Go back

009 Work capacity - what it is and how to improve it

from Hypertrophy Past and Present

42m 51s

009 Work capacity - what it is and how to improve it

The podcast explores a detailed silver era bodybuilding routine from Alan Steven, a multiple-time Mr. America winner, emphasizing heavy loads and high-volume sets totaling 50 sets across seven exercises. The workout, lasting two and a half hours, challenges conventional views of work capacity. A key insight is that work capacity must be precisely defined—either as recoverable volume, absolute work done, or relative muscular endurance. The latter, which measures fatigue resistance, improves primarily with higher repetition ranges (10–15+ reps), not through increased volume. Studies show volume has negligible effects on fatigue adaptation, while lighter loads improve pain tolerance and metabolite buffering. However, these adaptations don’t enhance hypertrophy in heavy-load training. Cardiovascular endurance is critical for sustaining multiple workouts in a session, as metabolite clearance between exercises limits performance. The podcast concludes that long, slow, low-impact cardio (like cycling) is the most effective way to build cardiovascular capacity and improve work capacity, not high-volume strength training. For bodybuilders focused on hypertrophy, the evidence suggests that volume and repetition range are less impactful than recovery and cardiovascular fitness, with the true benefit arising from efficient, sustainable training that balances strength, recovery, and metabolic clearance.

