better off
doing it multiple times a week because you can actually do less on it overall.
Ultimately this is kind of why I am so positive about four body AB three times a week you know
four body AB is just is one and a half times a week it literally just about works you get one
you get one maintenance and one and one stimulus each week basically phase each week
obviously if you were doing that every other day it would be it would work as a stimulus situation
and that's the same one set yeah one set of an exercise in your AB kind of format and that is
just gold because you end up in this scenario where you can do literally a whole rack of exercises
for a whole different load of regions single sets and do another different set of exercises
the next time you come in and just do that indefinitely and you get this enormous coverage
so enormous coverage which is so cool to do so if you've got a reasonable level of as you're saying
with advanced status you've got reasonable training status you know four body AB single sets there's
a really nice way to keep everything that you've got everything that you've got basically
and make very very slow progress over time I'm obviously you can jack the volume up a little bit
if you want to you know try and move more quickly but honestly I found as a
an older lifter. I find it's just a brilliant way to train because I'm not going to gain
very much at my age anyways. Just hang on to everything I've got.
And a full body A, B, I mean this might sound obvious to some people who may not be
others, it can actually be, the A and B program can be very similar to each other.
They could, or they could be completely different. I mean, that's the wonderful nature.
You can absolutely go either way. You can overlap or you can literally let your imagination
run wild because you've got, you're basically doing a situation where your A workout is
growing from A to A and your B workout is growing from B to B. So you've not got any restrictions
on your torch. One of the most flexible, you know, to program honestly, it's so cool.
Someone could say, Hey, my maximum sets per session that I know I can really get much
out of would be say 18 sets and there might be 20 exercises I want to do. And it could
be as simple as me like, okay, there's going to be all of those exercises that are overlapping
A and B. And there's one exercise or one or two exercise that it can be unique. And that's
it. I mean, if that's the problem, I need to solve then full body A, B solves that particular
unique problem. It's a, it's almost a skeleton key for unlocking programming. You can almost
fix any problem that you've got with full body A, B. Yeah. It's so versatile and usable.
And actually easy to easy to, as I say, programmer. I mean, I didn't really, you know, until
I until I really sort of got into programming, I didn't realize how easy it was with that
A, B format. And the fact that you can literally pick non-overlapping or overlapping exercises
as you wish, it is very, very easy to easy to get right.
Interesting road of change over the last few years and this has come from us as well has
been we used to say full body was the hardest to program. That's what I was just thinking
about as I was explaining that point. And it's not really into like got into programming
full body A, B that I realized that it could be easy. I was always trying to program multiple
sets and limited to four or five exercises per session. And so I've got, you know, three
workouts per week of as close to overlapping as I possibly get. And I was trying to make
ABC work. And it just did not work. And my brain was like overheating trying to get the
programming side to it. Because I'm basically, you know, I think in terms of physiology, I
think in terms of how muscles work, I think in terms of how the CNS controls the muscles
and I don't really think in terms of programming. I'm not to, not to programming geek in
that way. So ultimately finding full body A, B and realizing it solves all of my programming
problems was quite enjoyable experience. I used to tell people if you don't know, if you
don't understand by mechanical, don't understand excellent selection, you're far better off
just doing the same exercises as if you work out because you can't stuff that up. You
can't, the frequency issue isn't there. And ultimately, that's what AB does. You can't
stuff it up. Anything that you're using is getting enough volume. You just can't mess it
up. It's a sweet spot between not being able to stuff it up and yet having space to
do almost anything you want to do. Yeah, it's a better option. That's right. That's
why it's so good compared to just saying full body A, great, you know, you can't get that
wrong really three times a week. But full body A, B is, is that but better? Not, not
so it's always better if you want to make progress really quickly than full body A is probably
going to be your friend. But, you know, for, once you've arrived at a certain destination,
full body A, B is, is fantastic. I try to think if there's any other questions I commonly
get on this topic and I feel like we've covered most of them. I'm sure there's going
to be some that people are going to come at us with, but I think we've done fairly good
due diligence there. Is anything else you can think of worth covering or mentioning?
I think basically we've, we've covered all of the important stuff today and more besides
ultimately, I think really the only other physiological argument that people might want to tackle
is, is, is high, is hypertrophy really only must a virus specific? And I'm, I'm not going
to do that today because it's too much to dig into. But that's one I'm starting to see
people push back on is totally natural that people will push back on ideas of that nature
because they're just so powerful. I mean, ultimately, it's kind of my major contribution
apart from the force for us to radace chip observation. It's the major contribution
I've made to hypertrophy science really. So it's not surprising that people are going
to want to push back on that. But other than that, I think we've covered pretty much every
complaint, a critical, you know, kind of idea that I've seen floating around in this
area. I just think of one final one. So we've mentioned, or well, I mentioned that
if I was programming, I try not to drop off exercises. I prefer to add on exercises as
phase progress. Now, that may not necessarily mean that one never gets rid of an exercise
because there could be an exercise or one discovered that does the job of a former exercise,
but even better if we're talking about using that exercise to buy a particular muscle or
muscle region. Does that make sense? Totally. So I think that's a really good, a really
good point. So, you know, if maybe somebody's been using, you know, a, I don't know, some
kind of pressing exercises there, triceps exercise. And then they realized that dips actually
do a better job. Then you would kind of migrate away from using that pressing exercise for
the triceps and using the dip instead. I mean, you can think of probably better examples
than I can, but that kind of idea, I think, is probably an interesting exception to the
rule whereby you don't, you know, sort of say, well, I'm just going to abandon the
exercise because I'm abandoning the exercise. You switch it for something that is better.