Transcription

8673 Words, 48964 Characters

English
Welcome back everyone to another episode of high-perch fee pass and present. As always, I have Chris as me. Good morning Chris. I was just asking you whether you'd eaten because I know there's a concern that may be too early for you, but you have a full belly, don't you? I do. I got down to breakfast in my hotel and I've got back again and I've set up and everything looks to be running okay. So fingers crossed, we will have no disruptions to the wifi. And I was going to ask if you've had your morning coffee, but you don't drink coffee. I've had my evening coffee, so hopefully that'll keep me nice and alert. And let's jump into it today. I've got a interesting plan. A plan that's a little bit different to anything we've gone over so far. And when I talk to people about some of these plans or when I get feedback about some of these, one thing I hear a lot is, man, how long would those guys be spending in the gym? You know, I often get this sort of critique, but it's like, I don't have time to do that. Who can spend two and a half hours in the gym? You know, I don't, A, I don't have the time to do that, B, I don't have the, the capacity to do that. I couldn't possibly do something that long and exhausting in a session. And this is idea that these guys with this silver area had this unlimited work capacity and could do all this extra work than what people can do today. And we're going to talk about that a little bit and we're going to talk about why what I've just said doesn't really make a whole lot of sense, but I'm going to leave you guys hanging until Chris jumps in and does his part. So before we get there, let's talk about the plan. Now, this plan is, it's from a guy named Alan Steven. Now he's not one of the more well-known silver area lifters, even though arguably he maybe should have been. He has an amazing physique, but he did win Mr. America multiple times. He won Mr. USA as well, who's a winning the in the late 40s up until the the early 50s. And this is and he was a gym owner as well. And what's cool about that actually is he used these methods with hundreds of clients. And he says thousands of clients. And so not only was he getting real time feedback on himself, but with multiple other people as well. So you could see what was working and maybe what wasn't working. So I like that sort of component here where we can actually see, I guess, feedback from hundreds of people. So what kind of methods were working. And obviously understanding that all these people were natural at this point in time in the late 40s, steroids didn't exist or they weren't being used by in bodybuilding. So we've got good anecdotes here as to what kind of things were working. So this is what he referred to as a bulking routine, which again is a term that a lot of these silver aerial lifters use and basically this use to talk about gaining weight. And then they sort of shifted more into a defining routine, which would usually consist of more exercises. And this routine was part of a I guess part of a series of routines. Now one thing that is pretty common in these types of routines is I'm sure you guys have noticed when I've talked about these is they tend to do the same exercises each workout. That's almost always the case. And they'll do the same exercises for that workout, for that routine. And then they'll move on to a new phase. And typically you see these phases tend to last anywhere from about four to 12 weeks on average. Obviously there's some variance to that a little bit. And then in the new phase, they do use some new exercises. Sometimes they'll usually what they'll do is they'll keep the type of exercise and they'll do a slight variation. So they might go from like a stiff leg that lift to maybe a bent knee that lift or something like that, but they generally will keep the the moon pattern relatively similar. So this was part of a four part series of his. And this was a first routine of that four part series. Now the instruction for each exercise is the same. So I'll lead with that. And what you did is you warmed up to use the 10 repetition match load and warmed up with it. And then you established your five repetition max. And what you were to do is perform any number of sets, any rest period, whatever you needed until you got 25 repetitions out. So whether that was five sets of five or however you wanted to do it, he did say that you would probably only be getting a couple of repetitions out in your final set. So we're probably talking six, seven, eight sets until you get to those 25 repetitions. Now the first exercise was a standing barbell overhead press. He then went into a floor barbell press with an arch. So essentially a bench press with an arch, but they did this on a floor at this point. Then he did a bent over one arm dumbbell row, then a barbell clean or barbell cleans. And then a flat neutral grip chest press. And he emphasized, keep it always close to your body. And then he went into a barbell squat and then finally a deadlift from block. So essentially a rack pull. And he did say to do this above knees. And for memory, I think he actually did instruct to do this with your knees locked out as well. So it's essentially a stiff leg rack pull above knee height. So that's the workout plan 25 reps of each. And we're talking, let's say it was about seven sets per exercise to get to the 25. Then we're talking about 50 sets across the workout. And he did say to expect it to take you at least two and a half hours. So what do you think of that? A routine is really interesting. Obviously, as you said before, it's very, very different from what we've been talking about previously. Two things really. We've got an exercise selection, which is somewhat different. And we've got a rep set structure, which is also quite different. In terms of the rep set structure, it feels a lot more like the Hepburn type of stuff that we've, you know, maybe mentioned in passing before. I mean, ultimately Hepburn doing eight sets of three with a kind of a five rep max is probably very similar to what we're seeing here. It's a lot of work to be done. I mean, I think doing that for two and a half hours with all of these exercises is a real mission, not something that I would be interested in following it. Or I think that Hepburn with sort of two or three exercises is doable. Hepburn or even, you know, this, Stephen type routine of seven exercises would be really, really brutal. I don't know how many times he was thinking of doing this per week, but I mean, I'm guessing it was probably three times a week. But it's, it's really, yeah, really, really a lot of work. But as we've talked about, and this is nice to be talking about this now when we've, you know, previously described the difference between rep ranges and recover abilities because working with that five rep max, you know, it's interesting that he'd probably be capable of doing this three times a week because of the enhanced recoverability from heavy loads compared to moderate loads. So again, you know, it's really interesting to connect this with what we've talked about previously because ultimately it probably is recoverable, you know, on a muscle-wide muscle basis. I do think people will feel very tired doing this kind of work. But from a fatigue point of view and a recoverability point of view and a training point of view, I think it actually would work. Now, if somebody is listening to this and they don't understand the difference between feeling tired and fatigue and strength recovery, then they need to look at the FAQ or any other resource that we've provided or I've provided in the past and understand the difference between just feeling tired because you're doing a lot of exercise and actually recovering from a workout on a fatigue basis because fatigue is not the same thing. A fatigue refers to strength and the recoverability of that strength from a workout that we've just done on a muscle-wide muscle basis. In terms of exercise selection, I mean, I think this is really interesting because I've grumbled before about how we don't see enough deadlift variations. I've grumbled before that we don't see very many row variations necessarily. Really nice to see a row variation and also this is deadlift in the program. Pressing obviously is very well sort of catered for in this program. Obviously, we don't have a wide grip pull down or pull up. I'm really always going to say that. I don't see why we wouldn't have that. Cleans are interesting because it kind of probably does the job, does the job of the shrugs that we would probably want to see. Other than that, obviously, the major things that are missing are things that probably wouldn't have been available, like knee extensions, like girls, that kind of thing. And of course, very much, very obvious is the lack of single joint stuff, curls, triceps extensions, calf raises, that kind of thing. And I'm guessing, as you've explained before, that's simply because these bulking routines were designed to create a large stimulus across a large amount of the body and they would then shape with those single joint exercises in subsequent programs afterwards. That's exactly right. And even within the context of this bulking routine, he actually does add single joint exercises later on. He does add in. I believe both a biceps exercise and I think he does like a, they call it like a triceps curl, which is essentially like a skull crusher, so that does appear later on as well. I've said everything I can say about this routine really. I mean, the thing is, as we go more into these routines, and it becomes easier and easier to add on and explain, connect with things that we've talked about previously. So really for me, the interesting things about this routine are simply the set rep structure, which is very different from previous ones. It's much, it leverages the heavy load, kind of possibility for doing more volume essentially, more stimulating repetitions and each workout. And of course, the exercise selection, which is sort of tighter and smaller than we might expect in a perfect routine that covers every single muscle region in the body. So, no, yeah, really interesting to work through this really. One point I want to finish on with this is I find it interesting when sometimes you see people using heavier loads like this in this routine, often there's like a de-emphasis on how many reps you do specifically. So here where he's like, hey, use your five rep max, I don't really care how many you do, you're going to get to 25. What's interesting with that is you would predict that you're actually going to end up with the same outcome however you get there. And it's interesting that these guys seem to identify that, whether that I cognitively knew it or what, but that's what the physiology would be. predict isn't it, that if you're using a five-year max load, whether you do them always singles or you do them as fives or you do them as doubles, it doesn't really matter, does it? Exactly. I mean, again, stimulating rep theory basically says that if you're working with a five-year max, you can do whatever you like. You can do singles, you can do doubles, you can do triples, it doesn't really matter. The hypertrophy stimulus is going to be the same, however you structure that. And that is absolutely being leveraged by these guys. Yet again, we're seeing a connection between the silver era anecdotal sort of the anecdotal structures, anecdotally based training methods are connecting now with the physiologically based training methods that we're describing. And it's always the way. I mean, we see that connection so many times across so many different examples. And again, we've seen it here. So two and a half hour plus workout. That's obviously a pretty decent effort. And I introduced this workout by saying that a lot of people are going to complain about what someone's work capacity must be like to achieve this. And you're about to tell me and roughly so that that's a nebulous term that doesn't really mean a whole lot and we need an unpack it, aren't you? I am. So I'd like to take the opportunity today to explore what work capacity actually means because people are using it without defining it. I think what we have to do if we want to use the term work capacity is define exactly what we mean by it because the person that we might be talking to isn't necessarily going to hold the same ideas about that term as we do. So I'm going to give some options. And then we're going to unpack each of those options. The first option I would like to give is that when we say work capacity and somebody says, oh, well, it's the amount of work that you can do in a workout and recover from, OK, fine. So what you're describing there is the maximum recoverable workout volume. So you get to the next workout that you have planned and you've already recovered from that. Now, the problem there, of course, is that as we've just been talking about, if you use heavier loads, you can do more sets, more stimulating reps than you can if you do lighter loads. And so there's a little bit of difficulty there. But fundamentally, all things being equal, yes, you could argue that certain, you know, repeated bout effect related options could get you to be able to do more of that and recover in time. So first, first possible definition of work capacity is just recoverable workout work. So you actually don't need the term work capacity in that context. You could just say the amount of volume you can recover from in a workout in time for the next one that you have planned and that's going to be muscle specific, isn't it? Absolutely going to be muscle specific specific. Now, the next possibility is, well, how much work can you do in a set period of time? Now, the reason I'm saying in a set period of time is because one of the worst possible ways that you can think of work capacity is to just say, well, it's the amount of work you can do. No, you can't do that because you can literally just sit in the gym all day long and do an extra set and an extra set and an extra set. And it's just adding, you know, technically you're increasing your work capacity by having more patience. Well, that's a garbage idea. So you can't, you can't do that. So if somebody says, well, work capacity is just the amount of work you can do, just laugh at them and move on because they don't, they haven't thought about this. Work capacity can mean the amount of work you're doing in a set period of time. Two things that we need to just define here very quickly. One is that there are going to be two different measurement methods for how you can sort of calculate the work capacity in a, in a, all the work done in a fixed period of time. One is absolute and one is relative. Absolute means that you're literally just working with numbers of kilograms or, or pounds, whatever. And you're saying, how much, how much work can I physically do and numerically with this amount of weight or, you know, whatever amount of weight? So it's volume load. So the amount of weight in the bar multiplied by the number of sets and number of reps, you can say, okay, how much work can I physically do in the hour with the absolute amount of weight? And alternatively, you can do relative. Now relative just means relative to your maximum strength. Instead of working with the kilograms or the pounds, you work with your percentage of one rep max. It's like, well, how many reps can I do with my current percentage of one rep max? Now, the reason that we have these two separate metrics is because the absolute doesn't take into account the increases in strength gains. So if you get stronger, then automatically your work capacity will increase your volume load that you can lift in a given hour, for example, will increase. Even if the number of reps that you can do with a given percentage of one rep max doesn't change. In contrast, you're what we call relative muscular endurance or your relative work capacity will actually, you know, sort of take that into account because it uses the percentage of one rep max at the time when you're doing the workout. So it accounts for your maximum strength gains. So you've got these two totally separate concepts. One is influenced by maximum strength, the absolute value and one is not influenced by maximum strength, the relative value. So what we're seeing here is that if you want to get at work capacity as a concept independent of your gains in maximum strength, because honestly, why would you, why would you want to incorporate maximum strength into a definition of work capacity? Because ultimately, you already know what your maximum strength is. You don't need to incorporate it into a separate