You know, I think that makes sense. Yeah. So again, you know, we've said the point
that start with, I think I maybe said to start with all the exercises you want and maybe
you more correctly said, start by identifying all the regions you want to train. That would
be the best way of going about it because it may be that you discovered actually I was
using this exercise for Braco Gradiales. And in fact, he's a better exercise I've identified.
And in my training group, that tends to be where my programming works, where I'd say 80%
of exercises stay the same across each phase. And then maybe even more than that, maybe
85, 90% even. And then there'll be a couple of exercises that change usually because I've
identified, I'll actually think this is slightly better at what I was using this other exercise
for. No, totally, makes sense. Okay, that's it. That's a wrap on the topic. Thank you guys
for joining us. As always, please like, subscribe, share, all the good stuff and join us again
next week for another episode.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Silver era bodybuilders used specialized routines, like arm-focused phases, where specific exercises were prioritized while standard full-body work was reduced.
Period Radar’s 1955 arm specialisation plan included alternating barbell curls, bench presses, and unilateral dumbbell movements with high attention to joint mechanics and muscle region targeting.
The plan emphasized distinct muscle fiber activation—such as brachioradialis and triceps long head—indicating an early understanding of exercise-specific effects beyond general muscle stimulation.
These routines were not meant for long-term use; instead, they were temporary phases, with frequency adjusted (e.g., twice a week) to align with recovery capacity and volume limits.
Different exercises activate unique muscle fiber subsets; if one exercise activates fibers not activated in another, those fibers will only grow when trained specifically.
Full-body ABC workouts with three distinct exercises per week fail to optimize hypertrophy because unshared fibers are trained only once per week, leading to atrophy.
The presence of voluntary activation deficits explains why different exercises recruit different motor units, making muscle region targeting physiologically valid.
Programming must account for fiber overlap and uniqueness—advanced lifters are especially vulnerable to atrophy due to capped growth in oxidative fibers.
Summary:
This episode explores the physiological basis of exercise-specific muscle stimulation, challenging a common fitness myth that any exercise can train all regions of a muscle equally. Drawing on historical silver era bodybuilding plans—particularly one from Period Radar in 1955—the discussion reveals a sophisticated understanding of muscle fiber recruitment. The arm specialisation routine illustrates how exercises like leaning forward curls and high-elbow triceps extensions target distinct muscle regions, such as the brachioradialis and triceps long head, through unique fiber activation.
This is not merely theoretical; it aligns with the concept of voluntary activation deficits, where the brain cannot fully recruit all motor units during maximal effort, leading to exercise-specific fiber recruitment patterns. As a result, different exercises activate non-overlapping fiber subsets. , in a full-body ABC format) suffer atrophy in uniquely activated fibers, leading to suboptimal hypertrophy.
The evidence from maintenance studies—where long-term training with low frequency shows no growth—directly contradicts claims that such programs are effective. For advanced lifters, who have growth capacity capped in oxidative fibers, this becomes especially critical. While beginners may benefit from varied routines due to greater growth potential, the core principle remains: maximizing hypertrophy requires consistent, targeted stimulation of all fiber groups.
The episode concludes that training programs must move beyond superficial complexity to embrace a physiology-based model where exercise variation is meaningful only when it creates distinct fiber activation, not just perceived targeting. This refutes influencer claims of region-specific targeting within a single exercise, which is physiologically impossible. Ultimately, the episode advocates for programs that prioritize fiber overlap and frequency, ensuring continuous stimulation across the entire muscle.
FAQs
A muscle specialisation plan focuses on a specific muscle group for a set period, typically using only exercises targeting that muscle. In the silver era, practitioners would remove standard full-body exercises affecting that muscle and replace them with targeted ones, often doing so for 6 weeks based on individual programming.
Unlike a full-body routine that includes all major muscle groups, a specialisation phase isolates one muscle group by omitting exercises that affect it and replacing them with targeted variations, allowing focused development of that specific area.
Yes, some bodybuilders recommended doing arm specialisation on separate days—like Monday for full body and Tuesday for arms—to manage fatigue and optimise recovery, especially when the volume was high.
The routine includes barbell curls, barbell bench presses, leaning forward single-arm dumbbell curls, and flat barbell triceps extensions with high elbows, performed in alternating sets for a total of 12 sets.
Yes, different exercises activate distinct regions of a muscle due to variations in movement mechanics, such as plane of motion or joint angle, which recruit different fiber groups and create targeted stimulation.
Because muscle fibers are either activated or not in a given exercise. If all fibers are activated, there’s no mechanism to selectively stimulate one region more than another—targeting requires unique fiber activation in one exercise that isn’t present in another.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.