calculation. If you want to do that, you're going to end up talking about relative muscular endurance and that is then going to be talking ultimately about tier resistance mechanism. In summary, what I'm saying is we've got three separate things to think about. We've got work capacity, which is just how much work you can recover from and that is basically the repeat about effect and the mechanism is associated with that. Secondly, you've got absolute muscular endurance, which is going to be combination of maximum strength and your, essentially, your fatigue resistance. And then finally, you've got this third concept, which is relative muscular endurance or relative work capacity and that is ultimately literally going to be the isolated fatigue resistance concept. So, three things that we could use to define work capacity, what you can't do is just say, work capacity is just the amount of work I can do and then stop talking because that isn't a valid thing. So, if you're a capable volume, like you said, we've talked about this plenty and there's other podcasts we've gone into that. And then the second one, the absolute work done. I can't see really any utility to that as a metric, but well, at least not from a high-pertory perspective. Is there any reason one would be concerned about that? Ultimately, it's a composite measure and that's really the important starting point. If you want to talk about absolute muscular endurance, for example, or this absolute work or the volume load, which is an absolute measure automatically, you're describing your impact on the external environment. You're describing, for example, you're describing how many rocks of a certain weight you could lift and carry from one side of the room to the other. It's your influence on the external environment. It's not actually going to have, as you say, any impact on your capacity to produce hypertrophy, for example, because you could be doing almost no stimulating reps in that scenario. I mean, it doesn't really impact on adaptions, particularly. It's describing your impact on the external environment. So, if you have a pressing need to dig holes in the ground or build structures in the wilderness or anything like that, then absolute work capacity, absolute volume load or absolute muscular endurance is a really interesting thing to measure because it is describing your ability to lift and carry and all of those things. So, if you're kind of a survivalist and you're interested in those kind of concepts and your ability to basically be a living fork lift truck, then yeah, that is interesting. That's a vanishingly tiny number of people are going to be interested in that and they're probably not listening to me talking. Honestly, as you say, absolute muscular endurance is a composite measure of maximum strength plus fatigue resistance and it only really tells you your impact on the external environment. It's not really telling you anything about your adaptions that you're gaining from a particular type of exercise. Okay, so let's talk more about relative for muscular endurance then. So, I want to know, is this something that we should be concerned about, but even before we get to that point, can we train to change it? Tell me more about it. Yeah, so when we measure changes in relative muscular endurance or relative work capacity or relative volume load or anything like that, what we're doing is we are taking a given percentage of warm rep max at the beginning and end of a training program. So, let's say, for example, you take 70% of your warm rep max at the beginning of the training program and you do as many reps as you can in a bench press. That's a very simple relative muscular endurance measure that is isolated to a single set and at the end of the training program, you do exactly the same thing. You measure your new warm rep max, you calculate your new 70% of warm rep max and you do again as many reps as you possibly can. Now, what you're going to find is that that number doesn't change that much, not in comparison with absolute muscular endurance, which would be saying, okay, at the beginning of the training program, 70% of warm rep max is 70 kilos. I'm going to do as many reps as I can with 70 kilos and then at the end of the training program, I'm going to come back and do as again as many reps as I can with 70 kilos. The problem is at the end of the training program, hopefully, 70 kilos is now any 60% of my warm rep max into the 70%, and of course, I'm going to be able to do more reps because it's now a smaller percentage of my warm rep max. That's why absolute takes, you know, fails to take maximum strength gains into account and you end up with a composite measure of both your strength gain and also your fatigue resistance. If you measure as many reps as you can with this 70% being different as a absolute number at the beginning and end of the training program, you get a relative measurement which then only measures changes in fatigue resistance. Now, you can do this with volume load instead of doing a single set with 70%, you could do five sets with 70%. So you get a volume load, relative volume load instead of a relative muscular endurance on a single set measurement. You could do percentage drop-offs from one set to the next, so you could do five sets and you say how much does my strength or my number of reps decrease from one set to the next, and you could do an average reduction on a number of reps you get from set to set. Again, as long as you take the percentage of your maximum strength at the point when you're doing that muscular endurance test or that volume load test, their relative measures and they take your strength gains out of the equation when you're measuring that fatigue resistance. So there's multiple ways of doing this, the most common way is the single set, as many reps as possible, with a percentage of your maximum strength at the time when you're doing the test. So that's the one we tend to talk about, but you can use work, more work capacity, sort of type measurements where you take volume low for the whole workout, all the number of exercises that train a particular muscle or whatever you want to do. So just because I'm talking about relative muscular endurance as being a single set of sets to failure, doesn't mean that this is not relevant to work capacity. If you're thinking of work capacity as being a whole workouts worth of sets, the concept is identical. You're literally just talking about multiple sets or single sets. So that's the measurement that we would go about using, all the measurements that we would go about using, and that is the essence of the adjustment that we need to make. It's the adjustment in maximum strength from the beginning to the end. As I said, many times that you take these measurements, you find that they don't really change very much, particular if you do, for example, heavy load strength training with five, six rep maxes, that kind of thing, you will find it often doesn't change at all, and it can even reduce slightly in these single set measurements. Contrast abuse moderate loads tends to drift upwards a bit, and if you'd like to load, it tends to increase quite a lot. So what we're seeing is that if you want to increase fatigue resistance, you kind of have to do higher repetition sets. So literally at the moment, just talking about observing the adaptions occurring, I'm not describing what the adaptions are, and whether we want them, I'm just describing the fact that they do happen, and they do tend to happen with that type of training, not so much with heavier load, or even the moderate, heavy load type. Yep, so just to clarify, I just do to reiterate what you said there. So if someone's predominantly doing, you know, we often talk about four to eight repetitions per set as an example, then you're saying that at the end of that training block, assuming that they're using a relative percentage, so they've used, let's say, 80% of the one rev maxed at the start of that training block, saw how many reps they could get, then they do it again, 12 beats later, and you're saying that they're predominantly using these heavier loads, heavier moderate loads is not going to be much of a change in the repetitions they can get with, again, 80% of their new one rev max. Correct, it's likely to be quite a small movement upwards. If it is a movement upwards, it could even be a small movement downwards, or it could be no change at all, but it's really not going to be a substantial positive improvement. You might see, as I say, substantial improvements with more moderate loads at the top end of that range, 8 to 10 to 12, you are highly likely to see positive improvements if you're pushing things up to 15 plus. So what we're seeing then is its rep range that seems to be the primary driver of whether you get fatigue resistance changes in these situations. So even if someone we're doing like in this workout plan that we talked about at the start where he's doing seven sets per exercise or whatever it is of lower repetitions, you're saying that if someone's doing seven sets compared to doing one set of, say, five or four, whatever, just by doing more sets, you're still not going to increase that relative muscle endurance. So this is the really, really important point for this kind of podcast, I think, which is that a lot of the time when people message me about work capacity and I ask them to think about the definitions of it, what they're actually saying, they will often argue to me that the reason they are doing higher volume training programs is because they want to increase their work capacity. If you define work capacity ultimately in this way of saying, well, is it increasing my relative muscular endurance? Is it increasing my ability to do more work with my current maximum strength levels? The answer is volume doesn't really have anything like the same impact as rep range. There's only a minimal number of studies I've only found one study that measures the effect of volume, workout volume, on changes in relative muscular endurance and it didn't find a significant effect. There was a small numerical effect, there's no actual significant effect and that isn't what we see with the rep range effect, rep ranges, you absolutely start doing light loads, you're going to see some big shifts in relative muscular endurance. So again, the idea that doing more volume increases your work capacity, if we define work capacity as being essentially improving fatigue resistance, isn't substantiated. It's not what's going on. Rep range is where you want to go if you want to do that. Then you start to realize that people don't really want to do that. They just want a reason to do higher volume training. So what we're seeing then is that the higher repetition sets are producing fatigue resistance adaptions. Now before I mention this, I just want to clarify that if you look at changes in absolute muscular endurance and relative muscular endurance over a period of time and a training program, what you'll notice is that absolute muscular endurance carries on increasing indefinitely and that's because strength carries on increasing indefinitely. If you're measuring how many reps you can do with 50 kilograms, it's going to go up forever as long as your strength goes up because you're making it a smaller percentage of your warm wrap max every time you go back in the gym. In contrast, relative muscular endurance or fatigue resistance tends to increase or improve for about four weeks or so, maybe a little bit longer. So we see a very limited amount of adaption that you can generate of that particular quality. So it does look like the fatigue resistance adaptions, which I'm going to go on to explain in a moment, are actually relatively limited in their duration, at least in comparison with the adaptions that underpin gains in maximum strength. Okay, so the adaptions that underpin this improvement in fatigue resistance are obviously going to be related to individual fatigue mechanisms. So you've got the two central nervous system fatigue mechanisms, supraspinal and spinal, and you've got the two categories of local fatigue mechanisms, metabolite and calcium ion related. If we look at the central nervous system, spinal CNST, we've got very little later on how it changes over time, just have to kind of say we don't know. Supraspinal CNST, we've got data showing that people can improve their ability to tolerate the pain of things like metabolite burning sensations and cardiovascular sensations and stuff like that. So it does look like you can train yourself to accumulate more metabolites in the muscle at muscular failure with a given repetition range. And that tells you if you can tolerate a higher degree of metabolite in the muscle, you're getting better at that pain tolerance and you're improving the amount of, or you're reducing the amount of supraspinal CNST that you're going to suffer as you're doing that particular exercise with that higher repetition range. So we do know that you can start to reduce the amount of supraspinal central nervous system fatigue by tolerating pain sensations better. In local terms, you've got calcium ion related fatigue mechanisms and you've got metabolite related fatigue mechanisms. Or if you change calcium ion related fatigue mechanisms, you automatically change post-workout fatigue because that's the repeat about effect. Repeat about effect is gigantic from workout 1 to workout 2. Like 2010 to 20% of that size from workout 2 to 3 to 4 and after that is pretty much nonexistent. So ultimately, you're not going to see much of an impact of calcium ion related maintenance, but they do exist. I mean, you can see that happening, you know, through the repeat about effect. In terms of metabolite related fatigue, well, that's really improving stuff like buffering capacity. You're changing the ability of the muscle fibers to handle the accumulation of metabolites and you're going to see improvements there. That's probably the majority of what we see in this fatigue resistance effect in the first kind of three or four weeks of the training program. I would say metabolite related fatigue is probably the major player. It's getting better, but it has a limited lifespan in terms of how much of that you can actually do. Now, importantly, just finishing off while we talk about these mechanisms, if you change something that affects a hypertrophy adaption, then that's a positive thing if we're thinking about bodybuilding. If you change something that doesn't affect a hypertrophy adaption, it doesn't matter. Now, metabolite accumulation doesn't affect hypertrophy stimulus as long as it doesn't cause supospinal sinusitis. The fact that the majority of our fatigue resistance improvements in metabolite related means that this isn't really changing our ability to create hypertrophy. The stuff that does is the calcium ion related fatigue mechanisms, which affect mechanical tension, and the supospinal sinus fatigue that affects the motina accruement. So, at this point, somebody might say, well, okay, that sounds very positive. So, if I train to improve muscular endurance, relative muscular endurance by increasing my fatigue resistance, I can establish a situation where every time I do a strength training set, I can enhance the hypertrophy stimulus. Well, yes and no. Yes, if you're talking about training with light loads, because the metabolite accumulation to that degree that causes pain and suffering, only actually happens in light load sets. If you're doing heavy loads sets, you're not getting that problem anyway, so there's no need to try and seek the adaption that makes a problem go away, that you're not experiencing. So, yeah, if you want to train with light loads, then training with light loads will get you to a point where you can minimize the negative impact of training with light loads in producing supospinal sinus T. But if you're in training with heavier loads and moderate loads, that's not a problem anyway, so it doesn't exist. The calcium ion related fatigue stuff is going to go away no matter what you do. The repeat about the fact happens however you train. So, it doesn't really matter whether you're training with light loads heavy loads or manual resistency, you get to the same place. So, ultimately, the fatigue resistance adaptions do tend to happen with the light load training, but that's not going to help you enhance the hypertrophy stimulus that we're trying to get to. So, this is, I guess, a really important point, because there's a lot of people who argue that we should include light load blocks in our training programs in order to get advantages that then enhance our ability to stimulate our hypertrophy, or they don't, because all you're doing is mitigating fatigue mechanisms. In some ways, the calcium ion related fatigue is going to happen in respect to how you train. And in some ways, related to supospinal fatigue, which only affects you if you're training with light loads anyway. So, it doesn't get you anywhere interesting. In the small number of scenarios where an athlete might want to have a little bit of extra muscular endurance, relatively speaking to their maximum strength, sure, you know, that's relevant. I mean, you might want to go training for that, the way to do that is training with the lighter load rep ranges. It's not doing more volume with heavy loads. That isn't going to get you the adoption you're looking for. So when people are thinking about work capacity, it's like, well, define what you mean. If you mean doing more work in less time and you want to improve your fatigue resistance, more volume is not the way to do that. More higher repetition ranges is the way to do that. So if you're using these lower repetitions and you've outlined some of these mechanisms that's going to allow one to be able to do a few more repetitions at the end of a higher rep set, well, those mechanisms, like you said, they're not going to improve the lower repetition set. So you're not going to get more hypertrophy benefit out of them going back to low repetitions. And it's not necessarily going to make the higher repetitions set superior than the low repetition set either because ultimately what you're doing, you're kind of working from a deficit to begin with with the low repetition set because you've got all the extra metabolites and the affin feedback and these negative sensations. So all you're doing is kind of effectively removing some of that deficit, but it's not going to make it more effective than if you were just to do low repetitions in the first place, is it? Exactly correct. That's exactly what we're talking about. By using a lighter load, a higher repetition range, we put ourselves at disadvantage, training for the ability to suffer those painful sensations to a greater extent. We can get rid of some of that problem, but we don't get rid of all of it. So you're never going to get to the point where you're equal with the motinic human levels that you could get with a heavier load where you don't have those painful sensations ultimately. So yeah, it's just you're removing some of the problem you're not removing all. So from a high-pertory perspective, we would be interested in being able to increase how many sets per muscle one can do in a session. And as you've mentioned before, that's repeated bad effect and that's going to happen either way. So we're not going to train specifically for that. And then the other thing I guess I would be on per muscle volume, that would be interesting from a high-pertory perspective, would simply be how many different muscles and sets we can do within a single session. And we've kind of covered that a little bit in the past haven't we? But that's sort of I guess people would sometimes think about that when they talk about work capacity as well, wouldn't they? Yeah, so let me answer the first question and then come on to this more interesting one second. In terms of the repeat about effect, the repeat about effect is going to happen regardless of how we train. The only scenario in which you could change the magnitude of the repeat about effect, because the repeat about effect is muscle fibres specific. You could apply it to a larger number of muscle fibres by doing eccentric overload and you could expose all of your muscle fibres to that calciumine flood from eccentric injections. The problem is that when you've done that, obviously it creates a large amount of post-workup teeth. So you don't want to train like that all the time. But when you stop training like that, it goes away. And you've got kind of like maybe four weeks before it goes away completely. So we were talking before this podcast, like well, could you kind of engineer a scenario where you did one really horrible eccentric training workout once a month, and that would give you this really big repeat about effect? Yeah, you could think like that if you want to go down that route. That's starting to get really quite technical. But you know, that just I'm just alerting people to the fact that, you know, the repeat about effect is muscle fibres specific. You get a bigger repeat about effect from eccentric compared to concentric because you get this massive flood of calcium mines. That's only the really, that's the only real difference you're going to see between training variables is this eccentric versus eccentric overload versus conventional strength training. And again, but bodybuilders are not training like that because it just creates massive amounts post-workup teeth. And it's really, really inconvenient to set up and do and, you know, kind of implement. But just wanted to flag just for completeness. That is a possible scenario that people could think about. But honestly, practically it makes no sense. The more interesting kind of question then is, well, okay, what about if we're doing multiple muscle groups? What about this idea of, and as you already pointed out, we talked about this with our previous podcast when we said, well, maybe we want to split a full body routine that's massive into upper lower and do it on alternate dates. And that's just because you just physically feel like you're getting just exhausted by being in the gym for two, three, four hours, whatever it might be. That's a cardiovascular issue. Now, it's a cardiovascular issue because ultimately you're creating this cardiovascular demand every time you do any muscle group. And that then the tabolite is being produced. You've got to clear that and it's a whole body phenomenon. If you really push that, you're going to find that you end up creating supospinal fatigue because you're out of breath. You feel horrible. You've got a tabolite accumulation lactate in the bloodstream. And it just makes you miserable and reduces your maximum central motor command for the maximum tolerable perception of effort. So you end up with your back end of your workout with those exercises suffering and not training the muscles very effectively. Cardiovascular capacity is the driver, is the determining factor in it, which is different from what we've just described. When I've described these changes in local muscular endurance, I've described what's happening locally to the muscle in something like a bench press or a squat or actually the cardiovascular component that's quite as definitely present. But like a knee extension or something like that, you're doing as many reps as you can. It's not really about cardiovascular capacity. It's about what the local muscular fatigue mechanism is going to be. If on the other hand, you're trying to do like something like you've described today with this workout with seven exercises and you know, probably seven sets per exercise is you know, colossal amount of work. You're going to find that cardiovascular capacity is going to limit your ability to be successful in those final exercises of the workout. Otherwise, between acumen is going to be on the floor and you're going to be doing nothing of any value. Cardiovascular capacity allows you to recover between sets of different muscle groups. That's the important things. We're moving away from local muscular endurance where we talk about the muscle being the limiting factor. We're now talking about the cardiovascular system because if your cardiovascular system can clear out the metabolites of the exercise you've just done, then you can bounce back and you can do the next set with something completely different. You go from bench press to deadlift and pull down and whatever. And if anybody has worked as a personal trainer or strength coach and they've worked with, for example, endurance cyclists, they will know what this looks like. These guys will literally do an exercise of say, you know, five, six reps of squat, which if you did it, you'd probably discover quite quickly that you're breathing very heavily at the end of that set of reps and you needed some time to recover for the next set. These guys will be bouncing back in two minutes, you know, and they'll be doing equally going to another exercise and doing something else and they bounce back and they bounce back. And it's just that the cardiovascular system clears everything so fast that they don't have that limitation that those of us who don't do that kind of exercise to the same extent experience. Now just for completeness again, how do you improve cardiovascular capacity? Well, basically the standard, the gold standard way of improving cardiovascular capacity is just to do long slow endurance exercise. So, you know, build a foundation and I'm not, I'm not a cardiovascular physiologist by any means. I just, I have done endurance cycling. I know how it works and I know enough about how the body works to be able to connect that with my understanding of the science. You know, basically, you don't need to do intervals, you don't need to do, you know, anything silly like that. You just do, you know, a couple of hours a week of long slow cardiovascular activity. Ideally, if you want to mix that with your strength training, you want to do minimal muscle damage. So, you know, the bike is the fantastic way of doing that. Cross trainers will do that, you know, there's various ways of making it happen. But ultimately, running is probably the worst in terms of mixing with strength training because you're getting a lot of footfalls, a lot of muscle damage. You're going to find interference effects. I'm not saying it's impossible. You can absolutely do it. It's just, it wouldn't be the way that I went about it. If my sole purpose of doing that exercise was to improve cardiovascular capacity for strength training, I'm not going to do running because it's like, you're kind of, you're kind of robbing yourself for other reasons by creating that extra muscle damage. I would go down the cycling route all across trainer or something like that. And as I say, you're just doing like long, slow, easy cardio. And if you do enough of it, then your cardiovascular system starts to improve. Now, as you get into it and you can advance, you can start to play around with slightly more slightly more intense levels of cardiovascular activity. But honestly, that's icing on the cake. The real fact of the determines your cardiovascular capacity is just the volume of time you spend doing that easy, slow cardio. So, for people who are really confused about how to improve cardiovascular capacity, which I just find astounding. But if you are, that's how you do it. It's just long, slow cardio. That's what you need to work. So, for my hypertrophy perspective, and obviously a lot of people listen to this podcast. That's what they're interested in. From what we've talked about today, that's probably the main factor that we could actually influence that would have some bearing on the hypertrophic response of a workout. You've talked about, well, obviously you're paid about effect is going to come along kind of no matter what we do. So, you don't need to worry too much about that. These bouts of higher repetition phases, you've kind of dispelled the necessity of doing that. That's not going to particularly help someone from a hypertrophy perspective. So, if one was interested in quite increasing one's work capacity on endurance, really the type of endurance is going to help us there would be cardiovascular endurance. Yeah, absolutely. So, I would say including three sessions of cardio a week, if you are the true obsessive and you want to have everything absolutely perfect in your training program, then you would do your strength training workout and you would do your cardio afterwards. That's miserable. It really is miserable. It's one of the most miserable things that you can do in my experience. Much more enjoyable is to pick a very non-muscle damaging form of cardio and do it on the opposite. days. Like cycling, like cross-trainer, something like that. That is not perfect because it means that you're a little bit closer to the next workout and you will have some muscle damage, but honestly, if you keep the intensity low and you avoid the impacts by doing something like cycling or cross-training, you won't have a bigger factor. So my recommendation would be just to alternate between strength training and long slow cardio and you can do that indefinitely as long as you are careful. As I say, it's only the total obsessives with crazy degrees of self-control and the sort of dedication you are going to try and get the incremental slight benefit by putting the cardio straight after the strength training. I do not recommend doing that. Just plays havoc with your kind of sort of ability to sort of maintain that programme in the long term. I think honestly, alternating between strength training and cardio in that format is probably the best way of doing it in practice. I used to do 55 minutes after my weight session and this is back when I was training six times a week and I felt like my stomach was going to eat itself after I had done the 55 minutes of cardio. It is such an uncomfortable experience. It is a very, very horrible experience. I don't recommend it at all. The only scenarios that I've ever managed to combine strength training and endurance exercise on the same day have been when I've been on group endurance cycle rides. That's simply because when you're in a group ride and you're on the road, you've got a lot of other stuff to actually keep your attention on not as you say, the fact that your stomach is trying to eat itself is like, your brain is doing other stuff rather than thinking about how miserable you feel. The true pathway to work capacity improvements is actually endurance exercise. It's not really any of the kind of ways that people claim is the route. For example, doing higher volume strength training workouts is not going to get you there. Cardiovascular exercise is going to get you there. Hopefully that's cleared up a little bit of the confusion around work capacity and the necessity to do some of these things, depending on what your goal is. Obviously, like you've mentioned, if your goal is as an athlete and endurance athlete, that's going to be a little bit different. But for my hypertrophy perspective, hopefully that's given you guys something to think about. I know in my own experience, I've tried all these things. I've done the phases of high repetition sets because I thought that's what I needed to do. In the past, I've seen it away from cardio because there's been that mentality that cardio is somehow going to kill your gains. As you've talked about, it's ultimately coming down to muscle damage and we can do intelligent things to mitigate that muscle damage. I'm going to now, but hopefully that's given you guys something to think about. Some ways you can implement some of this stuff into your own plans and your own programs to enhance the efficacy of your workouts in the gym. As always, we hope you'll join us for another the episode next week.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The workout plan from Alan Steven involves seven exercises with 25 repetitions per exercise across seven sets, totaling 50 sets and lasting at least two and a half hours.
  2. This routine emphasizes heavy loads and a five-rep max structure, leveraging the principle that stimulating reps are similar regardless of set structure, supporting the idea of high work capacity via heavy volume.
  3. Work capacity is not simply the total work done but must be defined—either as recoverable volume, absolute muscular endurance, or relative muscular endurance, with the latter being most relevant to fatigue adaptation.
  4. Relative muscular endurance improves primarily with higher repetition ranges (e.g., 10–15+ reps), not through increased volume, as volume has minimal impact on fatigue resistance.
  5. Light-load training enhances pain tolerance and metabolite buffering, but these adaptations don’t significantly boost hypertrophy stimulus in heavy-load training.
  6. Cardiovascular endurance limits performance in multi-exercise, high-volume sessions, as metabolite clearance between sets is key to maintaining workout effectiveness.
  7. Improving cardiovascular capacity through long, slow, non-impact cardio (e.g., cycling) is more effective than volume-based training for enhancing overall work capacity.
  8. The silver era routines reflect practical, anecdotal training that aligns with modern physiology—showing that heavy-load, high-rep training does not enhance fatigue resistance as assumed.

Summary:

The podcast explores a detailed silver era bodybuilding routine from Alan Steven, a multiple-time Mr. America winner, emphasizing heavy loads and high-volume sets totaling 50 sets across seven exercises. The workout, lasting two and a half hours, challenges conventional views of work capacity.

A key insight is that work capacity must be precisely defined—either as recoverable volume, absolute work done, or relative muscular endurance. The latter, which measures fatigue resistance, improves primarily with higher repetition ranges (10–15+ reps), not through increased volume. Studies show volume has negligible effects on fatigue adaptation, while lighter loads improve pain tolerance and metabolite buffering.

However, these adaptations don’t enhance hypertrophy in heavy-load training. Cardiovascular endurance is critical for sustaining multiple workouts in a session, as metabolite clearance between exercises limits performance. The podcast concludes that long, slow, low-impact cardio (like cycling) is the most effective way to build cardiovascular capacity and improve work capacity, not high-volume strength training.

For bodybuilders focused on hypertrophy, the evidence suggests that volume and repetition range are less impactful than recovery and cardiovascular fitness, with the true benefit arising from efficient, sustainable training that balances strength, recovery, and metabolic clearance.

FAQs

Work capacity refers to how much physical work you can perform and recover from. It's not a single concept but can be defined in several ways, including recoverable workout volume, absolute muscular endurance, or relative muscular endurance. Each has different implications for training and adaptation.

No, higher volume alone does not increase relative muscular endurance. Studies show no significant effect on fatigue resistance. Volume has minimal impact on the ability to sustain training, especially when using heavy loads.

Rep range, especially in higher-repetition sets, is the primary driver. Training with lighter loads and higher reps improves metabolite buffering and pain tolerance, leading to better fatigue resistance without affecting hypertrophy directly.

The repeatable fatigue effect occurs when muscle fibers from one workout carry over to the next. It's strongest in the first few weeks and diminishes after about four weeks. It's muscle-specific and more pronounced in eccentric training, but not practical for regular use due to post-workout soreness.

Yes, cardiovascular endurance allows better recovery between sets, especially when training multiple muscle groups. This helps maintain performance in later exercises and reduces overall fatigue during long sessions.

Long, slow, low-intensity cardio (like cycling or cross-training) is most effective. Doing it 3–5 times per week helps improve blood flow and recovery without causing muscle damage or interference with strength gains.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.